© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 443–445

BlackwellOxford,1356-1294OEPP/EPPO,33StandardSafeEPPO use Standards UKEPPBulletin OEPP/EPPOof Science, biological 2002 Ltd control Bulletin Organisation Européenne et Méditerranéenne pour la Protection des Plantes European and Mediterranean Plant Protection Organization

Normes OEPP EPPO Standards

Safe use of biological control Sécurité de la lutte biologique

PM 6/3(2)

Organisation Européenne et Méditerranéenne pour la Protection des Plantes 1, rue Le Nôtre, 75016 Paris, France

443

444 EPPO Standards

Approval Approbation EPPO Standards are approved by EPPO Council. The date of approval Les Normes OEPP sont approuvées par le Conseil de l’OEPP. La date appears in each individual standard. In the terms of Article II of the d’approbation figure dans chaque norme. Selon les termes de l’Article IPPC, EPPO Standards are Regional Standards for the members of II de la CIPV, il s’agit de Normes régionales pour les membres de EPPO. l’OEPP.

Review Révision EPPO Standards are subject to periodic review and amendment. The Les Normes OEPP sont sujettes à des révisions et des amendements next review date for this set of EPPO Standards is decided by the EPPO périodiques. La prochaine date de révision de cette série de Normes Working Party on Phytosanitary Regulations. OEPP est décidée par le Groupe de travail pour l’étude de la réglementation phytosanitaire.

Amendment record Enregistrement des amendements Amendments will be issued as necessary, numbered and dated. Des amendements seront préparés si nécessaire, numérotés et datés. The dates of amendment appear in each individual standard (as Les dates de révision figurent (si nécessaire) dans chaque norme appropriate). individuelle.

Distribution Distribution EPPO Standards are distributed by the EPPO Secretariat to all EPPO Les Normes OEPP sont distribuées par le Secrétariat de l’OEPP à tous member governments. Copies are available to any interested person les Etats membres de l’OEPP. Des copies sont disponibles, sous under particular conditions upon request to the EPPO Secretariat. certaines conditions, auprès du Secrétariat de l’OEPP pour toute personne intéressée.

Scope Champ d’application The EPPO Standards on the safe use of biological control are intended Les Normes OEPP sur la sécurité de la lutte biologique sont destinés to be used by NPPOs or equivalent authorities, in their capacity as aux ONPV ou aux organismes équivalents, en leur qualité d’autorités bodies responsible for overseeing and, if appropriate, regulating the responsables de la surveillance et, le cas échéant, de la réglementation introduction and use of biological control agents. de l’importation et de l’utilisation des agents de lutte biologique.

Reference Référence IPPC (1995) Code of Conduct for the Import and Release of Exotic Biolog- CIPV (1995) Code de Conduite pour l’Importation et le Lâcher des Agents ical Control Agents. ISPM no. 3. IPPC Secretariat, FAO, Rome (IT). Exotiques de Lutte Biologique. NIMP no. 3. Secrétariat de la CIPV, FAO, Rome (IT).

Outline of requirements Vue d’ensemble NPPOs of the EPPO region generally promote the use of biological Les ONPV de la région OEPP soutiennent en général l’utilisation de la control in plant protection as, like other aspects of integrated pest lutte biologique en protection des végétaux, dans la mesure où, comme management, it reduces risks for human health and the environment. d’autres éléments de la lutte intégrée, elle réduit les risques pour la Use of biological control agents may, nevertheless, present some risks, santé humaine et pour l’environnement. L’utilisation des auxiliaires in particular for the environment if exotic agents are introduced from peut toutefois comporter certains risques, en particulier pour other continents, and for the user if agents are formulated as plant l’environnement dans le cas des agents exotiques introduits à partir protection products. In general, the latter case can be covered by EPPO d’autres continents, et pour l’applicateur lorsque les agents prennent la Standards of series PP, concerning plant protection products. The aim forme de produits phytosanitaires formulés. Ce dernier cas est en of the EPPO Standards on the safe use of biological control is to provide général couvert par les Normes OEPP de la série PP, concernant les the NPPOs with guidelines for assessing and reducing the risks produits phytosanitaires. L’objectif des Normes OEPP sur la sécurité de associated with various aspects of the introduction and use of biological la lutte biologique est de fournir aux ONPV des directives pour control agents and, as appropriate, for comparing them with the l’évaluation et la réduction des risques occasionnés par diverses étapes benefits in terms of efficacy. The EPPO Standards seek to make the de l’introduction et de l’utilisation des agents de lutte biologique et, le administrative framework for the introduction and use of biological cas échéant, de les comparer avec les avantages en termes d’efficacité. control agents as light as practically possible, in order to sustain a Les Normes OEPP préconisent que le cadre administratif pour general policy of promotion of biological control. l’introduction et l’utilisation des auxiliaires reste léger, afin d’éviter autant que possible dans la pratique tout conflit avec la politique générale de promotion de la lutte biologique.

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 443–445

Safe use of biological control 445

Existing EPPO standards in this series Normes OEPP déjà existantes dans cette série Two EPPO guidelines on the safe use of biological control have already Deux Normes OEPP sur la sécurité de la lutte biologique ont déjà been approved and published. Each standard is numbered in the style été approuvées et publiées. Chaque norme est individuellement PM 6/1(1), meaning an EPPO Standard on Phytosanitary Measures numérotée: par exemple, la norme PM 6/1(1) est une Norme OEPP sur (PM), in series 6 (Safe use of biological control), in this case standard les mesures phytosanitaires (PM), appartenant à la série 6 (Sécurité de no. 1, first version. The existing standards are: la lutte biologique); il s’agit dans ce cas de la Norme 1, première version. Les normes existantes sont: PM 6/1(1) First import of exotic biological control agents for research PM 6/1(1) Première importation d’agents exotiques de lutte biologique under contained conditions. Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 29, 269– aux fins de recherche en confinement. Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 272. 29, 269–272. PM 6/2(1) Import and release of exotic biological control agents. PM 6/2(1) Importation et lâcher d’agents exotiques de lutte biologique. Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 31, 29–36. Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 31, 29–36.

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 443–445

BlackwellOxford,1356-1294OEPP/EPPO,33StandardSafeEPPOEuropean use Standard UKEPPBulletin OEPP/EPPOof Science, biological 2002 Ltd control Bulletin and Mediterranean Plant Protection Organization PM 6/3(2) Organisation Européenne et Méditerranéenne pour la Protection des Plantes

Safe use of biological control Sécurité de la lutte biologique

List of biological control agents widely used in the EPPO region Liste d’agents de lutte biologique largement utilisés dans la région OEPP

Specific scope Champ d’application spécifique This standard gives a list of biological agents widely used in the EPPO Cette norme donne une liste d’agents de lutte biologique largement region, to facilitate decisions on the import and release of biological utilisés dans la région OEPP, afin de faciliter les décisions concernant control agents within EPPO countries. l’importation et le lâcher d’agents de lutte biologiques dans les pays de l’OEPP.

Specific approval and amendment Approbation et amendement spécifiques First approved in 2001-09. Revisions of the list are not subject to Approbation initiale en 2001-09. Les révisions de la liste ne sont pas approval by EPPO Council, but are decided by the Panel on Safe Use soumises à l’approbation du Conseil de l’OEPP, mais sont décidées par of Biological Control. Last revision in 2002-03. le Groupe d’experts sur la sécurité de la lutte biologique. Dernière révision en 2002-03.

Introduction Introduction EPPO Standards PM 6/1 and PM 6/2 provide guidelines to national Les Normes OEPP PM 6/1 et PM 6/2 fournissent des directives aux authorities in the EPPO region on the introduction and release of exotic autorités nationales de la région OEPP sur l’introduction et le lâcher biological control agents, so as to identify and avoid hazards for d’agents exotiques de lutte biologique, afin d’identifier et d’éviter les agricultural and natural ecosystems. These standards are intended to be risques pour les écosystèmes agricoles et naturels. Ces normes sont used in relation to future introductions but not retrospectively for past destinées à être utilisées en relation avec des introductions futures, introductions. There is extensive previous knowledge and experience of et non pas rétrospectivement pour d’anciennes introductions. the use of introduced biological control agents in a number of countries L’expérience et les connaissances accumulées sur l’utilisation des in the EPPO region, sufficient to indicate the absence of significant agents de lutte biologique introduits dans un certain nombre de pays risks, or the availability of reliable risk management measures, for de la région OEPP suffisent pour indiquer l’absence de risques many individual organisms. significatifs, ou l’existence de mesures appropriées pour la gestion du risque, pour de nombreux agents.

List of biological control agents Liste d’agents de lutte biologique This list accordingly specifies indigenous, introduced and established Cette liste spécifie donc les agents de lutte biologique indigènes, biological control agents1 which are recognized by the EPPO Panel introduits et établis1 qui sont reconnus par le Groupe d’experts OEPP on Safe Use of Biological Control to have been widely used in sur la sécurité de la lutte biologique comme ayant été largement utilisés several EPPO countries. Other EPPO countries may therefore presume dans plusieurs pays OEPP. D’autres pays OEPP peuvent donc with some confidence that these agents can be introduced and présumer, avec une certaine confiance, que ces agents peuvent être

1In relation to ISPM no. 3, this means biological control agents which either 1Par rapport à la NIMP no. 3, cela signifie les agents de lutte biologique originate in the EPPO region (i.e. indigenous), or have been released into an originaires de la région OEPP (c’est-à-dire indigènes), ou les agents de lutte ecosystem in the EPPO region where they did not exist previously (without biologique lâchés dans un écosystème de la région OEPP où ils n’étaient necessarily establishing) (i.e. introduced) or are perpetuating themselves pas présents (sans nécessairement s’établir) (c’est-à-dire introduits) ou les in the EPPO region after introduction for the foreseeable future (i.e. agents de lutte biologique persistants dans un avenir prévisible après leur established). introduction dans la région OEPP (c’est-à-dire établis).

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 447–461 447

448 Safe use of biological control

used safely. They may, according to their judgement, dispense with, introduits et utilisés en sécurité. Ils peuvent, d’après leur jugement, se or simplify, the notification procedures proposed in EPPO Standards passer de, ou simplifier, les procédures de notification proposées dans PM 6/1 and PM 6/2. les Normes OEPP PM 6/1 et PM 6/2. The agents are listed on the basis of an expert judgement of available Les agents sont ajoutés à la liste sur la base d’un jugement d’experts information. These are related to certain broad criteria, which are flex- sur les informations disponibles. Des critères larges sont appliqués, de ibly applied: manière flexible: (1) agent de lutte biologique classique utilisé avec succès ou (1) successful classical biological control agent, or (2) agent de lutte biologique qui est (ou a été) commercialisé et qui soit (2) biological control agent which is (or has been) commercially avail- est indigène et largement réparti dans la région OEPP, soit est établi able, and is either indigenous and widespread in the EPPO region, et largement réparti dans la région OEPP, soit a été utilisé pendant or established and widespread in the EPPO region, or has been used au moins 5 ans et dans au moins cinq pays OEPP (exceptionnelle- for at least 5 years in at least five EPPO countries (exceptionally ment moins, par ex. cultures cultivées dans quelques pays less, if crops are grown in few countries). seulement). Microorganisms used for biological control are not considered (since Les microorganismes utilisés pour la lutte biologique ne sont pas pris these are covered by EU Directive 91/414 or equivalent regulations in en compte (car ils sont couverts par la Directive de l’UE 91/414 ou des most EPPO countries). The absence of a given organism from the list réglementations équivalentes dans la plupart des pays OEPP). does not mean that it is considered unsafe, but only that it has not yet L’absence d’un organisme donné sur la liste ne signifie pas qu’il n’est been studied, that there are uncertainties that justify further study, or pas sûr, mais qu’il n’a pas encore été étudié, ou que des incertitudes else that its use is too recent for it to be included. The list (drawn up in nécessitent qu’il soit encore étudié, ou que son utilisation est trop English) is updated annually. It is divided into two parts: commercially récente pour pouvoir l’ajouter à la liste. La liste (établie en langue used biological control agents (Appendix I) and successfully intro- anglaise) est mise à jour chaque année. Elle est divisée en deux parties: duced classical biological control agents (Appendix II). agents de lutte biologique commercialisés (annexe I) et agents de lutte biologique introduit avec succès (annexe II).

Feltiella acarisuga Scutellista cyanea Appendix I Commercially used biological control Thripobius semiluteus agents / brassicae Further details are given for each agent on its name, common Anthocoris nemoralis Trichogramma cacoeciae synonyms, taxonomic classification, the pests against which it is Anthocoris nemorum Trichogramma dendrolimi mostly targeted, its origin, the date of first use as a commercial agent. Macrolophus melanotoma Trichogramma evanescens Countries where it is or has been used in the EPPO region are listed, albidipennis Orius laevigatus Neuroptera on the basis of information provided by the industry and by some Orius majusculus Chrysoperla carnea EPPO countries. This information was not available from all EPPO Picromerus bidens countries and may therefore be incomplete. Each agent has been used Podisus maculiventris Thysanoptera commercially at some time in the countries listed, but in some cases Franklinothrips megalops may no longer be commercially available or used there. Information is Franklinothrips vespiformis also given, when available, on natural distribution of the agent in the Anagrus atomus Karnyothrips melaleucus EPPO region, whether it is used in the field or under protected Anagyrus fusciventris conditions. Additional remarks are appended when needed. Anagyrus pseudococci Aphelinus abdominalis ARACHNIDA Aphidius colemani Acarina Table 1 List of commercially used biological control agents Aphidius ervi Amblyseius barkeri

Aphidius matricariae Amblyseius degenerans INSECTA Encyrtus lecaniorum Aphytis diaspidis Cheyletus eruditus Coleoptera Eretmocerus eremicus Aphytis holoxanthus Hypoaspis aculeifer Adalia bipunctata Eretmocerus mundus Aphytis lingnanensis Metaseiulus occidentalis Chilocorus baileyii Gyranusoidea litura Aphytis melinus Neoseiulus californicus Chilocorus bipustulatus Hungariella peregrina Aprostocetus hagenowii Neoseiulus cucumeris Chilocorus circumdatus Hungariella pretiosa Bracon hebetor Phytoseiulus persimilis Chilocorus nigrita Leptomastidea abnormis Cales noacki Stratiolaelaps miles Coccinella septempunctata Leptomastix dactylopii Coccophagus lycimnia Typhlodromus pyri Cryptolaemus montrouzieri Leptomastix epona Coccophagus rusti Delphastus catalinae Lysiphlebus testaceipes Coccophagus scutellaris NEMATODA Rhyzobius lophanthae Metaphycus flavus Compariella bifasciata Heterorhabditis bacteriophora Rodolia cardinalis Metaphycus helvolus Cotesia marginiventris Heterorhabditis megidis Scymnus rubromaculatus Metaphycus lounsburyi Dacnusa sibirica Phasmarhabditis hermaphrodita Stethorus punctillum Metaphycus swirskii Diglyphus isaea Steinernema carpocapsae Microterys flavus Encarsia citrina Steinernema feltiae Diptera Opius pallipes Encarsia formosa Aphidoletes aphidimyza Praon volucre Encyrtus infelix Episyrphus balteatus Pseudaphycus maculipennis

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 447–461

List of widely used agents 449

Cryptolaemus montrouzieri INSECTA Family: Coccinellidae Main target pest: Planococcus citri Coleoptera Original distribution: Australia Adalia bipunctata Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean area Family: Coccinellidae Date of first use: 1985 Main target pests: Aphididae EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Original distribution: Palaearctic (?) Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Netherlands, Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Norway, Poland, Portugal, Russia, Slovakia, Spain, Sweden, Date of first use: ? Switzerland, Tunisia, UK EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Germany, Netherlands, Use: Indoors/outdoors Portugal, Switzerland Use: Indoors Delphastus catalinae Synonym: Delphastus pusillae Chilocorus baileyii Family: Coccinellidae Family: Coccinellidae Main target pests: Aleyrodidae (Trialeurodes vaporariorum, Bemisia Main target pests: Diaspididae tabaci) Original distribution: Australia Original distribution: Nearctic/Neotropic Distribution in EPPO: Not established Distribution in EPPO: Not established Date of first use: 1985 Date of first use: 1993 EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Germany, Netherlands EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Finland, Use: Indoors France, Germany, Greece, Jordan, Netherlands, Poland, Russia, Spain, Tunisia, UK (restricted under license) Chilocorus bipustulatus Use: Indoors Family: Coccinellidae Main target pests: Diaspididae, Coccidae (Saissetia oleae) Rhyzobius lophanthae Original distribution: South Palaearctic Synonym: Lindorus lophanthae Distribution in EPPO: Widespread (South and Central) Family: Coccinellidae Date of first use: 1959 Main target pests: Diaspididae (Pseudolacaspis pentagona), EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Greece, Israel, Italy, Quadraspidiotus perniciosus, Chrysomphalus dictyospermi, Netherlands, Turkey Parlatoria blanchardi Use: Outdoors/indoors Original distribution: Australia Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean, Russia Chilocorus circumdatus Date of first use: 1980 Family: Coccinellidae EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Denmark, Germany, Greece, Main target pests: Diaspididae Israel, Italy, Netherlands, Portugal, Switzerland, Turkey Original distribution: S.E. Asia Use: Indoors Distribution in EPPO: Not established Date of first use: 1985 Rodolia cardinalis EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Germany, Family: Coccinellidae Netherlands Main target pest: Icerya purchasi Use: Indoors Original distribution: Australia Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean, CIS Chilocorus nigrita Date of first use: ?1980s Family: Coccinellidae EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Netherlands Main target pests: Diaspididae, Asterolecaniidae Use: Indoors/outdoors Original distribution: S. Asia, E. Africa Distribution in EPPO: Not established Scymnus rubromaculatus Date of first use: 1985 Family: Coccinellidae EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Main target pests: Aphididae Netherlands, UK Original distribution: Central Europe Use: Indoors Distribution in EPPO: Finland, Estonia, Lithuania Date of first use: 1990 Coccinella septempunctata EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Netherlands, Portugal Family: Coccinellidae Use: Indoors Main target pests: Aphididae Original distribution: Palaearctic Stethorus punctillum Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Family: Coccinellidae Date of first use: 1980 Main target pest: Panonychus ulmi EPPO countries where used: France, Germany, Portugal Original distribution: Palaearctic Use: Outdoors Distribution in EPPO: Widespread

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 447–461

450 Safe use of biological control

Date of first use: 1995 EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, UK Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Sweden Use: Outdoors Use: Indoors Macrolophus melanotoma Synonyms: Macrolophus caliginosus Diptera Family: Miridae Aphidoletes aphidimyza Main target pests: Aleyrodidae Family: Cecidomyiidae Original distribution: Mediterranean Main target pests: Aphididae (Aphis gossypii, Myzus persicae, Distribution in EPPO: Croatia, Turkey, France, Greece, Hungary, Macrosiphum sp., Aulacorthum sp.) Italy, Malta, Macedonia, Portugal, Spain (including Islas Canarias), Original distribution: Central Europe, Palaearctic Switzerland, Algeria, Morocco, Tunisia, Cyprus, Israel (also Libya, Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Yemen, Iraq) Date of first use: 1985 Date of first use: 1990 EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Jordan, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Jordan, Lithuania, Malta, Morocco, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Lithuania, Malta, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Spain, Slovakia, Sweden, Switzerland, Tunisia, UK Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Tunisia, Turkey, UK (restricted under Use: Indoors/outdoors licence) Use: Indoors Episyrphus balteatus Additional remarks: Macrolophus melanotoma has been reported as Family: Syrphidae damaging on cherry tomato and on Gerbera. It is therefore not Main target pests: Aphididae recommended for use on these crops. Caution is advised when using Original distribution: Europe M. melanotoma on any new crop, particularly ornamentals with a Distribution in EPPO: Widespread low threshold for cosmetic damage Date of first use: 1995 EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Denmark, Germany, Italy, Orius albidipennis Netherlands, Portugal Family: Use: Indoors/outdoors Main target pests: Original distribution: Mediterranean, palaearctic Feltiella acarisuga Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean Synonyms: Therodiplosis persicae Date of first use: 1991 Family: Cecidomyiidae EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Israel, Italy, Main target pests: Tetranychus urticae, T. cinnabarinus Netherlands, Spain Original distribution: W. Europe/Mediterranean Use: Indoors Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Date of first use: 1995 Orius laevigatus EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Finland, Family: Anthocoridae France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Lithuania, Netherlands, Norway, Main target pests: Thripidae ( occidentalis, Thrips Poland, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, UK tabaci) Use: Indoors Original distribution: Palaearctic (except north) Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Date of first use: 1991 Hemiptera/Heteroptera EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Anthocoris nemoralis Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Jordan, Family: Anthocoridae Lithuania, Malta, Morocco, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Main target pests: Psyllidae (orchards) Slovakia, Spain, Switzerland, Tunisia, UK Original distribution: Palaearctic Use: Indoors Established in EPPO: Yes Distribution in EPPO: Palaearctic Orius majusculus Date of first use: ? Family: Anthocoridae EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Denmark, Netherlands Main target pests: Thripidae (Frankliniella occidentalis, Thrips Use: Outdoors tabaci) Original distribution: Palaearctic Anthocoris nemorum Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Family: Anthocoridae Date of first use: 1991 Main target pests: Cacopsylla pyri, thrips EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Original distribution: Palaearctic Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Italy, Lithuania, Netherlands, Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Norway, Poland, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, UK Date of first use: 1992 Use: Indoors

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 447–461

List of widely used agents 451

Picromerus bidens Jordan, Netherlands, Poland, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Family: Pentatomidae Tunisia, UK Main target pests: Use: Indoors Original distribution: Palaearctic (also established in Nearctic) Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Aphidius colemani Date of first use: 1990 Family: Braconidae EPPO countries where used: CIS countries, Germany, Poland, Main target pests: Aphididae (Aphis gossypii, Myzus persicae, Russia M. nicotianae) Use: Outdoors/indoors Original distribution: North Africa, Middle East, India Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean area Podisus maculiventris Date of first use: 1992 Family: Pentatomidae EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Main target pests: Lepidoptera, Leptinotarsa decemlineata Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Jordan, Original distribution: North and South America Lithuania, Malta, Morocco, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Distribution in EPPO: Not established Slovakia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Tunisia, Turkey, UK Date of first use: 1996 Use: Indoors EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Bulgaria, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Italy, Netherlands, Russia, Spain Aphidius ervi Use: Indoors/outdoors Family: Braconidae Main target pest: Macrosiphum euphorbiae Original distribution: Palaearctic Hymenoptera Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Anagrus atomus Date of first use: 1995 Family: Mymaridae EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Finland, Main target pests: Cicadellidae France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Lithuania, Netherlands, Original distribution: Palaearctic Norway, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, UK Distribution in EPPO: ? Use: Indoors/outdoors Date of first use: 1994 EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Germany, Aphidius matricariae Netherlands, Spain, UK Family: Braconidae Use: Indoors Main target pest: Myzus persicae Original distribution: Holarctic Anagyrus fusciventris Distribution in EPPO: Widespread in temperate regions Family: Encyrtidae Date of first use: 1990 Main target pests: Pseudococcidae EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Netherlands, Poland, Original distribution: Australia Portugal, Slovakia, UK Distribution in EPPO: Not present Use: Indoors Date of first use: 1990 EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Aphytis diaspidis Netherlands, Spain Family: Aphelinidae Use: Indoors Main target pests: Diaspididae, Quadraspidiotus perniciosus, Pseudaulacaspis pentagona Anagyrus pseudococci Original distribution: California Family: Encyrtidae Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean Main target pests: Pseudococcidae Date of first use: ? Original distribution: Mediterranean EPPO countries where used: Netherlands Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean Use: Indoors Date of first use: 1995 EPPO countries where used: France, Czechia, Greece, Italy, Aphytis holoxanthus Netherlands, Portugal, Spain Family: Aphelinidae Use: Indoors/outdoors Main target pests: Diaspididae Original distribution: Asia Aphelinus abdominalis Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean Family: Aphelinidae Date of first use: 1996 Main target pests: Aphididae (Macrosiphum euphorbiae, EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Czechia, France, Germany, Aulacorthum solani) Netherlands, Spain Original distribution: Europe Use: Indoors Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Date of first use: 1992 Aphytis lingnanensis EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Czechia, Family: Aphelinidae Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Main target pests: Aonidiella aurantii, Chrysomphalus dictyospermi

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 447–461

452 Safe use of biological control

Original distribution: Probably eastern Asia (widely established Original distribution: Cosmopolitan elsewhere) Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean Date of first use: 1988 Date of first use: ? EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Netherlands, EPPO countries where used: Greece, Italy, Spain Spain Use: Indoors/outdoors Use: Indoors

Aphytis melinus Coccophagus scutellaris Family: Aphelinidae Family: Aphelinidae Main target pest: Aonidiella aurantii Main target pests: Coccidae Original distribution: India/Pakistan Original distribution: Cosmopolitan Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Date of first use: 1985 Date of first use: 1986 EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, France, EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Germany, Germany, Greece, Portugal, Spain Netherlands, Portugal, Spain Use: Outdoors/indoors Use: Indoors

Aprostocetus hagenowii Comperiella bifasciata Synonyms: Tetrastichus hagenowii, Tetrastichodes hagenowii Family: Encyrtidae Family: Eulophidae Main target pests: Diaspididae (Chrysomphalus aonidum, Aonidiella Main target pests: Blattidae (Periplaneta spp.) aurantii) Original distribution: ? Original distribution: ?California/South China Distribution in EPPO: Romania Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean Date of first use: 1993 Date of first use: 1985 EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Germany, EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Greece, Netherlands Netherlands, Spain Use: Indoors/outdoors Use: Indoors Cotesia marginiventris Bracon hebetor Synonyms: Apanteles marginiventris Synonyms: Habrobracon hebetor Family: Braconidae Family: Braconidae Main target pests: Lepidoptera (Noctuidae) Main target pests: Lepidoptera (on stored products) Original distribution: Americas Original distribution: India, New England Distribution in EPPO: ? Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean area (mostly Eastern) Date of first use: 1993 Date of first use: 1980 EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Germany, EPPO countries where used: Many (including Germany, Portugal) Netherlands, Spain Use: Indoors Use: Indoors

Cales noacki Dacnusa sibirica Family: Aphelinidae Family: Braconidae Main target pest: Aleurothrixus floccosus Main target pests: (Liriomyza spp.) Original distribution: Chile Original distribution: Palaearctic, Europe Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean Distribution in EPPO: Widespread, temperate regions Date of first use: 1970 Date of first use: 1981 EPPO countries where used: France, Greece, Israel, Italy, Malta, EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Czechia, Morocco, Portugal, Spain, Tunisia Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Italy, Jordan, Malta, Morocco, Use: Outdoors Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, UK Coccophagus lycimnia Use: Indoors/outdoors (celery, lettuce) Family: Aphelinidae Main target pests: Coccidae Diglyphus isaea Original distribution: Cosmopolitan Family: Eulophidae Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean Main target pests: Agromyzidae (Liriomyza spp.) Date of first use: 1988 Original distribution: Palaearctic EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Sweden Date of first use: 1984 Use: Indoors EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Hungary, Italy, Jordan, Malta, Morocco, Coccophagus rusti Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Spain, Sweden, Family: Aphelinidae Switzerland, Tunisia, Turkey, UK Main target pests: Coccidae Use: Indoors/outdoors

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 447–461 List of widely used agents 453

Encarsia citrina Original distribution: South Europe Family: Aphelinidae Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean Main target pests: Diaspididae Date of first use: 1996 Original distribution: Cosmopolitan EPPO countries where used: Germany, Italy, Netherlands, Portugal, Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean Spain Date of first use: 1984 Use: Indoors EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Germany, Netherlands, Spain Gyranusoidea litura Use: Indoors Family: Encyrtidae Main target pest: Pseudococcus longispinus Encarsia formosa Original distribution: Africa Family: Aphelinidae Distribution in EPPO: France, Spain Main target pests: Aleyrodidae (Trialeurodes vaporariorum, Bemisia Date of first use: 1990 tabaci) EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Germany, Original distribution: Southern nearctic Netherlands Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Use: Indoors Date of first use: 1930 EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Czechia, Hungariella peregrina Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Family: Encyrtidae Jordan, Lithuania, Malta, Morocco, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Main target pests: Pseudococcidae Portugal, Slovakia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Tunisia, Turkey, Original distribution: North America UK Distribution in EPPO: Israel Use: Indoors Date of first use: 1992 EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Israel, Netherlands, Encyrtus infelix Spain Synonyms: Eucomys tananarivensis Use: Indoors/outdoors Family: Encyrtidae Main target pests: Coccidae Hungariella pretiosa Original distribution: Afrotropical region Family: Encyrtidae Distribution in EPPO: Israel Main target pests: Pseudococcidae Date of first use: 1992 Original distribution: ? EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Distribution in EPPO: Italy Netherlands, Spain Date of first use: 1992 Use: Indoors EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Netherlands, Spain Use: Indoors Encyrtus lecaniorum Family: Encyrtidae Leptomastidea abnormis Main target pests: Coccidae Synonym: Leptomastix abnormis Original distribution: Palaearctic Family: Encyrtidae Distribution in EPPO: Widespread (south) Main target pests: Pseudococcidae Date of first use: 1980 Original distribution: Palaearctic EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Germany, Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Netherlands, Spain Date of first use: 1984 Use: Indoors EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Germany, Israel, Italy, Netherlands, Spain, Switzerland, Turkey, UK Eretmocerus eremicus Use: Indoors Synonyms: Eretmocerus californicus Family: Aphelinidae Leptomastix dactylopii Main target pest: Bemisia tabaci Family: Encyrtidae Original distribution: Southern nearctic Main target pest: Planococcus citri Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean Original distribution: Neotropic Date of first use: 1994 Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean area EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Finland, Date of first use: 1992 France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Lithuania, Malta, EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Morocco, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Spain, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Netherlands, Switzerland, Tunisia, Turkey Norway, Poland, Portugal, Spain, UK Use: Indoors Use: Indoors/outdoors

Eretmocerus mundus Leptomastix epona Family: Aphelinidae Family: Encyrtidae Main target pest: Bemisia tabaci Main target pests: Pseudococcidae, especially Pseudococcus affinis

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 447–461 454 Safe use of biological control

Original distribution: Palaearctic Main target pests: Coccidae (Saissetia oleae) Distribution in EPPO: Widespread (south) Original distribution: California, Pakistan Date of first use: 1992 Distribution in EPPO: Italy EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Germany, Date of first use: 1987 Netherlands, Spain, UK EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Use: Indoors Greece, Israel, Netherlands, Spain, former Yugoslavia Use: Indoors/outdoors Lysiphlebus testaceipes Family: Braconidae Opius pallipes Main target pests: Aphididae (Aphis gossypii) Family: Braconidae Original distribution: Nearctic, USA Main target pest: Liriomyza bryoniae Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean countries (and possibly others) Original distribution: Palaearctic (?) Date of first use: 1990 Distribution in EPPO: Widespread EPPO countries where used: Denmark, Italy, Spain Date of first use: 1980 Use: Indoors EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, France, Germany, Greece, Lithuania, Netherlands, Poland, Spain, UK Metaphycus flavus Use: Indoors Family: Encyrtidae Main target pests: Coccidae, Saissetia oleae, Coccus hesperidum Praon volucre Original distribution: Nearctic Synonym: Aphydius volucre Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean Family: Braconidae Date of first use: 1999 Main target pests: Aphididae EPPO countries where used: Germany, Netherlands, Switzerland Original distribution: Palaearctic Use: Indoors Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Date of first use: ? Metaphycus helvolus EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Germany, Netherlands, Family: Encyrtidae UK Main target pests: Coccidae (Saissetia oleae, Coccus hesperidum) Use: Indoors Original distribution: South Africa (also established in Nearctic) Distribution in EPPO: Greece, Italy Pseudaphycus maculipennis Date of first use: 1992 Family: Encyrtidae EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Denmark, France, Main target pests: Pseudococcidae Germany, Greece, Israel, Italy, Netherlands, Spain, Sweden, Original distribution: Palaearctic Switzerland Distribution in EPPO: Widespread (south) Use: Indoors/outdoors Date of first use: 1980 EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Germany, Metaphycus lounsburyi Netherlands, Spain Synonyms: M. bartletti, M. anneckei and M. hagenowii, also Use: Indoors established in some Mediterranean countries, have been misidentified as M. lounsburyi Scutellista cyanea Family: Encyrtidae Synonym: Scutellista caerulea Main target pests: Coccidae (Saissetia oleae) Family: Pteromalidae Original distribution: California, Australia, Hawaii, South Africa Main target pests: Coccidae (Saissetia oleae, S. coffea, Ceroplastes Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean rusci) Date of first use: 1997 Original distribution: Africa EPPO countries where used: Denmark, France, Italy, Netherlands Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean, CIS Use: Indoors/outdoors Date of first use: 1990 EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Denmark, France, Metaphycus swirskii Netherlands, Switzerland Family: Encyrtidae Use: Indoors Main target pests: Coccidae Original distribution: East Africa? Thripobius semiluteus Distribution in EPPO: France, Greece (Crete), Israel, Italy (probably Family: Eulophidae more widely in Mediterranean region) Main target pests: Thysanoptera (Heliothrips spp.) Date of first use: 1992 Original distribution: Tropical and subtropical areas of Africa, Asia EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Germany, and Australia Netherlands, Spain Distribution in EPPO: Israel Use: Indoors Date of first use: 1995 EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Microterys flavus Netherlands Family: Encyrtidae Use: Indoors

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 447–461 List of widely used agents 455

Trichogramma brassicae Original distribution: Africa, Israel, India Family: Distribution in EPPO: Israel, Tunisia Main target pests: Lepidoptera (Ostrinia nubilalis) Date of first use: 1992 Original distribution: Europe EPPO countries where used: Belgium, France, Netherlands, Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Spain Date of first use: 1980 Use: Indoors EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Italy, Jordan, Netherlands, Franklinothrips vespiformis Slovakia, Spain, Switzerland, UK Family: Use: Outdoors/indoors Main target pests: Thrips Original distribution: Asia Trichogramma cacoeciae Distribution in EPPO: Israel, Portugal Family: Trichogrammatidae Date of first use: 1990 Main target pests: Lepidoptera EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Original distribution: Europe Israel, Netherlands, Portugal, Sweden, Switzerland Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Use: Indoors Date of first use: 1980 EPPO countries where used: Denmark, France, Germany, Karnyothrips melaleucus Hungary Family: Phlaeothripidae Use: Outdoors Main target pests: Coccidae, Diaspididae (Howardia biclavis) Original distribution: Pantropical Trichogramma dendrolimi Distribution in EPPO: Portugal (Madeira) Family: Trichogrammatidae Date of first use: 1994 Main target pests: Lepidoptera EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Denmark, France, Original distribution: Europe Netherlands, Spain Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Use: Indoors Date of first use: 1985 EPPO countries where used: Germany, Slovakia Use: Outdoors ARACHNIDA Acarina Trichogramma evanescens Family: Trichogrammatidae Amblyseius barkeri Main target pests: Lepidoptera (including on stored products) Synonyms: Amblyseius mackenziei, Neoseiulus barkeri Original distribution: Europe Family: Phytoseiidae Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Main target pests: Thysanoptera (Thrips tabaci, Frankliniella Date of first use: 1993 occidentalis) EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Original distribution: Europe Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Italy, Jordan, Netherlands, Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Portugal, Slovakia, Spain, Tunisia, UK Date of first use: 1981 Use: Indoors/outdoors EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, Slovakia, Switzerland Use: Indoors Neuroptera Chrysoperla carnea Amblyseius degenerans Synonym: Chrysopa carnea Synonyms: Iphiseius degenerans Family: Chrysopidae Family: Phytoseiidae Main target pests: Aphididae, etc. Main target pests: Thysanoptera Original distribution: Cosmopolitan Original distribution: Africa/Mediterranean Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Distribution in EPPO: Mediterranean Date of first use: 1987 Date of first use: 1993 EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Finland, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Netherlands, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, UK Poland, Spain, Switzerland, Tunisia, Turkey, UK Use: Indoors/outdoors Use: Indoors

Cheyletus eruditus Thysanoptera Family: Cheyletidae Franklinothrips megalops Main target pests: Storage mites, spider (foliage) mites Synonym: Franklinothrips myrmicaeformis Original distribution: Indigenous Family: Aeolothripidae Distribution in EPPO: Belgium, Netherlands Main target pests: Thrips Date of first use: 1985

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 447–461 456 Safe use of biological control

EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Czech Republic, France, Distribution in EPPO: Southern Europe Germany, Netherlands Date of first use: 1968 Use: Indoors EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Additional remarks: Cases of allergic reactions to farmers have been Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Jordan, reported Lithuania, Malta, Morocco, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Tunisia, Turkey, UK Hypoaspis aculeifer Use: Indoors/outdoors Family: Laelapidae Main target pests: Sciaridae, Rhizoglyphus echinopus Stratiolaelaps miles Original distribution: Europe Synonyms: Hypoaspis miles, Geolaelaps miles Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Family: Laelapidae Date of first use: 1995 Main target pests: Sciaridae, Rhizoglyphus echinopus EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Finland, Original distribution: Palaearctic France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Netherlands, Norway, Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Poland, Portugal, Spain, Switzerland, UK Date of first use: 1994 Use: Indoors EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Netherlands, Norway, Metaseiulus occidentalis Poland, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, UK Synonyms: Galendromus occidentalis, Typhlodromus occidentalis Use: Indoors Family: Phytoseiidae Main target pests: Tetranychidae Typhlodromus pyri Original distribution: Nearctic Family: Phytoseiidae Distribution in EPPO: ? Main target pests: Panonychus ulmi, Tetranychus urticae, Eriophyes Date of first use: 1991 vitis, Epitrimerus vitis EPPO countries where used: Denmark, France, Germany, Greece, Original distribution: Europe/Nearctic Netherlands, Poland, Spain, UK Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Use: Indoors/outdoors Date of first use: 1985 EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Neoseiulus californicus France, Germany, Hungary, Portugal, Slovakia Synonyms: Amblyseius californicus, Typhlodromus californicus, Use: Outdoors Amblyseius mungeri, Typhlodromus mungeri, Amblyseius chilensis, Typhlodromus marinus Family: Phytoseiidae NEMATODA Main target pests: Tetranychidae Heterorhabditis bacteriophora Original distribution: Southern N. America/California Synonyms: Heterorhabditis heliothidis Distribution in EPPO: ? Family: Heterorhabditidae Date of first use: 1985 Main target pests: Vine weevils (Otiorhynchus spp.) EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Finland, Original distribution: South and central Europe/N. America France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Malta, Netherlands, Poland, Distribution in EPPO: South and central Europe Portugal, Spain, Switzerland, Tunisia, UK (restricted under license) Date of first use: 1984 Use: Indoors/outdoors EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, Switzerland Neoseiulus cucumeris Use: Outdoors/?indoors Synonyms: Amblyseius cucumeris Family: Phytoseiidae Heterorhabditis megidis Main target pests: Thysanoptera (T. tabaci, F. occidentalis) Family: Heterorhabditidae Original distribution: Cosmopolitan Main target pests: Vine weevils (Otiorhynchus spp.) Distribution in EPPO: Widespread (not present in Sweden, Finland, Original distribution: Europe Norway) Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Date of first use: 1985 Date of first use: 1984 EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Jordan, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Netherlands, Lithuania, Malta, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Norway, Poland, Slovakia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Tunisia, UK Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Tunisia, Turkey, UK Use: Indoors/outdoors Use: Indoors/outdoors Phasmarhabditis hermaphrodita Phytoseiulus persimilis Family: Phasmarhabditidae Synonyms: Phytoseiulus riegeli, Phytoseiulus tardi Main target pests: Slugs Family: Phytoseiidae Original distribution: Central Europe Main target pests: Tetranychidae (Tetranychus urticae) Distribution in EPPO: Widespread (except in Northern countries) Original distribution: Mediterranean Date of first use: 1984

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 447–461 List of widely used agents 457

EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Table 2 List of successfully introduced classical biological control agents Italy, Netherlands, UK Use: Indoors/outdoors INSECTA Aphytis lingnanensis Coleoptera Aphytis melinus Steinernema carpocapsae Adalia bipunctata Aphytis proclia Synonyms: Neoaplectana carpocapsae, N. feltiae Cryptolaemus montrouzieri Archenomus orientalis Family: Steinernematidae Harmonia axyridis Cales noacki Main target pests: Vine weevils (Otiorhynchus spp.), Sciaridae, soil- Rhizophagus grandis Clausenia purpurea borne Rhyzobius forestieri Comperiella bifasciata Rodolia cardinalis Encarsia berlesei Original distribution: Europe (Holarctic) Scymnus impexus Encarsia elongata Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Scymnus reunioni Encarsia lahorensis Date of first use: 1984 Serangium parcesetosum Encarsia perniciosi EPPO countries where used: Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Eretmocerus debachi Italy, Netherlands, Portugal, Sweden, UK Diptera Lysiphlebus testaceipes Use: Indoors/outdoors Cryptochetum iceryae Metaphycus anneckei Metaphycus flavus Steinernema feltiae Hymenoptera Metaphycus helvolus Synonyms: Neoaplectana feltiae, N. bibionis, Steinernema bibionis, Ageniaspis citricola Metaphycus lounsburyi N. leucaniae Allotropa burrelli Metaphycus swirskii Family: Steinernematidae Allotropa convexifrons Neodryinus typhlocybae Main target pests: Melolonthidae, Sciaridae, etc. Amitus spiniferus Neodusmetia sangwani Original distribution: Europe (Holarctic) Anagyrus agraensis Ooencyrtus kuvanae Distribution in EPPO: Widespread Anagyrus fusciventris Pseudaphycus malinus Date of first use: 1984 Anaphes nitens Psyllaephagus pilosus EPPO countries where used: Austria, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Aphelinus mali Psyttalia concolor Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Netherlands, Aphytis holoxanthus Pteroptrix smithi Norway, Poland, Slovakia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, UK Aphytis lepidosaphes Use: Indoors/outdoors

Appendix II Successfully introduced classical INSECTA biological control agents Further details are given for each agent on its name, common synonyms, Coleoptera taxonomic classification, the pest(s) against which it has been used, date of first use, whether the agent was introduced as single or multiple Adalia bipunctata introductions, and the origin of the collected material. Countries where Family: Coccinellidae the agent has been introduced for classical biological control in the Main target pest: Toxoptera aurantii EPPO region are listed. The presence of an agent on the list means that Date of first use: ? it has been used successfully in at least one of the countries mentioned. EPPO countries where introduced: Portugal (Azores) [S*] The result of the introduction is given, when available, as follows: [C] (Widespread in the EPPO region) complete, [S] substantial, [P] partial, [E] established but not contributing Multiple/single introductions: Single to control or status unknown, [F] failed to become established; [N] no Origin of collected material: Portugal information on the outcome; [T] established but believed to have died out. Asterisks (*) indicate cases where more than one organism Cryptolaemus montrouzieri contributed to the result. Information on countries and result of Family: Coccinellidae introduction are given on the basis of information provided by the Target pest: Pseudococcidae BIOCAT database of CABI (data from 1997 and 2000) and by some Date of first use: 1929 EPPO countries. Countries are, as far as possible, listed in the EPPO countries where introduced: Portugal [S] (Mediterranean chronological order of introduction of the agent for classical biological distribution) control. The list of countries indicates to a certain degree the area in Multiple/single introductions: Single which each organism is present and established in the EPPO region, to Origin of collected material: Australia the extent that each successful introduction can be presumed to have involved establishment. However, organisms may already be indigenous Target pest: Planococcus citri in some parts of the EPPO region, or have spread from countries where Date of first use: 1908- they were introduced, or indeed have disappeared from countries where EPPO countries where introduced: Italy [E; Sardegna P; Sicilia E], they were once established, so the true distribution is uncertain in many Israel [P], Portugal, Greece [F], Cyprus [T], Spain [T], former USSR cases. In some cases, a general statement can be made about present (Georgia) [F?] (Mediterranean distribution) distribution in the EPPO region and this has been added in italics at the Multiple/single introductions: Single, multiple end of the list of countries. Origin of collected material: Australia

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 447–461 458 Safe use of biological control

Harmonia axyridis EPPO countries where introduced: former USSR [Georgia, C*; Family: Coccinellidae Azerbaijan, C*; Uzbekistan, F], France (Corse) [E], Israel, Turkey Main target pest: Toxoptera aurantii [S?] Date of first use: 1964 Multiple/single introductions: Single EPPO countries where introduced: Portugal (Azores) [S*], Greece, Origin of collected material: India, former USSR former USSR [N], Ukraine, Tunisia, Italy Multiple/single introductions: Single Diptera Origin of collected material: East Asia Cryptochetum iceryae Rhizophagus grandis Family: Cryptochetidae Family: Rhizophagidae Main target pest: Icerya purchasi Main target pest: Dendroctonus micans Date of first use: 1987 Date of first use: 1963- EPPO countries where introduced: Israel [S] EPPO countries where introduced: former USSR (Georgia) [S], UK Multiple/single introductions: Single [E], France [E] (Probably widespread in Central & Eastern Europe) Origin of collected material: Australia Multiple/single introductions: Single, multiple Origin of collected material: Belgium Hymenoptera Rhyzobius forestieri Ageniaspis citricola Family: Coccinellidae Family: Encyrtidae Main target pest: Saissetia oleae Main target pest: Phyllocnistis citrella Date of first use: 1980 Date of first use: 1994- EPPO countries where introduced: Italy [S], France [S], Greece [E], EPPO countries where introduced: Israel, Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, Cyprus [N], Israel [E] France, Greece, Cyprus, Spain, Italy (Sicilia) Multiple/single introductions: Single Multiple/single introductions: Single, multiple Origin of collected material: Australia Origin of collected material: Thailand, Florida (USA)

Rodolia cardinalis Allotropa burrelli Family: Coccinellidae Family: Platygasteridae Main target pest: Icerya purchasi Main target pest: Pseudococcus comstocki Date of first use: 1897- Date of first use: 1945 EPPO countries where introduced: Portugal [C], former USSR EPPO countries where introduced: former USSR [P*] (Georgia) [C], Italy [S], former Yugoslavia [N], Israel [C*], France Multiple/single introductions: Single [C], Spain [S], Switzerland [F], Greece [S], Malta [C], Cyprus [S] Origin of collected material: Japan (Mediterranean distribution, CIS) Multiple/single introductions: Single, multiple Allotropa convexifrons Origin of collected material: Australia Family: Platygasteridae Main target pest: Pseudococcus comstocki Scymnus impexus Date of first use: 1945 Family: Coccinellidae EPPO countries where introduced: former USSR [P*] Main target pests: Adelges spp. Multiple/single introductions: Single Date of first use: 1968 Origin of collected material: Korea EPPO countries where introduced: Sweden [S], UK [N] (native in Europe) Amitus spiniferus Multiple/single introductions: Single Family: Platygasteridae Origin of collected material: Germany Main target pest: Aleurothrixus floccosus Date of first use: 1971- Scymnus reunioni EPPO countries where introduced: France [C*], Italy [S*] Synonym: Nephus reunioni Multiple/single introductions: Single Family: Coccinellidae Origin of collected material: Central America Main target pest: Planococcus citri Date of first use: 1967 Anagyrus agraensis EPPO countries where introduced: Israel [N], Italy (Sardegna) [P], Family: Encyrtidae former USSR (Georgia) [F?] Main target pest: Nipaecoccus viridis Multiple/single introductions: Single Date of first use: 1984- Origin of collected material: India EPPO countries where introduced: Jordan [S?], Israel [S?] Multiple/single introductions: Single Serangium parcesetosum Origin of collected material: Guam Family: Coccinellidae Main target pest: Dialeurodes citri Anagyrus fusciventris Date of first use: 1973 Family: Encyrtidae

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 447–461 List of widely used agents 459

Main target pests: Pseudococcidae (Pseudococcus longispinus) Multiple/single introductions: ? Date of first use: 1972 Origin of collected material: India/Pakistan EPPO countries where introduced: Israel [S] Multiple/single introductions: Single Target pest: Aonidiella aurantii Origin of collected material: Australia Date of first use: 1961- EPPO countries where introduced: Cyprus [P], Israel [P], Italy Anaphes nitens (Sicilia) [P], Morocco [E] (Mediterranean distribution) Family: Mymaridae Multiple/single introductions: Single, multiple Main target pest: Gonipterus scutellatus Origin of collected material: India/Pakistan Date of first use: 1978 EPPO countries where introduced: Italy [C], France [P], Spain [S] Target pest: Aspidiotus nerii Multiple/single introductions: Single Date of first use: ? Origin of collected material: Australia EPPO countries where introduced: Greece (Kriti) [P] (Mediterranean distribution) Aphelinus mali Multiple/single introductions: Single Family: Aphelinidae Origin of collected material: India/Pakistan Main target pest: Eriosoma lanigerum Date of first use: 1920- Aphytis proclia EPPO countries where introduced: France [P], Israel [P], Italy [S], Family: Aphelinidae Switzerland [S], former USSR (Azerbaijan) [C], Portugal [N], Main target pest: Pseudaulacaspis pentagona Belgium [C], Germany [P], UK [P], Slovenia, Malta, Netherlands Date of first use: 1924 [P], Spain [P], Poland [P], Sweden [P], Cyprus [C], Denmark [P] EPPO countries where introduced: Italy [S] (Widespread in the (Widespread in the EPPO region) EPPO region) Multiple/single introductions: Single Multiple/single introductions: Single Origin of collected material: USA Origin of collected material: East Asia

Aphytis holoxanthus Archenomus orientalis Family: Aphelinidae Family: Aphelinidae Main target pest: Chrysomphalus aonidum Main target pest: Pseudaulacaspis pentagona Date of first use: 1956 Date of first use: 1909 EPPO countries where introduced: Israel [C*] (Mediterranean EPPO countries where introduced: Italy [S] distribution) Multiple/single introductions: Single Multiple/single introductions: Single Origin of collected material: Japan Origin of collected material: Hong Kong Cales noacki Aphytis lepidosaphes Family: Aphelinidae Family: Aphelinidae Main target pest: Aleurothrixus floccosus Main target pest: Cornuaspis beckii Date of first use: 1970- Date of first use: 1956- EPPO countries where introduced: Spain [S], France [C], Italy [S], EPPO countries where introduced: Israel [C], Cyprus [N], France Morocco [C], Portugal [E], Tunisia [C], Malta, Greece [N], Greece [S], Spain [S], Italy (Sicilia) [P] (Mediterranean distribution) Multiple/single introductions: Single Multiple/single introductions: Single, multiple Origin of collected material: China Origin of collected material: Chile

Aphytis lingnanensis Clausenia purpurea Family: Aphelinidae Family: Encyrtidae Main target pest: Aonidiella aurantii Main target pest: Pseudococcus citriculus Date of first use: 1960- Date of first use: 1940 EPPO countries where introduced: Cyprus [P], Israel [E], Italy EPPO countries where introduced: Israel [C] (Sicilia), Morocco [E] (Mediterranean distribution) Multiple/single introductions: Single Multiple/single introductions: Single Origin of collected material: Japan Origin of collected material: China Comperiella bifasciata Aphytis melinus Family: Encyrtidae Family: Aphelinidae Main target pest: Aonidiella aurantii Target pest: Chrysomphalus dictyospermi Date of first use: 1924- Date of first use: 1962- EPPO countries where introduced: Israel [P*], Italy, France [N] EPPO countries where introduced: Greece [S; Kriti, C], Italy [C], (Mediterranean distribution) Morocco [C], France (Corse) [C], Spain [S], former USSR (Georgia) Multiple/single introductions: Single [E?] (Mediterranean distribution) Origin of collected material: South China

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 447–461 460 Safe use of biological control

Encarsia berlesei Multiple/single introductions: Single, multiple Family: Aphelinidae Origin of collected material: USA Main target pest: Pseudaulacaspis pentagona Date of first use: 1906- Metaphycus anneckei EPPO countries where introduced: Italy [C], Bulgaria [C], Family: Encyrtidae Switzerland [C], Spain [C], Austria [C], former USSR [C], France Main target pest: Saissetia oleae [P], Hungary, Slovenia Date of first use: ? Multiple/single introductions: Single EPPO countries where introduced: Greece [C], Israel [E], France [E], Origin of collected material: Japan, East Asia Italy [F] Multiple/single introductions: Single Encarsia elongata Origin of collected material: South Africa Family: Aphelinidae Main target pest: Lepidosaphes gloverii Metaphycus flavus Date of first use: 1979 Family: Encyrtidae EPPO countries where introduced: Spain [S] Main target pest: Coccus hesperidum Multiple/single introductions: Single Date of first use: 1959 Origin of collected material: East Asia EPPO countries where introduced: Italy [P], former USSR (Ukraine) [C] (Mediterranean distribution) Encarsia lahorensis Multiple/single introductions: Single Family: Aphelinidae Origin of collected material: Morocco Main target pest: Dialeurodes citri Date of first use: 1973- Metaphycus helvolus EPPO countries where introduced: Italy [S; Sardegna, P; Sicilia, C], Family: Encyrtidae former USSR (Georgia) [C*], France [E], Turkey, Greece [S, E], Main target pest: Saissetia oleae Israel [C*] Date of first use: 1960- Multiple/single introductions: Single, multiple EPPO countries where introduced: Israel [E], France (Corse) [P*], Origin of collected material: India, Pakistan Greece [C; Kriti, S], Italy [P], Spain [S], Cyprus [E], former USSR [F] Encarsia perniciosi Multiple/single introductions: Single Family: Aphelinidae Origin of collected material: South Africa Main target pest: Quadraspidiotus perniciosus Date of first use: 1932- Metaphycus lounsburyi EPPO countries where introduced: Italy [P], former USSR [E], Family: Encyrtidae Germany [P], France [P], Bulgaria [C], former Czechoslovakia [E, Main target pest: Saissetia oleae N], Switzerland [P], former Yugoslavia [N], Austria [E], Greece [E], Date of first use: 1973- Spain [P] (Widespread in the EPPO region) EPPO countries where introduced: France [P], Israel [C], Greece Multiple/single introductions: Single, multiple (Kriti) [P], Italy [E], Cyprus [S] (Mediterranean distribution) Origin of collected material: China, Korea Multiple/single introductions: Single Origin of collected material: South Africa Eretmocerus debachi Family: Aphelinidae Metaphycus swirskii Main target pest: Parabemisia myricae Family: Encyrtidae Date of first use: 1982- Main target pest: Saissetia oleae EPPO countries where introduced: Israel [C], Turkey [C], Italy [S] Date of first use: 1973 (Mediterranean distribution?) EPPO countries where introduced: Israel [E], France [E], Greece Multiple/single introductions: Single (Kriti) [P], Italy [P] Origin of collected material: Japan, North America Multiple/single introductions: Single Origin of collected material: Kenya Lysiphlebus testaceipes Family: Braconidae Neodryinus typhlocybae Target pest: Aphis citricola Family: Dryinidae Date of first use: 1973- Main target pest: Metcalfa pruinosa EPPO countries where introduced: former Czechoslovakia, France (Corse) Date of first use: 1989- [P], Morocco [N] (Mediterranean countries (and possibly others)) EPPO countries where introduced: Italy, France, Slovenia, Switzerland Multiple/single introductions: Single, multiple Multiple/single introductions: Single Origin of collected material: USA Origin of collected material: USA

Target pest: Toxoptera aurantii Neodusmetia sangwani Date of first use: 1973- Family: Encyrtidae EPPO countries where introduced: France [S, P], Spain [P], Italy [E], Main target pest: Antonina graminis Morocco [N] (Mediterranean countries (and possibly others)) Date of first use: 1971

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 447–461 List of widely used agents 461

EPPO countries where introduced: Israel [S] Main target pest: Ctenarytaina eucalypti Multiple/single introductions: Single Date of first use: 1994 Origin of collected material: South India EPPO countries where introduced: Ireland [S], France [S] Multiple/single introductions: Single Ooencyrtus kuvanae Origin of collected material: Australia Family: Encyrtidae Main target pest: Lymantria dispar Psyttalia concolor Date of first use: 1922 Synonym: Opius concolor EPPO countries where introduced: former Czechoslovakia [E], Spain Family: Braconidae [P], Morocco [E], Algeria [E], Portugal [E], former USSR Main target pest: Bactrocera oleae (Kazakhstan, Moldova, Russia, Ukraine, Uzbekistan) [P] Nature of control: Substantial, partial Multiple/single introductions: Single Date of first use: 1914- Origin of collected material: Japan EPPO countries where introduced: Italy [S], Greece [P], France [P], Spain [P], Portugal, former Yugoslavia [N] Pseudaphycus malinus Multiple/single introductions: Single Family: Encyrtidae Origin of collected material: Libya, Tunisia Main target pest: Pseudococcus comstocki Date of first use: 1945 Pteroptrix smithi EPPO countries where introduced: former USSR [C] Family: Aphelinidae Multiple/single introductions: Single Main target pest: Chrysomphalus aonidum Origin of collected material: Korea Date of first use: 1956 EPPO countries where introduced: Israel [C*] Psyllaephagus pilosus Multiple/single introductions: Single Family: Encyrtidae Origin of collected material: Hong Kong

© 2002 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 32, 447–461