United States Patent (19) (11 Patent Number: 4,795,824 Kippax Et Al
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
United States Patent (19) (11 Patent Number: 4,795,824 Kippax et al. (45) Date of Patent: Jan. 3, 1989 54 PROCESS FOR THE PRODUCTION OF Primary Examiner-Werren B. Lone DALKYL MALEATES Assistant Examiner-Vera C. Clarke 75 Inventors: John W. Kippax, Bedale; Colin Attorney, Agent, or Firm-Bernard, Rothwell & Brown Rathmell, Yarm, both of England 57 ABSTRACT 73) Assignee: Davy McKee (London) Limited, A process is described for the production of a dialkyl London, England maleate by reaction of maleic anhydride with an alkyl alcohol in a monoesterification zone to form the corre (21) Appl. No.: 80,060 sponding monoalkyl maleate, followed by reaction of (22 Filed: Jul. 31, 1987 resulting monoalkyl maleate with further alkyl alcohol 30 Foreign Application Priority Data to form the corresponding dialkyl maleate, which in cludes the steps of supplying a first liquid feed compris Aug. 1, 1986 GB United Kingdom ................. 86.18888 ing said monoalkyl maleate to a secondary esterification 51 Int. Cl'.............................................. CO7C 67/03 zone containing a charge of a solid esterification cata 52 U.S. C. ...................................... 560/204; 203/14; lyst, supplying a second feed stream comprising said 203/DIG. 2; 203/DIG. 11; 502/11; 560/191; alkyl alcohol to said secondary esterification zone, 562/595 maintaining said secondary esterification zone at an 58 Field of Search ................ 560/204, 191; 562/595; elevated temperature sufficient to form or to maintain 502/11; 203/14, 2, 11 therein a vaporous stream containing said alkyl alcohol, 56 References Cited intimately contacting said first liquid feed in said sec ondary esterification Zone in the presence of said cata U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS lyst with said vaporous feed stream, recovering from 3,862,147 1/1975 Cooley et al. .................. 560/204 X said secondary esterification zone a vaporous effluent 3,886,199 5/1975 Suter et al. ..................... 560/204X stream containing, in addition to alkyl alcohol vapor, 4,032,458 6/1977 Cooley et al. .................... 60/190 X 4,314,947 2/1982 Hohenschultz et al. ... 260/410 also water in vapor form, said water being produced in 4,361,710 1 1/1982 Weitz et al. ............. ... 568/864 said secondary esterification zone by esterification of 4,481,146 11/1984 Leupold et al...... ..., 260/40 said monoalkyl maleate with said alkyl alcohol, and 4,562,283 12/1985 Schnabel et al. ................... S60/204 recovering from said secondary esterification zone a liquid product stream containing said dialkyl maleate. FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS 0143634 5/1985 European Pat. Off. 34 Claims, 6 Drawing Sheets U.S. Patent Jan. 3, 1989 Sheet 1 of 6 4,795,824 SS n n n S ON S NoN ON NonSc SS s Q-4 r n NC V *-N s NQ s No MC) n N. ss R. ( s ) U.S. Patent Jan. 3, 1989 Sheet 2 of 6 4,795,824 U.S. Patent Jan. 3, 1989 Sheet 3 of 6 4,795,824 S SS s Nu s S Rs.ss: SS SS U.S. Patent 4,795,824 U.S. Patent Jan. 3, 1989 Sheet 5 of 6 4,795,824 yž U.S. Patent Jan. 3, 1989 Sheet 6 of 6 4,795,824 4,795,824 1. 2 liquor. Although it would be theoretically possible to PROCESS FOR THE PRODUCTION OF DALKYL recover the monoalkyl maleate from the resulting aque MALEATES ous liquors and to recycle this to the process for the production of further dialkyl maleate, this is not eco This invention relates to a process for the production 5 nomically feasible. Hence the monoalkyl maleate is lost of dialkyl maleates. to the process in these aqueous liquors which are a The production of dialkyl maleates by esterification potential pollution hazard. Moreover the loss of mono of maleic anhydride, of maleic acid or of a mixture alkyl maleate and disposal of these waste liquors repre containing both maleic anhydride and maleic acid has sent a significant operating cost. been described on many occasions in the literature. As O Similar procedures can be used for batch production maleic acid is dibasic, esterification proceeds stepwise of other dialkyl maleates using other alkyl alcohols in via the monoalkyl maleate. In the case of maleic anhy place of ethanol. dride this stepwise esterification can be described by the Although it would be possible to adapt this known equations: process for continuous operation with relatively simple 15 modifications thereof, the resulting process would still CH.CO.OR (1) suffer from the drawback of significant loss of potential product, in the form of monoalkyl maleate and of the other organic acid materials present in the reaction 20 product mixture. Moreover, as the acid catalyst is de and stroyed in the product recovery steps, the consumption of sulphuric acid or derivative thereof would add to the CHCO.OR (2) cost of operation of a large scale continuously operating plant. A further disadvantage of the known process is the CHCOOH 25 risk of contamination of the dialkyl maleate product with sulphur-containing impurities, which may rule out where R is an alkyl group. These reactions can be car ried out in two substantially separate steps in separate its use for some purposes, for example as a feedstock for reactors or simultaneously in a single reactor. The hydrogenation to yield butane-1,4-diol, tetrahydrofuran monoesterification step of equation (1) can be effected 30 and/or gamma-butyrolactone. Further teaching regard non-catalytically, conveniently by use of elevated tem ing use of dialkyl maleates (such as, for example, diethyl peratures. The diesterification step of equation (2) can maleate) for this purpose can be obtained, for example, likewise be carried out non-catalytically; however, it is from EP-A-No. 0143634, from WO-A-B No. 6/O3189 usually preferred to use an esterification catalyst in the or from WO-A-B No. 86/07358. As the catalysts used diesterification step of equation (2), such as an acid 35 for such duty are poisoned by the presence of sulphur catalyst (e.g. sulphuric acid). containing compounds in the feedstock. ester (or in the Diethyl maleate is produced as a fine chemical on a hydrogen-containing gas), stringent purification mea commercial scale, usually by a batch reaction process. sures may be required in order to reduce the sulphur In this known process maleic anhydride or a mixture of content of the ester to an acceptably low level. Such maleic anhydride and maleic acid, in either case possi 40 additional purification steps add significantly to produc bly containing a minor amount of fumaric acid, is re tion costs. acted with excess ethanol in the presence of a homoge Various proposals which avoid the use of catalysts neous liquid phase esterification catalyst, such as sul have been described. Thus U.S. Pat. No. 4,361,710 pro phuric acid or a derivative thereof. The reaction condi poses washing a gaseous mixture containing maleic tions are generally selected so as to cause substantially 45 anhydride with a monohydric or polyhydric alcohol all of the maleic anhydride to react. However, as the boiling above 180 C. (e.g. 2-ethylhexanol or dodecan diesterification reaction of equation (2) above is revers 1-ol) to form a solution of the corresponding maleic acid ible, the reaction product does not yield solely the de half-ester in the alcohol followed by heating the solu sired diethyl maleate; usually the reaction yields at most tion to remove water and to form a solution of maleic about 95 mole % diethyl maleate, the balance compris 50 acid diester in the alcohol. As water boils at a tempera ing mainly monoethyl maleate, besides smaller amounts ture well below that of the alcohol it is readily removed of monoethyl fumarate, diethyl fumarate, maleic acid from the reaction mixture, thus enabling the diesterifica and fumaric acid. The reaction mixture also contains tion reaction to be driven to completion. excess ethanol and water produced by the esterification U.S. Pat. No. 4,032,458 describes a process for the of the mono-esters formed as intermediates, i.e. mono 55 production of 1,4-butanediol in which maleic acid is ethyl maleate and monoethyl fumarate. esterified at elevated temperature and pressure and then In order to recover the dialkyl maleate product the subjected to a two step hydrogenation procedure. Ac catalyst must first be removed, prior to attempting puri cording to the description of the drawing it is preferred fication by distillation techniques, by neutralisation with to use for esterification a monohydric alcohol which alkali and then washing with water. These neutralisa 60 forms a heterogeneous azeotrope with water, such as tion steps produce significant quantities of aqueous li n-butanol. The esterification step is carried out in a quors and remove not only the catalyst but also any distillation zone from which an n-butanol-water azeo monoalkyl maleate and any other acid materials present, trope is removed overhead. According to column 11, such as traces of unreacted maleic anhydride or maleic lines 23 to 27, this azeotrope is condensed and allowed acid. 65 to separate into two layers. The n-butanol layer is de In addition, as diethyl maleate is somewhat soluble in canted, redistilled, and recycled to the distillation zone. water, some of the desired diethyl maleate product is The n-butanol-water azeotrope has a boiling point lost, together with the acidic materials, in the wash (92.7 C. at atmospheric pressure) which is appreciably 4,795,824 3 4. lower than the boiling point of the alcohol itself (117.4 maleate is avoided thereby obviating the risk of contam C. at atmospheric pressure), thus permitting the water ination of the product dialkyl maleate.