TOBACCO ROAD MOCK TRIAL INVITATIONAL HOSTED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA-CHAPEL HILL AND Chapel Hill/Durham, North Carolina TABULATION ROOM SUMMARY 9-10 November 2007

Team Name/Number Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4 Summary Arizona 338 Δ v. 526 Π v. 307 Δ v. 694 Π v. 304 W L L L W L L L 2 +5 -3 -3 -4 +9 -11 -3 -11 Byebuster 792 Δ v. 614 Π v. 756 Δ v. 346 Π v. 384 Roy Williams W L L L L L W L 2 +1 -6 -9 -16 -4 -30 +6 -3 Campbell 452 Δ v. 440 Π v. 305 Π v. 385 Δ v. 386 JJ Redick L L L L L L W W 2 -21 -28 -7 -12 -20 -23 +8 +6 Duke 304 Π v. 684 Δ v. 441 Π v. 386 Δ v. 338 Melinda Gates L L L L W W W W 4 -11 -16 -8 -10 +5 +3 +11 +3 Duke 305 Π v. 347 Δ v. 452 Δ v. 592 Π v. 440 Richard Nixon L L W W W W L W 5 -3 -11 +12 +7 +14 +2 +1 -18 Eastern Kentucky 592 Π v. 694 Δ v. 324 Π v. 305 Δ v. 761 Paul Farmer W W L L L L W W 4 +28 +14 -1 -3 -2 -14 +3 +15 Eastern Kentucky 593 Δ v. 345 Π v. 344 Δ v. 614 Π v. 760 Rick Wagoner W W L L L L W W 4 +21 +12 -2 -6 -4 -13 +6 +1 Elon 694 Δ v. 592 Π v. 760 Π v. 338 Δ v. 527 Elizabeth Dole L L W L W L L L 2 -14 -28 +9 -7 +11 -9 -1 -11 Furman 584 Π v. 441 Δ v. 684 Δ v. 307 Π v. 344 Charlie Rose W W W W W W W W 8 +16 +9 +6 +3 +23 +10 +5 +4 George Washington 756 Π v. 685 Δ v. 792 Π v. 323 Δ v. 345 Ricardo Lagos W T W W L L W L 4.5 +7 0 +16 +9 -3 -11 +7 -5 George Washington 757 Δ v. 384 Π v. 323 Π v. 526 Δ v. 324 Ken Starr W T W L W W W W 6.5 +7 0 +12 -6 +19 +3 +7 +2 George Washington 758 Δ v. 346 Π v. 306 Δ v. 322 Π v. 307 Susan Athey W L W W W L W W 6 +26 -1 +15 +9 +12 -2 +22 +17 Gonzaga 614 Π v. 792 Δ v. 334 Π v. 593 Δ v. 526 W L W L W W W W 6 +6 -1 +3 -1 +13 +4 +7 +1

Team Name/Number Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4 Summary Gonzaga 615 Δ v. 323 Π v. 526 Π v. 345 Δ v. 621 Randall Wallace L L L L L L W W 2 -1 -5 -13 -24 -2 -4 +28 +22 Gonzaga 616 Δ v. 344 Π v. 345 Δ v. 384 Π v. 322 Judy Woodruff L L W T W W W L 4.5 -10 -14 +7 0 +9 +3 +3 -1 Howard 684 Δ v. 304 Π v. 584 Π v. 441 Δ v. 306 W W L L W W L L 4 +16 +11 -3 -6 +6 +4 -3 -4 Howard 685 Δ v. 756 Π v. 346 Π v. 527 Δ v. 323 Charles Townes T L W W W W W L 5.5 0 -7 +9 +5 +13 +10 +3 -1 North Carolina 526 Π v. 338 Δ v. 615 Δ v. 757 Π v. 614 Gerald Henderson W L W W L L L L 3 +3 -5 +24 +13 -3 -19 -1 -7 North Carolina 527 Δ v. 761 Π v. 620 Δ v. 685 Π v. 694 Sheldon Williams W W L L L L W W 4 +6 +1 -2 -5 -10 -13 +11 +1 Ohio State 306 Π v. 385 Δ v. 758 Δ v. 334 Π v. 684 Andy Baldwin W W L L W W W W 6 +7 +4 -9 -15 +19 +6 +4 +3 Ohio State 307 Π v. 621 Δ v. 338 Π v. 584 Δ v. 758 W W W W L L L L 4 +13 +9 +4 +3 -10 -23 -17 -22 Richmond 760 Π v. 324 Δ v. 694 Π v. 621 Δ v. 593 L L W L W W L L 3 -4 -13 +7 -9 +21 +3 -1 -6 Richmond 761 Π v. 527 Δ v. 386 Δ v. 347 Π v. 592 Dean Smith L L W W L L L L 2 -1 -6 +17 +6 -5 -13 -3 -15 South Carolina-Upstate 620 Π v. 386 Δ v. 527 Δ v. 344 Π v. 347 Carl Kasell W W W W L L W W 6 +33 +16 +5 +2 -7 -13 +3 +2 South Carolina-Upstate 621 Δ v. 307 Π v. 384 Δ v. 760 Π v. 615 Andy Griffith L L W L L L L L 1 -9 -13 +15 -1 -3 -21 -22 -28 Southern California 344 Π v. 616 Δ v. 593 Π v. 620 Δ v. 584 James Polk W W W W W W L L 6 +14 +10 +6 +2 +13 _7 -4 -5 Southern California 345 Π v. 593 Δ v. 616 Δ v. 615 Π v. 756 Paul Wellstone L L T L W W W L 3.5 -12 -21 0 -7 +4 +2 +5 -7 Southern California 346 Π v. 758 Δ v. 685 Π v. 792 Δ v. 441 Thomas Wolfe W L L L W W W L 4 +1 -26 -5 -9 +30 +4 +2 -11

Team Name/Number Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4 Summary Southern California 347 Δ v. 305 Π v. 440 Π v. 761 Δ v. 620 Lewis Black W W L L W W L L 4 +11 +3 -5 -20 +13 +5 -2 -3 Tennessee 440 Π v. 452 Δ v. 347 Π v. 324 Δ v. 305 Chris Matthews W W W W L L W L 5 +28 +21 +20 +5 -1 -4 +18 -1 Tennessee 441 Δ v. 584 Π v. 304 Δ v. 684 Π v. 346 Charles Kuralt L L W W L L W L 3 -9 -16 +10 +8 -4 -6 +11 -2 Wake Forest 384 Π v. 757 Δ v. 621 Π v. 616 Δ v. 792 T L W L L L W L 2.5 0 -7 +1 -15 -3 -9 +3 -6 Wake Forest 385 Δ v. 306 Π v. 322 Δ v. 452 Π v. 334 John Edwards L L L L W W W L 3 -4 -7 -7 -10 +23 +20 +7 -6 Wake Forest 386 Δ v. 620 Π v. 761 Δ v. 304 Π v. 452 Franklin Porter Graham L L L L L L L L 0 -16 -33 -6 -17 -3 -5 -8 -6 Washington and Lee 322 Π v. 334 Δ v. 385 Π v. 758 Δ v. 616 Roy Cooper W L W W W L W L 5 +8 -1 +10 +7 +2 -12 +1 -3 Washington and Lee 323 Π v. 615 Δ v. 757 Δ v. 756 Π v. 685 W W W L W W W L 6 +5 +1 +6 -12 +11 +3 +1 -3 Washington and Lee 324 Δ v. 760 Π v. 592 Δ v. 440 Π v. 757 W W W W W W L L 6 +13 +4 +3 +1 +4 +1 -2 -7 William and Mary 334 Δ v. 322 Π v. 614 Π v. 306 Δ v. 385 Oliver Smithies W L W L L L W L 3 +1 -8 +1 -3 -6 -19 +6 -7

OUTSTANDING TRIAL TEAM AWARDS

1-Team 584, Furman University, 8 2-Team 757, George Washington University, 6.5 3-Team 344, University of Southern California, 6 (CS=22.5, SOO=2.5) 4-Team 758, George Washington University, 6 (CS=19, SOO=7.5) 5-Team 324, Washington & Lee University, 6 (CS=18.5, SOO=6)

Honorable Mention Teams: 6-Team 323, Washington & Lee University, 6 (CS=18.5, SOO=7) 7-Team 306, The Ohio State University, 6 (CS=16, SOO=9) 8-Team 620, University of South Carolina-Upstate, 6 (CS=14, SOO=11) 9-Team 614, Gonzaga University, 6 (CS=12, SOO=13)

OUTSTANDING ATTORNEY AWARDS

20-616, Gonzaga University, Forest Smith, Π 20-620, University of South Carolina-Upstate, Stephen Corby, Π 20-324, Washington & Lee University, Erin Coltrera, Π 20-758, George Washington University, Kevin Horniak, Π

19-684, Howard University, Yosef Wise, Δ 19-614, Gonzaga University, Dan Peck, Δ 19-592, Eastern Kentucky University, Kristeena Winkler, Π 19-685, Howard University, Alyssia Bryant, Π 19-685, Howard University, Marquis Bannetti, Δ

OUTSTANDING WITNESS AWARDS

20-685, Howard University, Marquis Bannetti, Π 20-305, Duke University, Justin Lorseau, Δ

19-322, Washington & Lee University, Thaddeous Larkin, Δ 19-758, George Washington University, Kate Meller-Davis, Π 19-761, University of Richmond, Nelle Seymour, Δ

18-616, Gonzaga University, Meg Houlihan, Π 18-344, University of Southern California, Gracie Li, Δ 18-756, George Washington University, Andrew Blackwell, Δ 18-527, University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill, Emily Laborde, Π 18-323, Washington & Lee University, Andrew Budzinski, Δ