P.09-Phaistos Disc:Valley of the Thracians 9/6/08 13:09 Page 1
P.09-Phaistos Disc:Valley of the Thracians 9/6/08 13:09 Page 1 The Phaistos Disk THE PHAISTOS DISK: A ONE HUNDRED-YEAR-OLD HOAX? The 10th in a series of articles by the Editor-in-Chief of Minerva, Jerome M. Eisenberg, Ph.D., dealing with the problems of forgery and ancient art. INTRODUCTION The Phaistos Disk (Figs 1, 2, 13, 14) is a small clay disk stamped with a series of unique ‘hieroglyphs’ purportedly exca- vated in July 1908 by Luigi Pernier in the palace of Phaistos on the island of Crete. It may not ever rank in the pub- lic’s mind with the Piltdown Man as an object of great renown in the field of man’s attempt to fool both the public and countless numbers of scholars. However, its exposure as the most famous fabrication of an ancient script should certainly end the long-standing controversy over its origins and the translation of its intriguing hiero- glyphs. On this 100th anniversary of its ‘discovery’, the writer hopes to bring to light its dubious origin. One of the most fascinating aspects of the attempts to decipher the disk is its innumerable interpretations and those of the individual glyphs. In fact, Fig 1. The Phaistos eight additional pages have been added Disk, side A. to this issue of Minerva in order to pre- sent a comprehensive listing of these decipherments and the various inter- pretations of the different signs. The interpretations of the script range from scholarly discussions of its relationship to ancient Greek scripts such as Proto- Ionian and, obviously, Minoan, to Ana- tolian (Hittite and Luwian), as well as often far-fetched links to Basque, Indo- European, Proto-Slavonic, Rhodian, Coptic, Semitic, Proto-Byblic, Tatarish- Turkish, scripts from the Black Sea area (South Caucasian/Georgian, Kartvelian, Colchian, Mingrelian-Laz), and even West Finnish or Old Estonian, Indian, Chinese, and Polynesian.
[Show full text]