APPENDIX A ACCDC Short List of Species of Conservation

CBCL Limited Appendices ACCDC Short List of Species Conservation Concern (25 km) Freq NSDNR General MinDist Habitat (*LFP = Larval Most No. Scientific Name Common Name NPROT SRANK SPROT w/i Status (km) foodplant) Recent 25 Plants 1 Polygala sanguinea Blood Milkwort S2S3 YELLOW -5 meadows, fields and glades 4 1995 2 tenera Tender Sedge S1S2 YELLOW -2 meadows, woodlands, and 2 2002 moist, dry openings 3 Lobelia spicata Pale-Spiked Lobelia S1 RED 0 dry fields 3 1954 4 Fraxinus nigra Black Ash S2S3 YELLOW 1 Low ground, damp woods and 11 2008 swamps. 5 Polygonum arifolium Halberd-leaved Tearthumb S2 YELLOW 1 thickets, marshy borders, 3 2006 usually near/under alders. Flourishes in rich, alluvial soil.

6 Carex lupulina Hop Sedge S3 GREEN 2 mucky meadows along 1 2006 intervales, swales, and wet, deciduous or treed swamps 7 Hedeoma pulegioides American False Pennyroyal S2S3 YELLOW 2 stony soils and upland pastures, 3 1997 occasionally near seashores

8 Carex tuckermanii Tuckerman's Sedge S1 RED 4 swales 4 1993 9 Polygonum scandens Climbing False Buckwheat S3 YELLOW 8 Low alluvial thickets along river 7 2007 intervales. 10 Campanula Marsh Bellflower S3 YELLOW 10 Meadows, ditches and river 3 2007 aparinoides banks. 11 Carex pellita Woolly Sedge S1 RED 10 wet meadows and fields, swales 1 2007 and seeps 12 Lilium canadense Canada Lily S2S3 YELLOW 10 In meadows and stream banks 3 2007

13 Liparis loeselii Loesel's Twayblade S3S4 GREEN 12 rich coniferous forests, swamp 1 1954 edge, bogs, wet pastures, moist forest, swales, fields, boggy roadside ditches.

14 Myriophyllum Farwell's Water Milfoil S2 YELLOW 12 Ponds and slow-moving 1 1989 farwellii streams. 15 Sparganium natans Small Burreed S3 GREEN 14 bays, pools ditches, peat bogs 2 2003 ACCDC Short List of Species Conservation Concern (25 km) Freq NSDNR General MinDist Habitat (*LFP = Larval Most No. Scientific Name Common Name NPROT SRANK SPROT w/i Status (km) foodplant) Recent 25 16 Cypripedium Ram's-Head Lady's-Slipper S1 Endangered RED 15 gypsum sinkholes, areas with 1 2002 arietinum gypsum 17 Proserpinaca palustris Marsh Mermaidweed S3 GREEN 15 boggy swales, wet marshes, and 1 2001 var. crebra the edges of streams 18 Potamogeton Blunt-leaved Pondweed S2S3 YELLOW 16 ponds, lakes, slow-moving 3 2007 obtusifolius streams, often on substrate of deep muck 19 Potamogeton White-stemmed Pondweed S3? UNDETERMINED 16 usually in deep water 1 2003 praelongus 20 Agrimonia Hooked Agrimony S3 GREEN 17 mesic to moist edges of forests 3 2003 gryposepala and woods, deciduous or mixed woodlands, tickets, clearings in forests, streams, marshes, bogs, low meadows, roadsides and pastures

21 Asclepias incarnata Swamp Milkweed S3 GREEN 18 wet or rocky thickets, usually 1 2003 near a stream or lakeshore

22 Equisetum scirpoides Dwarf Scouring-Rush S3S4 GREEN 18 moist thickets, mossy knolls, 1 1954 spring banks, coniferous forests.

23 Polygonum Pennsylvania Smartweed S3 GREEN 20 wet to moist, disturbed sites, 2 2003 pensylvanicum rich soil 24 Rudbeckia laciniata Cut-Leaved Coneflower S2 YELLOW 20 Swales, the edges of swamps, or 1 2002 var. gaspereauensis in gullies - in small colonies.

25 Carex bebbii Bebb's Sedge S1S2 RED 20 northern alkaline regions in 1 2003 poorly drained soils 26 Rhamnus alnifolia Alder-leaved Buckthorn S3 YELLOW 20 swampy woods and boggy 2 2003 meadows 27 Elymus wiegandii Wiegand's Wild Rye S1 RED 21 streambanks and meadows 2 2006 28 Sisyrinchium Narrow-leaved Blue-eyed- S3S4 GREEN 21 fields, meadows, open woods 1 2002 angustifolium grass and roadsides ACCDC Short List of Species Conservation Concern (25 km) Freq NSDNR General MinDist Habitat (*LFP = Larval Most No. Scientific Name Common Name NPROT SRANK SPROT w/i Status (km) foodplant) Recent 25 29 Anemone Wood Anemone S2 YELLOW 21 wooded riverbanks and shaded 1 2003 quinquefolia intervales 30 Megalodonta beckii Water Beggarticks S3 YELLOW 21 still or slow-moving water or 1 1954 lakes, streams, rivers and brooks

31 Carex adusta Lesser Brown Sedge S2S3 YELLOW 22 dry, open woods, gravels, rocks, 1 2003 and clearings. Often in acidic soils 32 Ranunculus Pennsylvania Buttercup S1 RED 22 wet meadows, moist clearings, 2 2003 pensylvanicus ditches, bogs, depressions in woodlands 33 Amelanchier fernaldii Fernald's Serviceberry S2? UNDETERMINED 23 riparian, scrub-shrub wetlands, 1 1956 barrens, shrubland/chaparral, shores, ravines.

34 Carex atlantica ssp. Atlantic Sedge S2 GREEN 24 swamps, bogs and peaty barrens 1 1992 capillacea 35 Hypericum Disguised St John's-wort S2S3 YELLOW 24 On shores and damp open 2 2001 dissimulatum areas. 36 Salix petiolaris Meadow Willow S3 GREEN 25 bog margin, roadsides, wet 1 2001 meadow, dry field, riverside in tall meadow, marshy ground.

Birds 1 Bucephala clangula Common Goldeneye S2B, GREEN -3 Breeds along wooded rivers and 8 2007 S5N lakes, Winters in marine waters

2 Mergus serrator Red-breasted Merganser S3B, GREEN -3 Breeds near water's edge, 8 2008 S5N prefers marine waters 3 Anas acuta Northern Pintail S2B GREEN 0 Breeds in shallow, seasonal 3 1989 wetlands, marshes. Winters in shallow water, tidal waters ACCDC Short List of Species Conservation Concern (25 km) Freq NSDNR General MinDist Habitat (*LFP = Larval Most No. Scientific Name Common Name NPROT SRANK SPROT w/i Status (km) foodplant) Recent 25 4 Dolichonyx oryzivorus Bobolink T S3S4B YELLOW 0 Breeds in open grasslands. In 30 2008 migration uses marshes, grasslands 5 Rallus limicola Virginia Rail S2B GREEN 0 Breeds mainly in freshwater 7 2008 marshes w/ abundant emergent vegetation 6 Charadrius Semipalmated Plover S1S2B, GREEN 1 Breeds along shorelines 7 2006 semipalmatus S5M 7 Icterus galbula Baltimore Oriole S2S3B GREEN 3 Breeds in open, deciduous 3 2007 woodland 8 Sterna hirundo Common Tern NAR S3B YELLOW 3 Breeds on islands and in 8 2008 marshes 9 Asio flammeus Short-eared Owl SC S1S2 YELLOW 4 Open country, including prairie, 2 2001 meadows, tundra, moorlands, marshes, savanna, and open woodland. Ground nester

10 Bucephala islandica Barrow's Goldeneye SC S1N YELLOW 5 Breeds along wooded rivers and 1 1996 (Eastern pop.) (Eastern pop.) lakes, Winters in marine waters

11 Coccyzus Black-billed Cuckoo S3?B GREEN 9 deciduous woodlands, and 6 2008 erythropthalmus thickets, including aspen, poplar, birch, sugar maple, hickory, hawthorn, and willow

12 Accipiter gentilis Northern Goshawk NAR S3S4 YELLOW 9 Breeds in mature forests 4 2008 13 Anas clypeata Northern Shoveler S2B GREEN 9 Breeds in open, shallow 2 2008 wetlands. In winter, inhabits both freshwater and saline marshes 14 Mimus polyglottos Northern Mockingbird S3B GREEN 9 open ground and with shrubby 2 1996 vegetation like hedges, fruiting bushes, and thickets. ACCDC Short List of Species Conservation Concern (25 km) Freq NSDNR General MinDist Habitat (*LFP = Larval Most No. Scientific Name Common Name NPROT SRANK SPROT w/i Status (km) foodplant) Recent 25 15 Myiarchus crinitus Great Crested Flycatcher S2B GREEN 9 Breeds in open deciduous 1 1988 woodlands, riparian corridors, wooded swamps, and urban areas with large shade trees. Cavity nester 16 Pooecetes gramineus Vesper Sparrow S2S3B YELLOW 9 open habitats with grass, 4 2007 including meadows, pastures, and roadsides. 17 Sayornis phoebe Eastern Phoebe S3S4B GREEN 9 woodlands and along forest 8 2008 edges, often near water 18 Sialia sialis Eastern Bluebird NAR S3B YELLOW 9 open country around trees, but 1 ? with little understory and sparse ground cover. Original habitats probably included open, frequently burned pine savannas, beaver ponds, mature but open woods, and forest openings. Today, they’re most common along pastures, agricultural fields, suburban parks, backyards, and golf courses. 19 Euphagus carolinus Rusty Blackbird SC S2S3B YELLOW 10 Breeds in wet forests, including 5 2008 areas with fens, bogs, muskeg, and beaver ponds. Winters in swamps, wet woodlands, and pond edges.

20 Toxostoma rufum Brown Thrasher S1?B GREEN 11 Breeds in brushy open country, 1 2006 thickets, shelter belts, riparian areas, and suburbs. Scrubland

21 Anas strepera Gadwall S2B GREEN 13 Marshes 1 2008 ACCDC Short List of Species Conservation Concern (25 km) Freq NSDNR General MinDist Habitat (*LFP = Larval Most No. Scientific Name Common Name NPROT SRANK SPROT w/i Status (km) foodplant) Recent 25 22 Catharus bicknelli Bicknell's Thrush T S1S2B Vulnerable YELLOW 13 montane fir and spruce forests, 1 1986 usually associated with recently disturbed areas.

23 Tringa melanoleuca Greater Yellowlegs S3B, GREEN 13 Breeds in muskeg, wet bogs 1 1986 S5M with small wooded islands, and forests (usually coniferous) with abundant clearings. Winters in wide variety of shallow fresh and saltwater habitats.

24 Tringa solitaria Solitary Sandpiper S1?B, GREEN 16 Breeds in taiga, nesting in trees 1 2001 S4S5M in deserted songbird nests. In migration and winter found along freshwater ponds, stream edges, temporary pools, flooded ditches and fields, more commonly in wooded regions, less frequently on mudflats and open marshes. 25 Progne subis Purple Martin S1B RED 17 Breeds near water and large 1 1987 open areas, cavity nester 26 Caprimulgus vociferus Whip-Poor-Will T S1?B GREEN 17 Breeds in deciduous or mixed 1 1990 forests with little or no underbrush. Winters in mixed woods near open areas.

27 Gallinula chloropus Common Moorhen S1B GREEN 18 Freshwater or brackish marshes 4 1988 with tall emergent vegetation, ponds 28 Branta bernicla Atlantic Brant S2S3M, YELLOW 19 marshes 1 1967 S2S3N ACCDC Short List of Species Conservation Concern (25 km) Freq NSDNR General MinDist Habitat (*LFP = Larval Most No. Scientific Name Common Name NPROT SRANK SPROT w/i Status (km) foodplant) Recent 25 29 Asio otus Long-eared Owl S2 GREEN 22 Dense vegetation adjacent to 1 2006 open grassland or shrubland, and open forests. Fish 1 Salmo salar Atlantic Salmon S2 RED -5 5 ? Invertebrates 1 Nymphalis milberti Milbert's Tortoiseshell S2 GREEN 0 Wet areas near woods. LFP: 3 2006 Stinginf Nettle, Utrica spp. 2 Lycaena dospassosi Salt Marsh Copper S2 UNDETERMINED 5 Salt marshes. LFP: Silverweed 6 2008 Potentilla egedii. 3 Danaus plexippus Monarch SC S2B YELLOW 9 Anywhere during the spring 1 2006 (northward) migration; near the larval foodplants during the breeding season; in the fall commonly near the coast, often in large numbers, all heading south. LFP: Common Milkweed (Asclepias syriaca) and Swamp Milkweed (A. incarnata)

4 Lampsilis radiata Eastern Lampmussel S2 GREEN 13 inhabits streams, rivers, ponds, 7 2002 and lakes, where it is usually quite common. It can be found in a variety of substrates but prefers sand and gravel.

5 Alasmidonta varicosa Brook Floater SC S1S2 YELLOW 14 clean water in gravel or sand 2 2002 substrates in riffles of creeks and small rivers 6 Epitheca princeps Prince Baskettail S2 YELLOW 16 along ponds lakes and rivers 2 2002 7 Williamsonia fletcheri Ebony Boghaunter S1 RED 16 sphagnum bog and swamps, 1 2002 often with open water, adjacent coniferous or mixed woodlands ACCDC Short List of Species Conservation Concern (25 km) Freq NSDNR General MinDist Habitat (*LFP = Larval Most No. Scientific Name Common Name NPROT SRANK SPROT w/i Status (km) foodplant) Recent 25 8 Somatochlora Delicate Emerald S1 UNDETERMINED 17 found in sedge- and moss-filled 1 1997 franklini fens, at the foot of hillsides below seepage or in wide-open meadows. It is not usually encountered near open water. Adult males fly through stretches of tall grasses, sedges, and shrubs 9 Gomphus descriptus Harpoon Clubtail S2 YELLOW 18 inhabits clean rivers and 2 1993 streams, often near gravel bars.

10 Aeshna constricta Lance-Tipped Darner S3 UNDETERMINED 21 marshy ponds and streams and 1 1993 often among the vegetation of seasonal ponds.

11 Boyeria grafiana Ocellated Darner S3 UNDETERMINED 21 found along rocky, small to 1 1994 medium, fast moving streams, but also found patrolling ponds and lakes 12 Lanthus parvulus Northern Pygmy Clubtail S3 YELLOW 21 along rocky streams adjacent 1 1993 forest 13 Ophiogomphus Riffle Snaketail S3 GREEN 21 clear, cold,and rocky streams 2 1997 carolus that are fast flowing with relatively few pools. Subrate must be fine gravel or sand in which nymphs of the species can burrow 14 anthedon Northern Pearly-Eye S3 GREEN 23 Moist, grassy places in woods. 2 1994 LFP: Woodland grasses, including Bearded Shortgrass ( erectum), and False Melic Grass ( purpurascens) (Layberry) ACCDC Short List of Species Conservation Concern (25 km) Freq NSDNR General MinDist Habitat (*LFP = Larval Most No. Scientific Name Common Name NPROT SRANK SPROT w/i Status (km) foodplant) Recent 25 15 Hesperia comma Laurentian Skipper S3 GREEN 23 Grassy meadows, fields, 1 1984 laurentina roadsides. LFP: Perennial grasses and sedges (Opler) 16 Ophiogomphus Brook Snaketail S1 RED 25 clear, sand-bottomed streams 1 1996 aspersus with intermittent rapids, often through dense woodlands

17 Strophitus undulatus Creeper S1 RED 25 shallow water in both small 1 2001 streams and large rivers. It inhabits a variety of substrates, from silt to boulder fields

Herpetofauna 1 Glyptemys insculpta Wood Turtle T S3 Vulnerable YELLOW 8 Clear, moderately moving rivers, 6 2004 tributaries and streams in forests or floodplains

2 Hemidactylium Four-toed Salamander NAR S3 GREEN 18 moist mossy woods, particularly 1 1993 scutatum in peat moss. Peat bogs or mossy areas bordering streams

Source: Based on ACCDC Report 4613 Pugwash, Nova Scotia, Ocotober 20, 2011. Species of Conservation Concern: Rankings Explained

Definitions of Rarity Rankings Species at Risk Act - COSEWIC Ranks Endangered A species facing imminent extirpation or extinction Threatened A species likely to become endangered if limited factors are not reversed Special Concern A species of concern because of characteristics that make it particularly sensitive to human activities or natural events. NS Endangered Species Act Endangered A species that faces imminent extinction or extirpation and it listed as an endangered species pursuant to Section 12 Threatened A species that is likely to become endangered if the factors affecting its vulnerability are not reversed and is listed as a threatened species pursuant to section 12 Vulnerable A species of special concern due to characteristics that make it particularly sensitive to human activities or natural events and that is listed as a vulnerable species pursuant to section 12 ACCDC Definitions (http://www.accdc.com/glossary.html) GRANK Global rarity rank of species, using CDC/NatureServe methods NPROT National conservation status of species, as designated by COSEWIC SRANK Sub-national rarity rank of species, using CDC/NatureServe methods SPROT Sub-national conservation status of species, as designated by given provincial jurisdiction T or Threatened Used by COSEWIC to refer to a species that is likely to become endangered if limiting factors are not reversed SC or Special Concern A term used by COSEWIC to identify species that are particularly sensitive to human activities or natural events but are not endangered or threatened. NAR or Not At Risk A term used by COSEWIC for a species that is unlikely to become extinct or extirpated. Endangered A term used generally and by COSEWIC to refer to a species facing imminent extinction. Extinct A species that no longer exists. Extirpated A species that no longer exists, where it existed previously, in the wild. ACCDC SRANK Definitions S1 Extremely rare throughout its range in the province (typically five or fewer occurrences or very few remaining individuals). May be especially vulnerable to extirpation. S2 Rare throughout its range in the province (six to 20 occurrences or few remaining individuals). May be vulnerable to extirpation due to rarity or other factors. S3 Uncommon throughout its range in the province, or found only in a restricted range, even if abundant at some locations (21 to 100 occurrences). S4 Usually widespread, fairly common throughout its range in the province, and apparently secure with many occurrences, but the species is of long-term concern, e.g., watch list (100+ occurrences). SU Unrankable: Possibly in peril throughout its range in the province, but status uncertain: need more information. Used for new species not previously identified. SX Extinct/Extirpated: Believed to be extirpated within the province. S#S# Numeric range rank: A range between two consecutive numeric ranks. Denotes uncertainty about the exact rarity of the species, e.g., S1S2. ? In exact or uncertain: For numeric ranks, denotes uncertainty, e.g., SE? denotes uncertainty of exotic status. NSDNR General Status Ranks Undetermined Species for which insufficient data, information or knowledge is available or reliably evaluate their status. Blue No longer in Nova Scotia or extinct in the wild. Red Known to be or is thought to be at risk. Yellow Sensitive. Species that are not believed to be at risk of immediate extirpation or extinction but which may require special attention or protection to prevent them from becoming at risk. Green Secure. Species that are not believed to be at risk or sensitive. This category includes some species that have declined in numbers but remain relatively widespread or abundant.

Interpreting USDA Wetland Indicator Status: Sourced directly from USDA Natural Resource Conservation Service at http://plants.usda.gov/wetinfo.html

Indicator Categories

Indicator Wetland Type Comment Code OBL Obligate Wetland Occurs almost always (estimated probability 99%) under natural conditions in wetlands. FACW Facultative Wetland Usually occurs in wetlands (estimated probability 67%-99%), but occasionally found in non-wetlands. FAC Facultative Equally likely to occur in wetlands or non-wetlands (estimated probability 34%- 66%). FACU Facultative Upland Usually occurs in non-wetlands (estimated probability 67%-99%), but occasionally found on wetlands (estimated probability 1%-33%). UPL Obligate Upland Occurs in wetlands in another region, but occurs almost always (estimated probability 99%) under natural conditions in non-wetlands in the regions specified. If a species does not occur in wetlands in any region, it is not on the National List. NA No agreement The regional panel was not able to reach a unanimous decision on this species. NI No indicator Insufficient information was available to determine an indicator status. NO No occurrence The species does not occur in that region.

National Indicators reflect the range of estimated probabilities (expressed as a frequency of occurrence) of a species occurring in wetlands versus non-wetland across the entire distribution of the species. A frequency, for example, of 67%-99% (Facultative Wetland) means that 67%-99% of sample plots containing the species randomly selected across the range of the species would be wetland. When two indicators are given, they reflect the range from the lowest to the highest frequency of occurrence in wetlands across the regions in which the species is found. A positive (+) or negative (-) sign was used with the Facultative Indicator categories to more specifically define the regional frequency of occurrence in wetlands. The positive sign indicates a frequency toward the higher end of the category (more frequently found in wetlands), and a negative sign indicates a frequency toward the lower end of the category (less frequently found in wetlands). A question mark (?) following a National Indicator denotes a tentative assignment based on the botanical literature and not confirmed by regional review.

Regional Indicators express the estimated probability (likelihood) of a species occurring in wetlands versus non-wetlands in the region. Regional Indicators reflect the unanimous agreement of the Regional Interagency Review Panel. An asterisk (*) following a regional Indicator identifies tentative assignments based on limited information from which to determine the indicator status.

The wetland indicator categories should not be equated to degrees of wetness. Many obligate wetland species occur in permanently or semi-permanently flooded wetlands, but a number of obligates also occur in and some are restricted to wetlands which are only temporarily or seasonally flooded. The facultative upland species include a diverse collection of plants, which range from weedy species adapted to exist in a number of environmentally stressful or disturbed sites (including wetlands), to species in which a portion of the gene pool (an ecotype) always occurs in wetlands. Both the weedy and ecotype representatives of the facultative upland category occur in seasonally and semi-permanently flooded wetlands. APPENDIX B Archaeological Resource Impact Assessment

CBCL Limited Appendices

PUGWASH WIND FARM: ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESOURCE IMPACT ASSESSMENT

Heritage Research Permit A2011NS108

January 2012

Submitted to: CBCL Ltd. 1489 Hollis Street PO Box 606 Halifax, Nova Scotia B3J 2R7

DAVISDAVIS MACINTYREMACINTYRE & ASSOCIATESASSOCIATES LIMITEDLIMITED 109 John Stewart Drive,Drive, Dartmouth,Dartmouth, NS B2W 4J74J7

PUGWASH WIND FARM: ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESOURCE IMPACT ASSESSMENT

Heritage Research Permit A2011NS108 Category C

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Project No.: 11-035.1CBH

Principal Investigator: Stephen A. Davis Report Compiled by: Laura A. de Boer, April D. MacIntyre & Stephen A. Davis

Cover: The largest of the stone mounds between turbine sites WTG-3 and WTG-4.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

LIST OF FIGURES  LIST OF PLATES  1.0 INTRODUCTION  2.0 STUDY AREA 3.0 METHODOLOGY 3.1 PREDICTIVE MODELING1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111< 3.2 MARITIME ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESOURCE INVENTORY 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111= 3.3 HISTORICAL BACKGROUND111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111> 3.4 FIELD RECONNAISSANCE – ORIGINAL (FALL 2011) LAYOUT111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111A 4.4 FIELD RECONNAISSANCE – REVISED (DECEMBER 2011) LAYOUT 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111 9; 4.0 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION   5.0 RECOMMENDATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS   6.0 REFERENCES CITED  PLATES  APPENDIX A: HERITAGE RESEARCH PERMITAND AMENDMENT LETTER  

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

i LIST OF FIGURES  (%:18290:899"%! '(%!!&&%" ,"('1"(%'&,  '1 : (%:182:0:899%)&4 %5'(%!!&&%" ,"('1"(%'&,   '11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111; (%;1;290' "!9@8= #,#(',(%),"%" &"&"*! "'& "('%"(!(*&&!1 !"!'!"%'&'&"'&!*& "% % ,%&%)"%' 6 $111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111? (%;1;2:0' " %"&(%3&9@?; #"( % !"(!',/&"*! "(#'"!!%'&'(,%*&  ''"' !!#%"+ ','" %&'"*!"!  %"1 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111@ (%;1;2;09A8=" " &(%), #*''"%! '(%!&'&/&& %"&/! #'*,&")% 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111A  

LIST OF PLATES   '90%" "&''#!)&&# ,&' %( %(&!"(!'%"!' #%"#"&&&'*!'(%!&29!2:11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 9A  ':0% ') ,"#!%''(%!&'2:1 ""!&"('11111111111111111111111111111 9A  ';0#%(&# !&!'%&"*!,*!''(%!&'2;1 1111111111111111 :8  '<0 %&'&'"! "(! "!'&&%"'*!'(%!&2; !20(%!&'2

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

ii  '@0!& %%"*'")%&'+&'!%"*,''#&&&'%"('(%! &'2?1 ""!&'11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 ::  'A0&' 2*'%"% , "& "*!&'% "!  %""1 "' ' "* ""# !"!'%!1 ""!&'1 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 :;  '980 ""!!"%'%"&&  %""'%"('%%1 "'' "&! "'%%&"% ! !'%"""!' '4*&'5111111111111111111111111111111111111111 :;  '990!"#! %2('%''(%!&'2A1 ""!*&'1 1111111111111111111111111 :<  '9:0&#%("%&'''(%!&'29:/ ""!!"%'&'1 11111111111111111111111111111 :<  '9;0&'"29/&"*!*!2 &#%("!!" 1 ""! "%'1 :=  '9<0(%!&'2;/ ""!&'%" !%'&  %""*"%%& '&'111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 :=  '9=0'2  '9>0'2A/&"*!&#%(*'&"  ( #&"%!'&'!1  !'#*&!"''"' '4&'5"% 1 ""!&"('111111111111111111111111 :>  '9?0(#'%"&&!"  %""/ ""!(#&'% "%&"('&'' '&"('&4%'5!' "*!%"(!"%'&4 '51 "'''  ! "& '"&)& !'% ) "*!&'% '"%' !"'%&' *'%!'"%%"(!111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 :?  '9@0(%!&'2991 ""!*&'1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 :? 

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

iii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

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

iv 1.0 INTRODUCTION  ! ") %:899/)&  !',%.&&"'&*&"!'%',  '1"!   " ' !' ! "*% "%#"%'"! !1 '" "!(' ! %" "  %&"(%  #' &&&& !' " ' #%"#"& (*& ! %  !( % ! "(!',1  #%"' *  ! ( ' "!&'%('"! "  *! %  "!&&'! " '(%!&/ && %"&/ ! '"!  &&"' !%&'%('(%1  * ) '(%!& %#%"#"&&* & "!!'"!&,&' !&(&''"!1  !%" " &'"#&'(,"') "# !'%*&"!(',)& %" "  "!&( '!'&  ' ! (! :88? (!% %' &% % ' :88? ;>!! ("!&( ''"!"&'"% #&/ !(&%#'&!#( & &"(%&&* &' %' %" " &"(% !)!'"%,1!+%&! #%') " ! *&  &" "!(' '"  # '% ! ' #"'!'  "% %&' '"!&%" " %&"(%&1 "'"!&"&" "''(%!&)! (&'&!':88?&'(,/ '"(',% "'*'!'& !%  %1  (&%" " %&"(%& ,)!%"%!'&'(,%&! ' :88? &&&& !'/ ' %'  %" "  &"(% !)!'"%, *& "!&( '!&#%'"'&&&&& !'1#%') " *& &"(#' '" % ' ' #"'!'  " %" "  %&"(%& *'! #%"#"&  #' %& ! ' #%)"(& %"(! &'(, *&  &" "!&% ! ' " '& (&' !'&! #'-"!&1     %"!!&&! " '  #' % ! (!   '* ) '(%!&/ && %"&/   "!!'"! &,&'  ! &(&''"! *& "!(' '" '% ! ' #"'!' "%%" " %&"(%&1  & &&&& !' *& "!(' (!% '"%,  %' &% % ' :899 98@&&(,' ")"'%')&"!1&%#"%'"!"% &'" '&'!%&%$(%,'%')&"!(!%'#  &%"''"! '1 

2.0 STUDY AREA  ) "# !'%& "'"!'&'&"(*&&!!&#!&' !"%'!&"('&&"' %&'"*!"1* )*!'(%!&*%"%! , #%"#"&"%') "# !'%!' ":8994(%:18295/ '%%)&'" !*# !"'* )#%"#"&&'&!'%'!' '%!')&'4(%:182:51  % & #%' " ' ") "'   "! !"*! & ' "%'( % !  !!&#%'"' "%'( % !'%'&(2!'47=:951 

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

1    !   !          Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

2 Pugwash Wind Farm Planned Matheson Cove Site Area

Pugwash Wind Farm Inc.

Proposed Turbine Locations 7 !( Proposed Turbine Locations 3 !( !( Proposed Road/Cable Layout Cable

4 Road !( NS Roads ALT 4 !( Paved Road 8 1 2 !( Unpaved Road !( !( 5 !( Lanes / Driveways ROAD ruin/inactive/abandoned 6 Cart Track / Footpath !( Property Boundary Rivers and Streams Wetlands

11 12 !( !( d. 9 wn R ishto !( 10 Ir !(

Turbine and Road/Cable Layout d. r R December 2011 lle Mi 0125 250 500 Meters

Rd . Coordinate System: NAD 1983 CSRS UTM Zone 20N Projection: Transverse Mercator ! Datum: North American 1983 CSRS False Easting: 500,000.0000 False Northing: 0.0000 Central Meridian: -63.0000 ! Scale Factor: 0.9996 Latitude Of Origin: 0.0000 Units: Meter 

!

   ! ! !            

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

3  &)+ ,$)#%+) +) &% * )+) 10#&.) *%-##0*#&% + &*+6 ) *!,+&,++&** #%**, *+,.* 6 -##0* &)$ )&,)* % %#+* #&% +  &*+6  ,  & +  ) &% # * %&)+  & +  ') $)0 .+)*  &,%)0 + +  **+* +  &(,  ##* ) &%6  &%)0 %+)+ )0.+)* *) %%&)+ + )&, #+)%+ %."%)* *+%+*+)+ *&+ ++ *+)$&,)** -!,*++&) %+ )&, + ."))&"+&&)$ +)## *) %'++)%*6 ))-)0.#"* %+ ) &%%' #-#*) %)##0#"# %6 &*+# % * )+) 10 %+)+ #$)* *%*,+ # #)***6  )&,)*% %#+*) )+) 10) & *'&%*% + #$)* *6 *& #* %+ ,.* )).##8) %*%0#&$+&*%0 #0#&$6 &)*+*)')&$ %%+#0 ).&&. + #"'),3 " %3  +'),3'),3%'# %+ $&*+&$$&%6   * ) &% *  * %  %+ $&,%+ & %&% )$#%6  &0&+3 $,*")+3 $ %"3%)&&%)*' *&$$&%#0*%%+ &*+#)*),%%+ % ) %'&',#+ &%*&,"*%$)*  )*3*')03##3#&-)3&$$&% )%3 )%*)3  ##+3 )) % ,##3 )+ #"8" ,##3 %  )'8+ # '))&.6    )&8. % ."3 )&.% )')3 &, 8# ."3 %&.0 .#3%%&.,%+ %&,) %+ &)*+%,'#%)*6)$8.+)*' * *, *&0*+)*%(, &*)&,%*.##6   * ) &% .* +) + &%##0 ,* 0 +   9"$( * *,$$) $'*%0  %* % +    +%+  %+,)0 . & +&&" -%+ & +  $)*  #%* &) )$ % % +  &*+# ) &% &) %$%+ % +   * )06  % +  % %+%+  %+,)03 %# *  % &++ *  *++#)* .) % % )$ %3  * %3 % &)*+)061  

3.0 METHODOLOGY   * $'+ ****$%+ %#,* &+  % ,'+ ")&,% *+,0 %   # )&%% **%6   DBBI *+&) # ")&,% *+,03 ') + - $&# %3 %  +*)*,#+* -##%)- * +%+  % %*)')*%+#&.6   # )&%% **% & +  ')&'&* $'+ )* .* #*& &%,+ +& +)$ %+ '&+%+ #&)) &#& #)*&,)*6  3.1 Predictive Modeling    ,.*  * % % +  **& + ) -)* % +) ,+) * ) # - +&  *, +# #&+ &%* &)  )*+ + &%* /'#& ++ &%6  #+ &,  + * %&. *'%% 0 $&)%)&%) #.0) *3+  & $ ##)&&"%+ + #'&&# %+&  C Davis and Browne, 1996:108-110. Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

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aritime Archaeological Resource Inventory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avis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

5 3.3 Historical Background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

)+#+),% 3#*&% +$' ) &0# *++ +)) - %CIJE3*++#&%+  .*+* &,.*  -),+  #+&''#0&)%&  #)%+%&% %,)0 CI3CJBF *FBB)*.).)+&+' %$% %/ %&)$%9* )%+&%+ *+* &+ ) -)6%CJBG$'0',+0,)-0&) &$*&  *+ ## % +* + + #%* .) *,)-0 &) +   9"$( &% +  %&)+  *  & ),% 9* )%+6  &.-)3 +  &$'%0 % %&++ &% *++* + ++ #%.* :&)$)#0# &,+&)+  % %*0)6,++#,+*$&*+&+ $)3&)#+ + ')&- %3 + %" +.&,#%#  #* +,+ &%&))6 ## $*2**& +*+& -+ )$ %)&+  )#%# &,+ % +7;= ,)E6E8C>6 

 DNova Scotia Archives and Records Management, 1967:565. ESmith, 1978:1. FClark, 1968; Brown 1922:120.  G)*"CKIJ5JK6 HSmith, 1978:2-8.  Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

6  %"5,5-3+$ 3:27 ) %$)%"&) " # # ' $#  %$" % %'##, $ "$#$# $#'#  "")"#"& "$ 1!,7

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oach, 1805. JSmith, 1978:9-11. KRG 20 Series A: Crane, James Noble & Crane, William.  Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

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

 %"5,5-4+$ " #%".#3:95  %" %$)*# ' % $ "$#$%)"'#$$ $ " ($)$ "#$ '  " ,34

 CBSmith, 1978:13-19; RG 20 Series A: Seaman, Stephen. CCSmith, 1978:71-79. CD ,) CJIE6 Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

8 

 %"5,5-5+3;27  #%"&) '$$ "$%"#$#*## " #* $')# &",35

   3.4 Field Reconnaissance – Original (Fall 2011) Layout    # )&%% **% & +  ')&'&* ** )&* % +,) % * +* .* &%,+0+' %- *% ,)&)&%&-$)J+ %K+ 3 DBCC6 #+ &, )* %+ #)**,))&,%+ *+,0)&%##* *3+ ')&'&* $'+ 1&%*.)&,%+&&%+ %*,)') * %#0# ++#- %&,#+,)#+ - +06    3+ "$# $ "34 " #'$%"## " &)  $,

            !"  "$%&%$ # #! !% &## !"%# #! &##   !""$$ "$%&& # # ##%$$!# !"%# #"#%    !"$%$ "$%!$ # # &! $ " !"%"% % "# ! !" "! "$%$& # # $&!%  !"%# $ #"

 CE Barlow, Ells and Fletcher, 1905 (Base map only; GIS data courtesy CBCL Ltd). Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

9 " !"%%% "$&  # #&% # $ !"%# & $! # !"%" "$%"&$ # #  "%&$"  !"%"& "$ %#  $ !"%&% "$$$%& # #&"#&!&% !"%"&%&%#$  % !" &" "$$&" # # % &!" !"%" !$ $  & !" & "$%$  # #!% ! !"%#"! &&&  !" $ "$%!  # #&# !$ !"%"$$ $   !" " "$%% ! # #" $$  !"%# % $$"   !" $ $ "$& "  # #%&! ""  !"%#"  !# %       ,) %* +8C *#&+ %$ /&)*+&0&,%*'),% ).&&*6  )&,% ,%,#+* - #03 %  )+ # & #) *+&%* ) ')*%+ &% +  *,)6   )& +.% +,) %* * +* C % D * %&+#3 * + +  + $ & +  *,)-0 +.*&*)-+ +#)% $#% *#&+#&%+ ')&'&*)& %+)# % ='')&/ $+#0 DB  FGBEHC GBIJKIF>6   % * % , %+&  :',* 8&,+;&)$&,%&)+ )+0,##&1)%))**0.&&*)&+ + +)%*+*+ *+,0)6 -% +** 1 + *# "#0+ ++ % *,*0)&) &0&+6&0&+*+.*%&+&%+ )**0)&+&+ .*+&+ %3%#) ,$),*.*%&+,%)%*+)&-)#**+ %FB$)&$+ %=#+C>6    *&% +,) % * + =8D> * '&* + &% %  $ / &)*+ &%* *+ % & ).&&*'# %*%*'),+ + *$+,)+& $+)*&,'+&FB$6  )&,%,%,#+* - #03%%#)*.$' *#&+ %#&*')&/ $ +0+&+  ')&'&*+,) %9*%+)#&&) %+*=#+D>6  ,) %* +8E *%+) %$ /&)*+&$+,)*'),' %3% ) 3 . + %,%)*+&)0&+ &)%*%*'),*'# %**.##*)+#&) * )&$#&.%8&.%+)*=#+E>6%+ -&.'*+,) *#&+ %#&*')&/ $ +0 +&+ ')&- &&) %+*3&,' ++ + $&+ )&%% **%. +  # &1% &#*+ %  )*6    ')&'&* ** )& +.% +,) % * +* 8E % 8F &%+ %* +  $&*+* %  %+ % %*%&,%+),) %+ * #)&%% **%6 )*+&% $&,%*.)%&,%+)&%#)"%&## %$+,)*'),&)*+=DBFGCCBG GBIJHFG4DBFGCBJDGBIJHEH4DBFGCBIFGBIJIBI>6 "%&## *-)0*$&&+  %#-#3 % + % +.*&%'#&, %,*&)'*+,)&)) ,#+,)6   *+&%$&,%*'')+&+ )*,#+& ##) %3%&%+ %*&$-)0 #)*+&%*3.  .&,# -+"%*-)#'&'#*&$&)++&$&-6%&+  #)*+ *+&%* .* &,% +& $*,) '')&/ $+#0 C$ / IB$ / FB$6 ## +  *+&%*- * # % $&,%.)&#&#*%*+&% %+ &$$&%)% &%0 &#&,)*6 

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

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avis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

11   )&&" +*# * #** + % +.& $+)* % . + 3 + &,   *#  + . % % % *+ ##.+) *%)+0*-)#+)+),%"*%&+ )&)*+) *&)$ % $ $$ +#0&.%*+)$=#+K>6#&.#&&'# % *&)$&% + )* 3 #- % - % & *+)&% **&%# #&& % % +  *++) +) +),%"* % )% *&,%+ )&, &,+6  *)-)&$+ *&,+ 3+ %&)+ * &+ )&&"'')+&+,)*$## +)) + + $0 - % *, +# &) %$'$%+ =#+ CB>6 &.-) ,'&% )&** % +  ) -) + .* &,% + + +  +)) .* -)0 )&, %.*#-+ '')&/ $+#0 D $+)* )&$ +  #&& '# % &)) % +  ) -)6   +)) % /+% % %&)+ .)*  % #)8,+3 )*,#+ % % %* ))&.+  & *'), *'# %*6  +) + )&. .* &*)- &% +  +)) % .* /$ % &) ) &#& #$+) #6&,#+,)#$+) #.*&*)-6   *&,+ * &+ ) -) *#-+'')&/ $+#0F$+)*&-+ #&&'# %6  )&,%*#&'*-)0%+#0,+&%* *+%+#0+&.)*+ ) -)&+ ,'*+)$% &.%*+)$&+ )&** %'& %+6  % +* +8J *#&+ %%)&%*#0)&. %*'),+)*#**+ % +.%+0 0)* &#6  ) * *&$ - % & +) $$ %3 *,*+ % * #-,#+,) + - +03%+ )&,%+ + *%&+&-)0*'), *)**03.+3%,%,#+ %6  ).*%&- %&,#+,)#+ - +00&%+ *'&) +) $$ %+ - + * %.)&, **)&*&)*" )+) #*6  %&'%)&)%+#0#)8,+' %&)*+*,))&,%*+ ')&'&*+,) %* + 8K =#+ CC>6   . ' %* + + )$ % *+% %3 * .## * +  *++) *+,$'*3 % + + + +  &)*+ .* + #*+ CBB 0)* &# . % + .* ,+6   )&,%,%,#+* - #0,++ &-)###%*' *)#+ -#0#-#6  ,) %% +* +8CB *#&+ %-)00&,% ) %'&'#)&)*+ . +  % ,%)*+&)0 & *'), *'# %*6   &)*+ '')* +& - )&.% ,' &% #%+ +.*#)8,+.*') &)+&+ *,)-06   #-%+ ')&'&*+,) %* + *%'# %*'),&)*+. + %* $&**0&)*+#&&)6. ).&&* -#*&)&.%,'3$&*+&.  ) ) 6 %  +) # #** + % KB$ )&$ +  ')&-  &&) %+* .* +  &%#0 - * # - %&,#+,)#+ - +0 %+ -  % +06  ,) %* +8CD.*#&+ %*'),&)*+#$&*+ %+ # %*) '+ &% +&* +8CC6)%+#)8,+&,#&,%+&+ *+&+ * +3%+ ) .)*++)&.%+)*)*,#+ %)&$*+)&%. %* %+ )=#+CD>6    

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

12 4.4 Field Reconnaissance – Revised (December 2011) Layout   %+ )- *+,) %%**)&#0&,+.***$# %$)DBCC3 + .* &,% +&  ) * %  %+#0 )&$ +  &)  %# #0&,+6 #+ &,  *-)# +,) %*.)'#-)0#&*+&+  )&)  %#'&* + &%*3&+ )*.)%+ )#0%. &) * %  %+#0 )#&+ % ## ** )&* - + * %  %+#0 )&$ +  &)) &)**,)-0 %)#0&-$)6*)*,#+3*&%)&%% **%&+ * %.#0&,+.*&%,+ %$)DBCC0+' %- *% ,)&)6   4+ "$# $"&#34 " #'$%"## " &)  $,*#'# " #$"$&#$6,

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

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

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

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

14 #+3*,*+ %+ #%$0 -%'*+,)&)'#&,  #+*&$'& %+ % + % %+%+ &))#0+.%+ + %+,)06

4.0 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION  %#0 &% & +  )* *,)-0 * & ')+ ,#) %&+ )) % ) &#& # * %  %5+ #&+ &%&+ ')&#*+&%) %+ + )*+&%$&,%* # "#0)*,#+ %)&$ ##) %&%&)$)#0) ,#+,)##%*+.%+,) % * +*8E%8F&%+ &)  %#+,) %#0&,+3&)!,*+.*+&+ ,))%+ 8D6#+ &, + *$&,%*)%&+&* %  %&%+  )&.%3#)$&,%* *, *+ *.&,# - %-&#-)+#&&)+&%+ ')+&+ )$)*&) *++#)*6 + + * %&%* )+ &%3 + *')&#+ + &$*+ *#&+ %#&* ')&/ $ +0+&+ *+&%*3-)0# "#0&%&)%)+ )*+&+ #&. ##)&,%.   +  $&,%* ) %+)6 #+ &,  %& *,  &$*+ )$ %* .) %+   ,) % + )&+ +.&*,)-0*3 + *'&** #+ + + )+ &,%+ &%.*!,*+ &,+*  +  ) *,)-0 &) + + +  &$*+ .*  #&  %8*+0# *+),+,) . + %& *)%###)%%&*+&%&,%+ &%6 + * *+ *3&%*+),+ &%& +  ** )& * +  '&+%+ # +&  *+,)  $&) * %  %+ ) &#& # )*&,)6  + * #*& .&)+   *,** % +  # )&** % &  $ ## )&&"6  )*+ + &%* %$'$%+ * +* ) ,*,##0 &,% &% +  * &) &) %"* & %- # ) -)*3 .  ##&.&)*&+)%*'&)+ %+&&-&+ 9* %+) &)6 &.-)3 $ ## )&&" &* %&+ '') +&  & *,  %+ * 1 +& ')&-  %- # .+)*6  + &%##03+ *$&&+ %+))#%*'+ + *$&*+*, ++&%$'$%+ * %&+ ')*%+ + +  #&+ &% . ) +  )&&" )&** % * ')&'&*6 ) + - $&# % %  # )&%% **% + )&) *,*+ + + + * #&+ &% * & #&. ) &#& #'&+%+ #6 

5.0 RECOMMENDATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS    )*,#+* & + * $'+ ****$%+ - % + + + &%#0 &% ) * & ) &#& # &%)%5 +  ** )& +.% +  &)  %##0 ')&'&* +,) % * +*8E%8F3&).*+&8D6 &)  %#)&#0&,+'**&-)+  #&. ##&%.  + $&,%*.)#&+3.   *+ $&*+# "#0#&+ &%&) &$*+6  &,# +  &)  %# #0&,+  ,+ # 1 % + * ) &%3 ) &#& # +*+ % * )&$$%6   +*+ % .&,#  &%,+ + G8$+) %+)-#* + )&, &,++ *+ &%&)&+ +'***+ )&, + )&#-+'&+%+ #6 '%%+ ,'&% )& . + 3 + * $0 )*,#+ % +.& &) + ) )&.* & +*+ ,% +*6 *+ % * &,#  &$'#+ +) +  %+)# % & +  )& * % *+" &) &+ ). * $)" % +  ')&'&* . +  * % +)$ % +& %*,) + + +*+ % * &%,+ + )&, &,+ +  )#-%+ $'+ )6  %0 * %  %+

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

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

6.0 REFERENCES CITED  Baker, 1802. Plan of land laid out at the mouth of the Rivers Philip and Pugwash, 27th May 1802. PANS F/230-1802, Land Papers Cumberland County: Pugwash.

Barlow, S., R. W. Ells, and H. Fletcher. 1905. Province of Nova Scotia, Cumberland County, Pugwash. Sheet No. 61. Geological Survey of Canada.

Church, Ambrose F. 1873. Topographical Township Map of Cumberland County. A. F. Church & Co., Halifax.

Clark, Andrew Hill. 1968. Acadia, The Geography of Early Nova Scotia to 1760. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison.

DAC (Davis Archaeological Consultants). 2007. “Pugwash Wind Farm, Cumberland County: Archaeological Resource Impact Assessment.” Heritage Research permit A2007NS36. Report on file, Nova Scotia Heritage Division.

Davis, Derek and Sue Browne. 1996. The Natural History of Nova Scotia, Volume II: Theme Regions. The Nova Scotia Museum and Nimbus Publishing, Halifax.

Nova Scotia Archives and Records Management. 1967. Place-Names and Places of Nova Scotia. Public Archives of Nova Scotia, Halifax.

PANS RG 20 Series A: Crane, James Noble & Crane, William. Petition of James Noble Crane and William Crane for Land at Pugwash.

Roach, Thomas (Deputy Surveyor). 1805. A Plan of Pugwash Harbour and River, April

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

16 18th, 1805. PANS F/230-1805, Land Papers Cumberland County: Pugwash.

Smith, James F. 1978. The History of Pugwash. North Cumberland Historical Society, Nova Scotia.

Trask, Deborah. 1978. Life How Short, Eternity How Long: Gravestone Carving and Carvers in Nova Scotia. Halifax: The Nova Scotia Museum and the Department of Education.

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

17                      

PLATES                      Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

18  $3+"  #$$ &## )#$"%"%# %$" $ " ###$'$%"#-3-4,



 $4+"$&) "$$%"#$-4, # %$,

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

19  $5+ "%# #$"# ')'$$%"#$-5,



 $6+"#$#$  % $##" $'$%"#-5 -6* #$, Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

20  $7+ ## '"/) '0" ###" /%0"$## " $'$%"#-5-6, #$, $$  ")/"0,

 $8+%"#$-6*  "$#$,

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

21  $9+"'"/%0"%##$#&""$"# ""# " , #$,



 $:+#"" '$ &"#$(#$" ')$$ ###$" %$%" #$-9, #$,

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

22  $;+#$-'$" ") # '#$" " , $$  '   $", #$,

 $32+  "$" ##" $" %$"", $$ # $""# "$"  $$/'#$0, Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

23  $33+ "-%$"$$%"#$-;, '#$,



 $34+# "% "#$$$%"#$-34*  "$#$,

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

24  $35+#$ -3*# ''-# "%  ,  "$,



 $36+%"#$-5* #$" "$#" ' ""# $#$,

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

25   





$37+$-6*# ' $&")'$ ##) $%" $ $" % %$,   "$#$,

          

 $38+$-;*# '# "%'$# % # "$#$, $ '# $$ $$/#$0 ", # %$, Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

26  $39+% $" ## " * % #$" "# %$#$$ $# %$#/"$0$ '" % "$#/$0, $$$  #$ #&#$"& '#$"$ "$ $" #$'$"$ "" %,



 $3:+%"#$-33, '#$, Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

27 

             

APPENDIX A: HERITAGE RESEARCH PERMIT

AND AMENDMENT LETTER 

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

28

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

29

Davis MacIntyre & Associates Limited Pugwash Wind Farm

30