TAYSIDE VALUATION APPEAL PANEL LIST OF APPEALS FOR CONSIDERATION BY THE VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE At The Town & County Hall, The Cross, on 23 October 2020

Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

001 01ANA0082800 ELECTRICITY PLANT (HYDRO) TULCHAN OF GLENISLA ESTATES LTD. £36,600 £36,600 411733 0001 TULCHAN PER EQ ACCOUNTANTS LLP Revaluation 2017 GLENISLA WESTBY 27 September 2017 BLAIRGOWRIE, PERTHSHIRE 64 WEST HIGH STREET PH11 8QW FORFAR, ANGUS DD8 1BJ 002 01ANB0144500 ELECTRICITY PLANT (HYDRO) HUGH NIVEN £30,500 £30,500 411735 0001 CLOVA HYDRO SCHEME PER RYDEN LLP Revaluation 2017 GLENCLOVA 25 ALBYN PLACE 14 April 2017 , ANGUS ABERDEEN DD8 4QS AB10 1YL 003 01ANB0144500 ELECTRICITY PLANT (HYDRO) HUGH NIVEN £10,750 £10,750 411735 0002 CLOVA HYDRO SCHEME PER RYDEN LLP Revaluation 2017 GLENCLOVA 25 ALBYN PLACE 28 June 2017 KIRRIEMUIR, ANGUS ABERDEEN DD8 4QS AB10 1YL 004 01ANB0210750 ELECTRICITY PLANT (HYDRO) GLENPROSEN ESTATES £36,600 £36,600 411732 0001 KILBO PER RUTH WHITE Revaluation 2017 GLENPROSEN HEADKEEPER'S COTTAGE 10 May 2017 KIRRIEMUIR, ANGUS GLENPROSEN DD8 4SD KIRRIEMUIR, ANGUS DD8 4SD 005 01ANF0173500 ELECTRICITY PLANT (AERO) REEDIE RENEWABLES LTD £19,900 £19,900 409147 0001 REEDIE FARM WIND TURBINES PER LYNDA GRANT Revaluation 2017 REEDIE REEDIE FARM 14 April 2017 KIRRIEMUIR, ANGUS WESTMUIR DD8 5LX KIRRIEMUIR ANGUS DD8 5LX

Page 1 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

005 01ANI0884000 MUSEUM ANGUS COUNCIL £6,500 £6,500 £1 016267 0001 TOWN HOUSE PER AVISON YOUNG Revaluation 2017 32 HIGH STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 05 September 2017 KIRRIEMUIR, ANGUS 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD8 4EG GLASGOW G2 5NW 002 01ANI1243000 COLLEGE(PART) DUNDEE & ANGUS COLLEGE £14,400 £14,400 £7,200 £7,200 792648 0001 FAIRLIE HOUSE PER RYDEN LLP Revaluation 2017 KIRKTON HILL 130 ST VINCENT STREET 06 July 2017 KIRRIEMUIR, ANGUS GLASGOW DD8 4JT G2 5HF 003 01ANK0135000 TELECOMMUNICATIONS SITE N A T S (EN ROUTE) PLC £90,500 £90,500 £1 129081 0001 CRAIGOWL PER CLUTTONS Revaluation 2017 TEALING PORTMAN HOUSE 27 September 2017 DUNDEE 2 PORTMAN STREET DD4 0RQ LONDON W1H 6DU 005 01ANK0137000 TELECOMMUNICATIONS SITE ARQIVA SERVICES LTD £21,000 £21,000 £1 802638 0001 CRAIGOWL PER AVISION YOUNG Revaluation 2017 TEALING NORFOLK HOUSE 13 September 2017 DUNDEE 7 NORFOLK STREET DD4 0RQ MANCHESTER M2 1DW 009 01ANK0222500 ELECTRICITY PLANT (AERO) ARK HILL WIND FARM LTD £163,000 £163,000 408092 0001 ARK HILL COVINGTON MILL Revaluation 2017 GLENOGILVY THANKERTON 05 July 2017 BIGGAR FORFAR, ANGUS ML12 6NE DD8 1UP 010 02AFA0031310 BIOGAS-TO-GRID PLANT STRACATHRO RENEWABLE ENERGY LTD £248,000 £248,000 421391 0001 BRAE OF PERT PER HRC LIMITED Update 2018 LAURENCEKIRK, KINCARDINESHIRE 13 HURST ROAD 28 February 2019 AB30 1QR HASSOCKS WEST SUSSEX BN6 9NJ

Page 2 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

012 02AFA0217500 ELECTRICITY PLANT (AERO) J ROBERTSON & SONS £27,900 £27,900 £17,000 £17,000 409228 0001 WHITEFIELD OF DUN PER SAM SYKES Revaluation 2017 MONTROSE, ANGUS DAVIDSON & ROBERTSON 14 September 2017 DD10 9LR 62 BANNATYNE STREET LANARK ML11 7JS 013 02AFC0079500 ELECTRICITY PLANT (HYDRO) SOUTHESK SETTLEMENT £10,400 £10,400 411751 0001 KINNAIRD WEIR PER CHARLES A H GOW FRICS Revaluation 2017 KINNAIRD ESTATE OFFICE 22 June 2017 BRECHIN, ANGUS HAUGHS OF KINNAIRD DD9 6TY BRECHIN DD9 7QZ 014 02ANP0014500 ELECTRICITY PLANT (HYDRO) INVERMARK HYDRO LTD £8,300 £8,300 411736 0001 DALBRACK PER RICHARD COOKE Revaluation 2017 GLENESK DALHOUSIE ESTATES 04 May 2017 BRECHIN, ANGUS ESTATES OFFICE DD9 7YY BRECHIN, ANGUS DD9 6SG 015 02ANP0019100 ELECTRICITY PLANT (HYDRO) INVERMARK HYDRO LTD £20,700 £20,700 411737 0001 AUCHRONIE PER RICHARD COOKE Revaluation 2017 GLENESK DALHOUSIE ESTATES 04 May 2017 BRECHIN, ANGUS ESTATES OFFICE DD9 7YZ BRECHIN, ANGUS DD9 6SG 016 02ANP0037100 ELECTRICITY PLANT (HYDRO) INVERMARK HYDRO LTD £11,900 £11,900 411734 0001 INCHGRUNDLE PER RICHARD COOKE Revaluation 2017 INVERMARK DALHOUSIE ESTATES 04 May 2017 GLENESK ESTATES OFFICE BRECHIN, ANGUS BRECHIN, ANGUS DD9 7YZ DD9 6SG 017 02ANP0038500 ELECTRICITY PLANT (HYDRO) INVERMARK HYDRO £15,700 £15,700 411739 0001 KIRKTON PER RICHARD COOKE Revaluation 2017 INVERMARK DALHOUSIE ESTATES 04 May 2017 GLENESK ESTATES OFFICE BRECHIN, ANGUS BRECHIN, ANGUS DD9 7YZ DD9 6SG

Page 3 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

030 02ANW0697000 MUSEUM ANGUS COUNCIL £6,300 £6,300 019212 0001 28A HIGH STREET PER AVISON YOUNG Revaluation 2017 BRECHIN, ANGUS SUTHERLAND HOUSE 05 May 2017 DD9 6ER 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 033 02ANW1134000 LIBRARY ANGUS COUNCIL £28,000 £28,000 020663 0001 10 ST NINIAN'S SQUARE PER AVISON YOUNG Revaluation 2017 BRECHIN, ANGUS SUTHERLAND HOUSE 05 May 2017 DD9 7AA 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 008 03ANY1713000 SHERIFF COURT HOUSE SCOTTISH COURT SERVICE £83,500 £83,500 £1 024542 0001 MARKET STREET PER AVISON YOUNG Revaluation 2017 FORFAR, ANGUS SUTHERLAND HOUSE 30 August 2017 DD8 3LA 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 024 03ANY2338500 ELECTRICITY PLANT (LANDFILL GA ANGUS COUNCIL £106,500 £106,500 £1 405574 0002 RESTENNETH PER AVISON YOUNG Revaluation 2017 FORFAR, ANGUS SUTHERLAND HOUSE 05 September 2017 DD8 2RL 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 004 03ANY2338500 ELECTRICITY PLANT (LANDFILL GA ANGUS COUNCIL £76,800 £76,800 405574 0003 RESTENNETH PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2017 FORFAR, ANGUS SUTHERLAND HOUSE 26 September 2017 DD8 2RL 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 040 03ANY3132000 MUSEUM ANGUS COUNCIL £26,200 £26,200 £1 026792 0001 MEFFAN INSTITUTE PER AVISON YOUNG Revaluation 2017 20 WEST HIGH STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 05 September 2017 FORFAR, ANGUS 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD8 1BB GLASGOW G2 5NW

Page 4 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

009 03ANY3133000 COLLEGE DUNDEE & ANGUS COLLEGE £12,200 £12,200 £6,000 £6,000 026793 0001 22-26 WEST HIGH STREET PER RYDEN LLP Revaluation 2017 FORFAR, ANGUS 130 ST VINCENT STREET 06 July 2017 DD8 1BA GLASGOW G2 5HF 027 04EFC0194700 ELECTRICITY PLANT (BIOMASS) A G M FORBES £87,500 £87,500 £15,000 £15,000 412102 0001 EAST DENSIDE PER GALBRAITH Revaluation 2017 MONIKIE LYNEDOCH HOUSE 25 August 2017 BROUGHTY FERRY, DUNDEE BAROSSA PLACE DD5 3QE PERTH PH1 5EP 033 04WFC0063500 ELECTRICITY PLANT (AERO) A.A.D. FARMS LTD £20,900 £20,900 408279 0001 BALKEMBACK BALKEMBACK Revaluation 2017 TEALING TEALING 14 April 2017 DUNDEE DUNDEE DD4 0RF DD4 0RF 034 04WFD0174150 ELECTRICITY PLANT (AERO) HENDERSTON RENEWABLES LIMITED £31,250 £31,250 411592 0001 HENDERSTON QUARRY HENDERSTON FARM Revaluation 2017 NEWTYLE NEWTYLE 19 July 2017 BLAIRGOWRIE, PERTHSHIRE BLAIRGOWRIE PH12 8UT PERTHSHIRE PH12 8UT 041 06AFF0608500 ELECTRICITY PLANT (AERO) M4 ENERGY LTD. £32,800 £32,800 410275 0001 HILLHEAD OF ASCURRY FARM 35 HILLSIDE ROAD Revaluation 2017 HILLHEAD OF ASCURRY FORFAR 07 August 2017 LETHAM ANGUS FORFAR, ANGUS DD8 2AY DD8 2ND 044 06AFI0051500 BIOGAS-TO-GRID PLANT GRISSAN ENERGY SERVICES LTD £345,000 £345,000 419530 0001 HATTON PER MONTAGU EVANS Update 2017 , ANGUS 302 ST VINCENT STREET 05 April 2018 DD7 6LP GLASGOW G2 5RU

Page 5 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

016 06AFJ1503000 COLLEGE DUNDEE & ANGUS COLLEGE £241,000 £241,000 £120,000 £120,000 033500 0001 KEPTIE ROAD PER RYDEN LLP Revaluation 2017 ARBROATH, ANGUS 130 ST VINCENT STREET 06 July 2017 DD11 3EA GLASGOW G2 5HF 017 06AFL0640500 COLLEGE DUNDEE & ANGUS COLLEGE £427,000 £427,000 411549 0001 NORTH SIDE OF PER RYDEN LLP Revaluation 2017 KEPTIE ROAD 130 ST VINCENT STREET 06 July 2017 ARBROATH, ANGUS GLASGOW DD11 3AZ G2 5HF 052 06AOD0113500 ELECTRICITY PLANT (AERO) W M ENERGY LTD £20,900 £20,900 £10,450 408093 0001 WESTER MEATHIE GEN. STATION PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Revaluation 2017 WESTER MEATHIE 233 ST VINCENT STREET 30 August 2017 FORFAR, ANGUS GLASGOW DD8 1XJ G2 5QY 053 06AOD0191500 ELECTRICITY PLANT (AERO) URBAN WIND ASSETS LTD £28,000 £28,000 £10 £10 410373 0001 GREENHILLOCK PER HRC LIMITED Revaluation 2017 KIRKBUDDO 13 HURST ROAD 29 September 2017 FORFAR, ANGUS HASSOCKS DD8 2NL WEST SUSSEX BN6 9NJ 007 07AFS0013000 VISITOR CENTRE & HISTORIC BLDG ANGUS COUNCIL £52,800 £52,800 772070 0001 ARBROATH ABBEY PER AVISON YOUNG Revaluation 2017 ABBEY STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 05 May 2017 ARBROATH, ANGUS 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD11 1EG GLASGOW G2 5NW 085 07AFS1237000 THEATRE ANGUS COUNCIL £50,000 £50,000 033202 0001 WEBSTER MEMORIAL PER AVISON YOUNG Revaluation 2017 64 HIGH STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 05 May 2017 ARBROATH, ANGUS 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD11 1AW GLASGOW G2 5NW

Page 6 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

020 07AFS1247000 SHERIFF COURT HOUSE SCOTTISH COURT SERVICE £53,000 £53,000 £1 033194 0001 88-94 HIGH STREET PER AVISON YOUNG Revaluation 2017 ARBROATH, ANGUS SUTHERLAND HOUSE 30 August 2017 DD11 1HL 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 086 07AFS1466000 LIBRARY ANGUS COUNCIL £70,300 £70,300 033329 0001 HILL TERRACE PER AVISON YOUNG Revaluation 2017 ARBROATH, ANGUS SUTHERLAND HOUSE 05 May 2017 DD11 1AH 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 087 07AFS1719000 MUSEUM ANGUS COUNCIL £16,400 £16,400 £1 033653 0001 SIGNAL TOWER PER AVISON YOUNG Revaluation 2017 LADYLOAN SUTHERLAND HOUSE 05 September 2017 ARBROATH, ANGUS 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD11 1PU GLASGOW G2 5NW 095 08AFU1587000 LIBRARY ANGUS COUNCIL £39,400 £39,400 029149 0001 214 HIGH STREET PER AVISON YOUNG Revaluation 2017 MONTROSE, ANGUS SUTHERLAND HOUSE 05 May 2017 DD10 8PH 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 096 08AFU1587000 LIBRARY ANGUS COUNCIL £43,300 £43,300 029149 0002 214 HIGH STREET PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2018 MONTROSE, ANGUS SUTHERLAND HOUSE 25 January 2019 DD10 8PH 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 099 08AFU2239000 MUSEUM ANGUS COUNCIL £22,900 £22,900 030142 0001 MUSEUM STREET PER AVISON YOUNG Revaluation 2017 MONTROSE, ANGUS SUTHERLAND HOUSE 05 May 2017 DD10 8HE 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW

Page 7 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

014 08XAS0730000 SHOOTING RIGHTS A & A WOODLANDS £1,000 £1,000 418571 0001 KILRY WOODLANDS JOHN CLEGG & CO Update 2017 KILRY 76 GEORGE STREET 28 March 2018 BLAIRGOWRIE, PERTHSHIRE EDINBURGH PH11 8HT EH2 3BU 061 08XAS3055500 SHOOTING RIGHTS (PART) BALMORAL ESTATES TRUSTEES £7,500 £7,500 419296 0001 GLENDOLL & BACHNAGAIRN PER GALBRAITH Update 2017 GLENDOLL 337 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD 15 June 2018 GLENCLOVA CULTS KIRRIEMUIR, ANGUS ABERDEEN DD8 4RD AB15 9SN 066 08XAS3190000 SHOOTING RIGHTS EAST MILL FARMS £1,000 £1,000 418915 0001 WELTON WOOD & KILRY HILL PER BELL INGRAM Update 2017 LINTRATHEN DURN 27 March 2018 KIRRIEMUIR, ANGUS ISLA ROAD DD8 5HY PERTH PH2 7HF 030 08XAU0006000 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES ARQIVA LIMITED £420,000 £420,000 400000 0002 ANGUS COUNCIL AREA PER AVISION YOUNG Update 2018 NORFOLK HOUSE 26 March 2019 7 NORFOLK STREET MANCHESTER M2 1DW 031 08XAU0006000 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES ARQIVA LIMITED £409,000 £409,000 400000 0003 ANGUS COUNCIL AREA PER AVISION YOUNG Update 2019 NORFOLK HOUSE 07 November 2019 7 NORFOLK STREET MANCHESTER M2 1DW 029 08XAU0006000 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES ARQIVA LTD £411,000 £411,000 £1 400000 0001 ANGUS COUNCIL AREA PER AVISION YOUNG Revaluation 2017 NORFOLK HOUSE 13 September 2017 7 NORFOLK STREET MANCHESTER M2 1DW

Page 8 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

034 08XAU0013000 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES O2 £176,500 £176,500 £1 792630 0001 ANGUS COUNCIL AREA PER CLUTTONS Revaluation 2017 PORTMAN HOUSE 11 August 2017 2 PORTMAN STREET LONDON W1H 6DU 036 08XAU0013000 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES TELEFONICA UK LIMITED £149,500 £149,500 792630 0003 ANGUS COUNCIL AREA PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Update 2018 93-96 OXFORD ROAD 23 January 2019 UXBRIDGE MIDDLESEX UB8 1LU 035 08XAU0013000 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES TELEFONICA UK LIMITED £195,500 £195,500 792630 0002 ANGUS COUNCIL AREA PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Update 2018 2 WEST REGENT STREET 03 December 2018 GLASGOW G2 1RW 044 08XAU0023000 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES VODAPHONE LIMITED £35,300 £35,300 792633 0002 ANGUS COUNCIL AREA PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Update 2018 2 WEST REGENT STREET 23 January 2019 GLASGOW G2 1RW 043 08XAU0023000 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES VODAFONE LIMITED - RBS £35,300 £35,300 792633 0003 ANGUS COUNCIL AREA PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Update 2018 2 WEST REGENT STREET 21 March 2019 GLASGOW G2 1RW 042 08XAU0023000 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES VODAFONE LIMITED - RBS £147,000 £147,000 £1 792633 0001 ANGUS COUNCIL AREA PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Revaluation 2017 2 WEST REGENT STREET 30 August 2017 GLASGOW G2 1RW 051 08XAU0024500 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES C T I L £127,250 £127,250 419532 0002 ANGUS COUNCIL AREA PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Update 2018 2 WEST REGENT STREET 21 March 2019 GLASGOW G2 1RW

Page 9 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

050 08XAU0024500 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES C T I L £323,500 £323,500 419532 0001 ANGUS COUNCIL AREA PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Update 2017 2 WEST REGENT STREET 05 April 2018 GLASGOW G2 1RW

Page 10