DOCSLIB.ORG

Oil and Gas Title Opinions: Structuring and Format

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Oil and Gas Title Opinions: Structuring and Format OIL AND GAS TITLE OPINIONS: STRUCTURING AND FORMAT Presented by: PAUL YALE Gray Reed & McGraw, P.C. Houston, Texas With Special Assistance From: KATIE ENGLISH BROOKE SIZER Associates, Gray Reed & McGraw, P.C. Houston, Texas BETSY RUMELY Attorney-at-Law Denver, Colorado State Bar of Texas OIL, GAS & MINERAL TITLE EXAMINATION COURSE June 25-26, 2015 Houston CHAPTER 17 PAUL G. YALE Shareholder Gray, Reed & McGraw P.C. 1300 Post Oak Blvd., Suite 2000 Houston, Texas 77056 [email protected] 713-986-7189 Mr. Yale is a Shareholder and the Energy Practice Area Head for Gray Reed & McGraw P.C. Mr. Yale has 38 years of legal experience working in both the domestic and international oil and gas industry, 27 years of which was spent with ExxonMobil Corporation and its predecessor companies. Mr. Yale was admitted to the Texas Bar in 1977 and has since become licensed in multiple US jurisdictions including North Dakota, Colorado, Utah, Oklahoma and Ohio. Mr. Yale is Board Certified in Oil, Gas and Mineral Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization. Mr. Yale received his undergraduate degree from Vanderbilt University in 1974 (cum laude) and his law degree from Southern Methodist in 1977. Mr. Yale is Chair of the Houston Bar Association, Oil, Gas and Mineral Law Section for 2015- 16. ii 2725328.1 Oil_________________________________________________________________________________________________________ and Gas Title Opinions: Structuring and Format Chapter 17 SPECIAL THANKS The author wishes to thank the following additional contributors to this paper and the accompanying presentation for their excellent suggestions, wise counsel and generous assistance: George Snell, Attorney at Law, Amarillo, Texas Terry Cross, McClure & Cross, LLP, Dallas, Texas Michelle Phillips, Land Advisor, Hess Corporation, Houston, Texas Christine Herron, CDOA, Division Order Analyst, Hess Corporation, Houston, Texas Bethany Payne, Division Order Analyst, Hess Corporation, Houston, Texas Lauren Bernard, Division Order Supervisor/ PPU, BHP Billiton, Houston, Texas Ryan Culberson, Land Supervisor, BHP Billiton, Houston, Texas Kacie Bevers, Steptoe & Johnson, PLLC, The Woodlands, Texas James Ormiston, Shareholder, Gray Reed & McGraw, Houston, Texas My other colleagues in Gray, Reed & McGraw PC’s Energy Group (Jonathan Worbington, Sandra Mazan and Alex Crawley (Associates) and especially to my Assistant, Sherry Colburn). TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................................... 1 II. COMMONALITY IN TITLE OPINION STRUCTURE AND FORMAT ........................................... 2 III. DIFFERENCES IN OPINION STRUCTURE AND FORMAT ............................................................. 3 IV. ORGANIZING COMMENTS AND REQUIREMENTS ..................................................................... 20 V. FORM TITLE OPINION ........................................................................................................................ 23 VI. TITLE OPINION WRITING STYLE .................................................................................................... 24 VII. CONCLUSION ......................................................................................................................................... 27 APPENDIX A: SAMPLE DRILLING TITLE OPINION ................................................................................. 28 APPENDIX B: SAMPLE DIVISION ORDER TITLE OPINION ................................................................... 31 APPENDIX C: PROPOSED MODEL FORM TITLE OPINION .................................................................... 34 APPENDIX D: ANOTHER SAMPLE TITLE OPINION ................................................................................. 40 APPENDIX E: FORM TITLE OPINION ........................................................................................................... 47 BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SUGGESTED FURTHER READING ....................................................................... 70 2725328.1 Oil_________________________________________________________________________________________________________ and Gas Title Opinions: Structuring and Format Chapter 17 OIL AND GAS TITLE OPINIONS: One obvious change from the past is the sheer volume and geographic diversity of oil and gas title STRUCTURING AND FORMAT examinations in the United States over the past decade. I. INTRODUCTION Advances in horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing and the opening of shale plays in basins An orderly mind, it has been said, “is reflected by throughout the United States have likely created the an orderly body; and an orderly body is reflected by largest demand for oil and gas title opinions in the orderly dress.1” An orderly title examiner’s mind, by industry’s history. analogy, should be reflected by an orderly title With the increased number of title opinions has examination; and an orderly title examination should come increased pressure within oil companies to make be reflected by an orderly title opinion. their internal processes dealing with title opinions more Few if any title examiners would take exception to efficient. It is easier and quicker to act on information the notion that an orderly, well-organized title opinion when a reader is reviewing a title opinion in a form that is more apt to serve the needs of the client than one the reader is accustomed to. This is even truer when a that is not. But title examiners and other industry reader must review a large number of title opinions or professionals disagree over how to best organize a title when multiple readers within the same company are opinion. looking at the same title opinion forms. There are many reasons for the widespread Technological advances also factor in. The author differences in title opinion forms used in the oil and is aware of at least one company who has attempted to gas industry today. Regional differences and the size put a system in place to link title opinions to its royalty and complexity of the area being examined account for check disbursements database. The theoretical some dissimilarities. Lawyers can have widely efficiencies and cost savings of such systems seem conflicting views on the subject and can be close- obvious. minded about changing their own forms. Competition For all these reasons more and more companies between law firms, conflicts of interests, and are requiring law firms to use a standard form title confidentiality concerns may chill exchanges of title opinion template. But efforts to standardize title opinion forms or otherwise dampen collaborative opinion forms by companies tend to be ad hoc and efforts to develop a more uniform approach. inconsistent. Lawyers, being anxious to please, often No wonder, then, that the oil and gas bar in Texas accept whatever form the client wants without further has failed to develop a model form title opinion discussion. Rigorous analysis can be preempted by template. Disorder, not order, reigns. But there have expediency. Best practices can be overlooked. been candles in the darkness. Over fifteen years ago an Therefore, the questions raised by George Snell article was written by George Snell for the State Bar of fifteen years ago (“A Model Form Title Opinion Texas Oil & Gas Section Report entitled “A Model Format—Is it Possible? Is it Practical?”) seem worth Form Title Opinion Format—Is it Possible? Is it revisiting. Has the time come for an industry wide Practical?”2 After pointing out the trend towards standard oil and gas title opinion format? The oil and standardized forms in the real estate industry, Snell gas industry has adapted model form leases, operating attached a proposed uniform title opinion template to agreements, gas purchase contracts, and drilling his article and issued a bell call for Texas oil and gas contracts. Why would a model form title opinion not practitioners to collaborate with him in developing a be attainable? more uniform approach. That bell call, however, Irrespective of the answer to that question this appears to have fallen on deaf ears. paper presumes that the oil and gas bar and its clients Or if ears were not deaf, perhaps they were can benefit from an exchange of ideas and best indifferent? Many lawyers might question whether practices with regard to title opinion structure and developing an industry wide model form is either format. Accordingly, following this Introduction, Part necessary or worth the trouble. The oil industry in the II of this paper lists twenty of the most common United States has survived so far without one. What elements of oil and gas title opinion formats found in has changed? Texas and elsewhere; Part III lists and discusses twenty common differences. Part IV discusses oil and gas title opinion comments and requirements and makes suggestions for organizing. Part V discusses a “Form 1 Dr. Harold Weatherby, Vanderbilt University, Freshman Opinion” (Appendix E). English, Fall 1970. Part VI addresses title opinion writing style. It is 2 George Snell, A Model Form Title Opinion Format - Is it difficult if not impossible to divorce a discussion about Possible? Is it Practical?, 25 STATE BAR OF TEX. OIL, GAS title opinion structure and format from a discussion of & MINERAL LAW SEC. REPORT 2 (Dec. 2000). 1 2725328.1 Oil_________________________________________________________________________________________________________ and Gas Title Opinions: Structuring and Format Chapter 17 writing
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Get a Glossary of Terms Used in the Title Industry
    GLOSSARY A Abstract Plant – A geographically arranged abstract plant, currently kept to date, that is adequate for use in insuring titles, so as to provide for the safety and protection of the policyholders. An abstract plant as further defined in Rule P-12 and as further provided for in the Insurance Code, Chapter 2501.003 and Chapter 2502, must include an abstract plant for each county in which a title insurance agent or direct operation maintains an office. Abstract of Title - A compilation of all the recorded documents relating to a parcel of land. Usually kept by the land owner and used as the basis for an attorney as to the condition of title. Still in use in some states, and in some areas of Texas, but mostly replaced by issuance of title insurance. Abstract of Judgment – A lien created by a statutory filing of a court judgment in the real property records. This lien, commonly referred to as an AJ (in Texas), attaches to all non- exempt real property of the person or entity that the judgment was against. Acceleration Clause (in a mortgage) – Specifies conditions under which the lender may advance the time when the entire debt which is secured by the mortgage becomes due. For example, most mortgages contain provisions that the note shall become due immediately upon the sale of the securing land without the lender's consent or upon failure of the landowner to pay an installment when due. Access – The right to enter and leave a tract of land from a public way. Can include the right to enter and leave over the lands of another.
    [Show full text]
  • Chain of Title – Information Sheet
    Chain of Title – information sheet Important note about this Chain of Title guidance This information sheet provides you with guidance about the New Zealand Film Commission (NZFC) requirements in relation to Chain of Title. It will help you provide the Chain of Title information we require for any form of NZFC funding. It is not intended to be legal advice nor is it intended to be comprehensive. You are welcome to call us to discuss any Chain of Title queries you may have. Before acting on this information, we recommend you seek other professional and legal advice. What is Chain of Title? Chain of Title is a timeline of transfers of title (ownership) in the rights to a project. The ‘chain’ analogy is used to illustrate the line of ownership running from the current owner back to the original owner of the property. Chain of Title means, collectively, all of the agreements that give you permission to use other people’s material in, and contributions to, your film. Why is Chain of Title important? In the film and television industry, it is very important to be able to have written agreements showing that the producer owns or controls the rights in the film. Before they will invest or lend to a production, funders and investors will want to see evidence that the production company has the right to make and distribute the film. And before they’ll represent or show a film, exhibitors, film festivals, sales agents and distributors will usually require documentation to verify the producer’s rights in the film.
    [Show full text]
  • Marketable Title Acts - a Means to Improve Title Practice
    Denver Law Review Volume 30 Issue 11 Article 4 June 2021 Marketable Title Acts - A Means to Improve Title Practice Robert T. Haines Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.du.edu/dlr Recommended Citation Robert T. Haines, Marketable Title Acts - Means to Improve Title Practice, 30 Dicta 423 (1953). This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Denver Law Review at Digital Commons @ DU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Denver Law Review by an authorized editor of Digital Commons @ DU. For more information, please contact [email protected],[email protected]. Nov., 1953 DICTA MARKETABLE TITLE ACTS-A MEANS TO IMPROVE TITLE PRACTICE* ROBERT T. HAINES of the Denver Bar Our Supreme Court has defined a marketable title as one "that is fairly deductible of record . that is reasonably free from such doubts as will affect the market value of the estate; one which a reasonably prudent person with knowledge of all the facts and their legal bearing would be willing to accept." The central concept of this definition is an economic one. That is, if a reasonably prudent person would feel sufficiently secure from the loss of his investment in the title that he would purchase it without discount, then the title is marketable. How- ever, we do not practice what we preach. The reagent by which the transactions in a chain of title are tested is not the probability of economic safety, but is a set of formal legalist standards. As ap- plied to transactions which took place within recent times these standards are objective in character and provide only a reasonable margin of security.
    [Show full text]
  • Abstract of Title an Abstract of Title Is a Summary of the Legal History of a Piece of Real Property
    Abstract of Title An abstract of title is a summary of the legal history of a piece of real property. It is used by title insurance companies as the basis for issuing title insurance and by attorney's examining title as the basis for their conclusions with regard to ownership. Despite its importance, the abstract of title is not a legal document and is not prepared by any gov- ernmental agency. Rather, it is a summary prepared by a title company or abstracting rm. To prepare the abstract, an employee of the rm, called an abstractor, reviews all of the records on le with the oce of the county recorder or similar government land title oce, which relate to that particular piece of property. The abstractor prepares a short summa- ry of each transaction, arranged in chronological order, which identify the instruments (deed, mortgage, etc.), names the grantor's and grant- ees, lists the dates the instruments were signed and led, and, where appropriate, provides a summary of their contents. This sequence of deeds and other documents are often call the property's chain of title, and the function of the abstract is to summarize it accurately. The abstract of title will have as its rst entry a summary of the transac- tion by which the United States Government conveyed the land to a private party for the rst time. It then shows every transaction aecting the land from that date up until the present. A new abstract is not prepared each time the property is sold. Rather, at each sale the abstract is updated to reect new transactions since the time of the last update.
    [Show full text]
  • Commonly Used Real Estate Transaction Terms
    Commonly Used Real Estate Transaction Terms The following terms are utilized frequently in real estate transactions that are not used in implementing other NRCS conservation programs. The definitions provided for this list of terms does not supersede definitions provided in the WRP manual or in the Department of Justice title standards, but is intended to clarify frequently used terms. 1. “Exceptions and clouds on title” refers to any evidence that the landowner is not in full control of the property to be encumbered by the Wetlands Restoration Program (WRP) easement or contract or that the property cannot be used for wetland restoration purposes. Exceptions and clouds on title can include mechanics’ liens, mortgages, judgments, divorce decrees, other conservation easements, hazardous waste risks, and squatters’ rights. 2. “Title search documents” refers to the summaries of information regarding the documents obtained by searching the land records, court dockets, and other public records. These summaries are contained in documents entitled “Preliminary Title Report,” “Title Commitment Binder,” “Title Abstract,” and the like. 3. “Underlying documents” refers to the individual documents listed in the title search documents summary that are obtained by searching the land records, court dockets, and other public records. 4. “Closing agent” refers to the person or entity preparing the title search document, providing the underlying documents, or handling the closing and legal transfer of title and ownership from the seller to the buyer. The closing agent is typically not an agent of either party, but simply the person entrusted to carry out all non-conflicting instructions from all parties. In WRP transactions, the closing agent is hired by NRCS and thus is consider a buyer’s agent.
    [Show full text]
  • Real Estate Dictionary
    REAL ESTATE DICTIONARY This dictionary serves as a reference tool for individuals and organizations in the real estate community. We hope you find useful its brief definitions of real estate-related terminology. We welcome the opportunity to be of service to you. A Adverse Possession: A claim made against the land of another by virtue of open and notorious possession Abstract of Title: A condensed history or summary of of said land by the claimant. all transactions affecting a particular tract of land. Affidavit: A sworn statement in writing. Access: The legal right to enter and leave a tract of land from a public way. Can include the right to enter and Agent: A person or company that has the power to leave over the land of another. act on behalf of another or to transact business for another, e.g., a title agent under contract with Old Accretion: The slow buildup of land by natural forces Republic Title is an agent solely for the purpose such as wind or water. of issuing policies of title insurance and other title insurance products. Adjustable Rate Mortgage (ARM): A residential mortgage that has an interest rate that is subject to Air Rights: The right to ownership of everything above change. The times of adjustment are agreed upon at the physical surface of the land. the inception of the loan. ALTA: American Land Title Association, a national Administrator: A person appointed by a probate court association of title insurance companies, abstractors to settle the affairs of an individual dying without a and attorneys specializing in real property law.
    [Show full text]
  • Insuring Entities Or Who, Who, Who Are You?
    THE NC CONNECTION North Carolina Insuring Entities or Who, Who, Who Resources Are You? Jane S. Barkley, Esq., Senior Commercial Title Attorney [email protected] CFPB/ALTA Best Practices Corporations have been called invtitle.com/cfpb/nc: CFPB and ALTA the most successful legal fiction. Best Practice articles, manuals, Ambrose Bierce said a solutions, and other resources. corporation was “An ingenious Events & Education device for obtaining individual profit without individual invtitle.com/events/nc: CLE/CPE credit responsibility.” From a title available through live and online courses. perspective, we don’t need to be corporate experts. We simply Articles & Newsletters need to confirm that the entity in invtitle.com/resources/nc: for a the chain of title is valid and in comprehensive directory of past good standing. newsletters, select Articles and Newsletters / Article Directory. In most states, the recording of corporations and limited liability Forms companies is available online through the Secretary (or states also require a current list invtitle.com/resources/nc: for a sometimes “Department”) of of officers and directors. It is a complete list of forms, select the Forms State. In North Carolina, both good idea to check the officers category. domestic and foreign entities are and directors as well. If your Tools listed at https:// documents are not being signed www.secretary.state.nc.us/ by one of those persons, a invtitle.com/resources/nc: for a search/index/corp. An entity resolution or corporate affidavit complete list of frequently-used tools, “chain of title” showing of authority should be required. view the tools box on the right.
    [Show full text]
  • The Oklahoma Marketable Record Title Act Introduction
    Tulsa Law Review Volume 9 Issue 1 Spring 1973 The Oklahoma Marketable Record Title Act Introduction John F. Hicks Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.law.utulsa.edu/tlr Part of the Law Commons Recommended Citation John F. Hicks, The Oklahoma Marketable Record Title Act Introduction, 9 Tulsa L. J. 68 (2013). Available at: https://digitalcommons.law.utulsa.edu/tlr/vol9/iss1/3 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by TU Law Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Tulsa Law Review by an authorized editor of TU Law Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Hicks: The Oklahoma Marketable Record Title Act Introduction TULSA LAW JOURNAL (Vol. 9, No. I THE OKLAHOMA MARKETABLE RECORD TITLE ACT INTRODUCTION By JomH F. HICKS* This article is based upon speeches delivered in 1972 to the Tulsa Title and Probate Lawyers Association and the Real Property Section of the Oklahoma Bar Association. The in- terest of attorneys across Oklahoma in the Oklahoma Market- able Record Title Act' was evidenced by the comments and questions raised during these speeches. Although the Act has been in effect for almost ten years, there is no judicial con- struction of it as yet and relatively little non-judicial inter- pretation of it. 2 The purpose of this article is to help fill in this gap by discussing the basic features of the Act and ex- amining some of the complexities surrounding it. BACKGROUND OF MARKETABLE RECORD TITLE LEGISLATION Problems in the American Conveyancing System in the Absence of Marketable Title Legislation Practitioners in the conveyancing field are well aware of many of the problems in this field that have given rise to the * Associate Professor of Law, University of Tulsa, College of Law.
    [Show full text]
  • Chain of Title Assessment (Cota) Checklist
    DK CONSULTANTS LLC 2935 THOUSAND OAKS DRIVE, #6-132 SAN ANTONIO, TEXAS 78247-3312 (512) 718-9604 Dave Krieger, Title Consultant Official Website: www.dkconsultants.us CHAIN OF TITLE ASSESSMENT (COTA) CHECKLIST IMPORTANT! Please read this entire document BEFORE proceeding with your COTA! NOTE: An explanation into each category follows each enumerated item in this checklist! DISCLAIMER: Use of this material is done at your discretion and at your own risk and offers no express or implied warranties whatsoever. The explanations in this material are for educational purposes only; do not constitute the rendering of legal advice and do not guarantee any legal outcome or seek to draw any conclusions of law. Our COTAs are utilized by attorneys in litigation case development and are not for evidentiary use. What we need to complete a chain of title assessment (COTA): I. COURTHOUSE RECORDS The following must be obtained from courthouse land records in BOTH Certified and regular copies (one of each; certified copy for evidence and regular copy for office use): ___ DEED (This can also be known as “Warranty Deed”; “General Warranty Deed”; “Special Warranty Deed”; “Grant Deed”; “Security Deed”; “Substitute Trustee’s Deed”; “Quit Claim Deed”; “Tax Deed”; or “Abstract Deed”. This “deed” represents itself as the Instrument that conveys the property to you by the former owner. The former owner would be the “Grantor”; you (and your spouse, if married) are the “Grantee”. This generally starts your chain of title.) ___ DEEDS OF TRUST (Promissory Note, if recorded) (This can also be referred to in judicial states as a “Mortgage”.
    [Show full text]
  • DEFINITIONS of REAL ESTATE TERMS the Following Section Is Definitions for Terms Used in the Register of Deeds Office
    DEFINITIONS OF REAL ESTATE TERMS The following section is definitions for terms used in the register of deeds office. ACKNOWLEDGMENT: The process of establishing the fact that each signature on an instrument is genuine. In most cases, the signatures on documents must be authenticated or acknowledged before the register may accept them. An acknowledgment is a type of authentication often performed by a notary public. How authentication may take place is set out in ss. 706.06 and 706.07. Because registers of deeds are empowered by law to acknowledge documents, a working knowledge of these sections is important. APPRAISAL: The process through which conclusions of property value are obtained; also refers to the report that sets forth the process of estimation and conclusion of value. ASSESSMENT: The imposition of a tax, charge, or levy, usually according to established rates. ASSIGNMENT: The transfer in writing of interest in a bond, mortgage, lease, or other instrument. ASSUMPTION OF MORTGAGE: Acquiring title to property on which there is an existing mortgage and agreeing to be personally liable for the terms and conditions of the mortgage, including payments. AUTHENTICATION: The process of establishing the fact that each signature on an instrument is genuine. In most cases, the signatures on documents must be authenticated or acknowledged before the Register may accept them. An attorney may authenticate a signature on a legal document. How authentication may take place is set out in ss. 706.06 and 706.07. Because Registers of Deeds are empowered by law to acknowledge documents, a working knowledge of these sections is important.
    [Show full text]
  • Uniform Residential Mortgage Satisfaction Act
    UNIFORM RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE SATISFACTION ACT drafted by the NATIONAL CONFERENCE OF COMMISSIONERS ON UNIFORM STATE LAWS and by it APPROVED AND RECOMMENDED FOR ENACTMENT IN ALL THE STATES at its ANNUAL CONFERENCE MEETING IN ITS ONE-HUNDRED-AND-THIRTEENTH YEAR PORTLAND, OREGON JULY 30-AUGUST 6, 2004 WITH PREFATORY NOTE AND COMMENTS Copyright ©2004 By NATIONAL CONFERENCE OF COMMISSIONERS ON UNIFORM STATE LAWS October 2004 DRAFTING COMMITTEE ON UNIFORM RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE SATISFACTION ACT EDWARD F. LOWRY, JR., 4200 N. 82nd St., Suite 2001, Scottsdale, AZ 85251, Chair ELLEN F. DYKE, 8010 Towers Crescent Dr., Suite 300, Vienna, VA 22182 ROBERT L. MCCURLEY, JR., Alabama Law Institute, P.O. Box 861425, Tuscaloosa, AL 35486, Enactment Plan Coordinator NEAL OSSEN, 21 Oak St., Suite 201, Hartford, CT 06106 ELWAINE F. POMEROY, 1415 SW Topeka Blvd., Topeka, KS 66612-1818 REGINA R. QUINN, Jackson State University, P.O. Box 17239, Jackson, MS 39217-0239 R. WILSON FREYERMUTH, University of Missouri-Columbia School of Law, 215 Hulston Hall, Columbia, MO 65211, Reporter EX OFFICIO FRED H. MILLER, University of Oklahoma, College of Law, 300 Timberdell Road, Norman, OK 73019, President LANI LIU EWART, Suite 1800, Alii Pl., 1099 Alakea St., Honolulu, HI 96813, Division Chair AMERICAN BAR ASSOCIATION ADVISOR PATRICK MEARS, 601 Campau Square Plaza, 99 Monroe Ave. NW, Grand Rapids, MI 49503, American Bar Association Advisor EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR WILLIAM H. HENNING, University of Alabama School of Law, Box 870382, Tuscaloosa, AL 35487-0382, Executive Director WILLIAM J. PIERCE, 1505 Roxbury Road, Ann Arbor, MI 48104, Executive Director Emeritus Copies of this Act may be obtained from: NATIONAL CONFERENCE OF COMMISSIONERS ON UNIFORM STATE LAWS 211 E.
    [Show full text]
  • Property - Practice Question 3: SELECTED ANSWER A
    Property - Practice Question 3: SELECTED ANSWER A 1. What right, title, or interest in Blackacre, if any, is held by Cathy, David, Ellen and/or Fred? At common law, there were no recording statutes and the rule was that the first in time prevailed. Under this jurisdiction, there is a race-notice statute that will govern the facts of this case. If the statute does not apply, then the common law does. A race-notice statute provides that any subsequent purchaser of property will take if they are a bona fide purchaser (BFP) and recorded first. To be a BFP, a party must pay value and take without notice of any prior recordings that may affect their title to the property. Notice can be by: (1) actual notice; (2) constructive notice; or (3) inquiry notice. Actual notice is that the party knew there was another party with a claim on the property. Constructive notice is when a recording in the grantor-grantee index gives notice to a party that there are other parties claiming interest to the land. Lastly, inquiry notice is when the party is given facts that there may be other possessors to the property and that party has a duty to inquire further (i.e., if they see a house built on the land with occupants, that party has a duty to inquire why they are on the land). A. Cathy A joint tenancy is created with a right of survivorship when the four unities are met: time, title, instrument and possession. In other words, the parties must acquire their joint tenancy at the same time, with the same amount of title, in the same instrument and each have the right to possess the entire land.
    [Show full text]