Highly Elliptical Orbit for Studies of the Carbon Cycle in the Arctic and Boreal Regions
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Observing CO2 from a highly elliptical orbit for studies of the carbon cycle in the Arctic and boreal regions Ray Nassar1, Chris Sioris2, Dylan B.A. Jones3, Kaley A. Walker3, Chris McLinden4, C. Tom McElroy5 1 Environment Canada - Climate Research Division, [email protected] 2 University of Saskatchewan 3 University of Toronto 4 Environment Canada - Air Quality Research Division 5 York University Arctic Products Validation and Evolution (APVE) workshop, 2014-11-13 Boreal and Arctic Carbon Boreal Forests • Longer growing season and increase in disturbances may enhance or reduce their net carbon flux Tarnocai et al. (2009) Permafrost • 1672 PgC, twice atm mass (835 PgC) with potential for release as CO2, CH4 • ~85 PgC by 2100 (0.8-1.1 PgC/yr) from extrapolation of measurements at an Alaskan site (Schurr et al. 2009) • Models: 104±37 PgC (Schaefer et al. 2011) and 9 - 114 PgC (Schneider von Deimling et al. 2012) by 2100 McDonald et al. (2004) How can satellites play a role? Satellite Orbits and Coverage • Low Earth Orbit (LEO) • Geostationary Orbit (GEO) • Near-polar plane • Near-equatorial plane ~35,800 km altitude • Below ~1000 km altitude • Synchronized with Earth rotation, continuous • If sun-synchronous, global coverage over selected area (< 60°N/S) sampling at fixed overpass • Communications, Weather, Trop Chemistry time (TEMPO, GEO-CAPE, Sentinel-4, GEMS) • GOSAT, OCO-2, TanSat … • Some proposed CO2 and CH4 missions GOSAT (NIES v2.00 2009-08 averaged at 0.9° x 0.9°) Satellite Orbits and Coverage • Low Earth Orbit (LEO) • Geostationary Orbit (GEO) • Near-polar plane • Near-equatorial plane ~35,800 km altitude • Below ~1000 km altitude • Synchronized with Earth rotation, continuous • If sun-synchronous, global coverage over selected area (< 60°N/S) sampling at fixed overpass • Communications, Weather, Trop Chemistry time (TEMPO, GEO-CAPE, Sentinel-4, GEMS) • GOSAT, OCO-2, TanSat … • Some proposed CO2 and CH4 missions Example of Geostationary Fields of Regard Highly Elliptical Orbit (HEO) • WMO Vision for the Global Observing System (GOS) in 2025 • Conservation of angular momentum requires faster motion when close to Earth (perigee), slower motion when far from Earth (apogee) Apogee • Tundra Orbit (2 apogees): T = 24 hr, Ha = 48,300 km • Three Apogee (TAP) Orbit: T= 16 hr, Ha = 43,500 km • Molniya Orbit (4 apogees): T = 12 hr, Ha = 39,800 km T = period, Ha = apogee altitude (higher than GEO 35,800 km) Perigee HEO options summarized in Garand, Trishchenko, Trichtchenko and Nassar (2014), Physics in Canada, 70, (4), in press. Polar Communications and Weather (PCW) • Canadian mission with 2 satellites in Highly Elliptical Orbit (HEO) configuration, under consideration for launch ~ 2020 • Main objectives are to expand Arctic communications capabilities and provide meteorological observations • Canadian Space Agency (CSA) is separately considering additional science instruments under the Polar Highly Elliptical Orbit Science (PHEOS) program • The Weather, Climate and Air quality (WCA) mission concept is an atmospheric research option that completed Phase A in 2012 (PHEOS-WCA PI was Jack McConnell of York U) PCW-PHEOS-WCA Spectral Bands / Species • Fourier Transform Spectrometer (FTS) • UV-Visible Spectrometer (UVS) Band (µm) Band (cm-1) Resolution Target species -1 1 14.2 - 6.7 700 - 1500 0.25 cm T, H 2O, O3, CO, CO2, 2 5.6 - 3.7 1800 - 2700 0.25 cm-1 CH4, HNO3, CH3OH, HCOOH, PAN, HCN, NH3, SO2… FTS -1 3a 1.67 - 1.66 5990 - 6010 0.25 cm CH4 columns -1 3b 1.67 - 1.60 5990 - 6257 0.25 cm CO2 / CH4 columns -1 4 0.766-0.760 13060-13168 0.50 cm O2 A band (psurf, aerosol) UVS 0.280-0.650 ~ 1 nm O3, NO2, aerosol, BrO, HCHO, SO2, … Mass/Volume Compliant Instrument has red bands, but not blue PCW-PHEOS-WCA Instrument Configurations • Fourier Transform Spectrometer (FTS) • UV-Visible Spectrometer (UVS) Optimal Configuration “Lite” CSA All Bands Configuration Allocations Compliant Configuration Size: 30 x 30 x 30 cm3 (27 000 cm3) Mass: 50 kg FTS (aperture 15 cm) Power: 100 W with UVS, 85 kg ~103 800* cm3 FTS (aperture 10 cm) with UVS, 45 kg FTS (aperture 10 cm) ~35 128* cm3 No O2 A band or SWIR CO2 O2 A band and SWIR CO2 No UVS, 37 kg ~25 184* cm3 *configuration volumes given with 20% contingency Observing System Simulation Experiment (OSSE) • Objective: Compare the potential information from HEO vs. LEO for constraining boreal and Arctic CO2 surface fluxes by data assimilation of atmospheric CO2 observations • Approach: – Designate a CO2 model simulation as the ‘Truth’ – Create synthetic observations for LEO and HEO by sampling the model at hypothetical observation locations/times then adding noise – Assimilate each set of synthetic observations to optimize biospheric CO2 fluxes and assess posterior fluxes and uncertainties relative to the ‘Truth’ Nassar, Sioris, Jones, McConnell (2014), Satellite observations of CO2 from a highly elliptical orbit for studies of the Arctic and boreal carbon cycle, J. Geophys. Res. 119, 2654–2673, doi:10.1002/2013JD020337 AGU Research Spotlight: EOS 95, no. 29, 2014-July-22 Generating Synthetic Observations GOSAT: Simulated orbit using SPENVIS (ESA), 3 cross track obs: orbit track, ±263 km, glint subsolar±20° PCW-PHEOS-WCA: Three Apogee Orbit 2 satellites, 8h apart in co-planar 16h orbit Apogee ~43,500 km, Perigee ~8100 km 3 Apogees/day (8:00 and 16:00 local time) observing ±4 h from apogee giving up to 16 h of data per 48 h per region Region/apogee: 48 scans consisting of 56x56 array of 10x10 km2 pixels in 80 min. Checkerboard pattern in FOV to thin data and meet downlink requirement. Observations every other repeat cycle to accommodate other observing priorities. Solar Zenith Angle, Albedo, Cloud Only retain when Solar Zenith Angle (SZA) < 85° Spectral Albedo Values from MODTRAN AVHRR* 1°x1° surface types *Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer GEOS-5 Cloud Fraction 0.5x0.67 0 1 Signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) depends on surface albedo. Nadir XCO2 retrievals over ocean, sea-ice and old snow are assumed unlikely. Used GOSAT v2.0 averaging kernels for each surface type. Comparison of observations per 1°x1° No observations over snow Obs over seasonal snow included* Number of observations per month Post-filtered GOSAT mean simulated obs per month: 13031(no snow) and 14973 (snow) st 14393 (NIES v2, 1 year of mission) *Precision of obs over snow degraded by a factor of 2 Summary of Key Findings flux TgC/month 2 CO Mean HEO/LEO uncertainty for 14 Arctic and boreal regions Configuration Obs over Snow Jun – Jul – Aug Annual Yes 0.54 0.69 Optimal No 0.55 0.72 Yes 0.72 0.83 Lite No 0.74 0.79 • PHEOS-FTS offers significant flux uncertainty reductions relative to GOSAT with the largest gain in the summer • Largest interannual variability, uncertainty and potential for change to Arctic/boreal carbon cycle (forest disturbances and permafrost thaw) is in the summer, when PHEOS-FTS offers the greatest potential constraints CO2 and CH4 Validation • Validation of column-average CO and CH mole fractions 2 4 ● (XCO , XCH ) requires ● 2 4 ● column measurements by ● ●● ground-based remote sensing ●● ● ●● • The Total Carbon Column Observing Network (TCCON) ● ● is the only widely accepted method • TCCON instrumentation and ● ● retrievals are standardized ● ● ● and data are calibrated to the WMO scale by in situ profile measurements from aircraft TCCON stations in the NH (white dots) overflights Cross Validation for GEO Missions LEO, GEO and HEO missions could be used to validate each other, but sun-synchronous LEO only give one point in the diurnal cycle. HEO can be compared with GEO FORs that do not overlap. PHEOS-FTS Balloon Demonstrator • Test PHEOS-FTS design readiness for CO / CH 2 4 * NEXT TALK * imaging, pointing stability/control over 100 s scan from a high altitude balloon launched from CNES-CSA balloon facility in Timmins, Canada (48.6°N, 81.4°W) Credit: CSA .