To Whom It May Concern, I Am the Hobbies Product Manager of Mighty

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

To Whom It May Concern, I Am the Hobbies Product Manager of Mighty To whom it may concern, I am the Hobbies Product Manager of Mighty Ape Ltd, the largest online retailer in New Zealand and also trading in Australia as Mighty Ape Australia. I am writing to provide a submission on the exclusive dealing notification lodged by Games Workshop Oz Pty Limited (GWOP), reference N97404. As our trade account is managed by GWOP and Games Workshop treat Australia & New Zealand as the same market under the same trade terms this notification is of specific interest to both the NZ and Australian arms of our business. We submit that the terms proposed by GWOP would result in significantly lessened competition within the market for Games Workshop products, an increase in the competitive advantage for GWOP’s own sales channels and would be detrimental to the public interest within the tabletop gaming and Games Workshop hobby communities. 1. By way of background, please provide a brief description of your business. Include details such as the demographics of your customer base, their location and the mix of distance selling and ‘bricks and mortar’ shop front selling if relevant. Mighty Ape is the largest New Zealand Online Retailer, offering a range of consumer products from Games and DVD’s through to Toys, Clothing and Hobbies and also trades in Australia via the Mighty Ape Australia website. Mighty Apes customers are spread through New Zealand & Australia and include an very wide range of demographic and regions. Many of our customers come from areas where there is no local hobby retail store and therefore have to purchase their products online. Our main sales channel is online, both within New Zealand and Australia, however we also conduct face to face sales at events and conventions such as the Armageddon Expo and Battlecry Convention and offer a click and collect service via our Auckland based pick­ups and showroom location. Over the counter retail purchases can also be made in our showroom, pending the availability of stock which is stored in the adjacent warehouse. Specifically the Hobbies Category within the business is run as a ‘Virtual Local Hobby Store’, as close as possible to offering the service and sales experience of a full physical hobby retail store. We offer a range of hobby products, including Games Workshop, tabletop wargaming, roleplaying games, scale model kits, model railway, slot cars and rc, as well as paints, tools and supplies. Via our social media channels, including our Hobbies facebook page and blog, we produce and promote a wide range of hobby content, promotions and competitions to support the hobby community. These include painting tutorials and competitions, how to guides, community shout outs and event promotion. We are also heavily involved in supporting and promoting gaming and hobby clubs and events throughout New Zealand, including sponsoring tournaments for Games Workshop products. 3. Has the proportion of GWOP sales or the mix of bricks and mortar versus distance selling of GWOP products changed in recent years? If so, please explain how and to the extent possible, why. It is common knowledge that across the entire retail industry there has been a significant shift in consumer purchasing behaviour from physical retailers to online retailers, both local and increasingly international. This is especially true within the hobby industry, including in particular the tabletop gaming market of which GWOP products are a feature. Regular online purchases have become the norm and the central importance of stores within the hobby community has diminished due to the rise of social media. Community forums, facebook groups and youtube have become key features in the growth of the hobby community and in recruiting new players and customers. Hobbyists are sharing their projects online via blogs and videos , offering tips and advice, arranging games with other local players. Many find it more convenient to shop and share their hobby from the comfort of their own homes as opposed to going to a physical retail store. Online stores like us operate facebook groups, post hobby editorial content in blogs and on their websites, organise, support and promote local hobby events such as tournaments, painting competitions and more. As such they are actively encouraging new people to enter the hobby and supporting the growth of the community. We are not “Free­loading” off the work of brick & mortar stores as GWOP contends. With regards to GWOPs products specifically customers are increasingly purchasing them online and often from overseas discount retailers. There are a number of factors involved with this shift; such as the closure of smaller local stores, increasingly fast and cost effective shipping options, and consumer confidence in the security of online transactions. One of the most significant factors is the regional pricing structure which Games Workshop Ltd have adopted, which makes their products significantly more expensive to purchase within Australia and New Zealand than anywhere else in the world. Combined with ongoing price increases this has created a customer base which is increasingly price sensitive. Local retailers, both online and bricks & mortar, are simply unable to compete with overseas prices as the wholesale price from GWOP is also regionally based. Restricted access to stock from Games Workshop has also been a factor in this. A number of products within their range are “Direct Only’, which stores do not typically hold stock of because of the lower return on investment. Such items have to be special ordered in so there is no time difference between buying them online or from a bricks & mortar store. Certain items are only released “While Stocks Last’ and with very limited initial stock allocations for all independent retailers. For instance we were only allocated 3 units of the recently released Warhammer 40,000 Space Wolves Datacards and we are a large extended range stockist. Note that significantly more stock is available through Games Workshops own webstore than they allow independent retailers to purchase. Therefore customers have to shop around in order to find a store which still has the item available and that is much easier online than driving from store to store, if you’re lucky to have more than one store in your town. A number of products are also only released via Games Workshop’s own webstore and therefore no independent retailers are able to sell them. Therefore there is no competition for those items whatsoever. GWOP are well aware of the importance of distance selling within the Australian and New Zealand market, as demonstrated by the companies recent investment into a massively overhauled webstore. 4. Are there products, such as other table top games products and miniatures or other hobby products that are substitutes for, or compete with, GWOP products? If so, please describe them. If not, please explain why you do not consider there are other products that are substitutes for, or compete with, GWOP products. There is an increasing number of different tabletop gaming systems and growing number of miniature companies emerging in the wargaming market, however they cannot all be considered to compete with GWOP products and Games Workshop Ltd. does its utmost to prevent or limit such competition. Tabletop gaming is a broad market, including a wide variety of themes such as historical gaming, fantasy and sci­fi; as well as scales of miniatures ranging from Flames of war’s 15mm WW2 miniatures to GWOP’s own 28mm heroic scale. Miniatures from one company or game can be used to represent, also known as proxy or ‘counts as’, those from the GWOP product range on an informal basis between customers but not in any official sense. However GWOP’s products exist within a specific niche in the tabletop gaming market, what they themselves refer to as “The Games Workshop Hobby”. Games Workshop and its two core product ranges Warhammer and Warhammer 40,000 are the most widely known brands within the tabletop gaming market and are promoted by Games Workshop as the highest quality wargaming miniatures in the world. Other than emerging counterfeit products from China there are no substitutes for GWOP products. In order to play Warhammer or Warhammer 40,000 you have to purchase the Games Workshop models and rules publications and GWOP is the only distributor for their products. They take a very hard legal stance on any competitors who market their own products as “Suitable for use in Warhammer/Warhammer 40,000” or “Compatible with Space Marines/Eldar” The most prominent example of this would be the recent trademark and copyright dispute Games Workshop Limited v. Chapterhouse Studios LLC 1:10­cv­8103 For instance as a retailer of both the Warhammer and Kings of War range (a massed fantasy battle game produced by Mantic Games) we could not advertise Kings of War miniatures as “Suitable for use in Warhammer” even if the models themselves are of a compatible scale and style, not to mention substantially cheaper. This is why you will see the description “Suitable for use with 28mm heroic scale miniatures” on a number of third party products. Recent GWOP releases have also further diminished the ability of customers to use products from competing manufacturers. One example of this is the Warhammer Armies: Wood Elves released 03.05.2014. Some of the unique abilities for the Wood Elves involve additional pieces of terrain which they can add to the table during battles. In this new release the rules specifically state a particular GWOP product­ the Citadel Wood, meaning that players have to use this particular product and not any similar product, for example a Gale Force Nine Autumn Wood, in order for their army to be official for in­store use or tournament play. Further more the examples of competing or substituting products which GWOP have included in their application includes a number of product types which are outside of both the specific ‘Games Workshop Hobby” and general tabletop gaming markets.
Recommended publications
  • Parker Review
    Ethnic Diversity Enriching Business Leadership An update report from The Parker Review Sir John Parker The Parker Review Committee 5 February 2020 Principal Sponsor Members of the Steering Committee Chair: Sir John Parker GBE, FREng Co-Chair: David Tyler Contents Members: Dr Doyin Atewologun Sanjay Bhandari Helen Mahy CBE Foreword by Sir John Parker 2 Sir Kenneth Olisa OBE Foreword by the Secretary of State 6 Trevor Phillips OBE Message from EY 8 Tom Shropshire Vision and Mission Statement 10 Yvonne Thompson CBE Professor Susan Vinnicombe CBE Current Profile of FTSE 350 Boards 14 Matthew Percival FRC/Cranfield Research on Ethnic Diversity Reporting 36 Arun Batra OBE Parker Review Recommendations 58 Bilal Raja Kirstie Wright Company Success Stories 62 Closing Word from Sir Jon Thompson 65 Observers Biographies 66 Sanu de Lima, Itiola Durojaiye, Katie Leinweber Appendix — The Directors’ Resource Toolkit 72 Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy Thanks to our contributors during the year and to this report Oliver Cover Alex Diggins Neil Golborne Orla Pettigrew Sonam Patel Zaheer Ahmad MBE Rachel Sadka Simon Feeke Key advisors and contributors to this report: Simon Manterfield Dr Manjari Prashar Dr Fatima Tresh Latika Shah ® At the heart of our success lies the performance 2. Recognising the changes and growing talent of our many great companies, many of them listed pool of ethnically diverse candidates in our in the FTSE 100 and FTSE 250. There is no doubt home and overseas markets which will influence that one reason we have been able to punch recruitment patterns for years to come above our weight as a medium-sized country is the talent and inventiveness of our business leaders Whilst we have made great strides in bringing and our skilled people.
    [Show full text]
  • How Superman Developed Into a Jesus Figure
    HOW SUPERMAN DEVELOPED INTO A JESUS FIGURE CRISIS ON INFINITE TEXTS: HOW SUPERMAN DEVELOPED INTO A JESUS FIGURE By ROBERT REVINGTON, B.A., M.A. A Thesis Submitted to the School of Graduate Studies in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts McMaster University © Copyright by Robert Revington, September 2018 MA Thesis—Robert Revington; McMaster University, Religious Studies McMaster University MASTER OF ARTS (2018) Hamilton, Ontario, Religious Studies TITLE: Crisis on Infinite Texts: How Superman Developed into a Jesus Figure AUTHOR: Robert Revington, B.A., M.A (McMaster University) SUPERVISOR: Professor Travis Kroeker NUMBER OF PAGES: vi, 143 ii MA Thesis—Robert Revington; McMaster University, Religious Studies LAY ABSTRACT This thesis examines the historical trajectory of how the comic book character of Superman came to be identified as a Christ figure in popular consciousness. It argues that this connection was not integral to the character as he was originally created, but was imposed by later writers over time and mainly for cinematic adaptations. This thesis also tracks the history of how Christians and churches viewed Superman, as the film studios began to exploit marketing opportunities by comparing Superman and Jesus. This thesis uses the methodological framework of intertextuality to ground its treatment of the sources, but does not follow all of the assumptions of intertextual theorists. iii MA Thesis—Robert Revington; McMaster University, Religious Studies ABSTRACT This thesis examines the historical trajectory of how the comic book character of Superman came to be identified as a Christ figure in popular consciousness. Superman was created in 1938, but the character developed significantly from his earliest incarnations.
    [Show full text]
  • Dragon Con Progress Report 2021 | Published by Dragon Con All Material, Unless Otherwise Noted, Is © 2021 Dragon Con, Inc
    WWW.DRAGONCON.ORG INSIDE SEPT. 2 - 6, 2021 • ATLANTA, GEORGIA • WWW.DRAGONCON.ORG Announcements .......................................................................... 2 Guests ................................................................................... 4 Featured Guests .......................................................................... 4 4 FEATURED GUESTS Places to go, things to do, and Attending Pros ......................................................................... 26 people to see! Vendors ....................................................................................... 28 Special 35th Anniversary Insert .......................................... 31 Fan Tracks .................................................................................. 36 Special Events & Contests ............................................... 46 36 FAN TRACKS Art Show ................................................................................... 46 Choose your own adventure with one (or all) of our fan-run tracks. Blood Drive ................................................................................47 Comic & Pop Artist Alley ....................................................... 47 Friday Night Costume Contest ........................................... 48 Hallway Costume Contest .................................................. 48 Puppet Slam ............................................................................ 48 46 SPECIAL EVENTS Moments you won’t want to miss Masquerade Costume Contest ........................................
    [Show full text]
  • Games Workshop Group Plc
    PRESS ANNOUNCEMENT GAMES WORKSHOP GROUP PLC For immediate release 26 July 2011 PRELIMINARY RESULTS 2011 Games Workshop Group PLC (“Games Workshop” or the “Group”) announces its preliminary results for the year ended 29 May 2011. Highlights • Revenue at £123.1m (2010: £126.5m) • Revenue at constant currency* at £122.8m (2010: £126.5m) • Operating profit - pre-royalties receivable at £12.8m (2010: £13.0m) • Operating profit at £15.3m (2010: £16.0m) • Pre-tax profit at £15.4m (2010: £16.1m) • Earnings per share of 36.1p (2010: 48.4p) • Year end net funds of £17.6m (2010: £17.1m) • Dividends per share paid in the year of 45p (2010: nil) • Proposed dividend per share of 18p (2010: 25p) Mark Wells, chief executive officer of Games Workshop, said: “2010/11 has seen satisfactory performance, driven by improved gross margins and good cost control leading to a healthy cash inflow. Although sales were down in the first half, Games Workshop delivered improved results in the second half as the focus on customer service training for Hobby centre managers and investment in new product development started to feed through into results. Games Workshop is in good shape. We know what we need to do to remain successful and to grow.” …Ends… For further information, please contact: Games Workshop Group PLC 0115 900 4003 Tom Kirby, chairman Mark Wells, chief executive officer Kevin Rountree, chief operating officer Investor relations website http://investor.games-workshop.com General website www.games-workshop.com The 2011 annual report may be viewed at the investor relations website at the address above.
    [Show full text]
  • Consolidated Profit & Loss Account
    PRESS ANNOUNCEMENT GAMES WORKSHOP GROUP PLC 14 January 2020 HALF-YEARLY REPORT Games Workshop Group PLC (‘Games Workshop’ or the ‘Group’) announces its half-yearly results for the six months to 1 December 2019. Highlights: Six months to Six months to 1 December 2019 2 December 2018 Revenue £148.4m £125.2m Revenue at constant currency* £145.6m £125.2m Operating profit pre-royalties receivable £48.5m £35.3m Royalties receivable £10.7m £5.5m Operating profit £59.2m £40.8m Operating profit at constant currency* £57.1m £40.8m Profit before taxation £58.6m £40.8m Cash generated from operations £60.4m £36.0m Basic earnings per share 145.9p 101.3p Dividend per share declared in the period 100p 65p Kevin Rountree, CEO of Games Workshop, said: “Our business and the Warhammer Hobby continue to be in great shape. We are pleased to once again report record sales and profit levels in the period. The global team have worked their socks off to deliver these great results. My thanks go out to them all. Sales for the month of December are in line with our expectations. We are also announcing that the Board has today declared a dividend of 45 pence per share, in line with the Company’s policy of distributing truly surplus cash.” …Ends… For further information, please contact: Games Workshop Group PLC 0115 900 4003 Kevin Rountree, CEO Rachel Tongue, Group Finance Director Investor relations website investor.games-workshop.com General website www.games-workshop.com *Constant currency revenue and operating profit are calculated by comparing results in the underlying currencies for 2018 and 2019, both converted at the average exchange rates for the six months ended 2 December 2018.
    [Show full text]
  • Financial Highlights
    FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS 2007 2006 Revenue £111.5m £115.2m Pre-exceptional operating profit £1.9m £4.2m Exceptional items - cost reduction programme £(4.0)m - Operating (loss)/profit £(2.1)m £4.2m Pre-tax (loss)/profit £(2.9)m £3.7m Year end net borrowings £10.2m £2.2m (Loss)/earnings per share (11.2)p 6.5p Dividend per share 4.95p 18.975p Contents 1 Financial highlights 2 Chairman's preamble 3 Business review 9 Financial review 11 Directors' report 16 Corporate governance 20 Remuneration report 23 Statement of directors' responsibilities 23 Company’s directors and advisers 24 Independent auditors' report 25 Income statement 25 Statements of recognised income and expense 26 Balance sheets 27 Cash flow statements 28 Notes to the financial statements 54 Five year summary and financial calendar 55 Notice of meeting 57 Appendix - Chairman's preambles from previous annual reports Games Workshop Group PLC 1 CHAIRMAN’S PREAMBLE To paraphrase Margaret Thatcher: 'The wisdom of hindsight, so useful to analysts and some shareholders, is sadly denied to practising businessmen.' Or least it is when we take our decisions. Like everyone else I wonder about the decisions I took and the things I said over the last few months and years. One can lose a great deal of sleep that way, but it is, of course, a futile exercise unless one is an historian. The real question is: did I do what I did and say what I said in good faith, with serious intent and with appropriate cognisance of the needs of all our stakeholders? Now, this is a good question and the answer for every one alive, never mind the few of us leading public companies, had better be yes.
    [Show full text]
  • Reflections on Progressive Media Since 1968
    THIRD WORLD NEWSREEL Reflections on Progressive Media Since 1968 CREDITS 2008 Editor: Cynthia Young 2018 Editors: Luna Olavarría Gallegos, Eric Bilach, Elizabeth Escobar and Andrew James Cover Design: Andrew James Layout Design: Luna Olavarría Gallegos Cover Photo: El Pueblo Se Levanta, Newsreel, 1971 THIRD WORLD NEWSREEL BOARD OF DIRECTORS Dorothy Thigpen (former TWN Executive Director) Sy Burgess Afua Kafi Akua Betty Yu Joel Katz (emeritus) Angel Shaw (emeritus) William Sloan (eternal) The work of Third World Newsreel is made possible in part with the support of: The National Endowment for the Arts The New York State Council on the Arts with the support of Governor Andrew M. Cuomo and the NY State Legislature Public funds from the NYC Department of Cultural Affairs in partnership with the City Council The Peace Development Fund Individual donors and committed volunteers and friends TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. TWN Fifty Years..........................................................................4 JT Takagi, 2018 2. Foreword....................................................................................7 Luna Olavarría Gallegos, 2015 3. Introduction................................................................................9 Cynthia Young, 1998 NEWSREEL 4. On Radical Newsreel................................................................12 Jonas Mekas, c. 1968 5. Newsreel: A Report..................................................................14 Leo Braudy, 1969 6. Newsreel on Newsreel.............................................................19
    [Show full text]
  • FTSE Russell Publications
    2 FTSE Russell Publications 19 August 2021 FTSE 250 Indicative Index Weight Data as at Closing on 30 June 2021 Index weight Index weight Index weight Constituent Country Constituent Country Constituent Country (%) (%) (%) 3i Infrastructure 0.43 UNITED Bytes Technology Group 0.23 UNITED Edinburgh Investment Trust 0.25 UNITED KINGDOM KINGDOM KINGDOM 4imprint Group 0.18 UNITED C&C Group 0.23 UNITED Edinburgh Worldwide Inv Tst 0.35 UNITED KINGDOM KINGDOM KINGDOM 888 Holdings 0.25 UNITED Cairn Energy 0.17 UNITED Electrocomponents 1.18 UNITED KINGDOM KINGDOM KINGDOM Aberforth Smaller Companies Tst 0.33 UNITED Caledonia Investments 0.25 UNITED Elementis 0.21 UNITED KINGDOM KINGDOM KINGDOM Aggreko 0.51 UNITED Capita 0.15 UNITED Energean 0.21 UNITED KINGDOM KINGDOM KINGDOM Airtel Africa 0.19 UNITED Capital & Counties Properties 0.29 UNITED Essentra 0.23 UNITED KINGDOM KINGDOM KINGDOM AJ Bell 0.31 UNITED Carnival 0.54 UNITED Euromoney Institutional Investor 0.26 UNITED KINGDOM KINGDOM KINGDOM Alliance Trust 0.77 UNITED Centamin 0.27 UNITED European Opportunities Trust 0.19 UNITED KINGDOM KINGDOM KINGDOM Allianz Technology Trust 0.31 UNITED Centrica 0.74 UNITED F&C Investment Trust 1.1 UNITED KINGDOM KINGDOM KINGDOM AO World 0.18 UNITED Chemring Group 0.2 UNITED FDM Group Holdings 0.21 UNITED KINGDOM KINGDOM KINGDOM Apax Global Alpha 0.17 UNITED Chrysalis Investments 0.33 UNITED Ferrexpo 0.3 UNITED KINGDOM KINGDOM KINGDOM Ascential 0.4 UNITED Cineworld Group 0.19 UNITED Fidelity China Special Situations 0.35 UNITED KINGDOM KINGDOM KINGDOM Ashmore
    [Show full text]
  • Financial Highlights
    FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS 2008 2007 Revenue £110.3m £109.5m Operating profit - pre-exceptional and pre-royalties receivable £3.2m £0.8m Royalties receivable £1.7m £1.4m Operating profit - pre-exceptional £4.9m £2.2m Exceptional items - cost reduction programme £(2.4)m £(4.0)m Operating profit/(loss) £2.5m £(1.8)m Pre-tax profit/(loss) £1.1m £(2.6)m Discontinued operations - loss for the year £(1.2)m £(0.3)m Year end net borrowings £10.1m £10.2m Loss per share (2.4)p (11.2)p Dividend per share - 4.95p Contents 1 Financial highlights 2 Chairman's preamble 3 Business review 9 Financial review 12 Directors' report 17 Corporate governance 20 Remuneration report 23 Statement of directors' responsibilities 23 Company’s directors and advisers 24 Independent auditors' report 25 Income statement 25 Statements of recognised income and expense 26 Balance sheets 27 Cash flow statements 28 Notes to the financial statements 57 Five year summary and financial calendar 58 Appendix - Chairman's preambles from previous annual reports Games Workshop Group PLC 1 CHAIRMAN’S PREAMBLE We have had a better year. Not as good as we would like, not as good as it will be, but better nevertheless. The better year is due, of course, to our new chief executive, Mark Wells. Mark has worked here since the turn of the century and has gradually made himself the leader the business needs. I didn't so much give him the role as watch while he took it away from me. We complement each other very well.
    [Show full text]
  • Imbeaumbsthesis.Pdf (2.574Mb)
    Copyright is owned by the Author of the thesis. Permission is given for a copy to be downloaded by an individual for the purpose of research and private study only. The thesis may not be reproduced elsewhere without the permission of the Author. Title Page Cooperation in Competitive Miniatures Games: An examination of coopetitive behaviour A thesis presented in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Business Studies in Management at Massey University Auckland, New Zealand Jean-Sebastien Imbeau 2019 1 Abstract The following study uses competitive miniatures board games as a novel research environment to examine how, when and why individuals choose between cooperative and competitive strategies to advance their interests, both within the game match itself and within the broader community of gamers, and what factors affect these decisions. Drawing on literature from the study fields of coopetition (a situation of simultaneous cooperation and competition) and decision making, the study focuses on environmental factors and systemic features of the games and game cultures, and how these impact player decisions and perspectives on the competitive/cooperative paradox. Findings supported value creation as a key motivator in player behaviour. Participants overall expressed a non zero-sum understanding of the coopetitive environment. The existence of a coopetitive tension within competitive miniatures games was acknowledged across the board, although its severity was perceived differently across participants. Participants also identified a number of key strategies and tools used to mitigate or navigate this tension. These included reciprocity, communicating intent, following the principles of clean play, and adhering to a set of unwritten rules and norms around sportsmanship and fairness.
    [Show full text]
  • The Not-So-Spectacular Now by Gabriel Broshy
    cinemann The State of the Industry Issue Cinemann Vol. IX, Issue 1 Fall/Winter 2013-2014 Letter from the Editor From the ashes a fire shall be woken, A light from the shadows shall spring; Renewed shall be blade that was broken, The crownless again shall be king. - Recited by Arwen in Peter Jackson’s adaption of the final installment ofThe Lord of the Rings Trilogy, The Return of the King, as her father prepares to reforge the shards of Narsil for Ara- gorn This year, we have a completely new board and fantastic ideas related to the worlds of cinema and television. Our focus this issue is on the states of the industries, highlighting who gets the money you pay at your local theater, the positive and negative aspects of illegal streaming, this past summer’s blockbuster flops, NBC’s recent changes to its Thursday night lineup, and many more relevant issues you may not know about as much you think you do. Of course, we also have our previews, such as American Horror Story’s third season, and our reviews, à la Break- ing Bad’s finale. So if you’re interested in the movie industry or just want to know ifGravity deserves all the fuss everyone’s been having about it, jump in! See you at the theaters, Josh Arnon Editor-in-Chief Editor-in-Chief Senior Content Editor Design Editors Faculty Advisor Josh Arnon Danny Ehrlich Allison Chang Dr. Deborah Kassel Anne Rosenblatt Junior Content Editor Kenneth Shinozuka 2 Table of Contents Features The Conundrum that is Ben Affleck Page 4 Maddie Bender How Real is Reality TV? Page 6 Chase Kauder Launching
    [Show full text]
  • Portfolio of Investments
    PORTFOLIO OF INVESTMENTS CTIVP® – Lazard International Equity Advantage Fund, March 31, 2020 (Unaudited) (Percentages represent value of investments compared to net assets) Investments in securities Common Stocks 96.4% Common Stocks (continued) Issuer Shares Value ($) Issuer Shares Value ($) Australia 6.4% Legrand SA 131,321 8,375,908 AGL Energy Ltd. 880,686 9,216,678 L’Oreal SA 104,607 27,073,419 Aristocrat Leisure Ltd. 728,775 9,443,206 Orange SA 949,535 11,496,452 ASX Ltd. 162,820 7,642,885 Peugeot SA 1,014,598 13,209,331 BHP Group Ltd. 471,264 8,549,345 Schneider Electric SE 553,434 46,777,833 CIMIC Group Ltd. 332,784 4,713,315 STMicroelectronics NV 400,446 8,608,225 CSL Ltd. 166,037 30,097,798 Total SA 1,095,152 41,264,011 Fortescue Metals Group Ltd. 4,669,354 28,614,857 Total 209,274,345 (a),(b) IDP Education Ltd. 447,152 3,487,548 Germany 4.2% Inghams Group Ltd. 1,200,179 2,405,115 Adidas AG 22,586 5,014,708 Magellan Financial Group Ltd. 729,823 19,356,167 Allianz SE, Registered Shares 319,746 54,451,936 Regis Resources Ltd. 1,318,187 2,929,557 Continental AG 32,324 2,304,645 Santos Ltd. 4,606,425 9,460,470 Dialog Semiconductor PLC(c) 82,878 2,154,248 (c) Saracen Mineral Holdings Ltd. 3,513,246 7,900,242 Hugo Boss AG 273,602 6,848,821 Technology One Ltd. 897,813 4,336,750 MTU Aero Engines AG 74,698 10,801,095 Total 148,153,933 SAP SE 91,344 10,198,367 Austria 0.2% Siemens Healthineers AG 179,517 6,939,504 OMV AG 81,189 2,221,890 Total 98,713,324 Raiffeisen Bank International AG 111,223 1,599,856 Hong Kong 3.9% Total 3,821,746 CK Hutchison Holdings Ltd.
    [Show full text]