DOCSLIB.ORG

MATRONA and RABBI JOSE: an ALTERNATIVE INTERPRETATION by TAL ILAN Jerusalem It Has Been Noted in the Past, That the Debates

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
MATRONA and RABBI JOSE: an ALTERNATIVE INTERPRETATION by TAL ILAN Jerusalem It Has Been Noted in the Past, That the Debates MATRONA AND RABBI JOSE: AN ALTERNATIVE INTERPRETATION BY TAL ILAN Jerusalem It has been noted in the past, that the debates (or perhaps study sessions) taking place between Rabbi Jose ben Halafta and a cer- tain Matrona, form a unique corpus of traditions in the midrashic literature'). In these pericopes (20 according to my calculation)2), 1) Z. FRAENKEL,"Zur Geschichte der jildischen Religionsgespräche", MGWJ IV (1855), pp. 206-209; M.D. HERR, "Dialogues between Sages and Roman Dignitaries", in Studiesin Aggadahand Folk Literature, ed. I. HEINEMANN,D. Noy, Jerusalem 1971 ( = Scripta Hierosolymitana XXII), pp. 146-149; F. B6HL, "Die Matronenfrage im Midrasch", Frankfurter judaistischeBeitrdge III (1975), pp. 29-64; R. GERSHONZON,E. SLOt..tomc, "A Second Century Jewish-Gnostic Debate. Rabbi Jose ben Halafta and the Matrona", Journal for the Study of Judaism XVI (1985), pp. 1-41. The last three will henceforth be referred to as HERB,BBHL and GERSHONZONand SLOMOVIC. 2) (1) Genesis Rabbah 1:7, THEODOR-ALBECKedition, p. 30, cf. Yalkut 5, SHILONIedition, p. 23; (2) 17:7, p. 158, cf. bsanhedrin 39a, Abot de Rabbi Nathan Version B 8, SCHECHTERedition, pp. 23-24, Yalkut 23 pp. 82-83, J. MANN, The Bible as Read and Preachedin the Old SynagogueII, Cincinnati 1940, p. 26 (Hebrew Section), M. GASTER,Exampla of the Rabbis, New York 1968, p. 34:LV; (3) 25:1, p. 239, cf. Yalkut 42, p. 146; (4) 63:8, p. 688, cf. Midrash Hagadol to Genesis 25:25, FISCHedition I, pp. 439-440; (5) 68:4, pp. 771-772, cf. Leviticus Rabbah 8:1, MARGALIOTedition, pp. 164-166, Tanhuma Ki Tisa 5, Bamidbar 16, Vayishlakh 10, Matot 6, Tanhuma BUBERedition Bamidbar 18, p. 8b, Matot 9, p. 81a, Psikta de Rab Kahana Ki Tisa 4, MANDELBAUMedition, pp. 18-19, Numbers Rabbah Bamidbar 3:6, Matot 22:8, Samuel Midrash 5:13, Yalkut 28, p. 28, 786, p. 635; (6) 84:21, p. 1027, cf. Tanhuma BUBERVeyeshev 8, p. 91a, Masekhet Semahot 21:9, Yalkut 143, p. 729, Midrash Hagadol to Genesis 37:35 I, pp. 639-640; (7) 87:10 pp. 1070-1071, cf. Yalkut 145, p. 752, Midrash Hagadol to Genesis 39:10 I, pp. 665-666; (8) Leviticus Rabbah 28:6, p. 662, cf. Pesikta de Rab Kahana Misbat Ha'omer 3, p. 143, Pesikta Rabbati Hacomer 18, ISH-SHALOMedition 93a; (9) Pesikta Rabbati Aseret Hadibbrot 21, p. 110b, cf. GASTER,p. 15:XVII; (10) 23, p. 117a, cf. Tanhuma Lekh Lekha 20; Bereshit Rabbati Lekh Lekha 17:1, ALBECKedition, pp. 72-73; (11) Tanhuma BUBERBereshit 2, p. lb, cf. Yalkut 6, p. 25, A. JELLINEK,Bet Hamidrasch V, Jerusalem 1938, p. 155; (12) Bereshit 20, p. 8a; (13) Miketz 9, p. 97a-b, cf. Ecclesiastes Rabbah 1:7:5, GASTER,p. 12:XIII, 28:XL; (14) Ecclesiastes Rabbah 3:21:1, cf. Midrash Zuta to Ecclesiastes 3:21; (15) Exodus Rabbah 3:12:2; (16) Numbers Rabbah 3:2, cf. Samuel Midrash 8:2; (17) Midrash Hagadol to 19 a certain woman, designated Matrona, sets questions based on the text of the Old Testament to the second century sage Rabbi Jose ben Halafta, one of Rabbi Aqiba's famous disciples, one of the chief figures in the post Bar-Kokhba revolt era and a resident of Sephoris. Rabbi Jose answers her either in sympathy or in scorn but never sends her away without satisfaction3). Based on her title-Matrona-scholars from the very beginning assumed that the woman must be a high-class Roman matron residing in Palestine, whose queries represent typical polemical questions set to Jews by various groups of philosophical gentiles and heretics familiar with the Jewish Holy Scriptures. However, all those who have tackled the problem have not been able to agree as to the spiritual identity of the debater or her historicity. FRAENKEL had identified her as a Christian4), BoHL as a Godfearer (sebomene)5), GERSHONZON and SLOMOVIC as a Gnostic6) and HERR as a typical archetype of an anti-Jewish debater representing opi- nions and beliefs of anybody from Stoic to Epicurean to Roman to Christian to Gnostic7). Despite modern skepticism in dealing with rabbinic traditions, all those who have handled the Rabbi Jose and Matrona traditions have not been able to avoid speculating on the historicity of the lady. Although the traditions are set in highly stylized midrashic form, they had, nonetheless, aroused some confidence in all the scholars who have tackled them, and all agreed that, although some Deuteronomy 21:19 V, pp. 602-603; (18) S.A. WERTHEIMER,Batei Midrashot I, Jerusalem 1952, Yelamdenu Pakudei, p. 167; (19) Da(at Zekenim (Tosfot to Genesis) 32:12; (20) Rabbi Judah ben Barzilai, Exegesison the Book of Yetsira, KAUFMANNedition, Berlin 1885, p. 150 (Hebrew). 3) Unlike Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus, when he is confronted with a similar question put forward by a Matrona, according to the Jerusalem Talmud (ySota 3:4, 19a) or a wise woman, according to the Babylonian Talmud (bYoma 66b). Therefore, B6HL'S identification (pp. 39-44) of this pericope as belonging to the same genre as the Rabbi Jose and Matrona traditions is unfounded. Not only is the chief character missing, the woman inconsistently called once matrona and once wise woman, and the compilations in which the story is found, as will be shown below, different, but also the lack of an appropriate answer renders it suspect. 4) FRAENKEL(above, n. 1), cf. also Z.W. BACHER,"Ein polemischer Ausspruch Jose b. Chalafatas", MGWJ XLII (1895), pp. 506-507. 5) B6HL, pp. 58-64. 6) Above, n. 1. 7) Above, n. 1. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Ten Makkos: Middah K'neged Middah According to the Midrash
    D_18365 Ten Makkos: Middah K’neged Middah According to the Midrash By Mr. Robert Sussman Grade Level: Elementary, Middle School, High School, Adult Description: Explanations, based on various midrashim, that display how each of the ten makkos were meted out to the Mitzrim middah k’neged middah. Additional interesting information about each makkah is included in the “Did You Know” sections. Use these professionally designed sheets when preparing to teach the makkos or distribute to students as a supplement to their haggados. Includes a source for each explanation. Instructions: 1. Read through the explanations. 2. Explain the concept of middah k’neged middah, if students are not already familiar with it. 3. Encourage students to figure out how each Makkah was middah k’neged middah. 4. Teach the explanations provided by the Midrash. 5. OPTIONAL: Distribute these sheets to your students. Haggadah Insights Shock and AWE Who doesn’t know the Ten Plagues? Hashem, who is All Powerful, could have done anything to the Egyptians that He wanted, so why did He choose those ten a# ictions? e Midrash teaches that Hashem brought the plagues middah keneged middah (measure for measure). In other words, each one of the plagues was to punish the Egyptians for something they had done to persecute the Children of Israel I BY ROBERT SUSSMAN the ! sh that died in the Nile and the KINIM !LICE" # WHY? stench that was in the air. And a proof of 3 e Egyptians would make the Chil- this is that we see that Pharaoh’s magi- dren of Israel sweep their houses, their cians were able to turn the Nile to blood – streets, and their markets, therefore if it hadn’t returned to its prior state of Hashem changed all of the dust in Egypt being water, how would they have been into lice until there was no more dust to able to do so?! (Chizkuni) sweep.
    [Show full text]
  • Hermeneutics As Poetics: the Case of Midrash Hagadol
    Abstract Hermeneutics as Poetics: The Case of Midrash HaGadol Gilad Shapira One of the fascinating characteristics of Midrash is its dual nature as both poetic and hermeneutic. Late Midrash has been shown to accentuate the literary, rather than the exegetical dimension of given genres (e.g. the Mashal, the retold biblical narrative). This paper addresses the place of hermeneutics in a seminal work of Late Midrash – Midrash HaGadol (Aden, Yemen, 14th century): This discussion is centered on the hermeneutical expression, ‘zehu sheamar hakatuv’ (this is what Scripture said) and the way it functions to create bundles of textual units around thematic focuses, and it indicates their components. Based on that, the paper argues that the function of hermeneutics in Midrash Hagadol is primarily poetic. [Jerusalem Studies in Hebrew Literature, XXXI (2020), pp. 1-25] Abstract The Road to Lydda: A Survivor’s Story Rabban Yohanan ben Zakkai’s Flight from Jerusalem According to Eicha Rabba 1:5 Moshe Shoshan This article presents an analysis of the story of the escape of R. Yohanan ben Zakkai from Jerusalem as it appears in Eicha Rabba. This version of the story differs markedly from the accounts found elsewhere in rabbinic literature, most notably in that it does not refer to R. Yohanan’s request to save ‘Yavne and her sages’. The Eicha Rabba account focuses on the survival of the Jews rather than on the establishment of a center of Jewish study and practice to succeed Jerusalem. Torah is presented as a source of practical wisdom, which gives the rabbis the ability to save a remnant of their people.
    [Show full text]
  • Parshat Matot/Masei
    Parshat Matot/Masei A free excerpt from the Kehot Publication Society's Chumash Bemidbar/Book of Numbers with commentary based on the works of the Lubavitcher Rebbe, produced by Chabad of California. The full volume is available for purchase at www.kehot.com. For personal use only. All rights reserved. The right to reproduce this book or portions thereof, in any form, requires permission in writing from Chabad of California, Inc. THE TORAH - CHUMASH BEMIDBAR WITH AN INTERPOLATED ENGLISH TRANSLATION AND COMMENTARY BASED ON THE WORKS OF THE LUBAVITCHER REBBE Copyright © 2006-2009 by Chabad of California THE TORAHSecond,- revisedCHUMASH printingB 2009EMIDBAR WITH AN INTERPOLATED ENGLISH TRANSLATION AND COMMENTARYA BprojectASED ON of THE WORKS OF ChabadTHE LUBAVITCH of CaliforniaREBBE 741 Gayley Avenue, Los Angeles, CA 90024 310-208-7511Copyright / Fax © 310-208-58112004 by ChabadPublished of California, by Inc. Kehot Publication Society 770 Eastern Parkway,Published Brooklyn, by New York 11213 Kehot718-774-4000 Publication / Fax 718-774-2718 Society 770 Eastern Parkway,[email protected] Brooklyn, New York 11213 718-774-4000 / Fax 718-774-2718 Order Department: 291 KingstonOrder Avenue, Department: Brooklyn, New York 11213 291 Kingston718-778-0226 Avenue / /Brooklyn, Fax 718-778-4148 New York 11213 718-778-0226www.kehot.com / Fax 718-778-4148 www.kehotonline.com All rights reserved, including the right to reproduce this book All rightsor portions reserved, thereof, including in any the form, right without to reproduce permission, this book or portionsin writing, thereof, from in anyChabad form, of without California, permission, Inc. in writing, from Chabad of California, Inc. The Kehot logo is a trademark ofThe Merkos Kehot L’Inyonei logo is a Chinuch,trademark Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • Rosh Hashana 5780: There Must Have Been Tears Rabbanit Leah Sarna
    Rosh Hashana 5780: There Must Have Been Tears Rabbanit Leah Sarna When is the last time you cried? Think back to it. This is an easy exercise for me since I cry all the time-- but for you it might not be. Was it recently? Was it yesterday? Was it years ago? Were you watching a movie? Reading the news? Tears of joy? Tears of sorrow? Frustration? Tears of truth-telling? Tears of empathy? Think back to it. In Great Expectations, Charles Dickens puts into the words of Pip, the main character and narrator, one of my favorite quotes about tears, just as he leaves his sister’s house and his apprenticeship and goes off to London to become a gentleman: “Heaven knows we need never be ashamed of our tears, for they are rain upon the blinding dust of earth, overlying our hard hearts. I was better after I had cried, than before--more sorry, more aware of my own ingratitude, more gentle.” Rain upon the blinding dust of earth, overlying our hard hearts. Tears open our hearts. It’s not always that feelings give way to tears, says Dickens-- often it’s the other way around, tears alert us to feelings, soften us, make us more sorry, more gentle, more whatever it is that we were feeling before --but unable to access. (PART I.) In today’s Haftara we have the tears of Rachel, crying for her exiled children. In yesterday’s Torah and Haftara readings, we encountered a whole lot of tears: the tears of Hagar, the tears of Ishmael, and the tears of Hannah.
    [Show full text]
  • Matot - Massei
    Matot - Massei MATOT In this weeks' Parshah, the Torah tells us to be very careful about making promises so that we don’t accidentally break them. Instead of making a promise, one should say “I hope I can . .” Last week, we read how Pinchas killed Zimri and the Midianite woman when they tried to marry against G-d’s will. G-d now commands the Jewish people to wage war against the Midianites for trying to convince the Jews to act immorally and worship idols. Moshe chooses 1,000 men from each of the twelve tribes to serve as soldiers and appoints Pinchas as one of the leaders of the army. When the Midianites see the Jewish army coming to fight them, they laugh and say, “The Jewish army is so small, we will win over them for sure!” However, with G-d’s help, the Jewish army is victorious over the Midianites without losing even one soldier. After the war is over, two tribes, Reuven and Gad, approach Moshe to make a request. They ask him if they can settle with their families on the east side of the Jordan River instead of crossing the river and entering the Land of Israel. “Why didn’t they want to join the rest of the Jewish People and enter into land of Israel?” you might wonder. Well, these two tribes owned a lot of cattle. They noticed that the land on the east of the Jordan was very fertile, with rich, green grass for their cattle to graze. Also, they knew that Moshe would not be buried in the Land of Israel and so they wanted to remain near Moshe’s burial place.
    [Show full text]
  • CBS Torah Weekly Matot Masei 2020
    J U L Y 1 8 , 2M0 A2 Y0 |8 , M 2A0 T2 O0 T|- ME AMSOERI | P A G E 1 Congregation Beth Sholom TORAH WEEKLY Learning Initiative ז"ל A Project of the Linda Mitgang To sponsor, please click here The Longest Three Weeks BY RABBI KENNETH HAIN ZMANIM [email protected] Candle-lighting 8:04 pm Mincha 7:00 pm Clearly this summer of the pandemic is a summer of our 8:12 pm discontent. Since March we have struggled with increasing 7:45 am restrictions and numbing isolation. Our celebrations are Shacharit Hashkama 8:45 am curtailed and our social interactions are minimal, and now Shacharit Sephardic 9:15 am we find ourselves in the Three Weeks period before Tish A Shacharit Joel Shiff/Main 8:10 pm B’Av and it hardly feels different from the past four months. Mincha Shiur with Rabbi Miller 8:25 pm I have been exploring new understandings of this Three Maariv 9:05 pm Week period. Our son Rabbi Yonah Hain at Columbia Shabbos Ends 9:11 pm University Hillel has shared with me some remarkable ideas and I hope to share them with you next week in a two part IN THIS ISSUE Zoom series – “ The Challenge of Lamentation” Monday, & Tuesday, July 20-21. 1 The Longest Three Weeks Rabbi Hain Much of our tradition focuses on the anticipation of what will 2 On the 5T's Vaad HaKashrus happen after the Three Week period of sadness. A Midrash Rabbi Fogel from Eicha Rabba 1:2 demonstrates this approach: 4 An Alternate Ending to the Torah “…she has no comforter…” (Lamentations 1:2) – R.
    [Show full text]
  • Matot of Bnei Yisrael? 2
    Dear Youth Directors, Youth chairs, and Youth Leaders, NCYI is excited to continue our very successful Parsha Nation Guides. I hope you’re enjoying and learning from Parsha Nation as much as we are. Putting together Parsha Nation every week is indeed no easy task. It takes a lot of time and effort to ensure that each section, as well as each age group, receives the attention and dedication it deserves. We inspire and mold future leaders. The youth leaders of Young Israel have the distinct honor and privilege to teach and develop the youth of Young Israel. Children today are constantly looking for role models and inspirations to latch on to and learn from. Whether it is actual sit-down learning sessions, exciting Parsha trivia games, or even just walking down the hall to the Kiddush room, our youth look to us and watch our every move. It’s not always about the things we say, it’s about the things we do. Our children hear and see everything we do whether we realize it or not. This year we are taking our Youth Services to new heights as we introduce our Leadership Training Shabbaton. This engaging, interactive shabbaton will give youth leaders hands on experience and practical solutions to effectively guide your y outh department. Informal education is key. What the summer shows us as educators is that informal education can deliver better results and help increase our youth’s connection to Hashem. More and more shuls are revamping their youth program to give their children a better connection to shul and to Hashem.
    [Show full text]
  • Through the Tanakh in a Year
    Jul 4 – 10, 2021 Parshat Matot-Masei Aug 15 – 21, 2021 Parshat Ki Teitzei 4 S Job 13–16 15 S Nehemiah 1–3 5 M Job 17–21 16 M Nehemiah 4–6 6 T Job 22–26 17 T Nehemiah 7 8 7 W Job 27–30 18 W Nehemiah 9 10 8 Th Job 31 32 19 Th Nehemiah 11–13 THROUGH THE TANAKH 9/10 Torah Portion: Num30:2 –36:13 20/21 Torah Portion: Deut 21:10–25:19 Haftarah: Isaiah 66:1-24 Haftarah: Isaiah 54:1-10 IN A Y EAR Jul 11 – 17, 2021 Parshat Devarim Aug 22 – 28, 2021 Parshat Ki Tavo 5781 / 2020 — 2021 11 S Job 33–35 22 S A Jewish Bible Reading Plan for 12 M Job 36–38 23 M 13 T Job 39–42 24 T 14 W 25 W 15 Th 26 Th Oct 11 – 17, 2020 Parshat Bereshit Nov 15 – Nov 21, 2020 Parshat Toldot 16/17 Torah Portion: Deut 1:1–3:22 27/28 Torah Portion: Deut 26:1–29:8 11 S Joshua 1–3 15 S 1 Samuel 21–23 Haftarah: Isaiah 1:1-27 Haftarah: Isaiah 60 SIMCHAT TORAH (See *Holidays) 16 M 1 Samuel 24–25 12 M Joshua 4–6 Jul 18 – 24, 2021 Parshat Vaetchanan Aug 29 - Sep 4 Parshat Nitzavim 17 T 1 Samuel 26–27 13 T Joshua 7–9 18 W 1 Samuel 28–31 18 S Ruth 1 2 29 S 14 W Joshua 10–11 19 Th 2 Samuel 1–2 19 M Ruth 3 4 30 M 15 Th Joshua 12–14 20 T 31 T 16/17 Torah Portion: Genesis 1:1–6:8 20/21 Torah Portion: Genesis 25:19–28:9 21 W 1 W Haftarah: I Samuel 20:18-42 Haftarah: Malachi1:1 –2:7 22 Th 2 Th Oct 18 – 24, 2020 Parshat Noach Nov 22 – 28, 2020 Parshat Vayetzei 23/24 Torah Portion: Deut 3:23–7:11 3/4 Torah Portion: Deut 29:9–30:20 Haftarah: Isaiah 40:1-26 Haftarah: Isaiah61:10 —63:9 18 S Joshua 15–18 22 S 2 Samuel 3–5 19 M Joshua 19–21 23 M 2 Samuel 6–8 Jul 25 – 31, 2021 Parshat Eikev Sept
    [Show full text]
  • Studies in Rabbinic Hebrew
    Cambridge Semitic Languages and Cultures Heijmans Studies in Rabbinic Hebrew Studies in Rabbinic Hebrew Shai Heijmans (ed.) EDITED BY SHAI HEIJMANS This volume presents a collec� on of ar� cles centring on the language of the Mishnah and the Talmud — the most important Jewish texts (a� er the Bible), which were compiled in Pales� ne and Babylonia in the la� er centuries of Late An� quity. Despite the fact that Rabbinic Hebrew has been the subject of growing academic interest across the past Studies in Rabbinic Hebrew century, very li� le scholarship has been wri� en on it in English. Studies in Rabbinic Hebrew addresses this lacuna, with eight lucid but technically rigorous ar� cles wri� en in English by a range of experienced scholars, focusing on various aspects of Rabbinic Hebrew: its phonology, morphology, syntax, pragma� cs and lexicon. This volume is essen� al reading for students and scholars of Rabbinic studies alike, and appears in a new series, Studies in Semi� c Languages and Cultures, in collabora� on with the Faculty of Asian and Middle Eastern Studies at the University of Cambridge. As with all Open Book publica� ons, this en� re book is available to read for free on the publisher’s website. Printed and digital edi� ons, together with supplementary digital material, can also be found here: www.openbookpublishers.com Cover image: A fragment from the Cairo Genizah, containing Mishnah Shabbat 9:7-11:2 with Babylonian vocalisati on (Cambridge University Library, T-S E1.47). Courtesy of the Syndics of Cambridge University Library. Cover design: Luca Baff a book 2 ebooke and OA edi� ons also available OPEN ACCESS OBP STUDIES IN RABBINIC HEBREW Studies in Rabbinic Hebrew Edited by Shai Heijmans https://www.openbookpublishers.com © 2020 Shai Heijmans.
    [Show full text]
  • Haftarah Text Pdfs
    Index of the current directory: /hazzan/readings/haftarot/ Click on any name to view a file or move into (display the contents of) a directory. Or select the button next to a file or directory and then choose from the list of actions. Select Name Size Created Type Unknown haftarah shelach lecha.pdf 48491 bytes Jun 15 17:11 File Unknown haftarah acharei mot kedoshim.pdf 38023 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah acharei mot.pdf 38977 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah balak.pdf 40851 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah bechukotai.pdf 41487 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah behaalotecha.pdf 44857 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah behar bechukotai.pdf 41514 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah behar.pdf 46847 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah bemidbar machar chodesh.pdf 48332 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah bemidbar.pdf 43939 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah bereishit.pdf 48268 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah beshalach.pdf 60566 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah bo.pdf 41833 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah chayei sarah.pdf 50599 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah chukat balak.pdf 40896 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah chukat rosh chodesh.pdf 50178 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah devarim.pdf 45072 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah ekev.pdf 47647 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah emor.pdf 41739 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah fast day mincha.pdf 41597 bytes Jun 15 17:09 File Unknown haftarah haazinu.pdf 48168 bytes Jun
    [Show full text]
  • Why Was the Tabernacle So Important? (Vayak-Hel)
    Sat 5 Mar 2016 – 25 Adar I 5776 B”H Dr Maurice M. Mizrahi Congregation Adat Reyim D’var Torah on Vayak-hel Why was the Tabernacle so important? This week's Torah portion, Vayak-hel, continues the long instructions for the building of the Tabernacle. The Tabernacle, or portable sanctuary, or Mishkan in Hebrew, containing the Ark of the Covenant, is the prototype of the future Temple, or Bet ha-Mikdash. God gives very detailed instructions on how to build it, stretching over many Torah portions, beginning with Parshat Terumah. One wonders: Why was the Tabernacle so important that it had to be built just so? Why so many verses devoted to it compared with other mitzvot? Let us begin with some examples of its perceived importance: -The Talmud, the Midrash, and the Zohar all say that the Mishkan came before the creation of the world. The Talmud says: It was taught: The following seven things were created before the world: The Torah, repentance, the Garden of Eden, Gehennom, the Throne of Glory, the Temple and the name of the Messiah [Pesachim 54a, also Gen. R. 1:4, Zohar, Tzav 34b]. This means that these things are at the very foundation of the world. -The Book of Samuel tells us that when the Philistines captured the Mishkan, the Israelites were thrown in despair. So much so that ‘Eli, a prominent judge and High Priest, and his pregnant daughter-in-law both died from the shock. [1Samuel 4]. -The number of lines in the Torah devoted to the Mishkan is far greater than the number of lines devoted to the creation of the world! A commentator has said that the reason is that it is easy for God to make a place for people to dwell in, but more difficult for people to make a place for God to dwell in.
    [Show full text]
  • Parashat Matot Masei
    Kol Rina An Independent Minyan Matot-Masei August 3, 2019 *** 2 Av, 5779 Kol Rina – An Independent Minyan, is a traditional egalitarian community. We are haimish (homey/folksy), friendly, participatory, warm and welcoming. We hold weekly services in South Orange as well as holiday services and celebrations which are completely lay led. We welcome all to our services and programs from non-Hebrew readers to Jewish communal and education professionals. Today's Portions 1: 33:50-34:15..............p. 957 5: 35:16-29….....p. 963 2: 34:16-29...................p. 960 6: 35:30-34….....p. 965 3: 35:1-8........................p. 961 7: 36:1-13....….....p. 965 4: 35:9-15......................p. 962 maf: 36:10-13.....p. 967 Haftarah for Ashkenazim: Jeremiah 2:4 - 28; 3:4.............p. 973 Matot-Masei in a Nutshell https://www.chabad.org/parshah/article_cdo/aid/2244/jewish/Matot-Massei-in-a-Nutshell.htm Moses conveys the laws governing the annulment of vows to the heads of the tribes of Israel. War is waged against Midianfor their role in plotting the moral destruction of Israel, and the Torah gives a detailed account of the war spoils and how they were allocated amongst the people, the warriors, the Levitesand the high priest. The tribes of Reuben and Gad (later joined by half of the tribe of Manasseh) ask for the lands east of the Jordan as their portion in the Promised Land, these being prime pastureland for their cattle. Moses is initially angered by the request, but subsequently agrees on the condition that they first join, and lead, in Israel’s conquest of the lands west of the Jordan.
    [Show full text]