Introduction to the Committee
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1 League of Nations LIMUN 2021 Table of Contents Directors’ Welcome 3 Introduction to the Dais 4 President - Dan Mikhaylov 4 President - Annabelle Ghanem 4 Introduction to the Committee 5 History of the Committee 5 Structure and Functions of the Committee 6 Question of Colonial Possessions, Leased, and Occupied Territories in the Far East 7 Topic Background 7 Introduction 7 Timeline 8 Discussion 12 The Lytton Report 13 China’s Position in International Society 14 Self-Determination in Korea and Indochina 15 The Future of Class C Mandates 16 Bloc Positions 18 Japan 18 European Colonial Powers 18 Far Eastern States 20 Points a Resolution Should Address 21 Further Reading 22 Bibliography 23 2 League of Nations LIMUN 2021 Directors’ Welcome Dear Delegates, It is our greatest pleasure to welcome you to the 2021 edition of the London International Model United Nations. We sincerely hope that this conference will remain an informative and rewarding experience for you despite not being in-person. More than two decades onwards and persevering in the face of the existing coronavirus pandemic adversity, LIMUN continues to attract students from different corners of the globe to debate and discuss the international issues that matter to all of mankind. LIMUN is unwavering in its commitment to providing a forum for constructive dialogue and instilling in its participants an understanding of the principles of collaboration and cooperation. We are honoured to present you the League of Nations committee precisely a century after the first recorded Model League of Nations simulation took place in London. In this committee, we will focus on the colonial possessions and occupied territories in the Far East and endeavour to reconcile the conflicting interests of the colonial powers with the notions of international security and self-determination for non-European powers. The topic is sufficiently broad and multidimensional to allow fruitful debate and a variety of solutions but requires that delegates compromise and negotiate. This study guide has been designed to offer a research framework suited to this task and highlight areas that should be discussed in the committee. We strongly encourage you to peruse it as you develop your solutions. To stand out and ensure the most productive committee session possible, we further recommend reading from various other sources and pondering on creative solutions that we might not have covered in this guide. If you have questions before or during the conference, whether concerning procedural matters or the content of our ensuing discussion, do not hesitate to contact us. Best of luck, Dan Mikhaylov and Annabelle Ghanem (LoN Directors) [email protected] 3 League of Nations LIMUN 2021 Introduction to the Dais President - Dan Mikhaylov I am an undergraduate student at the London School of Economics and Political Science, hoping to work in asset management or hedge funds upon graduation. I am active in the MUN circuit, whence you might find me chairing Security Council or NATO at another conference. Outside university, I am an amateur investor, whose small portfolio comprises stocks from four different continents, and a freelance political journalist. My greatest highlight was securing a research fellowship at the Pinsker Centre, a think tank specialising in Middle Eastern and Israeli affairs. I look forward to watching delegates experiment with this exciting new format and negotiate their way out of the stalemate, which the League of Nations failed to do. I hope that this simulation will provide a memorable learning experience and is enthused to meet all the delegates. President - Annabelle Ghanem I am an undergraduate student at the American University of Beirut double majoring in Political Science and Education, with a minor in International Law. I began my MUN journey in high school, having won multiple awards as both a Delegate and Chair in various international conferences, while serving in multiple leadership roles. In the year 2021, I am set to Chair in over five international conferences stretching from the borders of Pakistan, all the way to the borders of New York City. I also am the Secretary-General for Beirut International Model United Nations 2021. Beyond the academic and MUN realms, I also work as a writer and Chief of the Internship Program at The Phoenix Daily, an independent Lebanese newspaper in Beirut. I look forward to welcoming hardworking and spirited delegates to the League of Nations committee at LIMUN 2021, and am beyond excited to witness the intellectual contributions and solutions that shall be drafted and debated upon throughout the conference. I sincerely hope that this simulation will be an exceptionally unique and grand experience for all participating delegates. 4 League of Nations LIMUN 2021 Introduction to the Committee After the devastating first World War finally ended in 19181, it became evident that the coexistence of states with no international mediation or regulation present was a farfetched idea. Thus in 1920, the League of Nations was formed, and headquartered in Geneva, Switzerland. The entity served as an international forum tasked with mediating, resolving, and settling international disputes that arise, particularly throughout the transition period post World War 1.2 History of the Committee One year after the First World War had officially come to an end, Central and Allied Powers made their way to France in order to sign the treaty of Versailles, a document that has been having an impact on the political spectrum of the world to this very day.3 The Paris Conference founded the stepping stones for the League of Nations, with former American President Woodrow Wilson strongly advocating for the establishment of an international body in his “Fourteen Points for Peace.”4 The Treaty of Versailles initiated the formation of the League in 1919, which soon had 44 member states from all corners of the globe participating. Shockingly enough, the United States of America was not one of them, due to prevailing isolationism in the American political thinking at the time. On the 10th of January 1920, the League of Nations ratified its first treaty, the Treaty of Versailles, officially ending the First World War. However, the work had just begun for the League beyond that point. Since then, the entity became responsible for resolving all political disputes around the world. The League's most notable achievements include, resolving the Swedish- Finnish clash over the Aaland islands, safeguarding Albania, lifting Austria out of financial distress, while continuously supporting refugees and people in need. The entity’s success managed to maintain peace for over a decade. States began turning to the League of Nations for support against invasions led by other states. However, quite often, the League’s jurisdiction did not cover particular nations who never signed on as member states. A primary example of the League’s weakness is when the entity rejected Persia’s plea 1 Lengel, “To Conquer Hell.” 2 Potter, “Origin of the System of Mandates under the League of Nations.” 3 Sharp, “The Enforcement of the Treaty of Versailles, 1919–1923.”. 4 LaSaine, “Wilson, Woodrow (1856–1924).” 5 League of Nations LIMUN 2021 for help against Russia’s invasion. Russia was never invited to take part in the League of Nations due to its communist ideology. Thus the League’s jurisdiction did not extend onto the state, and no interference was able to have been made. Structure and Functions of the Committee The League of Nations began with 42 founding member states and consisted of three main organs.5 The first organ was the Secretariat, which consisted of a Secretary-General appointed by the council, with additional staff providing administrative support. This organ was tasked with preparing the agenda and publishing the treaties adopted by the League. In other words, the civil service of the League. The second organ was the Council, an authoritative sub-body tasked with safeguarding world peace. The council’s membership and structure was changed on multiple occasions, resulting with a total number of 5 permanent members, the United Kingdom, France, Italy, Japan, and later on, Germany, as well as 9 non-permanent members chosen and elected by the Assembly, the third organ. The Assembly was the largest organ of the League of Nations, where each and every member state was invited and equally represented by one vote. The Assembly sessions were held once every year. These three bodies were the foundation of the structure of the League of Nations.6 Several committees were created as the years went on, each tackling a particular sector such as health, labour laws, refugee rights, and more. Funding was one of the key aspects of the entity’s success, having helped multiple states out of economic despair, such as Austria. The funding was mainly generated by powerful member states who made generous contributions, particularly the permanent members of the council.7 5 “League of Nations.” SSRN, June 5, 2009.". 6 Ibid. 7 Singer, “The Finances of the League of Nations: International Organization.” 6 League of Nations LIMUN 2021 Question of Colonial Possessions, Leased, and Occupied Territories in the Far East Topic Background Introduction This topic presents a challenging case for delegates to consider; we shall set our starting date in October 1932. The Far East, hereinafter taken to include East Asia, Indochina, and the Pacific islands adjacent to them, has been subjected to the establishment of foreign concessions by local polities to European colonial powers and Japan. Furthermore, the so-called “unequal treaties”, many of which came about in the aftermath of colonial conflicts, and the 1920 Paris Peace Conference created a series of leased and occupied territories in the Far East.8 Such splintering of the Far Eastern states’ sovereignty, most visible in China, and the concomitant subjugation of smaller Far Eastern states, such as Indochina (present-day Vietnam) and Korea, has contributed to the rise of regional nationalism.