Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 1 of 100
No. 18-90020 UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT ______
IN RE: BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD ANTITRUST LITIGATION (MDL 2406) ______BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD ASSOCIATION; ANTHEM INC., F/K/A WELLPOINT, INC.; BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD OF ALABAMA; HEALTH CARE SERVICE CORPORATION; CALIFORNIA PHYSICIANS’ SERVICE, D/B/A BLUE SHIELD OF CALIFORNIA; PREMERA BLUE CROSS, D/B/A PREMERA BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD OF ALASKA; et al., Petitioners, v. JOSEPH D. ACKERSON, (PHD); SAKET K. AMBASHT, M.D.; CHARLES BARNWELL, D.C.; BREAKTHROUGH PHYSICAL THERAPY, INC.; BULLOCK COUNTY HOSPITAL; et al. Respondents. ______On Petition from the United States District Court for the Northern District of Alabama, Southern Division, No. 2:13-CV-20000-RDP ______MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE REPLY IN SUPPORT OF PETITION FOR PERMISSION TO APPEAL UNDER 28 U.S.C. §1292(b) ______Paul D. Clement Erin E. Murphy C. Harker Rhodes IV KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP 655 Fifteenth Street, NW Washington, DC 20005 (202) 879-5000 [email protected] Counsel for Petitioner Blue Cross Blue Shield Association (Additional Petitioners and Counsel Listed on Inside Cover) July 9, 2018
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 2 of 100
Craig A. Hoover David J. Zott, P.C. E. Desmond Hogan Daniel E. Laytin, P.C. Catherine E. Stetson Sarah J. Donnell Justin W. Bernick Christa C. Cottrell, P.C. HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP Zachary Holmstead Columbia Square KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP 555 13th Street, N.W. 300 North LaSalle Washington, DC 20004 Chicago, IL 60654 Tel: (202) 637-5600 Tel: (312) 862-2000 Fax: (202) 637-5910 Fax: (312) 862-2200 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Emily M. Yinger N. Thomas Connally, III Co-Coordinating Counsel for the HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP Petitioners Park Place II 7930 Jones Branch Drive, 9th Floor Kimberly R. West (Liaison Counsel) McLean, VA 22102 Mark M. Hogewood Tel: (703) 610-6100 WALLACE, JORDAN, RATLIFF & Fax: (703) 610-6200 BRANDT, LLC [email protected] First Commercial Bank Building [email protected] 800 Shades Creek Parkway, Suite 400 Birmingham, AL 35209 Co-Coordinating Counsel for the Tel: (205) 870-0555 Petitioners Fax: (205) 871-7534 [email protected] Cavender C. Kimble [email protected] Ed R. Haden BALCH & BINGHAM LLP Petitioners’ Liaison Counsel 1901 6th Avenue North, Suite 1500 Birmingham, AL 35203-4642 With Kirkland & Ellis LLP, counsel for Tel: (205) 226-3437 Petitioner Blue Cross Blue Shield Fax: (205) 488-5860 Association [email protected]
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 3 of 100
John Martin James L. Priester Lucile H. Cohen Carl S. Burkhalter NELSON MULLINS RILEY & John Thomas A. Malatesta, III SCARBOROUGH LLP MAYNARD COOPER & GALE PC 1320 Main Street, 17th Floor 1901 6th Avenue North, Suite 2400 Columbia, SC 29201 Regions Harbert Plaza Tel: (803) 255-9421 Birmingham, AL 35203 Fax: (803) 256-7500 Tel: (205) 254-1000 [email protected] Fax: (205) 254-1999 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] With Hogan Lovells, counsel for [email protected] Petitioners Anthem, Inc., f/k/a WellPoint, Inc., and all of its named Pamela B. Slate subsidiaries in this consolidated action; HILL HILL CARTER FRANCO COLE Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North & BLACK, P.C. Carolina, Inc.; Blue Cross and Blue 425 South Perry Street Shield of Florida, Inc.; Louisiana Montgomery, AL 36104 Health Service & Indemnity Company Tel: (334) 834-7600 (Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Fax: (334) 386-4381 Louisiana); Blue Cross and Blue Shield [email protected] of Massachusetts, Inc.; BCBSM, Inc. (Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Counsel for Petitioner Minnesota); Blue Cross and Blue Shield Blue Cross Blue Shield of Alabama of South Carolina; Horizon Healthcare Services, Inc. (Horizon Blue Cross and Helen E. Witt, P.C. Blue Shield of New Jersey); Blue Cross Jeffrey J. Zeiger, P.C. & Blue Shield of Rhode Island; Blue Erica B. Zolner Cross and Blue Shield of Vermont; Casey R. Fronk Cambia Health Solutions, Inc.; Regence KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP Blue Shield of Idaho; Regence Blue 300 North LaSalle Cross Blue Shield of Utah; Regence Chicago, IL 60654 Blue Shield (of Washington); Regence Tel: (312) 862-2000 Blue Cross Blue Shield of Oregon Fax: (312) 862-2200 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 4 of 100
Gwendolyn Payton Kimberly R. West (Liaison Counsel) KILPATRICK TOWNSEND & Mark M. Hogewood STOCKTON LLP WALLACE, JORDAN, RATLIFF & 1420 Fifth Avenue, Suite 37 BRANDT, LLC Seattle, WA 98101 First Commercial Bank Building Tel: (206) 626-7714 800 Shades Creek Parkway, Suite 400 Fax: (206) 299-0414 Birmingham, AL 35209 [email protected] Tel: (205) 870-0555 Fax: (205) 871-7534 Adam Charnes [email protected] KILPATRICK TOWNSEND & [email protected] STOCKTON LLP 2001 Ross Avenue, Suite 4400 Counsel for Petitioners Health Care Dallas, TX 75201 Service Corporation, an Illinois Mutual Tel: 214 922 7106 Legal Reserve Company, including its Fax: 214 481 0517 divisions Blue Cross and Blue Shield of [email protected] Illinois, Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas, Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Counsel for Petitioners Premera Blue New Mexico, Blue Cross and Blue Cross d/b/a Premera Blue Cross Blue Shield of Oklahoma, and Blue Cross Shield of Alaska; Premera Blue Cross of and Blue Shield of Montana; Caring for Washington Montanans, Inc., f/k/a Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Montana, Inc.; Highmark Inc., f/k/a Highmark Health Services; Brian K. Norman Highmark West Virginia Inc.; Highmark SHAMOUN & NORMAN, LLP Blue Cross Blue Shield Delaware Inc.; 1800 Valley View Lane, Suite 200 California Physicians’ Service d/b/a Farmers Branch, TX 75234 Blue Shield of California Tel: (214) 987-1745 Fax: (214) 521-9033 [email protected]
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 5 of 100
H. James Koch Jonathan M. Redgrave ARMBRECHT JACKSON LLP Victoria A. Redgrave RSA Tower, 27th Floor REDGRAVE, LLP 11 North Water Street 14555 Avion Parkway, Suite 275 Mobile, AL 36602 Chantilly, VA 20151 Tel: (251) 405-1300 Tel: (703) 592-1155 Fax: (251) 432-6843 Fax: (612) 332-8915 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Counsel for Petitioners Carefirst, Inc.; Carefirst of Maryland, Inc.; Group Additional Counsel for HCSC and Hospitalization and Medical Services, Highmark Petitioners Inc.; CareFirst BlueChoice, Inc. Charles L. Sweeris Law Department Rafael Escalera Rodríguez BLUE SHIELD OF CALIFORNIA Sylmarie Arizmendi 50 Beale Street Gustavo A. Pabón Rico San Francisco, CA 94105 REICHARD & ESCALERA, LLC Tel: (415) 229-5107 255 Ponce de León Avenue Fax: (415) 229-5343 MCS Plaza, 10th Floor [email protected] San Juan, PR 00917-1913 Tel.: (787) 777-8888 Counsel for Petitioner California Fax: (787) 765-4225 Physicians’ Service d/b/a Blue Shield of [email protected] California [email protected] [email protected] Todd Stenerson Counsel for Petitioner Triple-S Salud, SHEARMAN & STERLING LLP Inc. 401 9th Street, N.W., Suite 800 Washington, DC 20004-2128 Tel: (202) 508-8000 Fax: (202) 508-8100 [email protected]
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 6 of 100
R. David Kaufman Sarah L. Cylkowski M. Patrick McDowell Thomas J. Rheaume, Jr. BRUNINI, GRANTHAM, GROWER BODMAN PLC & HEWES, PLLC 1901 Saint Antoine Street 190 East Capitol Street 6th Floor at Ford Field The Pinnacle Building, Suite 100 Detroit, MI 48226 Jackson, MS 39201 Tel: (313) 259-7777 Tel: (601) 948-3101 Fax: (734) 930-2494 Fax: (601) 960-6902 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Andy P. Campbell John Martin Stephen D. Wadsworth Lucile H. Cohen A. Todd Campbell NELSON MULLINS RILEY & Yawanna N. McDonald SCARBOROUGH LLP CAMPBELL GUIN, LLC 1320 Main Street, 17th Floor 505 20th Street North, Suite 1600 Columbia, SC 29201 Birmingham, AL 35203 Tel: (803) 255-9421 Tel: (205) 224-0750 Fax: (803) 256-7500 Fax: (205) 224-8622 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Cheri D. Green [email protected] BLUE CROSS & BLUE SHIELD OF MISSISSIPPI, A MUTUAL Counsel for Petitioner Blue Cross and INSURANCE COMPANY Blue Shield of Michigan P.O. Box 1043 Jackson, MS 39215 John Briggs Tel: (601) 932-3704 Rachel Adcox [email protected] AXINN, VELTROP & HARKRIDER, LLP Counsel for Petitioner Blue Cross & 950 F Street, N.W. Blue Shield of Mississippi, A Mutual Washington, DC 20004 Insurance Company Tel: (202) 912-4700 Fax: (202) 912-4701 [email protected] [email protected]
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 7 of 100
Michael A. Naranjo Stephen A. Rowe FOLEY & LARDNER LLP Aaron G. McLeod 555 California Street, Suite 1700 ADAMS AND REESE LLP San Francisco, CA 94104-1520 Regions Harbert Plaza Tel: (415) 984-9847 1901 6th Avenue North, Suite 3000 Fax: (415) 434-4507 Birmingham, AL 35203 [email protected] Tel: (205) 250-5000 Fax: (205) 250-5034 Alan D. Rutenberg [email protected] Benjamin R. Dryden [email protected] FOLEY & LARDNER LLP 3000 K Street, N.W., Suite 600 Counsel for Petitioner Independence Washington, D.C. 20007-5109 Blue Cross Tel: (202) 672-5300 Fax: (202) 672-5399 Edward S. Bloomberg [email protected] John G. Schmidt [email protected] Anna Mercado Clark PHILLIPS LYTLE LLP Counsel for Petitioner USAble Mutual One Canalside Insurance Company, d/b/a Arkansas 125 Main Street Blue Cross and Blue Shield Buffalo, NY 14203 Tel: (716) 847-8400 Fax: (716) 852-6100 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
Stephen A. Walsh ADAMS AND REESE LLP 1901 Sixth Avenue North, Suite 3000 Birmingham, AL 35203 Tel: (205) 250-5000 Fax: (205) 250-5091 [email protected]
Counsel for Petitioner Excellus Health Plan, Inc., d/b/a Excellus BlueCross BlueShield, incorrectly sued as Excellus BlueCross BlueShield of New York
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 8 of 100
Robert K. Spotswood Kathleen Taylor Sooy Michael T. Sansbury Tracy A. Roman Joshua K. Payne April N. Ross Jess R. Nix Michael W. Lieberman Mary G. Menge CROWELL & MORING LLP Morgan B. Franz 1001 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. SPOTSWOOD SANSOM & Washington, D.C. 20004 SANSBURY LLC Tel: (202) 624-2500 One Federal Place Fax: (202) 628-5116 1819 5th Avenue North, Suite 1050 [email protected] Birmingham, AL 35203 [email protected] Tel: (205) 986-3620 [email protected] Fax: (205) 986-3639 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] John M. Johnson [email protected] Brian P. Kappel [email protected] LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE [email protected] LLC The Clark Building Counsel for Petitioner Capital 400 20th Street North BlueCross Birmingham, AL 35203 Tel: (205) 581-0700 Fax: (205) 581-0799 Christine Varney [email protected] Evan Chesler [email protected] Karin DeMasi Lauren Kennedy Counsel for Petitioners Blue Cross of CRAVATH SWAINE & MOORE Idaho Health Service, Inc.; Blue Cross 825 8th Avenue and Blue Shield of Kansas, Inc.; Blue New York, NY 10019 Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City; Tel: (212) 474-1000 Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Fax: (212) 474-3700 Nebraska; Blue Cross Blue Shield of [email protected] Arizona; Blue Cross Blue Shield of [email protected] North Dakota; Blue Cross Blue Shield [email protected] of Wyoming; HealthNow New York Inc.; [email protected] BlueShield of Northeastern New York; BlueCross BlueShield of Western New York
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 9 of 100
Robert R. Riley, Jr. David J. Zott, P.C. RILEY & JACKSON, P.C. Daniel E. Laytin, P.C. 3530 Independence Drive KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP Birmingham, AL 35209 300 North LaSalle Tel: (205) 879-5000 Chicago, IL 60654 Fax: (205) 879-5901 Tel: (312) 862-2000 [email protected] Fax: (312) 862-2200 [email protected] Counsel for Petitioner Blue Cross and [email protected] Blue Shield of Tennessee, Inc. Kimberly R. West (Liaison Counsel) Mark M. Hogewood
WALLACE, JORDAN, RATLIFF & BRANDT, LLC First Commercial Bank Building 800 Shades Creek Parkway, Suite 400 Birmingham, AL 35209 Tel: (205) 870-0555 Fax: (205) 871-7534 [email protected] [email protected]
John Martin Lucile H. Cohen NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH LLP 1320 Main Street, 17th Floor Columbia, SC 29201 Tel: (803) 255-9421 Fax: (803) 256-7500 [email protected] [email protected]
Counsel for Petitioners Wellmark of South Dakota, Inc. (Wellmark Blue Cross and Blue Shield of South Dakota); Wellmark, Inc. (Wellmark Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Iowa; Hawaii Medical Service Association (Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Hawaii)
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 10 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
AMENDED CERTIFICATE OF INTERESTED PERSONS AND CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT
Pursuant to 11th Cir. R. 26.1, Petitioners hereby certify that the following is a complete amended list of the trial judge and all attorneys, persons, associations of persons, firms, partnerships, or corporations that have an interest in the outcome of this particular case on appeal.
1. 450 Ventures, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
2. Accenda Health Company (Affiliate of Petitioner)
3. Access Health, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
4. Accident Fund Holding, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
5. ACE (including ACE American Insurance Company and Illinois Union
Insurance Company) (Petitioner’s Insurer)
6. Ackerson, Joseph D. (PhD) (Respondent)
7. Adams & Reese, LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
8. Adams Jr. James, G. (Counsel for Respondent)
9. Adcox, Rachel (Counsel for Petitioner)
10. Advance Insurance Company of Kansas (Affiliate of Petitioner)
11. Advanced Health Information Network, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
12. Aero Jet Intermediate Holdings, Inc., which is wholly owned by Aero
Medical International, Inc. (Parent to Respondent)
13. Ahrens, Ellen M. (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-1 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 11 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
14. American International Group Inc. (AIG) (including Lexington Insurance
Company, National Union Insurance Company, and Illinois National
Insurance Co.) (Petitioner’s Insurer)
15. Akins Law Firm (Counsel for Respondent)
16. Akins, Dale Ernest (Counsel for Respondent)
17. Alabama Industries Financial Corporation (Affiliate of Petitioner)
18. AlaHealth, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
19. Alexander, Laura (Counsel for Respondent)
20. Allen, Melissa (Respondent)
21. Allie, Renee E. (Respondent)
22. Allied World Assurance Company, f/k/a Darwin National and Darwin
Select (Petitioner’s Insurer)
23. Ambasht, M.D. Saket K. (Respondent)
24. Ambrecht Jackson LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
25. America’s 1st Choice of South Carolina, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
26. American Electric Motor Services Incorporated (Respondent)
27. AMERIGROUP Community Care of New Mexico, Inc. (Subsidiary of
Petitioner)
28. AMERIGROUP Corporation (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
29. Amerigroup District of Columbia, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
CIP-2 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 12 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
30. Amerigroup Insurance Company (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
31. AMERIGROUP Iowa, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
32. Amerigroup Kansas, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
33. AMERIGROUP Maryland, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
34. AMERIGROUP Ohio, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
35. AMERIGROUP New Jersey, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
36. AMERIGROUP Tennessee, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
37. AMERIGROUP Texas, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
38. AMERIGROUP Washington, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
39. AmeriHealth, Inc. (Parent to Petitioner)
40. AMGP Georgia Managed Care Company, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
41. Anthem Blue Cross (Blue Cross of California) (Petitioner)
42. Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Connecticut (Petitioner)
43. Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Indiana (Petitioner)
44. Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Missouri (Petitioner)
45. Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield of New Hampshire (Petitioner)
46. Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Virginia, Inc. (Petitioner)
47. Anthem Blue Cross Life and Health Insurance Company (Petitioner)
48. Anthem Financial, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
49. Anthem Health Insurance Company of Nevada (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
CIP-3 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 13 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
50. Anthem Health Plans of Kentucky, Inc. (Petitioner)
51. Anthem Health Plans of Maine (Petitioner)
52. Anthem Health Plans of Maine, Inc. (Petitioner)
53. Anthem Health Plans of New Hampshire, Inc. (Anthem Blue Cross and
Blue Shield of New Hampshire) (Petitioner)
54. Anthem Health Plans of Virginia, Inc. (Anthem Blue Cross and Blue
Shield of Virginia Inc.) (Petitioner)
55. Anthem Health Plans, Inc. (Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield of
Connecticut) (Petitioner)
56. Anthem Holding Corporation (Petitioner)
57. Anthem Insurance Companies, Inc. (Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield
of Indiana) (Petitioner)
58. Anthem, Inc. (ANTM) (Petitioner)
59. Anthem, Inc. (Anthem Health Plans of Virginia, Inc.) (Petitioner)
60. Anthem, Inc. (Parent to Anthem Insurance Companies, Inc.) (Petitioner)
61. Anthem, Inc. (Parent to Community Insurance Company) (Petitioner)
62. Anthem, Inc., f/k/a Wellpoint, Inc. d/b/a Anthem Blue Cross Life and
Health Insurance Company, Blue Cross of California, Blue Cross of
Southern California, Blue Cross of Northern California, Rocky Mountain
Hospital and Medical Service Inc. d/b/a Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield
CIP-4 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 14 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
of Colorado and Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield of Nevada, Anthem
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Connecticut, Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield
of Georgia, Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield of Indiana, Anthem Blue
Cross Blue Shield of Kentucky, Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield of
Maine, Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield of Missouri, RightCHOICE
Managed Care, Inc., HMO Missouri Inc., Anthem Health Plans of New
Hampshire as Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Hampshire,
Empire HealthChoice Assurance, Inc. as Empire Blue Cross Blue Shield,
Community Insurance Company as Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield of
Ohio, Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Virginia, Anthem Blue
Cross Blue Shield of Wisconsin (Petitioner)
63. Anthem Kentucky Managed Care Plan, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
64. Anthem Life & Disability Insurance Company (Affiliate of Petitioner)
65. Anthem Life Insurance Company (Petitioner)
66. Anthem Partnership Holding Company, LLC (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
67. Anthem Southeast, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
68. Anthem Workers’ Compensation, LLC (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
69. APC Passe, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
70. Arcara, Hon. Richard J. (W.D.N.Y.)
71. Arch Insurance Company (ACGL) (Petitioner’s Insurer)
CIP-5 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 15 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
72. Archie Lamb & Associates, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
73. Argo Re (ARGO) (Petitioner’s Insurer)
74. Arizmendi, Sylmarie (Counsel for Petitioner)
75. Arkansas Blue Cross and Blue Shield (Petitioner)
76. Armbrecht Jackson LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
77. ASC Benefit Services, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
78. Aschenbrenner, Juanita (Respondent)
79. Aschenbrenner, Tom (Respondent)
80. Associated Group, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
81. Asuris Northwest Health (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
82. ATH Holding Company, LLC (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
83. Ausman Law Firm (Counsel for Respondent)
84. Ausman, Jason (Counsel for Respondent)
85. Avalon Insurance Company (Affiliate of Petitioner)
86. Avantgarde Aviation, Inc. (Respondent)
87. Aware Integrated, Inc. (Parent to Petitioner)
88. Axelrod & Dean LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
89. Axelrod, Robert J. (Counsel for Respondent)
90. Axinn, Veltrop & Harkrider, LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
91. Bailey Glasser LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-6 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 16 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
92. Bailey, Arthur (Counsel for Respondent)
93. Baird, Lisa M. (Counsel for Petitioner)
94. Baker Wotring LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
95. Balch & Bingham LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
96. Ball & Scott Law Offices (Counsel for Respondent)
97. Ball, W. Gordon (Counsel for Respondent)
98. Balmori, Daniel (Counsel for Petitioner)
99. Balto, David A. (Counsel for Respondent)
100. Barnes, Benjamin L. (Counsel for Respondent)
101. Barnett, Tyler J. (Counsel for Respondent)
102. Barnwell, D.C. Charles (Respondent)
103. Barr, Sternberg, Moss, Lawrence, Silver & Munson, P.C. (Respondent)
104. Barstow, Erik (Respondent)
105. Bartlett, Inc. d/b/a Energy Savers (Respondent)
106. Battin, Timothy D. (Counsel for Respondent)
107. Baudin, Stanley P. (Counsel for Respondent)
108. BCBSM, Inc. d/b/a Blue Cross Blue Shield of Minnesota (Petitioner)
109. BCS Insurance Company (Petitioner’s Insurer)
110. Beard, Braden (Counsel for Respondent)
111. Beasley Allen Crow Methvin Portis & Miles, PC (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-7 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 17 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
112. Beck & Amsden PLLC (Counsel for Respondent)
113. Beck, Monte D. (Counsel for Respondent)
114. Bedford, Rogers & Bowling, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
115. Belin, Eric R.G. (Counsel for Respondent)
116. Belt Law Firm, PC (Counsel for Respondent)
117. Belt, Keith T. (Counsel for Respondent)
118. Belzer, Betsy Jane (Respondent)
119. Bender, Thomas V. (Counsel for Respondent)
120. BeneVive, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
121. Berger & Montague, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
122. Bernick, Justin (Counsel for Petitioner)
123. Berry, Mitchell Lloyd (Counsel for Respondent)
124. Bhuta, Monika (Respondent)
125. Bishop, Martin J. (Counsel for Petitioner)
126. Blanchfield, Garrett (Counsel for Respondent)
127. Bloomberg, Edward S. (Counsel for Petitioner)
128. Blue Care Network of Michigan (Affiliate of Petitioner)
129. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Alabama (Petitioner)
130. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Arizona (Petitioner)
131. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Florida (Petitioner)
CIP-8 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 18 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
132. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Florida, Inc. (Petitioner)
133. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Florida, Inc. d/b/a Florida Blue (Petitioner)
134. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Georgia (Petitioner)
135. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Georgia, Inc. (Petitioner)
136. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois (Affiliate of Petitioner)
137. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas (Petitioner)
138. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City (Petitioner)
139. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas Foundation (Affiliate of Petitioner)
140. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas, Inc. (Petitioner)
141. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Louisiana (Petitioner)
142. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts (Petitioner)
143. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts HMO Blue, Inc. (Affiliate of
Petitioner)
144. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts, Inc. (Petitioner)
145. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan (Petitioner)
146. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Minnesota (Petitioner)
147. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Mississippi (Petitioner)
148. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Montana (Affiliate of Petitioner)
149. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Nebraska (Petitioner)
150. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of New Mexico (Affiliate of Petitioner)
CIP-9 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 19 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
151. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina (Petitioner)
152. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina, Inc. (Petitioner)
153. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Dakota (Petitioner)
154. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Oklahoma (Affiliate of Petitioner)
155. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Rhode Island (Petitioner)
156. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of South Carolina (Petitioner)
157. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Tennessee (Petitioner)
158. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Tennessee, Inc. (Petitioner)
159. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas (Affiliate of Petitioner)
160. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Vermont (Petitioner)
161. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Wyoming (Petitioner)
162. Blue Cross Blue Shield Association (Petitioner)
163. Blue Cross Blue Shield Healthcare Plan of Georgia, Inc. (Petitioner)
164. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Alabama (Petitioner)
165. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona (Petitioner)
166. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Florida (Petitioner)
167. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts (Petitioner)
168. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (Petitioner)
169. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan Mutual Insurance Company
(Petitioner)
CIP-10 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 20 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
170. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Minnesota (Petitioner)
171. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Mississippi, a Mutual Insurance Company
(Petitioner)
172. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Montana (Petitioner)
173. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Nebraska (Petitioner)
174. Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Carolina (Petitioner)
175. Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Dakota (Petitioner)
176. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Northeastern Pennsylvania (Petitioner)
177. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Rhode Island (Petitioner)
178. Blue Cross Blue Shield of South Carolina (Petitioner)
179. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Tennessee (Petitioner)
180. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Vermont (Petitioner)
181. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Wisconsin (Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield of
Wisconsin) (Petitioner)
182. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Wyoming (Petitioner)
183. Blue Cross Complete of Michigan, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
184. Blue Cross of California Partnership Plan, Inc. (Petitioner)
185. Blue Cross of Idaho Care Plus, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
186. Blue Cross of Idaho Health Service, Inc. (Petitioner)
187. Blue Cross of Northeastern Pennsylvania - Wilkes-Barre (Petitioner)
CIP-11 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 21 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
188. BlueChoice HealthPlan of South Carolina, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
189. BlueCross and BlueShield of North Carolina Senior Health (Affiliate of
Petitioner)
190. BlueCross BlueShield Kansas Solutions (Affiliate of Petitioner)
191. Blue Shield of California (Petitioner)
192. Blue Shield of California Life & Health Insurance Company (Subsidiary
of Petitioner)
193. BMH, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
194. Bodman PLC (Counsel for Petitioner)
195. Boies, Alexander McInnis (Counsel for Respondent)
196. Boies, David (Counsel for Respondent)
197. Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
198. Bojedla, Swathi (Counsel for Respondent)
199. Bonnett Fairbourn Friedman & Balint, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
200. Boone, Meghan M. (Counsel for Respondent)
201. Borgeest, Wayne (Counsel for Insurer)
202. Bowling, Jeffrey L. (Counsel for Respondent)
203. Boyd, Matthew Allan (Respondent)
204. Bradberry, Christy (Respondent)
205. Bradberry, Kevin (Respondent)
CIP-12 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 22 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
206. Brain & Spine, LLC (Respondent)
207. Brashier, Andrew England (Counsel for Respondent)
208. Brazos SA Services, Inc. (Respondent)
209. BreakThrough Physical Therapy, Inc. (Respondent)
210. BridgeSpan Health Company (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
211. Briggs, John (Counsel for Petitioner)
212. Brijbasi, Vijay G. (Counsel for Petitioner)
213. Bronster Hoshibata (Counsel for Respondent)
214. Bronster, Margery S. (Counsel for Respondent)
215. Brooks, John (Counsel for Insurer)
216. Brooks, Pierce, McLendon, Humphrey & Leonard, LLP (Counsel for
Petitioner)
217. Brown Chiropractic, P.C. (Respondent)
218. Brown, D.C., Bradley J. (Respondent)
219. Brown, Katherine R. (Counsel for Respondent)
220. Brown, Molly (Counsel for Respondent)
221. Brown, Ray R. (Counsel for Respondent)
222. Brown, W. Tucker (Counsel for Respondent)
223. Bruner, Robert "Bo" P. (Counsel for Respondent)
224. Brunini, Grantham, Grower & Hewes, PLLC (Counsel for Petitioner)
CIP-13 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 23 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
225. Buchanan, Virginia (Counsel for Respondent)
226. Bullock County Hospital (Respondent)
227. Bunch & James (Counsel for Respondent)
228. Bunch, Van (Counsel for Respondent)
229. Burke Harvey & Frankowski, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
230. Burke Harvey, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
231. Burke, Peter H. (Counsel for Respondent)
232. Burkhalter, Carl S. (Counsel for Petitioner)
233. Burns, Erin C. (Counsel for Respondent)
234. Burr & Forman LLP (Counsel for Insurer)
235. Bush, Hon. Ronald E. (D. Idaho)
236. Cafferty Clobes Meriwether & Sprengel LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
237. Cafferty, Patrick (Counsel for Respondent)
238. Cahaba Government Benefit Administrators, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
239. Cahaba Medical Care (Petitioner)
240. Cahaba Safeguard Administrators, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
241. Cain, Christopher T. (Counsel for Respondent)
242. Cain, M.D., Kathleen (Respondent)
243. Caliendo, Charles T. (Counsel for Respondent)
244. California Physicians' Service (Petitioner)
CIP-14 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 24 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
245. California Physicians' Service, d/b/a Blue Shield of California
(Petitioner)
246. Cambia Health Solutions, Inc., f/d/b/a Regence Blue Shield of Idaho,
Regence Blue Cross Blue Shield of Oregon, Regence Blue Cross Blue
Shield of Utah, Regence Blue Shield of Washington (Petitioner)
247. Campbell Guin Williams Guy & Gidiere LLC (Counsel for Petitioner)
248. Campbell Guin, LLC (Counsel for Petitioner)
249. Campbell, A. Todd (Counsel for Petitioner)
250. Campbell, Andrew Phillip (Counsel for Petitioner)
251. Capital Administrative Services, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
252. Capital Advantage Assurance Company (Affiliate of Petitioner)
253. Capital Advantage Insurance Company (Affiliate of Petitioner)
254. Capital BlueCross (Petitioner)
255. Capital Health Plan, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
256. CareFirst Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Maryland (Petitioner)
257. CareFirst BlueChoice, Inc. (Petitioner)
258. CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield, d/b/a Group Hospitalization and Medical
Services and CareFirst Blue Cross Blue Shield of Maryland (Petitioner)
259. CareFirst Holdings, Inc. (Parent to Petitioner)
260. CareFirst of Maryland, Inc. (Petitioner)
CIP-15 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 25 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
261. CareFirst of Maryland, Inc. d/b/a CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield
(Petitioner)
262. CareFirst, Inc. (Petitioner)
263. CareMore Health Plan (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
264. CareMore Health Plan of Arizona, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
265. CareMore Health Plan of Nevada (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
266. CareMore Health Plan of Texas, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
267. CareMore Health System (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
268. Caring for Montanans, Inc., f/k/a Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Montana,
Inc. (Petitioner)
269. Caring for Montanans, Inc. (Petitioner)
270. Caring Foundation (Affiliate of Petitioner)
271. Carlson Lynch, Ltd. (Counsel for Respondent)
272. Carlson Lynch Sweet Kilpela & Carpenter, LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
273. Carr, James P. (Counsel for Respondent)
274. Casa Blanca, LLC (Respondent)
275. Casey, Justine (Counsel for Insurer)
276. Catamount Insurance Services, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
277. Cavanaugh, Patrick K. (Counsel for Respondent)
278. CB Roofing LLC (Respondent)
CIP-16 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 26 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
279. CCHA, LLC (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
280. Cerulean Companies, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
281. Cerven, Keith O. (Respondent)
282. Cerven, Teresa, M. (Respondent)
283. CGS Administrators, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
284. Chapman, Lewis & Swan, PLLC (Counsel for Respondent)
285. Chapman, Ralph E. (Counsel for Respondent)
286. Charles M. Thompson PC (Counsel for Respondent)
287. Charnes, Adam H. (Counsel for Petitioner)
288. Chavez, Kathleen (Counsel for Respondent)
289. Chesler, Evan (Counsel for Petitioner)
290. Chicoine, D.C., P.C., Bradley A. (Respondent)
291. Childress, Jennifer D. (Respondent)
292. Chiropractic Plus, P.C. (Respondent)
293. Chubb (CB) (including Federal Insurance and Executive Risk)
(Petitioner’s Insurer))
294. Chutkan, Tanya (Counsel for Respondent)
295. Claim Management Services, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
296. Clark III, Charles H. (M.D.) (Respondent)
297. Clark, Anna Mercado (Counsel for Petitioner)
CIP-17 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 27 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
298. Clark, Brian (Counsel for Respondent)
299. Clement, Paul D. (Counsel for Petitioner)
300. Clemon, U.W. (Counsel for Respondent)
301. Clobes, Bryan (Counsel for Respondent)
302. Cobalt Benefits Group, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
303. COBX Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
304. Coffey Burlington (Counsel for Petitioner)
305. Coffin, Christopher (Counsel for Respondent)
306. Cohen Milstein Sellers & Toll PLLC (Counsel for Respondent)
307. Cohen, Hon. James I. (S.D. Fla.)
308. Cohen, Lucile H. (Counsel for Petitioner)
309. Comet Capital LLC (Respondent)
310. Commencement Bay Risk Management Insurance Company (Subsidiary
of Petitioner)
311. Community Care Health Plan of Louisiana, Inc. d/b/a Healthy Blue
(Subsidiary of Petitioner)
312. Community Care Health Plan of Nevada, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
313. Community Insurance Company (Petitioner)
314. Community Insurance Company as Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield of
Ohio (Petitioner)
CIP-18 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 28 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
315. Companion Benefit Alternatives, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
316. Companion Data Services, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
317. Companion Life Insurance Company (Affiliate of Petitioner)
318. Companion Life Insurance Company of California (Affiliate of Petitioner)
319. Comparato, Paige (Counsel for Petitioner)
320. Compcare Health Services Insurance Corporation (Affiliate of Petitioner)
321. Comprehensive Benefits Administrators, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
322. Concepcion Martinez & Bellido (Counsel for Petitioner)
323. Concepcion, Esq., Carlos F. (Counsel for Petitioner)
324. Confluent Health (Parent of of Texas Physical Therapy Specialists, LLC,
BreakThrough Physical Theraply, Inc., Dunn Physical Therapy, Inc.)
(Respondent)
325. Connally, III, N. Thomas (Counsel for Petitioner)
326. Conner, Timothy J. (Counsel for Petitioner)
327. Connor, Glen M. (Counsel for Respondent)
328. Conrad Watson Air Conditioning, Inc. (Respondent)
329. Consolidated Benefits, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
330. Consumer Financial Education Foundation of America, Inc. (Respondent)
331. Conway, D.C., Jerry L. (Respondent)
332. Coolidge, Melinda (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-19 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 29 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
333. Cooper & Kirk, PLLC (Counsel for Respondent)
334. Cooper, Charles J. (Counsel for Respondent)
335. Cooper, Davis (Counsel for Respondent)
336. Cornelius, Hon. Staci G. (N.D. Ala.)
337. Corpion, Kristen A. (Counsel for Respondent)
338. Corporate Benefits Services, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
339. Corr, John A. (Counsel for Respondent)
340. Corr, Stephen A. (Counsel for Respondent)
341. Cory Watson Crowder & DeGaris, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
342. Cory Watson, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
343. Costello, Honor R. (Counsel for Petitioner)
344. Cottrell, P.C., Christa C. (Counsel for Petitioner)
345. Coulson, David A (Counsel for Petitioner)
346. Cowan, R. Christopher (Counsel for Respondent)
347. Cowan Law Firm (Counsel for Respondent)
348. Cox, Cox, Filo, Camel & Wilson, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
349. Cozen O’Connor (Counsel for Respondent)
350. Cramer, Eric L. (Counsel for Respondent)
351. Cravath Swaine & Moore (Counsel for Petitioner)
352. Crenshaw Community Hospital (Respondent)
CIP-20 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 30 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
353. Crispin, R. Randal (Counsel for Insurer)
354. Crosby, M.D., John Clifton (Respondent)
355. Crossroads Acquisition Corp. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
356. Crow, Christina D. (Counsel for Respondent)
357. Crowe & Dunlevy (Counsel for Petitioner)
358. Crowell & Moring LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
359. CSA Enterprises, Inc.
360. CSA General Insurance Agency, Inc.
361. Cude, Donna Smith (Counsel for Respondent)
362. Cunningham, Mark A. (Counsel for Petitioner)
363. Curtis, Frank (Respondent)
364. Cusimano, Gregory S. (Counsel for Respondent)
365. Cusimano, Roberts & Mills, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
366. Cylkowski, Sarah L. (Counsel for Petitioner)
367. Daube, Jr., M.D., Daniel C. (Respondent)
368. Dampier, M. Stephen (Counsel for Respondent)
369. Davidson, Jennifer Ray (Respondent)
370. Davis & Taliaferro LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
371. Davis, Greg L. (Counsel for Respondent)
372. Davis, John C. (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-21 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 31 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
373. Deal Cooper Holton PLLC (Counsel for Respondent)
374. DeCare Dental, LLC (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
375. DeCare Dental Health International, LLC (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
376. DeCare Dental Insurance Ireland, Ltd. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
377. DeCare Dental Networks, LLC (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
378. DeGaris, Annesley H. (Counsel for Respondent)
379. DeGiusti, Hon. Timothy D. (W.D. Okla.)
380. Del Sole Cavanaugh Stroyd LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
381. Del Sole, Steven J. (Counsel for Respondent)
382. Dellaccio, Douglas (Counsel for Respondent)
383. DeMasi, Karin (Counsel for Petitioner)
384. Dental Management Administrators, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
385. Designated Agent Company, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
386. Dickinson Wright, PLLC (Counsel for Petitioner)
387. Dickinson, Mackaman, Tyler & Hagen, P.C. (Counsel for Petitioner)
388. Dickson, Nathan A. (Counsel for Respondent)
389. Diddle, Samuel A. (Counsel for Petitioner)
390. Dillon & Findley, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
391. Dillon, Jessica (Counsel for Respondent)
392. Dobuler, Dale S. (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-22 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 32 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
393. Dodge, Michael C. (Counsel for Respondent)
394. Doherty, Hon. Rebecca F. (W.D. La.)
395. Dole, M.D., Michael (Respondent)
396. Dole, M.D., A.P.M.C., Michael (Respondent)
397. Dole, M.D., L.L.C., Michael (Respondent)
398. Doles, Troy A. (Counsel for Respondent)
399. Dominion Dental Services of New Jersey, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
400. Dominion Dental Services USA, Inc., Dominion National (Affiliate of
Petitioner)
401. Dominion Dental Services, Inc., d/b/a Dominion National (Affiliate of
Petitioner)
402. Dominion Dental USA, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
403. Dominion National Insurance Company of New Jersey (Affiliate of
Petitioner)
404. Donaldson Guin LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
405. Donnell, Sarah J. (Counsel for Petitioner)
406. Dorr, Jr., Luther M. (Counsel for Petitioner)
407. Dow, Karen (Counsel for Respondent)
408. Dowd, Augusta S. (Counsel for Respondent)
409. Draper, Hayward L. (Counsel for Petitioner)
CIP-23 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 33 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
410. Drew, Michael C. (Counsel for Respondent)
411. Dryden, Benjamin R. (Counsel for Petitioner)
412. Dummer, Constance (Respondent)
413. Dunn Physical Therapy, Inc. (Respondent)
414. Dyer, Karen (Counsel for Respondent)
415. Dyke Goldsholl & Winzerling PLC (Counsel for Respondent)
416. EAP Alliance Incorporated (Affiliate of Petitioner)
417. Ear, Nose & Throat Consultants and Hearing Services, P.L.C.
(Respondent)
418. Easter, Gerald F. (Counsel for Respondent)
419. Eberle Berlin, Kading, Turnbow & McKlveen, Chartered (Counsel for
Petitioner)
420. Eckinger, Helen L. (Counsel for Respondent)
421. EEPA, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
422. Eisler, Robert (Counsel for Respondent)
423. Empire HealthChoice Assurance, Inc. (Petitioner)
424. Empire HealthChoice Assurance, Inc., f/k/a Empire Blue Cross Blue
Shield (Petitioner)
425. Empire HealthChoice HMO, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
426. Encore System Professionals, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
CIP-24 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 34 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
427. Endurance Specialty Insurance Ltd. ( Petitioner’s Insurer)
428. Entrust Administrative Services, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
429. Entrust Agencies, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
430. Entrust Group, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
431. Entrust, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
432. Erbe Law Firm (Counsel for Respondent)
433. Erbe, Harley C. (Counsel for Respondent)
434. Erickson, Hon. Ralph R. (D.N.D.)
435. Evans, David (Counsel for Respondent)
436. Evergreen Medical Center, L.L.C. (Respondent)
437. Excellus Blue Cross Blue Shield (Petitioner)
438. Excellus BlueCross BlueShield of New York (Petitioner)
439. Excellus Health Plan, Inc. d/b/a Excellus BlueCrossBlueShield
(Petitioner)
440. Excellus Healthcare, Inc., d/b/a Excellus BlueCross BlueShield
(Petitioner)
441. Eyster Key Tubb Roth Middleton & Adams, LLP
(Counsel for Respondent)
442. Faegre Baker Daniels LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
443. Feinstein, Richard A. (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-25 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 35 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
444. Ferezy, D.C., Joseph S. d/b/a Ferezy Clinic of Chiropractic and
Neurology (Respondent)
445. Ficaro, James (Counsel for Respondent)
446. Filo, Thomas A. (Counsel for Respondent)
447. First Administrators, Inc. (Petitioner)
448. Fleming, Michael J. (Counsel for Respondent)
449. Fletcher, Joan M. (Counsel for Respondent)
450. Flippo, Linda G. (Counsel for Respondent)
451. Florida Combined Life (Affiliate of Petitioner)
452. Florida Health Care Plan, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
453. Freedom Health, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
454. Foley & Lardner LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
455. Foote, Mielke, Chavez & O'Neil LLC
(Counsel for Respondent)
456. Foote, Robert M. (Counsel for Respondent)
457. Forbes Law Group, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
458. Forbes, Frankie J (Counsel for Respondent)
459. Forsythe, Debora (Respondent)
460. Forsythe, Tony (Respondent)
461. Fort McClellan Credit Union (Respondent)
CIP-26 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 36 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
462. Fortbend SA Services, Inc. (Respondent)
463. Fowler, Jeffrey John (Counsel for Petitioner)
464. Frankowski, Richard S. (Counsel for Respondent)
465. Frankowski Firm, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
466. Franz, Morgan B. (Counsel for Petitioner)
467. Free State Growers, Inc. (Respondent)
468. Fronk, Casey R. (Counsel for Petitioner)
469. Fujichaku, Rex Y. (Counsel for Respondent)
470. G&S Trailer Repair Inc. (Respondent)
471. Galactic Funk Touring, Inc. (Respondent)
472. Gankendorff, Edgar D. (Counsel for Respondent)
473. Garner,Jeffrey S. (Respondent)
474. Gaspar Physical Therapy, P.C. (Respondent)
475. Gaston CPA Firm, P.C. (Respondent)
476. GC/AAA Fences, Inc. (Respondent)
477. Geneia Holdings LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
478. Geneia Insights and Innovations LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
479. Geneia LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
480. Geneia Management Solutions LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
481. Gentle III, Edgar C. (Special Master)
CIP-27 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 37 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
482. George, David (Counsel for Respondent)
483. Giarmarco, Mullins & Horton, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
484. Giglio, Jr., Joseph C. (Counsel for Petitioner)
485. Gilbert, Sallie E. (Counsel for Respondent)
486. Gillis, H. Lewis (Counsel for Respondent)
487. Gilmore, M.D., Michael (Respondent)
488. Given, Robert S. W. (Counsel for Petitioner)
489. Glast Phillips & Murray, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
490. Global TPA, LLC (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
491. Golden Security Insurance Co. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
492. Golden West Health Plan, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
493. Goodin, Janeen (Respondent)
494. Goodman, Jason (Respondent)
495. Goodman, Tom A. (Respondent)
496. Goodsir, David (Counsel for Petitioner)
497. Gordon Ball Law Office (Counsel for Respondent)
498. Gordon Jr., Ben W. (Counsel for Respondent)
499. Government Management Services, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
500. Grant & Eisenhofer (Counsel for Respondent)
501. Gravante III, John (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-28 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 38 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
502. Gray & White (Counsel for Respondent)
503. Gray, Mark K. (Counsel for Respondent)
504. Greater Brunswick Physical Therapy, P.A. (Respondent)
505. Greater Georgia Life Insurance Company (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
506. Green, Cheri D. (Counsel for Petitioner)
507. Greenberg Traurig, PA (Counsel for Petitioner)
508. Group Hospitalization and Medical Services, Inc. (Petitioner)
509. Group Hospitalization and Medical Services, Inc. d/b/a CareFirst
BlueCross BlueShield (Petitioner)
510. Group Insurance Services, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
511. Grubb II, Archibald I. (Counsel for Respondent)
512. GuideWell Mutual Holding Corporation (Parent to Petitioner)
513. Guin, David J. (Counsel for Respondent)
514. Guin, Stokes & Evans, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
515. Gurley, Jr., Michael E. (Counsel for Respondent)
516. Gustafson Gluek PLLC (Counsel for Respondent)
517. Gustafson, Daniel E. (Counsel for Respondent)
518. Guster, Ta’Kisha L. (Counsel for Respondent)
519. Haden, Ed R. (Counsel for Petitioner)
520. Hansen, Chad D. (Counsel for Petitioner)
CIP-29 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 39 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
521. Hansen, Stephen M. (Counsel for Respondent)
522. Hare, Scott M. (Counsel for Respondent)
523. Harrell, J. Wells (Counsel for Respondent)
524. Harris, Hon. Alonzo (27th Judicial District Court, St. Landry Parish,
Louisiana)
525. Harvalis, Jim (Affiliated with Counsel for Petitioner)
526. Harwood, Jr., Hon. R. Bernard (Special Master)
527. Hatch, Robert M. (Counsel for Respondent)
528. Hausfeld LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
529. Hausfeld, Michael (Counsel for Respondent)
530. Hawaii Medical Service Association d/b/a Blue Cross and Blue Shield of
Hawaii (Petitioner)
531. Hawkins & Norris, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
532. Hawran, Gregory R. Counsel for Petitioner
533. Hayes Hunger PC (Counsel for Respondent)
534. Hayes, Debra Brewer (Counsel for Respondent)
535. Hayes, Lisa N. (Counsel for Respondent)
536. Hazzard Law, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
537. Hazzard, Brent (Counsel for Respondent)
538. Health and Wellness Partners, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
CIP-30 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 40 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
539. Healthbox Nashville LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
540. Health Care Service Corporation (Petitioner)
541. Health Care Service Corporation d/b/a Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois,
Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Mexico, Blue Cross Blue Shield of
Oklahoma, Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Montana, Blue Cross Blue
Shield of Texas (Petitioner)
542. Healthcare Business Solutions, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
543. HealthKeepers, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
544. HealthLink HMO, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
545. HealthLink, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
546. Healthcare Management Administrators, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
547. Health Management Corporation (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
548. HealthNow New York Inc. (Petitioner)
549. HealthNow New York Inc., d/b/a Blue Cross Blue Shield of Western New
York and Blue Shield of Northeastern New York (Petitioner)
550. HealthNow Systems, Inc. (Petitioner)
551. Health Options, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
552. HealthPlus HP, LLC (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
553. HealthSun Health Plans, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
554. Healthy Alliance Life Insurance Company (Petitioner)
CIP-31 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 41 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
555. Hedlund, Daniel C. (Counsel for Respondent)
556. Heidman Law Firm (Counsel for Respondent)
557. Hellums, Chris T. (Counsel for Respondent)
558. Hendlin, D.C., Timothy H. (Respondent)
559. Hendren & Malone PLLC (Counsel for Respondent)
560. Heritage Medical Partners, L.L.C. (Respondent)
561. Herman, Matthew J. (Counsel for Respondent)
562. Hess, Hess & Daniel, P.C. (Respondent)
563. Hickey & Evans, LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
564. Highmark Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Delaware
(Affiliate of Petitioner)
565. Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield of Delaware, Inc. (Petitioner)
566. Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield of West Virginia (Petitioner)
567. Highmark Health (Parent to Petitioner)
568. Highmark Health Services, d/b/a Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield of
Delaware, Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield, and Highmark Blue Cross
Blue Shield of West Virginia (Petitioner)
569. Highmark Inc. (Petitioner)
570. Highmark West Virgina Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
571. Highway to Health, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
CIP-32 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 42 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
572. Hill Hill Carter Franco Cole & Black, PC
(Counsel for Petitioner)
573. Hill, Angie (Respondent)
574. Hill, Ross (Respondent)
575. Hillside Family Medicine, LLC (Respondent)
576. HMO Colorado (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
577. HMO Louisiana, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
578. HMO Missouri Inc. (Petitioner)
579. HMO Missouri, Inc. (Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Missouri)
(Petitioner)
580. HMO Partners, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
581. HMSA BSH, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
582. HMSA Foundation, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
583. Hodge, David J. (Counsel for Respondent)
584. Hofmeister, Dan (Counsel for Petitioner)
585. Hogan Lovells US LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
586. Hogan, E. Desmond (Counsel for Petitioner)
587. Hogewood, Mark M. (Counsel for Petitioner)
588. Holland & Knight (Counsel for Petitioner)
589. Holmes, Janet Brooks (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-33 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 43 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
590. Holmstead, Zachary D. (Counsel for Petitioner)
591. Holton, John R. (Counsel for Respondent)
592. Holton, Timothy R. (Counsel for Respondent)
593. Hoover, Craig A. (Counsel for Petitioner)
594. Horizon Blue Cross and Blue Shield of New Jersey (Petitioner)
595. Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey (Petitioner)
596. Horizon Casualty Services, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
597. Horizon Healthcare Dental, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
598. Horizon Healthcare of New Jersey, Inc. (which also operates under the
name Horizon NJ Health) (Affiliate of Petitioner)
599. Horizon Healthcare Services, Inc. d/b/a Horizon Blue Cross and Blue
Shield of New Jersey (Petitioner)
600. Horizon Healthcare Services, Inc. d/b/a Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield
of New Jersey (Petitioner)
601. Horizon Insurance Company (Affiliate of Petitioner)
602. Horner, Chelsea L. (Respondent)
603. Horton, William H. (Counsel for Respondent)
604. Hospital Service Association of Northeastern Pennsylvania d/b/a Blue
Cross of Northeastern Pennsylvania (Petitioner)
CIP-34 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 44 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
605. Hospital Service Association of Northeastern Pennsylvania d/b/a Blue
Cross of Northeastern Pennsylvania (Petitioner)
606. Hospital Service District 1 of the Parish of East Baton Rouge, Louisiana
d/b/a Lane Regional Medical Center (Respondent)
607. Hovland, Hon. Daniel L. (D.N.D.)
608. Hudson, Charles D. (Counsel for Respondent)
609. Hufford, D. Brian (Counsel for Respondent)
610. Hume, Hamish P.M. (Counsel for Respondent)
611. Hund, D.M.D., Cason T. (Respondent)
612. Hunter, Charles Clinton (Counsel for Respondent)
613. Huppert, Hon. Michael D. (5th Judicial District Court, Polk County,
Iowa)
614. IMA, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
615. Independence Blue Cross, LLC (Parent to Petitioner)
616. Independence Health Group Inc. (Parent to Petitioner)
617. Independence Hospital Indemnity Plan, Inc., f/k/a Independence Blue
Cross (Petitioner)
618. IngenioRx, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
619. Instil Health Insurance Company (Affiliate of Petitioner)
620. Insua, Nicholas (Counsel for Petitioner)
CIP-35 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 45 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
621. Integrated Services, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
622. International Plan Solutions, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
623. Iron Gate Technology, Inc. (Respondent)
624. Ironshore Inc. (Petitioner’s Insurer)
625. Iron-Starr Excess Agency Ltd. (Petitioner’s Insurer)
626. Isaacson, William A. (Counsel for Respondent)
627. Ivy Creek of Butler, L.L.C. d/b/a Georgiana Medical Center
(Respondent)
628. Ivy Creek of Elmore, L.L.C. d/b/a Elmore Community Hospital
(Respondent)
629. Ivy Creek of Tallapoosa, L.L.C. d/b/a Lake Martin Community Hospital
(Respondent)
630. Jackson Medical Center, L.L.C. (Respondent)
631. Jackson, Anthony F. (Counsel for Respondent)
632. James Hoyer, P.A. (Respondent)
633. James, Joey K. (Counsel for Respondent)
634. Jameson, Joel (Respondent)
635. Jarvey, Hon. John A. (S.D. Iowa)
636. Jenks III, James K. (Counsel for Respondent)
637. Jenner & Block LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
CIP-36 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 46 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
638. Jewelers Trade Shop (Respondent)
639. Jinks Crow & Dickson, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
640. Jinks, III, Lynn W. (Counsel for Respondent)
641. John D. Saxon, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
642. John F. Nevares & Associates, PSC (Counsel for Respondent)
643. Johnson, John M. (Counsel for Petitioner)
644. Johnston, Clint (Respondent)
645. Jones & Swartz PLLC (Counsel for Respondent)
646. Jones Walker LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
647. Jones Ward PLC (Counsel for Respondent)
648. Jones, Bruce C. (Counsel for Respondent)
649. Jones, Lawrence (Counsel for Respondent)
650. Jones, Megan (Counsel for Respondent)
651. Jordan, Eric M. Quetglas (Counsel for Respondent))
652. Junks, III, Lynn W. (Counsel for Respondent)
653. Kahn, Jeremy L. (Counsel for Respondent)
654. Kallas, Edith M. (Counsel for Respondent)
655. Kanne, Alison F. (Counsel for Respondent)
656. Kanzic, D.C. Judith (Respondent)
657. Kapke & Willerth LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-37 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 47 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
658. Kaplan, Andrew D. (Counsel for Petitioner)
659. Kappel, Brian P. (Counsel for Petitioner)
660. Kaufman, R. David (Counsel for Petitioner)
661. Kaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP (Counsel for Insurer)
662. Kellner, William E. (Counsel for Petitioner)
663. Kelso, Trent (Respondent)
664. Kennedy, Lauren (Counsel for Petitioner)
665. Kenney, Jeannine M. (Counsel for Respondent)
666. Keystone Health Plan Central, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
667. Keystone Medical Imaging, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
668. Kilene, Jason S. (Counsel for Respondent)
669. Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP (Petitioner's Counsel)
670. Kilpela, Jr., Edwin, J. (Counsel for Respondent)
671. Kimble, Cavender C. (Counsel for Petitioner)
672. Kirk, Michael (Counsel for Respondent)
673. Kirkland & Ellis LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
674. Knapp, Scott R. (Counsel for Petitioner)
675. Knott, Jason M. (Counsel for Respondent)
676. Knowlton II, Donald D. (Counsel for Respondent)
677. Koch, H. James (Counsel for Petitioner)
CIP-38 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 48 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
678. Kochanowski, Andrew J. (Counsel for Respondent)
679. Kozyak Tropin & Throckmorton, P.A. (Counsel for Respondent)
680. Krausman, Jeffrey A. (Counsel for Respondent)
681. Kravitz, Carl S. (Counsel for Respondent)
682. Krieger, Mark (Respondent)
683. Kruse, D.C., P.C., Dr. Mark A. (Respondent)
684. Labauve, Elizabeth Barnett (Counsel for Petitioner)
685. Lamb, Jr., Archie C. (Counsel for Respondent)
686. Lambert, Kenneth (Counsel for Petitioner)
687. Langston & Lott, P.A. (Counsel for Respondent)
688. Law Offices of David A. Balto (Counsel for Respondent)
689. Law Office of John C. Davis (Counsel for Respondent)
690. Law Office of Stephen M. Hansen (Counsel for Respondent)
691. Lawrence, Hon. William T. (S.D. Ind.)
692. Laytin, P.C., Daniel E. (Counsel for Petitioner)
693. Lemmon Law Firm (Counsel for Respondent)
694. Lemmon, Andrew (Counsel for Respondent)
695. Levin Papantonio Thomas Mitchell Rafferty & Proctor, P.A. (Counsel
for Respondent)
696. Lieberman, Michael W. (Counsel for Petitioner)
CIP-39 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 49 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
697. LifeMap Assurance Company (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
698. Life Secure Insurance Company Holdings (Affiliate of Petitioner)
699. Lifetime Healthcare, Inc. (Petitioner)
700. Lightfoot Franklin & White LL (Counsel for Petitioner)
701. Lindberg Law, PLC (Counsel for Respondent)
702. Liskow & Lewis (Counsel for Petitioner)
703. Little, Jonathan C. (Counsel for Respondent)
704. Lloyd’s of London (Petitioner’s Insurer)
705. Lockard & Williams Insurance Services, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
706. Lockridge Grindal Nauen P.L.L.P (Counsel for Respondent)
707. London ACE (Petitioner’s Insurer)
708. Lopez, Javier A. (Counsel for Respondent)
709. Lott, Casey Langston (Counsel for Respondent)
710. Louisiana Health Service & Indemnity Company d/b/a Blue Cross and
Blue Shield of Louisiana (Petitioner)
711. Lovell & Nalley (Counsel for Respondent)
712. Lundberg Law, PLC (Counsel for Respondent)
713. Lundberg, Paul (Counsel for Respondent)
714. Lungstrum, Hon. John W. (D. Kan.)
715. Lydian, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
CIP-40 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 50 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
716. Lytle, Joann (Counsel for Petitioner)
717. Macrae, Amy (Respondent)
718. Makin, M.D., Harbir (Respondent)
719. Malatesta, III, John Thomas A. (Counsel for Petitioner)
720. Malone, J. Michael (Counsel for Respondent)
721. Mandel and Mandel, LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
722. Mann, Jonathan S. (Counsel for Respondent)
723. Mansfield, Alan McQuarrie (Counsel for Respondent)
724. Marshall III, Charles F. (Counsel for Petitioner)
725. Marshall, Hope S. (Counsel for Respondent)
726. Martin, John (Counsel for Petitioner)
727. Martin, Scott Allen (Counsel for Respondent)
728. Martinez, Jr., Esq., Elio F. (Counsel for Petitioner)
729. Marwood Group & Co USA LLC (Parent of U.S. Imaging Network,
LLC) (Respondent)
730. Mason, Gary E. (Counsel for Respondent)
731. Massachusetts Benefit Administrators, LLC
(Affiliate of Petitioner)
732. Mathias, John (Counsel for Petitioner)
733. Matthew Thornton Health Plan, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
CIP-41 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 51 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
734. Matusko, Joanne E. (Counsel for Respondent)
735. Maynard Cooper & Gale PC (Counsel for Petitioner)
736. McCafferty, Hon. Landya B. (D.N.H.)
737. McCallum, Methvin & Terrell, PC (Counsel for Respondent)
738. McCallum, Phillip W. (Counsel for Respondent)
739. McCarter & English, LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
740. McCormick, M.D., L.L.C., Julie (Respondent)
741. McDevitt, Larry (Counsel for Respondent)
742. McDonald, Yawanna N. (Counsel for Petitioner)
743. McDowell, M. Patrick (Counsel for Petitioner)
744. McGartland & Borchardt LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
745. McGartland, Michael (Counsel for Respondent)
746. McGartland Law Firm, PLLC (Counsel for Respondent)
747. McGill, Brian (Respondent)
748. McGill, Rochelle (Respondent)
749. McKane, Mark E. (Counsel for Petitioner)
750. McKay Cauthen Settana and Stubley (Counsel for Respondent)
751. McKinney, Rebekah Keith (Counsel for Respondent)
752. McLean, Ronald H. (Counsel for Petitioner)
753. McLeod, Aaron G. (Counsel for Petitioner)
CIP-42 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 52 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
754. McQuilkin, Gail A. (Counsel for Respondent)
755. MCS Holdings, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)a
756. Means Gillis Law, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
757. Medical Helpline, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
758. Medrisk Actuarial Services, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
759. Meierhenry Sargent LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
760. Melson, II, Gilbert Reid (Respondent)
761. Menge, Mary G. (Counsel for Petitioner)
762. Meridian Resources Company, LLC (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
763. Meriwether, Ellen (Counsel for Respondent)
764. Meshbesher & Spence, LTD. (Counsel for Respondent)
765. Methvin, Jr., Robert G. (Counsel for Respondent)
766. Meyers, D. Kent (Counsel for Petitioner)
767. Michael E. Stark (Respondent)
768. Midwest Benefit Consultants, Inc. (Petitioner)
769. Miles Jr., Temus C. (Counsel for Respondent)
770. Miles, III, W. Daniel (Counsel for Respondent)
771. Miller, David E. (Counsel for Respondent)
772. Miller, D.C., Kevin D. (Respondent)
773. Miller, Mike (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-43 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 53 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
774. Mills, Emily Hawk (Counsel for Respondent)
775. Mills, Linda (Respondent)
776. Montis, Inc. (Respondent)
777. Mooney Green Saindon Murphy and Welch PC (Counsel for
Respondent)
778. Moreno, Hon. Federico A. (S.D. Fla.)
779. Morris, King & Hodge (Counsel for Respondent)
780. Morris, Scott A. (Respondent)
781. Morrissey, Mary (Respondent)
782. Morrow, Morrow, Ryan, Bassett & Haik
(Counsel for Respondent)
783. Morrow, Patrick C. (Counsel for Respondent)
784. Mosaic Group Services, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
785. Moser, Cynthia C. (Counsel for Respondent)
786. Moylan, Daniel Patrick (Counsel for Respondent)
787. Mueller, D.C., Kevin D. (Respondent)
788. Mueller, D.C., Steven A. (Respondent)
789. Murphy, Erin E. (Counsel for Petitioner)
790. Murphy, Mark J. (Counsel for Respondent)
791. Murphy, Michael L. (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-44 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 54 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
792. Murray Law Firm (Counsel for Respondent)
793. Murray, Arthur M. (Counsel for Respondent)
794. Murray, Jr., Stephen B. (Counsel for Respondent)
795. Musselman, M.D., Corey (Respondent)
796. My Care Alabama, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
797. Nalley, John Doyle (Counsel for Respondent)
798. Naranjo, Michael A. (Counsel for Petitioner)
799. Nast, Dianne M. (Counsel for Respondent)
800. NastLaw LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
801. National SA Services, Inc. (Respondent)
802. NDBH Holding Company, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
803. Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
804. Nelson, Christopher (Counsel for Respondent)
805. Nesbitt, M.D., Robert W. (Respondent)
806. Nesin, P.T., D.P.T., O.C.S., Janine (Respondent)
807. Netting, Irma L. (Counsel for Respondent)
808. Neuromonitoring Services of America, Inc. (Respondent)
809. Nevares, John F. (Counsel for Respondent)
810. New Directions Behavioral Health, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
811. Niagara Life and Health Insurance Company (Affiliate of Petitioner)
CIP-45 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 55 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
812. Nielson Jr., Howard C. (Counsel for Respondent)
813. Niles Chiropractic, Inc. (Respondent)
814. Niles, D.C., Mark A. (Respondent)
815. Nix, Jess R. (Counsel for Petitioner)
816. NobleHealth, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
817. Nordin, Daniel J. (Counsel for Respondent)
818. Noridian Mutual Insurance Company, d/b/a Blue Cross Blue Shield of
North Dakota (Petitioner)
819. Norman, Brian K. (Counsel for Petitioner)
820. Norris, Glenn L. (Counsel for Respondent)
821. North Jackson Pharmacy, Inc. (Respondent)
822. Northwest Florida Surgery Center, Inc. (Respondent)
823. Northwest Florida Surgery Center, L.L.C. (Respondent)
824. Nyemaster Goode PC (Counsel for Petitioner)
825. O'Brien, Charles A. (Counsel for Respondent)
826. O'Connell, Sean T. (Counsel for Respondent)
827. O'Connor, Hon. Reed. C. (N.D. Tex.)
828. Ogletree Deakins Nash Smoak & Stewart PC (Counsel for Petitioner)
829. Olwan, Ph.D., Dena Z. (Respondent)
830. O'Melveny & Myers LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
CIP-46 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 56 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
831. OneBeacon Insurance Group (including Atlantic Specialty Insurance
Company and Homeland Insurance Company) (Petitioner’s Insurer)
832. Onlife Health, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
833. Opelousas General Hospital Authority (Respondent)
834. Opelousas General Hospital Authority, a public trust, d/b/a Opelousas
General Health System (Respondent)
835. Optimum Healthcare, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
836. Pacella, Mario A. (Counsel for Respondent)
837. Page, Kimberly C. (Counsel for Respondent)
838. Palmer, Tim A. (Counsel for Petitioner)
839. Palmetto GBA, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
840. PGBA, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
841. Panhandle Orthopedics, LLC (Respondent)
842. Pantazis, Dennis (Counsel for Respondent)
843. Parsons, Eileen L. (Counsel for Respondent)
844. Partin, John W. (Counsel for Respondent)
845. Pasadena SA Services, Inc. (Respondent)
846. Payne, Joshua K. (Counsel for Petitioner)
847. Payton, Gwendolyn C. (Counsel for Petitioner)
848. PCS, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
CIP-47 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 57 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
849. Pearce, Bevill, Leesburg, Moore, P.C. (Respondent)
850. Pearson, O'Kelley H. (Counsel for Respondent)
851. Pendley, Baudin & Coffin LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
852. Pendley, Patrick W. (Counsel for Respondent)
853. Penn & Seaborn, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
854. Penn, Myron C. (Counsel for Respondent)
855. Penney, Brant (Counsel for Respondent)
856. Perlman, Alan J. (Counsel for Petitioner)
857. Pernia M.D., Luis R. (Respondent)
858. Pescia, Leslie Lee Ann (Counsel for Respondent)
859. Pete Moore Chevrolet, Inc. (Respondent)
860. Peterson, Rebecca (Counsel for Respondent)
861. Pettus Plumbing & Piping, Inc. (Respondent)
862. Pham, Allison N. (Counsel for Respondent)
863. Phillips Lytle LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
864. Phillips, Daniel E. (Counsel for Respondent)
865. Phipps, D.C., Larry D. (Respondent)
866. Phipps, Larry E. (D.C.) (Respondent)
867. Physicians' Service, d/b/a Blue Shield of California (Petitioner)
868. Pincavage, Danja J. (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-48 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 58 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
869. Pioneer Farm Equipment, Inc. (Respondent)
870. Pittman, C. Wes (Counsel for Respondent)
871. Pittman, Dutton & Hellums, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
872. Pittman Firm, P.A. (Counsel for Respondent)
873. Planned Administrators, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
874. Podhurst Orseck, P.A. (Counsel for Respondent)
875. Podhurst, Aaron S. (Counsel for Respondent)
876. Pollack-Avery, Elizabeth (Counsel for Respondent)
877. Pomerantz Grossman Hufford Dahlstrom & Gross, LLP (Counsel for
Respondent)
878. Poston, Jr., Paul N. (Respondent)
879. Preferred Care Services, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
880. Premara Blue Cross of Washington (Petitioner)
881. Premara, d/b/a Premara Blue Cross Blue Shield of Alaska (Petitioner)
882. Premera Blue Cross, d/b/a Premera Blue Cross Blue Shield of Alaska
(Petitioner)
883. Priester, James L. (Counsel for Petitioner)
884. Prieto, Peter (Counsel for Respondent)
885. Prime Therapeutics, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
886. Proctor, Hon. R. David (N.D. Ala.)
CIP-49 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 59 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
887. ProRehab, P.C. (Respondent)
888. Provosty & Gankendorff, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
889. Putnam, Hon. T. Michael (N.D. Ala.)
890. Quality Dialysis One, L.L.C., f/k/a Quality Dialysis One, L.P., and
Quality Dialysis Two (Respondent)
891. Quetglas Law Offices (Counsel for Respondent)
892. Quillen, Henry C. (Counsel for Respondent)
893. Quinlan, Patrick J. (Counsel for Respondent)
894. Quinn, Connor, Weaver, Davies & Ruoco LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
895. Ragsdale, Barry A. (Counsel for Respondent)
896. Rathod, Jason R. (Counsel for Respondent)
897. Ray, Ryan (Respondent)
898. Rayes, Douglas L. (D. Ariz.)
899. Rebarcak, D.C., Rod R. (Respondent)
900. Recovery Village at Umatilla, LLC (Respondent)
901. Redgrave, Jonathan M. (Counsel for Respondent)
902. Redgrave, LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
903. Redgrave, Victoria A. (Counsel for Petitioner)
904. Redmond, James (Counsel for Respondent)
905. Reed Smith LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
CIP-50 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 60 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
906. Reeves, Harold S. (Counsel for Respondent)
907. Regence BlueCross BlueShield of Oregon (Petitioner)
908. Regence BlueCross BlueShield of Utah (Petitioner)
909. Regence BlueShield (Petitioner)
910. Regence BlueShield of Idaho, Inc. (Petitioner)
911. Regence Insurance Holding Corporation (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
912. Reich & Binstock, LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
913. Reich, Dennis C. (Counsel for Respondent)
914. Reichard & Escalera, LLC (Counsel for Petitioner)
915. Reinhardt, Wendorf & Blanchfield (Counsel for Respondent)
916. Reis, John (Counsel for Respondent)
917. Resolution Health, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
918. REVA, Inc. (Respondent)
919. Rheaume, Jr., Thomas J. (Counsel for Petitioner)
920. Rhodes IV, C. Harker (Counsel for Petitioner)
921. Richmond SA Services, Inc. (Counsel for Respondent)
922. Rico, Gustavo A. Pabón (Counsel for Petitioner)
923. Riebel, Karen Hanson (Counsel for Respondent)
924. RightChoice Managed Care, Inc. (Petitioner)
925. Riley & Jackson, PC (Counsel for Petitioner)
CIP-51 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 61 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
926. Riley, Jr., Robert R. (Counsel for Petitioner)
927. Riverbend Govt. Benefits Administrator, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
928. RiverTrust Solutions, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
929. RLI/RSUI (Petitioner's Insurer)
930. Roach, Benjamin Patrick (Counsel for Petitioner)
931. Roadhouse D.C., Brian (Respondent)
932. Roberts, Michael L. (Counsel for Respondent)
933. Robertson, John Robert (Counsel for Petitioner)
934. Robinovitch, Hart L. (Counsel for Respondent)
935. Rockforte, Nicholas R. (Counsel for Respondent)
936. Rocky Mountain Hospital & Medical Service Inc., d/b/a Anthem Blue
Cross Blue Shield of Colorado (Petitioner)
937. Rocky Mountain Hospital & Medical Service Inc., d/b/a Anthem Blue
Cross Blue Shield of Nevada (Petitioner)
938. Rodanast, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
939. Roden, Robert B. (Counsel for Respondent)
940. Rodríguez, Rafael Escalera (Counsel for Petitioner)
941. Rolison Trucking Co., LLC (Respondent)
942. Roman Nation, M.D. (Respondent)
943. Roman, Tracy A. (Counsel for Petitioner)
CIP-52 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 62 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
944. Ross, April N. (Counsel for Petitioner)
945. Roth, Julia Smeds (Counsel for Respondent)
946. Roth, Nicholas B. (Counsel for Respondent)
947. Rouco, Richard (Counsel for Respondent)
948. Rowe, Stephen A. (Counsel for Petitioner)
949. Russo, Gary J. (Counsel for Respondent)
950. Rutenberg, Alan D. (Counsel for Petitioner)
951. Rx Concepts, Ltd. Co. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
952. Ryan, Graham H. (Counsel for Respondent)
953. Ryan, James P. (Counsel for Respondent)
954. Saccoccio & Lopez (Respondent)
955. Sadler Electric (Respondent)
956. Saeed & Little, LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
957. Salomon, Anne (Counsel for Petitioner)
958. Sansbury, Michael T. (Counsel for Petitioner)
959. Sargent, Clint (Counsel for Respondent)
960. Saxon, John (Counsel for Respondent)
961. Scheller, Kathryn (Respondent)
962. Schimmel, Charles T. (Counsel for Respondent)
963. Schlichter Bogard & Denton, LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-53 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 63 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
964. Schmidt, Jr., John G. (Counsel for Petitioner)
965. Schneider, Sydney L (Counsel for Petitioner)
966. Schreiber Law Firm (Counsel for Respondent)
967. Schreiber, J. Allen (Counsel for Respondent)
968. Schwiep, Paul J. (Counsel for Petitioner)
969. Scott & Cain (Counsel for Respondent)
970. Scott Jr., Thomas S. (Counsel for Respondent)
971. Scott, Lee McArthur (Counsel for Respondent)
972. Seaborn, L. Shane (Counsel for Respondent)
973. Sears & Swanson, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
974. Sears, Lance Michael (Counsel for Respondent)
975. SecurityCare of Tennessee, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
976. Self Insured Plans, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
977. Serkland Law Firm (Counsel for Petitioner)
978. Shaheen & Gordon, P.A. (Counsel for Respondent)
979. Shamoun & Norman, LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
980. Shared Health, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
981. Sharp, Marla S. (Respondent)
982. Shaw, Adam R. (Counsel for Respondent)
983. Shearman & Sterling LLP (Counsel for Petitioner)
CIP-54 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 64 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
984. Sheehan, Patrick J. (Counsel for Respondent)
985. Shelby Roden Law Firm (Counsel for Respondent)
986. Shelby Roden, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
987. Shelton, Alicia L. (Counsel for Respondent)
988. Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton LLP (Counsel for Insurer)
989. Sheridan, Judy (Respondent)
990. Simply Healthcare Plans, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
991. Simons & Associates Law, P.A. (Counsel for Respondent)
992. Simons, Gwen (Counsel for Respondent)
993. Simons, Kara Marie (Counsel for Respondent)
994. Sirocco, Inc. (Respondent)
995. Sirote & Permutt P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
996. Slate, Pamela B. (Counsel for Petitioner)
997. Small, Daniel (Counsel for Respondent)
998. Smith, Cyril V. (Counsel for Respondent)
999. Snowden Olwan Psychological Services (Respondent)
1000. Snowden, Ph.D., James V. (Respondent)
1001. Snyder, Hon. Christina A. (C.D. Cal.)
1002. Socios Mayores en Salud Holdings, Inc., d/b/a Triple-S Advantage
(Affiliate of Petitioner)
CIP-55 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 65 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
1003. Solberg Stewart Miller (Counsel for Respondent)
1004. Sommers Schwartz PC (Counsel for Respondent)
1005. Sooy, Kathleen Taylor (Counsel for Petitioner)
1006. Sompo International (Petitioner’s Insurer)
1007. Southeast Services, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
1008. Southern Diversified Business Services, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1009. Southern Health Plan, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1010. Spine Diagnostic Center of Baton Rouge, Inc. (Respondent)
1011. Spotswood Sansom & Sansbury LLC (Counsel for Petitioner)
1012. Spotswood, Robert K. (Counsel for Petitioner)
1013. Stackhouse, Andrea Layne (Counsel for Respondent)
1014. Stark & Stark, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
1015. Stecker, Brett (Counsel for Respondent)
1016. Stenerson, Todd (Counsel for Petitioner)
1017. Stetson, Catherine E. (Counsel for Petitioner)
1018. Stokes, Tammy (Counsel for Respondent)
1019. Stone & Magnanini LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
1020. Stone Law Firm, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
1021. Stone, Andrew M. (Counsel for Respondent)
1022. Stone, David (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-56 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 66 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
1023. Stoops, Kevin J. (Counsel for Respondent)
1024. Straus & Boies LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
1025. Strom Law Firm, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
1026. Strom, Jr., J. Preston (Counsel for Respondent)
1027. Stroyd, Jr., Arthur H. (Counsel for Respondent)
1028. Strutt, Jennifer (Counsel for Petitioner)
1029. Sudekum, Michael J. (Counsel for Respondent)
1030. Sugar Land SA, Inc. (Respondent)
1031. Swank, Ami (Counsel for Respondent)
1032. Swartz, Eric B. (Counsel for Respondent)
1033. Sweeris, Charles L. (Counsel for Petitioner)
1034. Sweet, Benjamin (Counsel for Respondent)
1035. Taylor, Jr., Daniel R. (Counsel for Petitioner)
1036. Templeton, Quentin (Counsel for Respondent)
1037. Tennessee Health Foundation, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1038. Terrell, James M. (Counsel for Respondent)
1039. Tessellate Holdings, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1040. Tessier, Kevin (Counsel for Petitioner)
1041. Texas Physical Therapy Specialists, L.L.C. (Respondent)
1042. The Caring Foundation (Affiliate of Petitioner)
CIP-57 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 67 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
1043. The Cowan Law Firm (Counsel for Respondent)
1044. The Dampier Law Firm PC (Counsel for Respondent)
1045. The Frankowski Firm, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
1046. The Hayes Law Firm (Counsel for Respondent)
1047. The Law Offices of David A. Balto (Counsel for Respondent)
1048. The Pittman Firm, P.A. (Counsel for Respondent)
1049. The Van Winkle Law Firm (Counsel for Respondent)
1050. The Weiser Law Firm, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
1051. Thomas Cooper & Co., Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1052. Thomas, Nancy (Respondent)
1053. Thompson, Charles M. (Counsel for Respondent)
1054. Thompson, Jason (Counsel for Respondent)
1055. Thompson, John G. (Respondent)
1056. Total Dental Administrators Health Plan, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1057. Total Dental Administrators of Utah, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1058. Total Dental Administrators, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1059. TrailBlazer Health Enterprises, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1060. The Travelers Companies, Inc. (TRV) (Petitioner’s Insurer)
1061. Tri-West (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1062. Tricenturion, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
CIP-58 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 68 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
1063. Trinnovate Ventures, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1064. Triple-S Blue, Inc., d/b/a BlueCross BlueShield Costa Rica (Affiliate of
Petitioner)
1065. Triple-S Management Corporation (GTS) (Parent to Petitioner)
1066. Triple-S Propiedad, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1067. Triple-S Salud (Petitioner)
1068. Triple-S Salud, Inc. (Petitioner)
1069. Triple-S Vida, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1070. Tropin, Harley S. (Counsel for Respondent)
1071. Turner, Ashley (Counsel for Petitioner)
1072. Tyler, Richard J. (Counsel for Respondent)
1073. Tyner, Star Mishkel (Counsel for Respondent)
1074. UNICARE Health Plan of West Virginia, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
1075. UniCare Life & Health Insurance Company (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
1076. UNICARE National Services, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
1077. UniCare Specialty Services, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
1078. U.W. Clemon, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
1079. Umatilla Properties, LLC (Parent Corp of Recovery Village at Umatilla,
LLC) (Respondent)
CIP-59 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 69 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
1080. USAble Mutual Insurance Company, d/b/a Arkansas Blue Cross and Blue
Shield (Petitioner)
1081. U.S. Imaging Network, LLC (Respondent)
1082. UTIC Insurance Company (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1083. Van Winkle Law Firm (Counsel for Respondent)
1084. Van Zant, Jennifer K. (Counsel for Petitioner)
1085. Vardas, Angel (Respondent)
1086. Varney, Christine (Counsel for Petitioner)
1087. Vaughan Pools, Inc. (Respondent)
1088. Ver Ploeg & Lumpkin, PA (Counsel for Respondent)
1089. Vermont Health Plan LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1090. VHP Insurance Solutions, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1091. Vibra Health Plan Holdings, LLC (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1092. Vibra Health Plan, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1093. Visiant Holdings Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1094. Voegele, Jonathan R. (Counsel for Respondent)
1095. Volunteer State Health Plan, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1096. Voorhees, Hon. Richard (W.D.N.C.)
1097. Wadsworth, Stephen D. (Counsel for Petitioner)
CIP-60 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 70 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
1098. Waldman Trigoboff Hildebrandt Marx & Calnan, PA (Counsel for
Respondent)
1099. Wall, Keynen J. (Counsel for Respondent)
1100. Wallace, Jordan, Ratliff & Brandt, LLC (Counsel for Petitioner)
1101. Walsh, Stephen A. (Counsel for Petitioner)
1102. Walters Bender Strohbehn & Vaughan, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
1103. Wandro & Associates, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
1104. Wandro, Steven P. (Counsel for Respondent)
1105. Wasser, Bradley A. (Counsel for Respondent)
1106. Wasvary, Mark K. (Counsel for Respondent)
1107. Watkins, Charles R. (Counsel for Respondent)
1108. Watson Jr., Herman (Counsel for Respondent)
1109. Watson McKinney LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
1110. Watts, Brett (Respondent)
1111. Weaver, D.P.M., Benjamin W. (Respondent)
1112. Webster, J. Harland (Counsel for Respondent)
1113. Weinshall, Matthew P. (Counsel for Respondent)
1114. Weiser, Robert (Counsel for Respondent)
1115. Weiser Law Firm, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
1116. Wellmark Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Iowa (Petitioner)
CIP-61 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 71 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
1117. Wellmark Blue Cross and Blue Shield of South Dakota (Petitioner)
1118. Wellmark Health Plan of Iowa, Inc. (Petitioner)
1119. Wellmark Holdings, Inc. (Petitioner)
1120. Wellmark Inc. d/b/a Wellmark Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Iowa and
Wellmark Health Plan of Iowa, Inc. (Petitioner)
1121. Wellmark of South Dakota, Inc. d/b/a Wellmark Blue Cross and Blue
Shield of South Dakota (Petitioner)
1122. Wellmark Synergy Health, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1123. Wellmark Value Health Plan, Inc. (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1124. Wellmark, Inc. d/b/a Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Iowa (Petitioner)
1125. Wellmark, Inc. d/b/a Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Iowa and Wellmark
Blue Cross Blue Shield of South Dakota (Petitioner)
1126. WellPoint California Services, Inc. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
1127. WellPoint Dental Services, Inc.
1128. WellPoint Holding Corp. (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
1129. WellPoint, Inc. (Petitioner)
1130. WellPoint Information Technology Services, Inc. (Subsidiary of
Petitioner)
1131. West, Kimberly R. (Counsel for Petitioner)
1132. Whatley Kallas, LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-62 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 72 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
1133. Whatley, Jr., Joe R. (Counsel for Respondent)
1134. White Arnold & Dowd, P.C. (Counsel for Respondent)
1135. White, J. Mark (Counsel for Respondent)
1136. Whitfield Bryson & Mason, LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
1137. Wiggins Childs Pantazis Fisher Goldfarb (Counsel for Respondent)
1138. Wiggins Childs Quinn & Pantazis, LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
1139. Wilkerson, David M. (Counsel for Respondent)
1140. Williams, Jennifer (Counsel for Respondent)
1141. Williams, Jr., James T. (Counsel for Petitioner)
1142. Winecoff, D.C., Ben (Respondent)
1143. Winegard, Deborah J. (Counsel for Respondent)
1144. Wisconsin Collaborative Insurance Company (Subsidiary of Petitioner)
1145. Witt, P.C., Helen E. (Counsel for Petitioner)
1146. Wojtalewicz Law Firm, LTD. (Counsel for Respondent)
1147. Wojtalewicz, Brian E. (Counsel for Respondent)
1148. Wolfe Pincavage (Counsel for Respondent)
1149. Wolfe, Douglas A. (Counsel for Respondent)
1150. Wolfla, Paul A. (Counsel for Petitioner)
1151. Wood Law Firm LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
1152. Wood, Jr., E. Kirk (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-63 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 73 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
1153. Woodbridge SA Services, Inc. (Respondent)
1154. Woodward Straits Insurance Company (Affiliate of Petitioner)
1155. Wotring, Earnest W. (Counsel for Respondent)
1156. Wright Schimmel LLC (Counsel for Respondent)
1157. Wright, Gene (Counsel for Respondent)
1158. Wright, Greg (Counsel for Respondent)
1159. WV Medical Services, Inc. (Respondent)
1160. Wylie, John R. (Counsel for Respondent)
1161. XL Group Ltd. (XL) (Petitioner’s Insurer)
1162. XL Catlin (Petitioner’s Insurer)
1163. Yancey, Perry Michael (Counsel for Respondent)
1164. Yinger, Emily M. (Counsel for Petitioner)
1165. Young, Lance C. (Counsel for Respondent)
1166. Yuhl Carr (Counsel for Respondent)
1167. Zeiger, P.C., Jeffrey J. (Counsel for Petitioner)
1168. Zimmerman Reed, PLLP (Counsel for Respondent)
1169. Zimmerman, Genevieve M. (Counsel for Respondent)
1170. Zolner, Erica B. (Counsel for Petitioner)
1171. Zott, P.C., David J. (Counsel for Petitioner)
1172. Zuckerman Spaeder LLP (Counsel for Respondent)
CIP-64 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 74 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
1173. Zuger, Peter W. (Counsel for Petitioner)
1174. Zurich Insurance Group Ltd. (ZURN) (Petitioner’s Insurer)
Corporate Disclosure. Pursuant to Fed. R. App. P. 26.1 and 11th Cir. R. 26.1-
1, 26.102, and 26.1-3, Petitioners respectfully submit this Corporate Disclosure
Statement and state as follows:
1. Anthem, Inc. (ANTM), f/k/a Wellpoint, Inc., has no parent corporation and
no publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
2. Anthem Blue Cross Life and Health Insurance Company is a wholly-
owned subsidiary of WellPoint California Services, Inc., which is a
wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem Holding Corp., which is a wholly-
owned subsidiary of Anthem, Inc. Anthem, Inc. has no publicly held
corporation that owns ten percent or more of its stock.
3. Anthem Health Plans, Inc., d/b/a Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield of
Connecticut, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of ATH Holding Company,
LLC, which is wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem, Inc. Anthem, Inc. has
no publicly held corporation that owns ten percent or more of its stock.
4. Anthem Health Plans of Kentucky, Inc., d/b/a Anthem Blue Cross and Blue
Shield of Kentucky, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of ATH Holding
Company, LLC, which is wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem, Inc.
CIP-65 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 75 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
Anthem, Inc. has no publicly held corporation that owns ten percent or
more of its stock.
5. Anthem Health Plans of Maine, Inc., d/b/a Anthem Blue Cross and Blue
Shield of Maine, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of ATH Holding Company,
LLC, which is wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem, Inc. Anthem, Inc. has
no publicly held corporation that owns ten percent or more of its stock.
6. Anthem Health Plans of New Hampshire, Inc., d/b/a Anthem Blue Cross
and Blue Shield of New Hampshire, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of ATH
Holding Company, LLC, which is wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem,
Inc. Anthem, Inc. has no publicly held corporation that owns ten percent
or more of its stock.
7. Anthem Health Plans of Virginia, Inc., d/b/a Anthem Blue Cross and Blue
Shield of Virginia, Inc., is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem
Southeast, Inc., which is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem,
Inc. Anthem, Inc. has no publicly held corporation that owns ten percent
or more of its stock.
8. Anthem Holding Corp. is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem,
Inc. Anthem, Inc. has no publicly held corporation that owns ten percent
or more of its stock.
CIP-66 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 76 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
9. Anthem Insurance Companies, Inc., d/b/a Anthem Blue Cross and Blue
Shield of Indiana, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem, Inc. Anthem,
Inc. has no publicly held corporation that owns ten percent or more of its
stock.
10. Anthem Life Insurance Company is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Rocky
Mountain Hospital and Medical Services, which is a wholly-owned
subsidiary of ATH Holding Company, LLC, which is wholly-owned
subsidiary of Anthem, Inc. Anthem, Inc. has no publicly held corporation
that owns ten percent or more of its stock.
11. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Alabama has no parent corporation and no
publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
12. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona has no parent corporation and no
publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
13. Blue Cross Blue Shield Association has no parent corporation and no
publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
14. Blue Cross of California, d/b/a Anthem Blue Cross, is a wholly-owned
subsidiary of WellPoint California Services, Inc., which is a wholly-owned
subsidiary of Anthem Holding Corp., which is a wholly-owned subsidiary
of Anthem, Inc. Anthem, Inc. has no publicly held corporation that owns
ten percent or more of its stock.
CIP-67 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 77 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
15. Blue Cross of California Partnership Plan, Inc. is a wholly-owned
subsidiary of Blue Cross of California, which is a wholly-owned subsidiary
of WellPoint California Services, Inc., which is a wholly-owned subsidiary
of Anthem Holding Corp., which is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem,
Inc. Anthem, Inc. has no publicly held corporation that owns ten percent
or more of its stock.
16. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Florida, Inc., d/b/a Florida Blue, is a
wholly-owned subsidiary of GuideWell Mutual Holding Corporation, a
not-for-profit corporation with no parent corporation. No publicly held
corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
17. Blue Cross Blue Shield Healthcare Plan of Georgia, Inc., d/b/a Blue Cross
and Blue Shield of Georgia, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Cerulean
Companies, Inc., which is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem Holding
Corp., which is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem, Inc. Anthem, Inc.
has no publicly held corporation that owns ten percent or more of its stock.
18. Blue Cross of Idaho Health Service, Inc. has no parent corporation and no
publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
19. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas, Inc. has no parent corporation and
no publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
CIP-68 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 78 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
20. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City has no parent corporation and
no publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
21. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts, Inc. has no parent
corporation and no publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of
its stock.
22. BCBSM, Inc., d/b/a Blue Cross Blue Shield of Minnesota has as its parent
corporation Aware Integrated, Inc. Aware Integrated, Inc. has no parent
corporation and no publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of
its stock.
23. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan has no parent corporation and no
publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
24. Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Mississippi, A Mutual Insurance Company,
has no parent corporation and no publicly held corporation owns ten
percent or more of its stock.
25. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Nebraska has no parent corporation and no
publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
26. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina has no parent corporation
and no publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
27. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Rhode Island has no parent corporation and
no publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
CIP-69 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 79 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
28. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of South Carolina has no parent corporation
and no corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
29. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Tennessee has no parent corporation and
no publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
30. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Vermont has no parent corporation and no
publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
31. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Wisconsin, d/b/a Anthem Blue Cross and Blue
Shield of Wisconsin, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Crossroads
Acquisition Corp., which is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem
Holding Corp., which is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem,
Inc. Anthem, Inc. has no publicly held corporation that owns ten percent
or more of its stock.
32. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Wyoming has no parent corporation and no
publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
33. California Physicians’ Service, d/b/a Blue Shield of California, has no
parent corporation and no publicly held corporation owns ten percent or
more of its stock.
34. Cambia Health Solutions, Inc., f/k/a The Regence Group, Inc., has no
parent corporation and no publicly held corporation owns ten percent or
more of its stock.
CIP-70 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 80 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
35. CareFirst, Inc. has no parent corporation and no publicly held corporation
owns ten percent or more of its stock.
36. CareFirst BlueChoice, Inc. has as its parent corporation CareFirst
Holdings, LLC, which is jointly owned by Group Hospitalization and
Medical Services, Inc. and CareFirst of Maryland, Inc. No publicly held
corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
37. CareFirst of Maryland, Inc., d/b/a CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield, has as
its parent corporation CareFirst, Inc. No publicly held corporation owns
ten percent or more of its stock.
38. Caring for Montanans, Inc., f/k/a BlueCross BlueShield of Montana, has
no parent corporation and no publicly held corporation owns ten percent
or more of its stock.
39. Capital BlueCross has no parent corporation and no publicly held
corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
40. Community Insurance Company, d/b/a Anthem Blue Cross and Blue
Shield of Ohio, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of ATH Holding Company,
LLC, which is wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem, Inc. Anthem, Inc. has
no publicly held corporation that owns ten percent or more of its stock.
41. Compcare Health Services Insurance Corporation is a wholly-owned
subsidiary of Blue Cross Blue Shield of Wisconsin, which is a wholly-
CIP-71 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 81 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
owned subsidiary of Crossroads Acquisition Corp., which is a wholly-
owned subsidiary of Anthem Holding Corp., which is a wholly-owned
subsidiary of Anthem, Inc. Anthem, Inc. has no publicly held corporation
that owns ten percent or more of its stock.
42. Empire HealthChoice Assurance, Inc., d/b/a Empire BlueCross
BlueShield, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of WellPoint Holding, Corp.
which is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem, Inc. Anthem, Inc. has no
publicly held corporation that owns ten percent or more of its stock.
43. Excellus Healthcare, Inc., d/b/a Excellus BlueCross BlueShield, has as its
parent corporation Lifetime Healthcare, Inc. No publicly held corporation
owns ten percent or more of its stock.
44. Group Hospitalization and Medical Services, Inc., d/b/a CareFirst
BlueCross BlueShield, has as its parent corporation CareFirst, Inc. No
publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
45. Hawaii Medical Service Association, d/b/a Blue Cross and Blue Shield of
Hawaii, has no parent corporation and no publicly held corporation owns
ten percent or more of its stock.
46. Health Care Service Corporation (including its unincorporated divisions
Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois, Blue Cross and Blue Shield of
Montana, Blue Cross and Blue Shield of New Mexico, Blue Cross and
CIP-72 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 82 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
Blue Shield of Oklahoma, Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas) has no
parent corporation and no publicly held corporation owns ten percent or
more of its stock.
47. HealthNow New York Inc., d/b/a BlueCross BlueShield of Western New
York and BlueShield of Northeastern New York, has as its parent
corporation HealthNow Systems, Inc. HealthNow Systems, Inc. has no
parent corporation and no publicly held corporation owns ten percent or
more of its stock.
48. Healthy Alliance Life Insurance Company is a wholly-owned subsidiary
of RightCHOICE Managed Care, Inc., which is a wholly-owned subsidiary
of Anthem Holding Corp., which is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem,
Inc. Anthem, Inc. has no publicly held corporation that owns ten percent
or more of its stock.
49. Highmark Inc., f/k/a Highmark Health Services Inc., has as its parent
Highmark Health. No publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more
of its stock.
50. Highmark West Virginia Inc. is a controlled affiliate of Highmark Inc. No
publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
51. Highmark BCBSD Inc. is a controlled affiliate of Highmark Inc. No
publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
CIP-73 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 83 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
52. HMO Missouri, Inc., d/b/a Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield of
Missouri, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of RightCHOICE Managed Care,
Inc., which is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem Holding Corp., which
is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem, Inc. Anthem, Inc. has no
publicly held corporation that owns ten percent or more of its stock.
53. Horizon Healthcare Services, Inc., d/b/a Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield
of New Jersey, has no parent corporation and no publicly held corporation
owns ten percent or more of its stock.
54. Hospital Service Association of Northeastern Pennsylvania, d/b/a Blue
Cross of Northeastern Pennsylvania, merged into Highmark Inc. on June
1, 2015. No publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its
stock.
55. Independence Hospital Indemnity Plan, Inc., f/k/a Independence Blue
Cross, has Independence Health Group Inc. as its ultimate parent
corporation and no publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of
its stock.
56. Louisiana Health Service & Indemnity Company, d/b/a Blue Cross and
Blue Shield of Louisiana, has no parent corporation and no publicly held
corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
CIP-74 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 84 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
57. Noridian Mutual Insurance Company, d/b/a/ Blue Cross and Blue Shield
of North Dakota, has no parent corporation and no publicly held
corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
58. Premera Blue Cross, d/b/a/ as Premera Blue Cross Blue Shield of Alaska,
has no parent corporation and no publicly held corporation owns ten
percent or more of its stock.
59. RightCHOICE Managed Care, Inc. is a wholly-owned subsidiary of
Anthem Holding Corp., which is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Anthem,
Inc. Anthem, Inc. has no publicly held corporation that owns ten percent
or more of its stock.
60. Regence BlueShield has as its parent corporation Regence Insurance
Holding Corporation, which has Cambia Health Solutions, Inc. as its
parent. Cambia Health Solutions, Inc. has no publicly held corporation that
owns ten percent or more of its stock.
61. Regence BlueShield of Idaho, Inc. is controlled by Cambia Health
Solutions, Inc. Cambia Health Solutions, Inc. has no publicly held
corporation that owns ten percent or more of its stock.
62. Regence BlueShield of Oregon, Inc. has as its parent corporation Regence
Insurance Holding Corporation, which has Cambia Health Solutions, Inc.
CIP-75 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 85 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
as it parent. Cambia Health Solutions, Inc. has no publicly held corporation
that owns ten percent or more of its stock.
63. Regence BlueCross BlueShield of Utah has as its parent corporation
Regence Insurance Holding Corporation, which has Cambia Health
Solutions, Inc. as it parent. Cambia Health Solutions, Inc. has no publicly
held corporation that owns ten percent or more of its stock.
64. Rocky Mountain Hospital and Medical Service, Inc., d/b/a/ Anthem Blue
Cross and Blue Shield of Colorado in Colorado and d/b/a Anthem Blue
Cross and Blue Shield of Nevada in Nevada, is a wholly-owned subsidiary
of ATH Holding Company, LLC, which is wholly-owned subsidiary of
Anthem, Inc. Anthem, Inc. has no publicly held corporation that owns ten
percent or more of its stock.
65. Triple-S Salud, Inc. (GTS) has as its parent corporation Triple-S
Management Corporation. No publicly held corporation owns ten percent
or more of its stock.
66. USAble Mutual Insurance Company, d/b/a Arkansas Blue Cross and Blue
Shield, has no parent corporation and no publicly held corporation owns
ten percent or more of its stock.
CIP-76 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 86 of 100 No. 18-90020, In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation
67. Wellmark Inc., d/b/a Wellmark Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Iowa, has
no parent corporation and no publicly held corporation owns ten percent
or more of its stock.
68. Wellmark of South Dakota, Inc., d/b/a Wellmark Blue Cross and Blue
Shield of South Dakota, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Wellmark,
Inc. No publicly held corporation owns ten percent or more of its stock.
July 9, 2018
s/Paul D. Clement PAUL D. CLEMENT Counsel of Record KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP 655 Fifteenth Street, NW Washington, DC 20005 (202) 879-5000 [email protected]
CIP-77 of 77
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 87 of 100
Petitioners respectfully move for leave to file the attached reply brief in
support of their petition for permission to appeal under Rule 5 and 28 U.S.C.
§1292(b). Both of the respondents’ briefs rely repeatedly on Ohio v. American
Express Co., 2018 WL 3096305 (June 25, 2018), a Supreme Court decision that
came out after petitioners filed their petition for permission to appeal. Accepting
petitioner’s short proposed reply brief will ensure that petitioners have a chance to
respond to respondents’ contention regarding American Express. A short reply brief
will also assist the Court in assessing respondents’ mistaken contentions that review
of the district court’s standard of review ruling would require delving into
unresolved factual disputes, and their unsustainable claims that immediate review
would not materially advance the litigation.
Courts have regularly granted similar motions, even without the presence of
an intervening Supreme Court decision. See, e.g., Kaur v. Things Remembered, Inc.,
829 F.3d 1117, 1117 (9th Cir. 2016); Lincoln Nat’l Life Ins. Co. v. Bezich, 610 F.3d
448, 449 (7th Cir. 2010); see also Ga. Power Co. v. NLRB, 484 F.3d 1288, 1292
(11th Cir. 2007). There is good reason to do so here as well.
For the foregoing reasons, petitioners respectfully request that this Court grant the motion and order that the attached reply brief be filed.
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 88 of 100
Respectfully submitted,
s/Paul D. Clement PAUL D. CLEMENT Counsel of Record Erin E. Murphy C Harker Rhodes IV KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP 655 Fifteenth Street, NW Washington, DC 20005 (202) 879-5000 [email protected] Counsel for Petitioner Blue Cross Blue Shield Association Craig A. Hoover David J. Zott, P.C. E. Desmond Hogan Daniel E. Laytin, P.C. Catherine E. Stetson Sarah J. Donnell Justin W. Bernick Christa C. Cottrell, P.C. HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP Zachary Holmstead Columbia Square KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP 555 13th Street, N.W. 300 North LaSalle Washington, DC 20004 Chicago, IL 60654 Tel: (202) 637-5600 Tel: (312) 862-2000 Fax: (202) 637-5910 Fax: (312) 862-2200 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
Co-Coordinating Counsel for the Petitioners
2
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 89 of 100
Emily M. Yinger Kimberly R. West (Liaison Counsel) N. Thomas Connally, III Mark M. Hogewood HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP WALLACE, JORDAN, RATLIFF & Park Place II BRANDT, LLC 7930 Jones Branch Drive, 9th Floor First Commercial Bank Building McLean, VA 22102 800 Shades Creek Parkway, Suite 400 Tel: (703) 610-6100 Birmingham, AL 35209 Fax: (703) 610-6200 Tel: (205) 870-0555 [email protected] Fax: (205) 871-7534 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Co-Coordinating Counsel for the Petitioners Petitioners’ Liaison Counsel
Cavender C. Kimble With Kirkland & Ellis LLP, counsel Ed R. Haden for Petitioner Blue Cross Blue Shield BALCH & BINGHAM LLP Association 1901 6th Avenue North, Suite 1500 Birmingham, AL 35203-4642 James L. Priester Tel: (205) 226-3437 Carl S. Burkhalter Fax: (205) 488-5860 John Thomas A. Malatesta, III [email protected] MAYNARD COOPER & GALE PC 1901 6th Avenue North, Suite 2400 Regions Harbert Plaza Birmingham, AL 35203 Tel: (205) 254-1000 Fax: (205) 254-1999 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
3
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 90 of 100
John Martin Pamela B. Slate Lucile H. Cohen HILL HILL CARTER FRANCO NELSON MULLINS COLE & BLACK, P.C. RILEY & 425 South Perry Street SCARBOROUGH LLP Montgomery, AL 36104 1320 Main Street, 17th Floor Tel: (334) 834-7600 Columbia, SC 29201 Fax: (334) 386-4381 Tel: (803) 255-9421 [email protected] Fax: (803) 256-7500 [email protected] Counsel for Petitioner [email protected] Blue Cross Blue Shield of Alabama
With Hogan Lovells, counsel for Helen E. Witt, P.C. Petitioners Anthem, Inc., f/k/a WellPoint, Jeffrey J. Zeiger, P.C. Inc., and all of its named subsidiaries in Erica B. Zolner this consolidated action; Blue Cross and Casey R. Fronk Blue Shield of North Carolina, Inc.; Blue KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP Cross and Blue Shield of Florida, Inc.; 300 North LaSalle Louisiana Health Service & Indemnity Chicago, IL 60654 Company (Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Tel: (312) 862-2000 Louisiana); Blue Cross and Blue Shield Fax: (312) 862-2200 of Massachusetts, Inc.; BCBSM, Inc. [email protected] (Blue Cross and Blue Shield of [email protected] Minnesota); Blue Cross and Blue Shield [email protected] of South Carolina; Horizon Healthcare [email protected] Services, Inc. (Horizon Blue Cross and Blue Shield of New Jersey); Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Rhode Island; Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Vermont; Cambia Health Solutions, Inc.; Regence Blue Shield of Idaho; Regence Blue Cross Blue Shield of Utah; Regence Blue Shield (of Washington); Regence Blue Cross Blue Shield of Oregon
4
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 91 of 100
Gwendolyn Payton Kimberly R. West (Liaison Counsel) KILPATRICK TOWNSEND & Mark M. Hogewood STOCKTON LLP WALLACE, JORDAN, RATLIFF & 1420 Fifth Avenue, Suite 3700 BRANDT, LLC Seattle, WA 98101 First Commercial Bank Building Tel: (206) 626-7714 800 Shades Creek Parkway, Suite 400 Fax: (206) 299-0414 Birmingham, AL 35209 [email protected] Tel: (205) 870-0555 Fax: (205) 871-7534 Adam Charnes [email protected] KILPATRICK TOWNSEND & [email protected] STOCKTON LLP 2001 Ross Avenue, Suite 4400 Counsel for Petitioners Health Care Dallas, TX 75201 Service Corporation, an Illinois Mutual Tel: 214 922 7106 Legal Reserve Company, including its Fax: 214 481 0517 divisions Blue Cross and Blue Shield of [email protected] Illinois, Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas, Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Counsel for Petitioners Premera Blue New Mexico, Blue Cross and Blue Cross d/b/a Premera Blue Cross Blue Shield of Oklahoma, and Blue Cross Shield of Alaska; Premera Blue Cross of and Blue Shield of Montana; Caring for Washington Montanans, Inc., f/k/a Blue Cross and Brian K. Norman Blue Shield of Montana, Inc.; Highmark SHAMOUN & NORMAN, LLP Inc., f/k/a Highmark Health Services; 1800 Valley View Lane, Suite 200 Highmark West Virginia Inc.; Farmers Branch, TX 75234 Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield Tel: (214) 987-1745 Delaware Inc.; California Physicians’ Fax: (214) 521-9033 Service d/b/a Blue Shield of California [email protected]
5
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 92 of 100
H. James Koch Jonathan M. Redgrave ARMBRECHT JACKSON LLP Victoria A. Redgrave RSA Tower, 27th Floor REDGRAVE, LLP 11 North Water Street 14555 Avion Parkway, Suite 275 Mobile, AL 36602 Chantilly, VA 20151 Tel: (251) 405-1300 Tel: (703) 592-1155 Fax: (251) 432-6843 Fax: (612) 332-8915 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Counsel for Petitioners Carefirst, Inc.; Carefirst of Maryland, Inc.; Group Additional Counsel for HCSC and Hospitalization and Medical Services, Highmark Petitioners Inc.; CareFirst BlueChoice, Inc. Charles L. Sweeris Rafael Escalera Law Department Rodríguez BLUE SHIELD OF CALIFORNIA Sylmarie Arizmendi 50 Beale Street Gustavo A. Pabón Rico San Francisco, CA 94105 REICHARD & ESCALERA, LLC Tel: (415) 229-5107 255 Ponce de León Avenue Fax: (415) 229-5343 MCS Plaza, 10th Floor charles.sweeris@blueshield San Juan, PR 00917-1913 ca.com Tel.: (787) 777-8888 Fax: (787) 765-4225 Counsel for Petitioner California [email protected] Physicians’ Service d/b/a Blue Shield of [email protected] California [email protected] Todd Stenerson Counsel for Petitioner Triple-S Salud, SHEARMAN & STERLING LLP Inc. 401 9th Street, N.W., Suite 800 Washington, DC 20004-2128 Tel: (202) 508-8000 Fax: (202) 508-8100 [email protected]
6
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 93 of 100
R. David Kaufman Sarah L. Cylkowski M. Patrick McDowell Thomas J. Rheaume, Jr. BRUNINI, GRANTHAM, GROWER BODMAN PLC & HEWES, PLLC 1901 Saint Antoine Street 190 East Capitol Street 6th Floor at Ford Field The Pinnacle Building, Suite 100 Detroit, MI 48226 Jackson, MS 39201 Tel: (313) 259-7777 Tel: (601) 948-3101 Fax: (734) 930-2494 Fax: (601) 960-6902 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Andy P. Campbell John Martin Stephen D. Wadsworth Lucile H. Cohen A. Todd Campbell NELSON MULLINS Yawanna N. McDonald RILEY & CAMPBELL GUIN, LLC SCARBOROUGH LLP 505 20th Street North, Suite 1600 1320 Main Street, 17th Floor Birmingham, AL 35203 Columbia, SC 29201 Tel: (205) 224-0750 Tel: (803) 255-9421 Fax: (205) 224-8622 Fax: (803) 256-7500 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Cheri D. Green BLUE CROSS & BLUE SHIELD OF Counsel for Petitioner Blue Cross and MISSISSIPPI, A MUTUAL Blue Shield of Michigan INSURANCE COMPANY P.O. Box 1043 Jackson, MS 39215 Tel: (601) 932-3704 [email protected]
Counsel for Petitioner Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Mississippi, A Mutual Insurance Company
7
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 94 of 100
Michael A. Naranjo John Briggs FOLEY & LARDNER LLP Rachel Adcox 555 California Street, Suite 1700 AXINN, VELTROP & HARKRIDER, San Francisco, CA 94104-1520 LLP Tel: (415) 984-9847 950 F Street, N.W. Fax: (415) 434-4507 Washington, DC 20004 [email protected] Tel: (202) 912-4700 Fax: (202) 912-4701 Alan D. Rutenberg [email protected] Benjamin R. Dryden [email protected] FOLEY & LARDNER LLP 3000 K Street, N.W., Suite 600 Stephen A. Rowe Washington, D.C. 20007-5109 Aaron G. McLeod Tel: (202) 672-5300 ADAMS AND REESE LLP Fax: (202) 672-5399 Regions Harbert Plaza [email protected] 1901 6th Avenue North, Suite 3000 [email protected] Birmingham, AL 35203 Tel: (205) 250-5000 Counsel for Petitioner USAble Mutual Fax: (205) 250-5034 Insurance Company, d/b/a Arkansas Blue [email protected] Cross and Blue Shield [email protected]
Counsel for Petitioner Independence Blue Cross
Edward S. Bloomberg John G. Schmidt Anna Mercado Clark PHILLIPS LYTLE LLP One Canalside 125 Main Street Buffalo, NY 14203 Tel: (716) 847-8400 Fax: (716) 852-6100 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
8
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 95 of 100
Robert K. Spotswood Stephen A. Walsh Michael T. Sansbury ADAMS AND REESE LLP Joshua K. Payne 1901 Sixth Avenue North, Suite 3000 Jess R. Nix Birmingham, AL 35203 Mary G. Menge Tel: (205) 250-5000 Morgan B. Franz Fax: (205) 250-5091 SPOTSWOOD SANSOM & [email protected] SANSBURY LLC One Federal Place Counsel for Petitioner Excellus Health 1819 5th Avenue North, Suite 1050 Plan, Inc., d/b/a Excellus BlueCross Birmingham, AL 35203 BlueShield, incorrectly sued as Tel: (205) 986-3620 Excellus BlueCross BlueShield of Fax: (205) 986-3639 New York [email protected] [email protected] Kathleen Taylor Sooy [email protected] Tracy A. Roman [email protected] April N. Ross [email protected] Michael W. Lieberman [email protected] CROWELL & MORING LLP 1001 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. Counsel for Petitioner Capital BlueCross Washington, D.C. 20004 Tel: (202) 624-2500 Christine Varney Fax: (202) 628-5116 Evan Chesler [email protected] Karin DeMasi [email protected] Lauren Kennedy [email protected] CRAVATH SWAINE & MOORE [email protected] 825 8th Avenue New York, NY 10019 Tel: (212) 474-1000 Fax: (212) 474-3700 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
9
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 96 of 100
Robert R. Riley, Jr. John M. Johnson RILEY & JACKSON, P.C. Brian P. Kappel 3530 Independence Drive LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE Birmingham, AL 35209 LLC Tel: (205) 879-5000 The Clark Building Fax: (205) 879-5901 400 20th Street North [email protected] Birmingham, AL 35203 Tel: (205) 581-0700 Counsel for Petitioner Blue Cross and Fax: (205) 581-0799 Blue Shield of Tennessee, Inc. [email protected] [email protected] David J. Zott, P.C. Daniel E. Laytin, P.C. Counsel for Petitioners Blue Cross of KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP Idaho Health Service, Inc.; Blue Cross 300 North LaSalle and Blue Shield of Kansas, Inc.; Blue Chicago, IL 60654 Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City; Tel: (312) 862-2000 Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Fax: (312) 862-2200 Nebraska; Blue Cross Blue Shield of [email protected] Arizona; Blue Cross Blue Shield of [email protected] North Dakota; Blue Cross Blue Shield of Wyoming; HealthNow New York Kimberly R. West (Liaison Counsel) Inc.; BlueShield of Northeastern New Mark M. Hogewood York; BlueCross BlueShield of Western WALLACE, JORDAN, RATLIFF & New York BRANDT, LLC First Commercial Bank Building 800 Shades Creek Parkway, Suite 400 Birmingham, AL 35209 Tel: (205) 870-0555 Fax: (205) 871-7534 [email protected] [email protected]
10
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 97 of 100
John Martin Lucile H. Cohen NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH LLP 1320 Main Street, 17th Floor Columbia, SC 29201 Tel: (803) 255-9421 Fax: (803) 256-7500 [email protected] [email protected]
Counsel for Petitioners Wellmark of South Dakota, Inc. (Wellmark Blue Cross and Blue Shield of South Dakota); Wellmark, Inc. (Wellmark Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Iowa; Hawaii Medical Service Association (Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Hawaii)
11
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 98 of 100
CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE 1. This motion complies with the type-volume limitation of Fed. R. App. P.
27(d)(2)(A) because this motion contains 217 words, excluding the parts of the motion exempted by Fed. R. App. P. 32(f) and 11th Cir. R. 32-4.
2. This brief complies with the typeface requirements of Fed. R. App. P.
32(a)(5) and the type style requirements of Fed. R. App. P. 32(a)(6), because it has been prepared in a proportionally spaced typeface using Microsoft Word 2016 in 14- point Times New Roman type.
July 9, 2018
s/Paul D. Clement Paul D. Clement
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 99 of 100
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on July 9, 2018, I electronically filed the foregoing with the Clerk of the Court for the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit by using the CM/ECF system. I certify that all CM/ECF registered participants were served via the CM/ECF system and that copies were sent to the following via
U.S. First Class Mail and electronic mail:
Barry A. Ragsdale Greg Wright SIROTE & PERMUTT PC WRIGHT SCHIMMEL LLC 2311 Highland Avenue South 6900 College Boulevard, Suite 285 P.O. Box 55727 Overland Park, KS 66211 Birmingham, AL 35255-5727 [email protected] [email protected]
Kara Marie Simons Stephen B. Murray, Jr. WANDRO & ASSOCIATES, P.C. MURRAY LAW FIRM 2501 Grand Avenue, Suite B 650 Poydras Street, Suite 2150 Des Moines, IA 50312 New Orleans, LA 70130 [email protected] [email protected]
Andrew M. Stone Ami Swank STONE LAW FIRM LLC AMI SWANK LAW FIRM 437 Grant Street, Suite 1806 811 Timberdell Road Pittsburgh, PA 15219 Norman, OK 73072 [email protected] [email protected]
Annesley H. DeGaris Lee McArthur Scott DEGARIS AND ROGERS, LLC 602 Harrison Avenue, Suite III 420 20th Street North Suite 2200 Panama City, FL 32401 Birmingham, AL 35203 [email protected] [email protected]
Case: 18-90020 Date Filed: 07/09/2018 Page: 100 of 100
Andrew England Brashier Clint Sargent BEASLEY ALLEN CROW MEIERHENRY SARGENT LLP METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC 315 S. Phillips Avenue P.O. Box 4160 Sioux Falls, SD 57104-6318 Montgomery, AL 36104 [email protected] [email protected]
Anthony F. Jackson BECK & AMSDEN 1946 Stadium Drive, Suite 1 Bozeman, MT 59715 [email protected]
s/Paul D. Clement Paul D. Clement