DOCSLIB.ORG

The Right to Occupyâ•Floccupy Wall Street and the First Amendment

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Right to Occupyâ•Floccupy Wall Street and the First Amendment Fordham Urban Law Journal Volume 39 | Number 4 Article 5 February 2016 The Right to Occupy—Occupy Wall Street and the First Amendment Sarah Kunstler Follow this and additional works at: https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/ulj Part of the First Amendment Commons, Law and Politics Commons, and the Supreme Court of the United States Commons Recommended Citation Sarah Kunstler, The Right to Occupy—Occupy Wall Street and the First Amendment, 39 Fordham Urb. L.J. 989 (2012). Available at: https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/ulj/vol39/iss4/5 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by FLASH: The orF dham Law Archive of Scholarship and History. It has been accepted for inclusion in Fordham Urban Law Journal by an authorized editor of FLASH: The orF dham Law Archive of Scholarship and History. For more information, please contact [email protected]. KUNSTLER_CHRISTENSEN 7/11/2012 9:25 AM THE RIGHT TO OCCUPY—OCCUPY WALL STREET AND THE FIRST AMENDMENT ∗ Sarah Kunstler Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty—power is ever stealing from the many to the few.1 Wendell Phillips, January 28, 1852 Introduction ............................................................................................. 989 I. Symbolic Speech ............................................................................... 993 II. Symbolic Sleeping and the Courts ................................................. 999 III. The Landscape of Symbolic Sleep Protection After Clark v. CCNV .......................................................................................... 1007 IV. The Occupy Movement in the Courts ....................................... 1012 Conclusion .............................................................................................. 1018 INTRODUCTION The Occupy movement, starting with Occupy Wall Street in Zuccotti Park in New York City, captured the public imagination and spread across the country with a force and rapidity that no one could have predicted. The original occupation in New York, the product of the efforts of a number of groups,2 was fueled by a call put out by Adbusters magazine in July of 2011 featuring the image of a ballerina posing atop the iconic bronze bull sculpture of Wall Street—while ∗ The author is grateful to Professors Ellen Yaroshefsky and Holly Maguigan for their mentorship and guidance, to Daniel Pearlstein for his research assistance and to Jesse Ferguson, Lazar Bloch, Tracy Bunting, and Margaret Ratner Kunstler for their invaluable suggestions. 1. Wendell Phillips speech in Boston, Massachusetts, (Jan. 28, 1852), in SPEECH- ES BEFORE THE MASSACHUSETTS ANTI-SLAVERY SOCIETY 13 (Robert F. Wallcut, No. 21 Cornhill 1852), available at http://www.archive.org/details/speechesbeforema01 phil. 2. The groups and individuals who helped organize the original Occupy Wall Street protest in New York include U.S. Day of Rage, Anonymous, New Yorkers Against, and The NYC General Assembly. See Nathan Schneider, Occupy Wall Street: FAQ, NATION (Sept. 29, 2011), http://www.thenation.com/article/163719/ occupy-wall-street-faq. 989 KUNSTLER_CHRISTENSEN 7/11/2012 9:25 AM 990 FORDHAM URB. L.J. [Vol. XXXIX protesters gather in the background amid a cloud of tear gas—and the following text: WHAT IS OUR ONE DEMAND? #OCCUPYWALLSTREET SEPTEMBER 17TH. BRING TENT3 The image was resonant and electrifying. “Charging Bull,” the giant bronze sculpture that stands in Bowling Green Park near Wall Street, the symbol of the financial optimism that characterizes a “Bull Mar- ket,” was to be challenged. The October 2008 stock market crisis— together with bank bailouts, high unemployment, and the increasing income disparity between the highest earners and everyone else—had fostered discontent and hopelessness among those who bore the brunt of disastrous financial decisions that appeared to have enriched the few at the expense of the many. To occupy Wall Street was an empowering way to give voice to this outrage. It was also an assertion of control over Wall Street as a symbol, and the power of the people to change its meaning. On September 17, 2011, about a thousand demonstrators answered the call to Occupy Wall Street, converging in Zuccotti Park in lower Manhattan near the New York Stock Exchange.4 Several hundred spent the night, and from that day forward, the park was “occupied” by demonstrators on a twenty-four-hour basis.5 The numbers were small by New York City protest standards; hundreds of thousands of New Yorkers had taken to the streets to demonstrate in opposition to the imminent Iraq War in 2003.6 But the concept of occupying Wall Street was provocative. “We are the 99%,” a popular chant at Occupy protests, and the movement’s core slogan, pointed not only to the vast wealth inequality between rich and poor, but to the power that Occu- py movement protesters—that all of us—have to combat inequality and injustice: the power of numbers. Over the course of the weeks that followed, many others visited Zuccotti Park, widely known in the movement by its original, pre-2006 name of Liberty Square or Liberty 3. Adbusters also put out an online call to action on its website on July 13, 2011. #OccupyWallStreet, ADBUSTERS (July 13, 2011), http://www.adbusters.org/blogs/ad busters-blog/occupywallstreet.html. 4. See WRITERS FOR THE 99%, OCCUPYING WALL STREET: THE INSIDE STORY OF AN ACTION THAT CHANGED AMERICA 15–19 (2012). 5. Id. 6. See Robert D. McFadden, From New York to Melbourne, Cries for Peace, N.Y. TIMES (Feb. 16, 2003), http://www.nytimes.com/2003/02/16/nyregion/threats-and -responses-overview-from-new-york-to-melbourne-cries-for-peace.html. KUNSTLER_CHRISTENSEN 7/11/2012 9:25 AM 2012] THE RIGHT TO OCCUPY 991 Plaza.7 Once there, it was difficult to remain a bystander or spectator. Everyone was invited to participate directly in the process of deter- mining what Occupy Wall Street was all about, through the democra- cy of the “General Assembly,” daily meetings at which collective de- cisions were made in an open, participatory manner.8 Adbusters had called for a single demand to emerge from the ac- tion.9 As the Occupy movement continued over weeks, the press fo- cused on the lack of a clear demand or demands of the protesters.10 What was their purpose? What were they asking for? The protesters themselves, through the General Assemblies, struggled with this is- sue.11 Various lists of demands were circulated, some held forth by the press. But over time, it became clear that the “demand” was the occupation itself and the direct democracy that was taking place there.12 The occupation of Zuccotti Park in New York, and of other parks and plazas across the country, became model communities that literally demonstrated the protesters’ vision of the form a more just society might take. But it was the round-the-clock nature of the pro- tests that was—and continues to be—the source of their expressive power, as well as the concept that unified Occupy protests across the country. The idea that demonstrators were willing to literally put their lives and bodies on the line, to physically occupy Wall Street and other locations in Washington, D.C., Augusta, Georgia, Fort Myers, Florida, Minneapolis, Minnesota and countless other cities and towns, in order to call attention to disparities in wealth and power, awakened a national discourse about the role of government in meeting the 7. The park was named Liberty Plaza Park from 1968 until 2006, when it re- ceived an $8 million renovation by Brookfield Properties, and was renamed Zuccotti Park in honor of John E. Zuccotti, the chairman of Brookfield, former City Planning Commission chairman and first deputy mayor under Abe Beame. See Schneider, su- pra note 2. 8. The General Assembly, or GA, is the decision-making body of the Occupy Movement, as well as the forum by which organizers make sure that the needs of those participating are being met. See id. 9. See #OccupyWallStreet, supra note 3. 10. See, e.g., Meredith Hoffman, Protesters Debate What Demands, if Any, to Make, N.Y. TIMES (Oct. 16, 2011), http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/17/nyregion/occ upy-wall-street-trying-to-settle-on-demands.html; Miranda Leitsinger, To Demand or Not to Demand? That is the ‘Occupy’ Question, MSNBC.COM (Nov. 17, 2011), http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/45260610/ns/us_news-life/t/demand-or-not-demand- occupy-question/; Alaina Love, What Occupy Wall Street Demands of Our Leaders, WASH. POST, (Oct. 11, 2011), http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/on-leadership/ what-occupy-wall-street-demands-of-our- leaders/2011/10/11/gIQAjHtZcL_story.html. 11. See Schneider, supra note 2. 12. Id. KUNSTLER_CHRISTENSEN 7/11/2012 9:25 AM 992 FORDHAM URB. L.J. [Vol. XXXIX needs of the people, and the power of people to participate in their own governance. To occupy these spaces was to transform them. As the occupations continued over days and weeks, lawyers13 and legal workers working with the Occupy movement began to consider whether the First Amendment might include a “Right to Occupy.”14 Over the past eighty years, the protections of the First Amendment have expanded to include conduct that has come to be viewed as ex- pressive, including demonstrating,15 marching,16 leafleting,17 picket- ing,18 wearing armbands,19 and attaching a peace symbol to an Ameri- can flag.20 Should these same protections be extended to round-the- clock occupations, which include activities that were not previously viewed as communicative, such as sleeping and camping? According to the Supreme Court, the answer is no. In a 1984 decision in Clark v. Community for Creative Non-Violence,21 the Court, although ac- knowledging that sleeping in connection with a twenty-four-hour demonstration is somewhat expressive, nonetheless upheld a regula- tion banning the activity. This nearly thirty-year-old decision, how- ever, is not the end of the argument. The boundaries of First Amendment protection of expressive conduct have moved over time.22 Once a particular form of conduct is recognized as having suf- ficient symbolic value, regulations that limit that conduct receive greater scrutiny.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A Brief History of Occupy Wall Street ROSA LUXEMBURG STIFTUNG NEW YORK OFFICE by Ethan Earle Table of Contents
    A Brief History of Occupy Wall Street ROSA LUXEMBURG STIFTUNG NEW YORK OFFICE By Ethan Earle Table of Contents Spontaneity and Organization. By the Editors................................................................................1 A Brief History of Occupy Wall Street....................................................2 By Ethan Earle The Beginnings..............................................................................................................................2 Occupy Wall Street Goes Viral.....................................................................................................4 Inside the Occupation..................................................................................................................7 Police Evictions and a Winter of Discontent..............................................................................9 How to Occupy Without an Occupation...................................................................................10 How and Why It Happened........................................................................................................12 The Impact of Occupy.................................................................................................................15 The Future of OWS.....................................................................................................................16 Published by the Rosa Luxemburg Stiftung, New York Office, November 2012 Editors: Stefanie Ehmsen and Albert Scharenberg Address: 275 Madison Avenue, Suite 2114,
    [Show full text]
  • The Occupy Wall Street Movement's Struggle Over Privately Owned
    International Journal of Communication 11(2017), 3162–3181 1932–8036/20170005 A Noneventful Social Movement: The Occupy Wall Street Movement’s Struggle Over Privately Owned Public Space HAO CAO The University of Texas at Austin, USA Why did the Occupy Wall Street movement settle in Zuccotti Park, a privately owned public space? Why did the movement get evicted after a two-month occupation? To answer these questions, this study offers a new tentative framework, spatial opportunity structure, to understand spatial politics in social movements as the interaction of spatial structure and agency. Drawing on opportunity structure models, Sewell’s dual concept of spatial structure and agency, and his concept of event, I analyze how the Occupy activists took over and repurposed Zuccotti Park from a site of consumption and leisure to a space of political claim making. Yet, with unsympathetic public opinion, intensifying policing and surveillance, and unfavorable court rulings privileging property rights over speech rights, the temporary success did not stabilize into a durable transformation of spatial structure. My study not only explains the Occupy movement’s spatial politics but also offers a novel framework to understand the struggle over privatization of public space for future social movements and public speech and assembly in general. Keywords: Occupy Wall Street movement, privately owned public space (POPS), spatial opportunity structure, spatial agency, spatial structure, event Collective actions presuppose the copresence of “large numbers of people into limited spaces” (Sewell, 2001, p. 58). To hold many people, such spaces should, in principle, be public sites that permit free access to everyone. The Occupy Wall Street (OWS) movement, targeting the engulfing inequality in the age of financialization and neoliberalization, used occupation of symbolic sites to convey its message.
    [Show full text]
  • What Comes After Occupy?
    What Comes After Occupy? ADAPT LABOUR STUDIES BOOK-SERIES International School of Higher Education in Labour and Industrial Relations Series Editors Tayo Fashoyin, University of Lagos (Nigeria) Michele Tiraboschi, University of Modena and Reggio Emilia (Italy) Guest Editors Massimo Pilati, University of Modena and Reggio Emilia (Italy) Hina Sheikh, UCLA University of California (Los Angeles) Francesca Sperotti, ADAPT Senior Research Fellow (Italy) Chris Tilly, UCLA University of California (Los Angeles) English Language Editor Pietro Manzella, ADAPT Senior Research Fellow (Italy) ADAPT (www.adapt.it) is a non-profit organisation founded in 2000 by Professor Marco Biagi with the aim of promoting studies and research in the field of labour law and industrial relations from an international and comparative perspective. In collaboration with the Centre for International and Comparative Studies on Law, Economics, Environment and Work (DEAL) at the Marco Biagi Department of Economics of the University of Modena and Reggio Emilia (Italy), ADAPT set up the International School of Higher Education in Labour and Industrial Relations, a centre of excellence which is accredited at an international level for research, study and the postgraduate programmes in the area of industrial and labour relations. ADAPT International Scientific Committee Bertagna Giuseppe (University of Bergamo, Italy), Bulgarelli Aviana (ISFOL, Italy), Fashoyin Tayo (University of Lagos, Nigeria), Frommberger Dietmar (Universität Magdeburg, Germany), Grisolia Julio Armando (Universidad
    [Show full text]
  • New York City Adventure “One If by Land, and Two If by Sea”
    NYACK COLLEGE HOMECOMING NEW YORK CITY ADVENTURE “ONE IF BY LAND, AND TWO IF BY SEA” 1 READE S T REE T WASHINGTON MARKET C PARK H G CIV I C T E URC W REE E C E N T E R O ROCKEFELLER C H A M B ERS S T REE T R PARK T E T R K R S RE A T S P N H L WE N W O N R W A RRE N S T REE T S DIS O A A M I C H E R P T T S H R I RE T 2 V E TRI B E C A N E R D AVEN W E T E N K F O R T S T R E CITY O F R A MSURRA YB ST REE T T E HALL BR E T SP W T R O RR PARK R K R O KLY ASHI A L RE O P A U N A P A R K P L A C E S P R U C E S B E D O V E R C RID N A E N G A E S T E MURR A Y S T REE T G T RE RE D D E T E T T T E T 3 Y O E W E N B T B A RCL A Y STREE T E T RE E E LL K M A E T A A N T S S T E RE E RE TRE Y T T S RE M T S R L A P E A I A C K S L L E E L H P I L D I P V ESEY S T REE T E R S T R E T A N N S T R E E T O T W G B EE A T N 4 K W W M A N ES FUL T O N STREE T FRO FU 5 H T C L D E Y T T W O RLD W O RLD T R A D E O S FINA N C I A L C E N T ER SI T E DU F N F T C E N T E R J O H N T S T R E CLI RE E T E T S O U T H S T R E E T T C O R T L A N D T Y E E E S E A P O R T Pier 17 A E M J O T A IDEN E PL H N S T A T T R W S T R R RE N O R T H L E T E E A N T T C O V E D E PEARL STRE T S A T S L I B ERT Y S T REE T LIBER FL W GREENWICH S E R T O T C H Y E R Pedestrian A U S T Bridge S I RE E T H N M CEDA R CED A R S T REE T A I M N BR AID I A S G E T N I T C E L S D A O Y T H A M E S A R S T N L R E E N E T T B AT T E R Y A S L A L B A N Y S T REE T T P O E S RE I PA R K N P U I N E S T T L R E E T T RE E P I N W E CIT Y H A E T T E RE CARLISLE S T REE T T
    [Show full text]
  • Real Democracy in the Occupy Movement
    NO STABLE GROUND: REAL DEMOCRACY IN THE OCCUPY MOVEMENT ANNA SZOLUCHA PhD Thesis Department of Sociology, Maynooth University November 2014 Head of Department: Prof. Mary Corcoran Supervisor: Dr Laurence Cox Rodzicom To my Parents ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This thesis is an outcome of many joyous and creative (sometimes also puzzling) encounters that I shared with the participants of Occupy in Ireland and the San Francisco Bay Area. I am truly indebted to you for your unending generosity, ingenuity and determination; for taking the risks (for many of us, yet again) and continuing to fight and create. It is your voices and experiences that are central to me in these pages and I hope that you will find here something that touches a part of you, not in a nostalgic way, but as an impulse to act. First and foremost, I would like to extend my heartfelt gratitude to my supervisor, Dr Laurence Cox, whose unfaltering encouragement, assistance, advice and expert knowledge were invaluable for the successful completion of this research. He was always an enormously responsive and generous mentor and his critique helped sharpen this thesis in many ways. Thank you for being supportive also in so many other areas and for ushering me in to the complex world of activist research. I am also grateful to Eddie Yuen who helped me find my way around Oakland and introduced me to many Occupy participants – your help was priceless and I really enjoyed meeting you. I wanted to thank Prof. Szymon Wróbel for debates about philosophy and conversations about life as well as for his continuing support.
    [Show full text]
  • Campuses New York City, NY Los Angeles, CA South Beach, Miami
    132 LOCATIONS LOCATIONS 133 Campuses New York City, NY Los Angeles, CA South Beach, Miami, FL Gold Coast, Australia Satellite Locations Florence, Italy Paris, France Harvard University, MA Walt Disney World® Resort, FL Beijing, China Shanghai, China Mumbai, India Doha, Qatar Moscow, Russia Kyoto, Japan Seoul, Korea Amsterdam, Netherlands Rio De Janeiro, Brazil Locations 134 NEW YORK CITY NEW YORK CITY 135 New York City, NY The New York Film Academy’s flagship campus in New Chinatown and Spanish Harlem, the stately Museum Mile Central Location Extracurricular Activities York City places students in the heart of one of the on the Upper East Side, the neighborhood brownstones of world’s greatest metropolises. For its size, excitement, Park Slope in Brooklyn. New York City is about neon lights, The New York Film Academy’s New York City campus in “The city that never sleeps” offers as many exciting culture, and landscape, the city remains unparalleled taxi horns, street music, bookstores, landscaped parks, Manhattan’s historic Financial District is split between adventures and discoveries as there are people. For — and plays a starring role in the projects and lives of and 10 million inhabitants working together — each as premier facilities on Battery Park and Broadway, steps dining, film, nightlife, shopping, museums, and so much our students. unique as the next. from the iconic Charging Bull statue on Wall Street, more, New York ranks number one in the world. the beautiful Hudson River Park, and the Castle Clinton Dynamic, rich in diversity, and always alive, New York Our students in New York City have the opportunity National Monument in Battery Park.
    [Show full text]
  • Occupy Wall Street: a Movement in the Making
    Trinity College Trinity College Digital Repository Senior Theses and Projects Student Scholarship Spring 5-20-2012 Occupy Wall Street: A Movement in the Making Hannah G. Kaneck Trinity College, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalrepository.trincoll.edu/theses Part of the American Politics Commons, Civil Rights and Discrimination Commons, Economic Policy Commons, Education Policy Commons, Energy Policy Commons, Environmental Policy Commons, Health Policy Commons, Human Rights Law Commons, International Law Commons, Law and Gender Commons, Law and Politics Commons, Law Enforcement and Corrections Commons, Organizations Law Commons, Political Economy Commons, and the Social Policy Commons Recommended Citation Kaneck, Hannah G., "Occupy Wall Street: A Movement in the Making". Senior Theses, Trinity College, Hartford, CT 2012. Trinity College Digital Repository, https://digitalrepository.trincoll.edu/theses/245 Occupy Wall Street: a movement in the making Hannah Kaneck Spring 2012 1 Dedicated to my grandmother Jane Armstrong Special thanks to my parents Karrie and Mike Kaneck, my readers Stephen Valocchi and Sonia Cardenas, the Trinity College Human Rights Program, and to my siblings at Cleo of Alpha Chi 2 Table of Contents Timeline leading up to September 17, 2011 Occupation of Wall Street…………………….……………….4 Introduction…………………………………………………………………………………..……………………………….….……..6 Where did they come from?...........................................................................................................7
    [Show full text]
  • The Ethics of Artistic Appropriation
    Taking Charging Bull by the Horns: The Ethics of Artistic Appropriation In the wake of the global stock market crash of 1987, the Sicilian immigrant Arturo Di Modica created the guerilla artwork known as Charging Bull. Without permission, and after spending $350,000 of his own funds, Di Modica had the bull installed in 1989 near Wall Street in New York City during the height of Christmas season to symbolize the strength and power of the American people. Many tourists and locals alike loved the Charging Bull and identified it as “the only significant work of guerrilla capitalist art in existence.” The New York Stock Exchange quickly removed the 3.5-ton statue the day it was installed, but the resulting public outcry led to its “temporary installation” in a nearby location; thirty years later, Charging Bull is still standing strong as one of the most iconic symbols of New York City. On March 7, 2017, Charging Bull was faced with a new opponent. Photo: Anthony Quintano/CC BY 2.0 During the night before International Women’s Day in March 2017, a small sculpture of a young girl was quietly placed in front of Charging Bull. Known as Fearless Girl, the unscheduled installation stands defiantly with her hands on her hips and faces the bull with an unwavering confidence. At the feet of the statue was a bronze plaque that reads “Know the power of women in leadership. SHE makes a difference.” The initial reaction from many people was that this was another act of guerrilla art, one particularly needed now given Wall Street’s challenges with gender equity and diversity.
    [Show full text]
  • The Effect of Increased Tourism in Lower Manhattan by Catherine Mcvay Hughes, Chair Of
    The City of New York Manhattan Community Board 1 Catherine McVay Hughes CHAIRPERSON | Noah Pfefferblit DISTRICT MANAGER Committee on Lower Manhattan Redevelopment Oversight Hearing on The Effect of Increased Tourism in Lower Manhattan Testimony by Catherine McVay Hughes Chairperson Friday, September 28, 2012 250 Broadway, Committee Room, 16th Floor, New York, NY 10:00 AM Good morning Chairperson Chin and members of the New York City Council Committee on Lower Manhattan Redevelopment. I am Catherine McVay Hughes Chairperson of Manhattan Community Board One. We thank you for the opportunity to comment on the effect of increased tourism in Lower Manhattan. Lower Manhattan has long served as a destination for tourists because it is rich in historical, iconic, cultural, and economic assets, ranging from the National 9/11 Memorial, Statue of Liberty/Ellis Island, Wall Street, The Bull (at Bowling Green), Brooklyn Bridge, and Governor’s Island. Lower Manhattan residents appreciate the significance of these local assets, understand the desire of tourists to experience them, and recognize the economic benefits such tourists generate for the area and the City. There has been increased tourism in the aftermath of 9/11. “Eleven years after September 11, Lower Manhattan attracts 10 million tourists per year. According to the Downtown Alliance, the local Business Improvement District largely responsible for spearheading the area's growth, there are 39,380 visitors to the area each day with more than 309,500 weekday workers and 61,000 residents living in more than 325 residential buildings,” according to the NY Daily News (September 6, 2012, by Jason Sheftell).
    [Show full text]
  • Lower Manhattan Public Art Offers Visitors Grand, Open-Air Museum Experience
    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Contact: Maria Alvarado, (212) 835.2763, [email protected] LOWER MANHATTAN PUBLIC ART OFFERS VISITORS GRAND, OPEN-AIR MUSEUM EXPERIENCE Works by Dubuffet, Koons and Naguchi are among the 14 unique installations featured South of Chambers Street (February 23, 2015) – With more than a dozen masterpieces from world-renowned artists, Lower Manhattan is home to a remarkable and inspiring public art program. The works of art are now featured in a new walking tour itinerary curated by the Downtown Alliance, “Lower Manhattan by Public Art.” The full tour can be found on the Alliance’s website at http://downtownny.com/walkingtours. The walking tour begins at the district’s northernmost edge at 1 Police Plaza, across from City Hall. Here, visitors will find 5-in-1 by Tony Rosenthal. The artist’s work of five interlocking steel discs, rising to a height of 35 feet, represents the five boroughs coming together as one city. Additional pieces of art featured are: Shadows and Flags by Louise Nevelson (William Street between Maiden Lane and Liberty Street) Seven pieces bundled together as a singular abstract unit alludes to the wafting flags, ceremonious spirals, and blooming trees that define the New York City landscape. Group of Four Trees by Jean Dubuffet (28 Liberty Street) The “four trees” are created by a series of intertwined irregular planes, which lean in different directions and are connected by thick black outlines. The piece is part of Dubuffet’s “L’Hourloupe” cycle — a bold, graphic style inspired by a doodle. Sunken Garden by Isamu Noguchi (28 Liberty Street) In the winter, the garden, set one story below ground level, is a dry circular expanse; in the summer, it is transformed into a giant water fountain.
    [Show full text]
  • Occupy Boise Case
    Case 1:12-cv-00076-BLW Document 17 Filed 02/26/12 Page 1 of 16 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF IDAHO EDWARD WATTERS, DEAN GUNDERSON, STEVEN FARNWORTH, MATTHEW ALEXANDER NEWIRTH, Case No. 1:12-CV-76-BLW individuals, and OCCUPY BOISE, an Idaho unincorporated nonprofit association MEMORANDUM DECISION AND ORDER Plaintiffs, v. C.L. (BUTCH) OTTER, in his official capacity as the Governor of the State of Idaho, TERESA LUNA, in her official capacity of the Director of the Idaho Department of Administration, and COL. G. JERRY RUSSELL, in his official capacity as the Director of the Idaho State Police, Defendants. INTRODUCTION The Court has before it Occupy Boise’s motion for injunctive relief. The Court heard oral argument on the motion on February 24, 2012, and took the motion under advisement. For the reasons explained below, the Court will grant the motion, to the extent it seeks to enjoin the state from removing the symbolic tent city erected by Occupy Boise, but deny the motion, to the extent it seeks to enjoin the occupants from camping, sleeping or storing camping-related personal property at the site. Memorandum Decision & Order - 1 Case 1:12-cv-00076-BLW Document 17 Filed 02/26/12 Page 2 of 16 SUMMARY Occupy Boise’s motion for injunction comes before the Court – as most injunction motions do – on a rushed schedule with expedited briefing. Hasty decisions are rarely wise decisions, and the law recognizes that fact: Preliminary injunctions are issued on a showing of a “likelihood” of success; there is no final resolution of any issue.
    [Show full text]
  • Occupy! Scenes from Occupied America 28 Daily Acadlemsice Bo Ork Reevievwsi Efrowm T Hoe Sfo Cbial Oscoienkcess 2012 Blog Admin
    Jul Book Review: Occupy! Scenes from Occupied America 28 daily acadLemSicE bo oRk reevievwsi efrowm t hoe sfo cBial oscoienkcess 2012 Blog Admin Like 19 Tw eet 28 Share 3 In the fall of 2011, a small protest camp in downtown Manhattan exploded into a global uprising, sparked in part by what many saw as the violent overreactions of the police. Occupy! is an unofficial record of the movement and combines first-hand accounts with reflections from activist academics and writers. Jason Hickel finds the book has excellent moments of insight but thought it could benefit from a more lengthy analysis. Occupy! Scenes from Occupied America. Astra Taylor and Keith Gessen (eds). Verso. 2011. Find this book When a small group of activists first occupied Zuccotti Park in Lower Manhattan last September nobody thought it would amount to much. But it wasn’t long before Occupy Wall Street struck a chord with a nation embittered by bank bailouts, plutocracy, and rising social inequalities, galvanized hundreds of thousands of angry protestors, and inspired similar encampments in dozens of cities across the United States and Europe. As a scholar who followed OWS closely with both personal and scholarly interest, I was thrilled to get my hands on Occupy!: Scenes from Occupied America, one of the first book-length texts to have been published on the topic. Occupy! was composed in an unconventional style. It compiles 34 short chapters and dozens of sketches and photographs selected and edited by a team of eight scholar-activists, mostly from radical journals in New York such as n+1 and Dissent, led by Astra Taylor and Keith Gessen.
    [Show full text]