Dr. Jeffrey A. Lieberman, Md Testimony Before The

DR. JEFFREY A. LIEBERMAN, MD LAWRENCE C. KOLB PROFESSOR AND CHAIRMAN, DEPARTMENT OF PSYCHIATRY, COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PHYSICIANS AND SURGEONS; DIRECTOR, NEW YORK STATE PSYCHIATRIC INSTITUTE; AND PSYCHIATRIST-IN-CHIEF, COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER OF THE NEW YORK-PRESBYTERIAN HOSPITAL TESTIMONY BEFORE THE UNITED STATES HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES HOUSE ENERGY & COMMERCE COMMITTEE HEALTH SUBCOMMITTEE “EXAMINING H.R. 2646, THE HELPING FAMILIES IN MENTAL HEALTH CRISIS ACT” JUNE 16, 2015 1 Chairman Upton, Subcommittee Chairman Pitts, Ranking Members Pallone and Green, members of the Committee, thank you for inviting me to attend the hearing today. My name is Dr. Jeffrey Lieberman, and I am the Lawrence C. Kolb Professor and Chairman of the Department of Psychiatry at Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons in New York. I also hold the title of Director at the New York State Psychiatric Institute and serve as Psychiatrist-in-Chief at the New York-Presbyterian Hospital - Columbia University Medical Center. My 35-year career in psychiatric medicine has focused on research on the causes and treatment of schizophrenia and related psychotic disorders, and the care of patients. I have authored more than 550 articles published in the scientific literature and written and/or edited 16 books on mental illness and psychiatry including most recently Shrinks: The Untold Story of Psychiatry and personally treated or overseen the care of thousands of patients. I was honored to receive the Lieber Prize for Schizophrenia Research from NARSAD/Brain and Behavior Foundation, the Adolph Meyer and Research Awards from the American Psychiatric Association, the Research Award from the National Alliance on Mental Illness, and the Neuroscience Award from the International College of Neuropsychopharmacology. In 2000 I was elected to the National Academy of Sciences Institute of Medicine, and I am a past president of the American Psychiatric Association. I am grateful for the opportunity to testify about mental illness and mental health care and the relevance of the Helping Families in Mental Health Crisis Act, H.R. 2646, introduced by Representatives Murphy and Johnson. First, I wish to provide the Committee with a short summary of my perspective on the current status of our nation in treating serious mental illness. Second, I wish to speak to several provisions of H.R. 2646 and how enactment of these provisions would significantly advance our approach to the treatment and care of serious mental illness. Finally, I wish to add some concluding thoughts on this Committee’s work on the legislation, and encourage swift adoption of the Helping Families in Mental Crisis Act to allow me, and tens of thousands of 2 other health care professionals across the country, to better care for those suffering from serious mental illness and their families. We need to end the mental health crisis that exists in America today. I. The Mental Health Crisis Facing America I know that this Committee and the members of Congress are well aware of the mental health crisis facing this country, and I applaud Congressman Tim Murphy for all he has done to bring the facts to light on this issue, including the many hearings he has led. I also wish to thank Chairman Upton for his support of this effort, and also his leadership on the 21st Century Cures legislation which is so vital to those of us in the biomedical research community and the American population who benefit from progress in health care, as well as the other Committee Members for their contribution to making comprehensive mental health reform and enhancement of biomedical research a major focus of the 113th and 114th Congress. Let me state at the outset that by mental illness I am referring to what are traditionally considered mental illnesses (e.g. schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, depression), addiction (e.g. substance use disorders) and intellectual disabilities (e.g. autism, Fragile X syndrome). The distinctions between these are arbitrary as they all are conditions affecting the same real estate in the brain and manifest by disturbances in common mental functions. Many problems that you, as the leaders of our country, face are impossibly complex or require new knowledge to solve, such examples are Alzheimer’s disease, terrorism and global warming. However, that is not the case with mental health. We have the knowledge and the means to do so much more. We simply lack the political and social will, which I fervently hope this committee will galvanize. 3 To understand the crisis in mental health care, we must view its historical context1. From the inception of psychiatry in the early 19th century until the 1950’s, there was virtually no scientific understanding of mental illness or any effective treatments. The first effective treatments did not come until psychotropic drugs were discovered and introduced into clinical practice in 1955 beginning with antipsychotics and anxiolytics, and followed by antidepressants in the 1960’s and mood stabilizers 1970’s. Up until then, institutionalization was the primary mode of mental health care, apart from invasive and potentially dangerous treatments that were devised out of desperation such as Malaria Therapy, Coma Therapy, Electroshock Therapy and Pre-Frontal Leucotomy. 1 Shrinks: The Untold Story of Psychiatry. Little Brown 2015 Following the advent of psychopharmacology came the development of scientifically proven forms of psychosocial treatments such as Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), Assertive Community Treatment, Supported Employment and Cognitive Rehabilitation, as well as neuromodulatory therapeutic devices including ECT, Repeated Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation, Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation and Deep Brain Stimulation, which comprised a broad array of effective and safe treatments for mental illness. In 1955, when the first antipsychotic drug, chlorpromazine, was introduced, the population of institutionalized mentally ill persons in the U.S. (most of whom lived in appalling conditions) had reached its zenith (550,000 people). Our government’s and citizens’ humanitarian concerns combined with the newfound dramatic effectiveness of the miracle drugs inspired a grand plan for community based mental health care that was formalized in JFK’s Community Mental Health Act of 1963. This historic initiative called for patients to be released from hospitals and be cared for on an outpatient basis at community mental health clinics. However, the resources, workforce and infrastructure of the state mental institutions were not transferred to the community settings, and, as a result, the deinstitutionalization movement was a catastrophic failure from which our society is still suffering. This is reflected in the large numbers of mentally ill persons who are homeless and incarcerated in 4 prisons, as well as by the epidemic of preventable and repeat hospitalizations (for psychiatric and medical reasons) that drive up health care costs. Half-century later we are still fighting the same battle. Millions of individuals and their families across the country continue to struggle with preventable mental health crises. Approximately twenty million Americans suffer from serious mental illness, with almost 40 percent of these individuals receiving no treatment at all.1 Prior to 1955 if you had a mental illness, the biggest barrier to relief from your symptoms was the lack of effective treatments. Currently, the greatest obstacles are lack of awareness, embarrassment and lack of access to effective care. Imagine an analogy to infectious disease in which large numbers of the U.S. population were suffering from pneumonia, tuberculosis, polio and AIDS and we were not using antibiotics, vaccines, antiretroviral drugs and protease inhibitors because of lack of awareness, fear or inability to find them. This is the situation we face with mental illness. Although our treatments are not perfect (they do not work for everyone and are not cures, and many medications and procedures do have side effects), they are highly effective and, when properly administered, are life changing and in some cases life saving. There are two reasons for the peculiar situation in which we have effective treatments but are not using them. The first is stigma, which consists of ignorance and fear. Stigma of mental illness is pervasive in American society and is actively perpetuated by a virulent Anti-Psychiatry Movement. Psychiatry has the dubious distinction of being the only medical specialty with a movement dedicated to its eradication. (There are no anti-pediatrics, dermatology or orthopedics movements.) This movement is comprised by diverse constituencies who dispute the concept of mental illness and way to treat them including Scientology, the latter being motivated by financial designs rather than ideological reasons. 1 http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa1413512 5 The second reason is our country’s failed mental health care and financing policies. Without discussing the myriad specific elements, the absence of an effective and enlightened policy has resulted in a fragmented and defective system that offers care which is limited, often incompetent and difficult to access.1 The fact of the matter is that the workforce, infrastructure and financing mechanisms to enable the provision of comprehensive state of the art mental health care to the populations with mental illness are lacking. While many agencies and stakeholder organizations and constituencies share responsibility

Load more