April 3, 2020 Enbridge Line 3 Public Comments

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

April 3, 2020 Enbridge Line 3 Public Comments April 3, 2020 Enbridge Line 3 Public Comments Minnesota Pollution Control Agency Attn: Commissioner Laura Bishop 520 Lafayette Road North St. Paul, MN 55155-4194 Dear Commissioner Bishop: Thank you for the opportunity to offer comments on the 401 Certification for the Enbridge Line 3 Replacement Project. Minnesotans value our natural resources, including water bodies, ground water and wetlands. Protecting our water resources is important and we believe replacing an aging pipeline with a new, safer, state-of-the-art model is one way to do so. Since the beginning of this proposed replacement project, Enbridge has worked diligently to develop a plan that will protect water resources, which, in some areas, even meant modifying the route from its current one to minimize impacts on wetlands and waterbodies. Minnesota sets a high bar in regard to environmental protections – as it should. In preparing its draft 401 Certification application to address comments put forth by the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency (MPCA) and others, the application reflects multiple changes to further minimize impacts to water quality. Enbridge also has developed an Environmental Protection Plan (EPP) that details best-management practices and mitigation measures to be used during construction to minimize construction related impacts. Some examples in the EPP of these practices include clearing construction workspace using low pressure equipment, using timber mats to limit wetland disturbance, installing erosion control devises, minimizing in-stream work activities and identifying additional temporary workspace outside of wetlands to the extent possible. In areas where there are unavoidable impacts, Enbridge plans to minimize the footprint of the construction workspace and use best-management practices, which will be guided by data collected in the field, such as saturation, water levels, and soil stability. Over the past two years the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission has approved – and reapproved – the Certificate of Need and route permit for this project – confirming that the existing Line 3 needs to be replaced. Replacing an aging pipeline with new, modern construction is the safest and best option for protecting the environment and communities. In addition to the enhanced protection, this replacement pipeline will provide to the environment, it also represents a $2.6 billion private investment in Minnesota’s energy infrastructure. Construction will bring 8,600 family-sustaining jobs and an economic boost for northern Minnesota communities. Over the many years now that the Line 3 Replacement Project has been in the environmental review and permitting process, it has become the most thoroughly planned and studied pipeline project in state history. We ask that the MPCA promptly process and approve the permits and authorizations needed for the Line 3 Replacement Project to move forward. Sincerely, Minority Leader Kurt Daudt Deputy Minority Leader Anne Neu Representative Tony Albright Representative Paul Anderson Representative Jeff Backer Representative Dave Baker Representative Peggy Bennett Representative Brian Daniels Representative Greg Davids Representative Lisa Demuth Representative Bob Dettmer Representative Sondra Erickson Representative Dan Fabian Representative Mary Franson Representative Pat Garofalo Representative Steve Green Representative Matt Grossell Representative Glenn Gruenhagen Representative Bob Gunther Representative Barb Haley Representative Rod Hamilton Representative John Heinrich Representative Josh Heintzeman Representative Jerry Hertaus Representative Brian Johnson Representative Deb Kiel Representative Ron Kresha Representative Sandy Layman Representative Eric Lucero Representative Dale Lueck Representative Joe McDonald Representative Shane Mekeland Representative Jim Nash Representative Nathan Nelson Representative Bud Nornes Representative Paul Novotny Representative Tim O’Driscoll Representative Marion O’Neill Representative John Petersburg Representative Nels Pierson Representative John Poston Representative Duane Quam Representative Kristin Robbins Representative Linda Runbeck Representative Joe Schomacker Representative Peggy Scott Representative Chris Swedzinski Representative Tama Theis Representative Paul Torkelson Representative Dean Urdahl Representative Bob Vogel Representative Nolan West .
Recommended publications
  • 2020 Final Public Subsidy Payments
    CAMPAIGN FINANCE AND PUBLIC DISCLOSURE BOARD RELEASES FINAL PUBLIC SUBSIDY PAYMENT AMOUNTS FOR 2020 ELECTION During 2020 the Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board distributed $2,131,887 in public subsidy payments to 349 candidates running for state senate or state representative. The 349 candidates who received a public subsidy payment represent 78% of the 449 legislative candidates who were on the general election ballot. A list of qualifying candidates and the payments they received is attached. Of the 504 candidates who filed for state legislative office this year, 401 (79.3%) signed voluntary agreements to abide by spending limits and other conditions required to be eligible for public subsidy payments for their campaigns. To qualify for public subsidy a candidate must: • be opposed at either the primary or general election, • appear on the general election ballot, • sign and file a public subsidy agreement with the Board to abide by applicable campaign expenditure limits, and • raise a specified amount in contributions from individuals eligible to vote in Minnesota counting only the first $50 from each donor. Money for the public subsidy program comes from the state general fund. A portion of public subsidy money is allocated to specific parties and districts based on taxpayer checkoffs on income and property tax returns. By office and party, the total public subsidy payments totaled: DFL RPM State Senate $670,054 $393,772 House of Representatives $663,589 $404,471 Total $1,333,643 $798,243 DFL = Democratic Farmer Labor RPM = Republican Party of Minnesota Note: No other major or minor party candidates qualified for a public subsidy payment in 2020.
    [Show full text]
  • 2019 Minnesota House of Representatives Minneapolis and Saint Paul
    2019 Minnesota House of Representatives Minneapolis and Saint Paul Includes Results from 03/20/2019 Special Election North Oaks Brooklyn Park 10 St. Vincent Fridley ¤£ Mahtomedi Humboldt 41A Connie Bernardy DFL Brooklyn Center Warroad ¦¨§694 Lancaster Roseau New Brighton Birchwood Village Roosevelt Arden Hills Hallock Anoka Shoreview Kittson White Bear Lake Badger Gem Lake Vadnais Heights Roseau Williams Lake Bronson 42A Kelly Moller DFL Greenbush 40B Samantha Vang DFL Hilltop Baudette Halma Kennedy Columbia Heights 45A Lyndon R. Carlson DFL Donaldson Lake of the Woods Karlstad Ranier 42B Jamie Becker-Finn DFL Strathcona New Hope International Falls Strandquist 41B Mary Kunesh-Podein DFL Crystal ¦¨§694 Stephen 01A Dan Fabian R ¤£75 Middle River Marshall Argyle Newfolden Littlefork Robbinsdale Little Canada St. Anthony Holt Grygla 59A Fue Lee DFL Oslo Viking ¤£61 Alvarado Warren Roseville Maplewood Koochiching North St. Paul Goodridge Big Falls Thief River Falls 43A Peter M Fischer DFL Pennington 02A Matthew J. Grossell R 60A Diane Loeffler DFL St. Hilaire Orr 45B Mike Freiberg DFL ¤£71 East Grand Forks Plummer Kelliher Ramsey Beltrami Winton Lauderdale 66A Alice Hausman DFL 43B Leon M. Lillie DFL Red Lake Falls Mizpah Ely Oakdale Golden Valley 01B Debra Kiel R Red Lake Oklee Falcon Heights Northome 03A Rob Ecklund DFL Fisher Brooks Effie Cook Crookston Tower Trail Funkley Grand Marais Gully Bigfork 59B Raymond Dehn DFL Polk Mentor Gonvick Cook Clearbrook Blackduck 66B John Lesch DFL Erskine Climax McIntosh Leonard Tenstrike Babbitt Squaw Lake 394 Fosston Clearwater Turtle River ¦¨§ Nielsville Beltrami 60B Mohamud Noor DFL 67A Tim Mahoney DFL Fertile 94 Winger St.
    [Show full text]
  • Minnesota Citizens for the Arts
    MINNESOTA Vote Citizens for the Arts Legislative Candidate Survey 2016 smART! The election on November 8, 2016 will have a huge impact on the arts and on our country. If you agree with thousands of Minnesotans who believe that the arts matter, you’ll want to know where legislators stand. IMPORTANT: Visit the Secretary of State’s website to fnd out your district and where to vote: http://pollfnder.sos.state.mn.us/ READ: We’ve asked all legislative candidates fve questions about current arts issues so they can tell you how they would vote. Due to limited space, comments were limited to 3 sentences. To see full responses visit our website at www.artsmn.org ALL STARS: Look for the symbol telling you which legislators have been awarded an Arts All Star from MCA for their exceptional support for the arts at the legislature! CONNECT: With MCA on Facebook, Twitter @MNCitizen, and our website www.artsmn.org. We’ll make sure you stay informed. ASK: If your candidates didn’t respond to the survey, make sure to ask them these questions when you see them on the campaign trail! ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ Minnesota Citizens for the Arts is a non-partisan statewide arts advocacy organization whose mission is to ensure the opportunity for all people to have access to and involvement in the arts. MCA organizes the arts com- munity and lobbies the Minnesota State Legislature and U.S. Congress on issues pertaining to the nonproft arts. MCA does not endorse candidates for public ofce. MCA’s successes include passing the Clean Water, Land and Legacy Amendment in 2008 which created dedi- cated funding for the arts in the Minnesota State Constitution for the next 25 years, and the Creative Minnesota research project at CreativeMN.org.
    [Show full text]
  • 2020 Minnesota House of Representatives Seating Chart
    The Minnesota House of Representatives House Leadership Seat Melissa Hortman .................................... 139 Minnesota House of Representatives Public Information Services, 651-296-2146 or 800-657-3550 Speaker of the House District Room* 296- Seat Ryan Winkler.......................................... 102 44A Klevorn, Ginny (DFL) .........581 ....... 5511 ..... 104 Majority Leader 37A Koegel, Erin (DFL) .............375 ....... 5369 ..... 126 48B Kotyza-Witthuhn, Carlie (DFL) ....567 ............7449 ...........81 Golden Valley—45B Bloomington—49B Shelly Christensen Kurt Daudt ............................................... 23 Mike Freiberg Stillwater—39B 58A Koznick, Jon (R) .................229 ....... 6926 ......... 5 Seat 129 Steve Elkins Seat 135 Minority Leader Seat 124 9B Kresha, Ron (R) ...................207 ....... 4247 ....... 12 Seat 6 41B Kunesh-Podein, Mary (DFL)... 445 ..........4331 ......... 97 Seat 1 Seat 11 Mary Franson Luverne—22A Alexandria—8B Joe Schomacker 5B Layman, Sandy (R) ..............233 ....... 4936 ....... 38 Shane Mekeland House Officers Clear Lake—15B Maplewood—53A Rosemount—57B St. Peter—19A Jeff Brand 59A Lee, Fue (DFL) ....................485 ....... 4262 ..... 125 Seat 128 John Huot Tou Xiong Tou Seat 134 Patrick D. Murphy .......... 142 Marilee Davis .................. 141 Seat 123 Seat 139 Chief Clerk Desk Clerk Melissa Hortman 66B Lesch, John (DFL) ...............563 ....... 4224 ..... 116 Timothy M. Johnson ....... 143 David G. Surdez ............. 140 Brooklyn Park—36B Seat 7 Seat 2 26A Liebling, Tina (DFL) ...........477 ....... 0573 ..... 114 Speaker of the House Seat 12 Peggy Scott Ron Kresha 1st Asst. Chief Clerk Legislative Clerk John Poston Andover—35B Little Falls—9B Brooklyn Center—40B Lake Shore—9A International Falls—3A 4A Lien, Ben (DFL) ..................415 ....... 5515 ....... 72 Gail C. Romanowski ....... 144 Bob Meyerson ................... 69 South St. Paul—52A Samantha Vang Seat 127 2nd Asst.
    [Show full text]
  • MACTE Weekly Legislative Update, 2.16.20 Prepared by Cyndy Crist, MACTE Legislative and Policy Liaison 2020 Session Underway. Th
    MACTE Weekly Legislative Update, 2.16.20 Prepared by Cyndy Crist, MACTE Legislative and Policy Liaison 2020 Session Underway. The Minnesota Legislature opened its 2020 session on Tuesday, February 11. As in all even-numbered years, this shorter session will focus on a bonding bill as well as other policy and funding issues it may choose to address. It seems likely that many of the policy issues that were included in omnibus bills last year but ultimately not enacted because of the deep divisions between the House, Senate, and Governor will be brought up again this year. This could include many of the preparation and licensure issues of interest to us in 2019, including changes in the tiered licensure structure and measures to increase the diversity of teachers in our state. In addition, the predicted budget surplus will be much on the minds of legislators as they decide whether to use or save surplus dollars and/or cut planned spending to reflect the additional funding. The committee structure from 2019 remains unchanged, although two new legislators have now been sworn in. In House District 60A, DFLer Sydney Jordan won a special election to fill the seat left vacant by the death of Diane Loeffler. House District 30A will now be represented by Republican Paul Novotny who was elected to fill the seat left vacant by the resignation of Nick Zerwas. Since the new members are of the same party as the incumbents they are replacing, there is no change in the balance between the two parties in the House. It is also worth noting that all members of the House and Senate are up for election this year, and to date, approximately 14 current members have announced that they will not be seeking re-election.
    [Show full text]
  • AMSD Member Districts Minnesota House of Representatives 2017 1
    AMSD Member Districts Minnesota House of Representatives 2017 House School District District Legislator Twitter Facebook Anoka-Hennepin 31A Kurt Daudt @kdaudt http://www.facebook.com/KDaudtMN 31B Cal (Calvin) K. Bahr @calbahrsd31 https://www.facebook.com/Bahrforhouse/ 34A Joyce Peppin @JoycePeppin http://www.facebook.com/joycepeppin 35A Abigail Whelan @abigailWhelan https://www.facebook.com/WhelanforHouse 35B Peggy Scott N/A https://www.facebook.com/PeggyScottForMNHouse 36A Mark Uglem N/A http://www.facebook.com/repmarkuglem 36B Melissa Hortman @melissahortman https://www.facebook.com/MelissaHortman 37A Erin Koegel @erinma14 https://www.facebook.com/erinformn 37B Nolan West N/A https://www.facebook.com/NolanWestforMinnesota 38A Linda Runbeck @lindacrunbeck http://www.facebook.com/pages/Linda-Runbeck-for-MN-House/113284255359047 40B Debra Hilstrom @debrahilstrom http://www.facebook.com/debra.hilstrom 41A Connie Bernardy @conniebernardy https://www.facebook.com/RepConnieBernardy/ Bloomington 49B Paul Rosenthal @PaulRosenthalMN http://www.facebook.com/citizensforrosenthal 50A Linda Slocum N/A https://www.facebook.com/linda.slocum.79 50B Andrew Carlson N/A https://www.facebook.com/ElectAndrewCarlson/ Brooklyn Center 40B Debra Hilstrom @debrahilstrom http://www.facebook.com/debra.hilstrom Burnsville-Eagan-Savage 51A Sandra A. Masin @Masin4Rep https://www.facebook.com/pages/Sandra-Masin/120752178235 51B Laurie Halverson @LaurieHalverson http://www.facebook.com/pages/Representative-Laurie-Halverson/415376705222306 55A Bob Loonan @BobLoonan https://www.facebook.com/BobLoonanforHouse
    [Show full text]
  • 2018 Election Directory of the Minnesota Legislature
    2018 ELECTION DIRECTORY for the 2019-2020 MINNESOTA LEGISLATURE Minnesota House of Representatives Nov. 7, 2018 2019-2020 House Membership Statistics List as of Nov. 7, 2018 59 Republican members 75 DFL members 86 members are men 48 members are women 46 Republican men 40 DFL men 13 Republican women 35 DFL women Newly elected members 39 newly elected members 5 newly elected Republican members 34 newly elected DFL members 29.1 percent of 2019-20 members did not serve last session 20 newly elected members are men 19 newly elected members are women 86.4 percent of incumbents on the ballot were re-elected 15 Republican incumbents lost (includes Rep. Jim Knoblach who suspended his campaign Sept. 21) 0 DFL incumbents lost 24 seats were open at the time of the election 2 races were uncontested (Mahoney, Pelowski, Jr.) New House DFL members Patty Acomb ................................. 44B Dave Lislegard ................................ 6B Kristin Bahner.............................. 34B Jamie Long .................................... 61B Robert Bierman ...........................57A Alice Mann ................................... 56B Jeff Brand ......................................19A Kelly Moller ..................................42A Hunter Cantrell ............................56A Kelly Morrison ............................. 33B Michelle (Shelly) Christensen .... 39B Mohamud Noor ........................... 60B Anne Claflin .................................54A John Persell .....................................5A Heather Edelson ..........................49A
    [Show full text]
  • Minnesota House of Representatives Bonding Bill Roll Call Vote Total 75 Yea and 57 Nay
    Minnesota House of Representatives bonding bill roll call vote Total 75 yea and 57 nay. Does not meet required 81 yea votes to pass. July 20, 2020 44B DFL Rep. Patty Acomb Minnetonka Y 55B R Rep. Tony Albright Prior Lake N 12B R Rep. Paul Anderson Starbuck N 12A R Rep. Jeff Backer Browns Valley N 34B DFL Rep. Kristin Bahner Maple Grove Y 31B R Rep. Cal Bahr East Bethel N 17B R Rep. Dave Baker Willmar N 42B DFL Rep. Jamie Becker-Finn Roseville Y 27A R Rep. Peggy Bennett Albert Lea N 41A DFL Rep. Connie Bernardy New Brighton Y 57A DFL Rep. Robert Bierman Apple Valley Y 47B R Rep. Greg Boe Chaska N 19A DFL Rep. Jeff Brand St. Peter Y 56A DFL Rep. Hunter Cantrell Savage Y 50B DFL Rep. Andrew Carlson Bloomington Y 45A DFL Rep. Lyndon Carlson, Sr. Crystal Y Rep. Michelle (Shelly) 39B DFL Christensen Stillwater Y 54A DFL Rep. Anne Claflin South St. Paul Y 19B DFL Rep. Jack Considine Jr. Mankato Y 24B R Rep. Brian Daniels Faribault N 31A R Rep. Kurt Daudt Crown N 28B R Rep. Greg Davids Preston N 63A DFL Rep. Jim Davnie Minneapolis Y 59B DFL Rep. Raymond Dehn Minneapolis Y 13A R Rep. Lisa Demuth Cold Spring N 39A R Rep. Bob Dettmer Forest Lake N 21B R Rep. Steve Drazkowski Mazeppa N 03A DFL Rep. Rob Ecklund International Falls Y 49A DFL Rep. Heather Edelson Edina Y 49B DFL Rep. Steve Elkins Bloomington Y 15A R Rep. Sondra Erickson Princeton NV 01A R Rep.
    [Show full text]
  • – 2015 – MINNESOTA LEGISLATIVE SCORECARD CLEAN WATER ACTION’S 2015 Minnesota Legislative Scorecard
    – 2015 – MINNESOTA LEGISLATIVE SCORECARD CLEAN WATER ACTION’S 2015 Minnesota Legislative Scorecard Clean Water Action’s goal is to protect and restore our lakes, rivers and streams now and for future generations. We work to protect Minnesota’s health and water by making systemic change. We educate the public, develop grassroots citizen leaders and mobilize our members to get involved in policy decisions. This is a comprehensive scorecard for the 2015 legislative session and the special session that was held in June. Clean Water Action’s Legislative Scorecard provides a permanent record that scores every Minnesota state legislator on their votes that affect the issues of clean, renewable energy, water quality, and toxics in our environment. These were the primary areas of focus for Clean Water Action this year. To find out who your legislators are, visit http://www.gis.leg.mn/OpenLayers/districts/ HOW LEGISLATORS WERE SCORED: The Clean Water Action Legislative Scorecard provides objective, factual information about the environmental + = A pro-environment vote voting records of members of the Minnesota Legislature. – = An anti-environment vote The votes included in this scorecard took place during the 2015 legislative session and focus heavily, although not NA = The legislator did not vote exclusively, on votes that would seriously affect the issues of clean, renewable energy, water quality, and toxics in our environment. The votes that are included are recorded votes in which the entire body of either the Senate or House, had the opportunity to participate. Senate legislators were scored on 5 votes on important environmental issues acted on in 2015, with House legislators being scored on 7.
    [Show full text]
  • Regular City Council – February 10, 2020
    CITY OF MADISON AGENDA AND NOTICE OF MEETING Regular Meeting of the City Council – 5:00 PM Monday February 10, 2020 Madison Municipal Building 1. CALL THE REGULAR MEETING TO ORDER Mayor Thole will call the meeting to order. 2. APPROVE AGENDA Approve the agenda as posted in accordance with the Open Meetings law, and herein place all agenda items on the table for discussion. A MOTION is in order. (Council) 3. APPROVE MINUTES Page 1 A copy of the January 27, 2020 regular meeting minutes are enclosed. A MOTION is in order. (Council) 4. PUBLIC PETITIONS, REQUESTS, HEARINGS, AND COMMUNICATIONS (public/mayor/council) Members of the audience wishing to address the Council with regard to an agenda item, presentation of a petition, utility customer hearing, or a general communication should be recognized at this time. A MOTION may be in order (Public/Council) 5. CONSENT AGENDA A. Cash Investment Balance – January 2020 - receive Page 4 B. MMUA Training – February 10, 2020 – receive Page 5 C. MRES Board Meeting – February 13, 2020 – receive Page 6 D. MRES Legislative Line – February 4, 2020 – receive Page 8 E. LqP Computer Commuter – February 2020 – receive Page 13 F. Council Revenue/Expenses – January 2020 – receive Page 14 G. Senator Dahmes – January 2020 – receive Page 17 H. Liquor Store Report – January 2020 – receive Page 20 I. MDH Sanitary Survey – receive Page 22 J. MEDA Loan Note Status – January 2020 – receive Page 32 K. Mediacom Franchise Fee – 2019 – receive Page 33 L. Regular Drill/Special Meeting – January 2020 - receive Page 34 M. Water Plant Report – January 2020 – receive Page 37 N.
    [Show full text]
  • Edallies Legislative Scorecard Educational Excellence & Equity at the Capitol
    EdAllies Legislative Scorecard Educational Excellence & Equity at the Capitol 2017–2018 TABLE OF CONTENTS EdAllies Legislative Scorecard Educational Excellence and Equity at the Capitol 2017-2018 Introduction 2 What’s in the Scorecard 3 Issues Diverse & Effective Educators 4 School Discipline 11 Data & Transparency 14 Welcoming & Accessible Schools 18 Parent Choice 22 Final Votes: The Omnibus Bills 26 Vote Tables House 29 Senate 40 EdAllies Legislative Scorecard 2017–2018 1 INTRODUCTION Dear partners, At EdAllies, we work to ensure that every young Minnesotan has access to a rigorous and engaging education—work we simply cannot do without empowered, informed advocates. Yet, too often, Minnesota’s confusing policymaking process makes it hard to understand what’s happening with education policy change at the Capitol. Given our state’s urgent need to address opportunity and achievement gaps, this is unacceptable. To accomplish more for Minnesota students, we need greater transparency around policy progress and setbacks. We made this legislative scorecard to help you understand education efforts over the last two years, also known as the legislative biennium. We recap key policies that legislators introduced, our position, and, when possible, the votes. Though our policymakers didn’t make as much progress for Minnesota students as we hoped during the 90th biennium, they made some notable changes. For example, our legislators reached across the aisle to: • open Minnesota’s doors to great out-of-state and alternatively prepared educators; • support new programs to recruit and retain teachers of color; • advance trailblazing legislation to disaggregate student achievement data, and more. Of course, there’s much more work to do to set up all Minnesota students for success.
    [Show full text]
  • SC COLA Directory-Reference June 2020
    Protecting our lakes, rivers and waterways today and tomorrow Directory & Reference For distribution to members only June 2020 We thank our sponsors because they help us meet our goals. Please buy from them and tell them you saw their ad here. Please note that SC COLA is not responsible for their goods or services. EROSION CONTROL HILLSIDE STABILIZATION LAND RECLAMATION Before Installation After Call: (651) 353-5144 Email: [email protected] www.midwesterosiontech.com 1 2 3 CONTENTS About SC COLA ......................................................................................................................... 5 SC COLA Contacts ................................................................................................................. 6-7 Fundraising Ideas ....................................................................................................................... 8 Educational Resources .............................................................................................................. 9 Grant Sources ............................................................................................................................ 9 Service Providers ................................................................................................................ 10-13 City/Township, County and Government Contacts .............................................................. 14-20 4 ABOUT SC COLA SC COLA is a Coalition of Lake Associations in Sherburne County, Minnesota formed in 2017. Working
    [Show full text]