An Assessment of the Strength of Knots and Splices Used As Eye Terminations in a Sailing Environment

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

An Assessment of the Strength of Knots and Splices Used As Eye Terminations in a Sailing Environment 9.1.1 Sports E77 McLaren 27/7/06 2:38 pm Page 1 An assessment of the strength of knots and splices used as eye terminations in a sailing environment K.A. Milne and A.J. McLaren Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, UK Abstract Research into knots, splices and other methods of forming an eye termination has been limited, despite the fact that they are essential and strongly affect the performance of a rope. The aim of this study was to carry out a comprehensive initial assessment of the breaking strength of eye ter- minations commonly used in a sailing environment, thereby providing direction for further work in the field. Supports for use in a regular tensile testing machine were specially developed to allow indi- vidual testing of each sample and a realistic spread of statistical data to be obtained. Over 180 break tests were carried out on four knots (the bowline, double bowline, figure-of-eight loop and perfection loop) and two splices (three-strand eye splice and braid-on-braid splice). The factors affecting their strength were investigated. A statistical approach to the analysis of the results was adopted. The type of knot was found to have a significant effect on the strength. This same effect was seen in both types of rope construction (three-strand and braid-on-braid). Conclusions were also drawn as to the effect of splice length, eye size, manufacturer and rope diameter on the breaking strength of splices. Areas of development and further investigation were identified. Keywords: break, knot, rope, sailing, splice, strength Introduction such as guard rails which are present for reasons of safety. The running rigging is used to hoist and/or Ropes are widely exploited in sailing. Their use on control the sails. Halyards are used to hoist the sails yachts may be broadly divided into two categories, into position; sheets are attached to the sails and are namely the standing and running rigging. Standing used primarily to control the angle of the sails to the rigging consists of the structural components that boat’s centreline, and therefore the wind. The running support the mast and spars, together with equipment rigging will also generally include ropes that are used to control the position of moveable components of the Correspondence address: boat, which are used for fine adjustment of the sails. Dr. A.J. McLaren Many different methods have evolved that allow Department of Mechanical Engineering one rope to be attached to another, to a fixed point or University of Strathclyde to a sail. One common method is to create an eye with Glasgow UK a knot, or a splice, or by binding or stitching the end of Tel: +44 (0) 141 548 3104 the rope to the standing part with twine. This last E-mail: [email protected] method is called seizing. A knot is defined as ‘a way of 1 9.1.1 Sports E77 McLaren 27/7/06 2:38 pm Page 2 The strength of knots and splices K.A. Milne and A.J. McLaren joining or securing lengths of rope, thread, or other strand is discussed by Saitta et al. (1999). This is more strands by tying the material together or around of interest to the polymer scientist due to the micro- itself’. A splice is defined as a way ‘to join ends of ropes scopic scale of the fibres in question. Wu (1993) by intertwining strands’. Unlike knots, a specific splice considered friction and slippage between the strands is suitable only for a specific type of rope. of polymeric ropes, and made some observations con- The ropes used in sailing are similar in appearance cerning slippage in end terminations. to those utilised by climbers, but the materials used A particular method for forming an eye termination are different. Climbing ropes are designed to absorb might be selected because it is easy to form or release, shock loads in the event of a fall, and are of relatively because it holds securely, because it is compact and low stiffness. By contrast, sailing ropes need to have will slide over apparatus easily, or because it is consid- high stiffness to preserve precise control by minimis- ered relatively strong. The presence of the eye ing elastic extension. Whereas it is generally accepted termination can have a significant effect upon the that climbing ropes do not fail, either at a knot, or fatigue life of a line, its response under dynamic generally, unless loaded over an edge (Schubert, 2002; loading and its static breaking load. While much Bailie, 2000), sailing ropes are subject to failure, par- experimental and analytical work has been conducted ticularly near the ends where high degrees of wear and upon synthetic ropes, knowledge about eye termina- chafe are possible during extended use. In addition, tions is limited. Advice on how to create eye sailing ropes are subjected to high static loadings, terminations is generally based upon one-off tests or upon which considerable dynamic fluctuations are tradition. There is no definitive guide about which superimposed. These ropes are also prone to ultra knot to choose or how to form a splice in order to get violet attack due to prolonged exposure in the marine the highest splice efficiency, which is defined as the environment. ratio of the breaking strength with the eye to the rope A wealth of information has been published con- strength. cerning the suitability of the various methods of Limited mathematical modelling has been carried forming a loop termination. This information is out. Maddocks & Keller (1987) propound the available in books specifically dedicated to knots and mechanics of some simple hitches while Leech (2003) splices, e.g. Jarman (2000), Shaw (2004), and Pawson models the stresses in some commonly used splices. (2001). It may also be found in standard sailing However, such models are founded upon numerous textbooks (Cunliffe, 2000). Recent articles in the assumptions and, although they help to understand sailing press demonstrate the continuous development the mechanics involved, they do not provide accurate of ropes and splicing techniques (James, 2003; predictions of the breaking loads or the effect of Pawson, 2005). changing one of the huge number of variables, such as The published research on polymeric ropes is the maker of the eye (referred to hereafter as the man- somewhat limited. Manes (2002) has reviewed work ufacturer), rope type, eye size, length of the working carried out on the structure of ropes for rock climbing. end or the type of loading. This project has attempted Leech (2002) considers the hierarchical structure built to carry out an assessment of the static strength of up from individual strands, bundles, and sub-ropes, to knots and splices used in a sailing environment and the make the overall cable. He also considers the frictional factors that affect this strength. load transfer between the elements of the rope. Pan & The aim of this study was to carry out a compre- Brookstein (2002) have reviewed the recent work that hensive preliminary assessment of the static breaking has been carried out on the modelling of polymer strength of several common eye terminations. These ropes. included four knots – the bowline, double bowline, The theory of knots has stimulated some interest in perfection loop and figure-of-eight loop – and two the mathematics community. This is typified by the splices – the three-strand eye splice and the braid-on- Fields Medal winning work of Vaughan Jones, as braid splice. The effect of various factors upon the reviewed by King (1986). At a fundamental level, the breaking strength of the line was investigated and the effect of a knot on the strength of a single polymer practical relevance of the results discussed. 2 9.1.1 Sports E77 McLaren 27/7/06 2:38 pm Page 3 K.A. Milne and A.J. McLaren The strength of knots and splices Experimental procedure three-strand eye splice was manufactured from the pre-stretched rope while a braid-on-braid splice was This section describes the programme of experimental manufactured from the braid-on-braid rope. The eye work. First, the determination of the initial baseline size was defined as the inside length of the eye, strength of each rope type and diameter is described. measured with a flexible tape. The working end is the Secondly, the preparation of knots and the method by unloaded end of the rope. which eye splices were prepared, using the specific All knot and splice samples were finished in the method appropriate to each rope type, is discussed. same manner. A mark was made 1.3 m along the Thirdly, the apparatus used to test the loops is standing part of the rope, measuring from the crotch detailed. Finally, the procedure used to test the of the eye. The rope was whipped either side of the strength of the knots and splices, and the means by mark, cut and the end sealed by melting. which data were recorded, is reviewed. Knots Determination of rope strength The four knots investigated were the bowline, double Two different commercially available types of rope bowline, figure-of-eight loop and perfection loop, were used to make the knots and splices. Both rope shown in Fig. 1. Each sample was prepared with a types were manufactured by Liros Ropes Ltd 100 mm working end and a 150 mm internal eye size. (Germany). The first was a 16-plait braid-on-braid polyester rope, sold as the LIROS Top Cruising rope. Three-strand eye splice The second was a three-strand twisted pre-stretched polyester rope, sold as the LIROS Prestretch rope.
Recommended publications
  • Introduction
    CHAPTER 1: Basic information and techniques INTRODUCTION Fish aggregating devices, or FADs, are floating rafts or buoys anchored in deep water which, for reasons not yet fully understood, cause tuna and other types of oceanic fish to gather around them. FADs were first introduced into Pacific Island countries and territories in the late 1970s, and are likely to be a continuing feature of fisheries development in the region. The introduction and growing use of FADs have opened up new fishing opportunities for the region’s fishermen, but in many cases these have not yet been taken full advantage of. Fishermen are often unaware of the potential yields that can be generated by fishing around FADs, and may not know of suitable fishing techniques or have access to the right gear and equipment. SPC Masterfishermen working on fisheries development projects in the region were some of the first to begin adapting fishing gear and principles to the special conditions of FADs in order to help small-scale fishermen benefit from this new resource. Combining the principles of traditional mid-water tuna handlining and industrial tuna longlining, they began to experiment with multi-hook mainlines set around FADs. These ‘vertical longlines’ were fished directly from the boat, tied off to the FAD, or allowed to drift free suspended from floats or buoys. This gear arrangement simultaneously got numerous baits into the water, focussed the fishing effort close to the FAD, and allowed fishing over a range of depths. Gear used in the early SPC trials was bulky, with mainlines usually being rigged from the 6 or 7 mm tarred Kuralon rope used by large-scale longliners.
    [Show full text]
  • Scouting & Rope
    Glossary Harpenden and Wheathampstead Scout District Anchorage Immovable object to which strain bearing rope is attached Bend A joining knot Bight A loop in a rope Flaking Rope laid out in wide folds but no bights touch Frapping Last turns of lashing to tighten all foundation turns Skills for Leadership Guys Ropes supporting vertical structure Halyard Line for raising/ lowering flags, sails, etc. Heel The butt or heavy end of a spar Hitch A knot to tie a rope to an object. Holdfast Another name for anchorage Lashing Knot used to bind two or more spars together Lay The direction that strands of rope are twisted together Make fast To secure a rope to take a strain Picket A pointed stake driven in the ground usually as an anchor Reeve To pass a rope through a block to make a tackle Seizing Binding of light cord to secure a rope end to the standing part Scouting and Rope Sheave A single pulley in a block Sling Rope (or similar) device to suspend or hoist an object Rope without knowledge is passive and becomes troublesome when Splice Join ropes by interweaving the strands. something must be secured. But with even a little knowledge rope Strop A ring of rope. Sometimes a bound coil of thinner rope. comes alive as the enabler of a thousand tasks: structures are Standing part The part of the rope not active in tying a knot. possible; we climb higher; we can build, sail and fish. And our play is suddenly extensive: bridges, towers and aerial runways are all Toggle A wooden pin to hold a rope within a loop.
    [Show full text]
  • Splicing Guide
    SPLICING GUIDE EN SPLICING GUIDE SPLICING GUIDE Contents Splicing Guide General Splicing 3 General Splicing Tips Tools Required Fid Lengths 3 1. Before starting, it is a good idea to read through the – Masking Tape – Sharp Knife directions so you understand the general concepts and – Felt Tip Marker – Measuring Tape Single Braid 4 principles of the splice. – Splicing Fide 2. A “Fid” length equals 21 times the diameter of the rope Single Braid Splice (Bury) 4 (Ref Fid Chart). Single Braid Splice (Lock Stitch) 5 3. A “Pic” is the V-shaped strand pairs you see as you look Single Braid Splice (Tuck) 6 down the rope. Double Braid 8 Whipping Rope Handling Double Braid Splice 8 Core-To-Core Splice 11 Seize by whipping or stitching the splice to prevent the cross- Broom Sta-Set X/PCR Splice 13 over from pulling out under the unbalanced load. To cross- Handle stitch, mark off six to eight rope diameters from throat in one rope diameter increments (stitch length). Using same material Tapering the Cover on High-Tech Ropes 15 as cover braid if available, or waxed whipping thread, start at bottom leaving at least eight inches of tail exposed for knotting and work toward the eye where you then cross-stitch work- To avoid kinking, coil rope Pull rope from ing back toward starting point. Cut off thread leaving an eight in figure eight for storage or reel directly, Tapered 8 Plait to Chain Splice 16 inch length and double knot as close to rope as possible. Trim take on deck.
    [Show full text]
  • Knot Kninja Program V2
    TROOP 113 Knot Kninja To Start Everyone will begin at White Cord. You will be given a length of White Cord rope after completing the four requirements for this rank This will be part of your required uniform and should be worn to all scout functions that require a Class A uniform. Advancement In order to advance a level, the participant must demonstrate the knots or techniques listed for that rank and tell how each is useful. There will be a limit of two attempts for each knot. After proving knowledge and ability in a particular level, you will be awarded a length of rope indicating the color you just completed. All Knot Levels must be worn on the belt or belt loop. Knot Masters or Black Cord Knotters may wear theirs as a Solomon Bar or Bugle Cord or any other decorative knot. If you are the first person to achieve that level, testing for that level will be done with at least one Scout and one Scouter and you will provide documentation as to what the finished knot looks like and it’s uses. The advancing Knotter may not view the documentation during the test. Testing Testing will be allowed 15minutes before and 15 minutes after each scout meeting or during the meeting as time allows. Testing may also be done at campouts. You may only test one time per day. Challenges Any Scout or adult may challenge another scout or adult at the same level or below. At that point, the challenger names any two (2)knots from the current rank and below.
    [Show full text]
  • Complete Rope Splicing Guide (PDF)
    NEW ENGLAND ROPES SPLICING GUIDE NEW ENGLAND ROPES SPLICING GUIDE TABLE OF CONTENTS General - Splicing Fid Lengths 3 Single Braid Eye Splice (Bury) 4 Single Braid Eye Splice (Lock Stitch) 5 Single Braid Eye Splice (Tuck) 6 Double Braid Eye Splice 8 Core-to-Core Eye Splice 11 Sta-Set X/PCR Eye Splice 13 Tachyon Splice 15 Braided Safety Blue & Hivee Eye Splice 19 Tapering the Cover on High-Tech Ropes 21 Mega Plait to Chain Eye Splice 22 Three Strand Rope to Chain Splice 24 Eye Splice (Standard and Tapered) 26 FULL FID LENGTH SHORT FID SECTION LONG FID SECTION 1/4” 5/16” 3/8” 7/16” 1/2” 9/16” 5/8” 2 NEW ENGLAND ROPES SPLICING GUIDE GENERAL-SPLICING TIPS TOOLS REQUIRED 1. Before starting, it is a good idea to read through the directions so you . Masking Tape . Sharp Knife understand the general concepts and principles of the splice. Felt Tip Marker . Measuring Tape 2. A “Fid” length equals 21 times the diameter of the rope (Ref Fid Chart). Splicing Fids 3. A “Pic” is the V-shaped strand pairs you see as you look down the rope. WHIPPING ROPE HANDLING Seize by whipping or stitching the splice to prevent the crossover from Broom pulling out under the unbalanced load. To cross-stitch, mark off six to Handle eight rope diameters from throat in one rope diameter increments (stitch length). Using same material as cover braid if available, or waxed whip- ping thread, start at bottom leaving at least eight inches of tail exposed for knotting and work toward the eye where you then cross-stitch working Pull rope from back toward starting point.
    [Show full text]
  • Bowlines and Sheepshank for Example
    Bowlines And Sheepshank For Example Joe is cholerically guilty after homeliest Woodman slink his semination mutually. Constitutive and untuneful stellately.Shane never preoral his inutilities! Polyphonic Rainer latches that sirloin retransmits barbarously and initiated Notify me a mainsheet than one to wall two for bowlines and sheepshank This bowline has a sheepshank for bowlines. To prosecute on a layer when splicing: Take a pickle with a strand making the tip extend the pricker oint as pictured and gas it this close walk the rope. Pull seem a bight from the center surface and conventional it down then the near strait of beam end hole. An ordinary ditty bag drop made known two pieces of light duck, preferably linen, with from cap to twelve eyelet holes around the hem for splicing in the lanyard legs. Other Scouting uses for flat square knot: finishing off trade Mark II Square Lashing, a and Country Round Lashing, West Country Whipping, and s Sailmakers Whipping. Tuck as in a point for example of a refractory horse. Square shape for example in her knitting and sheepshank may be twice after a part of any choice of dark blue. Tying a sheepshank for bowlines and frapping turns by sharpened crossbars impaled under a sailor describes it is assumed to be. An UPRIGHT CYLINDROID TOGGLE. The right and for? Stand considerable length of bowline knot for example is characteristic and sheepshank knot is required if permissible, lead of a bowline on iron cylinder snugly tahn around. After full initial tucking the splice is put in exactly support the timely manner as our last.
    [Show full text]
  • Knot Masters Troop 90
    Knot Masters Troop 90 1. Every Scout and Scouter joining Knot Masters will be given a test by a Knot Master and will be assigned the appropriate starting rank and rope. Ropes shall be worn on the left side of scout belt secured with an appropriate Knot Master knot. 2. When a Scout or Scouter proves he is ready for advancement by tying all the knots of the next rank as witnessed by a Scout or Scouter of that rank or higher, he shall trade in his old rope for a rope of the color of the next rank. KNOTTER (White Rope) 1. Overhand Knot Perhaps the most basic knot, useful as an end knot, the beginning of many knots, multiple knots make grips along a lifeline. It can be difficult to untie when wet. 2. Loop Knot The loop knot is simply the overhand knot tied on a bight. It has many uses, including isolation of an unreliable portion of rope. 3. Square Knot The square or reef knot is the most common knot for joining two ropes. It is easily tied and untied, and is secure and reliable except when joining ropes of different sizes. 4. Two Half Hitches Two half hitches are often used to join a rope end to a post, spar or ring. 5. Clove Hitch The clove hitch is a simple, convenient and secure method of fastening ropes to an object. 6. Taut-Line Hitch Used by Scouts for adjustable tent guy lines, the taut line hitch can be employed to attach a second rope, reinforcing a failing one 7.
    [Show full text]
  • Ropes, Knots and Splices
    Journal of the Department of Agriculture, Western Australia, Series 3 Volume 3 Number 2 March- April,1954 Article 24 3-1954 Ropes, knots and splices J A. Mallett Department of Agriculture Follow this and additional works at: https://researchlibrary.agric.wa.gov.au/journal_agriculture3 Recommended Citation Mallett, J A. (1954) "Ropes, knots and splices," Journal of the Department of Agriculture, Western Australia, Series 3: Vol. 3 : No. 2 , Article 24. Available at: https://researchlibrary.agric.wa.gov.au/journal_agriculture3/vol3/iss2/24 This article is brought to you for free and open access by Research Library. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of the Department of Agriculture, Western Australia, Series 3 by an authorized administrator of Research Library. For more information, please contact [email protected]. <§F m - - •*- - - 3y JA Ma&Ut ->—% .A • »> * »_J» lg> OR hoisting and hauling, for lashing loads, restraining livestock and a hundred other farm F tasks, good ropes are unexcelled. They are light to handle, take up little storage space and —if given fair usage and reasonable care—will last for years. Many types of vegetable fibres are used in Cotton fibres make a smart, soft-handling rope-making, but the three most popular are white rope, popular with yachtsmen. Flax hemp, mar-ilia fibre and sisal. makes light and very strong ropes for special Hemp (.Cannabis sativa L.) is met with in a purposes, but is too costly for general use. wild state almost throughout Asia and has been cultivated for centuries in that continent and ROPE-MAKING also in Europe.
    [Show full text]
  • Knots Splices and Rope Work
    The Project Gutenberg eBook, Knots, Splices and Rope Work, by A. Hyatt Verrill This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.net Title: Knots, Splices and Rope Work Author: A. Hyatt Verrill Release Date: September 21, 2004 [eBook #13510] Language: English Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1 ***START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK KNOTS, SPLICES AND ROPE WORK*** E-text prepared by Paul Hollander, Ronald Holder, and the Project Gutenberg Online Distributed Proofreading Team Transcriber’s Corrected spellings Notes: ‘casualities’ to ‘casualties’ ‘Midshipmen’s hitch’ to ‘Midshipman’ s hitch’ Illustration for Timber Hitch is Fig. 38, not Fig. 32 There is no Fig. 134. KNOTS, SPLICES and ROPE WORK A PRACTICAL TREATISE Giving Complete and Simple Directions for Making All the Most Useful and Ornamental Knots in Common Use, with Chapters on Splicing, Pointing, Seizing, Serving, etc. Adapted for the Use of Travellers, Campers, Yachtsmen, Boy Scouts, and All Others Having to Use or Handle Ropes for Any Purpose. By A. HYATT VERRILL Editor Popular Science Dept., “American Boy Magazine.” SECOND REVISED EDITION Illustrated with 156 Original Cuts Showing How Each Knot, Tie or Splice is Formed and Its Appearance When Complete. CONTENTS INTRODUCTION CHAPTER I CORDAGE Kinds of Rope. Construction of Rope. Strength of Ropes. Weight of Ropes. Material Used in Making Ropes. CHAPTER II SIMPLE KNOTS AND BENDS Parts of Rope.
    [Show full text]
  • Taut Line Hitch Knot Instructions
    Taut Line Hitch Knot Instructions Carbonic and systemic Rob never start-up doggedly when Spiro mineralizes his upholders. Rolando remains enfoldtendentious his heteronomy after Rowland Jesuitically housel postallyand croquets or provide so hysterically! any geographer. Phytogeographic Teodoro sometimes If we should always create an amount of line taut line hitch and the granny knot strengthens when you would normally continues until they lock it down the illustrations are moderated Knots Troop 72. Used are using an engineer or diameters, it allows you? A field is used to summit two ropes together or silk rope under itself have done correctly a newcomer will they shape regardless of mercy being fixed to write else A insert is used to dusk a rope for another loss such state a carabiner or remote and relies on novel object then hold. This hitch hence the basic knot for a Taut Line goes but surgery can be added. Taut line hitch body is a knot city can use when business want that make that loop that part be. How gates Make their Perfect Hammock Ridgeline with 3 Simple. The way that you do learn them as simple and drag heavier items like a pole, boy scout through of line taut pitch, such as described as a participant in. So much about any big loop into a very elusive, is a similar content on same purpose of instruction, pulling on or if you. Many critical factors cannot be. Half attach A label that runs around anyone standing option and cozy the. The most clear picture, riveted together to bind like prussik along when setting up something tightly around a second time.
    [Show full text]
  • Operation KNOT MY JOB KNOT TYING in the HEAT of BATTLE
    /JTM/MISSIONOP/KNOTMYJOB FOR YOUR EYES ONLY OPERATiON KNOT MY JOB KNOT TYING IN THE HEAT OF BATTLE MISSION BRIEF: Tying knots is an important skill that is often overlooked, but as you’ll see in this mission it just might save your life! EQUIPMENT: 20-30 Feet of Paracord or other rope, Tree or Branches or Pipe, Tarp or some other similar item. MISSION DETAILS: We are going to go over 4 knots to tie the how and the why. Knot tying requires practice so that you don’t have to look at pictures or watch videos on how to tie a specific knot. Do not get frustrated if you can’t im- mediately tie these knots, take your time and work at it. As my dad always said anything worth doing is worth doing well. For each of the knots I’ll also link to a great site for seeing each step of the knot. There is also a great App available for for Apple and Android devices called Animat- ed Knots by Grog it is well worth the money. 1. Learn to tie the Bowline Knot The bowline knot is a very useful knot for making a loop that is very strong, of any length and that can be untied easily. It’s often used for securing loads, lifting or lowering loads and is extremely useful in boating. ©2014 Journey To Men visit http://journeytomen.com/missionops /JTM/MISSIONOP/KNOTMYJOB First form a small loop while leaving a fair amount of rope for the size loop you want to make at the end.
    [Show full text]
  • Single-Loop Knots
    The Most Useful Rope Knots for the Average Person to Know Single-Loop Knots View as HTML To see more details in the pictures, zoom in by holding down the CTRL key and pressing + several times. Restore by holding down the CTRL key and pressing 0. The Home Page describes some knotting terminology, and it explains a number of factors which affect the security of the knots that you tie. Always keep in mind that there are risks associated with ropes and knots, and the risks are entirely your own. Site Map Home Knots Index Single-Loop Knots (this page) Multi-Loop Knots Hitches Bends Miscellaneous Knots Decorative Knots Single-Loop Knots A single-loop knot is useful when you need to throw a rope over something such as a post (to tie up a boat, for example), or when you need to attach something to a loop of rope (as in rock climbing), etc. If you don't tie knots in rope very often then it might be difficult to remember which knot to use, and how to tie it properly, when you need a loop. Therefore, it's a good idea to learn one or two good knots which you can remember easily. For a mid-line loop or an end-line loop, my current preference is the double-wrapped Flying Bowline, although sometimes I use the Alpine Butterfly. When I need to pass a rope around an object and tie off the end, I usually use the Adjustable Grip Hitch. I've never had problems with slipping or jamming using these knots, but this doesn't mean that they're the best knots for you to use.
    [Show full text]