Religion and Imposture in Colonial India by Joshua

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Religion and Imposture in Colonial India by Joshua Divine Exposures: Religion and Imposture in Colonial India by Joshua Barton Scott Department of Religion Duke University Date:_______________________ Approved: ___________________________ Dr. Bruce Lawrence, Supervisor ___________________________ Dr. Leela Prasad ___________________________ Dr. Richard Jaffe ___________________________ Dr. David Gilmartin ___________________________ Dr. Srinivas Aravamudan Dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Religion in the Graduate School of Duke University 2009 i v ABSTRACT Divine Exposures: Religion and Imposture in Colonial India by Joshua Barton Scott Department of Religion Duke University Date:_______________________ Approved: ___________________________ Dr. Bruce Lawrence, Supervisor ___________________________ Dr. Leela Prasad ___________________________ Dr. Richard Jaffe ___________________________ Dr. David Gilmartin ___________________________ Dr. Srinivas Aravamudan An abstract of a dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Religion in the Graduate School of Duke University 2009 Copyright by Joshua Barton Scott 2009 ABSTRACT My dissertation asks how narratives of religious fraud have been used to rethink Hinduism. It begins in a theoretical register by arguing that the unmasking of charlatans serves as a metonym for the secularizing procedures of modernity more broadly. Tales of charlatans’ exposure by secularist skeptics promise a disenchanted world freed from the ill-gotten influence of sham divines; such tales evacuate the immanent frame of charismatic god-men, thereby allowing the extension and consolidation of secular power. I trace the trope of charlatanic exposure, beginning with Enlightenment anxieties about “priestcraft,” continuing on to nineteenth century criticisms of religion, and then making a lateral move to colonial India. I suggest that by the 1830s it had become difficult for many English critics to extricate the problem of priestly imposture from the broader problematic of empire and, more specifically, from the specter of the “crafty brahmin.” I track the cultural crosscurrents that conjoined English and Indian anticlericalisms, not only to insist on the centrality of colonial thinkers to the constitution of modernity, but also to reconsider modernity’s putative secularity. The “anticlerical modernity” that I identify brings religious and secular skeptics together in a shared war on sacerdotal charisma, best observed at the interstices of empire. The dissertation disperses the intellectual lineage of the “imposture theory of religion” by rerouting it through colonial India. The imposture theory, or the notion that religion is but a ruse concocted by crafty priests to dupe gullible masses, was central to the emergence of secular modernity and its mistrust of religion. Closely associated with the English and French Enlightenments, it was also pervasive in British polemics against Indian iv religions. My dissertation demonstrates how in its colonial redeployment the imposture theory came to abut Indic imaginaries of religious illusion, ranging from folkloric spoofs of gurus’ authority to philosophical debates about the ontological status of “maya.” Starting from the religious controversies of the colonial era, my interrogation of Indic illusion extends from the ninth century philosopher Shankaracharya to the sixteenth century saint Vallabhacharya to the twentieth century guru Osho. Its focus, however, is on three nineteenth century religious reformers: Karsandas Mulji, Dayanand Saraswati, and H.P Blavatsky. Through archival research, textual analysis (in Hindi, Gujarati, and English), and theoretical inquiry, I insinuate these three colonial thinkers into the history of the imposture theory of religion. In doing so, my aim is to contribute to scholarship on the genealogy of religion, particularly in colonial contexts. v CONTENTS Abstract…………………………………........................................................................... iv Acknowledgements………………………………………………………………………………….. vii Introduction……………………………………………………………………………………………… 1 1: The History of Priestcraft in All Ages and Nations………………………………. 40 2: Priestly Despots…………………………………………………………………………………….. 71 3: Guru is God……………………………………………………………………………………………. 112 4: Pur!"ic Popery……………………………………………………………………………………… 171 5: A Skeptic’s Medium………………………………………………………………………………. 217 Conclusion………………………………………………………………………………………………… 266 Bibliography……………………………………………………………………………………………… 281 Biography…………………………………………………………………………………………………. 303 vi ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS First, I would like to thank my dissertation committee. Bruce Lawrence, ever encouraging, was a great support throughout the research and the writing of this dissertation; I was lucky to have him as chair. Leela Prasad, Richard Jaffe, David Gilmartin, and Srinivas Aravamudan all provided incisive feedback on the dissertation itself, as well as invaluable support throughout my career as a graduate student. I also benefited immensely from the support and advice of other Triangle-area faculty. In particular, I would like to thank Tom Tweed, Randall Styers, Sandy Freitag, and Satti Khanna. My dissertation research was made possible by fellowships from the American Institute of Indian Studies, the American Institute of Pakistan Studies, and Duke University. I thank all of those institutions for their generous financial support. Jawaharlal Nehru University provided me with an institutional base in India, and I would like to thank Susan Viswanathan in particular for all of her help during the nine months in which I was affiliated with JNU. Additionally, I would like to thank the staff of the following libraries and archives: the British Library’s Asian and African Studies Reading Room, Cambridge University Library, the Victoria and Albert Museum, the National Archives of India, the Nehru Memorial Museum and Library, the Maharashtra State Archives, the Cama Institute, the Forbes Gujarati Sabh!, the Asiatic Society of Mumbai, and the Theosophical Society’s Adyar Library and Research Centre. The staff of the Forbes Gujarati Sabh! deserves particular thanks for their truly remarkable assistance. Portions of Chapter 5 have previously appeared in article form as “Miracle Publics: Theosophy, Christianity, and the Coulomb Affair,” History of Religions 49:2 (November 2009): vii 172-196 (© 2009 by the University of Chicago Press). I thank the University of Chicago Press for permission to reproduce that material here. While abroad, I benefited from the advice of several senior scholars. Particular thanks are due to Usha Thakkar, Amrita Shodhan, and Geraldine Forbes. At an earlier phase of the project, Ashis Nandy and Makarand Paranjape offered both encouragement and logistical support, and I thank them both. My year in the archives would have been far drabber without the company of friends. For the pints in London and Cambridge, and also for the housing, I would like to thank Robert Ricks, Hilary Smith, Cornelius O’Boyle, Alice Fodor, Michael Thompson, Will Erikson, and Caitlin Anderson. The Delhi winter was made warmer by Dann Naseemullah, Surita Parashar, Julie Hughes, Brandon Marsh, and Paul Staniland, as well Prabha and the staff of Manushi. Special thanks go to Leo Mirani for showing me such a very good time in Bombay. Thanks also to Anuja Ghosalkar, Rasheed Wadia, Raghu Karnad, Girish Karnad, and Munni Kabir for their hospitality in that city. Back in the States, many friends provided me with invaluable research advice: particular thanks are due to Matt Cook and Pinki Vaishnava. For sharing work or providing useful leads, thanks go, in addition to those above, to James Tabor, Mitra Sharafi, and Chris Pinney. Additionally, I would like to thank Leela Gandhi, who proved both an inspiration and a calming influence during the anxious final months of my Ph.D. Completing a Ph.D., seldom a straightforward task, requires forms of support far more intangible than those enumerated above. Without the steadfastness of friends, I would not have gotten this far. Here, I will simply pause to thank my graduate school colleagues for seeing me through: Susanna Drake, Lori Baron, Kyle Smith, Kristi Upson- viii Saia, Kate Blanchard, Ali Aslam, Jacob Remes, Mari Armstrong-Hough, Mitch Fraas, Brett and Cristina Wilson, Youshaa Patel, SherAli Tareen, Isaac Weiner, and Jenna Tiitsman. Without my family, I cannot imagine ever having embarked on the academic life to begin with: thanks to Catherine and John Bishir for giving me a home in Raleigh, and to Jean, Thornton, and Lucile Scott for homes in all the other places—for, that is, a lifetime of love and support. Finally, thanks to Daniel Elam for following me, and this project, over some very long distances. Whether in Chapel Hill or Durham, London or Delhi, Bombay or Chicago, he’s been an incomparable companion. ix INTRODUCTION: THEORIZING IMPOSTURE The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of men is a demand for their real happiness. The call to abandon their illusions about their condition is a call to abandon a condition which requires illusions. Karl Marx, 1843 1 The divine “pretender” stood exposed, and he knew it. His head and hands ceased their ecstatic gyrations, and he confessed to the crowd that the Goddess had left him. The Rev. William Bowley was pleased. A man on a mission, he had rushed to the banyan tree earlier that 1820 morning, upon learning of the blacksmith
Recommended publications
  • Ultranationalism: a Proposal for a Quiet Withdrawal
    I developed an early suspicion of any form of nationalism courtesy of a geography teacher and an imaginary cricket game. As the only student of Chinese origin in a high school in Bangalore, I was asked by my teacher in a benign voice who I would support if India and China played a match. Aside from the ridiculousness of the question 01/05 (China does not even play cricket), the dubious intent behind it was rather clear, even to a teenager. Still, I dutifully replied, “Sir, I will support India,” for which I received a gratified smile and a pat on the head. I was offended less by the crude attempt by someone in power to force a kid to prove his patriotism, than by the outright silliness of the game. If all it took to Lawrence Liang establish the euphoric security of nationalism was that simple answer, I figured there must be something drastically wrong with the question. I Ultranationalism: was left, however, with an uneasy feeling (one that has persisted through the years), not A Proposal for a because I had given a false answer but because I had been forced to answer a false question. The Quiet answer made pragmatic sense in a schoolboy way (you don’t want to piss off someone who is going to be marking your papers), and I hadn’t Withdrawal read King Lear yet to know that the only appropriate response to the question should have been silence. If Cordelia refuses to participate in Lear’s competition of affective intimacy, it is not just the truth, but also the distasteful aesthetics of her sister’s excessive declarations of love, that motivates her withdrawal into silence.
    [Show full text]
  • Theosophy and the Origins of the Indian National Congress
    THEOSOPHY AND THE ORIGINS OF THE INDIAN NATIONAL CONGRESS By Mark Bevir Department of Political Science University of California, Berkeley Berkeley CA 94720 USA [E-mail: [email protected]] ABSTRACT A study of the role of theosophy in the formation of the Indian National Congress enhances our understanding of the relationship between neo-Hinduism and political nationalism. Theosophy, and neo-Hinduism more generally, provided western-educated Hindus with a discourse within which to develop their political aspirations in a way that met western notions of legitimacy. It gave them confidence in themselves, experience of organisation, and clear intellectual commitments, and it brought them together with liberal Britons within an all-India framework. It provided the background against which A. O. Hume worked with younger nationalists to found the Congress. KEYWORDS: Blavatsky, Hinduism, A. O. Hume, India, nationalism, theosophy. 2 REFERENCES CITED Archives of the Theosophical Society, Theosophical Society, Adyar, Madras. Banerjea, Surendranath. 1925. A Nation in the Making: Being the Reminiscences of Fifty Years of Public Life . London: H. Milford. Bharati, A. 1970. "The Hindu Renaissance and Its Apologetic Patterns". In Journal of Asian Studies 29: 267-88. Blavatsky, H.P. 1888. The Secret Doctrine: The Synthesis of Science, Religion and Philosophy . 2 Vols. London: Theosophical Publishing House. ------ 1972. Isis Unveiled: A Master-Key to the Mysteries of Ancient and Modern Science and Theology . 2 Vols. Wheaton, Ill.: Theosophical Publishing House. ------ 1977. Collected Writings . 11 Vols. Ed. by Boris de Zirkoff. Wheaton, Ill.: Theosophical Publishing House. Campbell, B. 1980. Ancient Wisdom Revived: A History of the Theosophical Movement . Berkeley: University of California Press.
    [Show full text]
  • The Contest of Indian Secularism
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Helsingin yliopiston digitaalinen arkisto THE CONTEST OF INDIAN SECULARISM Erja Marjut Hänninen University of Helsinki Faculty of Social Sciences Political History Master’s thesis December 2002 Map of India I INTRODUCTION...........................................................................................................1 PRESENTATION OF THE TOPIC ....................................................................................................................3 AIMS ......................................................................................................................................................... 5 SOURCES AND LITERATURE ......................................................................................................................7 CONCEPTS ............................................................................................................................................... 12 SECULARISM..............................................................................................................14 MODERNITY ............................................................................................................................................ 14 SECULARISM ........................................................................................................................................... 16 INDIAN SECULARISM ..............................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Church Missionary Society and the Christians of Kerala, 1813-1840
    Half-Brothers in Christ: The Church Missionary Society and the Christians of Kerala, 1813-1840 by Joseph Gerald Howard M. A. (History), University at Buffalo, State University of New York, 2010 Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts in the Department of History Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences Joseph Gerald Howard 2014 SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY Fall 2014 Approval Name: Joseph Gerald Howard Degree: Master of Arts (History) Title: Half-Brothers in Christ: The Church Missionary Society and the Christians of Kerala, 1813-1840 Examining Committee: Chair: Aaron Windel Assistant Professor of History Paul Sedra Senior Supervisor Associate Professor of History Derryl MacLean Supervisor Associate Professor of History Mary-Ellen Kelm Supervisor Professor of History Laura Ishiguro External Examiner Assistant Professor Department of History University of British Columbia Date Defended: August 28, 2014 ii Partial Copyright Licence iii Abstract In the 1810s, the Church Missionary Society (CMS) established the College at Cottayam in south India to educate boys intended for the priesthood in the local, indigenous church. While their goal was to help the church, their activities increased British power in the community. The results of CMS involvement included increasing interference of British officials in matters internal to the Malankara Church (e.g., episcopal succession), tacit recognition of the authority of colonial courts to resolve disputes in the church, and the fragmentation of the St. Thomas Christian community. These effects reshaped the church into something more consistent with British Christianity and more subject to British rule. Keywords: British Empire; Christianity; India; mission iv Dedication In memory of M.
    [Show full text]
  • Faculty Profile
    Format-II FACULTY PROFILE 1. Name: Dr. SHOBHA RAWAT 2. Designation: ASSISTANT PROFESSOR (Guest Faculty) 3. Qualification: M. Sc. BOTANT, Ph. D 4. Area of Specialization/Research field: LICHENOLOGY 5. Awards/Recognitions: RGNF- JRF (2007) RGNF- SRF (2009) UGC-POST DOCTORAL FELLOW (2012) 6. Number of Research projects: 01 i) Completed Sl. No. Title of the project Funding Agency Amount(Rs.) Year (From-To) 1 UGC- (PDF) UGC 18,75, 883 Rs. 2012-2017 ii) On-going: NA 7. Number of Ph. D candidates successfully completed: NO 8. Number of Ph. D candidates currently working: NO 9. Publications: 20 i) Books: NO ii) Research Articles published in journals 1. Rawat, S., Upreti, D. K. and Singh, R. P. (2009). Lichen flora of Mandal and adjoining localities towards Ukhimath in Chamoli district of Uttarakhand. Journal of Phytological Research 22 (1) 47-52. ISSN: 0970-5767. 2. Rawat, S., Upreti, D. K. and Singh, R. P. (2010). Lichen diversity in Valley of Flowers National Park Western Himalaya, Uttarakhand, India. Phytotaxonomy 10 112-117. ISSN 0972-4206. 3. Rawat, S., Upreti, D. K. and P. K. Divakar (2011). Xanthoparmelia xizangensis (J. C. Wei) Hale, a new record of lichen from India. Geophytology 41 (1-2) 101- 103. ISSN 0376-5561. 4. Rawat, S., Upreti, D. K. and Singh, R. P., (2011). Estimation of epiphytic lichen litter fall biomass in three temperate forests of Chamoli district, Uttarakhand, India. International Society for Tropical Ecology 52 (2) 193-200. ISSN 0564-3295 5. Rawat, S., Singh, R. P. Upreti, D. K., (2013). Lichen Diversity Of Durmi Forest In Chamoli District, Uttarakhand, Journal Of Economic and Taxonomic Botany, 37(2), 223.
    [Show full text]
  • Th E O S O P H
    JANUARY 1947 VOL. 68, No, 4 THE TH EOSOPH1ST Edited by C. JINARAJADASA CONTENTS PAGE The Presidential Address.C. JINARAJADASA . 213 Our Planetary Chain.A nnie B esant . 227 The Autobiography of A. P. Sinnett . 233 Ancient Ritual of the Magi in Iran.E rvad K. S. DABU . 240 The Teachings of Carpocrates. NG.evin D rinkwater . ,246 Day of Remembrance of Two World Wars . 249 Theosophy for the Artist.G eoffrey H odson . , 251 The Path of Holiness.M adeleine P ow ell . • 255 The Road to Utopia. U. KG.rishnamurti . • • 263 The Artist in us. Sidney A. Cook . 268 The Dance of Shiva.J ohn Moxford . 269' Reviews . 271 Supplement: Official Notice . 275 Theosophists at Work Around the World . 276 THE THEOSOPHICAL PUBLISHING HOUSE ADYAR, MADRAS 20, INDIA ' THE THEOSOPHICAL SOCIETY T he THEOSOPHICAL SOCIETY was formed at New York, November 17, 1875, and incorpo­ rated at Madras, April 3, 1905, It is an absolutely unsectarian body of seekers after Truth, striving to serve humanity on spiritual lines, and therefore endeavouring to check materialism and revive the religious tendency. Its three declared Objects are : FIRST.— T o form a nucleus of the Universal Brotherhood of Humanity, without distinction of race, creed, sex, caste or colour. SECOND.—T o encourage the study of Comparative Religion, Philosophy and Science. T hird.— T o investigate the unexplained laws of Nature and the powers latent in man. THE THEOSOPHICAL SOCIETY is composed of students, belonging to any religion in the world or to none, who are united by their approval of the above objects, by their wish to remove religious antagonisms and to draw together men of goodwill whatsoever their religious opinions, and by their desire to study religious truths and to share the results of their studies with others.
    [Show full text]
  • Appendix 5A – Consultations the List Includes Stakeholders Interviewed During the Inception and Field Phase of the Joint Evaluation
    Joint Evaluation of the Secondary Education Support Programme Appendix 5a – Consultations The list includes stakeholders interviewed during the inception and field phase of the joint evaluation. In addition, the joint evaluation has benefited from feedback made by participants at the inception seminar and the seminar arranged to present the draft report. These included government officials, researchers, peer reviewers, civil society representatives and development partners. Appendix 5b has details on stakeholders consulted at districts and school level. Name Position Institution 1. Arjun Bahadur Bhandari Joint Secretary MoE 2. Janardhan Nepal Joint Secretary 3. Dr. Lava Deo Awasthi Joint Secretary 4. Bharat Nepali Pyakurel Under Secretary School Inspectorate, MoE 5. Ram Bahadur Khadka Section Officer 6. Ms. Usha Paudel (Kandel) Section Officer 7. Gopal Prasad Bhandari Section Officer 8. Nakul Baniya Section Officer Policy Analysis & Planning 9. Pralhad Aryal Section Officer Section, MOE 10. Deepak Sharma Under Secretary 11. Geha Nath Gautam Section Officer Planning Section, MoE 12. Narayan K Shrestha Section Officer Foreign Aid Coordination 13. Indra Bahadur Kunwar Section Officer Section (FACS), MOE 14. Mukunda Khanal Section Officer 15. Lesha Nath Poudel Under Secretary 16. Subhadra Kumari RC Thapa Under Secretary 17. Frank Jensen Chief Technical Adviser Education Sector Advisory Team / MoE 18. Mahashram Sharma Director General DoE 19. Chudamani Poudel Section Chief Gender Equity Section, DOE 20. Damodar Regmi Section Officer 21. Dibya Dawadi Section Officer 22. Kamala Gyawali Section Officer 23. Ram Hari Rijal 24. Arun Tiwari Section Chief Inclusive Education Section, 25. Ganesh Poudel Section Officer DOE 26. Narayan Subedi Section Officer 27. Kumar Bhattarai Section Officer 28.
    [Show full text]
  • Secularism: Its Content and Context
    SECULARISM: ITS CONTENT AND CONTEXT BY AKEEL BILGRAMI COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY OCTOBER, 2011 Abstract This paper addresses two sets of questions. First, questions about the meaning of secularism and second questions about its justification and implementation. It is argued that Charles Taylor‘s recent efforts to redefine secularism for a time when we have gone ‗beyond toleration‘ to multiculturalism in liberal politics, are based on plausible (and laudable) political considerations that affect the question of justification and implementation, but leave unaffected the question of the meaning and content of secularism. An alternative conceptualization of secularism is offered, from the one he proposes, while also addressing his deep and understandable concerns about the politics of secularism for our time. In the characterization of secularism offered, it turns out that secularism has its point and meaning, not in some decontextualized philosophical argument, but only in contexts that owe to specific historical trajectories, with specific political goals to be met. 1 1. I begin with three fundamental features of the idea of ‗secularism.‘ I will want to make something of them at different stages of the passage of my argument in this paper for the conclusion—among others—that the relevance of secularism is contextual in very specific ways.1 If secularism has its relevance only in context, then it is natural and right to think that it will appear in different forms and guises in different contexts. But I write down these opening features of secularism at the outset because they seem to me to be invariant among the different forms that secularism may take in different contexts.
    [Show full text]
  • Book Reviews / Asian Journal of Social Science 41 (2013) 219–236
    230 Book Reviews / Asian Journal of Social Science 41 (2013) 219–236 Neeti Nair (2011) Changing Homelands: Hindu Politics and Partition in India. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press. 356 pages. ISBN: 9780674057791. Most of the literature on the partition of India and Pakistan highlights the role of Muslim League and the British colonialists in dividing the Indian peninsula. However in a novel rendition of partition studies, Nair analyses the situation of the minority Punjabi Hindus in the Muslim majority province of Punjab, who as a religious community were otherwise a majority throughout India, during the partition. The partition suddenly rendered the Pun- jabi Hindus alien in their own land. In this revisionist history of the partition, Nair focuses on the social and political history of the Punjab province in India, from the four decades preceding independence to the post- colonial times. She traces the religious and communitarian politics of the Punjabi Hindu minorities and their dynamics of interaction with the British, the Sikhs and the Muslims. Plodding through an unconventional analysis, Nair demonstrates that there was nothing inexorable about the partition of Punjab. Presenting an eventful historical narrative from 1920 onwards, Nair rejects the usual notion that the communal divide between the Hindu and the Muslim led to the partition of India. She also culls the naturalized view that the Muslims were responsible for the partition of India. In fact many of the influential Punjabi Hindu families and leaders actively contrib- uted to the petty politics that led to the partition. However it was not a sinisterly pre-planned decision, as none of these families oversaw the brutal destruction of life and property that followed the partition.
    [Show full text]
  • The Validity of Human Language: a Vehicle for Divine Truth
    Grace Theological Journal 9.1 (1988) 21-43 [Copyright © 1988 Grace Theological Seminary; cited with permission; digitally prepared for use at Gordon and Grace Colleges and elsewhere] THE VALIDITY OF HUMAN LANGUAGE: A VEHICLE FOR DIVINE TRUTH JACK BARENTSEN Doubts have arisen about the adequacy of human language to convey inerrant truth from God to man. These doubts are rooted in an empirical epistemology, as elaborated by Hume, Kant, Heidegger and others. Many theologians adopted such an empirical view and found themselves unable to defend a biblical view of divine, inerrant revelation. Barth was slightly more successful, but in the end he failed. The problem is the empirical epistemology that first analyzes man's relationship with creation. Biblically, the starting point should be an analysis of man's relationship with his Creator. When ap- proached this way, creation (especially the creation of man in God's image) and the incarnation show that God and man possess an adequate, shared communication system that enables God to com- municate intelligibly and inerrantly with man. Furthermore, the Bible's insistence on written revelation shows that inerrant divine communication carries the same authority whether written or spoken. * * * As a result of the materialistic, empirical scepticism of the last two centuries, many theologians entertain doubts about the ade- quacy of human language to convey divine truth (or, in some cases, to convey truth of any kind). This review of the philosophical and theological origins of the current doubts about language lays a foundation for a biblical view of language. THE CONTEMPORARY PROBLEM One recent writer stated the problem of the adequacy of religious language in these words: The problem of religious knowledge, in the context of contemporary philosophical analysis, is basically this: no one has any.
    [Show full text]
  • The Kano Durbar: Political Aesthetics in the Bowel of the Elephant
    Original Article The Kano Durbar: Political aesthetics in the bowel of the elephant Wendy Griswolda,* and Muhammed Bhadmusb aDepartment of Sociology, Northwestern University, 1810 Chicago Avenue, Evanston, Illinois 60208, USA. E-mail: [email protected] bDepartment of Theatre and Drama, Bayero University Kano, Kano, Nigeria. E-mail: [email protected] *Corresponding author. Abstract Political aesthetics deploy theatrical techniques to unite performers and audience into a cultural community, thereby distracting from conflicts. The Kano Durbar in northern Nigeria demonstrates how the aesthetics of power can promote a place-based political culture. Although power in Kano rests on a wobbly three-legged stool of traditional, constitutional and religious authority, the status quo celebrated by the Durbar holds back ideological challengers like Boko Haram even as it perpetuates distance from the unified nation-state. The Durbar works as a social drama that helps sustain a Kano-based collective solidarity against the threats of ethnic/religious tensions and Salafist extremism. A cultural-sociological and dramaturgical analysis of the Durbar demonstrates how weak sources of power can support one another when bound together in an aesthetically compelling ritual. American Journal of Cultural Sociology (2013) 1, 125–151. doi:10.1057/ajcs.2012.8 Keywords: political aesthetics; place; social drama; Kano; Nigeria; Durbar Introduction While political rituals are expressions of power, what is less often noticed is that they are expressions of place. Bringing this insight to bear on the analysis of these rituals can reveal how they work, what exactly they accomplish, thereby resolving some of the puzzles they present. This article examines the case of the Kano Durbar, a Nigerian ritual that presents a social drama of and for Kano residents, a drama that helps sustain a sense of r 2013 Macmillan Publishers Ltd.
    [Show full text]
  • REPORT on ACTIVITIES in CREATING AWARENESS and COOPERATION AMONG ORTHODOX and EVANGELICAL CHURCHES in INDIA Fr
    REPORT ON ACTIVITIES IN CREATING AWARENESS AND COOPERATION AMONG ORTHODOX AND EVANGELICAL CHURCHES IN INDIA Fr. Dr. Jossi Jacob Holy Trinity Theological College, Addis Ababa The history of the interactions between the Orthodox Church in India and the Evangelical Traditions goes back to early nineteenth century. In spite of the ruptures and tremors of the past the relationship and interactions had reaped mutual benefits too. We could trace in-numerous events of mutual interactions which happened in the nineteenth, twentieth and twenty first centuries. Several of the events had gone without any written records. I would like to particularly highlight the travels made by two of our luminary bishops to the western countries in the first half of the twentieth century. Those visionary leaders of the Church travelled extensively in the western European countries to make contacts and interactions with the Churches of Protestant traditions. In turn they had visitors from these respective Churches visiting the Malankara Orthodox Church and staying in the monasteries which these two bishops had found. There attempts were before the formal inception of the international ecumenical bodies. Later on the founding of the World Council of Churches, in the inception of which the Orthodox Church in India has played a role too, has added momentum to the fraternal ties between the traditions. Exploring to the early part of the 19th century, it is made clear that the cooperation in the beginning was mainly made in publishing the Holy Scripture, and in promoting western form of education in Keralite1 society. Later it has developed into theological higher education.
    [Show full text]