Hearing Unit Cover and Text

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Hearing Unit Cover and Text Public Hearing before ASSEMBLY JUDICIARY COMMITTEE Assembly Concurrent Resolution 1 “Proposes constitutional amendment to authorize Legislature to permit by law establishment and operation of casinos in certain counties” LOCATION: Committee Room 12 DATE: March 7, 2016 State House Annex 10:00 a.m. Trenton, New Jersey MEMBERS OF COMMITTEE PRESENT: Assemblyman John F. McKeon, Chair Assemblyman Gordon M. Johnson, Vice Chair Assemblyman Joseph A. Lagana Assemblywoman Elizabeth Maher Muoio Assemblyman Andrew Zwicker Assemblyman Chris A. Brown Assemblyman Michael Patrick Carroll ALSO PRESENT: Miriam Bavati Rafaela Garcia Kate McDonnell Kevin Logan Office of Legislative Services Assembly Majority Assembly Republican Committee Aides Committee Aide Committee Aide Hearing Recorded and Transcribed by The Office of Legislative Services, Public Information Office, Hearing Unit, State House Annex, PO 068, Trenton, New Jersey TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Assemblyman Ralph R. Caputo District 28 6 John Heinz Private Citizen 21 Vicki T. Clark President Cape May County Chamber of Commerce 24 Joseph D. Kelly President Greater Atlantic City Chamber 25 Debra P. DiLorenzo President and CEO Chamber of Commerce Southern New Jersey 26 Sal M. Anderton, Esq. General Counsel Porzio Governmental Affairs, LLC 29 Gordon MacInnes President New Jersey Policy Perspective 29 Anthony Russo Executive Vice President Government Affairs and Communications Commerce and Industry Association of New Jersey 38 APPENDIX Testimony submitted by Vicki T. Clark 1x Testimony submitted by Debra P. DiLorenzo 2x TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued) Page Testimony submitted by Joseph D. Kelly 5x Testimony submitted by Gordon MacInnes 9x Testimony submitted by Sal M. Anderton, Esq. 11x Testimony submitted by Anthony Russo 13x Testimony submitted by Michele N. Siekerka, Esq. President and CEO New Jersey Business and Industry Association 14x Testimony submitted by Assemblyman Chris A. Brown District 2 15x Testimony submitted by Marlene Z. Asselta President Southern New Jersey Development Council 20x pnf:1-49 ASSEMBLYMAN JOHN F. McKEON (Chair): Welcome to everyone. We are going to defer on the regularly scheduled agenda to move forward on the public hearing on ACR-1. So we need to gavel in, so to speak, on that and take attendance; and then gavel out before we get to the regular part of the meeting. MS. GARCIA (Committee Aide): Assemblyman Brown. ASSEMBLYMAN BROWN: Here. MS. GARCIA: Assemblyman Carroll. ASSEMBLYMAN CARROLL: Here. MS. GARCIA: Assemblyman Zwicker. ASSEMBLYMAN ZWICKER: Here. MS. GARCIA: Assemblywoman Muoio. ASSEMBLYWOMAN MUOIO: Here. MS. GARCIA: Assemblyman Lagana. ASSEMBLYMAN LAGANA: Here. MS. GARCIA: Assemblyman Johnson. ASSEMBLYMAN GORDON M. JOHNSON (Vice Chair): Here. MS. GARCIA: Assemblyman McKeon. ASSEMBLYMAN McKEON: Present. I’d like to, again, welcome Assemblyman Brown. I probably made the mistake of telling Michael Patrick Carroll that I missed him (laughter); so don’t make me feel badly, as far as that statement to you, Michael, today. Be good to me. 1 I will take two minutes of time just to, in general, talk about ACR-1. This is now the fifth hearing that this Committee, Judiciary, has had -- number five as it relates to ACR-1; and really, frankly, with only some very important, but relatively minor, straightforward changes. So I’d like everybody to keep in mind that this Committee has heard themselves, as well as any other witness that purports to be before us today. So try to do your best to be brief and succinct. I think we know everyone’s stated position. We know that, in 2006, the gross revenues from the casinos was $5.2 billion; and that in 2015, I think, the number was somewhere around $2.6 billion. Notwithstanding the dedication of the industry, and the men and women who make up those -- make that a part of our very important tourism economy, the proliferation of casinos really all over the place -- in Pennsylvania, New York, Delaware -- are such to have put a dent into that number. There was a five-year plan, that has about a little less than a year left, that has continued to show those revenues having been decreased; and it’s a matter of us having to take action, and frankly, action that probably should have taken place probably five or ten years ago. At the end game, although it’s very important to preserve the economy of that section of the state, let’s not lose mind or set of the fact that, at least, we’re down -- to this point -- about $200 million that comes back to the State for the sake of funding some very, very important programs that relate to property tax relief, that relate to senior programs -- everything from prescription aid, to transportation aid, to other essential 2 services -- and we can’t continue to watch as that important revenue source goes away. The bill, in general terms, requires as follows: If it’s-- Again, with the voters having the final word, there will be two new licenses -- so long as those licensees get a full and complete application in within a 60- day timeframe so it’s not sat on; that those operators will be current Atlantic City operators; that any of the casinos won’t be any closer than 72 miles to Atlantic City. We have on record a full compilation of every town in the state, as well as a map, if anybody has any questions as to where that exact mark is delineated. That those current operators will have to spend no less than $1 billion on acquisition, construction, and development of either of those two casinos to make certain that we just don’t end up with videos in a box, so to speak; and that this is true investment, and will put a dent into what the other states have done; and that the way that the money will be split, if you will -- and, by the way, it has to be at least two separate counties; they can’t both be in Hudson County, by way of example -- 2 percent of the fees will go to host benefit, meaning that either the county or the town that will be hosting the casinos will get that money as it relates to infrastructure and other things to support that; 2 percent of the funds off the top will go to our Thoroughbred industry and Standardbred industry as it relates to supporting that part of our very important tourism economy. And the rest of the money, through-- You know, I don’t, certainly, want to bore you all and go through all those numbers. But in the first fiscal year it will go, after that 4 percent, just as it goes now -- to the current manner in which those revenues come through; and then from year 2 to 16, again, the first $150 3 million -- 50 percent to Atlantic City, and 50 percent on the other side. The second $150 million -- 40 percent to Atlantic City. The third $150 million -- if we should be so lucky that there’s that much -- 30 percent to Atlantic City; and all remaining -- 20 percent to Atlantic City. I won’t get into years 17 to 27 because we’ll all be old by then -- or most of us -- but again, it’s a diminishing number as it relates to the sums to Atlantic City. But letting that all go aside, Atlantic City will never get more than one-third of the total amount. So if that number is $1 billion, even though if that structure would lead to sums that are even greater than that, one-third will be their maximum. The other good news -- again, if you care about all these important programs -- is that the funding for programs that get supported now by that $200 million will never be less than Fiscal Year 2015. So we’ll make sure -- at least today, we’ll hold volley regarding the financial support for those very important programs. So with that as an overview of what the legislation or what the constitutional amendment to be voted on will do, also keep in mind our current tax rate is 8 percent; other states are as high as 50 percent. We’ll see what will happen with that as it gets into the enabling legislation. We’ll see what happens as it relates to the specifics on that $1 billion of investment. We know what the Constitution will say; the details will come through in enabling legislation that will go forward. With us today is the primary sponsor -- who, beyond the five hearings that have been here thus far, has been diligent over the years as it relates to his opinions, and his advocacy, and leadership in expanding the 4 gaming industry in New Jersey to allow us to be competitive -- Ralph Caputo. Ralph, I probably talked longer than I should have; but I gave it an overview. Mr. Brown, again, I welcomed him here. He promises me that although he’ll be given no restriction as it relates to offering his opinion prior to voting -- and I’m going to bet a nickel as to how that vote might go -- that we’re going to limit the questions. This is a public hearing; so the time to let your opinions be known will be when you vote, as opposed to through long questions. So any questions there are -- pointed questions, and I’m going to use the prerogative of the Chair to slow that down if need be. ASSEMBLYMAN CARROLL: Mr. Chairman, we don’t vote at a public hearing, do we? ASSEMBLYMAN McKEON: I don’t know; that’s a good question. Do we have to vote to-- So we don’t even have to vote. So thank you very much; I knew, Michael, I needed you here to remind me of what to do.
Recommended publications
  • 2019 Legislative Scorecard
    ENVIRONMENTAL SCORECARD OCTOBER 2019 TABLE OF CONTENTS LETTER FROM EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR..... 3 ENVIRONMENTAL AGENDA................... 4 AT A GLANCE SCORE SUMMMARY......... 8 BILL DESCRIPTIONS............................ 12 SENATE SCORECARD........................... 18 ASSEMBLY SCORECARD....................... 23 ABOUT NEW JERSEY LCV ..................... 27 New Jersey League of Conservation Voters Board of Directors: Julia Somers, Chair Joseph Basralian, Vice Chair Carleton Montgomery, Treasurer Bill Leavens, Secretary Michele S. Byers, Trustee James G. Gilbert, Trustee Scott Rotman, Trustee Arniw Schmidt, Trustee New Jersey League of Conservation Voters Staff: Ed Potosnak, Executive Director Kaitlin Barakat, Water Quality Coordinator Dominic Brennan, Field Organizer Lee M. Clark, Watershed Outreach Manager Henry Gajda, Public Policy Director Joe Hendershot, Field Organizer Rebecca Hilbert, Policy Assistant Anny Martinez, Bi-Lingual Environmental Educator Hillary Mohaupt, Social Media Strategist and Inclusion Manager Eva Piatek, Digital Campaigns Manager Kristin Zilcosky, Director of Digital Engagement Jason Krane, Director of Development 2 DEAR FELLOW CONSERVATION VOTER, I am excited to present the New Jersey League of Conservation Voters’ 2019 Environmental Scorecard. Our scorecard rates each member of the New Jersey Senate and Assembly on their conservation record and actions taken to protect the environment in the Garden State. It does this by tracking how New Jersey’s 40 senators and 80 Assembly members voted on key legislation affecting air and water quality, open space, and the fight against climate change. As “the political voice for the environment,” New Jersey LCV uses its resources to elect environmental champions and support them in office while helping to defeat candidates and officeholders whose legislative priorities do not include air, water, and land protections. We empower legislators by providing background information before key environmental votes, and we hold legislators accountable for their positions and actions related to our environment.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction Lobbying and Advocacy
    Introduction This Legislative Handbook is designed to provide guidance and assistance to representatives of the New Jersey Association of Mental Health and Addiction Agencies, Inc. (NJAMHAA) member organizations who participate in legislative activities. Specifically, the Legislative Handbook presents the Association’s legislative policy and procedures, simplifies the complexities of the legislative process, and provides an orientation to grassroots lobbying for all members. On behalf of its members, NJAMHAA meets with legislators, policy makers and business leaders in order to influence legislative, regulatory and funding decisions in ways that have the most positive outcome on its members. Through increased visibility and a stronger presence, NJAMHAA ensures that members’ concerns are expressed and that their interests are represented. This allows members the peace of mind of knowing that legislative or regulatory changes that are made will occur with their views expressed. NJAMHAA is committed to facilitating meaningful exchange both within the Association and with other industry stakeholders to achieve mutual advocacy. While NJAMHAA aggressively lobbies state and federal legislators on behalf of its members, these lawmakers need to hear from you, their local constituents, those who elect them. The louder and stronger the voice, the more impact that it has on all who hear it. Please use and refer back to this valuable resource to familiarize yourself with legislative advocacy procedures and to contact key legislators to collectively join other NJAMHAA members in advancing the cause for an improved community behavioral health system. Lobbying and Advocacy Oftentimes, the words “lobbying” and “advocacy” are used interchangeably. The legal definition of lobbying usually involves attempting to influence legislation.
    [Show full text]
  • 2016Midyearpoliticalcontributio
    1 Verizon Political Activity January – June 2016 A Message from Craig Silliman Verizon is affected by a wide variety of government policies -- from telecommunications regulation to taxation to health care and more -- that have an enormous impact on the business climate in which we operate. We owe it to our shareowners, employees and customers to advocate public policies that will enable us to compete fairly and freely in the marketplace. Political contributions are one way we support the democratic electoral process and participate in the policy dialogue. Our employees have established political action committees at the federal level and in 18 states. These political action committees (PACs) allow employees to pool their resources to support candidates for office who generally support the public policies our employees advocate. This report lists all PAC contributions, corporate political contributions, support for ballot initiatives and independent expenditures made by Verizon and its affiliates during the period January – June 2016. The contribution process is overseen by the Corporate Governance and Policy Committee of our Board of Directors, which receives a comprehensive report and briefing on these activities at least annually. We intend to update this voluntary disclosure twice a year and publish it on our corporate website. We believe this transparency with respect to our political spending is in keeping with our commitment to good corporate governance and a further sign of our responsiveness to the interests of our shareowners. Craig L. Silliman Executive Vice President, Public Policy and General Counsel 2 Verizon Political Activity January – June 2016 Political Contributions Policy: Our Voice in the Democratic Process What are the Verizon Good Government Clubs? setting of monetary contribution limitations and the The Verizon Good Government Clubs (GGCs) exist to help the establishment of periodic reporting requirements.
    [Show full text]
  • 2020 218Th NEW JERSEY LEGISLATURE COUNTY
    2020 218th NEW JERSEY LEGISLATURE (Senators are listed first, NJEA PAC-endorsed victors are CAPITALIZED, NJEA members are bold-type) 1 Senate: Mike Testa (R); 21 JON BRAMNICK (R); NANCY MUNOZ (R) Assembly: Antwan McClellan (R); Erik Simonsen (R) 22 LINDA CARTER (D); JAMES KENNEDY (D) 2 Phil Guenther (R); John Risley (R) 23 Erik Peterson (R); John DiMaio (R) 3 John Burzichelli (D); Adam Taliaferro (D) 24 Harold Wirths (R); Parker Space (R) 4 Paul Moriarty (D); Gabriela Mosquera (D) 25 Brian Bergen (R); VACANCY (R) 5 William Spearman (D); William Moen (D) 26 BETTYLOU DECROCE (R); Jay Webber (R) 6 Louis Greenwald (D); Pamela Lampitt (D) 27 JOHN MCKEON (D); MILA JASEY (D) 7 Herb Conaway (D); Carol Murphy (D) 28 RALPH CAPUTO (D); CLEOPATRA TUCKER (D) 8 RYAN PETERS (R); JEAN STANFIELD (R) 29 Eliana Pintor Marin (D); Shanique Speight (D); 9 DiAnne Gove (R); Brian Rumpf (R) 30 SEAN KEAN (R); NED THOMSON (R) 10 Greg McGuckin (R); John Catalano (R) 31 NICHOLAS CHIARAVALLOTI (D); ANGELA MCKNIGHT (D) 11 JOANN DOWNEY (D); ERIC HOUGHTALING (D) 32 ANGELICA JIMENEZ (D); PEDRO MEJIA (D) 12 RONALD DANCER (R); ROBERT CLIFTON (R) 33 ANNETTE CHAPARRO (D); RAJ MUKHERJI (D) 13 SERENA DIMASO (R); GERALD SCHARFENBERGER (R) 34 THOMAS GIBLIN (D); BRITNEE TIMBERLAKE (D) 14 WAYNE DEANGELO (D); DANIEL BENSON (D) 35 SHAVONDA SUMTER (D); BENJIE WIMBERLY (D) 15 VERLINA REYNOLDS-JACKSON (D); ANTHONY VERRELLI (D) 36 GARY SCHAER (D); CLINTON CALABRESE (D) 16 ANDREW ZWICKER (D); ROY FREIMAN (D) 37 VALERIE HUTTLE (D); GORDON JOHNSON (D) 17 Joseph Egan (D); JOE DANIELSEN(D)
    [Show full text]
  • Primary Election Results
    08/10/2015 Official List Page 1 of 48 Candidates for General Assembly For PRIMARY ELECTION 06/02/2015 Election, * denotes incumbent Name Address Party County Slogan Tally First Legislative District: ATLANTIC (part) - CAPE MAY - CUMBERLAND (part) Counties BOB ANDRZEJCZAK * 22 LOLA LANE Democratic (bracketed with R. BRUCE CAPE MAY, NJ 08204 LAND) ATLANTIC ATLANTIC COUNTY REGULAR 83 DEMOCRAT, INC. CAPE MAY CAPE MAY COUNTY REGULAR 913 DEMOCRATIC ORGANIZATION CUMBERLAND CUMBERLAND COUNTY REGULAR 968 DEMOCRATIC ORGANIZATION Total 1,964 R. BRUCE LAND 789 CYPRESS DRIVE Democratic (bracketed with BOB VINELAND, NJ 08360 ANDRZEJCZAK) ATLANTIC ATLANTIC COUNTY REGULAR 77 DEMOCRAT, INC. CAPE MAY CAPE MAY COUNTY REGULAR 762 DEMOCRATIC ORGANIZATION CUMBERLAND CUMBERLAND COUNTY REGULAR 934 DEMOCRATIC ORGANIZATION Total 1,773 SAM FIOCCHI * 1745 DOLLY DRIVE Republican (bracketed with JIM SAURO) VINELAND, NJ 08361 ATLANTIC ATLANTIC COUNTY REGULAR 192 REPUBLICAN ORGANIZATION CAPE MAY CAPE MAY COUNTY REGULAR 2,925 REPUBLICAN ORGANIZATION CUMBERLAND CUMBERLAND COUNTY REGULAR 776 REPUBLICAN ORGANIZATION Total 3,893 JIM SAURO 5219 TRENTO AVENUE Republican (bracketed with SAM FIOCCHI) VINELAND, NJ 08361 ATLANTIC ATLANTIC COUNTY REGULAR 187 REPUBLICAN ORGANIZATION CAPE MAY CAPE MAY COUNTY REGULAR 2,657 REPUBLICAN ORGANIZATION CUMBERLAND CUMBERLAND COUNTY REGULAR 744 REPUBLICAN ORGANIZATION Total 3,588 Total 11,218 08/10/2015 Official List Page 2 of 48 Candidates for General Assembly For PRIMARY ELECTION 06/02/2015 Election, * denotes incumbent Name Address Party County Slogan Tally Second Legislative District: ATLANTIC (part) Counties VINCENT MAZZEO * P.O. BOX 362 Democratic (bracketed with COLIN BELL) NORTHFIELD, NJ 08225 ATLANTIC ATLANTIC COUNTY REGULAR 3,657 DEMOCRAT, INC. Total 3,657 COLIN BELL P.O.
    [Show full text]
  • Legislative Report Card 218Th Nj Legislature 2018-2019 Dear Friends
    LEGISLATIVE REPORT CARD 218TH NJ LEGISLATURE 2018-2019 DEAR FRIENDS, I am pleased to share this report card for the 2018-2019 New Jersey state legislature. Here is a snapshot of how lawmakers voted on key social and moral legislation related to the right to life, education, family, marijuana, marriage, and other issues. Guided by our mission of building a state where God is honored, religious liberty flourishes, families thrive, and life is cherished, this report card focuses on seven bills in the New Jersey Assembly and Senate during the 2018-2019 Legislative Session. All of those bills are included in this report card. A bill is passed by a simple majority in the Senate (21 votes out of 40 senators) and the Assembly (41 votes out of 80 Assembly members.) Lawmakers earned letter grades ranging from A–F based on how they voted on all the bills. This report card is not an endorsement of any candidate or political party. It does not measure any lawmakers’ integrity, commitment to their faith, work ethic, or rapport with Family Policy Alliance of New Jersey. It is only a report on how each lawmaker voted. One of the most common questions people ask is, “How did my legislator vote?” This report card should help you answer that question. Sincerely, Shawn Hyland Director of Advocacy CONTENTS Introduction Letter 2 Vote Descriptions 4 About the Report Card 3 Legislator Votes 5-7 - 2 - ABOUT THE REPORT CARD Family Policy Alliance of New Jersey selected votes on key legislation in the New Jersey Assembly and New Jersey Senate based on our core belief in promoting, protecting, and strengthening traditional family values.
    [Show full text]
  • JNESO District Council 1 Endorses Members of NJ Legislature for November Election
    TEL: (732) 745-2776 JNESO FAX: (732) 828-6343 DISTRICT COUNCIL 1, IUOE / AFL-CIO WEB: WWW.JNESO.ORG the professional health care union MEMBERS: (800) 292-0542 ELFRIEDA V. JOHNSON, RNC, PRESIDENT 1225 LIVINGSTON AVE., NORTH BRUNSWICK, NJ 08902 DOUGLAS A. PLACA, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR For Immediate Release JNESO District Council 1 Endorses Members of NJ Legislature For November Election North Brunswick, N.J. (Oct. 15, 2019) – JNESO District Council 1, representing more than 5,000 healthcare workers, is proud to announce the endorsement of candidates for the New Jersey State Legislature. The JNESO Board of Directors, unanimously voted to endorse these candidates after a thorough review of voting records, public positions and responses to a top healthcare issues questionnaire. “These candidates have shown support for JNESO and our efforts to protect and preserve the quality of care for patients, and to improve working conditions for all nurses, techs and healthcare professionals throughout the State of New Jersey,” said Doug Placa, Executive Director of JNESO. The top issues for JNESO union members include passing legislation to require safe staffing ratios for nurses, reinstatement of regularly scheduled hospital inspections, and guaranteed collective bargaining rights for healthcare employees. “These individuals understand the issues that matter most to our membership,” said Placa. “They stand with patients and healthcare workers and deserve our support.” JNESO represents more than 5,000 healthcare professionals in facilities across New Jersey and Pennsylvania. The JNESO union represents nurses, medical technicians, medical support personnel, caregivers and others in the healthcare field. www.jneso.org (See next page for list of endorsements) * Incumbent + Labor Candidate ^ A1470/S989 Sponsor/Co-Sponsor JNESO: 2019 Legislative Endorsements DISTRICT 1 DISTRICT 14 DISTRICT 28 Senate Wayne P.
    [Show full text]
  • Legislative Disability Caucus Backgrounder
    November 2020 New Jersey Legislative Disability Caucus Backgrounder PURPOSE: To serve as a bipartisan forum within the New Jersey Legislature for lawmakers and their staff to consider the impact on the disability community when shaping ALL public policies in the Garden State through increased awareness and a greater understanding of the complexities of the disabilities service system and issues affecting individuals with disabilities and their families. THE FACTS: • According to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, approximately 61 million Americans – 25% of the population – have a disability that “impacts major life activities”. • Approximately 25% of adults in New Jersey identify as having some type of disability. This equates to 2,227,250. * • Despite progress, adults with disabilities in New Jersey and across the country continue to experience significant differences in health characteristics and behaviors compared to adults without disabilities. ** • The jobless rate for persons with a disability continues to be about twice as high as the rate for those without a disability. *** • People with disabilities live in poverty at more than twice the rate of people without disabilities. **** HOW THE CAUCUS WORKS: Individuals with disabilities, their families and organizations that serve, support and advocate for individuals with disabilities in New Jersey will be a resource to the NJ Legislative Disability Caucus, providing education and programming as needed. Legislators who join the caucus agree to be champions for individuals with disabilities in New Jersey by meeting with them in their district offices; participating in quarterly education forums; and above all, promote policies to improve the lives of people with disabilities and consider the impact on the disability community in shaping all public policies in New Jersey.
    [Show full text]
  • Strengthen Political Parties to Offset Increased Spending by Independent Groups, Says Jeff Brindle
    Strengthen political parties to offset increased spending by independent groups, says Jeff Brindle JEFF BRINDLE • March 17, 2018 For The Press In four legislative elections since 2011, so-called dark-money groups drilled down with more than $3.7 million in independent spending in the 2nd Legislative District. With the 2nd District among the most competitive in the state, that figure would have been tops in the state among legislative districts if not for $14 million spent by dark-money groups in neighboring 3rd District this past November. Dark money is campaign funding whose source isn’t required to be disclosed, although it often is. Dark-money groups are independent committees operated by special interests outside the control of parties or candidates. They are often anonymous, not regulated by state law, and often exempt from disclosing their activities. Seventeen Atlantic county communities, including Atlantic City, comprise the 2nd District. Attesting to its competitiveness, the district is represented by state Sen. Chris Brown, a Republican, and Democratic Assemblymen Vince Mazzeo and John Armato. If history is a guide, this district will continue to be highly competitive, a sure invitation to significant, if not overwhelming, dark money involvement in the future. What has occurred in the 2nd District reflects statewide trends at all levels of government. For instance, between the state elections of 2005 and 2017, dark-money spending grew by more than 11,000 percent. From $411,224 in 2005 dark-money independent spending climbed to $47.5 million in 2017. In comparison, state and county parties spent $48 million in 2005 and $26 million 2017, a complete reversal of fortune.
    [Show full text]
  • Pfizer Inc. Regarding Congruency of Political Contributions on Behalf of Tara Health Foundation
    SANFORD J. LEWIS, ATTORNEY January 28, 2021 Via electronic mail Office of Chief Counsel Division of Corporation Finance U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission 100 F Street, N.E. Washington, D.C. 20549 Re: Shareholder Proposal to Pfizer Inc. Regarding congruency of political contributions on Behalf of Tara Health Foundation Ladies and Gentlemen: Tara Health Foundation (the “Proponent”) is beneficial owner of common stock of Pfizer Inc. (the “Company”) and has submitted a shareholder proposal (the “Proposal”) to the Company. I have been asked by the Proponent to respond to the supplemental letter dated January 25, 2021 ("Supplemental Letter") sent to the Securities and Exchange Commission by Margaret M. Madden. A copy of this response letter is being emailed concurrently to Margaret M. Madden. The Company continues to assert that the proposal is substantially implemented. In essence, the Company’s original and supplemental letters imply that under the substantial implementation doctrine as the company understands it, shareholders are not entitled to make the request of this proposal for an annual examination of congruency, but that a simple written acknowledgment that Pfizer contributions will sometimes conflict with company values is all on this topic that investors are entitled to request through a shareholder proposal. The Supplemental letter makes much of the claim that the proposal does not seek reporting on “instances of incongruency” but rather on how Pfizer’s political and electioneering expenditures aligned during the preceding year against publicly stated company values and policies.” While the company has provided a blanket disclaimer of why its contributions may sometimes be incongruent, the proposal calls for an annual assessment of congruency.
    [Show full text]
  • Hearing Unit Cover and Text
    Committee Meeting of SENATE ENVIRONMENT AND ENERGY COMMITTEE ASSEMBLY TELECOMMUNICATIONS AND UTILITIES COMMITTEE Senate Bill No. 3560, Assembly Bill No. 5330 “Establishes Nuclear Diversity Certificate program” LOCATION: Committee Room 4 DATE: December 20, 2017 State House Annex 10:00 a.m. Trenton, New Jersey MEMBERS OF COMMITTEES PRESENT: Senator Bob Smith, Chair Senator Richard J. Codey Senator Stephen M. Sweeney Senator Christopher “Kip” Bateman Senator Samuel D. Thompson Assemblyman Wayne P. DeAngelo, Chair Assemblyman Benjie E. Wimberly, Vice Chair Assemblyman Joseph V. Egan Assemblyman Eric Houghtaling Assemblywoman Eliana Pintor Marin Assemblyman Andrew Zwicker Assemblyman Sean T. Kean ALSO PRESENT: Kevil Duhon Richard Diaconu Kate McDonnell Ben Graziano Judith L. Horowitz Senate Majority Assembly Majority Tara M. Howley Rebecca Panitch Glen Beebe Office of Legislative Services Senate Republican Assembly Republican Committee Aides Committee Aides Committee Aides Meeting Recorded and Transcribed by The Office of Legislative Services, Public Information Office, Hearing Unit, State House Annex, PO 068, Trenton, New Jersey TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Assemblyman John J. Burzichelli District 3 3 Ralph Izzo, Ph.D. Chairman, President, and CEO Public Service Energy Group (PSEG) 5 Stefanie A. Brand, Esq. Director Division of Rate Counsel State of New Jersey 10 James J. Florio Former Governor State of New Jersey 40 Mauricio Gutierrez President and CEO NRG Energy, Inc. 43 Edward H. Salmon, Ed.D. Chairman New Jersey Energy Coalition 45 John E.
    [Show full text]
  • Government Representatives for NJ FRC Teams
    Team Number Team Name Senator Senator Email Assembly Assembly Email Assembly Assembly Email 11 MORT Steven V. Oroho [email protected] Parker Space [email protected] Gail Phoebus [email protected] 25 Raider Robotix Bob Smith [email protected] Joe Danielsen [email protected] Joseph V. Egan [email protected] 41 RoboWarriors Thomas H. Kean Jr. [email protected] Jon M. Bramnick [email protected] Nancy F. Munoz [email protected] 56 R.O.B.B.E. Michael J. Doherty [email protected] John DiMaio [email protected] Erik Peterson [email protected] 75 RoboRaiders Christopher Bateman [email protected] Jack M. Cittarelli [email protected] Andrew Zwicker [email protected] 87 Red Devils Dawn Marie Addiego [email protected] Joe Howarth [email protected] Maria Rodriguez-Gregg [email protected] 102 The Gearheads Christopher Bateman [email protected] Jack M. Ciattarelli [email protected] Andrew Zwicker [email protected] 136 Killer Kardinals Patrick J. Diegnan Jr. [email protected] Robert J. Karabinchak [email protected] Nancy J. Pinkin [email protected] 193 MORT Beta Steven V. Oroho [email protected] Parker Space [email protected] Gail Phoebus [email protected] 203 One TUFF Team (Team United for FIRST)Fred H. Madden [email protected] Paul Moriarty [email protected] Gabriela Mosquera [email protected] 204 Eastern Robotic Vikings James Beach [email protected] Louis D. Greenwald [email protected] Pamela R. Lampitt [email protected] 219 Team Impact Thomas H. Kean, Jr. [email protected] Jon M. Bramnick [email protected] Nancy F. Munoz [email protected] 223 Xtreme Heat Gerald Cardinale [email protected] Robert Auth [email protected] Holly Schepisi [email protected] 224 The Tribe Bob Smith [email protected] Joe Danielsen [email protected] Joseph V.
    [Show full text]