2019 Tribunals and Appeals Last Updated 19/09/2019 10:05 AM To access the Hearing Notice and Determinations Record please click the case number.
Case Club Charges Club Associate Finding Suspension Loss of Points Other
Fraser Chalmers (FFA TA19001 Moreland Zebras FC Red Card Appeal Not Guilty Auto + 2 ID: 10285156)
Brodie Paterson (FFA Letter of Apology Casey Comets FC Red Card Determination Guilty 2 Years ID: 10629882) Respect & Responsibility Course TA19002 Josh Valadon Mornington SC Red Card Appeal Guilty Auto + 2 Downgraded to R5_1 (FFA ID: 51125268)
Besnik Kutleshi TA19003 North Sunshine Eagles SC Red Card Appeal Guilty Auto + 12 (FFA ID: 71340053)
Good Behaviour Avondale FC Club Misconduct Ben Garang Guilty $200 suspended bond
TA19004 Guilty $750 Melbourne Knights FC Club Misconduct
Rob Colina Guilty 2 Matches $500
Jahrad Bhowan Club & Player to Attend Laws of TA19005 Pascoe Vale FC Club Misconduct Not Guilty (FFA ID: 10377182) the Game Course.
Appeal against Federation Already served 2 Match TA19006 Melbourne Knights FC Mark Colina Guilty 2 Matches imposed penalty Suspension.
James Smith TA19007 Bunyip District SC Red Card Referral Guilty Auto + 16 (FFA ID: 79906848)
Nicholas Spiteri (FFA TA19008 Sunbury United SC Red Card Appeal Guilty Auto + 2 ID: 74075730)
Joel Campbell Gisborne SC Red Card Determination Guilty 16 Matches (FFA ID: 82977286)
Michael Armocida Red Card Determination Guilty 16 Matches (FFA ID: 10597443) TA19009 John Kouts Marcellin Old Collegians SC Red Card Determination Guilty 16 Matches (FFA ID: 10659283)
Tom Boeck Red Card Determination Not Guilty Auto + 2 Downgraded to MP4A. (FFA ID: 10009877)
TA19010 Breakwater Eagles SC Club Misconduct Cory Hall Not Guilty
Mornington SC Club Misconduct Not Guilty
TA19011 Clarinda United to pay $1,000 Clarinda United Club Misconduct Tony Kiymaz Guilty 8 Matches fine. Tony Kiymaz to attend anger management course.
Not Guilty Team to undertake relevant education course (e.g. rules of Club Misconduct the game. Hume United FC to Not Guilty post the FV Inclusion Charter to all members. TA19012 Hume United FC
Not Guilty Mustafa Uzunomer Club Misconduct (FFA ID: 73693251) Not Guilty
$3,000 fine - less deduction for Guilty 3 points guily plea Club Misconduct $2,000 fine - less deduction for Guilty 3 points TA19013 Westgate FC guilty plea
Miljan Tolj Club Misconduct Guilty Life ban (FFA. ID: 10631074)
Club Misconduct Removal of penalty of 3 Match MP5D Points for MP5C. All other penalties remain TA19013 AB Westgate FC undisturbed. Club Misconduct Fines remain in place. 3 Match MP5C Point loss only.
If you would like access to past determinations or require more information concerning disciplinary processes please contact [email protected]. 1 of 6 2019 Tribunals and Appeals Last Updated 19/09/2019 10:05 AM To access the Hearing Notice and Determinations Record please click the case number.
Case Club Charges Club Associate Finding Suspension Loss of Points Other
5 penalty units (suspended until Club Misconduct Guilty end of 2019 season).
6 point deduction (suspended Club Misconduct Guilty until end of 2019 season). Essendon Royals SC Thomas Prebble Red Card Determination Guilty Auto + 12 (FFA. ID: 10385766) TA19014 Yohannes Tilahun Red Card Determination Guilty Auto + 2 Downgraded to R5_1 (FFA ID: 10622204)
5 penalty units (suspended until Club Misconduct Guilty end of 2019 season) Preston Lions FC Marcus Trentino (FFA Red Card Determination Guilty Auto + 2 Downgraded to R5_1 ID: 63331177)
Altona Magic SC Club Misconduct Not Guilty
Dandenong Thunder SC Club Misconduct Not Guilty
$10,000 fine suspended until 31 Club Misconduct Guilty December 2020 TA19015 Besnik Kutleshi Banned until Tribunal Determination - Club Misconduct Guilty (FFA ID: 71340053) August 2022 05/09/2019 North Sunshine Eagles SC Arsim Kutleshi Club Misconduct Guilty 2 Year Ban (FFA ID: 85091098) Tribunal Determination - 15/07/2019 George Briskovic Club Misconduct Guilty 2 Year Ban (FFA ID: 74202961)
Guilty $1,500 fine
Guilty 3 points $1,500 fine
Guilty $500 fine Melbourne Knights FC Club Misconduct Guilty $1,000 fine TA19016
Downgraded to MP4A - $500 Not Guilty fine
Anthony Burin Guilty 4 weeks (FFA ID: 10139520)
Downgraded to MP4A - $500 South Melbourne FC Club Misconduct Not Guilty fine
Appeal TA19016 AB Melbourne Knights FC Club Misconduct Dismissed
Red Card Determination Jason Minglis Downgraded to R5_3 TA19017 Old Ivanhoe SC Not Guilty Auto + 6 R5_4 (Auto + 12) (FFA ID: 10043616) (Auto + 6)
Club Misconduct Guilty 3 points
Club Misconduct Guilty 3 points $1000 fine
Loukman Khor (FFA Red Card Determination Not Guilty TA19018 Greenvale United SC ID: 82556697)
Auto +8 (3 Hamza Soueid (FFA Red Card Determination Guilty games ID: 10411802) suspended)
Auto + 4 (2 Abdul-Khader Ayad Red Card Determination Guilty games (FFA ID: 10571369) suspended)
Club Misconduct Zlatko Holovka Guilty 18 month ban
TA19019 St Albans Saints SC Club Misconduct Damir Njegac Guilty 2 year ban
Club Misconduct Mate Vlahovic Guilty 2 year ban
Armend 1 year ban + 13 TA19020 North Sunshine Eagles SC Red Card Determination Barjaktarevic Guilty matches (FFA ID: 10547602)
If you would like access to past determinations or require more information concerning disciplinary processes please contact [email protected]. 2 of 6 2019 Tribunals and Appeals Last Updated 19/09/2019 10:05 AM To access the Hearing Notice and Determinations Record please click the case number.
Case Club Charges Club Associate Finding Suspension Loss of Points Other
Suspended from playing until Salih Mahat TA19021 Richmond FC Red Card Determination Guilty 2 year ban Round 1 of 2022 Regular FV (FFA ID: 10619113) Season
Club Misconduct Not Guilty
TA19022 Whitehorse United FC Rien MacDonald Club Misconduct Not Guilty (FFA ID: 10042910)
Andrew Paraskevas TA19023 FC Clifton Hill Red Card Appeal Guilty Auto + 8 (FFA ID: 10278374)
Izaak Papadimitriou TA19024 Brunswick Zebras FC Red Card Appeal Guilty Auto + 4 (FFA ID: 10654429)
Appeal against Federation TA19025 Bundoora United FC Dean Stafrace Not Guilty Auto $500 fine imposed penalty
Appeal against Federation TA19026 Dandenong City SC N/A Dismiss appeal imposed penalty
Raj Umit Club Misconduct Guilty 5 year ban (FFA. 10576356) TA19028 Casey Panthers SC
Ban relates to relevant club Club Misconduct Guilty 4 Matches associate
Appeal against Federation TA19029 Williamstown SC Guilty $1,000 fine imposed penalty
Jovan Milenkovic TA19030 Springvale White Eagles FC Red Card Appeal Not Guilty Auto (FFA ID: 10298194)
Club Misconduct Not Guilty MP10
Club Misconduct Springvale City SC Guilty 3 Points 5 Penalty Units MP5C
Club Misconduct Not Guilty MP8B
Club Misconduct 10 Penalty Units suspended until Guilty 6 Points MP10 2020.
Club Misconduct TA19031 Guilty MP5C Charges covered under MP10 Club Misconduct Guilty MP8B Sandown Lions FC Red Card Determination Duol Keyi Guilty 8 Matches MP10 (FFA. 10673790)
Club Misconduct Nhial Mabor Not Guilty MP4E
Club Misconduct Youngmag Kam Not dealt with as it is a police MP4E (FFA. 10577428) matter.
If you would like access to past determinations or require more information concerning disciplinary processes please contact [email protected]. 3 of 6 2019 Tribunals and Appeals Last Updated 19/09/2019 10:05 AM To access the Hearing Notice and Determinations Record please click the case number.
Case Club Charges Club Associate Finding Suspension Loss of Points Other
25 Penalty Units Club Misconduct Guilty 6 Points Respect & Responsibility Course Bundoora United FC George Club Misconduct Papamathealus Not Guilty (FFA. 10660832)
30 Penalty Units Club Misconduct Guilty 6 Points Respect & Responsibility Course
13 Matches Areeb Furrukh (FFA. TA19032 Club Misconduct Guilty (from date of 82111717) Tribunal)
Andrew Matti (FFA. 6 Matches (from Craigieburn City FC Club Misconduct Guilty 10603199) date of Tribunal)
13 Matches Hamza Shaikh Club Misconduct Guilty (from date of (FFA.10604128) Tribunal)
13 Matches Fady Aboo (FFA. Club Misconduct Guilty (from date of 77362283) Tribunal)
Ali Assaad TA19033 Greenvale United SC Red Card Determination Guilty 1 Year (FFA ID 75656413)
Club Misconduct Guilty 3 Points MP5C St Kilda Casuals Club Misconduct Kevin Murray TA19034 Guilty 13 Matches MP4D (FFA: 10603987)
Mohammad Aref Club Misconduct Riversdale SC Sheef Not Guilty MP4A (FFA: 10641399) Club Misconduct Guilty 9 Points Respect & Responsibility Course MP4E
Club Misconduct Ayman Hassoun Guilty 18 Matches Respect & Responsibility Course MP4E (FFA:10706779) Moreland Eagles FC Club Misconduct Mohamed Aziz (FFA: Guilty 18 Matches Respect & Responsibility Course MP4E 10647241) TA19035 Club Misconduct Ali Salarinia Guilty 20 Matches Respect & Responsibility Course MP4E (FFA: 10647249) Club Misconduct Guilty 6 Points Respect & Responsibility Course MP4E Meadow Park SC Club Misconduct Ahmed Abdallah Guilty 13 Matches Respect & Responsibility Course MP4E (FFA: 75923375)
Red Card Appeal Stephen Hatzikostas TA19036 Pascoe Vale FC Not Guilty Auto + 2 Downgraded to R5_1 R5_3 (FFA ID: 10276234) Mohammad Naeem TA19037 Pascoe Vale FC Red Card Appeal Rahimi (FFA ID: Not Guilty Auto Downgraded to Auto 10277169) Club Misconduct 15 Penalty Units & 3 Points Preston Lions FC Guilty MP5D Suspended until end of 2019.
Club Misconduct 15 Penalty Units & 3 Points TA19038 Guilty MP5D Suspended until end of 2019. North Sunshine Eagles SC Club Misconduct 4 Match Suspension to relevant Guilty MP5C individual
Club Misconduct Guilty 1 Penalty Unit MP5C Essendon Royals SC Club Misconduct Michael Harper Guilty 14 matches MP4E TA19040 Club Misconduct Not Guilty MP5C
Caroline Springs George Cross FC Suspended until end of 2020 Club Misconduct Zoran Kostur Guilty season. MP4E Respect & Responsibility Course
Club Misconduct Brimbank Stallions FC Pat Rottura Guilty 8 Matches MP4D TA19041 Club Misconduct Steve Castvan (FFA Caroline Springs George Cross FC Guilty 3 Matches Downgraded to MP4A MP4D ID: 5805527)
If you would like access to past determinations or require more information concerning disciplinary processes please contact [email protected]. 4 of 6 2019 Tribunals and Appeals Last Updated 19/09/2019 10:05 AM To access the Hearing Notice and Determinations Record please click the case number.
Case Club Charges Club Associate Finding Suspension Loss of Points Other
Club Misconduct 8 Penalty Units MP4D
Club Misconduct 2 Penalty Units MP5C FC Birrarung Slayman Suleman Club Misconduct Dib 10 Matches MP4D (FFA ID: 10487717) Club Misconduct Aydin Dib TA19042 10 Matches MP4D (FFA ID: 71609481)
Club Misconduct 3 Points 10 Penalty Units MP4D
Club Misconduct Newmarket Pheonix FC 2 Penalty Units MP5C
Club Misconduct Hudeyfa Abshirr (FFA 13 Matches MP4D ID: 82187014)
Club Misconduct Guilty 3 Points 15 Penalty Units MP4D
Club Misconduct Ihsan Ozdamar (FFA Broadmeadows Stars SC Guilty 16 Matches MP4D ID: 56072473) TA19043 Club Misconduct Ihsan Ozdamar (FFA Guilty 8 Matches MP9B ID: 56072473)
Club Misconduct Craigieburn City FC Guilty 6 Points 15 Penalty Units MP4D
Club Misconduct Guilty 6 Points 5 Penalty Units MP4E
Club Misconduct Adam Saeed Guilty 13 Matches MP4E (FFA ID: 10691830)
Club Misconduct Munthatar Al Sharifi Craigieburn City FC Guilty 13 Matches MP4D (FFA ID: 10693240)
TA19044 Club Misconduct Abdul Hammoud Guilty 13 Matches MP4D (FFA ID: 10691839)
Club Misconduct Khaled Halabi Guilty 13 Matches MP4D (FFA ID: 10691827) Club Misconduct Guilty 6 Points 5 Penalty Units MP4E North Melbourne AFC Club Misconduct Chris Skehan Guilty 5 Matches Downgraded to MP4B MP4D (FFA ID: 10631939)
Player Misconduct Zarko Tomovski (FFA TA19045 Plenty Valley Lions FC Guilty 17 Matches MP7E ID: 10363318)
Club Misconduct Not Guilty MP4D
Club Misconduct Craigieburn City FC Guilty 3 Points MP5C
Player Misconduct Hisham Nehfaoui TA19046 Guilty 7 Matches Downgraded to MP4C MP4D (FFA ID: 10406645)
Club Misconduct Not Guilty MP4D FC Strathmore Club Misconduct Not Guilty MP5C
Henry Silva TA19047 Murray United FC Red Card Determination Guilty Auto + 16 (FFA ID: 10276057)
Evan Dolios Not Guilty of R8_6. TA19048 Whittlesea Ranges FC Red Card Determination Not Guilty Auto + 4 (FFA ID: 10397732) Guilty of R8_2
Frank Azzato Match Official MP10 Not Guilty (FFA ID: 56073786) TA19049 Sam Montesano Match Official MP10 Not Guilty (FFA ID: 56076193)
Appeal against Federation Not Guilty of MP4D TA19050 Port Melbourne SC imposed penalty Not Guilty Guilty of MP4A - 4 Penalty Units MP4D
Edin Ali TA19051 FC Noble Hurricanes Red Card Determination Guilty Auto + 16 (FFA ID: 10042346)
Player Misconduct Yehya Dimassi Not Guilty of MP4E TA19052 Springvale City SC Not Guilty 10 Matches MP4E (FFA. 10696434) Guilty of MP4D
Player Misconduct Haider Al TA19053 Hampton Park United Sparrows FC Guilty 10 Year Ban MP7H (FFA. 10564933)
Appeal against Federation John Gomez TA19055 Laverton Park SC imposed penalty Guilty 5 Matches (FFA: 63065114) MP7B
Club Misconduct Medin Jecka TA19058 North Sunshine Eagles SC Guilty Banned for the 2020 Season MP7E (FFA: 10030647)
If you would like access to past determinations or require more information concerning disciplinary processes please contact [email protected]. 5 of 6 2019 Tribunals and Appeals Last Updated 19/09/2019 10:05 AM To access the Hearing Notice and Determinations Record please click the case number.
Case Club Charges Club Associate Finding Suspension Loss of Points Other
Nami Yilmaz $500 fine Kingsbury United SC MP4A Guilty (FFA ID: 82570367) Anger Management Course
MP5C Guilty 3 Points $500 fine TA19060 Newmarket Pheonix FC MP4E Mohamed “Mazey” Guilty Life Ban
$1,000 fine MP4B Abdi Ali Guilty Anger Management Course
Appeal against Federation TA19062 Northern Falcons FC imposed penalty Kaan Kalayci Guilty 7 Matches MP7C
If you would like access to past determinations or require more information concerning disciplinary processes please contact [email protected]. 6 of 6