C. the Life of Dwight Moody
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Open Research Online The Open University’s repository of research publications and other research outputs An analysis of Dwight Moody’s Urban Social Vision Thesis How to cite: Quiggle, Gregg William (2010). An analysis of Dwight Moody’s Urban Social Vision. PhD thesis The Open University. For guidance on citations see FAQs. c 2010 The Author https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Version: Version of Record Link(s) to article on publisher’s website: http://dx.doi.org/doi:10.21954/ou.ro.0000d4dc Copyright and Moral Rights for the articles on this site are retained by the individual authors and/or other copyright owners. For more information on Open Research Online’s data policy on reuse of materials please consult the policies page. oro.open.ac.uk An Analysis of Dwight Moody's Urban Social Vision By Gregg William Quiggle MA (Wheaton College) MA (Marquette University) Submitted to the Open University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirement of the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Religious Studies November 2009 Date., 0J S u.hMi5slcn ~ 2q Sep t.(~b ~r 2009 DoJ:L ~ ~{)J{O--; Il JuVte.. 2010. A STATEMENT OF COPYRIGHT The copyright of this thesis rests with the author. No part of it should be reproduced without his prior consent and information derived from it should be acknowledged. Permission is granted to the British Library and the Open University to grant access to copies of the thesis held in their libraries and to make copies for library purposes only. AN ANALYSIS OF DWIGHT MOODY'S URBAN SOCIAL VISION GREGG QUlGGLE Thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Open University, United Kingdom, November 2009. ABSTRACT Dwight Moody was the dominant English-speaking evangelist of the late nineteenth century. Much of Moody's work focused on urban centers. This thesis is an analysis of the origins of Dwight Moody's urban social vision. Specifically it studies the role Moody's theology played in the formation of his approach to the various urban ills that emerged during the mid to late nineteenth century in the United States and the United Kingdom. The thesis seeks to show that theology drove Moody's approach to urban ills. Because of Moody's temperament and limited educational background, his personal experiences and personal relationships played an inordinately significant role in the formation of Moody's theology. The thesis explores these experiences and relationships demonstrating how they shaped Moody's theology. It concludes by outlining Moody's theological commitments that framed his social vision, and his resultant social activities. The thesis concludes Moody was an evangelical whose social vision was in significant ways contiguous with those of earlier revivalists like Finney. Specifically, Moody, like Finney, always made evangelism his first priority. Further, similar to Finney, Moody was active in the temperance movement and various educational endeavors. However, Moody's conception of human sinfulness and commitment to premillennialism created a different set of expectations. Moody was dubious about the future of human society. He believed sin was the cause of poverty and that conversion brought freedom from sin and a desire to love others, especially the poor. He also believed the Bible commanded charity to the poor. Consequently, while Moody never fully embraced the Calvinistic goal of a righteous republic, he was concerned aboqt the moral state of the country and the lot of the poor. In fact, Moody was active in numerous charitable endeavors targeting the urban poor. However, Moody maintained the only way to improve public morality and the suffering of the poor was through personal conversion, because only conversion would solve the problem of sin and generate charity. Thus, from Moody's perspective political or structural reforms divorced from evangelism were ultimately doomed to fail. 1 CONTENTS Introduction 3 I. Crucial Contexts: Evangelicalism, Urbanization and Immigration 27 A. Evangelicalism and Revivalism: Definition and History 27 B. Urbanization and Immigration 40 C. Conclusion 46 Il. The Formation of Moody's Theology and Social Vision: To the Civil War 48 A. Childhood in Massachusetts 51 B. Moody's early religious life 58 C. Conclusion 95 Ill. The Formation of Moody's Theology and Social Vision: From the Civil War unta 1873 97 A. Moody and the Civil War 98 B. The 1867 trip to the United Kingdom: its impact and lingering Influence 108 C. 1871 140 D. Conclusion 146 IV. Moody's Theology 148 A. The Love of God 150 B. Non-sectarianism 158 C. The Bible 168 D. The "Three Rs" 184 E. The Holy Spirit 192 F. Premillennialism 196 G. Conclusion 202 V. Moody's Social Vision and Social Work 203 A. Moody's Social Vision 203 B. Moody's Social Work 220 C. Conclusion 250 VI. The Influence ojDwight Lyman Moody: Tributes, Legacy and Analysis 251 A. Tributes and Legacy 251 B. Analysis 260 Bibliography 275 2 INTRODUCTION The dominant evangelist of the late nineteenth century was an American from rural Massachusetts named Dwight Lyman Moody. By the time of his death in 1899, "Moody" was a household name throughout the English-speaking world. His work cast a long shadow over the evangelical world for decades after his death.1 Moody lived in a time when both the United States and the United Kingdom were going through the throes of a major change. Urbanization, industrialization and immigration changed both societies and created a new set of issues for Christianity. Churches on both sides of the Atlantic struggled with dealing with the urban masses.2 Dwight Moody made this problem the focal point of his life's work. Drawn to the city initially to make his fortune, he remained tied to the city as the focus of his work. Because of his fame and his urban emphasis, his approach to urban social ills is particularly intriguing. A. Statement of Purpose and Thesis Consequently, this study will focus on Dwight Moody's urban social vision. It is not an attempt to evaluate the effectiveness of Moody's social work; rather, I will examine the motives and values that drove his work. Specifically, I am seeking to answer three questions. First, although Moody lived before the full blossoming of what would become known as the Social Gospel movement, he was active during its embryonic stage.3 As I David Bebbington, The lJominance o/Evangelicalism: The Age 0/Spurgeon andMootO' (Downers Grove, Illinois: InterVarsity Press, 2005), 40-50. 2 Ibid., 12-20; and Stanley Gundry, Love Them /n.· The Lift and Theology 0/'lJwlgh/ Moody (Grand ' Rapids, Michigan: Baker Book House, 1976),58-68. 3 R. T. Handy, ed., The Social Gospel in America (New York: Oxford University Press, 1966); C. H. Hopki ns, The Hise 0/'the Social Gospelin American Protestan/ism, /6'65-/9/5(New Haven, Connecticut: Yale, 1940); N. A. Magnuson, Salpa/ion ill/heSluHl.J': Ji'pallgelical Social Work, /6'65-/.900(Metuchen, New Jersey: Scarecrow Press, 1977). The dating of the beginning of the Social Gospel movement is difficult, although there is a consensus its roots go to the period right after the American Civil War. 3 we shall see, he interacted with men like Lyman Abbott and Washington Gladden; in fact, he invited them to speak at various campaigns and conferences. However, there is no evidence he seriously considered the approaches they were proposing relative to urban social ills. In short, why did he reject their theories in favor of a personal conversion strategy? Second, was Moody's social vision a function of his relationship with the "robber barons," his middle-class Victorian values, or his commitment to the Republican Party? Moody maintained cordial relationships with many of the great captains in American industry, especially in Chicago. Names like McCormick, Field, Armour, Scott, and Farwell bankrolled much of Moody's work. What role did those relationships play in Moody's approach to urban ills? He also reflected many of the middle-class values of the day; was his social vision an extension of those values? Moody was also a committed Republican with a disdain for central government. Was this a critical factor in his insistence on individualistic solutions? Third, how did Moody understand the relationship between addressing social ills and evangelism? What importance did he give to charity and attempts to formulate social change? This is, therefore, an attempt to explicate Moody's social vision and examine its roots. It is my contention that Moody's work revealed some elements of what David Moberg called "the great reversal." Moody eschewed structural/legislative reforms to alleviate urban ills in favor of mass conversions of the poor. While he did occasionally speak to structuralllegislative issues, he never engaged in a sustained dialogue or functioned as an advocate for these types of causes. Yet, at the same time, Moody created educational institutions at least partly for the purpose of educating the poor and improving their lives. 4 Moody's vision was also in significant ways contiguous with those of the earlier revivalists like Finney, the exception being that Moody's premillennialismcreated a different set of expectations. Specifically, it will be demonstrated in this thesis that Moody, like Finney, always made evangelism his first priority. Further, in continuity with Finney, Moody was active in the temperance movement and in various educational endeavors. As a young man, he was an abolitionist, a staunch defender of the Union and active in the Freedman's Bureau.4 In addition, like Finney, he became involved in education. In fact, by the end of his career he was more of an educator than an evangelist. As we shall see, Moody was hardly dispassionate about the plight of the poor.