Wij-Articles-Final2- Joanna Russ-Breaking up Borders And
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Joanna Russ’s Kittatiny: A Tale of Magic Breaking up Borders and Spaces of Confinement in Joanna Russ’s Kittatiny: A Tale of Magic Isabel Morales Jareño, Universidad Camilo José Cela, Madrid, España1 ABSTRACT Joanna Russ (1937-2011) has taken her readers into a world of fantasy with the adventure story Kittatiny: A Tale of Magic (1978). Although it is seemingly a fantasy narration for children and follows the structure of the traditional hero’s tale – separation, initiation, and return – Kittatiny is pervaded with the author’s usual radical feminist and sexual touches, characteristic of a good part of her literary production. The narrative contrasts with Russ’s usual science fiction short stories, novels, novellas, and critical essays because of its resemblance to the fantasy genre. This study highlights the book’s valuable contribution to the literary feminism of the 1970s and analyzes Russ’s treatment of the traditional fantasy literature for children from a feminist perspective. The focus is on Kit’s journey across natural environments, where she can live in her own space of uncertainty without social or emotional rules and is free to live her own experiences without any ties and confinements. JOANNA RUSS: THE FANTASY WRITER In the 1970s radical feminism and sexuality played an important role in the US panorama, prompting the appearance of social and political groups. Joanna Russ was one of the representatives in the literary spheres and also a writer and critic of traditional folktales and mythology. The 1960s and 1970s were not only political periods about civil rights movements, feminism, or anti-war movements, but also a time of political radicalism on all levels across the nation (Grant, 2006). Russ expressed particular admiration for Carla Fraiser, activist and writer who in 1967 set up the Radical Women (RW) group-aimed to teach women leadership, theoretical skills, and class-consciousness. Joanna’s introduction to Clara Fraser’s Revolution, She wrote (1998) is a praise of her courage and socialist revolutionary ideas and an appreciation of successfully combining feminism and socialism for twenty-nine years. Fraser was also the originator of the Freedom Socialist Party (FSP) based on Leon Trotsky’s ideas, where women, people of color, and sexual minorities (such as homosexuals) struggled for their liberation. Inspired by these ideas, fervent American feminist writers like Betty Friedan 1926-2006)– writer and founder of the National Organization for Women (NOW)– the radical and unconventional Kathy Acker (1948-1993), Alice Sheldon- James Tiptree Jr. (1915-1987), and Joanna Russ (1937-2011) expressed sharp criticism about “the social pressure on girls to be nice rather than authentic and honest, thus becoming “female impersonators,” who must fit their whole selves into small crowded Women in Judaism: A Multidisciplinary Journal Volume 13 Number 1 (2016) ISSN 1209-9392 © 2016 Women in Judaism, Inc. All material in the journal is subject to copyright; copyright is held by the journal except where otherwise indicated. There is to be no reproduction or distribution of contents by any means without prior permission. Contents do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors. 1 Joanna Russ’s Kittatiny: A Tale of Magic spaces” (Lindow 2009, 132). Nancy F. Scott describes the origins of National Organization for Women in the foreword to Barbara J. Love’s Feminist Who Changed America, 1963-1975 (2006), and explains its main purpose during a time of antiwar- protest against the US war in Vietnam: …the time has come for all women in America, and toward true equality for all women in America, and toward a full equal partnership of the sexes, as part of the world-wide revolution of human rights now taking place within and beyond our national borders. (Love 2006, 1) Russ was influenced by this revolutionary context of protests and radicalism led by women’s determination to end patriarchy, as the most necessary step towards a truly free society. She, therefore, attempts to struggle for such feminist ideas as social pressure, love, and family relationships through a fantasy tale for children. As a fantasy story, Kittatiny: A Tale of Magic (1978) epitomizes a new shift in Russ’s literary production, which includes a number of science-fiction short stories and novels, as well as critical academic writings. However, Joanna Russ is not in the only one to write feminist fairy tales, and other works also exalt womanhood and girlhood in the limited patriarchal frames. Anne Sexton’s poems, Briar Rose (Sleeping Beauty) and Little Red Riding Hood, both published in 1971, show women’s oppressive stances. Other feminist fairy tales like Little Red Riding Hood (1977) by Olga Broumas, The Moon Ribbon (1976) by Jane Yolen, Angela Carter’s The Donky Prince (1970) and Tanith Lee’s Petronella (1979) are only a few epitomes of this style of writing. Literary fairy tales as Jack Zipes describes, “… are socially symbolical acts and narrative strategies formed to take part in civilized discourses about morality and behavior in particular societies and cultures.” (Zipes 1994, 19) Russ’s fantasy tale appeared only three years after the publication of one of her most renowned feminist SF2 novels, The Female Man (1975). At that period, she also published some of her most famous titles of SF genre, among them And Chaos Died (1970), The Adventures of Alyx (1976), We Who Are About to (1977), and Two of Them (1978). However, Kitattiny: A Tale of Magic is not a SF story or a feminist polemic; it is, however, an adventure narration where fantastic and imaginary characters help the writer tell a magic tale. Is it a children’s fairytale? What is the aim of writing about feminism through a fantastic tale? As this paper attempts to show, Kitattiny thoroughly represents Russ’s feminist and sexual insights concerning the cultural ambivalence Women in Judaism: A Multidisciplinary Journal Volume 13 Number 1 (2016) ISSN 1209-9392 © 2016 Women in Judaism, Inc. All material in the journal is subject to copyright; copyright is held by the journal except where otherwise indicated. There is to be no reproduction or distribution of contents by any means without prior permission. Contents do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors. 2 Joanna Russ’s Kittatiny: A Tale of Magic about women and their emotional and cognitive skills to behave with authenticity and honesty under social pressure. As Marge Piercy (2001) suggests, the range of concerns that runs through the body of Russ’s work includes “…survival, alienation, loneliness, community, violence, sex roles, the nature of oppression both external and internal, the necessity and the nature of further civilization.”3 The references to Joanna Russ’s magic tale, as in the Cyclopedia of World Authors (Magill 1997, 1287), are usually non-existent or brief: “Kittatiny: A Tale of Magic is written to provide young girls with a positive female figure for the genre of fantasy.” There is, largely, a lack of awareness or minor interest in a story like Kittatiny, since she is considered a successful SF writer with her noted work The Female Man (1975). And although Kittatiny4 has not been recognized as one of her award-winning works, it should be claimed as another notable representation of Joanna Russ, as a feminist writer. Furthermore, given that this story has been scarcely analyzed, this essay aims to analyze its valuable contribution both as another feminist literary depiction of the 1970s and as a fantasy-inspired manifestation of Joanna Russ’s feminist leanings. It focuses on how Russ treats women’s gender roles and sexuality through a narration replete with many characteristics of the traditional fantasy literature for children. Among those, it is necessary to investigate how two different spaces, fantasy and reality, converge and influence the hero throughout her journey, in the course of which accidental imaginary characters and natural landscapes are also protagonists. These rhetorical elements are all part of a quest, and particularly, a young girl’s quest. Throughout the girl’s journey, there exists a tight relationship between the natural environment and the girl, which Russ joyfully deals with, and no ties or confinements, either psychological or physical, can be found. Intentionally, these openness and psychological freedom show how women can live in their own space of uncertainty, where no social or emotional rules are a condition any more. During her quest, she ventures into imaginary episodes where she experiences vulnerability and uncertainty, and meanwhile she finds herself surrounded by amazing natural elements and events. In this way, she finds no social confinements, limits, or pressures, and becomes connected to an open world. Nature is a habitual element that Russ uses to provide the reader with either a disconcerting taste of natural spaces as in Women in Judaism: A Multidisciplinary Journal Volume 13 Number 1 (2016) ISSN 1209-9392 © 2016 Women in Judaism, Inc. All material in the journal is subject to copyright; copyright is held by the journal except where otherwise indicated. There is to be no reproduction or distribution of contents by any means without prior permission. Contents do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors. 3 Joanna Russ’s Kittatiny: A Tale of Magic The Adventures of Alyx (1976)5, or else, descriptions of her deep love for natural beauty, as in On Strike against God (1980). Both as a SF and critical essayist, Russ has thoroughly defended a strong feminist position. And her anger, wit and strength shown in her fictional writing is further incremented by her publications as a critical feminist writer, including How to Suppress Women’s writing (1983) and To Write Like a Woman (1995). And among her SF works, there are three representative examples: When It Changed (1972, the short story precursor of The Female Man), Picnic on Paradise (1968, her first SF novel collected in the Adventures of Alyx), and the 1982 Hugo Award novella, Souls.