DOCSLIB.ORG

Comparison and Analysis of Methods for Migrating Legacy Systems to SOA

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Comparison and Analysis of Methods for Migrating Legacy Systems to SOA MATEC Web of Conferences 77, 04005 (2016) DOI: 10.1051/matecconf/20167704005 ICMMR 2016 Comparison and analysis of methods for migrating legacy systems to SOA LIU Dong1,ZHANG Caihuan2 1Dept. of Information Technology, Luoyang Normal University, 471022 Luoyang Henan, China 2Dept. of Mathematics, Luoyang Normal University, 471022 Luoyang Henan, China Abstract. Migration of legacy systems to SOA has caught lots of attention in both academic and industry. People have proposed many methods, such as wrapping, reengineering etc. However, various characteristics of legacy systems can make the migration complicated, and different enterprises can afford different level migration cost. In this paper, the existing methods and options for evolving legacy systems are compared, and their advantages and disadvantages are identified respectively. Different adaptive situations are listed to assist in making migration decision. 1 Introduction Simple standards that define the available interfaces and structure of data that is The generic term legacy systems has been coined to refer conveyed across those interfaces. to existing IT assets that have been deployed in the past, Platform and language-independent interfaces and in many cases, may have come into the enterprise as based on these standards, which allow a result of a merger or acquisition. No standard definition application to invoke services operating on any exists. There are a set of common features: large device supporting the SOA regardless of the scale(often millions of lines of monolithic code); old age; hardware platform, operating system, or obsolete languages such as assembler; lack of consistent implementation language. (or any) documentation; poor management of data; Clear separation of service interface from degraded structure following years of modification; and implementation, thus allowing many service finally, a support team which is totally reliant on the updates to occur without impact on service expertise and knowledge of expert individuals. These users. factors together cause the cost of maintenance support to Ь Message-based communication allowing be very high, and the applications backlog to be distribution across a wide area. unacceptable [1]. However, it is an undeniable fact that Loose coupling between services, minimize legacy systems generally consist of invaluable assets with interdependencies and facilitating reuse. embedded business logic representing many years of Mechanisms for discovery of services available coding, developments, enhancements, and modifications. and for establishing connections with services. In addition, legacy systems is generating unusually high Clearly, one of the most attractive features of SOA to profit margins in many cases and thus, are responsible for many organizations is that SOA offers the promise of a large amount of a company’s operating profit. enabling legacy systems to expose their functionality as Consequently, many business and IT benefits are realized services without making significant changes to the legacy from reusing legacy assets, evolving them to integrate systems themselves. with or migrate to modern platforms and architectures Over the past few years, migration of legacy systems like Service Oriented Architecture (SOA). to SOA has caught lots of attention in both academic and SOA has become an increasingly popular paradigm at industry. People have proposed many methods, such as present for achieving interoperability between systems wrapping, reengineering etc. However, various because it provides a standard based conceptual characteristics of legacy systems, such as age, language, framework. At the core of an SOA is a service. A service and architecture, as well as the target SOA environment, is a coarse-grained, discoverable, and self-contained can make the migration complicated. In addition to this, software entity that interacts with applications and other different enterprises can afford different level migration services through a loosely coupled, often asynchronous, cost. So it may not be immediately obvious whether to message-based communication model [2]. Proponents migrate or not and which method be suitable for a suggest a long list of advantages [3]: specific organization. In this paper, we compare the © The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). MATEC Web of Conferences 77, 04005 (2016) DOI: 10.1051/matecconf/20167704005 ICMMR 2016 existing methods and options for legacy systems, solved. However, There are some cases where the especially legacy systems with many applications, and freezing approach may be a good option, if: identify their advantages and disadvantages respectively. The size of the application is small. Different adaptive situations are listed to assist in making The cost of ownership is low. migration decision. Critical business is not embedded in the The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. In application. Section 2, a few existing methods of migration to SOA The application is generating low profit are listed. Their advantages and disadvantages are margins for organization. compared and analysed. Accordingly, their adaptive The application changes infrequently. situations are identified respectively. Section 3, illustrates The application has low integration needs with the related works and highlights the main contributions, other ones. and Section 4 concludes the paper. 2.3 Rewrite 2 Comparison and analysis of the existing methods Rewriting means to retire the application and outsource or re-develop from ground-up. Actually, Rewriting is not one of the methods advocated by SOA proponents. But, it 2.1 requirements and background may make sense because of the following advantages: It can deliver a complete customized solution Generally, the primary motivation for migration to SOA that can be built exactly to meet the is based on one or more of the following requirements: organization’s need. reduce the high cost of ownership; accelerate time to market; monolithic architecture with little or no It is a “big-bang” approach to solve the main modularity together with redundant code. closed and problem. obsolete technology; decreasing developers skilled in New and standards-compliant technologies are existing systems; lack of vendor support; lack of introduced. consistent documentation. The organization can gain the control of In the following subsection, we will base our software source code base. comparison and analysis on the aforementioned New added values are brought by leveraging requirements. Before presenting our findings, let’s SOA. consider a situation: an enterprise has many applications. There are a few shortcomings that make many Recently, the enterprise has decided to adopt SOA and consider the approach incompliant with the idea of SOA: developed a SOA infrastructure. A question to be Legacy assets cannot be reused so that addressed is which application should be migrated to investment in the past is lost. SOA, which method be suitable for it and how. The May be risky and long time consuming. answer will be various for different application and May be high cost. organization. Our findings provide baseline for making Although these shortcoming evidents, in the situations decision through comparison and analysis of different below, this may be an appropriate method. methods. It is difficult to understand the business rules embedded in the application. 2.2 Freeze The size of the application is small. The application involves obsolete or difficult The term “freeze” means that the organization decides to maintain technologies. that no further work on the legacy application should be The application needs to be customized. performed. Although freezing seems to sound absurd, it Organization needs the control of software may make sense to deal with some specific application. source code base. In fact, people always justify a project at first according Reliable outsource partner or people of to the value and the state of the art of an application as development and maintenance skilled in SOA well as cost-benefit analysis. Manager would prefer to exist. have an application maintain its current state in many cases. The freezing approach has four advantages: 2.4 Replace No additional cost input. Replacement sometimes is easy to be confused with No time consuming. rewriting. Replacement here refers to replace an No risk of failure. application with an Commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) Continue to keep profit generated by the legacy package. Some common advantages and disadvantages application. exist between replacement and rewriting methods, for Of course, the disadvantages of this approach are also example, both belong to “big-bang” approach, both bring evident. All requirements mentioned above can’t be met. new added value by leveraging SOA, both introduce new The main pain points organization faced with cannot be and standards-compliant technologies, however ,both throw all the legacy assets away and lose the investment 2 MATEC Web of Conferences 77, 04005 (2016) DOI: 10.1051/matecconf/20167704005 ICMMR 2016 in the existing application. A particular advantage is less As defined by Chikofsky and Cross [4], reengineering is risky and time consuming. Some disadvantages the examination and alteration of a subject system to differentiating from rewriting method are listed below. reconstitute it in
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Software Evolution Objectives
    Software evolution Objectives To explain why change is inevitable if software systems are to remain useful To discuss software maintenance and maintenance cost factors To describe the processes involved in software evolution To discuss an approach to assessing evolution strategies for legacy systems Topics covered Program evolution dynamics Software maintenance Evolution processes Legacy system evolution Software change Software change is inevitable New requirements emerge when the software is used The business environment changes Errors must be repaired New computers and equipment is added to the system The performance or reliability of the system may have to be improved A key problem for organisations is implementing and managing change to their existing software systems Importance of evolution Organisations have huge investments in their software systems - they are critical business assets To maintain the value of these assets to the business, they must be changed and updated The majority of the software budget in large companies is devoted to evolving existing software rather than developing new software Spiral model of evolution Program evolution dynamics Program evolution dynamics is the study of the processes of system change After major empirical studies, Lehman and Belady proposed that there were a number of ‘laws’ which applied to all systems as they evolved There are sensible observations rather than laws. They are applicable to large systems developed by large organisations. Perhaps less applicable in other cases Lehman’s laws Law Description Continuing change A program that is used in a real-world environment necessarily must change or become progressively less useful in that environment. Increasing complexity As an evolving program changes, its structure tends to become more complex.
    [Show full text]
  • Software Evolution of Legacy Systems a Case Study of Soft-Migration
    Software Evolution of Legacy Systems A Case Study of Soft-migration Andreas Furnweger,¨ Martin Auer and Stefan Biffl Vienna University of Technology, Inst. of Software Technology and Interactive Systems, Vienna, Austria Keywords: Software Evolution, Migration, Legacy Systems. Abstract: Software ages. It does so in relation to surrounding software components: as those are updated and modern- ized, static software becomes evermore outdated relative to them. Such legacy systems are either tried to be kept alive, or they are updated themselves, e.g., by re-factoring or porting—they evolve. Both approaches carry risks as well as maintenance cost profiles. In this paper, we give an overview of software evolution types and drivers; we outline costs and benefits of various evolution approaches; and we present tools and frameworks to facilitate so-called “soft” migration approaches. Finally, we describe a case study of an actual platform migration, along with pitfalls and lessons learned. This paper thus aims to give software practitioners—both resource-allocating managers and choice-weighing engineers—a general framework with which to tackle soft- ware evolution and a specific evolution case study in a frequently-encountered Java-based setup. 1 INTRODUCTION tainability. We look into different aspects of software maintenance and show that the classic meaning of Software development is still a fast-changing environ- maintenance as some final development phase after ment, driven by new and evolving hardware, oper- software delivery is outdated—instead, it is best seen ating systems, frameworks, programming languages, as an ongoing effort. We also discuss program porta- and user interfaces. While this seemingly constant bility with a specific focus on porting source code.
    [Show full text]
  • A Technique for Legacy System Re-Engineering
    International Journal of Management and Applied Science, ISSN: 2394-7926 Volume-2, Issue-12, Special Issue-1, Dec.-2016 INFORMATION SYSTEM INTEGRATION: A TECHNIQUE FOR LEGACY SYSTEM RE-ENGINEERING EMOKPAE OSATOHANMWEN Dept of Computer Engineering, Institute of Opencast Mining and Technology. Agbor Road Benin City, Nigeria. E-mail:[email protected] Abstract - Many organizations are still faced with the problems of converting applications written in legacy compilers such as COBOL, PASCAL ANS FORTRAN etc. into internet compliant applications. This has become necessary because most internet-based applications are written in C++, Java and Ms.Net. The objective of this paper is to show how information system integration can aid in the forward engineering of legacy system. Software re-engineering covers the examination and alteration of legacy system in order to rebuild it according to modem software engineering methods and technologies in a forward engineering process. Information system integration provides a means for both understanding and capturing about the application and its domain and re-developing the system based on change requirement. Information system integration helps to rebuild any legacy by adopting modern software engineering principles, methods and technologies, which allows systems to architecture engineers over the years have devises many modernization techniques. This paper evaluates the use of information system integration as a veritable technique for transformation of legacy system. Keywords - COBOL, PASCAL, FORTRANS, C++,Java Ms.Net etc I. INTRODUCTION streamlining business processes to the software used. There are five levels of integrating information Many organizations are still faced with the problem system, which include data, data management, of converting applications written in Legacy middleware, application and user interface (Bizer, compilers such as COBOL, Pascal and FORTRAN 2003).
    [Show full text]
  • The 2020 Guide to Legacy System Innovation
    The 2020 Guide to Legacy System Innovation Legacy Systems The Keys A New Freedom for 2 APIs 4 6 8 Meet the to Freedom Approach to the Future 21st Century Modernization. The 2020 Guide to Legacy System Innovation Legacy Systems Meet the 21st Century egacy systems running on mainframe computers are at the heart of our economy – and our society. L They are an essential part of our tax systems, our social services, and our public safety. They also run the stock market, our financial institutions, ATMs, transportation systems and utility grids. In fact, we use them all the time and likely don’t even know it. For state and local governments, these legacy systems are a mixed blessing. On the one hand, they have provided extraordinary reliability. They’ve proved themselves with successful track records of 20, 30, or APIs even 40 years. On the other hand, they are rigid, and some would even say fragile, closed and expensive to maintain. Making changes to a legacy system is costly, risky, and prone to failure. Also, legacy systems are by nature siloed systems that keep their data locked inside where it’s safe, but inaccessible. As one senior public sector IT executive put it, “I feel like my data is in jail.” For decades, agencies have been looking for freedom include day-to-day operations, staffing, responding to from legacy systems—a way off of their existing systems. pressure for innovation from elected officials, application Software AG offers a better, stronger alternative: the users and citizens themselves, and complying with Freedom for Legacy solution.
    [Show full text]
  • Impact Analysis of Legacy System Migration to the Cloud Environment: a Focused Study
    ISSN 2278-3091 Volume 9, No.1, January – February 2020 H. SeetharamaTantry et al., International Journal of Advanced Trends in Computer Science and Engineering, 9(1), January – February 2020, 134 – 141 International Journal of Advanced Trends in Computer Science and Engineering Available Online at http://www.warse.org/IJATCSE/static/pdf/file/ijatcse21912020.pdf https://doi.org/10.30534/ijatcse/2020/21912020 Impact Analysis of Legacy System Migration to the Cloud Environment: A Focused Study H. SeetharamaTantry1, Murulidhar N.N2., K. Chandrasekaran3 1 Department of Mathematics & Computational Sciences, National Institute of Technology Karnataka, Surathkal, India, e-mail: [email protected] 2 Department of Mathematics & Computational Sciences, National Institute of Technology Karnataka, Surathkal, India, e-mail: [email protected] 3 Department of Computer Science and Engineering, National Institute of Technology Karnataka, Surathkal, India, e-mail: [email protected] ABSTRACT creating, and recycling the software modules and platforms when expected maintenance follow-ups can never again Although “Legacy System” frameworks are frequently accomplish the ideal framework properties. The essential worked over numerous years by a blend of IT and business point of software modernization [1] is to decrease support specialists. They stay inflexible inside the authoritative cost and increase adaptability. The majority of these setting and business speculation made by practical frameworks were created years back and have kept on applications. Semantic Design provides highly automated advancing. New necessities have repeated changes on these tools and services to migrate legacy system to a new legacy system bringing about unstructured source code that platform. The proposed migration of the legacy software life is hard to keep up.
    [Show full text]
  • Enterprise Application Integration Using Service Oriented Architecture with Generic Pattern
    International Journal of Current Engineering and Technology E-ISSN 2277 – 4106, P-ISSN 2347 - 5161 ® ©2014 INPRESSCO , All Rights Reserved Available at http://inpressco.com/category/ijcet Research Article Enterprise Application Integration using Service Oriented Architecture with Generic Pattern Nilesh Vishwasrao PatilȦ*, M. C. KshirsagarȦ and P. C. JaypalȦ ȦVishwbharati Academy College of Engineering, Ahmednagar, Pune University Accepted 01 Oct 2014, Available online 10 Oct 2014, Vol.4, No.5 (Oct 2014) Abstract Nowadays the computer world is almost migrating from the tightly coupled architecture to loosely coupled architecture directly or indirectly. There are many intentions of Enterprise Application Integration in the organizations to achieved desired functions. The main objective of the Enterprise Application Integration is to implement integration layer between heterogeneous and/or homogeneous systems using Service Oriented Architecture in the direction of achieving the loosely coupled architecture. The integration architecture we have today is very limited and need to improve it as agile as possible. The reusability is not the new thing for software industry; it has been playing the crucial part in the software life cycle development process from last decade. Software industry has achieved the powerful accomplishment in throughput and preeminence because of reusability in software development process instead of creating same thing again and again. In this paper, we will discuss about Enterprise Application Integration using Service Oriented Architecture for achieving loosely coupled architecture directly or indirectly with the help of Web Services or Messaging Queue services. Keywords: SOA: Service Oriented Architecture, WS: Web services, WSDL: Web Service Description/Definition Language, W-SOA: Web Service Oriented Architecture, ESB: Enterprise Service Bus.
    [Show full text]
  • Addressing Software Related Issues on Legacy Systems – a Review
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENTIFIC & TECHNOLOGY RESEARCH VOLUME 9, ISSUE 03, MARCH 2020 ISSN 2277-8616 Addressing Software Related Issues On Legacy Systems – A Review Mubashir Ali, Shahzad Hussain, Mahmood Ashraf, Mahnoor Khalid Paracha Abstract: In current technological era, organizations and systems are moving towards automation. Software development always played a sensitive role and software maintenance continually bring challenges for developers. The problem of legacy systems is continuously travels with time. Technologically outdated software or computer systems are known as legacy systems. While software or system development, whatever technique or technology adopted by developers, current developed systems will be the legacy of future. Due to constant advancement in computing, legacy systems are not supporting the technologically updated software. Replacing or updating legacy systems and development of requirement oriented new systems as substitute brings many challenges like budget, time, data movement, training etc. Most of the small level and middle level companies are not able to face these challenges. This paper will conduct an extensive review to highlight the software related issues and their respective solution on legacy systems. The old legacy systems will be used with technologically updated software to fulfill the current requirements. This solution made the scope wider by reusing the available system, refining it with latest features, providing architecture of updated software installation and maintenance that reduce
    [Show full text]
  • Mitigating Cyber Security Risks in Legacy Process Control Systems
    Process Solutions White Paper Mitigating Cyber Security Risks in Legacy Process Control Systems Executive Summary The term “legacy process control system” has different connotations for different people. To many, it refers to proprietary systems from a past era. To others, the term may imply the new generation DCS that have been founded on open technology, or systems using no-longer-supported Microsoft operating systems. These systems have fundamentally different architectures and present different risks. The continuous evolution of the DCS enabled organizations to protect the investment in equipment and control strategies over long periods of time. However, interfacing decades- old controllers with current technology also makes this equipment indirectly vulnerable to attack. All these systems have one common denominator: they experience gaps in support. This makes them more vulnerable than contemporary systems. This white paper will discuss various techniques for protecting legacy systems, the problems surrounding these techniques, and new methods for analyzing security. Mitigating Cyber Security Risks in Legacy Process Control 2 Systems Table of Contents Introduction ..................................................................................................................................................................................................... 3 How to Prevent or Delay a System from Becoming a Legacy System ................................................................................................... 4 Prevention
    [Show full text]
  • Administering Evergreen Through the Command Line Documentation Interest Group Administering Evergreen Through the Command Line Documentation Interest Group
    Administering Evergreen through the Command Line Documentation Interest Group Administering Evergreen through the Command Line Documentation Interest Group Report errors in this documentation using Launchpad. Table of Contents I. Introduction ............................................................................................................................................................. 7 1. About This Documentation ............................................................................................................................... 9 2. About Evergreen ............................................................................................................................................ 10 II. Installing Evergreen ............................................................................................................................................... 11 3. System Requirements ..................................................................................................................................... 14 Server Minimum Requirements .................................................................................................................... 14 Web Client Requirements ........................................................................................................................... 14 Staff Client Requirements ........................................................................................................................... 14 4. Installing the Evergreen server ........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Legacy Systems Management Needs Improvement
    TREASUR Y INSPECTOR GENERAL FOR TAX ADMINISTRATION Legacy Systems Management Needs Improvement August 19, 2020 Reference Number: 2020-20-044 [email protected] | www.treasury.gov/tigta | 202-622-6500 This report has cleared the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration disclosure review process and information determined to be restricted from public release has been redacted from this document. 1 To report fraud, waste, or abuse, please call us at 1-800-366-4484 HIGHLIGHTS: Legacy Systems Management Needs Improvement Final Audit Report issued on August 19, 2020 Reference Number 2020-20-044 Why TIGTA Did This Audit What TIGTA Found This audit was initiated to assess The IRS has not developed specific or long-term plans to address the IRS’s efforts to identify and updating, replacing, or retiring most of its legacy systems. Through replace its legacy systems. various initiatives, the IRS identified 45 systems for modernization or candidates for modernization and 34 systems for retirement. Impact on Taxpayers While various business units and functions have differing definitions Legacy systems are critical for of a legacy system, the IRS does not have an enterprise-wide many organizations because definition or a complete and accurate inventory of legacy systems. By they support key mission applying the Information Technology organization’s definition of a functionalities. However, they legacy system to the As-Built Architecture (ABA) as of April 29, 2020, can also carry significant risks, TIGTA determined that 288 (43 percent) of the 669 systems in the including increased cybersecurity IRS’s production environment had missing information that prevented threats and maintenance costs.
    [Show full text]
  • Microsoft Windows "Chicago"
    Microsoft Windows ‘‘Chicago’’ Reviewer’s Guide Beta-1 The information discussed in this guide is based on features and functionality present either in the Beta-1 release of Chicago, or planned for a future release. The discussion of Chicago herein, does not represent a commitment on the part of Microsoft for providing or shipping the features and functionality discussed in the final retail product offerings of Chicago. This document is for informational purposes only. MICROSOFT MAKES NO WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, IN THIS DOCUMENT. Table of Contents INTRODUCTION ....................................................1 Welcome ..................................................................................1 Chicago Mission......................................................................1 Where We’ve Been.................................................................................................1 Where We Are Today.............................................................................................1 Where We’re Headed .............................................................................................2 How We Get There.................................................................................................3 A Quick Preview of Chicago’s Top Features ........................4 Even Easier.............................................................................................................4 Faster and More Powerful ......................................................................................5
    [Show full text]
  • Challenges and Success Factors in the Migration of Legacy Systems to Service Oriented Architecture (SOA)
    School of Technology Department of Computer Science Master Thesis Project 30p, Spring 2014 Challenges and success factors in the migration of legacy systems to Service Oriented Architecture (SOA) By Nataliya Vlizko Supervisor: Annabella Loconsole Examiner: Paul Davidsson Abstract Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA) provides a standards-based conceptual framework for flexible and adaptive systems and has become widely used in the recent years because of it. The number of legacy systems has already been migrated to this platform. As there are still many systems under consideration of such migration, we found it relevant to share the existing experience of SOA migration and highlight challenges that companies meet while adopting SOA. As not all of these migrations were successful, we also look into factors that have influence on the success of SOA projects. The research is based on two methods: a literature review and a survey. The results of the thesis include identification and quantitative analysis of the challenges and success factors of SOA projects. We also compare the survey results for different samples (based on the company industry, work area, size, and respondents experience with SOA and respondents job positions). In total, 13 SOA challenges and 18 SOA success factors were identified, analyzed and discussed in this thesis. Based on the survey results, there are three SOA challenges received the highest importance scores: “Communicating SOA Vision”, “Focus on business perspective, and not only IT perspective” and “SOA Governance”. The highest scored SOA success factor is “Business Process of Company”. While comparing different samples of the survey results, the most obvious differences are identified between the results received from people with development related job positions and people with business related job positions, and the results from companies of different sizes.
    [Show full text]