Seventh Periodic Report of Ukraine on Implementation of the Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman Or Degrading Treatment Or Punishment
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SEVENTH PERIODIC REPORT OF UKRAINE ON IMPLEMENTATION OF THE CONVENTION AGAINST TORTURE AND OTHER CRUEL, INHUMAN OR DEGRADING TREATMENT OR PUNISHMENT • KHARKIV KHARKIV HUMAN RIGHTS PROTECTION GROUP 2019 This report was prepared with financial support of This document has been produced with the financial assistance of the European Union. The contents of this document are the sole responsibility of Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group and can under no circumstances be regarded as reflecting the position of the European Union Довідкове видання Сьома періодична доповідь України про виконання положень конвенції ООН проти катУвань та нелюдяного або такого, що принижУє гідніСть, поводження чи покарання (англійською мовою) Відповідальний за випуск Євген Захаров Редактор Євген Захаров Комп’ютерна верстка Олег Мірошниченко Підписано до друку 06.12.2019 1 Формат 60 × 84 /8. Папір офсетний. Гарнітура PT Serif Умов. друк. арк. 8,83. Облік.-вид. арк. 8,43 Наклад 25 прим. Зам. № КС-08/19 ГО «ХаРКіВСьКа ПРаВОЗаХиСНа ГРУПа» 61002, Харків, а/с 10430 http://khpg.org http://library.khpg.org http://archive.khpg.org/ Друк: ФОП Капуста С. і. 61168, м. Харків, вул. Героїв Праці, 12-Б, кв. 143 Seventh Periodic Report of Ukraine on Implementation of the Convention against Tor- ture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment / Y. Zakharov, G. To- karev: compilation; CO «Kharkiv Human Rights Protection group». — «Kharkiv: 2019. — 76 p. This report was prepared by Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group with the support of the United Nations Develop- ment Program (UNDP). The views, expressed in this publication, are those of the authors and may not coincide with the official position of the UNDP. © Y. Zakharov, G. Tokarev, compilation, 2019 © CO «Kharkiv Human Rights Protection group», 2019 SEVENTH PERIODIC REPORT OF UKRAINE ON IMPLEMENTATION OF THE CONVENTION AGAINST TORTURE AND OTHER CRUEL, INHUMAN OR DEGRADING TREATMENT OR PUNISHMENT Contents Page Abbreviations/Glossary.................................................................................................................... 4 Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 5 Questions 1–9 — Responses to UN issues “List of issues before the reporting” ............................. 6 Questions 10, 11 — Crimes of torture ............................................................................................ 21 Questions 12, 13 — Responsibility of state officials for torture and other crimes ........................ 21 Questions 14 — Investigations of crimes of militants from volunteer battalions ......................... 22 Question 15 — Video recording of interrogations ......................................................................... 23 Question 19 — Independence of judges ......................................................................................... 24 Question 20, 24 — Protection of rights of asylum seekers and IDPs ........................................26, 31 Question 23 — Juvenile justice ...................................................................................................... 30 Question 27 — Prisoners’ rights .................................................................................................... 34 Question 28 — Visits of Ombudsman in the framework of the NPM ............................................ 37 Question 29 — Mobile groups’ activities on monitoring of institutions ....................................... 38 Questions 30, 31 — Monitoring of institutions by international bodies and NGOs ...................... 40 Question 32 — Access to places of detention and administrative premises of the Security Service ................................................................................................................... 43 Question 33 — Penitentiary medicine ........................................................................................... 44 Question 34 — Effectiveness of investigation of complaints on torture. Statistics of the State Investigation Bureau .................................................................................. 53 Question 35 — Disciplinary responsibility for ineffective investigations ..................................... 54 Question 36 — The results of criminal investigations into torture .............................................. 54 Question 40 — Means of restraint for persons with mental disorders .......................................... 65 ABBREVIATIONS/GLOssARY AFU Armed Forces of Ukraine ART Antiretroviral therapy ATO Anti-Terrorist Operation CAP Code of Administrative Procedure of Ukraine CC Criminal Code of Ukraine CGS Court Guard Service of Ukraine CEC Criminal Executive Code of Ukraine CP Criminal proceeding CPC Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman CPT or Degrading Treatment or Punishment Crimea Autonomous Republic of Crimea and Sevastopol Donbas Donetsk and Luhansk regions ECtHR European Court of Human Rights FLA Free legal aid IDP Internally Displaced Person JFO Joint Forces Operation KHPG Civil organization “Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group” MoD Ministry of Defence of Ukraine MoIA Ministry of Internal Affairs of Ukraine MoJ Ministry of Justice of Ukraine MoH Ministry of Healthcare of Ukraine OHCHR Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights PG Prosecutor-General of Ukraine PI Penitentiary Institution PC Penal Colony PTDC Pre-Trial Detention Centre RONP Regional Office of National Police SBGS State Border Guard Service of Ukraine SBI State Investigation Bureau of Ukraine SCES State Criminal Enforcement Service of Ukraine SIHC State Institution “SCES Health Centre” SMS State Migration Service of Ukraine SСU Supreme Court of Ukraine SСJ Supreme Council of Justice United Nations Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture and other Cruel, SPT Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment SSU Security Service of Ukraine THC Temporary Holding Centre for Foreign Nationals and Stateless Persons of the SMS THF Temporary Holding Facility TOT Temporarily Occupied Territory INTRODUCTION In the second half of July 2020, the UN Committee against Torture (hereinafter — the Committee) should consider the Seventh Periodic Report of Ukraine on implementation of the provisions of the UN Convention against Torture and Cruel Treatment. We recall that the previous Sixth Periodic Report of Ukraine was con- sidered by the Committee in November 2014 and the periodic reports are provided once in four years. In early 2017, the Committee provided a list of 42 issues completely covering the problems of torture and ill-treatment to the Government of Ukraine. In November 2018 the Government had prepared a draft of the Seventh Periodic Report. The draft is posted on the website of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine for discussion and it is available at https://minjust.gov.ua/news/announcement/gromadski-obgovorennya- proektu-periodichnoi-dopovidi-ukraini-pro-vikonannya-polojen-konventsii-oon-proti-katuvan?fbclid=Iw AR18NrKG6QsgGcRe_ti02XGCs26mkeWIQwPhwv4rtbLnnfHr0j7TwYjM5Pw. This draft was prepared ahead of many important amendments in legislation and practice which took place in 2015 — 2018. However, the Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group (KHPG) has prepared the Shadow Report to the draft report of the Government and offers it to the reader. We hope that it will be use- ful for the governmental experts. The KHPG continues the tradition of commenting the periodic reports of the Government on implementation of the UN Convention against Torture. In 1997, 2001, 2007 and 2014 the KHPG prepared and published its Shadow Reports to the Third, Fourth, Fifth and Sixth Reports respec- tively. The Shadow Report of the KHPG represents the answers to almost all 42 issues of the UN Committee against Torture. It covers a variety of issues of the respect of the Convention during November 2014 — Au- gust 2019 and it was prepared on the basis of its own information and the information got from the partner organizations and state authorities. The Shadow Report of the KHPG is submitted to the UN Committee against Torture and it aims at comprehensive coverage of the issues of respect of the rights enshrined in the Convention and attraction of the attention of the Committee`s experts to the most actual problems in the sphere of their implementation which in our opinion are not reflected or which are incompletely covered in the draft report of the Government of Ukraine. We admit that during the past five years there have been positive changes and trends in Ukraine. However, we set a goal to present our position regarding the situation with torture and other forms of ill- treatment in the most problematic areas of human rights protection in our country in order to assist the Committee`s experts to get the fullest possible understanding of the problems in this area. In particular, our concern is the problems of impunity in the cases of torture, conflict of the prosecution functions which makes it difficult to effectively investigate the cases of torture, routine practice of violation of the rights to liberty and other rights of detainees, practice of mass violence in penal institutions, and the lack of ad- equate medical care for the persons deprived of liberty. When preparing the Shadow Report, we used the materials of monitoring of the situation of torture carried out in 2014 — 2019 in all regions of Ukraine by the Coalition of human rights