The Governor and the Guard in the Omaha Tram Strike of 1935
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Nebraska History posts materials online for your personal use. Please remember that the contents of Nebraska History are copyrighted by the Nebraska State Historical Society (except for materials credited to other institutions). The NSHS retains its copyrights even to materials it posts on the web. For permission to re-use materials or for photo ordering information, please see: http://www.nebraskahistory.org/magazine/permission.htm Nebraska State Historical Society members receive four issues of Nebraska History and four issues of Nebraska History News annually. For membership information, see: http://nebraskahistory.org/admin/members/index.htm Article Title: The Governor and the Guard in the Omaha Tram Strike of 1935 Full Citation: Mary Cochran Grimes, "The Governor and the Guard in the Omaha Tram Strike of 1935," Nebraska History 69 (1988): 120-130. URL of article: http://www.nebraskahistory.org/publish/publicat/history/full-text/NH1988OmaTramStrike.pdf Date: 5/30/2012 Article Summary: At the height of violence in the Omaha streetcar strike of 1935, Nebraska's new governor, Robert Leroy "Roy" Cochran, called out the National Guard and declared martial law to force the street car company to arbitrate. Cataloging Information: Names: Robert Leroy "Roy" Cochran, Ronald Gephart, Gurdon W Wattles, Jack Shanahan, William Sheets, Richard L Blume, J A C Kennedy, B F Danbaum, John Savage, Walter Jurgensen, H J Paul, Walter Christenson, R B Armstrong, Ernest Bowerman, Clyde Herring, Hugh P Finerty, R N Denham, Guy R Spencer, Floyd B Olson, Roy Towl, Nelson Kraschel, Hugh A Butler, Richard Samardick, H J Paul, Sam W Reynolds, John J Ledwith, Hird Stryker Keywords: martial law; anti-unionism; New Deal; National Industrial Recovery Act, Omaha-Council Bluffs Street Railway Company, Business Men's Association; War Labor Board; Amalgamated Association of Street, Electric, and Motor coach Employees Local 1002; American Federation of Labor; National Industrial Recovery Act; Employees' Protective Association; Paxton Hotel; Midwest Adjustment Company; Omaha Free Ride Association; jitney ordinance; the Unionist; Tram Workers Union; Omaha Central Labor Union; Wagner Act Photographs / Images: April 1935 photo of Omaha streetcar with heavy wire over the windows to protect riders from possible violence; Governor Robert L Cochran; March-June 1935 scrapbook of unidentified newspaper clippings, Roy Towl papers, MS 3534, State Archives, NSHS; Omaha Police Chief Richard Samardick and Adjutant General H J Paul; Remnants of burned out streetcars near Railroad Avenue; Arrival of National Guardsmen in mid-June of 1935; Guy R Spencer cartoon "Speaking of 'Seniority Rights', Omaha World Herald, June 20, 1935; Meeting in the fall of 1935 to plan a toll-free bridge spanning the Missouri: Omaha Mayor Roy Towl, Iowa Governor Clyde L Herring, Nebraska Governor Robert L Cochran, and Council Bluffs Mayor Hugh P Finerty (others not identified) -. ByApril 1935 Omaha streetcars had been equipped with heavy wire over the windows to protect riders from possible violence. Courtesy of John Savage. THE GOVERNOR AND THE GUARD IN THE OMAHA TRAM STRIKE OF 1935 By Mary Cochran Grimes At the height of violence in the Gephart, the primary role of state troops, his subsequent handling of the Omaha streetcar strike of1935 Ne bras militias or the National Guard was 1935 strike represented a more bal ka's new governor, Robert Leroy shifting from fighting Indians to break anced approach to resolving a labor ("Roy") Cochran, called out the ing strikes. This shift conformed to the management conflict. He used his brief National Guard and declared martial thinking of many businessmen who assumption of power in a city accus law. This brought immediate peace, argued that the main purpose of tomed to anti-unionism to force the national attention, and praise from the government was to protect and pro tram company to arbitrate. He was ada press and even from labor, which mote the interests of property.2 mant that the National Guard was in usually dreaded the march of the Government officials routinely used Omaha only to maintain order and not troops.! Not since the late nineteenth state or federal troops as "the prescrip to take sides. century had Nebraska governors re tion applied to industrial disputes" The New Deal brought a changing sorted to military force to maintain with the usual effect of crushing a political climate. For the first time a order. Then, according to Ronald strike.3 presidenthad endorsed legislation, the Several things were unusual about National Industrial Recovery Act of the Omaha tram strike of 1935. The 1933, that made it legal for employees Mary Cochran Grimes is the daughter of Omaha World-Herald said it was the to organize and bargain collectively Robert L. Cochran, governor of Nebraska from 1935 to 1941. She is the editor of first time the city had had a "military through representatives of their own Knights in Fiction: Two Labor Novels of the dictator."4 Though Cochran employed choosing. While conservative Ne 1880s (University of Illinois Press, 1987). the traditional response of calling out braska still had an anti-picketing law, it 120 Omaha Tram Strike of 1935 also had a governor who supported deductions. Finding the company in New Deal measures.5 "fair financial condition," the comp The Omaha-Council Bluffs Street troller thought prospects for improve Railway Company, which operated a ment were good if "business tactics streetcar and bus system throughout leading to betterment of public ser and between the two cities, had a his vice," i.e. lower fares, were adopted. 14 tory of stormy labor relations. Conflict Probably more relevant to its dated from the crushing of a union in traditionally fierce opposition to union 1909 by company president Gurdon W. activity was the fear, shared by other Wattles with support from the Busi Omaha business leaders, that an out ness Men's Association, whose chief side union would "remove the company purpose was to oppose unions. During from the hands of its owners" and give the 1909 strike, Wattles announced that organized labor a foot in the door for the company would "operate its cars, if future gains.IS necessary, under protection of govern In April 1934 a brief strike ended ment itself."6 Another attempted strike when both sides agreed to federal in late 1918 or early 1919 led to the arbitration. The National Labor Board intervention ofthe War Labor Board on sent mediator Richard L. Blume from the side of the tram company.7 The its Kansas City office. Though Blume's Business Men's Association later report granted a five cent retroactive claimed success in keeping Omaha pay increase (which still did not re "the best open shop city of its size in store the ten percent cut of 1933), it the United States."s said nothing about union recognition. One tram company president, "Smil Workers in July rejected Blume's ing Jack" Shanahan (1927 -32), excelled report by a vote of 359 to 1, claiming in the art of smoothing relationships continued discrimination against union 9 Governor Robert L. Cochran. (NSHS with employees. In 1931 there was the C663-7J members. The union called another threat of a strike, but Shanahan strike and Blume returned. This time skillfully gained the replacement of (in effect, a company union). It was workers were appeased with promises two-man cars with those requiring only later revealed that the company paid an to establish a grievance board, further one operator by offering workers a five operative, William Sheets, to stay at arbitration, and the "possibility of an cent-per-hour raise along with the Paxton Hotel for two months under election on collective bargaining." But assurance that there would be no an assumed name while he organized the tram company had no intention of layoffs. However, Shanahan's suc the company union. He was warned to recognizing the union; it merely wanted cessors would be perceived as less take every precaution "to give the to buy time to prepare for the next friendly to labor.lo appearance of independent action."12 strike and to solidify support from After Shanahan left Omaha in 1933, a Claiming that it could not afford Omaha businessmen and politicians. 16 ten percent wage cut was absorbed by wage increases, the company refused Under the counsel of J. A. C. Ken the carmen. Six months later, when the to recognize Local 1002. Company nedy, the company's tactics were National Industrial Recovery Act finances had been hurt by a decline in planned carefully. The company even opened the doors to collective bargain passengers and revenue since 1921, hired mediator Blume as co-counsel ing, a union organizer from Detroit when there had been over 58,000 riders after a shakeup in the Kansas City NLB came to Omaha to help organize the compared to 23,000 in 1934. Fare office. Opposing the union's demand Amalgamated Association of Street, increases in 1925 and 1930 caused for an election to determine represen Electric, and Motor Coach Employees resentment against the tram company tation for collective bargaining, the Local 1002, affiliated with the and reduced ridership. However, the company contended that it had already American Federation of Labor.11 Early company was still making healthy prof negotiated with the union and that no in 1934 the union, claiming 442 of 535 its on its Douglas Street toll bridge, election was requiredP The National eligible workers, gave the tram com popularly regarded as a gold mine.13 In Labor Board agreed in the spring of pany a list of demands concerning 1934 the company claimed a profit of 1935. Two more national mediators wages, hours, and working conditions. $131,411 on its streetcar operations, came to Omaha but the tram company To combat the union, the company se while a city comptroller's audit showed refused further arbitration.