Canadian Law Library Review Revue Canadienne Des Is Published By: Bibliothéques De Droit Est Publié Par
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Volume/Tome 39 (2014) No. 1 ISSN 1180-176X CANADIAN LAW LIBRARY REVIEW REVUE CANADIENNE DES BIBLIOTHÈQUES DE DROIT EDITOR SUSAN BARKER CONTENTS SOMMAIRE Digital Services and Reference Librarian 2014 2014 Bora Laskin Law Library University of Toronto Canadian Law Library Review Revue canadian des biliothèques de droit T: (416) 978-5799 Volume 39, No. 1 Tome 39 No. 1 E-mail: [email protected] FROM THE EDITOR DE LA RÉDACTRICE 4 ASSOCIATE EDITOR WENDY HEARDER-MOAN PRESIDENT’S LETTER LE MOT DE LA PRÉSIDENTE 6 WHM Library Services E-mail: [email protected] featured ARTICLES ARTICLES DE FOND Edited by Amy Kaufman and Leslie Taylor ADVERTISING MANAGER ANNAMARIE BERGEN The Legal History of Same-Sex Marriage in Canada 8 Legal Information Specialist By Andrea Battiston Osler, Hoskin & Harcourt LLP E-mail: [email protected] The Canadian Association of Law Libraries/Assocation Canadienne des biliothèques de droit: 13 A Continuing History, 1988-2012 EDITOR EMERITUS By Janet M. Moss NANCY MCCORMACK Librarian and Associate Professor Beyond the Rules: Creating Great Writers - Not Just Legal Writers 23 Lederman Law Library By Adam Lamparello and Charles E. MacLean Faculty of Law Queen’s University REVIEWS RECENSIONS E-mail: [email protected] Edited by Nancy McCormack and Kim Clarke The 3 Secrets to Effective Time Investment: How to Achieve More Success with Less Stress 25 LESLIE TAYLOR Reviewed by Helen Mok Reference/Technical Services Librarian The Canadian Constitution 25 Lederman Law Library Reviewed by Emily Landriault Queen’s University E-mail: [email protected] Caring and the Law 26 Reviewed by Dani Pahulje PLANNING AND SOLICITATIONS EDITOR SUSANNAH TREDWELL Constitutional Labour Rights in Canada: Farm Workers and the Fraser Case 26 Library Manager Reviewed by Kim Nayyer Lawson Lundell LLP E-mail: stredwell@lawsonlundell Debtor-Creditor Law and Procedure 27 Reviewed by Mary Hemmings BOOK REVIEW EDITORS Emotional Vampires at Work: Dealing with Bosses and Coworkers Who Drain You Dry NANCY MCCORMACK 27 Librarian and Associate Professor Reviewed by Katherine Laundy Lederman Law Library Grateful Leadership: Using the Power of Acknowledgment to Engage All Your People and 28 Faculty of Law Achieve Superior Results Queen’s University E-mail: [email protected] Reviewed by Goldwynn Lewis Linguistic Justice: International Law and Language Policy 29 KIM CLARKE Reviewed by Anna Szot-Sacawa Director, Bennett Jones Law Library Modern Warfare: Armed Groups, Private Militaries, Humanitarian Organizations, and the Law 30 Faculty of Law Reviewed by Stephen Spong University of Calgary E-mail: [email protected] A Primer on American Labor Law 30 Reviewed by Anjali Dandekar INDEXER JANET MACDONALD Reasonable Accommodation: Managing Religious Diversity 31 Macdonald Information Consultants Reviewed by Patrick Fawcett E-mail: [email protected] BIBLIOGRAPHIC NOTES CHRONIQUE BIBLIOGRAPHIQUE 32 FRENCH LANGUAGE EDITOR Submitted by Susan Jones NATHALIE LÉONARD Bibliothécaire de référence LOCAL AND REGIONAL update MISE À JOUR LOCALE ET RÉGIONALE 36 Bibliothèque de droit Brian-Dickson Edited by Mary Jane Kearns-Padgett Université d’Ottawa E-mail: [email protected] NEWS FROM FURTHER AFIELD NouvELLES DE L’ÉTRANGER News from the UK COLUMN EDITORS 39 BIBLIOGRAPHIC NOTES Jackie Fishleigh and Pete Smith SUSAN JONES Developments in the U.S. Law Libraries 42 Technical Services Librarian Anne L. Abramson Gerard V. La Forest Law Library University of New Brunswick E-mail: [email protected] LOCAL AND REGIONAL UPDATE MARY JANE KEARNS-PADGETT Librarian Hamilton Law Association E-mail: [email protected] 2014 Canadian Law Library Review/Revue canadienne des biliothèques de droit, Volume/Tome 39, No. 1 3 From the Editor de la rédactrice This has been a hard winter article to find out what that acronym stands for! for most Canadians; we have weathered snow storms, ... the Letter from Australia as ice storms, power outages and record breaking low well as the Notes from the UK temperatures but, as I write and Developments in US Law this, I am happy to say the days are getting longer, the sun is Libraries highlight not only the beginning to shine and soon the “Winter of 2013/2014” will be a differences but the similarities faded memory. One distraction between our respective from the pains of winter has Susan Barker been the Sochi Olympics; jurisdictions... national pride, medal counts, hockey supremacy and stories of sporting heroism have all been welcome diversions. But I want to take a moment to thank our contributors from the Sochi Olympics have not been without controversy. Prior overseas who put a great deal of time and effort into bringing to the opening of the games, Russia’s anti-gay propaganda the world to our doorstep. Although Margaret Hutchison is laws received worldwide attention which resulted in calls absent from this issue as she was “somewhere in Orlando, to boycott the games. While a full boycott did not happen, wearing mouse ears and waving [her] Harry Potter wand” there was both overt and covert protest of Russia’s anti-gay at the time of the deadline, her Letter from Australia as well stance in Russia as well as throughout the world. As there as the Notes from the UK and Developments in US Law are heroes in the sporting world, the battle for gay rights also Libraries highlight not only the differences but the similarities has a particular set of heroes. In Canada, these heroes are between our respective jurisdictions; questions like should the many individuals have been willing to take a risk and court proceedings be televised or should witnesses be fight for equality in the courts. Within that context, it is timely allowed to wear a niqab while testifying in court will be familiar that this issue of the Canadian Law Library Review/ Revue to all of us I am sure. Issues like changes in the process of canadienne des bibliothèques de droit features Andrea legal education and even the value to law librarians of good Battiston’s Legal History of Same-Sex Marriage in Canada. writing skills are also timely and familiar. This article traces the evolution of marital rights for same- While on the subject of good writing skills, our final sex couples in Canada from suppression to entrenchment, feature article by Adam Lamparello and Charles E McLean, through case law and legislation; the article is not only Beyond the Rules: Creating Great Writers – Not Just Legal historically interesting but a good starting point for further Writers, provides a number of tips for writers who aspire to research into the topic. go beyond good writing to great writing. I think we can all benefit from that. This series as a whole has And finally, my mother who has a saying for practically everything will often say to me “remember, pride been a wonderful window into goeth before a fall,’ and she is right. When the last issue of the Review went out I was sure it was perfect, error free the history and evolution of and accurate in every way, given that it had been edited the Association. to exhaustion. But I was wrong; we are not perfect yet. Balfour Halévy, who has a prodigious institutional memory, Speaking of historically interesting, this issue also pointed out to me that Phillip Cohen of Oceana Publishing contains the final instalment of Janet Moss’s continuing was incorrectly identified as Morris Cohen in our summary of history of CALL/ABCD. Part IV: Relationships and Margaret Bank’s interview. I apologize for the mistake. Conferences. This series as a whole has been a wonderful window into the history and evolution of the Association. With Relationships and Conferences, Janet focuses on how the Association had made and continues to make connections L’hiver a été dur pour la plupart des Canadiens. Nous avons with law and general library associations throughout Canada traversé des tempêtes de neige, des tempêtes de verglas, and the world. She also looks at how our relationships with des pannes de courant et des records de froid; cependant, vendors have evolved in the last twenty-five years and the en écrivant ces lignes, j’ai le plaisir de souligner le fait que les role the Vendor Liaison Committee played in that evolution. journées s’allongent, que le soleil commence à briller et que Lastly, we learn all about the conferences, the fun, the l’« hiver 2013-2014 » sera bientôt un vague souvenir. Les programs and B.A.C.C.H.U.S. You will have to read the Jeux de Sotchi, notamment, nous ont fait oublier les rigueurs 4 2014 Canadian Law Library Review/Revue canadienne des biliothèques de droit, Volume/Tome 39, No. 1 de l’hiver; la fierté nationale, la récolte de médailles, la domination au hockey et les récits d’héroïsme sportif ont été ...sa « lettre d’Australie », ses pour nous des distractions bienvenues. Toutefois, les Jeux « notes du Royaume-Uni » olympiques de Sotchi n’ont pas été exempts de controverse. Avant l’ouverture des Jeux, les lois russes liées à la et son article portant sur propagande homophobe ont suscité une attention mondiale l’évolution de la situation dans qui a entraîné des appels au boycott de l’événement. Même s’il n’y a pas eu de boycott complet, la position homophobe les bibliothèques de droit des de la Russie a été contestée ouvertement et implicitement, en Russie et dans le monde entier. Tout comme le milieu du États-Unis mettent en évidence sport a ses héros, la lutte pour les droits des homosexuels non seulement les différences, compte ses propres figures héroïques. Au Canada, ces héros sont les nombreuses personnes qui assument des risques mais aussi les similitudes entre et se battent pour l’égalité devant les tribunaux.