Developing the Yeast Disaggregase Hsp104 As a Treatment for Polyglutamine Disease in Drosophila Mary Cushman Nick University of Pennsylvania, [email protected]
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Publicly Accessible Penn Dissertations 1-1-2013 Developing the Yeast Disaggregase Hsp104 as a Treatment for Polyglutamine Disease in Drosophila Mary Cushman Nick University of Pennsylvania, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations Part of the Neuroscience and Neurobiology Commons Recommended Citation Nick, Mary Cushman, "Developing the Yeast Disaggregase Hsp104 as a Treatment for Polyglutamine Disease in Drosophila" (2013). Publicly Accessible Penn Dissertations. 904. http://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/904 This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. http://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/904 For more information, please contact [email protected]. Developing the Yeast Disaggregase Hsp104 as a Treatment for Polyglutamine Disease in Drosophila Abstract There is currently no cure for neurodegenerative disease or the underlying burden of protein aggregation that is associated with symptom development. A novel approach to combat this accumulation of misfolded protein species is surprisingly found in a protein disaggregase in yeast, the heat shock protein Hsp104. To investigate whether Hsp104 can be introduced into an animal system and harnessed to attack disease-associated protein inclusions, we created a transgenic Drosophila model expressing Hsp104 and investigated whether this would mitigate toxicity and alter the load of protein accumulations. We found that Hsp104 indeed suppressed toxicity of a disease-associated protein fragment containing an expanded polyglutamine tract. However, we found that Hsp104 worsened toxicity of the full-length pathogenic polyglutamine protein, and this coincided with increased accumulation of amyloid inclusions. This aberrant activity of Hsp104 depended on intact domains in the non-polyglutamine stretches of the protein, and this negative interaction could be prevented by mutation to these neighboring domains. These results indicate that knowing the precise protein state of a disease environment is critical in evaluating potential therapeutics. Moreover, we sequentially activated Hsp104 after the onset of protein aggregation and start of tissue degeneration, to find that Hsp104, but not Hsp70, significantly suppressed progressive degeneration. Thus, the unique ability of Hsp104 to tackle pre- existing amyloid conformers may offer a novel opportunity to reverse disease progression once underway. Degree Type Dissertation Degree Name Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) Graduate Group Neuroscience First Advisor Nancy M. Bonini Second Advisor James Shorter Keywords amyloid, chaperone, disaggregase, Drosophila, Hsp104, polyglutamine Subject Categories Neuroscience and Neurobiology This dissertation is available at ScholarlyCommons: http://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/904 DEVELOPING THE YEAST DISAGGREGASE HSP104 AS A TREATMENT FOR POLYGLUTAMINE DISEASE IN DROSOPHILA Mary Cushman Nick A DISSERTATION in Neuroscience Presented to the Faculties of the University of Pennsylvania in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy 2013 Co-Supervisor of Dissertation Co-Supervisor of Dissertation __________________________ __________________________ Nancy M Bonini, PhD James Shorter, PhD Florence R.C. Murray Professor of Biology and Associate Professor of Biochemistry and Investigator, Howard Hughes Medical Institute Biophysics Graduate Group Chairperson __________________________ Joshua I Gold, PhD Associate Professor of Neuroscience Dissertation Committee Harry Ischiropoulos, PhD Virginia M-Y Lee, PhD, MBA Research Professor of Pediatrics and John H Ware 3rd Professor in Alzheimer’s Research Pharmacology and Professor of Pathology and Lab Medicine Erika LF Holzbaur, PhD Robert Fairman, PhD Professor of Physiology Professor of Biology and Associate Provost, Haverford College DEVELOPING THE YEAST DISAGGREGASE HSP104 AS A TREATMENT FOR POLYGLUTAMINE DISEASE IN DROSOPHILA COPYRIGHT 2013 Mary Cushman Nick ACKNOWLEDGEMENT I am so grateful to Jim Shorter and Nancy Bonini for guidance and support throughout the course of this dissertation work. I learned so much from Jim about how to think about science and design experiments, and I greatly appreciate all the time he has invested in training me. Nancy has been a great inspiration to me in how to be a tough scientist and also an encouraging mentor. From her, I have learned how to work efficiently, and will forever be indebted to her for advising me to develop detailed outlines and contingency plans. Moreover, there is no greater group of people than those working in these two labs, and I have been surrounded by exceptional colleagues that I am glad to call my friends. I have also been fortunate to have an outstanding thesis committee, and despite feeling intimidated by such an accomplished group, I have truly enjoyed discussing science with them. I must also acknowledge my family. My husband Jeff has graciously absorbed all of my frustrations and has managed to offer the best advice in return. I could not have completed any of this without his support and reinforcement, and while I am proud of the work presented here, finding him has been my greatest accomplishment. I’m also lucky enough to have three sets of parents to encourage me (and constantly mention that a cure for age-related disease is needed as soon as possible). To my brother and siblings-in-law, I cannot express how pleased I am that I happen to be related to the people I consider my best friends. iii ABSTRACT DEVELOPING THE YEAST DISAGGREGASE HSP104 AS A TREATMENT FOR POLYGLUTAMINE DISEASE IN DROSOPHILA Mimi Cushman-Nick Dr. Nancy M. Bonini Dr. James Shorter There is currently no cure for neurodegenerative disease or the underlying burden of protein aggregation that is associated with symptom development. A novel approach to combat this accumulation of misfolded protein species is surprisingly found in a protein disaggregase in yeast, the heat shock protein Hsp104. To investigate whether Hsp104 can be introduced into an animal system and harnessed to attack disease-associated protein inclusions, we created a transgenic Drosophila model expressing Hsp104 and investigated whether this would mitigate toxicity and alter the load of protein accumulations. We found that Hsp104 indeed suppressed toxicity of a disease-associated protein fragment containing an expanded polyglutamine tract. However, we found that Hsp104 worsened toxicity of the full-length pathogenic polyglutamine protein, and this coincided with increased accumulation of amyloid inclusions. This aberrant activity of Hsp104 depended on intact domains in the non-polyglutamine stretches of the protein, and this negative interaction could be prevented by mutation to these neighboring domains. These results indicate that knowing the precise protein state of a disease environment is critical in evaluating potential therapeutics. Moreover, we sequentially activated Hsp104 after the onset of protein aggregation and start of tissue degeneration, to find that Hsp104, but not Hsp70, significantly suppressed progressive degeneration. Thus, the unique ability of Hsp104 to tackle pre-existing amyloid conformers may offer a novel opportunity to reverse disease progression once underway. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ...................................................................................... iii ABSTRACT .......................................................................................................... iv LIST OF TABLES ................................................................................................ ix LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS ................................................................................... x CHAPTER 1 : INTRODUCTION ........................................................................... 1 HARNESSING THE MOLECULAR DISAGGREGASE HSP104 TO COMBAT THE AMYLOID ACCUMULATION THAT UNDERLIES NEURODEGENERATIVE DISEASE ............................... 2 Protein aggregation underlies neurodegenerative disease .................................................. 3 Molecular chaperones: a natural defense against protein misfolding ................................ 7 HSPs in treating neurodegenerative disease ....................................................................... 11 Can chaperones reverse neurodegenerative disease? ....................................................... 15 CHAPTER 2 : MANUSCRIPT ............................................................................. 19 HSP104 SUPPRESSES POLYGLUTAMINE-INDUCED DEGENERATION POST ONSET IN A DROSOPHILA MJD/SCA3 MODEL. ............................................................................................ 19 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................... 20 RESULTS ..................................................................................................................................... 24 Hsp104 mitigates toxicity of truncated MJD, but enhances toxicity of the full-length MJD .................................................................................................................................................. 24 The opposite effects of Hsp104 on MJDtrQ78 and MJDnQ78 correspond to distinct modulation of underlying protein accumulations ................................................................ 27 Domains neighboring the expanded PolyQ tract hinder protective Hsp104 activities