1 'No Peace No War' Situation Between Ethiopia and Eritrea
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
‘No peace No war’ situation between Ethiopia and Eritrea: Perspectives of Eritrean and Ethiopian students and local people, Adigrat Town, Ethiopia. A research Paper Presented by: Berhe Yonas. B In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for obtaining the degree of: MASTER OF ARTS IN DEVELOPMENT STUDIES Major: Human Rights, Gender and Conflict Studies: Social Justice Perspectives (SJP) Members of the Examining Committee: Dr. Dubravka Zarkov (Supervisor) Proff. Dr. Murshed Mansoob (Second Reader) 1 2 Acknowledgement I am grateful to Dubravka Zarcov (Dr.), my advisor, for her scholarly enlightening supervision in carrying out the research work. Her scholastic insight and the genuine classroom reflection have also influenced me positively in the course she offered me during my study. Her substantial guide, suggestion and constructive comments throughout the research work are priceless. In line with this I deeply appreciate my second reader Mansoob Murshed (Proff. Dr) for his constructive comments he gave me throughout the research work. My warmest and honorable thanks also goes to Mr Hagazi Mewael, a former lecturer in Mekelle University, for all the encouragements and his honest and constructive preliminary piece of advice he gave to me regarding the area of the research and a notable articles and published books on the area of conflict and peace. I want also to thank Mr Russom Bereket Moreover, I would like to thank to all my informants without whom the research would have come in to existence. I especially thank Mr Mulat Aradom, Mis Dehab Kiros, Mr Nasser Mohammad and Mr Samuel Kahsay for their cooperation in meeting and convincing the resourceful informants. I also thank, Alexander Berhane, Samsom Berhane, Michael Kihishen, Shewit Gebregzabhear, Gebresellasie Kiros and all my friends who have their own part in guide and suggestion in the accomplishment the research work. i Contents Acknowledgement ............................................................................................................................................... i Definition of terms ........................................................................................................................................... iv Abstract ................................................................................................................................................................ v Chapter one ......................................................................................................................................................... 1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................................................ 1 1.1. Contextual Background .................................................................................................................... 1 1.2. Identity and conflict .......................................................................................................................... 5 1.3. Statement of the problem ................................................................................................................. 6 1.4. Research Objectives and Questions of the study ............................................................................... 7 1.5. Significance of the Study........................................................................................................................ 7 1.6. Description of the study Area .......................................................................................................... 8 1.6. Scope and Limitation of the study .................................................................................................. 8 1.8. Organization of the study ...................................................................................................................... 9 Chapter Two ..................................................................................................................................................... 10 Methodology of the study ............................................................................................................................... 10 2.1. Research Strategy .................................................................................................................................. 10 2.2. Data type and Source ........................................................................................................................... 10 2.3. Background and selection of the Respondents ........................................................................... 10 2.4. Data Collection Tools ..................................................................................................................... 11 2.5. Data Analysis and Interpretation................................................................................................... 11 2.6. Original contribution ............................................................................................................................ 12 2.7. Ethical considerations .......................................................................................................................... 12 Chapter Three ................................................................................................................................................... 13 Theoretical perspectives/Approach .............................................................................................................. 13 3.1. Discourses on peace, violence and conflict ................................................................................. 13 ii 3.2. Current state of academic field ........................................................................................................... 16 3.2.2. Youth and conflict ......................................................................................................................... 18 3.2.3. ‘No peace No war’ ......................................................................................................................... 22 Chapter Four ..................................................................................................................................................... 24 Data Analysis and Interpretation ................................................................................................................... 24 4.1. ‘No peace No war’ Realities ................................................................................................................ 24 4.2. Aspects of the ‘no war no peace’ reality ............................................................................................ 29 4.2.1. Economic and political Aspects .................................................................................................. 29 4.2.2. Social Aspects ................................................................................................................................. 32 4.3. The Role of Identity ............................................................................................................................. 33 Chapter Five ...................................................................................................................................................... 38 Conclusion ......................................................................................................................................................... 38 Appendix A ....................................................................................................................................................... 40 Interview Checklist ...................................................................................................................................... 40 Appendix B ....................................................................................................................................................... 41 Background of the respondents ................................................................................................................. 41 Bibliography ...................................................................................................................................................... 42 iii List of Acronyms EEBC………………………………Ethiopia Eritrea Boundary Commission EECC………………………………Ethiopia Eritrea Claims Commission Definition of terms ‘No peace no war’…………………………………”አይ ሰላም አይ ኩናት” iv Abstract This study deals with the ‘no peace no war’ situation existed in Eritrea and Ethiopia. The study was aimed at assessing the opinion and experience of students and local people in Adigrat town. This study employed qualitative case study research design. Purposive sampling technique was used to identify a total of fourteen sample respondents from which ten are university students, two are elders and two women from the town. The study employs unstructured interview with open ended questions as a main data collection instrument which is supported by secondary sources with academic literatures including the theories of peace like the positive peace, Liberal peace and the ‘new war’ theory. Accordingly the findings, the study shows that ‘no peace no war’ situation currently existing in Ethiopia and Eritrea has an adverse effect for both peoples by prohibiting peaceful coexistence and integration to enhance their social and economic development. This ranges from separation of families, migration and economic entrapment to