LISTING OF CITATIONS - VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE

Hearing on 10th March 2021 at 10.00 am in Community Room 3, Deveron Community Centre, Bellview Road, Banff, Ab45

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

1 54641/62397 TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITIES SCOTTISH POLICE AUTHORITY P 119,000 119,000 GRAMPIAN JOINT POLICE BOARD FINANCE DEPARTMENT THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL AREA DELOITTE LLP A

2 54643/79797 TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITIES ARQIVA LIMITED P 1,156,000 1,156,000 ARQIVA LTD THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL AREA AVISON YOUNG A

3 13003/79859 GARDEN CENTRE SIMPSONS AT HAPPY PLANT P 111,000 111,000 HAPPY PLANT GARDEN CENTRE NORTH STREET J & E SHEPHERD A

4 90170/79856 FACTORY AUGEAN NORTH SEA SERVICES LTD P 146,000 146,000 DAMHEAD WAY RYDEN LLP A

5 13981/70320 WORKSHOP SMITHS GARAGE (2020) LTD T 18,000 18,000 ALBERT STREET

6 14532/79702 OFFICES THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 45,500 45,500 COUNCIL CHAMBERS PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES 1 SALTOUN SQUARE FRASERBURGH RYDEN LLP A

24/11/2020 Page 1 of 10 CASES CONTINUED FROM 20/11/2019 HEARING

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

63 36935/62228 OFFICE NEEROCK LTD P 17,250 17,250 MARKETHILL ROAD T/A WOODHEAD BROTHERS TURRIFF GL HEARN LIMITED A

64 11860/62225 OFFICE NEEROCK LTD P 5,300 5,300 MARKETHILL ROAD T/A WOODHEAD BROTHERS TURRIFF TURRIFF GL HEARN LIMITED A

65 43485/62239 ROOMS NEEROCK LTD P 7,100 7,100 MARKETHILL ROAD T/A WOODHEAD BROTHERS TURRIFF TURRIFF GL HEARN LIMITED A

66 43486/62236 OFFICE NEEROCK LTD P 5,400 5,400 MARKETHILL ROAD T/A WOODHEAD BROTHERS TURRIFF TURRIFF GL HEARN LIMITED A

149 31781/53359 SURGERY DR WATT & PARTNERS P 31,000 31,000 33 FINLAYSON STREET FRASERBURGH WYMRE A

152 14636/57411 COLLEGE NORTH EAST COLLEGE P 850,000 850,000 BANFF & COLLEGE HENDERSON ROAD FRASERBURGH F G BURNETT LTD A

24/11/2020 Page 2 of 10 CASES CONTINUED FROM 29/04/2020 HEARING

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

2 36873/59376 AQUARIUM THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 45,250 45,250 11 HIGH SHORE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES MACDUFF RYDEN LLP A

8 10549/58515 DISTILLERY JOHN DEWAR & SONS LIMITED P 114,000 114,000 MACDUFF DISTILLERY GLENDEVERON BANFF AVISON YOUNG A

25 11033/57708 HOTEL MOUNTWEST ABATTIS LIMITED P 168,000 168,000 BANFF SPRINGS HOTEL 8 GOLDEN KNOWES ROAD BANFF RYDEN LLP A

28 11096/59427 COURT HOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 13,750 13,750 PART PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES LOW STREET BANFF RYDEN LLP A

33 37102/56968 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES TELEFONICA UK LTD P 590,000 590,000 (TELEFONICA) THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL AREA COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

34 37102/69174 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES TELEFONICA UK LTD P 590,000 590,000 (TELEFONICA) THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL AREA COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

35 37102/69185 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES TELEFONICA UK LTD P 374,600 374,600 (TELEFONICA) THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL AREA COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

36 38749/57679 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES VODAFONE LIMITED P 815,000 815,000 (VODAFONE) THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL AREA COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

37 38749/69175 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES VODAFONE LIMITED P 815,000 815,000 (VODAFONE) THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL AREA COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

38 38749/69184 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES VODAFONE LIMITED P 260,200 260,200 (VODAFONE) THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL AREA COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

39 93693/67762 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES CORNERSTONE TELECOMMUNICATIONS P 1,405,000 1,405,000 CTIL INFRASTRUCTURE LIMITED THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL AREA COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

40 93693/69173 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES CORNERSTONE TELECOMMUNICATIONS P 1,405,000 1,405,000 CTIL INFRASTRUCTURE LIMITED THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL AREA COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

41 93693/69183 TELECOMMUNICATION SITES CORNERSTONE TELECOMMUNICATIONS P 768,000 768,000 CTIL INFRASTRUCTURE LIMITED THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL AREA COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

24/11/2020 Page 3 of 10 CASES CONTINUED FROM 29/04/2020 HEARING

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

56 11339/57631 DISTILLERY THE GLENGLASSAUGH DISTILLERY P 153,000 153,000 GLENGLASSAUGH COMPANY LIMITED MONTAGU EVANS A

68 11624/57632 GRAIN STORE BAIRDS MALT LTD P 97,000 97,000 ROSEHALL TURRIFF WYMRE A

118 13159/52506 OFFSHORE OIL SUPPORT BASE ASCO UK LTD P 1,690,000 1,690,000 SOUTH BASE PETERHEAD OFFSHORE SUPPLY BASE PETERHEAD RYDEN LLP A

129 86775/55071 OFFSHORE OIL SUPPORT BASE NORSEA GROUP (UK) LTD T 287,000 287,000 SMITH QUAY BATH STREET PETERHEAD F G BURNETT LTD A

130 86775/67783 OFFSHORE OIL SUPPORT BASE NORSEA GROUP (UK) LTD T 335,000 335,000 SMITH QUAY BATH STREET PETERHEAD F G BURNETT LTD A

131 86775/70213 OFFSHORE OIL SUPPORT BASE NORSEA GROUP (UK) LTD T 720,000 720,000 SMITH QUAY BATH STREET PETERHEAD WYMRE A

133 13471/52509 OFFSHORE OIL SUPPORT BASE SERVICE COMPANY T 428,000 428,000 NORTH BASE (NORTH SEA) LIMITED KEITH STREET PETERHEAD RYDEN LLP A

140 13724/60025 LIBRARY THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 43,500 43,500 53 ST PETER STREET PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES PETERHEAD RYDEN LLP A

142 13738/58372 BUS STATION STAGECOACH BLUEBIRD T 46,750 46,750 PETERHEAD TRANSPORT INTERCHANGE ST PETER STREET PETERHEAD MONTAGU EVANS A

143 13738/60026 BUS STATION THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 46,750 46,750 PETERHEAD TRANSPORT INTERCHANGE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES ST PETER STREET PETERHEAD RYDEN LLP A

144 89393/52510 OIL STORAGE DEPOT ABERDEEN SERVICE COMPANY T 145,000 145,000 SHIP STREET (NORTH SEA) LTD PETERHEAD RYDEN LLP A

160 14371/61118 LIBRARY THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 32,500 32,500 KING EDWARD STREET PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES FRASERBURGH RYDEN LLP A

195 35698/63356 RADAR STATION NATS (EN ROUTE) PLC P 101,000 101,000 ALLANSHILL GROUP PROPERTY SERVICES CTC SOUTHAMPTON FRASERBURGH CLUTTONS LLP A

24/11/2020 Page 4 of 10 CASES CONTINUED FROM 02/09/2020 HEARING

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

7 10362/55370 QUARRY LOVIE LTD T 5,100 5,100 COTTONHILL 13,300 M 6,650 MACDUFF RYDEN LLP A

8 87588/52566 WIND FARM TARLAIR RENEWABLES LLP T 31,000 31,000 TARLAIR WIND FARM MACDUFF

9 86868/62426 WIND TURBINE AURA WIND (COWIEHILL) LIMITED T 35,000 35,000 COWIE HILL PER AG RENEWABLES ALVAH BANFF DUNLOP HEYWOOD A

10 86845/52565 WIND TURBINE SANDLAW FARMING COMPANY T 13,750 13,750 AUCHENBADIE ALVAH BANFF

11 86837/52561 WIND TURBINE WHITEFIELD WIND ENERGY LTD T 35,000 35,000 MAINS OF WHITEFIELD FORGLEN BANFF

12 83336/64176 WIND TURBINE BENZIES RENEWABLE POWER LTD T 60,000 60,000 GAIRNIESTON TURRIFF

13 87865/62835 WIND TURBINE MILWIND LIMITED T 61,000 61,000 MILTON OF FISHERIE KING EDWARD BANFF DUNLOP HEYWOOD A

14 87866/62833 WIND TURBINE MILWIND LIMITED T 61,000 61,000 MILTON OF FISHERIE KING EDWARD BANFF DUNLOP HEYWOOD A

16 83751/55361 WIND FARM LOVIE LTD P 65,000 65,000 LITTLE BYTH TURRIFF RYDEN LLP A

17 83751/55364 WIND FARM 4 L ENERGY T 65,000 65,000 LITTLE BYTH NEW BYTH TURRIFF RYDEN LLP A

18 87813/52563 WIND TURBINE CULVIE WIND LTD P 35,000 35,000 NEWTON OF CULVIE

19 88624/52558 WIND TURBINE CULVIE HILL WIND LTD T 35,000 35,000 CULVIE HILL ABERCHIRDER HUNTLY

21 89093/60808 SPORTS CENTRE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 141,000 141,000 MACDUFF COMMUNITY & SPORTS CENTRE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES DUFF STREET MACDUFF RYDEN LLP A

24/11/2020 Page 5 of 10 CASES CONTINUED FROM 02/09/2020 HEARING

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

37 48622/52544 WIND FARM WIND ENERGY LTD T 510,000 510,000 BOYNDIE AIRFIELD BOYNDIE BANFF GERALD EVE LLP A

38 84058/58703 WIND FARM MUIRAKE WIND FARM LTD T 110,000 110,000 MUIRAKE FARM PER VENTO LUDENS LTD CORNHILL BANFF GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

39 86867/58341 WIND TURBINE AURA WIND (BADENTOUL) LTD T 35,000 35,000 BADENTOUL PER AG RENEWABLES FORDYCE BANFF DUNLOP HEYWOOD A

40 88621/52557 WIND TURBINE BRAESIDE WIND LTD T 35,000 35,000 BRAESIDE FORDYCE BANFF

46 88018/52562 WIND TURBINE ASHOGLE WIND LIMITED P 33,500 33,500 ASHOGLE PER MUIRDEN ENERGY TURRIFF

47 87952/52513 WIND FARM ANDREW RENNIE P 27,750 27,750 GASK TURRIFF DAVIDSON & ROBERTSON A

48 86773/56331 WIND TURBINE A & V RENEWABLES LTD P 35,000 35,000 HOSPITAL WOOD TURRIFF RYDEN LLP A

49 86700/53346 WIND FARM HILTON GREEN ENERGY LTD T 49,750 49,750 LITTLE HILTON TURRIFF WYMRE A

50 87979/53372 RADIO STATION HILTON GREEN ENERGY LTD T 9,500 9,500 LITTLE HILTON TURRIFF WYMRE A

51 86772/52569 WIND TURBINE LITTLE WHITERASHES RENEWABLES LLP T 35,000 35,000 LITTLE WHITERASHES TURRIFF

52 90009/56780 WIND FARM CWE NW3 LTD T 27,750 27,750 UPPER MAINS OF MUIRESK TURRIFF

53 86771/52564 WIND TURBINE WRAE FARM RENEWABLES LLP T 35,000 35,000 WRAE TURRIFF

60 11859/62291 SLAUGHTERHOUSE NEEROCK LTD P 270,000 270,000 MARKETHILL ROAD T/A WOODHEAD BROTHERS TURRIFF TURRIFF GL HEARN LIMITED A

24/11/2020 Page 6 of 10 CASES CONTINUED FROM 02/09/2020 HEARING

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

61 34785/59876 SPORTS CENTRE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 91,500 91,500 QUEEN'S ROAD PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES TURRIFF RYDEN LLP A

62 11912/59880 LEISURE CENTRE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 60,000 60,000 POOL AND COMMUNITY CENTRE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES VICTORIA TERRACE TURRIFF RYDEN LLP A

63 85327/54872 WIND FARM GORDONSTOWN HILL WIND FARM LTD T 320,000 320,000 GORDONSTOWN HILL PER INFINIS AUCHTERLESS TURRIFF GERALD EVE LLP A

64 33971/55372 QUARRY LOVIE LTD P 3,200 3,200 KNAPPS OF THERNIE 19,000 M 9,500 AUCHTERLESS TURRIFF RYDEN LLP A

65 88626/52559 WIND TURBINE ND WIND LLP T 32,500 32,500 NETHER DARLEY AUCHTERLESS TURRIFF

66 88639/53390 WIND TURBINE BLAIRWIND RENEWABLES LTD T 33,500 33,500 BLAIRFOWL TURRIFF WYMRE A

67 85192/64167 WIND TURBINE H P SLEIGH & SON P 20,000 20,000 CROMLET FARM ST KATHERINES

68 83750/52516 WIND TURBINE KEITHFIELD ENERGY LTD T 58,500 58,500 DENHILL ST KATHERINES INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

69 87949/53383 WIND TURBINE CAMWIND RENEWABLES T 31,500 31,500 MEIKLE CAMALOUN FYVIE TURRIFF WYMRE A

70 87950/52524 WIND TURBINE JAMM POWER LTD T 31,500 31,500 SOUTH CAMALOUN FYVIE TURRIFF RYDEN LLP A

71 83089/63570 WIND TURBINE TETRO ENERGY LTD T 32,000 32,000 COWHILL INVERURIE

72 86664/62895 WIND TURBINE CRUICKSHANK ENERGY (WESTERTON) LTD T 35,000 35,000 WESTERTON OF FOLLA MEIKLE WARTLE INVERURIE

73 86857/56462 WIND TURBINE BURNSIDE WIND LTD T 13,750 13,750 BURNSIDE FORTRIE TURRIFF GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

24/11/2020 Page 7 of 10 CASES CONTINUED FROM 02/09/2020 HEARING

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

74 88595/52560 WIND TURBINE BALNOON WIND LTD P 33,500 33,500 NORTH BALNOON FORGUE HUNTLY

75 86821/57337 WIND FARM CLOFFRICKFORD RENEWABLE T 162,000 162,000 CLOFFRICKFORD, SKILMAFILLY & DENMORE ENERGY CO LTD AUCHNAGATT PER DAVID SMITH ELLON RYDEN LLP A

76 88038/58299 WIND TURBINE BIRNIE GOWKHILL ENERGY LTD T 33,500 33,500 EAST GOWKHILL MAUD PETERHEAD

77 84494/62839 WIND TURBINE GREENHILL RENEWABLES LTD P 66,000 66,000 GREENHILL CROFT BONNYKELLY DUNLOP HEYWOOD A FRASERBURGH

78 87925/52567 WIND FARM SOUTH NITTANSHEAD RENEWABLES LLP P 27,750 27,750 SOUTH NITTANSHEAD NEW PITSLIGO FRASERBURGH

79 87192/58395 WIND TURBINE THRIVE RENEWABLES (AUCHTYGILLS) LTD T 32,000 32,000 AUCHTYGILLS C/O THRIVE RENEWABLES PLC FRASERBURGH DUNLOP HEYWOOD A

80 87196/58396 WIND TURBINE THRIVE RENEWABLES (CLAYFORDS) LTD T 32,000 32,000 CLAYFORDS C/O THRIVE RENEWABLES PLC STRICHEN FRASERBURGH DUNLOP HEYWOOD A

81 86581/64404 WIND TURBINE J & S ANDERSON P 6,600 6,600 MOSS-SIDE BOGENSOURIE STRICHEN FRASERBURGH

82 83088/58295 WIND TURBINE ABERDEEN & NORTHERN EGGS LTD P 31,500 31,500 WEST COCKMUIR STRICHEN FRASERBURGH GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

83 89063/56785 WIND TURBINE CWE NW3 LTD T 13,750 13,750 LITTLE ELRICK MAUD PETERHEAD

84 84010/66641 WIND FARM WIND POWER LTD P 69,000 69,000 WEST KNOCK FARM STUARTFIELD PETERHEAD

89 85934/62630 PRISON SCOTTISH PRISON SERVICE P 1,560,000 1,560,000 HMP & YOI GRAMPIAN SOUTH ROAD PETERHEAD MONTAGU EVANS A

91 87665/62629 SUPPORT CENTRE SCOTTISH PRISON SERVICE P 39,750 39,750 FAMILY CENTRE & HELP HUB HMI & YOI GRAMPIAN SOUTH ROAD MONTAGU EVANS A PETERHEAD

24/11/2020 Page 8 of 10 CASES CONTINUED FROM 02/09/2020 HEARING

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

96 86775/70319 OFFSHORE OIL SUPPORT BASE NORSEA GROUP (UK) LTD T 790,000 790,000 SMITH QUAY BATH STREET PETERHEAD WYMRE A

98 13550/67671 BINGO HALL SAVA ESTATES LIMITED P 21,500 21,500 63 MARISCHAL STREET PETERHEAD WHITELAW BAIKIE FIGES A

110 14441/53379 BINGO HALL CARLTON CLUBS LTD P 23,750 23,750 CARLTON CLUB FRASERBURGH MID STREET FRASERBURGH WYMRE A

118 84914/61346 SPORTS CENTRE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 365,000 365,000 FRASERBURGH COMMUNITY AND SPORTS CENTRE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES MACONOCHIE PLACE FRASERBURGH RYDEN LLP A

121 10685/55365 GRAVEL PIT LOVIE LTD P 7,600 7,600 HOWE OF BYTH 21,750 M 10,875 NEW BYTH TURRIFF RYDEN LLP A

122 85846/64405 WIND TURBINE J & S ANDERSON P 10,250 10,250 MILL OF AUCHLIN NEW ABERDOUR FRASERBURGH

123 14876/55369 SANDPIT LOVIE LTD T 4,250 4,250 BROOMHEAD 22,000 M 11,000 FRASERBURGH RYDEN LLP A

125 34854/55373 QUARRY LOVIE LTD P 106,000 106,000 QUARRY 48,000 M 24,000 BODYCHELL FARM MEMSIE RYDEN LLP A FRASERBURGH

126 89893/58294 WIND TURBINE CORTES RENEWABLES LTD T 33,500 33,500 CORTES GARDENS LONMAY FRASERBURGH GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

127 83091/53877 WIND FARM HOUSE O HILL WIND ENERGY LTD T 71,500 71,500 HOUSE O HILL PER GREENCAT RENEWABLES LTD FRASERBURGH GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

130 15076/55363 SANDPIT LOVIE LTD P 24,750 24,750 BLACKHILLS 38,000 M 19,000 TYRIE RYDEN LLP A

135 87125/52587 WIND FARM TEUCHAN WIND LTD T 29,000 29,000 BRACO FARM HATTON PETERHEAD GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

136 95301/70121 WAREHOUSE SCOTT DIRECT (PETERHEAD) LTD T 16,250 16,250 UNIT 2A SANDFORD BUSINESS PARK INVERNETTIE WYMRE A PETERHEAD

24/11/2020 Page 9 of 10 CASES CONTINUED FROM 02/09/2020 HEARING

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

137 15301/53391 QUARRY BREEDON AGGREGATES SCOTLAND LTD P 60,000 60,000 STIRLINGHILL 39,500 M 19,750 BODDAM GERALD EVE LLP A

141 85657/58296 WIND TURBINE R & R RENEWABLES LLP T 21,750 21,750 AUCHMORE LONMAY FRASERBURGH GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

142 88152/52681 WIND TURBINE DRUMS WIND LTD T 35,000 35,000 INVERQUHOMERY WIND TURBINE 2 (NW) INVERQUHOMERY & LONGSIDE

143 87921/52678 WIND TURBINE FF ENERGY LLP T 35,000 35,000 TURBINE 1 (SE) INVERQUHOMERY LONGSIDE PETERHEAD

145 82432/53376 WIND TURBINE BRUXIEHILL WIND ENERGY LTD T 32,000 32,000 BRUXIEHILL PETERHEAD WYMRE A

146 84014/53378 WIND FARM EDNIE WIND ENERGY LTD T 47,750 47,750 EDNIE FARM ST FERGUS PETERHEAD WYMRE A

147 85198/63572 WIND FARM GREENSPAN ELECTRIC ST FERGUS LTD T 153,000 153,000 ST FERGUS MOSS FRASERBURGH GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

148 85798/53377 WIND FARM GWEL OPERATING COMPANY LTD T 230,000 230,000 GREENSIDE WIND FARM OVERSIDE ST FERGUS WYMRE A PETERHEAD

24/11/2020 Page 10 of 10