Financial Task Force | Report and Recommendations C2020-0742 ATTACHMENT 3 Organization of the Report

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Financial Task Force | Report and Recommendations C2020-0742 ATTACHMENT 3 Organization of the Report C2020-0742 ATTACHMENT 3 TAX Financial Task Force Report and RecommendationsTAX TAX C2020-0742 Attach 3 ISC: Unrestricted C2020-0742 ATTACHMENT 3 Organization of the Report Table of Contents Contents Organization of the Report .....................................................................................................................................2 Table of Contents ..........................................................................................................................................................................................2 Summary of Key Messages........................................................................................................................................................................4 Mandate, Focus and Acknowledgement ...............................................................................................................5 Mandate and Responsibilities of the Task Force ................................................................................................................................5 Reasons for More Focus on Funding Flows relative to Spending Discipline ...........................................................................5 External Members of the Task Force ......................................................................................................................................................5 Members of City Administration that offered Subject Matter Support ....................................................................................5 The Context for Funding City Operations ..............................................................................................................6 Sources of Operating Dollars ....................................................................................................................................................................6 Uses of Operating Dollars ..........................................................................................................................................................................9 Evolution of Municipal Taxation Policy in Calgary ..........................................................................................................................10 The Important Role of Property Taxes ................................................................................................................................................10 Textbox 1: Existing Taxation Authority Outside Property Taxes .................................................................................................13 Using Property Assessments to Inform Property Taxation ..........................................................................................................13 Responding to Calgary’s Cyclical Economy using Existing Tools ...................................................................... 15 Increasing focus on evidence and monitoring ................................................................................................................................15 Enhancing practices and processes that use existing revenue authority .............................................................................15 Textbox 2: Independent Review of Non-Residential Assessments and Complaints ..........................................................16 Measures Proposed by the Task Force.................................................................................................................................................17 Improving the Understanding of Municipal Finance Circumstances ............................................................... 19 Achieving a Better Understanding of the Property Tax Bill .........................................................................................................19 Responding to an Increasing Municipal Fiscal Imbalance ..........................................................................................................19 Measures Proposed by the Task Force.................................................................................................................................................20 Supporting Regional Economic Development ................................................................................................... 22 City-Shaping and Building in a Regional Context ...........................................................................................................................22 Assessing the Impact of Activity in the Region on The City’s Financial Position .................................................................22 Measures Proposed by the Task Force.................................................................................................................................................22 Bringing Property Taxation into the Twenty-First Century ............................................................................... 24 Reducing Reliance on a Land and Property-based Approach to Taxation ............................................................................24 Growing the Size of Non-Residential Accounts ...............................................................................................................................24 Addressing inflexibility in Non-Residential Sub-Classes ..............................................................................................................24 Changes in Market Values resulting from Gentrification .............................................................................................................25 Measures Proposed by the Task Force.................................................................................................................................................25 2 Financial Task Force | Report and Recommendations C2020-0742 ATTACHMENT 3 Organization of the Report Preparing for changes that would occur as the economy evolves ................................................................... 27 The Emergence of the Rapidly Growing Digital Economy ..........................................................................................................27 Municipal Revenue Opportunities available through the Digital Economy ........................................................................27 Measures Proposed by the Task Force.................................................................................................................................................29 Making Calgary More Competitive, Livable and Attractive .............................................................................. 31 Tax Competitiveness and Livability ......................................................................................................................................................31 Adding stability to tax competitiveness to build credibility and trust of private capital .................................................31 Building capacity to offer relief when prevailing economic conditions demand it ..........................................................32 Measures Proposed by the Task Force.................................................................................................................................................33 Working Better with Partners in Achieving Progress ........................................................................................ 35 Improving working relationships with a province that prefers few fiscal tools ...................................................................35 Improving working relationships with local businesses ..............................................................................................................35 Measures Proposed by the Task Force.................................................................................................................................................38 Improving Tax Efficiency for Long-Term Fiscal Sustainability .......................................................................... 39 Opportunity to enhance management of City financial resources ..........................................................................................39 Identifying early signals of the urgency for tax reform .................................................................................................................39 Adequate consideration for the volatility impacts on taxpayers ..............................................................................................39 Measures Proposed by the Task Force.................................................................................................................................................40 Annex 1: Recommendations for COVID-19 Relief Measures ............................................................................. 43 Annex 2: Overview of Municipal Revenue Tools in Other Jurisdictions ........................................................... 52 Revenue Sources in Other North American Cities ..........................................................................................................................52 Financial Task Force | Report and Recommendations 3 C2020-0742 ATTACHMENT 3 Organization of the Report Summary of Key Messages Key Message I: Adopt an evidence-based approach to decision-making .................................................................................................... 17 Key Message II: Anticipate and respond
Recommended publications
  • Lets Talk Blockwatch!!
    OCTOBER 2018 Over 20,000 monthly printed copies Stoney Trail d v l B COVENTRY HILLS s l il H PANORAMA t 2 s e v r HILLS a H VIVO Center / NHCA COUNTRY HILLS Country Hills Blvd VILLAGE * HARVEST HILLS COUNTRY HILLS Airport Trail Calgary International Airport Northern Hills NewsNorthern 2 CountryCountry HillsHills •• CountryCountry HillsHills VillageVillage • Coventry• Coventry HillsHills •• HarvestHarvest HillsHills •• PanoramaPanorama HillsHills Community AssociationHills Official Newsletter of the Northern Hills Community Association ❖ www.nhca.ca @northernhillscalgary @northernhills Lets Talk Blockwatch!! David Hartwick, 1st VP, NHCA bership and talk about the value of blockwatch to the Over the summer, some community. The program is questions and concerns have successful. It has now grown been raised about the Block- to over 70 different Facebook watch or Building Safer Com- groups in 11 communities munities program, specifically because the Calgary Police in Coventry Hills. Service support what we The NHCA pursued a are doing. It has expanded blockwatch style program outside of the Northern Hills a number of times over the and our BSC Committee is years, but our representatives constantly sought after for of the Calgary Police Service their knowledge to set one up were not very receptive for a elsewhere. number of reasons. However, The Blockwatch or social media posts brought Building Safer Communities more crime to light a few program is grassroots. It is years back and a resident growing and we are growing started up the Watchdogs with it. We are all volunteers Facebook group. Since that and we are learning as we go. time, leaders emerged within Thank you to all those that the community that worked have supported this initiative.
    [Show full text]
  • Centre City Plan Refresh What We Heard: 2018 Public Engagement
    Centre City Plan Refresh What We Heard: 2018 public engagement March 13, 2019 calgary.ca | contact 311 03 Centre City Plan Refresh What We Heard: 2018 public engagement About this what we heard report This report summarizes the activities and results of engagement for the Centre City Plan Refresh project. It outlines the project, the purpose of the public engagement, the activities we did, and a summary of what we heard at the events. A full list of comments received through public engagement is included in this report. This report does not outline what has happened as a result of the public engagement. That summary will be published at a later date, once all engagement has been completed and project plans have been finalized. Project overview In 2007, based on extensive citizen input, City Council adopted the Centre City Plan, a vision document that describes what the Centre City could look like in 30 years. The Centre City Plan is a coordinated strategy document that pulls together the vision for the Centre City along with strategies and actions relating to land use planning, economic, cultural, and social development, and governance. With the approval of the adoption of the Centre City Plan (CPC2007-049), it included a recommendation for regular monitoring and reporting. In January 2017 the Centre City Plan was identified as one of 28 Council policies to be amended. It’s time to review and refresh the original Centre City Plan. Calgary’s Centre City is the area south of the Bow River (including Prince’s Island Park) from 17th Avenue Southwest and 14th Street Southwest, to the Elbow River.
    [Show full text]
  • Point of View 2 0 1 Q2 8 Downtown and Beltline Office Market Report Market OVERVIEW
    POV Point of View 2 0 1 Q2 8 Downtown and Beltline Office Market Report Market OVERVIEW Downtown Market Unless the function of an office as we know it is eliminated entirely, Table ONE any commercial office market will never reach full vacancy. BUILDING TRANSACTIONS Despite advances in technology, artificial intelligence, and work structure, the presence of the office appears to be a very secure Sale one. On the other hand, what is to stop a market from cratering to 441 - 5 Avenue SW Fourth & Fourth 30% vacancy? Or worse? Five years ago in Calgary, when office 622 - 5 Avenue SW IBM Corporate Campus occupancy neared 97.5%, you would have been hard pressed to find anyone who foresaw a vacancy rate near 25% in the 840 - 7 Avenue SW Joffre Place downtown core, but alas, here we are at the end of the second 1035 - 7 Avenue SW Lavalin Building quarter of 2018 with a vacancy rate of 24.95%, having edged up Alpine Building Life Plaza 0.5% higher from the previous quarter. Atrium I & II McFarlane Tower Keeping such a dramatic swing in mind, we find ourselves asking: Centennial Place Mount Royal Place where is the bottom of the market and how will we be certain Dominion Centre Northland Building when we find it? In the first quarter, vacancy declined by a mere 0.14%. This quarter, it increased by an almost equally slim margin. Eau Claire Place II Prospect Place With plenty of churn, but no meaningful growth, are the modest Eau Claire Tower Roslyn Building changes we have experienced thus far in 2018 an indication of F1RST Tower Scotia Centre what is in store for the rest of the year? Five Ten Fifth TransCanada PipeLines Tower What we can say for certain is that there are signs the market is Ford Tower reaching the bottom.
    [Show full text]
  • Speaker Index 111
    Hansard Page Number Directory, 25th Legislature, First Session, 2001 Issue Number Date Page Numbers 1 (Elect.Spk/Thr Sp.)................... Apr.9 aft. & Apr.10 aft ..................... 1-2 & 3-7 2................................................ Apr.11 aft ...................................... 9-35 3................................................ Apr.11 eve. & Apr.12 aft. ................. 37-50 & 51-75 4 (Easter recess) ......................... Apr.23 aft ..................................... 77-102 5 (Budget Address) ...................... Apr.23 eve. & Apr.24 aft. ................. 103-107 & 109-130 6................................................ Apr.24 eve. & Apr.25 aft. ................. 131-140 & 141-167 7................................................ Apr.25 eve. & Apr.26 aft. ................. 169-187 & 189-216 8................................................ Apr.30 aft ...................................... 217-241 9................................................ Apr.30 eve. & May 1 aft ................... 243-260 & 261-286 10 .............................................. .May 1 eve. & May 2 aft. .................. 287-301 & 303-328 11 .............................................. .May 2 eve. & May 3 aft. .................. 329-348 & 349-373 12 .............................................. .May 7 aft ...................................... 375-402 13 .............................................. .May 7 eve. & May 8 aft. .................. 403-419 & 421-446 14 .............................................. .May 8 eve.
    [Show full text]
  • Subject Index 1
    2001 Hansard Subject Index 1 4-H Alberta-Northwest Territories agriculture Aboriginal early childhood intervention programs development tour See Child welfare, Early childhood intervention General remarks ... VanderBurg 666 programs: Aboriginal children 4-H clubs Aboriginal foster home care General remarks ... Marz 272; Taft 643 See Foster home care, Aboriginal children Highway cleanup campaign ... Danyluk 385 Aboriginal gambling 24-hour health clinics See Gambling–Aboriginal reserves See Health clinics, 24-hour Aboriginal health careers bursary 2001 World Championships in Athletics, Edmonton [See also Scholarships] See World Championships in Athletics, Edmonton General remarks ... Mar 550 (2001) Aboriginal high school–Edmonton 2002 North American Indigenous Games See Amiskwaciy Academy See North American Indigenous Games (2002) Aboriginal inmates 2005 Alberta centennial celebrations See Prisoners, Aboriginal General remarks ... Klein 144; Lund 288; Mason 292; Aboriginal issues Pannu 144 Federal/provincial co-operation re See Canada/Alberta MLA delivery of cheques re ... Pannu 650–51 partnership forum (Aboriginal issues) Provincial funding for ... Zwozdesky 647 General remarks ... Calahasen 1167–68; Evans 1167; Role of Public Affairs Bureau re ... MacDonald 600 Klein 1167; Taft 1167 530376 Alberta Ltd. Interdepartmental co-operation re ... Calahasen 711; Taft Registry document re (SP191/01: Tabled) ... Mason 464 712 542936 Alberta Ltd. Province/industry/aboriginal groups collaboration re ... Swan Hills joint venture, Estimated revenues from Calahasen 711; Massey 716 (Q4/01: Defeated) ... Cardinal 737; Carlson 737; Aboriginal land claims Taylor 737 General remarks ... Calahasen 711–12, 717 Swan Hills joint venture, Projected revenues from (Q6/01: Public input into ... Massey 716 Answer tabled) ... Cardinal 738; Carlson 737–38; Aboriginal peoples Taylor 738, 934 General remarks ..
    [Show full text]
  • Western Canadian Place
    OFFICE SPACE FOR SUBLEASE Colliers International 900, 335 8th Avenue, SW Calgary, AB T2P 1C9 www.collierscanada.com JIM REA Executive Vice President/Partner 403 215 7250 [email protected] DAN LANNON Senior Vice President/Partner 403 215 9865 [email protected] TODD SUTCLIFFE Vice President/Partner 403 298 0414 [email protected] WESTERN CANADIAN PLACE South Tower - 700 9th Avenue SW Average Number Constructed Rentable Area Floorplate of Floors Western Canadian Place is an A Class office project BUILDING th SOUTH TOWER SOUTH located on 9 Avenue SW and connected to the main 394,560 SF 15,000 SF DETAILS 1983 30 +15 walkway system. It is conveniently located one block east of Eighth Avenue Place, neighboring The CORE Shopping Centre and Bankers Hall. Western Canadian Place has recently undergone a $10 million re- Landlord HVAC vitalization on the main floor, +15, and +30 levels. These upgrades bcIMC Realty Corporation Monday - Friday included the addition of new retail amenities, collaborative meeting 6:00 am - 6:00 pm spaces, elevator modernization and lobby upgrades. Managed by QuadReal Property Group LP WESTERN CANADIAN PLACE South Tower - 700 9th Avenue SW OFFICE SPACE FOR SUBLEASE SUBLEASEACCESS SOUTH TOWER SOUTH DETAILS Western Canadian Place is located on 9th Avenue SW and provides quick and convenient access in and out of downtown. Parking is abundant along 9th Avenue and additional parking can be provided in the building and Centennial Parkade. WESTERN CANADIAN PLACE SOUTH TOWER Centennial Parkade WESTERN CANADIAN
    [Show full text]