1 February 21, 2014 Commission's Secretary Office of the Secretary

February 21, 2014

Commission’s Secretary Office of the Secretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, SW Room TW-A325 Washington, DC 20554

Re: Petition for Declaratory Ruling filed by the Retail Industry Leaders Association (CG Docket No. 02-278)

To whom it may concern:

The American Financial Services Association (“AFSA”) welcomes the opportunity to comment on the Petition for Declaratory Ruling (“Petition”) filed by the Retail Industry Leaders Association (“RILA”) requesting that the Federal Communications Commission (“FCC”) clarify certain aspects of the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (“TCPA”), and in particular the prior written consent rules that became effective October 16, 2013. We request that the FCC declare expeditiously that the TCPA rules effective October 16, 2013, do not apply to isolated, immediate, one-time responses to consumer-initiated requests for text offers (“on demand texts”).

AFSA is the national trade association for the consumer credit industry, protecting access to credit and consumer choice. Its more than 350 members include consumer and commercial finance companies, auto finance/leasing companies, mortgage lenders, mortgage servicers, credit card issuers, industrial banks and industry suppliers. Like the retailers discussed in the Petition, AFSA members may use on demand text offers to meet their customer’s increased expectations for value, personalization, and convenience.

On demand texts are only sent as a one-time, immediate response to a consumer-initiated text request. For example, consumers may see a call to action display, such as “text ‘lease’ to 12-345 for a special offer.” If interested, consumers text the word “lease” to the number provided. Consumers then receive a near instant text response containing the desired offer.

I. Sending a one-time, on demand text in response to a consumer’s specific request does not violate the TCPA.

AFSA agrees with RILA that the FCC could not have intended for the new written consent rules that became effective October 16, 2013 to apply to consumer-initiated on demand texts because these texts are: “(1) proactively initiated by the consumer, not a telemarketer, (2) isolated, one-

time only messages sent immediately in response to a consumer’s specific request, and (3) contain only the specific information requested by the consumer.”1

Sending a one-time, on demand text in response to a consumer’s specific request does not constitute “initiating” a call for TCPA purposes. Neither does sending a one-time on demand text in response to a consumer’s specific request constitute an “advertisement” or “telemarketing” for TCPA purposes. Clarifying that on demand texts may be made without prior written consent is consistent with the purpose and intent of the TCPA. As the Petition notes, “Because one-time, responsive, on demand texts in no way impinge on a consumer’s privacy, and instead are a direct response providing what the consumer specifically requested, this clarification will in no way undermine the congressional intent of the TCPA.”2 The TCPA rules are intended to prevent consumers from receiving intrusive and unwanted telemarketing calls. On demand texts are not intrusive, but on the contrary are desired, requested communications.

II. Clarification is necessary to eliminate the high risk of frivolous class action lawsuits.

Given the increasing number of frivolous and costly TCPA class action lawsuits, the FCC should explicitly state what is obvious – that a company should be able to provide the information specifically requested by a consumer without being subject to TCPA litigation.

Plaintiffs’ attorneys see dollar signs with every potential TCPA case. In several TCPA class actions, companies settled for millions of dollars. Each class action member only received a few dollars, while the attorneys walked away with millions.3 For example, Bank of America recently entered into a $32 million settlement with a class of 7.7 million individuals based on alleged violations of the TCPA.4 Without conceding any violation of the TCPA, the bank agreed not to oppose any request from plaintiffs’ counsel for attorneys’ fees up to $8 million. The settlement will provide less than $5 to each plaintiff if every single person submits a claim (with the exception of seven named class representatives who receive $2,000 each). Instead of receiving compensation from class action litigation, consumers will experience rising costs as businesses struggle to make up the massive legal fees incurred during TCPA litigation.

The lack of clarity, combined with penalties of up to $1500 per violation of the TCPA, has provided plaintiffs’ attorneys with fodder for lawsuits that enrich the attorneys rather than compensate their clients. Hundreds of TCPA class actions seeking multi-millions of dollars have been filed in recent years, and their number continues to climb. TCPA lawsuits were up 116 percent in September 2013 compared to September 2012. To demonstrate the number of TCPA lawsuits, we have included an appendix with a partial list of TCPA case law available on the TCPAlaw.com site. Even when companies prevail, the cost of defending a TCPA class action most often exceeds $100,000, which may be devastating for small and mid-size companies.

1 See Petition of Retail Industry Leaders Association for Declaratory Ruling, CG Docket No. 02-278, filed by Retail Industry Leaders Association on Dec. 30, 2013. 2 Ibid. 3 Hoffman, Erin, Eileen Hunter, and Aaron Van Oort. “Recent Developments in TCPA Litigation.” Faegre Baker Daniels. April 5, 2013. http://www.minncle.org/attendeemats/30313/10_VAN%20OORT.pdf 4 Dkt. No. 59-1, Rose v. Bank of Am. Corp. Case No. 5:11-cv-02390-EJD (N.D. Cal.).

III. Conclusion

AFSA requests that the FCC make the narrow declaration that obtaining prior express written consent is not necessary when responding to a consumer with an on demand text. We look forward to working with the FCC on this Petition. Please contact me by phone, 202-466-8616, or e-mail, [email protected], with any questions.

Sincerely,

Bill Himpler Executive Vice President American Financial Services Association

Appendix

This is only a partial list of TCPA case law on the TCPALaw.com5 site.

o Accounting Outsourcing, LLC Commc'ns, LP v. Verizon Wireless Personal Commc'ns, LP, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1678 (2006) (Motion to recoinsider denial of motion to amend complaint denied.) o Besco Steel Supply, Inc. v. Enmark Sys, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1703 (2003) (Motion to dismiss denied in part and granted in part.) o Cleveland v. Ark-La-Tex Fin. Servs., LLC, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1576 (2007) (Plaintiff's motion to remand granted.) o Ex parte First Western Bank v. BankCard USA Merch. Servs., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1326 (2004) (Petition for writ of mandamus granted.) o Ex parte Lary, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1448 (2006) (Reversed and remanded.) o Forstman & Cutchen, LLP v. Away Travel, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1716 (2006) (Class certification granted) o Hunt v. 21st Mortg. Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2621 (2013) (Motion to compel inspection of premises granted.) o Lary v. Am. Med. Practice Servs., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1339 (2005) (reversed and remanded) o Lary v. Doctors Answer, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2472 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Lary v. Flasch Bus. Consulting, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1340 (2005) (reversed and remanded) o Lary v. Flasch Bus. Consulting, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1239 (2003) (order affirming in part and reversing in part) o Lary v. Genelex Corp., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1338 (2005) (order dismissing appeal ex mero motu) o Lary v. Genelex Corp., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1953 (2009) (Order granting judgment to plaintiff.) o Lary v. Tom Taylor Agency, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1245 (2003) (appeal reversing trial court) o Lary v. VSB Financial Consulting, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1347 (2005) (affirmed in part and denied in part and remanded) o Lary v. Work-Loss Data Inst., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1346 (2005) (reversed in part and remanded) o Meadows v. Franklin Collection Serv., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2001 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Meadows v. Franklin Collection Serv., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2098 (2011) (Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded.) o Page v. Regions Bank, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2435 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Pinkard v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2396 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Yance, Inge, and Assocs., Inc. v. Enrollment First, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 2151 (2008) (Motion to remand granted.)

o Abramson v. Perfekt Mktg. LLC, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1547 (2007) (Objections to domestication of default judgment denied.) o Driesen v. First Revenue Assurance, LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2070 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o ESI Ergonomic Solns., LLC v. United Artists Theatre Circuit, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1062 (2002) (Denial of class certification reversed and remanded.)

5 TCPALaw.com originally began in 1996 as a repository of research materials and case law for litigants and attorneys. It slowly evolved with news, a slip reporter service, and on-line databases for tracking defendant activities. It is now the number one source for research and support of TCPA litigation. It has been recommended to litigants by the FCC as a resource, and counts many state legislators’ offices and state attorneys’ general offices as subscribers. Case list available at: http://www.tcpalaw.com/free/cases.htm. 4

o ESI Ergonomic Solns., LLC v. United Artists Theatre Circuit, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1086 (2003) (order granting class cert.) o ESI Ergonomic Solns., LLC v. United Artists Theatre Circuit, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1230 (2003) (order granting plaintiff's partial MSJ) o ESI Ergonomic Solns., LLC v. United Artists Theatre Circuit, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1713 (2001) (Motion to dismiss denied, class certification denied.) o Fax Exterminators v. Arrow Security, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1341 (2003) (order denying def. MTD) o Flury v. Customer Servs. Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1789 (2008) (Dismissed sua sponte.) o Garo v. Global Credit & Collection Corp., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2087 (2011) (Motion for class certification granted in part and denied in part.) o Garo v. Global Credit and Collection Corp., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2069 (2010) (Rulings on MSJ and class certifcation deferred.) o Guadagni v. Deitch, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1240 (2002) (trial order finding for plaintiff) o In re United Artists Theatre Co., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1900 (2009) (Motion for partial summary judgment denied.) o Joffe v. Acacia Nat'l Mortg. Corp., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1159 (2002) (order denying def. MSJ) o Joffe v. Acacia Nat'l Mortg. Corp., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1381 (2005) (affirmed) o Joffe v. Acacia Nat'l Mtg. Corp., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1744 (2007) (Class certification granted.) o Martinez v. Ballas, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1484 (2006) (Dismissal w/o prejudice) o Martinez v. Green, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1558 (2006) (Affirmed) o Martinez v. Sunbelt Commc'ns and Mktg., LLC., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1430 (2005) (order denying MTD) o Nat'l Union Fire Ins. Co. v. ESI Ergonomic Solns., LLC, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1327 (2004) (order granting motion to dismiss and remand.) o Shupe v. JPMorgan Chase Bank of Ariz., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2282 (2012) (Motions to dismiss and to remand denied.) o Shupe v. JPMorgan Chase Bank of Ariz., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2284 (2012) (Motions to dismiss and to remand denied.) o Strojnik, P.C. v. Signalife, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1874 (2009) (Motions to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o United Artists Theatre Circuit, Inc. v. FCC, 2000 TCPA Rep. 1218 (2000) (order dismissing DJ action)

o ACS Sys. Inc. v. St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1515 (2007) (affirmed) o ACS Sys. Inc. v. St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1750 (2004) (Demurrers sustained with 20 days leave to amend.) o Abuan v. JPMorgan Chase & Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2642 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted with leave to amend.) o Amini v. Group 1 Automotive, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2215 (2011) (Order to show cause.) o Arkow v. Bank of America, 1995 TCPA Rep. 1116 (1995) (small claims order and judgment) o Bellows v. NCO Fin. Systems, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1825 (2008) (Master recommended that class settlement be approved.) o Bickelmann v. Assil Sinskey Eye Inst., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1842 (2008) (Affirmed) o Bickelmann v. Dale Carnegie & Assoc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1386 (2005) (reversal) o Bickelmann v. Dove Capital Corp., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1440 (2004) (trial judgment) o Blair v. CBE Group Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2529 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Blair v. CBE Group Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2651 (2013) (Motion to strike and to dismiss denied.) o Bland v. Fessler, 1996 TCPA Rep. 1009 (1996) (Affirmed.) o Bland v. Fessler, 1996 TCPA Rep. 1658 (1996) (Affirmed.) o Boling v. Santa Maria, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1652 (2005) (Affirmed in part and reversed and remanded in part.)

o Boling v. Trendwest Resorts, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1516 (2005) (Reversed in part and affirmed in part) o Bonime v. DirecTV, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1253 (2003) (appeal reversing dismissal) o Boydston v. Asset Acceptance LLC, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1580 (2007) (Remanded on the court's motion.) o Brown v. DIRECTV, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2558 (2013) (Motion to compel arbitration granted.) o Bruns v. E-Commerce Exchange, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1082 (2002) (order imposing sanctions on Def.) o California v. Am. Home Craft, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1560 (2004) (judgment and injunction) o California v. Fax.com, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1688 (2007) (Final judgment with injunction.) o California v. Fax.com, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1438 (2004) (prelim. inj.) o Casey v. Capital Line Fin., LLC, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1648 (2006) (Judgment for plaintiff.) o Catalyst Strategic Design, Inc. v. Kaiser Found. Health Plan, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1611 (2007) (Dismissal of claims based on EBR affirmed.) o Cayanan v. Citi Holdings, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2462 (2013) (Motion to compel arbitration granted.) o Chamber of Commerce v. Lockyer, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1441 (2006) (Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment granted.) o Chen v. Allstate Ins. Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2549 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Connelly v. Hilton Grant Vacations Co., LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2319 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Connelly v. Hilton Grant Vacations Co., LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2668 (2013) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Craftwood II, Inc. v. Tomy Int'l, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2562 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Craftwood II, Inc. v. v. Tomy Intern., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2573 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Emanuel v. NFL Enters., LLC,, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2243 (2012) (Motion to intervene granted.) o Fenerty v. Cedar Mortg. Co., Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1408 (2002) (Judgment for plaintiff.) o Fields v. Mobile Messengers Am., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2672 (2013) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Fields v. Wise Media, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2623 (2013) (Motion for leave to file a second amended complaint granted.) o Freidman v. Massage Envy Franchising, LCC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2557 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Friedman v. Torchmark Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2509 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted with leave to amend.) o Friedman v. Torchmark Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2597 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o GBL Assoc. v. Usallianz Investor Servs., LLC, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1748 (2007) (Class certification denied.) o Gannon v. Network Tele. Servs., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2545 (2013) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Gibson & Co. Ins. Brokers, Inc. v. Jackson Nat'l Life Ins. Co., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1685 (2006) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Gibson & Co. Ins. Brokers, Inc. v. Jackson Nat'l Life Ins. Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1777 (2007) (Class certificaiton granted (settlement)) o Gibson and Co. Ins. Brokers, Inc. v. Jackson Nat. Life Ins. Co., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1784 (2008) (Final order approving class settlement.) o Glauser v. Twilio, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2251 (2012) (Stay granted.) o Gomez v. Campbell-Ewald Co., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2160 (2011) (Motion to strike granted.) o Gomez v. Campbell-Ewald Co., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2161 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Gomez v. Campbell-Ewald Co., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2170 (2010) (Motion for reconsideration denied.) o Gomez v. Campbell-Ewald Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2458 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment granted.)

o Grannan v. Alliant Law Group, P.C., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2242 (2012) (Order approving class settlement.) o Grant v. Capital Mgmt. Servs., L.P., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2159 (2011) (Application for stay denied.) o Grant v. Capital Mgmt. Servs., L.P., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2320 (2012) (Motions to compel arbitration and for sanctions denied.) o Grant v. Capital Mgmt. Servs., L.P.,, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2165 (2011) (Reversed.) o Gutierrez v. Barclays Group, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2101 (2011) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Heidorn v. BDD Mktg. & Mgmt. Co., LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2693 (2013) (Motion for default granted.) o Heidorn v. BDD Mktg. & Mgmt. Co., LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2694 (2013) (Motion for default recommended be granted.) o Hughes v. Frontrange Solutions USA, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1707 (2007) (Motion to dismiss affirmed.) o Huizar v. Mandarich Law Group LLP, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2593 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Hurrey-Mayer v. Wells Fargo Home Mortg., Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1929 (2009) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Hypertouch, Inc. v. Perry Johnson, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1869 (2009) (Affirmed.) o Hypertouch, Inc. v. Superior Court ex rel. Perry Johnson, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1355 (2005) (Writ of mandate issued.) o Ibey v. Taco Bell Corp, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2322 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o In re Jiffy Lube Intern., Inc., Text Spam Litig., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2259 (2012) (Motions to dismiss and compel arbitration denied.) o In re Martin, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1682 (2004) (Investigator's license revoked for fraud and dishonesty in defending TCPA suits.) o Iniguez v. The CBE Group, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2611 (2013) (Motions to strike and to dismiss denied.) o Iniguez v. The CBE Group, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2683 (2013) (Motion for reconsideration and for interlocutory appeal denied.) o J2 Global Comm., Inc. v. Vision Lab Telecom., Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1450 (2006) (Defendant's motion to dismiss denied.) o J2 Global Comm., Inc. v. Vision Lab Telecom., Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1454 (2006) (order granting MTD) o J2 Global Commc'ns, Inc. v. Protus IP Solutions,, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2499 (2010) (Motion for summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.) o J2 Global Communications, Inc. v. Blue Jay Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1952 (2009) (Motion for default granted.) o J2 Global Communications, Inc. v. Protus IP Solutions, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1882 (2009) (Motion to bifurcate denied.) o J2 Global Communications, Inc. v. Protus IP Solutions,, 2010 TCPA Rep. 1978 (2010) (Rule to show cause for subject matter jurisdiction and standing.) o Kaufman v. ACS Sys., Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1151 (2003) (Reversed.) o Kaufman v. ACS Sys., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1281 (2004) (order granting class cert.) o Kaufman v. ACS Systems, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1052 (2001) (order on demurr) o Kaufman v. ACS Systems, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1053 (2001) (ammended order on demurr) o Kaufman v. HTOA, Inc., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1008 (2000) (order overruling demurr) o Kazemi v. Payless Shoesource, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1956 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Kinder v. Citibank, 2000 TCPA Rep. 1108 (2000) (Motion to remand denied.) o Kinder v. Northland Group, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1781 (2008) (Reversed and remanded.) o Kirsch v. Cuadra, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1388 (2005) (order granting mtn. to dismiss) o Knutson v. ReplyA, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2091 (2011) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Knutson v. Schwan's Home Service, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2488 (2013) (Motion to compel granted.) o Knutson v. Schwan's Home Service, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2574 (2013) (Reversed in part and remanded.) o Knutson v. Schwan's Home Service, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2610 (2013) (Motion for class certification granted in part and denied in part.)

o Knutson v. Sirius XM Radio Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2309 (2012) (Motion to compel arbitration granted.) o Kramer v. Autobytel, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2072 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Krause v. Barclays Bank Delaware, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2675 (2013) (Motion to compel arbitration granted.) o Law Offices of Hermez Moreno v. Travelcom Ind., Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1770 (2008) (Plaintiff's motion for remand granted.) o Law Offices of Hermez Moreno, P.C., Travelcomm Inds., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2036 (2010) (Affirmed.) o Leckler v. Cashcall, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1790 (2008) (Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment granted) o Lee v. Stonebridge Life Ins. Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2454 (2013) (Motion for class certification granted.) o LensCrafters, Inc. v. Liberty Mut. Fire Ins. Co., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1633 (2005) (Partial summary judgment for insured on duty defend.) o Lo v. Oxnard European Motors, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2224 (2011) (Motion to approve class settlement granted.) o Lo v. Oxnard European Motors, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2310 (2012) (Motion for final approval granted.) o Maier v. J.C. Penney Corp., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2556 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Malta v. Federal Home Loan Mortg. Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2447 (2013) (Motion for preliminary approval for class settlement granted.) o Martin v. Bureau of Sec. and Investigative Servs., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1667 (2007) (Writ to set aside license revocation denied.) o Mashiri v. Ocwen Loan Servicing, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2652 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o McGrew v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1899 (2009) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Melingonis v. Network Commc'ns Int'l. Corp., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2060 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Meyer v. Portfolio Recovery Assocs., LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2359 (2012) (Affirmed.) o Meyer v. Portfolio Recovery Assocs., LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2424 (2012) (Affirmed.) o Mocella v. IDC Solutions, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1674 (2003) (Stipulation and permanent injunction) o Mocella v. Vision Quest, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1217 (2003) (injunction) o Moriarity v. Nationstar Mortg., LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2592 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Munro v. King Broad. Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2677 (2013) (Motion for judgment on the pleadings denied.) o Murphey v. Lanier, 1998 TCPA Rep. 1200 (1998) (Motion to dismiss granted for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.) o Murphey v. Lanier, 2000 TCPA Rep. 1569 (2000) (Dismissal of TCPA claims for lack of subject matter jurisdiction affirmed.) o Myers v. Hunt & Henriques,, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2269 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o N.B. Indus. v. Wells Fargo & Co., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2058 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o N.B. Indus. v. Wells Fargo & Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2230 (2012) (Affirmed) o Narayn v. Citibank, N.A., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2609 (2013) (Recommendation to grant motion to dismiss.) o Narayn v. Citibank, N.A., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2645 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Nat'l Fire Ins. Co. v. Grantsmanship Cntr., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1567 (2007) (Insurer's motion for summary judgment denied.) o Nat'l Notary Ass'n v. U.S. Notary, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1067 (2002) (order modifying trial court's injunction) o O'Brien v. Am. Exp. Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2304 (2012) (Motion to compel granted in part and denied in part.)

o O'Brien v. American Exp. Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2346 (2012) (Motion to compel arbitration denied.) o Onley v. Job.com, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2635 (2013) (Motion to strike class allegations and to dismiss denied.) o Optima Funding, Inc. v. Strang, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1622 (2007) (judgment for consumer in anti- SLAPP claims affirmed) o Pimental v. Google Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2256 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Pimental v. Google, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2285 (2012) (Motion for stay denied.) o Pimental v. Google, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2486 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Redefining Progress v. Fax.com, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1191 (2003) (Motion to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction granted.) o Reyes v. Saxon Mortg. Servs., Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1930 (2009) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Ridley v. Union Bank, N.A., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2235 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Robbins v. Coca-Cola-Company, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2530 (2013) (Motion to dismiss and for a more definite statement denied.) o Roberts v. PayPal, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2543 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Roylance v. ADT Security Servs., Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1795 (2008) (Motion to remand granted.) o Roylance v. Matsuura (In re Matsuura ), 2011 TCPA Rep. 2194 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Ryabyshchuck v. Citibank, N.A., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2392 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Ryabyshchuk v. Citibank N.A., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2214 (2011) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Sarabri v. Weltman, Weinberg & Reis Co., L.P.A., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2370 (2012) (Order granting joint motion for class certification and approving settlement.) o Satterfield v. Simon & Schuster, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1584 (2007) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Satterfield v. Simon & Schuster, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1896 (2009) (Reversed and remanded.) o Sepehry-Fard v. Dept. Stores Nat'l Bank, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2687 (2013) (Motions to dismiss denied in part and granted nipart.) o Smith v. Microsoft Corp., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2332 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Smith v. Microsoft Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2691 (2013) (Motion to strike denied.) o State Farm General Ins. Co. v. JT's Frames, Inc.,, 2010 TCPA Rep. 1939 (2010) (Affirmed.) o Strang v. Bridge Capital Corp., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1156 (2003) (trial order and judgment) o Strang v. Citywide Fin. Group, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1162 (2002) (trial order and judgment) o Strang v. Fairon & Assoc., d/b/a LoanNow.com, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1161 (2002) (judgment) o Strang v. Shorewood Realtors, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1157 (2003) (trail order and judgment) o Sutton v. First Chartered Fin., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1701 (2004) (Order holding that TCPA claims can be brought as separate actions.) o Sznyter v. Malone, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1632 (2007) (Judgment on the pleadings in favor of defendant reversed and remanded.) o Tague v. Healthfusion, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1987 (2010) (Final class judgment.) o Thomas v. Taco Bell Corp., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2321 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o True Health Chiropractic Inc v. McKesson Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2673 (2013) (Motion to transfer venue denied.) o Vaccaro v. CVS Pharmacy, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2569 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Van Patten v. Vertical Fitness Group, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2528 (2013) (Motion to compel denied.) o Vandervort v. Balboa Capital Corp., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2391 (2012) (Motion for classc ertification granted in part and denied in part.) o Watts v. Enhanced Recovery Corp., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2035 (2010) (Motion to remand denied.) o Wilder Chiropractic, Inc. v. Microwize Tech., Inc, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2353 (2012) (Motion to compel granted.) o Wylder v. DialAmerica Mktg., Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1070 (2002) (Order and judgment for plaintiff.)

o j2 Global Commc'ns, Inc. v. Blue Jay, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1851 (2009) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o j2 Global Commc'ns, Inc. v. The Hot Lead Co., LLC, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1768 (2008) (Permanent injunction issued.) o j2 Global Commc'ns., Inc. v. Protus IP Solns., Inc, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1753 (2008) (Motion to dismiss denied as to constitutional grounds; granted in part otherwise)

o Weingarten v. Colony Brands, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2605 (2013) (Motion to compel arbitration granted.)

o A & L Abatement, LLC, v. Construction Expo, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 2449 (2006) (Trial judgment in favor of plaintiffs.) o A AAA Custom Plumbing Corp. v. Nat'l Telemedicine Center Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2102 (2011) (Motion for default denied.) o Bailey v. Cookies in Bloom, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1033 (2001) (appeal from small claims ct.) o Bailey v. Drummond, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1373 (2004) (affirmed in part and reversed in part) o Bailey v. J&L Consulting, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1301 (2004) (reversal on appeal) o Chavez v. Advantage Group, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2589 (2013) (Motion for partial summary judgment granted.) o Consumer Crusade Inc. v. Affordable Health Care Solns., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1379 (2005) (reversed and remanded) o Consumer Crusade, Inc. v. Clarion Mortg. Captial, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1801 (2005) (Def. motion for summary judgment denied.) o Consumer Crusade, Inc. v. Everycontractor.com, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1605 (2006) (Defendant's motion for stay granted.) o Consumer Crusade, Inc. v. Farion and Assoc., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1375 (2005) (order granting remand) o Consumer Crusade, Inc. v. Internet Payphone Corp., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1542 (2007) (Dismissed, sua sponte, for lack of standing.) o Consumer Crusade, Inc. v. JD & T Ent., Inc. d/b/a Travel to Go, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1490 (2006) (recon. denied) o Consumer Crusade, Inc. v. Keller-Lowry Ins., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1456 (2005) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Consumer Crusade, Inc. v. Public Tel. Corp. of Am, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1597 (2006) (Magistrate's order affirmed, defendant's motion for sanctions granted.) o Consumer Crusade, Inc. v. Scientific Research Group, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1608 (2005) (Dismissed sua sponte for lack of subject matter judisdiction) o Donaca v. Dish Network L.L.C., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2347 (2012) (Motion to compel granted in part and denied in part.) o Holcomb v. Colo. Ass'n of Real Estate Investors, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2571 (2013) (Reversed.) o Holcomb v. Jan-Pro Cleaning Services of S. Colorado, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1735 (2007) (Refersed and remanded.) o Holcomb v. Jan-Pro Cleaning Servs. of S. Colo., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1909 (2009) (Reversed and remanded, with instructions.) o Holcomb v. Jan-Pro Cleaning Sys. of S. Colorado, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1752 (2006) () o Holcomb v. Steven D. Smith, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1647 (2007) (Reversed and remanded.) o Holcomb v. SullivanHayes Brokerage Corp., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1078 (2002) (appeal) o Kruse v. McKenna, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1771 (2008) (Reversed) o Lion Capital, LLC v. Alliance Fin. Capital, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1357 (2004) (order granting plaintiff MSJ)

o Livingston v. U.S. Bank, N.A., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1202 (2002) (Denial of class certification affirmed.) o Lyons v. Dish Network L.L.C., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2649 (2013) (Motions for costs and stay denied.) o Mainstream Mktg. Servs., Inc. v. FTC, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1636 (2004) (NDNCL upheld against constitutional challenge.) o Mainstream Mktng. Servs., Inc. v. FCC, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1227 (2003) (order denying motion to stay FCC order) o Mainstream Mktng. Servs., Inc. v. FTC, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1225 (2003) (Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.) o Mainstream Mktng. Servs., Inc. v. FTC, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1229 (2003) (order granting stay of trial court ruling) o Mainstream Mktng. Servs., Inc. v. FTC, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1663 (2003) (Emergency motion to stay injunction denied.) o Makowski v. First Nat. of Neb., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2467 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment recommended be granted in part and denied in part.) o Mathemaesthetics, Inc. v. Lassiter Mktg. Group, LLC, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1061 (2002) (order granting Pl. MSJ) o Mathemaesthetics, Inc. v. Reiner, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1039 (2001) (appeal from county ct.) o McKenna v. Accurate Computer Servs., Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1115 (2002) (statute of limitations) o McKenna v. Accurate Computer Servs., Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1135 (2002) (order denying Def. MTD re constitution) o McKenna v. Kruse, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1645 (2006) (Trial decisision dismissing TCPA claims reversed.) o McKenna v. Oliver, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1498 (2006) (affirmed on other grounds) o Physicians Data Inc. v. US West Wireless, LLC, 2000 TCPA Rep. 1016 (2000) (order den. Def. mtn. to dismiss) o Rice v. Vacations Outlet of Colorado, 1998 TCPA Rep. 1120 (1998) (appeal) o U.S. Fax Law Center, Inc. v. Myron Corp., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1623 (2006) (Affirmed dismissal of TCPA claims on grounds that assignee lacked standing.) o U.S. Fax Law Center, Inc. v. The Barrington Group, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1827 (2005) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o U.S. Fax Law Ctr, Inc. v. T2 Tech., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1736 (2007) (Affirmed) o US Fax Law Center, Inc. v. iHire, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1660 (2005) (Motion to certify questons to state supreme court denied.) o US Fax Law Ctr., Inc. v. iHire, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1376 (2005) (order granting Def. MTD.) o US Fax Law Ctr., Inc. v. iHire, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1464 (2005) (order granting MTD) o US Fax Law Ctr., Inc. v. iHire, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1520 (2007) (Affirmed) o US Tax Law Center, Inc. v. Capital Arbitration, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1352 (2004) (reversed and remanded) o USA Tax Law Center, Inc. v. Office Warehouse Wholesale, LLC, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1548 (2007) (Affirmed) o Warnick v. Dish Network LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2498 (2013) (Motions to dismiss and for costs denied.)

o 3081 Main Street, LLC v. Bus. Owners Liab. Team LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2385 (2012) (Motion for class certification denies without prejudice to renewal.) o Americana Art China Co. v. Hartford Cas. Ins. Co.,, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2619 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied. Motion to stay granted.) o Giovanniello v. ALM Media, LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2041 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Giovanniello v. ALM Media, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2189 (2011) (Affirmed.) o Giovanniello v. ALM Media, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2588 (2013) (Affirmed.) o Kaye v. WebMD, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2128 (2011) (Order granting final settlement approval.)

o Physicians Healthsource, Inc. v. Purdue Pharma L.P., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2613 (2013) (Motion for class certification denied WOP.) o Sal's Glass Co., LLC v. Duplicating Methods Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2466 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Sal's Glass Co., LLC v. Duplicating Methods Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2507 (2013) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Weber v. U.S. Sterling Sec., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1317 (2004) (procedural order) o Weber v. U.S. Sterling Sec., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1556 (2007) (Affirmed in part and reversed in part.)

o Adler v. Vision Lab Telecomm., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1387 (2005) (Def. JOP granted in part and denied in part.) o Biggerstaff v. FCC, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1746 (2007) (Petition challenging EBR for faxes dismissed.) o Cincinnati Ins. Co v. All Plumbing, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2650 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment granted to insured.) o City Lights School, Inc. v. T-Mobile USA, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1698 (2003) (Motion to dismiss and motion for class certification denied.) o Covington & Burling v. Int'l Mktng. & Research, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1164 (2003) (order granting pl. MSJ and denying def. MSJ) o FDS Restaurant, Inc. v. All Plumbing Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2372 (2012) (Remand granted.) o Kopff v. Battaglia, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1604 (2006) (Motions to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Kopff v. Roth, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1555 (2007) (Motion for default granted in part.) o Kopff v. World Research Group LLC, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1250 (2003) (order denying remand) o Kopff v. World Research Group, LLC, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1818 (2006) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Morris v. Fax.com, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1136 (2003) (order denying def. mtn. to dismiss negligence claim) o Morris v. Fax.com, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1251 (2003) (order denying def. MTD) o Morris v. Fax.com, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1271 (2004) (order denying def. MSJ) o Portuguese-American Leadership Council of the U.S., Inc. v. Investors' Alert, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1431 (2003) (order granting MTD) o Portuguese-American Leadership Council of the U.S., Inc. v. Investors' Alert, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1823 (2008) (Reversed and remanded)

o New Century Mortg., Corp. v. Great N. Ins. Co., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1924 (2009) (Cross motions for partial summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.)

o A Aventura Chiropractic Center, Inc. v. Med Waste Mgmt. LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2531 (2013) (Motion fro class certification denied.) o A Aventura Chiropractic Center, Inc. v. Med Waste Mgmt. LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2561 (2013) (Motion for reconsideration granted. Class certification granted.) o Balthazor v. Central Credit Servs., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2425 (2012) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Bentley v. Bank of America, N.A., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2113 (2011) (Motion to dismiss granted, without prejudice.) o Bianchi v. Bronson & Migliaccio, LLP, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2015 (2010) (Motion to compel granted.) o Bianchi v. Bronson & Migliaccio, LLP, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2092 (2011) (Motion for attorney fees granted in part and denied in part.)

o Bresko v. M & T Bank Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2624 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Breslow v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2286 (2012) (Motion for partial summary judgment granted.) o Brook v. Suncoast Schools, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2410 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Buslepp v. B & B Entertainment, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2292 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Buslepp v. B & B Entertainment, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2383 (2012) (Motions for partial summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.) o Buslepp v. Improv Miami, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2290 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Capote v. United Collection Bureau, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2016 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Cavero v. Franklin Collection Serv. Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2246 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Cellco Partnership v. Plaza Resorts Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2636 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Clarke v. Weltman, Wienberg & Reis, Co., L.P.A., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2019 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Condon v. Office Depot, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1210 (2003) (appeal reversing trial court on opt- in) o Condon v. Rose, 2000 TCPA Rep. 1015 (2000) (order den. Def. MSJ) o Conklin v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2692 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Delgado v. Collecto, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2684 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Dennis v. The Regional Adjustment Bureau, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2024 (2010) (Defendant's motion for summary judgment is denied in part and granted in part.) o Dewar v. Fla. Freezz of SW Fla., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2241 (2012) (Motion for class certifcation granted.) o Dewar v. Kolesov & Assocs., PA, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2361 (2011) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Dewar v. Kolesov & Assocs., PA, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2362 (2012) (Affirmed.) o Dewar v. Pilcher Enters., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2239 (2012) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Duran v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2333 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Ebsary v. Twins Luncheon, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1942 (2009) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Fillichio v. M.R.S. Assoc., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2044 (2010) (MSJ granted in part and denied in part.) o Fini v. Dish Network LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2582 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Fla. First Fin. Group, Inc. v. Magnum Painting, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2046 (2010) (Class certification granted.) o Florida Dept. of Ag and Cons. Servs. v. The Sports Authority Florida, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1314 (2004) (order granting remand) o George v. Leading Edge Recovery Solutions, L.L.C., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2568 (2013) (Motion to strike denied.) o Goldstein v. Juris Publ'g, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1699 (2006) (Motion to dismiss, stay, or in the alternative transfer, denied.) o Goldstein v. Juris Publ'g, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1700 (2007) (Final judgment approving class settlement.) o Guy's World, Inc. v. Condon, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1849 (2008) (Class certification affirmed.) o Harrier v. Verizon Wireless Personal Commc'ns LP, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2348 (2012) (Motion to compel arbitration denied.) o Hicks v. Client Servs., Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1821 (2008) (Motion to amend complaint granted.) o Hicks v. Client Servs., Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1853 (2008) (Class certification granted in part.) o Hicks v. Client Servs., Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1893 (2009) (Summary judgment granted to plaintiff on TCPA claims.) o Interline Brands, Inc. v. Chartis Spec. Ins. Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2503 (2012) (Motion for judgment on the pleadings granted.)

o Johnson v. Credit Protection Ass'n, L.P., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2399 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Kahn v. Portfolio Recovery Assocs., LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2088 (2011) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Kaner v. Robert Schiffman, D.C., P.C., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2312 (2012) (Reversed and remanded.) o Keim v. ADF MidAtlantic, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2575 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Lusskin v. Seminole Comedy, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2554 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Mais v. Gulf Coast Collection Bureau, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2522 (2013) (Motions to dismiss denied in part and granted in part.) o Manfred v. Bennett Law, PLLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2413 (2012) (Motion to dismiss and for more definite statement denied.) o Manno v. Healthcare Revenue Recovery Group, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2501 (2013) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Manno v. Healthcare Revenue Recovery Group, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2541 (2013) (Motion to reconsider denied.) o Manshum Ent., Inc. v. Nat'l Bus. Info. Corp., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1477 (2006) (Remand granted) o Manshum Ent., Inc. v. Nat'l Bus. Info. Corp., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1598 (2006) (Motion for attorney fees for improper removal denied.) o Manshum Ent., Inc. v. Nat'l Bus. Info. Corp., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1654 (2006) (Magistrate judge's regommendation to grant remand.) o Mims v. Arrow Fin. Servs., LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2176 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted,) o Mims v. Arrow Fin. Servs., LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2231 (2012) (Reversed and remanded. ) o Moise v. Credit Control Servs., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2451 (2011) (Order on discovery.) o Moise v. Credit Control Servs., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2452 (2011) (Order regarding prior express consent.) o Nicholas v. Nationwide Credit, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2012 (2010) (Cross motions for summary judgment denied.) o Obremski v. Springleaf Fin. Servs., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2341 (2012) (Motion to compel arbitration granted.) o Ortega v. Collectors Training Inst. of Ill., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2085 (2011) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Osorio v. State Farm Bank, F.S.B., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2289 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Osorio v. State Farm Bank, F.S.B., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2306 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Osorio v. State Farm Bank, F.S.B.,, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2227 (2011) (Motion for leave to file third– party complaint granted.) o Ownings v. T-Mobile USA, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2594 (2013) (Motion to stay and compel arbitration granted.) o PHS v. Anda, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2415 (2012) (Motion to compel denied in part and granted in part.) o Palm Beach Golf Center-Boca, Inc. v. Sarris, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2664 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Penzer ex rel. Se. Wireless, Inc. v. Transp. Ins. Co., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1831 (2008) (Reversed, and question certified to Florida Supreme Court.) o Penzer v. MSI Mktg., Inc., d/b/a Y2Marketing, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1142 (2003) (order granting class cert.) o Penzer v. Trans. Ins. Co., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1940 (2010) (Certified question answered affirmatively.) o Penzer v. Transp. Ins. Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1704 (2007) (Declaratory action finding no duty to defend TCPA claims.) o Penzer v. Transp. Ins. Co., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1982 (2010) (Reversed.) o Pollock v. Bay Area Credit Serv., LLC, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1912 (2009) (Motions to dismiss and for summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.) o Rick's Cabaret Intern., Inc. v. Indem. Ins. Corp., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2244 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.)

o Robert A. Dalzell, Inc. v. European TIle & Floors, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2203 (2011) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Rutherford v. Zoom Tan, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2590 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Sabon, Inc. v. Aqualogic, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2407 (2012) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Scott v. Merchants Ass'n Collection Div., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2389 (2012) (Motion to dismiss and for a more definite statement denied.) o Shea v. BBVA Compass Bancshares, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2469 (2013) (Motion to compel arbitration granted.) o Smilko v. Accelerated Receivables, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2201 (2011) (Motion for entry of default granted.) o Sprogis v. Suntrust Bank, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2547 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o TSA Stores, Inc. v. Dept. of Agric. and Consum. Servs., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1549 (2007) (Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded.) o The Broadcast Team, Inc. v. FTC, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1656 (2006) (Plaintiff's motion for preliminary injunction against enforcement of TSR denied.) o The Broadcast Team, Inc. v. FTC, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1693 (2006) (Defendant's motion to dismiss granted.) o The Broadcast Team, Inc. v. FTC, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1755 (2007) (Entry of stipulated judgment and permanent injunction.) o Wood v. GC Services, LP, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2270 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment recommended to be granted.) o Yarbrough v. Credit Control Servs., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2108 (2011) (Recommendation that motion for fees denied.) o Zelma v. Williams, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2217 (2011) (Motions for summary judgment denied.) o Zinni v. ER Solutions, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2345 (2012) (Reversed and remanded.)

o A Fast Sign Co., Inc v. Am. Home. Servs., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1968 (2010) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o A Fast Sign Co., Inc v. Am. Home. Servs., Inc.,, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2009 (2010) (Judgment.) o A Fast Sign Co., Inc. v. Am. Home Servs., Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1485 (2006) (Order granting class cert.) o AT & T Mobility LLC v. C1F, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1999 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o AT&T Mobility LLC v. C&C Global Ent., LLC, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1583 (2007) (Defendant's motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction granted.) o Alea London LTD. v. Am. Home Servs., Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1933 (2009) (Cross motions for summary judgment denied in part and granted in part.) o Alea London, LTD v. Am. Home Servs., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2120 (2011) (Reversed in part, affirmed in part, and remanded.) o Allison and Assoc., Inc. v. Dartek Corp., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1383 (2005) (Order granting mtn. to transfer) o Am. Home Servs., Inc. v. A Fast Sign Co., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1568 (2007) (Affirmed) o Am. Home Servs., Inc. v. A Fast Sign Co., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2122 (2011) (Vacated and remanded) o Am. Home Servs., Inc. v. A Fast Sign Co., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2390 (2012) (Reversed and remanded.) o Am. Home Servs., Inc. v. A Fast Sign Co., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2538 (2013) (Judgment vacated and remanded for corrected judgment.) o Busbia v. Direct TV, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1034 (2001) (interlocutory uinjunction to preserve evidence) o C and E, Inc., v. Friedman's Jewelers, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1751 (2008) (Remand granted.) o Carnett's, Inc. v. Hammond, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1337 (2005) (reversal)

o Garver v. Susquehanna Radio Corp., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1027 (2001) (order denying Def. mtn. to dismiss [vacated on other grounds and remanded]) o Hammond v. Carnett's, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1274 (2004) (appeal reversing denial of class certification) o Hershovitz v. Staff Counsel, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1725 (2005) (Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment granted in part.) o Hooters of Augusta, Inc. v. Am. Global Ins. Co., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1165 (2003) (Insured's motion for summary judgment granted on coverage.) o Hooters of Augusta, Inc. v. Am. Global Ins. Co., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1420 (2005) (Affirmed in part and reversed in part.) o Hooters of Augusta, Inc. v. Nicholson, 2000 TCPA Rep. 1153 (2000) (appeal affirming class cert. and rejecting opt-out) o McGarry v. Cingular Wireless, LLC, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1277 (2004) (order affirming denial of class cert.) o McGarry v. Cingular Wireless, LLC, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1282 (2004) (order affirming denial of class cert.) o Mims v. Arrow Fin. Servs., LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2061 (2010) (Affirmed.) o Nicholson v. Hooters of Augusta, Inc., 1998 TCPA Rep. 1004 (1998) (Order granting class certification) o Nicholson v. Hooters of Augusta, Inc., 1996 TCPA Rep. 1436 (1996) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Nicholson v. Hooters of Augusta, Inc., 1998 TCPA Rep. 1570 (1998) (Vacated and remanded) o Nicholson v. Hooters of Augusta, Inc., 1999 TCPA Rep. 1630 (1999) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Nicholson v. Hooters of Augusta, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1631 (2001) (Final judgment and award of costs and fees.) o Phillip Long Dang, D.C., P.C. v. XLHealth Corp., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2103 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Schneider v. Susquehanna Radio Corp., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1203 (2003) (affirmed in part and reversed in part and remanded) o Teper v. Empire Ent. & Travel, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1646 (2005) (Order granting inspection of computers without notice.) o Wreyford v. Citizens for Transp. Mobility, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2586 (2013) (Motion for judgment on the pleadings denied.)

o Arnold v. Melwani, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2169 (2011) (Motions to reconsider, vacate, and amend denied.)

o Inhance Corp. v. Discount Vacation Rentals, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1131 (2001) (class cert.) o Inhance Corp. v. Special T Travel Services, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1132 (2001) (class cert.)

o ABC Bus. Forms, Inc. v. Pridamore, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1951 (2009) (Motions to dimiss and srike granted in part and denied in part.) o ABC Business Forms, Inc. v. Acroprint Time Recorder, Co., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1876 (2008) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Abbas v. Selling Source, LLC, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1947 (2009) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Acuity Mut. Ins. Co. v. Sup. Mktg. Sys., Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1242 (2003) (order finding duty to defend) o Addison Automatics, Inc. v. Hartford Cas. Ins. Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2625 (2013) (Reversed and remanded.)

o Addison Automatics, Inc. v. RTC Group, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2577 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Alleman v. Yellowbook, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2614 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Am. Economy Ins. Co., Inc. v. T.J. Copy Prods., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1321 (2004) (Defendant's motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction granted.) o Am. Home Assurance Co. v. Mcleod USA, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1526 (2007) (Insured's motion for partial summary judgment ion duty to defend granted.) o Am. Home Assurance Co. v. Mcleod Usa, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1496 (2006) (MSJ granted to Pltf.) o Am. States Ins. Co v. Capital Assoc. of Jackson County, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1315 (2004) (Reversed.) o Am. States Ins. Co. v. Capital Assoc. of Jackson County, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1259 (2003) (order finding duty to defend) o Anderson v. Leading Edge Recovery Solutions, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2384 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment denied.) o Auto-Owners Ins. Co. v. Websolv Computing, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1575 (2007) (Insured's MSJ granted on duty to defend.) o Auto-Owners Ins. Co. v. Websolv Computing, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1927 (2009) (Reversed and remanded.) o Ballard Nursing Center, Inc. v. All Pro Ele., Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1857 (2008) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Ballard Nursing Ctr., Inc. v. GF Health Prod., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1757 (2007) (Remand granted.) o Benedia v. Super Fair Cellular, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1692 (2007) (Motion to dismiss on statute of limitations denied.) o Bernstein v. Am. Family Ins. Co., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1268 (2004) (order denying def. MTD) o Bernstein v. Am. Family Ins. Co., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1405 (2005) (Order denying class cert.) o Birchmeier v. Caribbean Cruise Line, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2403 (2012) (Motions to dismiss denied.) o Birchmeier v. Caribbean Cruise Line, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2455 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Bogot v. Olympic Funding Chicago, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1267 (2003) (order granting class certification) o Bridgeport Pain Control Center, Ltd. v. Cutera, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1870 (2009) (Motion to amend granted.) o Bridgeview Health Care Center Ltd. v. Clark, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2493 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment granted in pat and denied in part.) o Bridgeview Health Care Center Ltd. v. Clark, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2603 (2013) (Motion for reconsideration denied.) o Bridgeview Health Care Center, LTD v. Clark, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2192 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment denied.) o Bridgeview Health Care Center, LTD v. Clark, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2193 (2011) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Bridgeview Health Care Center, LTD v. Clark,, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2473 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment granted in part.) o Bridgeview Health Care Center, Ltd. v. State Farm Fire and Cas. Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2553 (2013) (Reversed and remanded.) o Brill v. Becktold Ent., Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1494 (2006) (MTD denied) o Brill v. Becktold Enters., Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1856 (2009) (Class certification granted.) o Brill v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1389 (2005) (Reversal) o Brill v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1607 (2005) (Plaintiff's motion for remand granted.) o Brodsky v. Humana, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1904 (2009) (Motion to compel granted in part.) o Brodsky v. HumanaDental Ins. Co., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2090 (2011) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Brodsky v. HumanaDental Ins. Co., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2190 (2011) (Motion to certify interlocutory appeal denied.)

o Brodsky v. HumanaDental Ins. Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2402 (2012) (Motion for leave to file second amended complaint denied.) o Brodsky v. HumanaDental Ins. Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2419 (2012) (Motion for reconsideration denied.) o Business Pro Commc'n, Inc. v. Express Products, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1791 (2008) (Motion to remand granted.) o Byer Clinic & Chiropractic, Ltd. v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2489 (2013) (Affirmed.) o C.E. Design LTD v. King Architectural Metals, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2068 (2010) (Motion for class certification granted.) o C.E. Design LTD v. Matrix LS, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1974 (2010) (Motion for class certification granted.) o C.E. Designs v. Kallman Worldwide, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1524 (2006) (Motion for remand and attorney fees granted.) o C.E.Desing, Ltd. v. Letrix USA, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2656 (2013) (Motion for class certification granted.) o CE Design Ltd. v. Cy's Crabhouse North, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1908 (2009) (Class certification granted.) o CE Design Ltd. v. Cy's Crabhouse North, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1991 (2010) (Motion do dismiss denied. Motion for protective order granted.) o CE Design Ltd. v. Cy's Crabhouse North, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2032 (2010) (Motion to challenge confidential designation granted.) o CE Design Ltd. v. King Architectural Metals, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2106 (2011) (Vacated and remanded.) o CE Design Ltd. v. King Supply Co., LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2334 (2012) (Motion to intervene denied.) o CE Design Ltd. v. Prism Bus. Media, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1986 (2010) (Affirmed.) o CE Design Ltd. v. Prism Business Media, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1910 (2009) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o CE Design Ltd. v. Speedway Crane, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2183 (2011) (Motion for class certification denied.) o CE Design v. Beaty Constr., Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1855 (2009) (Class certification granted.) o CE Design v. Omni Facade, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1425 (2006) (Defendant's motion to dismiss and deny class certification denied.) o CE Design, LTD v. C&T Pizza, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2496 (2013) (Motion for class certification granted.) o CE Design, Ltd. v. Bryce Parker Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2302 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o CE Design, Ltd. v. Federal Schedules, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1721 (2006) (Insurer's motion to intervene denied.) o CE Design, Ltd. v. Mortg. Exch., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1621 (2007) (Appeal of denial of class certification dismissed as out of time.) o CE Designs, LTD. v. The Tradeshow Network Mktng., Grp., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1364 (2004) (Class certification granted.) o Centerline Equip. Corp. v. Banner Personnel Serv., Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1775 (2008) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Centerline Equip. Corp. v. Banner Personnel Serv., Inc.,, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1894 (2009) (Summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.) o Chapman v. Wagener Equities, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2414 (2012) (Motions to modify class and to file a 2nd amended complaing granted.) o Cincinnati Ins. Co. v. Chapman, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2329 (2012) (Certified questions answered) o Clearbrook v. Rooflifters, LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2003 (2010) (Class certification denied.) o Clendenin v. Philly's Best Cheese Steaks, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1879 (2008) (Motion to transfer denied.) o Cohen & Malad, P.C. v. USMoney Source, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1802 (2006) (Motion for class certification granted.)

o Constr. Consulting Group, LTC v. Gersten Fin. & Ins., Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1199 (2002) (Motion to remand granted.) o Constr. Consulting Group, LTD v. Gersten Fin. & Ins., Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1342 (2003) (order certifying settlement class) o Country Mut. Ins. Co. v. Cell Net, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1689 (2007) (Reversed and remanded.) o Craftwood Lumber Co. v. Interline Brands, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2607 (2013) (Motion for sanctions granted.) o Creative Montessori Learning Center v. Ashford Gear, LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2038 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Creative Montessori Learning Center v. Ashford Gear, LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2039 (2010) (Motion to designate documents confidential denied.) o Creative Montessori Learning Center v. Ashford Gear, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2149 (2011) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Creative Montessori Learning Centers v. Ashford Gear LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2208 (2011) (Vacated and remanded.) o Creative Montessori Learning Centers v. Ashford Gear LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2356 (2012) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Cynthia L. Holmes, P.C. v. Back Doctors, LTD, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1923 (2009) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Cynthia L. Holmes, P.C. v. Back Doctors, LTD, 2010 TCPA Rep. 1954 (2010) (Reconsideration denied, case remanded.) o D.G. ex rel. Tang v. William W. Siegel & Associates, Attorneys at Law, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2139 (2011) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o D.G. v. Diversified Adjustment Service, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2200 (2011) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Damas v. Ergotron, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1455 (2005) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Damas v. Ergotron, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1715 (2005) (Defendant's motion for summary judgment denied.) o Damas v. Ergotron, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1722 (2006) (Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment granted.) o Damasco v. Clearwire Corp., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2040 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Damasco v. Clearwire Corp., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2205 (2011) (Affirmed) o Desai v. ADT Sec. Sys., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2382 (2012) (Motion to dismiss third-party claims granted in part and denied in part.) o Desai vs. ADT Security Services, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2143 (2011) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Dobbin v. Wells Fargo Auto Fin., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2138 (2011) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Donnelly v. NCO Fin. Sys., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2013 (2010) (Objections to magistrate judge's discovery order denied. ) o Eclipse Manuf. Co. v. M and M Rental Center, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1466 (2006) (order denying MTD) o Eclipse Manuf. Co. v. M and M Rental Center, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1554 (2007) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Eclipse Manuf. Co. v. M and M Rental Center, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1588 (2007) (Motion to strike denied.) o Eclipse Manuf. Co. v. M and M Rental Ctr., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1543 (2007) (Defendant's motion to strike denied.) o Eclipse Manuf. Co. v. U.S. Compliance Co., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1638 (2006) (Remand granted in post-judgment third-part action against insurer.) o Eclipse Manuf. Co. v. U.S. Compliance Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1730 (2007) (Affirmed) o Erie Ins. Exchange v. Uncle Tom's Inc, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2314 (2012) (Motion for summary judgement granted.) o First Capital Mortg. Corp. v. Union Federal Bank of Indianapolis., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1563 (2007) (Reversed and remanded) o First Capital Mortg. Corp. v. Union Federal Bank of Indianapolis., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1862 (2005) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Flag Co. v. Maynard, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1458 (2005) (MTD denied)

o Flexicorps, Inc. v. Benjamin & Williams Debt Collectors, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1726 (2007) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Flexicorps, Inc. v. Benjamin & Williams Debt Collectors, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1557 (2007) (Motion to dismiss granted and motion to transfer venue denied.) o Flexicorps, Inc. v. Myron Corp., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2067 (2010) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Frausto v. IC System, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2172 (2011) (Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment denied. Defendant's motion granted.) o G.M. Sign, Inc. v. 400 Freight Servs., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1934 (2010) (Class certification granted.) o G.M. Sign, Inc. v. Brink's Mfg. Co., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2086 (2011) (Motion for class certification denied.) o G.M. Sign, Inc. v. Finish Thompson, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1911 (2009) (Class certification granted.) o G.M. Sign, Inc. v. Franklin Bank, S.S.B., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1595 (2006) (Motion to file third-party complaint granted.) o G.M. Sign, Inc. v. Franklin Bank, S.S.B., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1659 (2006) (Remand denied, motion to dismiss header violations count granted.) o G.M. Sign, Inc. v. Franklin Bank, S.S.B., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1737 (2007) (Class certification denied.) o G.M. Sign, Inc. v. Franklin Bank, S.S.B., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1799 (2008) (Motion for class certification denied.) o G.M. Sign, Inc. v. Franklin Bank, S.S.B., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1820 (2008) (Class certification granted.) o G.M. Sign, Inc. v. Global Shop Solutions, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1471 (2006) (Remand granted) o G.M. Sign, Inc. v. Group C Commc'ns, Inc,, 2010 TCPA Rep. 1949 (2010) (Motion for class certification granted.) o G.M. Sign, Inc. v. Group C Commc'ns, Inc, (N.D. Ill. Jan. 10, 2011), 2011 TCPA Rep. 2076 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o G.M. Sign, Inc. v. Groupe Cirque Du Soleil, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1990 (2010) () o G.M. Sign, Inc. v. MFG.COM, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1885 (2009) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o G.M. Sign, Inc. v. Schane, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2464 (2013) (Reversed and remanded.) o G.M. Sign, Inc. v. Stergo, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1946 (2009) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o GBL Assoc. v. Staples, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1535 (2004) (Motion for legal determination granted.) o Gans v. Seventeen Motors, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1144 (2002) (order granting class cert [settlement class]) o Garrett v. Ragle Dental Lab., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2045 (2010) (Class certification granted.) o Gen. Repair Servs.of Central Indiana v. Soff-Cut Int'l, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1307 (2002) (order granting class cert.) o Glen Ellyn Pharmacy v. Meda Pharm. Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2077 (2011) (Motion to dismiss conversion and state law claims denied.) o Glen Ellyn Pharmacy v. Promius Pharma, LLC, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1916 (2009) (Motion to summary judgment denied.) o Green v. Anthony Clark Int'l Ins. Brokers, Ltd., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1913 (2009) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Green v. Anthony Clark Int'l Ins. Brokers, Ltd.,, 2010 TCPA Rep. 1943 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Green v. Dahn Yoga & Health Ctrs., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2206 (2011) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Green v. Service Master On Location Servs. Corp., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1901 (2009) (Class certification granted.) o Green v. Time Ins. Co., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1897 (2009) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Greene v. DirecTV, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1977 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Greene v. DirecTV, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2054 (2010) (Motion for summary judgment granted.)

o Griffith v. Consumer Portfolio Serv., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2163 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment denied.) o Gruse v. AccuWeather, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2521 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Hanley v. Green Tree Servicing, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2494 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Hartford Cas. Ins. Co. v. Topsail Sportswear, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2022 (2010) (Motion to transfer venue granted.) o Hartford Fire Ins. Co. v. Eagle Equity Serv., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1998 (2010) (Motion to transfer granted.) o Hinman v. M & M Rental Center, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1785 (2008) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Hinman v. M & M Rental Center, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1861 (2009) (Motions for summary judgment granted and part and denied in part.) o Holliday v. Staples, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1444 (2005) (Defefendant's motion for summary judgment granted (Hobbs Act).) o Holt v. MRS BPO, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2655 (2013) (Motion to dismiss and for partial summary judgment denied.) o Holtzman v. Caplice, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1796 (2008) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Holtzman v. Turza, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1798 (2008) (Motion to dismisss denied.) o Holtzman v. Turza, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1922 (2009) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Holtzman v. Turza, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2008 (2010) (Partial MSJ granted to plaintiff.) o Holtzman v. Turza, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2050 (2010) (Cross motions for summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.) o Holtzman v. Turza, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2167 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment granted. Motion to decertify class denied.) o Holtzman v. Turza, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2567 (2013) (Affirmed.) o Hoppe v. Great Western Bus. Servs, LLC, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1783 (2008) (Motion to enforce settlement denied.) o Hurst v. Mauger, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2510 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Illinois v. Discovery Mktg., Inc., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1110 (2000) (order denying mtn. to dismiss) o In re Lake City Indistrial Products, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2440 (2013) (Petition denied.) o Indiana Ins. Co. v. Matrix LS, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1738 (2007) (Motion to dismiss counterclaim granted.) o Ins. Corp. of Hanover v. Shelborne Assocs., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1878 (2009) (Affirmed duty to defend.) o Ins. Corp. of Hanover v. Shelborne Assocs., 2005 TCPA Rep. 2367 (2005) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Ins. Corp. of Hanover v. Shelborne Assocs., 2007 TCPA Rep. 2368 (2007) (Motion for summary judgment denied.) o Irish Sisters, Inc. v. Crown Mortg Co., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2184 (2011) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Italia Foods, Inc. v. Marinov Ent., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1728 (2007) (Motion to dismiss on constitutional grounds denied) o Italia Foods, Inc. v. Sun Tours, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1944 (2010) (Certified questions answered.) o Italia Foods, Inc. v. Sun Tours, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2134 (2011) (Affirmed in part and vacated in part.) o Iverson v. Lily's Bridal & Gifts, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2005 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Iverson v. Rick Levin & Assocs., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2004 (2010) (Order on motion to compel discovery responses.) o JT's Frames, Inc. v. The Sunhill NIC Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2268 (2012) (Affirmed) o Jamison v. First Credit Services, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2500 (2013) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Jamison v. First Credit Services, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2583 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Johansen v. Vivant, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2422 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Kershner v. Murray & Trettel, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1669 (2006) (Motion to dismiss common law and state law claims granted.) o Kim v. Sussman, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1404 (2004) (Motion for class certification denied.)

o Kubiesa, Spiroff, Gosselar, Acker & Kern, P.C. v. Tier One Telecom. Mgmt. Group., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1293 (2004) (order denying def. MTD) o Landmark Am. Ins. Co. v. NIP Group, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2180 (2011) (Reversed and remanded.) o Landmark Am. Ins. Co. v. NIP Group, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2222 (2011) (Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remand.) o Locklear Ele. v. Matrix Lead Source, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1525 (2006) (order denying remand) o Locklear Ele., Inc. v. Lay, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1950 (2009) (Motion to dimiss denied.) o Locklear Elec. v. My Overhead Corp., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1729 (2007) (Sua sponte order directing plaintiff to file motion for remand.) o Loncarevic & Assocs., Inc. v. Stanley Foam Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2495 (2013) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Lozano v. Twentieth Century Fox Film Corp., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1963 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o MAFS, Inc., of Ill. v. Marcus & Millichap, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1859 (2009) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o MAFS, Inc., of Ill. v. Marcus & Millichap, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1906 (2009) (Motion to reconsider and to certify question denied.) o MBH, Inc. v. Eniva USA, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2056 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Mark Chair Co. v. Mortg. Managers, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1241 (2002) (order denying def. MTD) o Martin v. Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless,, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2443 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Martin v. Comcast Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2678 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Martin v. Leading Edge Recovery Solutions, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2342 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Martin v. Midland Funding LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2166 (2011) (Motion to reassign and consolidate denied.) o Martin v. Onstaff, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1284 (2003) (order granting class cert. (settlement)) o Martin v. PPP, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1996 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Maximum Indem. Co. v. Global Gear Sales Co., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1794 (2008) (Insured's motion for summary judgment granted on duty to defend.) o Maxum Indem. Co. Sec. Ins. Co. of Hartford v. Eclipse Mfg. Co., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1838 (2008) (Petition to intervene granted.) o Maxum Indem. Co. v. Eclipse Mfg. Co., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2137 (2011) (Motions for summary judgmet denied in part and granted in part.) o Maxum Indem. Co. v. Eclipse Mfg. Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2236 (2012) (Reconsideration granted. Summary judgment denying duty to defend vacated.) o Maxum Indem. Co. vs. Global Gear Sales Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1649 (2007) (Magistrate recommendation that stay be denied.) o Maxum Indemnity Co. v. Eclipse Mfg. Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2660 (2013) (Insurer's motion for summary judgment denied.) o Maxum Indemnity Co. v. Eclipse Mfg. Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2665 (2013) (Insurer's motion for summary judgment denied.) o Md. Cas. Co. v. Pennswood Partners, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2363 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Meridian Sec. Ins. Co. v. Sadowski, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1459 (2006) (vacated and remanded) o Metro Kirby Co. v. Hines, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1255 (2003) (order denying def. MTD) o Mitchem v. Ill. Collection Serv., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2031 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied. Class certification denied.) o Mitchem v. Ill. Collection Serv., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2075 (2011) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Mitchem v. Ill. Collection Serv., Inc.,, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2245 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Mixon Ins. Agency, Inc. v. Taylorville Chiropractic Clinic, LTD., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2152 (2011) (Motion for class certifcation granted.)

o Mussat v. Global Healthcare Resource, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2476 (2013) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Nationwide Ins. Co. v. New United, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2299 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o New Century Mortg. Corp. v. Great Northern Inc. Co., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1479 (2006) (Cross MSJs denied.) o Norman v. Northern Illinois Gas Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2653 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted with leave to amend.) o North Suburban Chiropractic Clinic, Ltd. v. Merck & Co., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2617 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Old Town Pizza of Lombard, Inc. v. Corfu-Tasty Gyro's Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2257 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Overlord Ent., Inc. v. Wheaton-Winfield Dental Assocs., Ltd., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1718 (2006) (Class certification granted.) o Pace Commc'ns. Servs. Corp. v. Express Prods. Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2111 (2011) (Affirmed.) o Paldo Sign & Display Co. v. Topsail Sportswear, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2057 (2010) (Class certification granted.) o Paldo Sign and Display Co. v. Topsail Sportswear, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1938 (2010) (Motion to dismiss state law claims granted.) o Pastry Partners, Inc. v. Ticket Heaven, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1717 (2006) (Judgment in favor of plaintiff.) o Pekin Ins. Co. v. Valentino Elec., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2124 (2011) (Defendant's motion for summary judgment granted.) o Pekin Ins. Co. v. XData Solutions, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2267 (2011) (Affirmed.) o Pereira v. Santander Consumer USA, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2377 (2012) (Motion to compel arbitration denied.) o Perkin Ins. Co. v. XData Solutions, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2182 (2011) (Affirmed) o Phillips Randolph Ent., LLC v. Adler-Weiner Research Chicago, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1590 (2007) (Defendant's motion to dismiss granted.) o Phillips Randolph Ent., LLC v. Rice Fields, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1517 (2007) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Physicians Healthshource, Inc. v. Alma Lasers, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2354 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Physicians Healthsource, Inc. v. Allscripts-Misy's Healthcare Solutions, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2404 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Pickering v. ADP Dealer Servs., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2475 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Pintas v. Bebon Office Machines Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1683 (2007) (Motion to strike class allegations denied.) o Pollack v. Cunningham Fin. Group, LLC, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1837 (2008) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Pollack v. Fitness Innovative Techs., LLC, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1858 (2009) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Powell v. West Asset Mgmt., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2118 (2011) (Motion to strike affirmative defense granted.) o Practice Mgmt. Support Servs., Inc v. Appeal Solutions, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1948 (2010) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Quality Mgmt. & Consulting Servs., Inc. v. SAR Orland Food Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2666 (2013) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Quality Mgmt.and Consulting Servs., Inc. v. SAR Orland Food Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2316 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o R. Rudnick & Co. v. Brilliant Event Planning, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2099 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o R. Rudnick & Co. v. G.F. Protection, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1852 (2009) () o Radha Geismann, M.D., P.C. v. Allscripts Healthcare Solution, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2078 (2011) (Motion to dismiss based on offer of judgment denied.)

o Rawson v. C.P. Partners, LLC, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1407 (2005) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Repay v. The Flag Co., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1299 (2004) (order granting remand) o Robin Hill Dev., Co. v. JD&T Ent., Inc., d/b/a Travel to Go, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1073 (2002) (order denying Def. mtn. to dismiss) o Rossario's Fine Jewelry, Inc. v. Jurgens Fine Jewelry, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1720 (2007) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Rossario's Fine Jewelry, Inc. v. Paddock Publications, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1578 (2007) (Defendants motion of summary judgment granted.) o Rossario's Fine Jewelry, Inc. v. Paddock Publications, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1599 (2006) (Motion to dismiss common law and state law claims granted.) o Sadowski v. Med1 Online, LLC, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1773 (2008) (Motions to strike, to dismiss, and for class certification denied.) o Sadowski v. Med1 Online, LLC, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1793 (2008) (Motion for class certification granted) o Sadowski v. OCO Biometical, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1845 (2008) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Saf-T-Gard Int'l, Inc. v. Vanguard Energy Servs., LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2411 (2012) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Saf-T-Gard Int'l, Inc. v. Wagener Equities, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1810 (2008) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Sandusky Wellness Center LLC v. Medtox Scientific, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2578 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Sather Builders, Inc. v. Cornerstone Distrib., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2083 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted in pat and denied in part.) o Sather Builders, Inc. v. Cornerstone Distributing, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2123 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Savannah Group, Inc. v. Trynex, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2429 (2013) (Motion for class certification continued.) o Savannah Group, Inc. v. Trynex, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2606 (2013) (Cross motions for summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.) o Schlosser v. St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1320 (2004) (order granting def. motion to dismiss) o Scott v. Westlake Servs., LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2546 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Sengenberger v. Credit Control Services, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1983 (2010) (Partial summary judgment granted to plaintiff and defendant.) o Sengenberger v. Credit Control Services, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2115 (2010) (Motion to reconsider granted.) o Shen v. Distributive Networks, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1676 (2007) (Final order and judgment in settlement class.) o Shen v. Distributive Networks, LLC, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1519 (2007) (Order granting preliminary approval of class settlement.) o Smith v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2627 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Soppet v. Enhanced Recovery Co., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2173 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment denied.) o Soppet v. Enhanced Recovery Co., LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2297 (2012) (Affirmed.) o St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co. v. Brother Intern. Corp., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1601 (2006) (Motion to transfer granted.) o St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co. v. Brunswick Corp., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1461 (2005) (Judgment finding no duty to defend) o St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co. v. Franklin Bank, S.S.B., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1592 (2006) (Transfer of venue sought by insured granted.) o St. Paul Guardian Ins. Co. v. Baird & Warner Holding Co., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1463 (2005) (Motion to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction granted.) o St. Paul Mercury Ins. Co. v. Commercial Prop. Assocs., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1609 (2005) (Insured's motion to dismiss granted.)

o St. Paul Mercury Ins. Co. v. Commercial Property Assocs., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1465 (2005) (reconsideration denied.) o Standard Mut. Ins. Co. v. Lay, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2283 (2012) (Affirmed.) o Standard Mut. Ins. Co. v. Lay, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2514 (2013) (Reversed in part, affirmed in part, and remanded.) o Standard Mut. Ins. Co. v. Lay, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2680 (2013) (Reversed.) o Sterk v. Path, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2637 (2013) (Motion to dismiss and to stay denied.) o Stonecrafters v. Almo Distrib. New York, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1813 (2008) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Stonecrafters, Inc. v. CM Sys., Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1246 (2003) (order granting remand) o Stonecrafters, Inc. v. Foxfire Printing and Packaging, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1905 (2009) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Strickler v. Bijora, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2393 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Tang v. Medical Recovery Specialists, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2141 (2011) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Targin Sign Sys., Inc. v. CYC Golden Palace Corp., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2195 (2011) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Targin Sign Sys., Inc. v. Preferred Chiropractic Center, LTD, 2010 TCPA Rep. 1937 (2010) (Motion for class certification granted. ) o Telecom. Network Design v. McLeodUSA Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1417 (2005) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Telecom. Network Design, Inc. v. Paradise Distrib., Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1433 (2006) (order certifying settlement class) o Telecom. Network Design, Inc. v. Paradise Distrib., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1564 (2007) (Insurer's motion to intervene denied.) o The Savannah Grp., Inc. v. Truan, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2202 (2011) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Thrasher-Lyon v. CCS Commercial, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2358 (2012) (Cross-motions for partial summary judgment denied and granted.) o Thrasher-Lyon v. Illinois Farmers Ins. Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2271 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Torres v. Nat'l Enter. Systems, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2343 (2012) (Partial motion to dismiss denied..) o Transp. Ins. Co. v. Casey, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1365 (2005) (order finding duty to defend) o Transp. Ins. Co. v. Casey, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1370 (2005) (order denying mtn. to reconsider) o Transp. Ins. Co., v. Striker Sec., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1544 (2007) (Affirmed in part and reversed in part.) o Travel 100 Group v. Empire Cooler Servs., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1312 (2004) (order granting class cert.) o Travel 100 Group v. Empire Cooler Servs., Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1482 (2006) (Cross motions for summary judgment denied.) o Travel 100 Group, Inc. v. Mediterranean Shipping Co., (USA), Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1185 (2003) (order to preserve documents) o Travel 100 Group, Inc. v. Mediterranean Shipping Co., (USA), Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1792 (2008) (Affirmed.) o Travel 100 Group, Inc. v. Mediterranean Shipping Co., (USA), Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1887 (2006) (Motion to strike denied; Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Trojanowski v. Advance Placement Services, Inc.,, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2082 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied in apart and granted in part.) o Uesco Inds., Inc. v. Continental Cas. Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2432 (2012) (Reversed and remanded.) o Uesco Indus., Inc. v. Poolman of Wis., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2550 (2013) (Reversed and remanded.) o Uesco v. Poolman, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2156 (2011) (Motion for class certification granted.) o United States v. DISH Network, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2519 (2013) (Motion for sanctions granted in part and denied in part.)

o United States v. DISH Network, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2670 (2013) (Motion to compel allowed in part and denied in part.) o United States v. Dish Network, LLC, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1926 (2009) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o United States v. Dish Network, LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 1941 (2010) (Reconsideration denied.) o United States v. Dish Network, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2079 (2011) (Motion to compel granted in part and denied in part.) o United States v. Dish Network, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2100 (2011) (Stay granted.) o United States v. Dish Network, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2504 (2013) (Motion for sanctions granted in part and denied in part.) o Uretsky v. Starr Security Systems, 1994 TCPA Rep. 1117 (1994) (trial decision in favor of plaintiff) o Valley Forge Ins. Co. v. Swiderski Ele., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1402 (2005) (Affirmed) o Valley Forge Ins. Co. v. Swiderski Ele., Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1499 (2006) (affirmed) o Vigus v. S. Ill. Riverboat/Casino Cruises, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2105 (2011) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Volpe v. Caribbean Cruise Line, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2576 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Weiss, Sugar, Dvorak & Dusek v. Human Resource Store, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1759 (2004) (Motion to dismiss denied with respect to consitutional grounds.) o Wellington Homes, Inc. v. West Dundee China Palace Restaurant, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2444 (2013) (Certified questions answered.) o West Washington Bldg., LLC v. Body Wise Int'l, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1686 (2007) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Western Ry. Devices Corp. v. Lusida Rubber Prods., Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1481 (2006) (MTD granted in part and denied in part.) o Whiteamire Clinic, P.A., Inc. v. Quill Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2612 (2013) (Motion for stay denied.) o Whiteamire Clinic, P.A., Inc. v. Quill Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2626 (2013) (Motion to compel granted.) o Whiting Corp. v. Goindustry, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1719 (2005) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Whiting Corp. v. JIT Human Resource Solutions, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1234 (2003) (order denying def. MTD re: Lutz) o Whiting Corp. v. MSI Mktg., Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1141 (2003) (order denying def. MTD) o Whiting Corp. v. MSI Mktg., Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1232 (2003) (order denying def MTD based on McCarran-Ferguson Act) o Whiting Corp. v. MSI Mktg., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1333 (2004) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Whiting Corp. v. SunGard Corbel, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1413 (2005) (Order granting class cert.) o Windmill Nursing Pavilion, LTD. v. Gornick's Auto Rebuilders, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2512 (2013) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Windmill Nursing Pavillion, LTD. v. Res-Care Ill., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2112 (2011) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Younes v. Capital Research Group, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1231 (2003) (order denying motion to dismiss based on tender offer to class rep.) o Younes v. Capital Research Group., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1360 (2005) (MTD third party plaintiff's third party complaint denied.) o Zersen v. PT Ins. Group, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2400 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Zoes v. North Am. Bancard, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1562 (2004) (Motion to dismiss (constitutional defenses) denied.)

o Ace Mortg. Fund., Inc. v. Travelers Indem. Co. of Am., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1780 (2008) (Affirmed.) o Am.Family Mut. Ins. Co. v. C.M.A. Mrtg., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2014 (2010) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Cohen & Malad, P.C. v. USMoney Source, Inc., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1111 (2000) (order reversing position on federal court jurisdiction)

o Core Funding Group, LLC v. Young, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1145 (2003) (affirming class certification) o Erie Ins. Exch. v. Kevin T. Watts, Inc. d/b/a The Benefits Network, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1497 (2006) (Insurer's motion for judgment on the pleadings granted.) o Erie Ins. Exchange v. Kevin T. Watts, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1637 (2006) (Judgment granted to insurer on duty to defend and imdemnify.) o FreeEats.com, Inc. v. Indiana, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1593 (2006) (Preliminary injunction against enforcement of state telemarketing law denied.) o FreeEats.com, Inc. v. Indiana, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1634 (2007) (Reversed in part, vacated in part, and remanded for dismissal.) o Gold Seal Termite & Pest Control Co. v. DirecTV, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1190 (2003) (Remand granted.) o Gold Seal Termite and Pest Control Co. v. Prime TV, LLC, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1075 (2002) (order granting class cert.) o Gold v. YOUMAIL, INC., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2482 (2013) (Motion to amend granted.) o Gold v. YouMail, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2596 (2013) (Motion to amend granted.) o Indiana v. Economic Freedom Fund, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2228 (2011) (Reversed and remanded,) o Kenro, Inc. v. APO Health Care, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1211 (2001) (order granting class cert.) o Kenro, Inc. v. Fax Daily, Inc., 1995 TCPA Rep. 1173 (1995) (Motion to remand denied.) o Kenro, Inc. v. Fax Daily, Inc., 1997 TCPA Rep. 1174 (1997) (Motions to dismiss and for class certification denied.) o Patriotic Veterans, Inc. v. Ind. ex rel. Zoeller, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2187 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Patriotic Veterans, Inc. v. Indiana, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2676 (2013) (Reversed and remanded.)

o Adv. Med. Assocs., P.A v. Drake, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2563 (2012) (Affirmed.) o Anderson Office Supply, Inc. v. Adv. Med. Assocs., P.A., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2110 (2011) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Anderson Office Supply, Inc. v. Adv. Med. Assocs., P.A., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2125 (2010) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Anderson Office Supply, Inc. v. Adv. Med. Assocs., P.A., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2129 (2011) (Order granting class certification, clarifying class definition, and denying sta) o Anderson Office Supply, Inc. v. Advanced Med. Assocs., P.A., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2261 (2012) (Affirmed) o Crichfield Physical Therapy v. Taranto Group, Inc, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1863 (2009) (Class certification granted.) o Critchfield Physical Therapy v. Taranto Group, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2181 (2011) (Affirmed) o Critchfield Physical Therapy, P.C. v. Taranto Group, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2281 (2012) (Motion to remand granted.) o Fun Servs. of Kansas City v. Hertz Equip. Rental Corp, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1767 (2008) (Motion to remand granted.) o Fun Servs. of Kansas City, Inc. v. Nat'l Floral Exchange, Inc.,, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1846 (2008) (Default Judgment.) o Geismann v. Aesthetic Cate, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1786 (2008) (Motion for remand granted.) o Geismann v. Aesthetic Cate, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1806 (2008) (Motion for attorney fees granted.) o Park Univ. Ent., Inc. v. Am. Cas. Co., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1285 (2004) (order finding duty to defend) o Park Univ. Ent., Inc. v. Am. Cas. Co., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1460 (2006) (affirmed)

o Ashland Hosp. Corp. v. Service Employees Intern. Union, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2460 (2013) (Affirmed.)

o Whaley v. T-Mobile, USA, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2616 (2013) (Motion to compel arbitration granted.)

o Accounting Outsourcing, LLC v. Verizon Wireless Personal Commc'ns, L.P., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1219 (2003) (order denying remand) o Accounting Outsourcing, LLC v. Verizon Wireless Personal Commc'ns, L.P., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1221 (2003) (magistrate judge decision on motion to remand) o Accounting Outsourcing, LLC v. Verizon Wireless Personal Commc'ns, L.P., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1222 (2003) (magistrate judge decision on motion to remand) o Accounting Outsourcing, LLC v. Verizon Wireless Personal Commc'ns, L.P., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1304 (2004) (order denying def. mtd.) o Accounting Outsourcing, LLC v. Verizon Wireless Personal Commc'ns, L.P.,, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1970 (2007) (Class final judgment.) o Bailey v. Domino's Pizza, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2276 (2012) (Motion for reconsideration granted.) o Display South, Inc v. Express Computer Supply, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1552 (2007) (Class certification affirmed.) o Display South, Inc v. Graphics House Sports Promotions, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1797 (2008) (Affirmed.) o Display South, Inc v. Graphics House Sports Promotions, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1871 (2008) (Settlement.) o Display South, Inc v. Graphics House Sports Promotions, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1872 (2008) (Final class judgment.) o Gene & Gene, LLC v. Biopay, LLC, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1513 (2006) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Gene & Gene, LLC v. Biopay, LLC, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1819 (2008) (Reversed) o Gene & Gene, LLC v. Biopay, LLC, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1931 (2009) (Motion to recertify class granted.) o Gene and Gene, LLC v. Biopay, LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2047 (2010) (Reversed.) o Paradise v. Al Copeland Investmetns, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1917 (2009) (Reversed.) o RPM Pizza, LLC v. Argonaut Great Cent. Ins. Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2505 (2013) (Motion for partial summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.) o Spillman v. RPM Pizza, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2062 (2010) (Motion to remand denied.) o Spillman v. RPM Pizza, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2136 (2011) (Motion for reconsideration denied.) o Spillman v. RPM Pizza, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2532 (2013) (Memorandum approving class settlement. )

o Bais Yaakov of Spring Valley v. ACT, Inc, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2686 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Blue Wave Corp. v. North End Chiropractic LLC., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2633 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o CE Design Ltd. v. Am. Economy Ins. Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2426 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Collins v. Locks & Keys, of Woburn, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1936 (2009) (Class certification granted.) o Cynosure v. St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins., Co., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1883 (2009) (Insured's for summary judgment granted.) o Fray-Witzer v. Metro. Antiques, LLC, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1411 (2005) (Order granting class cert.) o Fray-Witzer v. Metro. Antiques, LLC, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1650 (2006) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Fray-Witzer v. Olde Stone Land Survey Co., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2089 (2011) (Order approving class settlement)

o Harper v. Credit Control Servs., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2307 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Jones v. FMA Alliance Ltd., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2644 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Mulhern v. MacLeod, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1247 (2003) (order granting def. MTD) o Mulhern v. MacLeod, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1289 (2004) (appeal reversing and remanding) o Mulhern v. MacLeod, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1428 (2006) (Order granting class cert.) o NVS v. Bruno, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2207 (2011) (Order assessing damages.) o Oney v. Fiducia, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1279 (2004) (memorandum order granting judgment to plaintiff) o Pelland v. America's Toner, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1072 (2002) (order and judgment) o Physicians HealthSource, Inc. v. MultiPlan Services, Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2620 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Reichenbach v. Fin. Fredom Ctrs, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1644 (2007) (Trial decision denying attorney's fees affirmed.) o Reichenbach v. Fin. Freedom Ctrs., Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1423 (2006) (Affirmed) o Sherman v. Vision Lab Telecom., Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1432 (2006) (order denying MTD) o Sparkle Hill, Inc. v. v. Interstate Mat Corp., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2418 (2012) (Motion for class certification graanted.) o Terra Nova Ins. Co. v. Fray-Witzer, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1565 (2007) (Judgment in favor of insurer reversed and remanded.) o Terra Nova Ins. Co. v. Metro. Antiques, LLC, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1443 (2006) (Insurer's MSJ granted on duty to defend and indemnify.)

o AGV Sports Group, Inc. v. Protus IP Solutions, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1902 (2009) (MTD granted in part.) o AGV Sports Group., Inc. v. Protus IP Solutions, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1976 (2010) (Reconsideration denied.) o AVG Sports Group, Inc. v. Westfax, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2010 (2010) () o Adoff v. Protus IP Solutions, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1928 (2009) (Remand granted.) o Applestein v. Fairfield Resorts, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1979 (2009) (Affirmed) o Asher & Simons, P.A. v. j2 Global Canada, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2615 (2013) (Motions to dismiss, for partial summary judgment, and default judgment granted.) o Asher & Simons, P.A. v. j2 Global Canada, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2647 (2013) (Motion to reconsider granted; motion for partial summary judgment denied.) o Balt. Podiatry Group v. IHire, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2130 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Balt.-Washington Tel. Co. v. The Hot Leads Co., LLC, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1835 (2008) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Baltimore Podiatry Group v. National Direct, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2515 (2013) (Reversed.) o Brey Corp. v. LQ Mgmt. L.L.C., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2229 (2011) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Brey Corp. v. LQ Mgmt. L.L.C., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2340 (2012) (Application for request for international judicial assistance granted.) o Dr. Stuart T. Zaller, LLC V. Pharmawest Pharmacy, LTD., et al., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2198 (2011) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Felland Limited Partnership v. Digi-tel Commc'ns, LLC., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1318 (2004) (affirmance) o Germantown Copy Center, Inc., v. Comdoc, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2142 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment denied.) o Kensington Physical Therapy, Inc. v. Jackson Therapy Partners, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2325 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Kensington Physical Therapy, Inc. v. Jackson Therapy Partners, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2638 (2013) (Renewed motion to dismiss denied.)

o Law Offices of Leonard I. Desser, P.C. v. Shamrock Commc'ns, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2533 (2013) (Motions denied in part and granted in part.) o Levitt v. Fax.com, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1035 (2001) (injunction to preserve evidence) o Levitt v. Fax.com, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1069 (2002) (order denying Def. MSJ) o Levitt v. Fax.com, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1158 (2002) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Levitt v. Fax.com, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1328 (2004) (Reversed and remanded.) o Levitt v. Fax.com, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1419 (2005) (Order granting D. MTD re SOL.) o Levitt v. Fax.com, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1600 (2007) (Motion to decertify class granted.) o Lynn v. Monarch Recovery Mgmt., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2324 (2012) (Motion to compel granted in part and denied in part.) o Lynn v. Monarch Recovery Mgmt., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2483 (2013) (Motions for summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.) o Lynn v. Monarch Recovery Mgmt., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2555 (2013) (Reconsideration granted in part and denied in part.) o Marine Tech., Inc. v. DirecTV, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1076 (2002) (order granting class cert.) o Md. Cas. Co. v. Express Prods., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2240 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Md. v. Universal Elections, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2133 (2011) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Md. v. Universal Elections, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2564 (2013) (Affirmed.) o Md. v. Universal Elections, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2313 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Nat'l Fed'n of the Blind v. FTC, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1635 (2005) (Constitutionality of FTC Telemarketing Sales Rule affirmed) o Nat'l Fed'n of the Blind v. FTC, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1662 (2004) (Summary judgment granted in favor of defendant.) o Pasco v. Protus IP Solutions, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2209 (2011) (Motions for summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.) o Powers v. Dupree, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1860 (2009) (Reversed and remanded.) o R.A. Ponte Architects, Ltd. v. Investors' Alert, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1204 (2003) (Affirmed,) o R.A. Ponte Architects, Ltd. v. Investors' Alert, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1303 (2004) (reversal on appeal) o R.A. Ponte Architects, Ltd. v. Investors' Alert, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1706 (2005) (Class certification granted.) o Rantz-Kennedy v. Discover Fin. Servs., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2551 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Silbaugh v. Omni Credit, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2247 (2012) (Entry of default judgment granted.) o Silbaugh v. Omni Credit, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2255 (2012) (Order granting default judgment.) o Weiner v. Protus IP Solutions, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2153 (2011) (Motion to transfer granted. Reconsideration denied.) o Weiner v. Protus IP Solutions, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2154 (2011) (Motion for protective order denied.) o Weiner v. Protus IP Solutions, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2155 (2011) (Motion to compel granted.) o Worsham v. Accounts Receivable Mgmt., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2395 (2012) (Affirmed.) o Worsham v. Acct. Receivables Mgmt., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2216 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Worsham v. Americor Lending Group, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1854 (2008) (Class certification denied.) o Worsham v. Americor Lending Group, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 2140 (2007) (Affirmed in part and reversed in part.) o Worsham v. Ehrlich, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1824 (2008) (Affirmed.) o Worsham v. Fairfield Resorts, inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1918 (2009) (Vacated and remanded.) o Worsham v. Nationwide Ins. Co., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1031 (2001) (Affirmed in part, vacated in part, and remanded.) o Worsham v. Shimony, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1606 (2007) (Motion to dismiss on statute of limitations denied.) o Worsham v. TNT Mktg., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1508 (2007) (Motion to dismiss denied.)

o Zurich Am. Ins. Co. v. Fieldstone Mortg. Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1758 (2007) (Insured's motion for summary judgment on duty to defend granted.)

o APB Assocs., Inc. v. Bronco's Saloon, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1955 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o APB Assocs., Inc. v. Bronco's Saloon, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2352 (2012) (Motion for leave to file 3rd party complaint denied.) o APB Assocs., Inc. v. Bronco's Saloon, Inc.,, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2517 (2013) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Am. Copper & Brass, Inc. v. Lake City Ind. Prods, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2030 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Am. Copper & Brass, Inc. v. Lake City Ind. Prods, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2339 (2012) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Am. Copper & Brass, Inc. v. Lake City Ind. Prods, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2539 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Am. Copper & Brass, Inc. v. Lake City Indus. Prods., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2049 (2010) (Motion to certifiy interlocutory appeal granted.) o Auto-Owners Ins. Co. v. Tax Connection Worldwide, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2412 (2012) (Affirmed.) o Bridging Communities, Inc. v. Top Flite Fin., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1981 (2010) (Dismissed for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.) o Bridging Communities, Inc. v. Top Flite Fin., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2211 (2011) (Reversed and remanded.) o Bridging Communities, Inc. v. Top Flite Fin., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2434 (2013) (Motion fto dismiss denied.) o Bridging Communities, Inc. v. Top Flite Fin., Inc.,, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2544 (2013) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Compressor Eng'g Corp. v. Chicken Shack, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2028 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Compressor Eng'g Corp. v. Chicken Shack, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2599 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Compressor Eng'g Corp. v. Manufacturers Fin. Corp., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2025 (2010) (Dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.) o Compressor Eng'g Corp. v. Manufacturers Fin. Corp., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2212 (2011) (Reversed and remanded.) o Compressor Eng'g Corp. v. Manufacturers Fin. Corp., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2364 (2012) (Motion for leave to file 3rd party complaint denied.) o Compressor Eng'g Corp. v. Manufacturers Fin. Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2520 (2013) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Comspec Intern., Inc. v. RentSonic, L.L.C., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2248 (2012) (Recommendation motion to dismiss be denied.) o Erie Ins. Exchange v. Lake City Indus. Prods., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2301 (2012) (Reversed and remanded.) o Exclusively Cats Veterinary Hosp. v. Anesthetic Vaporizer Servs., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2071 (2010) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Exclusively Cats Veterinary Hosp. v. Florida Infusion Services, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2537 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Exclusively Cats Veterinary Hosp. v. Thomas Veterinary Drug, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2037 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Farm Bureau Mut. Ins. Co. v. Graphics House Sports, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1800 (2008) (Affirmed.) o GM Sign, Inc. v. Auto-Owners Ins. Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2387 (2012) (Affirmed. ) o Glassbrook v. Rose Acceptance, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2685 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.)

o Harris v. World Fin. Network Nat. Bank, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2277 (2012) (Motions to strike and for partial summary judgment granted.) o Imhoff Inv., LLC v. Alfoccino of Auburn Hills, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2279 (2012) (Reversed and remanded.) o Imhoff Investment, LLC v. Alfoccino of Auburn Hills, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2020 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Imhoff Investment, LLC v. Sammichaels, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2365 (2012) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Investments, LLC v. Sammichaels, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2300 (2012) (Motion to dismiss class allegations denied.) o Jackson's Five Star Catering, Inc. v. Beason, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2344 (2012) (Order to show cause set aside.) o Jackson's Five Star Catering, Inc. v. Beason, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2662 (2013) (Motion to strike granted. Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Kane v. Nat'l Action Fin. Servs., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2197 (2011) (Motion to dismiss denied in part and granted in part.) o Kane v. Nat'l Action Fin. Servs., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2298 (2012) (Motion to compel granted.) o Machesney v. Lar-Bev of Howell, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2017 (2010) (Dismissed for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.) o Machesney v. Lar-Bev of Howell, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2511 (2013) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Pugliese, v. Professional Recovery Serv., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2002 (2010) (Motion for partial summary judgment and to strike granted.) o Samaras v. Morgen Drexen, 2010 TCPA Rep. 1965 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Samaras v. Morgen Drexen, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1966 (2009) (Motion for summary judgment denied.) o Shelton v. Cyberdata, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1697 (2007) (Trial decision denying exemption for fax broadcasters affirmed.) o Small v. Kmart Holding Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2474 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o State Farm Fire and Cas. Co. v. Piron, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2162 (2011) (Recommendation toat entry of default be granted.) o Van Sweden Jewelers, Inc. v. 101 VT, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2323 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment denied.) o Van Sweden Jewelers, Inc. v. 101 VT, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2355 (2012) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Vandenberg & Sons Furniture, Inc. v. Katchen, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2446 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Washington Mortg. Co. v. Instant Response Mktg., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1374 (2004) (order denying Def. MTD.)

o Barry v. Dell Computer Corp., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1193 (2000) (Motion to remand granted.) o Carnes v. IndyMac Mortg. Servs., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2073 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Carye v. Luzaich, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1331 (2003) (Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment granted.) o Carye v. Luzaich, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1343 (2004) (Judgment in favor of plaintiff.) o Gelakoski v. Colltech, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2430 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Hashw v. Department Stores Nat. Bank, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2681 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Merchant & Gould, P.C., v. Premiere Global Servs., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2027 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Merchant & Gould, P.C., v. Premiere Global Servs., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2064 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.)

o Minnesota v. Casino Mkt'g. Group, Inc., 1991 TCPA Rep. 1178 (1991) (Temporary injunction against advertiser's use of ADAD affirmed.) o Minnesota v. Casino Mktg. Group, Inc., 1992 TCPA Rep. 1179 (1992) (affirming denial of def. MTD) o Minnesota v. Sunbelt Commc'ns and Mktg., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1112 (2002) (Motion for preliminary injunction granted.) o Minnesota v. Sunbelt Commc'ns and Mktg., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1186 (2002) (Plaintiff's motion for preliminary injunction granted.) o Owners Ins. Co. v. European Auto Works, Inc. d/b/a/ Autopia, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2164 (2011) (Insured's motion for summary judgment granted.) o Owners Ins. Co. v. European Auto Works, Inc. d/b/a/ Autopia, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2357 (2012) (Affirmed) o Percic Enters., Inc. v. European Autoworks, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1988 (2010) (Remand granted.) o Sandusky Wellness Center LLC v. Medtox Scientific, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2477 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Seebach v. Mobile Cellular Unlimited. Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1439 (2003) (order granting ptf. MSJ on liability) o Seebach v. Source Lending Corp., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1390 (2005) (Order denying def. MTD.) o Van Bergen v. Minnesota, 1995 TCPA Rep. 1235 (1995) (Affirmed.) o Zortman v. J.C. Christensen & Assocs., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2291 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment granted.)

o Affordable Healthcare, LLC v. Protus IP Solutions, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1884 (2009) (Motion to dismiss out of state plaintiffs granted.) o Affordable Healthcare, LLC, v. Protus IP Solution, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1914 (2009) (Motion for protective order granted.) o All Am. Painting, LLC v. Fin. Solutions and Assocs., Inc, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1891 (2009) (Affirmed.) o All Am. Painting, LLC v. Fin. Solutions and Assocs., Inc,, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2000 (2010) (Reversed and remanded.) o Altman v. Aqua Vie Beverage Corp., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1329 (2005) (order granting plaintiff MSJ) o Altman v. Inside Edge, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1291 (2004) (order denying def. MSJ, granting pltf. MSJ) o Americom Imaging Sys. Inc. v. Diamond Waste Ind. III, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1273 (2004) (order denying def. MTD.) o Americom Imaging Sys., Inc. v. Texas Computer Resale, LLC, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1184 (2003) (order denying def. MTD) o Americom Imaging Sys., Inc. v. Texas Computer Resale, LLC, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1367 (2004) (order denying def. MTD) o Americom Imaging Sys., Inc. v. Trash Taxi of St. Louis, LLC, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1272 (2004) (order denying def. MTD.) o Ameriguard, Inc. v. Univ. of Kansas Med. Ctr. Research Inst., Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1491 (2006) (MTD granted) o Ameriguard, Inc. v. Univ. of Kansas Med. Ctr. Research Inst., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1532 (2007) (affirmed) o BMR Ind., Inc. v. Central Missouri Pizza, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1077 (2002) (injunction to preserve records) o Boschert v. Professionals Direct Ins. Servs., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2497 (2011) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Brentwood Travel Serv., Inc. v. Ewing d/b/a Carousel of Stitches, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1063 (2002) (order denying def. MTD)

o Brentwood Travel Servs., Inc v. DCT Enters., Inc, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1840 (2007) (Class certification granted.) o Brentwood Travel v. Dana Capital Group, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1536 (2007) (Order denying PO) o Brentwood Travel, Inc. v. Annex Computers, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1046 (2001) (order granting Pl. MSJ and injunction issued) o Brentwood Travel, Inc. v. Lancer, Ltd., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1018 (2001) (order den. Def. mtn. to dismiss) o Brentwood Travel, Inc. v. Lancer, Ltd., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1019 (2001) (order granting Pl. MSJ) o Brodeur v. Lou Fusz Automotive Network, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1412 (2005) (Order denyiong def. MSJ) o Brodeur v. Lou Fusz Automotive Network, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1541 (2006) (Final judgement and class certification.) o Brodeur v. Swan Fin. Corp., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1437 (2006) (Motion to remand granted.) o C-Mart, Inc. v. Metro. Live Ins. Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2540 (2013) (Motion to transfer granted.) o CBI.COM, Inc. v. Gross, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1372 (2005) (order denying def. MTD) o Clean Carton Co. v. 24 Hour Fitness USA, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1305 (2002) (order denying class cert.) o Clean Carton Co. v. Prime TV, LLC, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1294 (2004) (order granting class cert.) o Clean Carton Co., Inc. v. Constellation 3D, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1055 (2002) (order denying Def. mtn. to dismiss re First Amendment) o Clean Carton Co., Inc. v. Constellation 3D, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1056 (2002) (order denying MTD on third party acts) o Clean Carton Co., Inc. v. Robert Reason, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1102 (2002) (order and judgment granting pltf. MSJ) o Coleman v. Am. Blast Fax, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1021 (2001) (order and judgment) o Coleman v. Am. Blast Fax, Inc., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1022 (2000) (order denying Def. JOP.) o Coleman v. Real Estate Depot, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1026 (2001) (order granting Pl. MSJ) o Coleman v. Varone, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1030 (2001) (order denying Def. mtn to dismiss.) o Colt Ind., Inc. v. Ernie Patti Pontiac-GMC, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1097 (2002) (order denying def. MTD on 1st amendment grounds and denying stay) o Columbia Cas. Co. v. Hiar Holdings, LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2048 (2010) (Order finding duty to defenend.) o Columbia Cas. Co. v. Hiar Holdings, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2131 (2011) () o Columbia Cas. Co. v. Hiar Holdings, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2175 (2011) (Insured's motion for summary judgment on duty to defend granted.) o Columbia Cas. Co. v. Hiar Holdings, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2204 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Columbia Cas. Co. v. Hiar Holdings, LLC,, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2565 (2013) (Affirmed.) o Critchfield Physical Therapy, P.C. v. Techhealth, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2351 (2012) (Motion for relief granted.) o Critchfield Physical Therapy, P.C. v. Techhealth, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2468 (2013) (Motion to compel granted in part and denied in part.) o Daniel Co. of Springfield v. Fax.com, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1265 (2004) (order declaring mitigation of damages unavailable as a defense) o Danis, Cooper, Cavanagh & Hartweger, LC v. Capital Commc'ns Co., 1995 TCPA Rep. 1712 (1995) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Davis v. Chatter, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1839 (2008) (Entry of default and sanctions affirmed) o Davis, Keller, Wiggins, LLC. v. JTH Tax, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1040 (2001) (order denying Def. mt. to dismiss) o Evans & Green, LLP v. Meadoworks, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2232 (2012) (Motion to remand denied.) o Evans & Green, LLP v. That's Great News, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2386 (2012) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Fortune Group, LLC v. JD&T Ent., d/b/a Travel To Go, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1309 (2004) (order denying def. MTD)

o Franklin County Express, LLC v. Global Commc'ns, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1099 (2002) (order denying def. MTD) o Fun Services of Kansas City, Inc. v. Love, 2010 TCPA Rep. 1985 (2010) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Fun Services of Kansas City, Inc. v. Love, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2127 (2011) (Motion to remand granted.) o Fun Servs. of Kansas City, Inc. v. AMF Bowling Centers, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1841 (2005) (Order and Judgment (Class settlement)) o Fun Servs. of Missouri, Inc. v. Drury Inns, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1095 (2003) (order denying costs on remand motion) o Fun Servs. of Missouri, Inc. v. Drury Inns, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1098 (2002) (order remanding to state court) o Gans v. Leiserv, Inc. d/b/a Brunswick Four Seasons Bowl, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1092 (2003) (order granting pl. mtn. to remand) o Gans v. Leiserv, Inc. d/b/a Brunswick Four Seasons Bowl, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1354 (2004) (Final judgment and class certification) o Goans Acquisition, Inc. v. Merchant Solutions, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2629 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Harjoe v. Colonial Life & Accident Ins. Co., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1064 (2002) (order granting Pl. MSJ) o Harjoe v. Colonial Life & Accident Ins. Co., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1065 (2002) (trial de novo order granting Pl. MSJ) o Harjoe v. Freight Center, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1017 (2001) (order den. Def. mtn. to dismiss) o Harjoe v. Herz Fin., Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1205 (2003) (Affirmed) o Harjoe v. Prime TV, LLC, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1278 (2004) (order denying def. MSJ.) o Harvey v. General Elec. Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2337 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Heller v. HRB Tax Group, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2191 (2011) (Motion to remand denied.) o Heller v. HRB Tax Group, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2234 (2012) (Motion to remand denied.) o Heller v. HRB Tax Group, Inc.,, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2405 (2012) (Motion for protective order granted.) o Hoops & Assocs., P.C. v. Fin. Solutions & Assocs, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2199 (2011) (Reversed and remanded.) o Hoops & Assocs., P.C. v. Fin. Solutions & Assocs, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2406 (2011) (Judgment order for plaintiff.) o Hoops & Assocs., P.C. v. Fin. Solutions and Assocs., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2442 (2013) (Reversed and remanded.) o I Dream Solns., Inc. v. Ellsworth, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1071 (2002) (order denying Def. mtn. to dismiss) o Information Mgmt. Solns., Inc. v. Data Support. Sys., Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1330 (2003) (order denying def. MTD) o J.C. Corporate Management, Inc. v. Resource Bank, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1384 (2005) (order granting remand) o Joseph-Cowan v. Royal Gate Dodge, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1540 (2006) (Final judgement and class certification.) o Karen Little, LLC v. Brinker Missouri, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1382 (2005) (order granting class cert.) o Karen Little, LLC v. Brinker Missouri, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1528 (2006) (Motion to approve confession of judgment denied.) o Karen Little, LLC v. Brinker Missouri, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1624 (2006) (appeal of class certification dismissed on procedural grounds) o Karen S. Little, L.L.C. v. Drury Inns, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1877 (2009) (Class certification granted.) o Karen S. Little, LLC v. Brinker Mo., Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1865 (2008) (Final judgment and order.) o Karen S. Little, LLC v. Drury Inns, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1935 (2010) (Class certification affirmed.)

o Lander and Berkowitz, P.C. v. Transfirst Health Servs., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1366 (2005) (order granting remand) o Lindsay Transmission, LLC v. Office Depot, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2437 (2013) (Motion to strike granted.) o Little v. Drury Inns, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1421 (2005) (Order denying MTD re SOL.) o MSG Jewelers, Inc., v. C & C Quality Printing, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1811 (2008) (Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment granted.) o Margulis v. 1-800-GOT-JUNK?, LLC, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1470 (2006) (Motion to dismiss class allegations denied.) o Margulis v. Benson, d/b/a/ Nat'l Assoc. of Ind. Landlords, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1306 (2004) (order denying def. MTD) o Margulis v. Fairfield Resorts, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1292 (2004) (order denying def. motion to compel) o Margulis v. P&M Consulting, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1094 (2003) (order denying def. MSJ and granting pl. MSJ) o Margulis v. P&M Consulting, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1248 (2003) (order affirming trial decision) o Margulis v. Voice Power Telecom., Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1023 (2001) (order denying Def. mtn. to dismiss) o Marquis Fin. Corp. v. Salter, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1332 (2004) (order debying def. MTD) o Med. W. Ballas Pharm., LTD v. Food Mktng. Merch., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1967 (2010) (Motion to dsimiss conversion count denied.) o Med. W. Ballas. Pharm., Ltd. v. Lidtke Tech., Corp., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1984 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Med. West Ballas Pharm., LTD v. Anda, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2121 (2011) (Motion to dismiss and to stay denied.) o Micro Eng. v. St. Louis Ass'n of Credit Mgmt., Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1080 (2002) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Micro Eng. v. St. Louis Ass'n of Credit Mgmt., Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1081 (2002) (order denying Def. mtn. to sever) o Micro Eng., Inc. v. Hotel Reservations Network, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1091 (2003) (order allowing motion to intervene) o Missouri ex rel JD&T Ent., d/b/a Travel To Go, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1310 (2004) (writ of prohibition denied) o Missouri ex rel. Nixon v. Am. Blast Fax, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1188 (2003) (order upholding constitutinality and reversing trial court) o Missouri v. Am. Blast Fax, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1196 (2002) (Motion to dismiss on First Amendment grounds granted.) o Missouri v. Am. Blast Fax, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1228 (2001) (order denying discovery) o Missouri v. Am. Blast Fax, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1426 (2005) (Judgment and injunction) o Mo. Info. Solutions, Inc. v. KC Subs, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1850 (2008) (Class certification granted.) o Moore v. CCB Credit Servs., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2433 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied in part and granted in part.) o Nack v. Walburg, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2081 (2011) (Judgment entry.) o Nack v. Walburg, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2513 (2013) (Reversed.) o Nack v. Walburg, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2618 (2013) (Motion for stay granted.) o Nat'l Ed. Acceptance, Inc. v. Community Lending Svc., Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1101 (2002) (form order denying def. MTD) o Nat'l Ed. Acceptance, Inc. v. Expiry Corp., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1096 (2002) (order denying def. MTD) o Nat'l Ed. Acceptance, Inc. v. Smartforce, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1057 (2002) (order and judgment) o Nat'l Ed. Acceptance, Inc. v. The Mars Corp. d/b/a Heavenly Ham, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1089 (2003) (order granting pl. MSJ.) o Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. v. Harris Med. Assocs., LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2632 (2013) (Motion for judgment on the pleadings denied.)

o O'Connor v. Diversified Consultants, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2375 (2012) (Motions to compel and to strike denied.) o O'Connor v. Diversified Consultants, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2536 (2013) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Olsen v. Siddiqi, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2196 (2011) (Motion for tunrnover granted.) o Onsite Computer Consulting Servs., Inc. v. Dartek Compter Supply Corp., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1452 (2006) (order denying MTD) o Onsite Computer Consulting Servs., Inc. v. Jansen, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1518 (2006) (Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment granted.) o Platke & Berkowitz, LLP v. IhireInc.Com, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1090 (2005) (Ptf. MSJ granted) o Psych. Assoc. v. Whittemore Corp., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1371 (2005) (order denying Def. MTD.) o Psychological Assoc., Inc. v. Advanced Tracking Tech., Inc., d/b/a Glaco, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1316 (2004) (order denying def. MTD) o R.F. Schraut Heating & Cooling, Inc. v. Maio Success Sys., Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1038 (2001) (order denying Def. Mtn. to dismiss) o Rada Geismann, M.D., P.C. v. Contexo Media, LLC, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1932 (2009) () o Rada Geismann, M.D., P.C. v. Contexo Media, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2238 (2012) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Radha Geismann, M.D., P.C. v. Byram Healthcare Centers, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1980 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Reynolds v. Diamond Foods & Poultry, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1048 (2002) (Reversed.) o Reynolds v. Diamond Foods & Poultry, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1175 (2002) (Reversed and remanded.) o Rhone v. Olympic Commc'n., Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1060 (2002) (order granting Pl. MSJ) o Rogers v. Medicredit, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2600 (2013) (Motion to amend denied.) o Schraut v. Rocky Mtn. Reclamation, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1182 (2001) (Order denying def. MTD) o Schumacher Fin. Servs., Inc. v. Allianz Life Ins. Co. of North Am., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1100 (2002) (form order denying def. MSJ.) o Schumacher Fin. Servs., Inc. v. Metropark Commc'ns, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1093 (2003) (order granting pl. MSJ) o Schumacher Fin. Servs., Inc. v. Nat'l Fed'n of Ind. Bus., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1088 (2003) (order granting pl. MSJ) o Schumacher Fin. Servs., Inc. v. Sorkins' Directories, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1264 (2004) (order denying def. MSJ and granting ptf's. MSJ.) o Schumacher Fin. Servs., Inc. v. Steckelberg, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1236 (2003) (Defendant's motion to dismiss denied.) o St. Louis Heart Center, Inc. v. Gilead Palo Alto, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2639 (2013) (Motion to stay granted.) o St. Louis Heart Center, Inc. v. Vein Centers For Excellence, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2266 (2011) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o St. Louis Heart Center, Inc. v. Vein Centers For Excellence, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2689 (2013) (Motion for class certification gratned.) o St. Louis Heart Center, Inc., v. Forest Pharm., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2471 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o State ex rel Nixon v. E. Dish Direct, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1539 (2006) (TRO granted) o State ex rel Nixon v. Progressive Bus. Pubs., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1538 (2007) (MTD granted) o State ex rel. Coffman Group, LLC v. Sweeney, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1391 (2005) (Preliminary order made permanent in part and dissolved in part.) o Swope v. Credit Mgmt., LP, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2459 (2013) (Motions to stay and to dismiss denied.) o Swope v. Credit Mgmt., LP, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2490 (2013) (Motion to sever and transfer granted.) o Top Craft Inc. v. Int'l Collection Servs., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1764 (2007) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Top Craft Inc. v. Int'l Collection Servs., Inc.,, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1805 (2008) (Reversed and remanded.)

o Travel Travel Kirkwood, Inc. v. Jen N.Y. Inc., dba Discount Tickets, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1410 (2005) (Order granting plaintiff MSJ.) o Travel Travel Kirkwood, Inc. v. Oceania Cruises, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1296 (2004) (order denying remand) o Travel Travel Kirkwood, Inc. v. Up and Away Travel, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1363 (2005) (order denying def. MTD.) o Travel Travel Kirkwood, Inc. v. Up and Away, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1394 (2005) (Order deny Def. MTD.) o Travel Travel, Kirkwood, Inc. v. Jen N.Y. Inc., dba Discount Tickets, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1467 (2006) (affirmed) o Univ. Und. Ins. Co. v. Lou Fusz Auto. Network, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1344 (2005) (Duty to defend addirmed.) o Univ. Und. Ins. Co. v. Lou Fusz Automotive Network, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1256 (2004) (order finding duty to defend) o VC Group Corp., v. HMA S. County,, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2157 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o VC Group, Corp. v. HMA S. County, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2188 (2011) (Affirmed.) o VC Group, Corp. v. HMA S. County, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2213 (2011) (Affirmed; motion to publish denied.) o Velez v. Portfolio Recovery Assocs., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2338 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Vertex Chem. Corp. v. Asphalt Paving Equip., LLC, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1263 (2004) (order denying def. MTD) o Vertex Chem. Corp. v. HMA S. County, LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2148 (2010) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Vertex Chem. Corp. v. Starbeam Supply Co., Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1139 (2003) (order granting pl. MSJ) o Whitehead v. J.C. Penney Corp., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1625 (2007) (Class certification granted (settlement).) o Zeid v. Image Connection, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1044 (2001) (Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment granted.) o Zeid v. The Reding Law Firm, P.C., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1051 (2002) (order denying def. MSJ on constitutional issues)

o Mr. Charley's Fun Jumps, LLC v. JRK Residential Group, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2560 (2013) (Remand denied.) o Teltech Systems, Inc. v. Barbour, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2219 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Teltech Systems, Inc. v. Bryant, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2409 (2012) (Affirmed.)

o A & L Indus., Inc. v. P. Cipollini, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2674 (2013) (Motion for reconsideration denied.) o Blitz v. Agean, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1612 (2007) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Blitz v. Agean, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1889 (2009) (Reversed in part and affirmed in part and remanded.) o Blitz v. Agean, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2280 (2012) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Blitz v. Agean, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2542 (2013) (Affirmed.) o Blitz v. Xpress Image, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1487 (2006) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Blitz v. Xpress Image, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1613 (2007) (Motion to dismiss interlocutory appeal granted.) o Friends of Joe Sam Queen v. Ralph Hise for NC Senate, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2397 (2012) ()

o Gibbons v. GC Services LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2628 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Hartford Cas. Ins. Co. v. Topsail Sportswear, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2084 (2011) (Scheduling order entered.) o In re Pryor (Pryor v. Bank of Am., N.A.), 2012 TCPA Rep. 2381 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Jenkins v. Allied Interstate, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1920 (2009) (Motion to dismiss granted, remanded sua sponte.) o Jenkins v. G.C. Servs., LP, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2273 (2012) (Motions to compel granted in part and denied in part.) o Jenkins v. Mann Bracken, LLP, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2174 (2011) (Motion to strike and for default granted.) o Leyse v. Bank of America, Nat. Ass'n, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1915 (2009) (Motion to transfer granted.) o North Carolina ex rel. Cooper v. Debt Mgmt. Found. Servs., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1313 (2004) (motion to remand granted) o Prime TV, LLC v. Travelers Ins. Co., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1113 (2002) (Partial summary judgment granted in favor of insured.) o Sacco v. Bank of America, N.A., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2416 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Thomas Cook Printing Co., Inc. v. Subtle Impressions, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1834 (2008) (Order approving class settlement.)

o North Dakota v. FreeEats.com, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1446 (2006) (affirmed decision finding no preemption of state law) o North Dakota v. FreeEats.com, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1803 (2005) (Def. motion for summary judgment denied.)

o Holster v. BNA Subsidiaries, LLC,, 2010 TCPA Rep. 1971 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Raitport v. Crown Kosher Meat Market, Inc.,, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2221 (2011) (Stay granted.) o Raitport v. Harbour Capital Corp., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1973 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied.)

o A & L Inds., Inc. v. CDM Tech. Training Inst., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2104 (2011) (Motion to remand granted.) o A & L Indus., Inc. v. P. Cipollini, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2640 (2013) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Bailey v. Colorado Prime, 1997 TCPA Rep. 1119 (1997) (order and judgment) o Bais Yaakov of Spring Valley v. Peterson's Nelnet, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2177 (2011) (Motion for stay granted.) o Bais Yaakov of Spring Valley v. Peterson's Nelnet, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2388 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Bais Yaakov of Spring Valley v. Peterson's Nelnet, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2461 (2013) (Motion to certify interlocutory appeal granted.) o Cellco P'ship v. Wilcrest Health Care Mgmt. Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2296 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted in part.) o Cherokee Realty v. Mega Trucking, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1416 (2005) (Order granting judgment to plaintiff) o City Select Auto Sales, Inc. v. David Randall Assocs., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2253 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Corson v. Accounts Receivable Mgmt., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2591 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.)

o Ex Parte Loube Consulting International, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2018 (2010) (Writ issued.) o Fenza's Auto, Inc. v. Montagnaro's, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2117 (2011) (Motion to remand granted.) o Fitzgerald v. Gann Law Books, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2438 (2013) (Affirmed.) o Fitzgerald v. Gann Law Books, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2584 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Freed v. Metro Marketing Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2641 (2013) (Motion to dismiss and for summary judgment denied.) o Freedman v. Advanced Wireless Cellular Commc'ns, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1694 (2005) (Motion to vacate default judgment and class certification granted) o Goodrich Mgmt. Corp. v. Afgo Mech. Servs., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2417 (2012) (Motion to deny class certification denied.) o Landsman & Funk, P.C. v. Skinder-Strauss Assocs., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1903 (2009) (Dismissed for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.) o Landsman & Funk, P.C. v. Skinder-Strauss Assocs., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2119 (2011) (Reversed and remanded.) o Landsman & Funk, P.C. v. Skinder-Strauss Assocs., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2327 (2012) (Motion for consolidation denied.) o Landsman & Funk, P.C. v. Skinder-Strauss Assocs., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2420 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Landsman & Funk, P.C. v. Skinder-Strauss Assocs., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2445 (2013) (Motion for reconsideration denied.) o Levine v. 9 Net Ave., Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1657 (2001) (Denial of class certification affirmed.) o Leyse v. Bank of Am., Nat. Ass'n, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2516 (2013) (Affirmed.) o Leyse v. Bank of America, N.A., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2335 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Leyse v. Bank of America, Nat. Ass'n, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2634 (2013) (Vacated and remanded.) o Local Baking Prods. Inc. v. Kosher Bagel Munch, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2144 (2011) (Affirmed.) o Local Baking Prods., Inc. v. Westfield Rental-Mart, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2463 (2013) (Remanded with instructions.) o Margulis v. Resort Rental, LLC, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1812 (2008) (Motion for remand denied.) o Meyer v. Howard S. Bixenholtz Constr., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1817 (2008) (Reversed and remanded.) o Mikhail v. Pipersville Car Parts, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2095 (2011) (Motions to transfer and to strike denied.) o Myron Corp. v. Atlantic Mut. Ins. Corp., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1510 (2007) (Insured's motion for partial summary judgment granted on duty to defend.) o Myron Corp. v. Atlantic Mut. Ins. Corp., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2029 (2010) (Affirmed.) o Myron Corp., v. Atlantic Mut. Ins. Corp., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1890 (2009) (Reversed and remanded.) o Oettinger v. Stevens Commercial Roofing, LLC, d/b/a Stevens Roofing, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2581 (2013) (Reversed.) o Penn Nat'l Ins. Co v. Group C Communc'ns, inc, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2150 (2011) (Affirmed in part and reversed in part.) o Physicians Healthsource, Inc. v. Janssen Pharm., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2448 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Physicians Healthsource, Inc. v. Janssen Pharm., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2453 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Spectracom, Inc. v. CellDirect Corp., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1137 (2003) (order granting class cert.) o St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co. v. Brother Intern. Corp., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1574 (2007) (Insurer's motion for summary judgment granted.) o St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co. v. Brother Intern. Corp., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1880 (2009) (Affirmed.) o Sterling Realty Co. v. Klein, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1353 (2005) (trial judgment) o Swisher v. The Labor Depot, LLC, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1739 (2007) (Denial of motion to open default reversed and remanded.) o Szefczek v. Hillsborough Beacon, 1995 TCPA Rep. 1118 (1995) (Trial order and judgment for plaintiff.) o Zelma v. Art Conway, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2690 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.)

o Zelma v. Konikow, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1369 (2005) (Reversed.) o Zelma v. Market U.S.A., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1032 (2001) (Reversed.) o Zelma v. Total Remodeling, Inc., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1002 (2000) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Zelma v. United Online Commc'ns, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1809 (2008) (Remand granted.)

o Carlson v. Nevada Eye Care Professionals, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2534 (2013) (Motions to dismiss denied.) o Edwards v. Direct Access, LLC, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1422 (2005) (Reversed and remanded) o Edwards v. Emperor's Garden Rest., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1451 (2006) (affirmed in part and reversed in part) o Edwards v. Nat'l Credit Adjusters, LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2042 (2010) (Reversed and remanded.) o Edwards v. Nat'l Credit Adjusters, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2398 (2012) (Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded.) o Edwards v. Osteopathic Med. Assoc. of Nevada, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1512 (2004) (Def. MTD granted in part and denied in part.) o Edwards v. Prof. Collection Consultants, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2097 (2011) (Reversed and remanded.) o Harris v. Am. Gen. Fin. Servs., LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2317 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Kaffko v. Quepasa Corp., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2186 (2011) (Motion to quash denied.) o Kristensen v. Credit Payment Servs. Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2465 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Pfister v. Selling Source, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2526 (2013) (Motion to transfer granted.)

o Antollino v. Hispanic Media Group USA, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1334 (2003) (order granting plaintiff MTD) o Antollino v. Lasalle Servs., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1335 (2004) (order granting plaintiff MSJ.) o Ari Weitzner, M.D., P.C. v. Commercial Lighting Indus., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1585 (2007) (Motion to compel denied.) o Bais Yaakov of Spring Valley v. Alloy, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2484 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Bank v. Green Bullion Fin. Servs., LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2114 (2011) (Affirmed.) o Bank v. Independence Energy Group LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2524 (2013) (Motion for reconsideration denied.) o Bank v. Independence Energy Group LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2682 (2013) (Vacated and remanded.) o Bates v. I.C. System, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1925 (2009) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Bonime v. Avaya, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1527 (2006) (order granting MTD) o Bonime v. Avaya, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1832 (2008) (Affirmed.) o Bonime v. Bridge 21, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1399 (2005) (Affirmed) o Bonime v. Discount Funding Assocs., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1401 (2005) (Affirmed) o Branham v. ISI Alarms, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2608 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Bromberg Law Office, P.C. v. Itkowitz & Harwood, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1501 (2006) (Judgment for Plaintiff) o Castro v. Green Tree Servicing LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2598 (2013) (Motions for summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.) o Conover v. BYL Collection Servs., LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2379 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment granted. ) o Foxhall Realty Law Off., Inc. v. Telecomm. Premium Servs., Ltd, 1998 TCPA Rep. 1170 (1998) (Affirmed.) o Foxhall Realty Law Off., Inc. v. Telecomm. Premium Servs., Ltd., 1997 TCPA Rep. 1169 (1997) (Motion to dismiss granted for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.)

o Ganci v. Cape Canaveral Tour and Travel, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1297 (2004) (order denying reargument) o Ganci v. Cape Canaveral Tour and Travel, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1398 (2005) (Affirmed.) o Ganci v. Cape Canaveral Tour and Travel, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1843 (2004) (Motion to dismiss denied in part and granted in part.) o Giovanniello v. Carolina Wholesale Office Machine Co., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1677 (2007) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Giovanniello v. Hispanic Media Group, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1308 (2004) (order granting def. motion for p.o. granted) o Giovanniello v. Hispanic Media Group USA, Inc.., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1397 (2005) (Affirmed in part and reversed in part.) o Giovanniello v. New York Law Pub. Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1579 (2007) (Defendant's motion to dismiss granted.) o Giovanniello v. Perry Johnson, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1290 (2004) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Giovanniello v. Perry Johnson, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1358 (2005) (order granting class cert.) o Gottleib v. Carnival Corp., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1864 (2009) (Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment granted.) o Gottleib v. Carnival Corp., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1907 (2009) (Reconsideration granted; Motion for summary judgment denied.) o Gottlieb v. Carnival Corp., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1356 (2005) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Gottlieb v. Carnival Corp., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1424 (2006) (Reversed) o Gottlieb v. Carnival Corp., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2233 (2011) (Motions for relief from judgment granted and denied.) o Gratt v. Etour and Travel, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1919 (2009) (Affirmed.) o Gratt v. Etourandtravel, Inc, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1705 (2007) (Dismissed for lack of jurisdiciton under CAFA.) o Haley v. Hughes Network Systems, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2663 (2013) (Default judgment entered.) o Hamlett v. Santander Consumer USA Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2491 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Holster v. Cohen, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2080 (2011) (Reversed and remanded.) o Holster v. Gatco, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1586 (2007) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o J.A. Weitzman, Inc. v. Lerner, Cumbo & Assoc., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1743 (2007) (Affirmed.) o Kaplan v. Democrat and Chronicle, 1999 TCPA Rep. 1207 (1999) (Reversed and remanded.) o Kaplan v. Democrat and Chronicle, 1998 TCPA Rep. 1696 (1998) (Dismissed for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.) o Kaplan v. First City Mortg., 1999 TCPA Rep. 1001 (1999) (Trial judgment for plaintiff.) o Kaplan v. Life Fitness Center, 1999 TCPA Rep. 1122 (1999) (order on trial de novo granting judgment to pl.) o Kaplan v. Ludwig, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1042 (2001) (Modified and affirmed as modified.) o Kenny v. Mercantile Adjustment Bureau, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2525 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Klein v. Vision Lab Telecoms., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1415 (2005) (Order denying remand and granting def. MTD) o Kovel v. Lerner, Cumbo & Assocs., Inc.,, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2126 (2011) (Modified and remanded.) o Levy v. Receivables Performance Mgmt., LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2622 (2013) (Motion for partial summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.) o Leyse v. Bank of Am. Nat'l Ass'n, 2010 TCPA Rep. 1992 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Leyse v. Clear Channel Broad., Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1462 (2006) (MTD granted) o Leyse v. Clear Channel Broad., Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1844 (2008) (Affirmed) o Leyse v. Flagship Capital Servs. Corp., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1396 (2005) (Affirmed) o Leyse v. Flagship Capital Servs. Corp., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1435 (2004) (order denying MTD) o May v. Asset Acceptance LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2506 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.)

o McGaughey v. Treistman, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1523 (2007) (Motion for class certification denied and motion to dismiss granted.) o Merchants & Bus. Men's Mut. Ins. Co. v. A.P.O. Health Co., Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1690 (2002) (On reargument, holds insurer had duty to defend and indemnify insured.) o Merchants & Bus. Men's Mutual Ins. Co. v. A.P.O.. Health Co., Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1079 (2002) (order on duty to defend insured) o Moore v. Firstsource Advantage, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2178 (2011) (Motion to strike granted. Motions for summary judgment denied.) o Nigro v. Mercantile Adjustment Bureau, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2478 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Rudgayzer & Gratt v. Cape Canaveral Tour and Travel, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1378 (2005) (affirmed) o Rudgayzer & Gratt v. Enine, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1208 (2002) (Motion to dismiss on First Amendment grounds granted.) o Rudgayzer & Gratt v. Enine, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1283 (2004) (order reversing and remanding) o Rudgayzer & Gratt, v. LRS Commc'ns, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1319 (2003) (Motion to vacate and amend complaint denied.) o Rudgayzer & Gratt, v. LRS Commc'ns, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1324 (2004) (affirmed and modified) o Saporito v. Vision Lab Telecomm., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1385 (2005) (Order denying motion to remand.) o Saporito v. Vision Lab Telecomm., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1393 (2005) (Order granting interlocutory appeal.) o Saporito v. Vision Lab Telecomm., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1418 (2005) (Order denying def. MTD.) o Saunders v. NCO Fin. Sys., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2421 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Schulman v. Chase Manhattan Bank, 2000 TCPA Rep. 1006 (2000) (Affirmed.) o Starkey v. Firstsource Advantage, LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 1997 (2010) (Recommendation that motion to dismiss be granted.) o Stein v. Greenlight Funding and Mortg. Corp., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1740 (2007) (Summary judgment granted to plaintiff.) o Stern v. Bluestone, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1483 (2006) (order granting partial SJ to plaintiff and striking defenses.) o Stern v. Bluestone, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1763 (2008) (Affirmed.) o Stern v. Bluestone, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1892 (2009) (Reversed) o Sussman v. I.C. System, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2470 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Sussman v. I.C. System, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2667 (2013) (Defendant's motion for certification for interlocutory appeal denied.) o Weber v. Rainbow Software, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1400 (2005) (Affirmed) o Weiss v. 4 Hour Wireless, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1472 (2004) (Reversal) o Weitzner v. Iridex Corp., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1469 (2006) (Motion for PO denied.) o Weitzner v. Sciton, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1591 (2006) (Defendant's motion to stay discovery denied.) o Weitzner v. Sciton, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1643 (2007) (Motion to dismiss granted.)

o Charvat v. Echostar Satellite, LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2074 (2010) (Matter referred to FCC.) o Adamo v. AT&T, 2000 TCPA Rep. 1083 (2000) (order and judgment) o Adamo v. AT&T, 2000 TCPA Rep. 1084 (2000) (Journal entry in favor of plaintiff upholding magistrate's decision.) o Adamo v. AT&T, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1087 (2001) (appeal)

o Ambrose v. Advanced Wireless Cellular Commc'ns Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1614 (2007) (Dismissal for lack of service reversed and remanded.) o Ambrose v. Expiry Corp., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1325 (2004) (judgment for plaintiff) o Ambrose v. Prime Time Ent., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1348 (2005) (judgment in favor of plaintiff) o Axis Fin. Group, Inc. v. I Hire, LLC, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1766 (2005) (Motion for remand granted.) o Betor v. Quantalytics, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1243 (2003) (order and judgment) o Boehm, Kurtz & Lowry v. Interstate Ins. Agency Servs., Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1836 (2008) (Reversed and remanded.) o Boehm, Kurtz & Lowry v. Interstate Ins. Agency Servs., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2055 (2010) (Affirmed.) o Bransky v. Shahrokhi, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1349 (2005) (reversed and remanded) o Brehm v. Worldwide Ind. Enters., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1994 (2010) (Motions for summary judgment denied.) o Bunn v. Precision Funding Corp., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1761 (2003) (Defendant's motion for summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.) o Burdge v. Assoc. Health Care Mgmt., Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1868 (2009) (Motion to dismiss granted, without prejudice.) o Burdge v. Assoc.Health Care Mgmt., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2093 (2011) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Burdge v. On Guard Sec. Servs. Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1474 (2006) (Reversed and Remanded.) o Cardinal Partners, LTD. v. Fernadez Discipline, LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2011 (2010) () o Cardinal Partners, LTD., v. Fernandez Discipline, LLC., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2096 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Cardinal Partners, LTD., v. Fernandez Discipline, Llc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2053 (2010) (Affirmed) o Chambers v. R & C Delivery, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1140 (2002) (Trial judgment for plaintiff.) o Charvat v. AT&T, 1999 TCPA Rep. 1005 (1999) (order denying in part and granting on part def. MSJ) o Charvat v. ATW, Inc., 1998 TCPA Rep. 1224 (1998) (affirmed) o Charvat v. Apaz, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1687 (2004) (Defendant's motion to transfer venue denied.) o Charvat v. Colorado Prime, Inc., 1998 TCPA Rep. 1223 (1998) () o Charvat v. Colorado Prime, Inc., 1998 TCPA Rep. 1302 (1998) (order affirming trail decision) o Charvat v. Continental Mortg. Servs., Inc., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1007 (2000) (Consent Judgment) o Charvat v. Crawford, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1244 (2003) (order reversing trial court decision for defendant) o Charvat v. Crawford, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1702 (2002) (Motion to dismiss granted as to TCPA claims.) o Charvat v. Credit Found. of Am., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1691 (2006) (Plaintiff's MSJ granted in part and denied in part.) o Charvat v. DFS Servs. LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2116 (2011) (Motion for default held in abeyance, motion tod dismiss granted.) o Charvat v. Direct Connect Digital, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1238 (2003) (decision and entry of default judgment and declaratory judgment) o Charvat v. Dish TV Now, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1671 (2005) (Stay issued.) o Charvat v. Dispatch Consumer Servs., Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1068 (2002) (Reversed and remanded.) o Charvat v. Dispatch Consumer Servs., Inc., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1714 (2000) (Judgment affirmed.) o Charvat v. Doucet, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1270 (2004) (consent judgment) o Charvat v. Echostar Satellite, LLC, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1848 (2008) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Charvat v. Farmers Ins. Columbus, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1822 (2008) (Affirmed in part and reversed in part.) o Charvat v. Foley, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1449 (2006) (order granting default) o Charvat v. GVN Mich., Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1881 (2009) (Affirmed) o Charvat v. GVN Mich., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2021 (2010) (Reversed and remanded.)

o Charvat v. GVN Michigan, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1762 (2008) (Defendant's motion for partial summary judgment granted.) o Charvat v. Hallmark Mortgage Servs., Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1041 (2001) (order denying def. MSJ) o Charvat v. Health Care Plan of Am., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1534 (2007) (trail judgment for plaintiff) o Charvat v. Integrity Indus. of Ohio, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1473 (2001) (.) o Charvat v. Konah Indus., LTD, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1681 (2005) (Cross motions for summary judgment denied in part and granted in part.) o Charvat v. NMP, LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2171 (2011) (Reversed and remanded.) o Charvat v. NMP, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2328 (2012) (Motion for default denied without prejudice.) o Charvat v. NMP, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2380 (2012) (Motion for default judgment granted.) o Charvat v. Oasis Mortg., Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1434 (2003) (affirming trial decision) o Charvat v. Ryan, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1480 (2006) (Reversed in part and affirmed in part.) o Charvat v. Ryan, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1503 (2006) (Recon. denied., conflict certified) o Charvat v. Ryan, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1618 (2006) (Conflict certified.) o Charvat v. Ryan, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1745 (2007) (Affirmed) o Charvat v. Telelytics, LLC, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1488 (2006) (Affirmed in part and reversed in part) o Charvat v. Voice Power Telecom., Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1024 (2001) (admission to being common carrier) o Charvat v. Voice Power Telecom., Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1155 (2003) (order on damages hearing) o Cicero v. U.S. Four, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1734 (2007) (Affirmed denial of class certification) o Clark v. Erickson Elec. Equip. Co., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1350 (2004) (Trial judgment for plaintiff.) o Clark v. Red Rose, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1300 (2004) (trial judgment) o Clockwork Courier, Inc. v. Blue Jay, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1620 (2005) (Default judgment for less than statutory damages reversed and remanded.) o Compoli v. AVT Corp., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1107 (2000) (Motion to remand granted.) o Compoli v. EIP Ltd., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1134 (2002) (Consent order and judgment for plaintiff.) o Compoli v. Providence, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1286 (2004) (order and judgment with injunction) o Compoli v. Weisberg, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1163 (2003) (order denying def. mtd and granting pl. MSJ on liability) o Culbreath v. Golding Ent., LLC, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1453 (2006) (affirmed) o Culbreath v. Golding Ents., LLC, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1572 (2007) (Affirmed) o Dawson v. Am. Dream Home Loans, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1505 (2006) (Trial judgment in favor of plaintiff.) o Dawson v. Am. Dream Home Loans, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1847 (2006) (Opinion and judgment.) o Dawson v. Digicall Comun'cns, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1476 (2006) (Plaintiff's MSJ granted) o Dawson v. Fidelity & Guar. Inc. Co., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1788 (2008) (Motion for remand granted) o Dawson v. Fidelity & Guar. Ins. Co., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2043 (2010) (Motion for summary judgment garndetgranted.) o Dawson v. Global Quality Assurance, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1509 (2006) (Judgment entry in favor of plaintiffs.) o Dubsky v. Advanced Cellular Commc'ns, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1266 (2004) (order certifying class and entering judgment) o Dun-Rite Const. Co. v. Amazing Tickets, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1260 (2004) (order granting remand and awarding fees) o Dun-Rite Const., Inc. v. Amazing Tickets, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1361 (2004) (affirmed) o Eagle Comms. v. Coral Beach Travel & Tours, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1492 (2006) (Appeal dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.) o Economus v. Providence, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1133 (2003) (order affirming magistrate's decision denying def. MTD) o Fackelman v. Micronix, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2408 (2012) (Affirmed.) o Ferron & Assoc., L.P.A. v. U.S. Four, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1619 (2005) (Summary judgment for defendant holding no PROA for header violations affirmed.) o Ferron v. DIRECTV, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1778 (2008) (Motion to remand granted)

o Goldberg v. Empire Mortg., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1377 (2004) (Third-party defendant's motion for summary judgment granted.) o Grady v. AMT Group, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1502 (2006) (Affirmed) o Grady v. Lenders Interactive Servs., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1295 (2004) (reversed and remanded) o Grady v. OTC Investor's Edge, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1262 (2003) (order and judgment in favor of plaintiff with injunction) o Grady v. Progressive Bus. Compliance, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1727 (2007) (Affirmed in part and reversed in part.) o Grady v. St. Cloud Mortg., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1138 (2003) (Trial judgment for plaintiff.) o Guiley v. Lexington Lending & Mortg. Group, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1684 (2005) (Magistrate report vacated and judgment entered for plaintiff.) o Hamilton v. Spurling, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2225 (2011) (Motion for judgment on the pleadings denied.) o Hamilton v. Spurling, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2487 (2013) (Discovery memo. granted in part and denied in part.) o Hamilton v. Spurling, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2492 (2013) (Judgment for defendant.) o Hamilton v. United Health Group, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1826 (2008) (Remand denied.) o Hamilton v. Voxeo Corp., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1873 (2009) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Harper v. New England Handpiece Repair, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1731 (2007) (Affirmed) o Hartford Fire Ins. Co. v. Flagstaff Inds., Corp., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2295 (2012) (Motion for default judgment granted.) o Hartford Fire Ins. Co., v. Flagstaff Inds., Corp, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2185 (2011) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Harvard Mtge Corp. v. Phillips, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1779 (2008) (Affirmed.) o Hirz v. Matrix Lead Source, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1537 (2007) (Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment granted.) o Hirz v. Matrix Lead Source, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1629 (2007) (Judgment entry in favor of plaintiffs) o Hirz v. Pickens, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1749 (2007) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Hirz v. Travelcom Ind., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1561 (2007) (Remanded, sua sponte) o Hirz v. Travelcom Ind., Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1787 (2008) (Motion for attorney fees granted.) o Houttekier v. Chiropractice Leadership Alliance, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2007 (2010) (Plaintiff's Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Irvine v. Akron Beacon Journal, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1045 (2002) (Judgment affirmed in part, reversed in part, and cause remanded.) o Jacobson v. Doctor's Assistance Corp., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1807 (2008) (Class certification granted.) o Jemiola v. XYZ Corp., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1037 (2001) (order granting prelim. injunction to preserve evidence) o Jemiola v. XYZ Corp., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1146 (2001) (order granting class cert.) o Jemiola v. XYZ Corp., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1252 (2003) (trial judgment in favor of plaintiff) o Lapurga v. Computer Bus. Works Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1626 (2006) (Judgment in favor of plaintiffs.) o Leyse v. Clear Channel Broad., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2369 (2012) (Affirmed.) o Leyse v. Clear Channel Broad., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2659 (2013) (Affirmed.) o Lucas v. Telemarketer Calling from (407) 476-5670, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2601 (2013) (Motion for PI denied; default granted.) o MDC Acquisition Co. v. North River Ins. Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2378 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o MDC Acquisition Co. v. Traveler's Property Cas. Co. of Am., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2654 (2013) () o Madorsky v. Radiant Telecom., Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1616 (2006) (Dismissal for lack of service reversed and remanded.) o Magnet Mortg., Inc. v. IMPAC Funding Corp., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1754 (2006) (Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.) o McPhillips v. Travelers Indemn. Co., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1867 (2009) (Affirmed.)

o McPhillips v. Travelers Property Cas. Ins. Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1577 (2007) (Motion to remand granted.) o Michel v. WM Healthcare Solutions, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2220 (2011) (Motion to compel granted.) o Michel v. WM Healthcare Solutions, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2223 (2011) (Magistrate order to compel affirmed.) o Miller v. Painters Supply & Equip. Co., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2158 (2011) (Affirmed.) o Miranda v. Saratoga Diagnostics, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2318 (2012) (Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded.) o Mokrytzky v. Direct Safety Co., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1808 (2008) (Remand granted.) o Mokrytzky v. Direct Safety Co.,, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1830 (2008) (Motion to remand granted.) o Mokrytzky v. Job Shop Network, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1617 (2007) (Judgment affirmed.) o Mokrytzky v. Super Sys., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1521 (2007) (Dismissal of claims filed after four year statute of limitations affirmed.) o Motorists Mut. Ins. Co. v. Dandy-Jim, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1886 (2009) (Affirmed) o Ohio ex rel. Corday v. Inner Health Chiropractic, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1995 (2009) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Omerza v. Bryant & Stratton, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1641 (2007) (Trial judgment in favor of advertiser affirmed.) o Omerza v. Bryant & Stratton, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1642 (2007) (Appeal from award of sanctions affirmed in part and reversed in part.) o Omerza v. Geppetto's Pizza & Ribs, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1468 (2006) (Ptf. MSJ granted.) o Pechnik v. Auto Accents Home Servs., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1345 (2004) (trial order in favor of plaintiff) o Pricom Asphalt Sealcoating, Inc. v. Furnas, 2009 TCPA Rep. 1895 (2009) (Appeal dismissed.) o Reichenbach v. Fin. Freedom Ctrs., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1322 (2004) (affirmed in part and reversed in part and remanded) o Reichenbach v. Fin. Freedom Ctrs., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1351 (2004) (plaintiff MSJ granted) o Reichenbach v. Chung Holdings, LLC, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1323 (2004) (reversal) o Royal Surplus Lines Ins. Co. v. U.S. Four, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1733 (2007) () o Sandusky Wellness Center, LLC v. DrFirst.com, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2427 (2012) (Motion to stay or transfer granted.) o Schuetz v. State Farm Fire and Cas. Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1804 (2007) (Cross-motions for judgment on the pleadings granted in part and denied in part.) o Siding and Insulation Co. v. Acuity Ins. Co., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2559 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Siding and Insulation Co. v. Beachwood Hair Clinic, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2179 (2011) (Motion for stay denied.) o Siding and Insulation Co. v. Beachwood Hair Clinic, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2237 (2012) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Siding and Insulation Co. v. Beachwood Hair Clinic, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2258 (2012) (Motion to intervene denied.) o Siding and Insulation Co. v. Combined Ins. Group, Ltd., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2287 (2012) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Silbaugh v. Viking Magazine Servs., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2260 (2012) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Singer v. BFS Capital, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1672 (2005) (Judgment in favor of plaintiffs.) o Singo v. Pentagon Mortg., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1336 (2004) (order and judgment) o Singo v. Sniper Security, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1257 (2004) (order on judgment) o Singo v. Statewide Fin. Servs., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1258 (2004) (order on judgment) o Speer v. Grady Med. Sys., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1741 (2007) (Defendant's motion for reconsideration denied.) o Speer v. Tony Riso Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1723 (2007) (Judgment entry in favor of plaintiffs.) o Squires Roofing, Inc. v. Hays, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1511 (2006) (order denying def. mtn. for reconsideration) o State ex rel. Charvat v. Frye, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1495 (2006) (writ granted)

o State ex rel. Charvat v. Frye, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1559 (2007) (Affirmed) o State ex rel. Madorsky v. Buchanan, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1493 (2006) (mandamus granted) o State ex rel. Petro v. Singer Secure Servs., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1673 (2005) (Judgment entered in favor of plaintiff.) o Stefano & Assoc., Inc. v. Global Lending Group, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1760 (2008) (Affirmed.) o Stefano & Assocs., Inc. v. Global Lending Grp., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1628 (2007) (Trial judgment in favor of plaintiffs.) o Stefano & Assocs., Inc. v. TCRM Commercial Corp., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1742 (2007) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Stoneman v. Turner Metal Prods., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1551 (2007) (Summary judgment in favor of defendant affirmed.) o Talty v. Strada Capital Corp., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1921 (2009) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Taylor v. XRG, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1615 (2007) (MSJ in favor of defendant phone company affirmed.) o Tower City Title Agency, Inc. v. Phillips, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1774 (2008) (Affirmed.) o Tryon v. Nationwide Chem. Corp., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1769 (2007) (Judgment entry in favor of plaintiff.) o Westfield Ins. Co. v. Diamond Co., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1675 (2005) (Summary judgment finding coverage granted to insured.) o Yavitch & Palmer Co., LPA, v. US Four, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1392 (2005) (Order granting plaintiff MSJ.) o Yavitch & Palmer Co., LPA, v. US Four, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1409 (2005) (Reversed and remanded.) o Yavitch & Palmer Co., LPA, v. US Four, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1504 (2006) (Reversed and remanded) o Zehala v. Am. Express, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2450 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment denied in part and granted. in part.) o Zehala v. American Exp., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2294 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment denied in part and granted in part.)

o Braver v. Perry Johnson, Inc., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1104 (2000) (order granting remand) o Charvat v. EchoStar Satellite, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2648 (2013) (Vacated and remanded.) o Charvat v. Echostar Satellite, LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2034 (2010) (Motion to unseal granted.) o Charvat v. NMP, LLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 1969 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Lampkin v. GGH, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1489 (2006) (Denial of class certification reversed and remanded.) o Lampkin v. GGH, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1765 (2007) (Final judgment approving class settlement.) o Leyse v. Clear Channel Broad., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1993 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Lucas v. Telemarketer Calling from (407) 476-5670, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2548 (2013) (Motion for PI denied; default granted.) o MLC Mortg. Corp. v. Sun America Mortg. Co., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1888 (2009) (Affirmed) o Morgan v. Branson Vacation & Travel, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2643 (2013) (Motion to strike denied. Motion for partial summary judgment granted.) o Oklahoma v. Pope, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1506 (2007) (Plaintiff's motion for partial summary judgment granted.) o Oklahoma v. Pope, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1531 (2007) (Judgment with injunction) o Oklahoma v. Pope, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1772 (2008) (Vacated and remanded without opinion on merits.) o Simington v. Zwicker & Assoc., P.C., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2401 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o U.S. Sec. v. FTC, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1664 (2003) (Plaintiffs motion for preliminary injunction denied.)

o U.S. Security v. FTC, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1226 (2003) (order granting ptf. MSJ)

o Destination Ventures Ltd. v. FCC, 1995 TCPA Rep. 1167 (1995) (affirming trial court granting of MSJ to pl.) o Destination Ventures, Ltd. v. FCC, 1994 TCPA Rep. 1166 (1994) (Plaintiff's MSJ judgment denied; Defendant's motion to dismiss granted.) o Flag Co. v. Maynard, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1475 (2006) (Motion to strike affirmative defenses denied in part and granted in part.) o McBride v. Affiliated Credit Servs., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2107 (2011) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Moser v. FCC, 1993 TCPA Rep. 1180 (1993) (order granting def. MTD on first amendment grounds) o Moser v. FCC, 1995 TCPA Rep. 1181 (1995) (Reversed.) o Moser v. FCC, 1992 TCPA Rep. 1665 (1992) (Plaintiff's motion for preliminary injunction granted.) o The Flag Co. v. Maynard, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1602 (2006) (Defendants' motions to dismiss denied.)

o Abramson v. AT&T Wireless Servs., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1368 (2005) (order denying in part and granting in part Def. preliminary objections.) o Abramson v. Aegis Ins. Agency Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1414 (2005) (Motion for injunctive relief denied.) o Abramson v. Aegis Ins. Agency, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1362 (2005) (Deny def. MTD.) o Abramson v. Royalty Holidays, LLC., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1447 (2006) (order denying MTD) o Advent Home Mortg. Corp. v. Hartford Cas. Ins. Co., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1680 (2006) (Judgment on the pleadings granted to insurer on duty to defend.) o Ambassador Home Improvements, Inc. v. Hiqu Italian Am. Stone Corp., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2094 (2010) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Aronson v. Bright-Teeth Now, LLC, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1209 (2003) (appeal affirming trial court dismissal) o Aronson v. Bright-Teeth Now, LLC, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1655 (2002) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Aronson v. Fax.com, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1020 (2001) (Defendant's preliminary objections denied.) o Bell v. BSM Fin., L.P., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1964 (2006) (Judgment and order.) o Bell v. E-Loan, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1958 (2008) (Approval of settlement and class judgment.) o Bell v. Fidelity Bancorp Funding, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1959 (2007) (Final judgment and order.) o Bell v. Money Resource Corp., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1866 (2009) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Bell v. Pacific Mercantile Bank, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1960 (2006) (Judgment and order.) o Bell v. People's Choice Home Loan, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1962 (2005) (Judgment and order granting class certification.) o Bell v. Sterlin Nat'l Mortg. Co., Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1957 (2007) (Class Judgment.) o Chaturvedi v. JTH Tax, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1147 (2001) ((order on settlement class cert.)) o Clean Air Council v. Dragon Int'l Group., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1478 (2006) (Remand denied) o Clean Air Council v. Dragon Int'l. Group, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1553 (2007) (Motion to compel denied.) o Clean Air Council v. Dragon Int'l. Group, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1732 (2007) (Discovery directed to foreign personnel of US corporation limited.) o Clean Air Council v. Dragon Intern. Group, 2008 TCPA Rep. 1829 (2008) (Motin to dismiss granted.) o ErieNet, Inc. v. Velocity Net, Inc., 1998 TCPA Rep. 1168 (1998) (Affirmed.) o Forman v. Data Transfer, Inc., 1995 TCPA Rep. 1171 (1995) (Motion for class certification denied.)

o Forrest v. Genpact Services, LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2602 (2013) (Motion for judgment on the pleadings denied.) o Gager v. Dell Fin. Servs., LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2311 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted. ) o Gager v. Dell Fin. Servs., LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2566 (2013) (Reversed and remanded.) o Hawk Valley, Inc. v. Taylor, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2275 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Hicks v. Am. Billing Sys., Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1233 (2002) (order overrulling def. demurr) o High Probability, Inc. v. Int'l Collection Servs., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1961 (2005) (Order granting class certification.) o Hoover v. Monarch Recovery Mgmt., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2349 (2012) (Motion to dismiss and for judgment on the pleadings granted in part and denied i) o Jeffrey Press, Inc. v. Hartford Cas. Ins. Co., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1457 (2004) (remand denied) o Lewis v. Gitt, 1998 TCPA Rep. 1103 (1998) (Sua sponte dismissal for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.) o Linko v. Am. Educ. Servs., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2288 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Lutz Appellate Servs, Inc. v. Curry, 1994 TCPA Rep. 1176 (1994) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Melrose Hotel Co. v. St Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1640 (2006) (Insurer's motion to dismiss granted on duty to defend.) o Michaels v. Micamp Merchant Servs., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2661 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. v. David Randall Assocs., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2436 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Paradise v. Commonwealth Fin. Sys., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2646 (2013) (Default judgment entered.) o Physicians Healthsource, Inc. v. Cephalon, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2360 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Physicians Healthsource, Inc. v. Cephalon, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2570 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Resource Bank v. Progressive Cas. Ins. Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1639 (2007) (Insured's motion to transfer venue granted.) o Roy v. Dell Fin. Servs., LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2579 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Ruby v. Southwest Credit Sys., L.P., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2254 (2011) (Motion to strike counterclaim granted.) o Salpietro v. Resort Exchange Int'l of Am., Inc., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1114 (2000) (order granting class cert. [default]) o Stuart v. AR Res., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2109 (2011) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Subclass 2 v. St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1661 (2007) (Judgment in favor of insurer affirmed.) o Tague v. Doctor's Assistance Corp., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1828 (2008) (Motion to enter default granted.) o Telecom. Network Design, Inc. v. Bretheren Mutual Ins., Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1566 (2007) (Judgment on the pleadings finding duty to defend.) o Telecomms. Network Design v. Brethren Mut. Ins. Co., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2033 (2010) (Affirmed.) o Telecomms. Network Design v. Brethren Mut. Ins. Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 2066 (2007) (Motion for judment on the pleadings granted.) o Watson v. NCO Group, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1486 (2006) (order denying MTD) o Watson v. NCO Group, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1500 (2006) (Reconsideration denied.) o Web.com, Inc. v. Federal Ins. Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1756 (2007) (Jurisdiction declined on state law claims and stay issued on other claims.) o Weitzner v. Sanofi Pasteur, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2315 (2012) (Motion for abstention denied.) o Weitzner v. Sanofi Pasteur, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2631 (2013) (Motions for reconsideration and for sanctions denied.) o Weitzner v. Vaccess America Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 1833 (2008) (Motion to dismiss granted in part.)

o Agostinelli v. L.M. Commc'ns of South Carolina, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1049 (2002) (judgment) o Agostinelli v. Roberts Mortg. Co., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1054 (2002) (order and judgment) o Allendale County Bank v. Fax.com, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1043 (2001) (TRO to preserve records) o BCS Ins. Co. v. Big Thyme Enters., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2456 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Battery, Inc. v. United Parcel Service, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1143 (2002) (order granting class cert. [settlement]) o Big Thyme Enters., Inc. v. Palmetto Gold Buying Serv., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1989 (2010) () o Biggerstaff v. CSJ Consulting and Jay M. Taylor, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1126 (2001) (default judgment) o Biggerstaff v. Computer Prods., 1999 TCPA Rep. 1123 (1999) (order and judgment) o Biggerstaff v. Low Country Drug Screening, 1999 TCPA Rep. 1124 (1999) (order and judgment) o Biggerstaff v. Marriott Int'l, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1129 (2001) (order granting class cert.) o Biggerstaff v. Ramada Inn, Coliseum, 2000 TCPA Rep. 1128 (2000) (Motion for class certification granted) o Biggerstaff v. SBS Resort Promotions, Inc., 1999 TCPA Rep. 1125 (1999) (trial decision) o Biggerstaff v. Voice Power Telecomm., Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1160 (2002) (Motion to remand granted.) o Biggerstaff v. Websiteuniversity.com, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1025 (2001) (order granting mtn. to strike defenses) o Connor v. Cumpston, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1066 (2002) (order and judgment) o Hyatt v. Morgan Drexen, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1898 (2009) (MTD granted.) o Johnson v. Key Equip. Fin., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1627 (2006) (Affirming forum selection clause in contract did not prevent suit in state.) o Lipscomb v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1183 (2003) (Order granting class cert. [settlement class]) o Mais v. Gulf Coast Collection Bureau, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2502 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o OLDAPG, Inc. f/k/a Atlantic Pub. Group, Inc. v. New England Bus. Servs., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1195 (2003) (Judgment approving class settlement.) o Syrett v. Allstate Ins. Co., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1215 (2003) (order granting class cert. [settlement class]) o WPS, Inc. v. Lobel Fin., Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1130 (2001) (order granting class certification) o Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Lipscomb d/b/a Am. Amusements, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1212 (2003) (Order dismission DJ action)

o Beam Miller & Rogers, PLLC, v. Officeplanner, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1550 (2002) (MTD granted) o Brown v. Hosto & Buchan, PLLC, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2065 (2010) (Motion to dismiss denied in part and granted in part.) o McLaughlin Chiropractic Assocs., Inc. v. McKesson Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2479 (2013) (Motion to transfer granted.)

o Adamcik v. Credit Control Servs., Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2226 (2011) (Motion for judgment as a matter of law is granted in part and denied in part.) o Apartment Inv. and Mgmt Co. v. Suggs & Assocs., PC, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1269 (2004) (reversed and remanded) o Autoflex Leasing, Inc. v. Mfrs. Auto Leasing, Inc., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1206 (2000) (Affirmed.) o Autoflex Leasing, Inc. v. Mfrs. Auto Leasing, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1288 (2004) (order affirming trial court grant of SJ to plaintiff)

o Baltimore–Washington Tel. Co. v. Horne (in re Horne), 2012 TCPA Rep. 2336 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Bank v. Spark Energy Holdings LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2658 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Bank v. Spark Energy Holdings, LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2376 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Biddle v. Santander Consumer USA, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2135 (2011) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Brandt v. Welch, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1197 (2001) (Motion to remand granted.) o Brown v. Enterprise Recovery Systems, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2604 (2013) (Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded.) o Chair King, Inc. v. GTE Mobilnet of Houston, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1276 (2004) (Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded.) o Chair King, Inc. v. GTE Mobilnet of Houston, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1287 (2004) (order affirming trial decision) o Chair King, Inc. v. GTE Mobilnet of Houston, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1427 (2006) (Affirmed in part and dismissed in part as moot.) o Chair King, Inc. v. Houston Cellular Corp., 1995 TCPA Rep. 1150 (1995) (Motion to dismiss granted except as to trespass to chattels claim.) o Chair King, Inc. v. Houston Cellular Corp., 1997 TCPA Rep. 1571 (1997) (Vacated and remanded for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.) o Conrad v. General Motors Acceptance Corp., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2326 (2012) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Coontz v. Nextel Commc'ns, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1074 (2002) (order granting class cert.) o Coontz v. Nextel Commc'ns, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1237 (2003) (ammended order granting class cert.) o Dallas Basketball, LTD v. TIG Ins. Co., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1154 (2003) (order finding duty to defend) o David L. Smith & Assoc., LLP v. Keane Landscaping, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1507 (2006) (reversed) o David L. Smith & Assoc., LLP v. Stealth Detection, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2052 (2010) (Reversed in part and remanded.) o David L. Smith & Assocs., LLP v. Advanced Placement Team, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1546 (2007) (Reversed and remanded) o Davis v. Johnson, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1047 (2001) (judgment) o Diugosh v. DirectBuy, Inc. of San Antonio, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2657 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o First Nat. Collection Bureau, Inc. v. Walker,, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2145 (2011) (Affirmed.) o Fried v. Sensia Salon, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2679 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied. Stay granted.) o Genaw v. NCO Fin. Sys., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2523 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Girards v. Inter-Continental Hotels Corp., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1782 (2007) (Final judgment approving class settlement.) o Girards v. Intercontinental Hotels Corp., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1058 (2002) (order granting Pl. MSJ and DJ) o Girards v. Intercontinental Hotels Corp., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1059 (2002) (order granting class cert.) o Girards v. Intercontinental Hotels Corp., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1220 (2003) (amended order granting class cert.) o Girards v. Intercontinental Hotels Corp., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1429 (2005) (Order granting class cert.) o Girards v. Intercontinental Hotels Corp., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1724 (2007) (Preliminary approval of class settlement.) o Hutchins v. Dallas Basketball, Ltd., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1149 (2002) (class settlement) o In re: Horne, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1201 (2002) (Trustee's motion to dismiss denied.) o Intercontinental Hotels Corp. v. Girards, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1403 (2004) (Class certification reversed and remanded.) o Intercontinental Hotels Corp. v. Girards, 2007 TCPA Rep. 1530 (2007) (Reversed and Remanded) o Kennard v. Electronic Data Sys Corp., 1998 TCPA Rep. 1695 (1998) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Kondos v. Am. Blast Fax, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1216 (2003) (order granting class cert.)

o Kondos v. Lincoln Property Co., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1036 (2001) (order granting class cert.) o Kondos v. Lincoln Property Co., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1152 (2003) (Vacated and remanded.) o Lee v. Club Resort Interval, LLC, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1254 (2003) (order denying def. mtn to dismiss) o Lee v. Credit Mgmt., LP, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2265 (2012) (Order adopting report and recommendation.) o Main P.C. v. Electronic Data Sys. Corp., 1996 TCPA Rep. 1177 (1996) (Motion for class certification denied.) o Masters v. Time Warner Cable, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2441 (2012) (Motion to compel arbitration granted.) o Masters v. Wells Fargo Bank South Cent., N.A., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2580 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Nutmeg Ins. Co. v. Employers Inc. Co. of Wausau, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1442 (2006) (Insured's motion for summary judgment granted on duty to defend.) o Omnibus Int'l, Inc. v. AT&T, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1085 (2002) (order affirming in part and denying in part, trial court granting pl. MSJ) o Omnibus Int'l, Inc. v. AT&T, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1187 (2003) (On rehearing, judgment affirmed in part, denied in part, and remanded in part.) o Omnibus Int'l, Inc. v. Dallas Cowboys Football Club, LTD, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1014 (2001) (order granting partial summ. j to pl.) o Parker v. Am. Blast Fax, Inc., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1010 (2000) (order) o Parker v. Am. Blast Fax, Inc., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1011 (2000) (Contempt of Court order against ABF) o Parker v. Am. Blast Fax, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1012 (2001) (Order compelling production of fax logs and other data) o Parker v. Am. Blast Fax, Inc., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1013 (2000) (Second partial summary judgment for pltf.) o Pinnacle Realty Mgmt. Co. v. Kondos, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1653 (2004) (Class certification reversed and remanded.) o Registry Dallas Assocs., L.P. v. Wausau Bus. Ins. Co., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1280 (2004) (order finding duty to defend) o Robinson v. Carrao, 1999 TCPA Rep. 1003 (1999) (order and judgment after jury trial) o Santee v. Encore Receivable Mgmt, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1747 (2007) (Motion to remand granted.) o Shields v. Americor Lending Group, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1666 (2007) (Summary judgment in favor of defendant affirmed. ) o Shields v. R&B Home Security, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1029 (2001) (judgment) o Shields v. Voice Power Telecom., Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1028 (2001) (order and judgment) o Smith and Assoc., LLP v. Advanced Placement Team, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1380 (2005) (Affirmed in part, and reversed and remanded in part) o Suggs & Suggs & Assoc., P.C. v. Apartment Inv. and Mgmt. Co., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1127 (2003) (order granting class cert.) o TIG Ins. Co. v. Dallas Basketball, LTD, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1261 (2004) (appeal affirming duty to defend) o TIG Ins. Co. v. Dallas Basketball, LTD, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1275 (2004) (Affirmed in part and reversed in part.) o Texas v. Am. Blast Fax, Inc, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1198 (2001) (trial judgment and order) o Texas v. Am. Blast Fax, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1192 (2001) (order granting pl. MSJ in part and denying def. MSJ) o Texas v. Am. Blast Fax, Inc., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1194 (2000) (Motion to dismiss (constitutional issues) denied.) o Western Rim Inv. Advisors, Inc. v. Gulf Ins. Co., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1189 (2003) (order granting pl. MSJ in part and denying def. MSJ in part.) o Western Rim Inv. Advisors, Inc. v. Gulf Ins. Co., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1311 (2004) (Affirmed.) o Whatley v. Creditwatch Servs., Ltd., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2331 (2012) (Motions for summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.)

o in re MSI Mktng., Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1359 (2005) (Memorandum opinion and order)

o Holster v. Gatco, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1975 (2010) (Vacated and remanded.)

o Martinez v. Johnson, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2480 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.) o Mitchell v. King's Creek Plantation, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1708 (2004) (Motion to dismiss denied) o Monson v. King's Creek Plantation, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1709 (2004) (Motion to dismiss on personal jurisdiction denied) o Monson v. King's Creek Plantation, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1710 (2006) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Monson v. King's Creek Plantation, 2006 TCPA Rep. 1711 (2006) (Reconsideration denied.) o Utah Div. of Cons. Prot. v. Flagship Capital dba Integrated Credit Solutions, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1395 (2005) (Reversed.) o Warkentin v. Farmers Group Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 2147 (2009) (Motion for summary judgment denied.)

o Belcher v. Kohl's Dept. Stores, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2168 (2011) (Motion to remand granted.) o Clayton v. Aaron's Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2552 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Downing v. Papa John's USA, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2535 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment denied.) o Gray v. Wittstadt Title & Escrow Co., LLC, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2218 (2011) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Int'l Science & Tech. Inst., Inc. v. Inacom Commc'n, Inc., 1997 TCPA Rep. 1172 (1997) (Affirmed dismissal for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.) o Lee v. Wells Fargo Home Mortg., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2688 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Mey v. Honeywell Int'l, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2485 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Mey v. Monitronics Intern., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2272 (2012) (Motion to strike offer of judgment denied.) o Resource Bank v. Progressive Cas. Ins. Co., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1573 (2007) (Partial summary judgment granted to insurer on duty to defend.) o Resource Bankshares Corp. v. St. Paul Mercury Ins. Co., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1298 (2004) (order finding duty to defend) o Resource Bankshares Corp. v. St. Paul Mercury Ins. Co., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1406 (2005) (Affirmed in part and reversed in part, and remanded.) o Virginia ex rel. Jagdmann v. Real Time Int'l, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1610 (2005) (Recommendation to enter judgment)

o Agne v. Papa John's Int'l, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2394 (2012) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Anderson v. Domino's Pizza, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2274 (2012) (Motion for protective order granted in part and denied in part.) o Anderson v. Domino's Pizza, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2293 (2012) (Motions denied in part and granted in part.) o Baron v. Merchant Servs. of Seattle, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1545 (2006) (Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment granted.) o Chesbro v. Best Buy Stores, LP, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2366 (2012) (Reversed and remanded.) o Chesbro v. Best Buy Stores, LP, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2423 (2012) (Reversed and remanded.)

o Clausen Law Firm, PLLC v. Nat'l Acad. of Continuing Legal Educ., 2008 TCPA Rep. 2063 (2008) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Cubbage,v. The Talbots, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2023 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Gragg v. Orange Cab Co., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2439 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied in part and granted in part.) o Gragg v. Orange Cab Co., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2518 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Hickey v. Voxernet LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2350 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied in part and granted in part.) o Hovila v. Tween Brands, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 1972 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Kavu, Inc. v. Omnipak Corp., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1514 (2007) (Class certification granted.) o Kavu, Inc. v. Omnipak Corp., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1587 (2007) (Motion to approve class settlement granted.) o Meilleur v. AT&T, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2210 (2011) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Meilleur v. AT&T, Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2249 (2012) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Meyer v. Receivables Performance Mgmt., LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2527 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Oregon Mut. Ins. Co. v. Rain City Pizza, L.L.C., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2431 (2013) (Reversed.) o Palmer v. Sprint Nextel Corp., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1945 (2009) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Permison v. Comcast Holdings Corp., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2457 (2013) (Motion to compel arbitration denied in part.) o Responsive Mgmt. Sys. v. Onvia Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1522 (2006) (Order approving final class settlement.) o Southwell v. Mortg. Inv. Corp. of Ohio, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2671 (2013) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Spafford v. Echostar Commc'ns Corp., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1581 (2007) (Motion to dismiss denied.) o Spafford v. Echostar Commc'ns Corp., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1651 (2006) (Motion to dismiss on First Amendment grounds denied.) o St. Paul Fire & Marine Ins. Co. v. Onvia, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1582 (2007) (Questions certified to state supreme court.) o St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co. v. Onvia, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1529 (2007) (Insurer's motion for summary judgment on duty to defend granted.) o Transp. Inst. v. Seattle PC-Magic, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1533 (2005) (Class certificaiton granted) o Washington v. Fax.com, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1109 (2001) (consent order) o Washington v. Tri-Star Mktg., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1105 (2000) (trial order and injunction) o Washington v. Tri-Star Mktg., 2000 TCPA Rep. 1106 (2000) (supplemental order)

o Acuity v. Interlog USA, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1679 (2005) (Insurer's motion to dismiss granted.) o Babb Real Estate, LLC v. Bennett, 2011 TCPA Rep. 2146 (2011) (Motio for class certification granted.) o Beal v. Wyndham Vacation Resorts, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2585 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.) o Berg v. Verizon Wireless, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2669 (2013) (Motion to amend granted. Motion for summary judgment denied.) o Landsman & Funk, P.C. v. Lorman Business Center, Inc., 2009 TCPA Rep. 1875 (2009) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Mudgett v. Navy Federal Credit Union, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2262 (2012) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Nelson v. Santander Consumer USA, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2481 (2013) (Motion for summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.)

o R&G, Inc. v. Bennett, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2051 (2010) (Motion for summary and declaratory judgment granted.) o Reliable Money Order, Inc. v. McKnight Sales Co., Inc., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2278 (2012) (Motion for class certification granted.) o Reliable Money Order, Inc. v. McKnight Sales Co., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2428 (2013) (Affirmed.) o Sawyer v. Atlas Heating & Sheet Metal Works, Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2026 (2010) (Motion to dismissed denied.) o Sawyer v. Atlas Heating & Sheet Metal Works, Inc., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2132 (2011) (Affirmed.) o Sawyer v. West Bend Mut. Ins. Co., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2330 (2012) (Affirmed) o State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. v. Easy PC Solutions LLC, 2013 TCPA Rep. 2630 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Wilder Chiropractic, Inc. v. Pizza Hut of S. Wis., Inc., 2010 TCPA Rep. 2059 (2010) (Motions to dismiss and for class certification stayed.)

o Bailey v. SLM Corp., 2012 TCPA Rep. 2305 (2012) (Remand denied.) o Emanuel v. Los Angeles Lakers, Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2508 (2013) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Herbalife Int'l, Inc. v. St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1596 (2006) (Motion for stay granted in part and denied in part.) o Herbalife Int'l, Inc. v. St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1603 (2006) (Motion to remand denied.) o Herbalife Intern., Inc. v. St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1594 (2006) (Order on discovery motions.) o Mey v. Feature Films for Families, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1050 (2002) (order and judgment) o Mey v. Herbalife Int'l, Inc., 2003 TCPA Rep. 1249 (2003) (order denying remand) o Mey v. Herbalife Int'l, Inc., 2006 TCPA Rep. 1445 (2006) (order granting class cert) o Mey v. Herbalife Int'l, Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1814 (2004) (Motion for remand granted.) o Mey v. Herbalife Int'l, Inc., 2005 TCPA Rep. 1815 (2005) (Motion for reconsideration denied.) o Mey v. Herbalife Int'l, Inc., 2007 TCPA Rep. 1816 (2007) (Class settlement preliminary approval granted.) o Mey v. Herbalife Int'l, Inc., 2008 TCPA Rep. 2006 (2008) (Order approving class settlement.) o Mey v. Monitronics Int'l., Inc., 2013 TCPA Rep. 2595 (2013) (Motion for partial summary judgment denied.) o Mey v. Pinnacle Sec., LLC, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2373 (2012) (Motion for summary judgment granted.) o Mey v. The Pep Boys - Manny, Moe & Jack, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2371 (2010) (Motion to dismiss granted.) o Mey v. The Pep Boys - Manny, Moe & Jack, 2010 TCPA Rep. 2374 (2010) (Motion for relief denied.) o Montgomery v. Applied Bank, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2250 (2012) (Motion to compel arbitration granted.) o Montgomery v. Credit One Bank, NA, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2252 (2012) (Motion to compel arbitration granted.) o Shaffer v. HSBC Bank Nevada, Nat. Ass'n, 2012 TCPA Rep. 2308 (2012) (Motion to compel arbitration denied.)

o Versteeg v. Bennett, DeLoney & Noyes, P.C., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2263 (2011) (Motion for damages and attorney fees granted.) o Versteeg v. Bennett, DeLoney & Noyes, P.C., 2011 TCPA Rep. 2264 (2011) (Motion for class certification denied.)