Shakespearean Female Characters in Contemporary Rock Music

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Shakespearean Female Characters in Contemporary Rock Music “Mark the music”: Shakespearean female characters in contemporary rock music by Maria Elisa Montironi 1. INTRODUCTION: STATE OF THE ART AND OBJECTIVES On October 13th, Bob Dylan was awarded the Nobel prize in literature “for having created new poetic expressions within the great American song tradition” (The Nobel Prize in Literature 2017). This honor obliges even the most purist intellectuals to redefine the boundaries of literature, because it assimilates the lyrics of a singer- songwriter to the works of the most celebrated Nobel writers, such as Thomas Mann (1929), Luigi Pirandello (1934), T. S. Eliot (1948), Ernest Miller Hemingway (1954), and Samuel Beckett (1969). This fact helps to introduce my paper, which offers an analysis of offshoots of Shakespearean women characters in classical rock songs, in order to show how these figures are used and reshaped in the lyrics and to examine how these musical products can affect the study of Shakespeare’s reception. The surprise choice of the Swedish academy was welcomed with skepticism, apparently by the winner himself, who did not attend the traditional December Nobel ceremony to accept the prize, but sent a thankful banquet speech.1 Significantly 1 Bob Dylan once said: “I consider myself a poet first and a musician second” (cited in Ricks 2004: IX); but it is at least odd that Bob Dylan did not attend the Nobel ceremony to accept the prize because of pre-existing commitments. Saggi/Ensayos/Essais/Essays Will forever young! Shakespeare & Contemporary Culture – 11/2017 107 enough for the purpose of this paper, in his message Bob Dylan called in Shakespeare while incredulously wondering how music can be considered literature. He wrote: I was out on the road when I received this surprising news, and it took me more than a few minutes to properly process it. I began to think about William Shakespeare, the great literary figure. I would reckon he thought of himself as a dramatist. The thought that he was writing literature couldn’t have entered his head. His words were written for the stage. Meant to be spoken not read. When he was writing Hamlet, I’m sure he was thinking about a lot of different things: “Who’re the right actors for these roles?” “How should this be staged?” “Do I really want to set this in Denmark?” His creative vision and ambitions were no doubt at the forefront of his mind, but there were also more mundane matters to consider and deal with. “Is the financing in place?” “Are there enough good seats for my patrons?” “Where am I going to get a human skull?” I would bet that the farthest thing from Shakespeare’s mind was the question “Is this literature?” […] Like Shakespeare, I too am often occupied with the pursuit of my creative endeavors and dealing with all aspects of life’s mundane matters. (Dylan 2016)2 After more than three months, Bob Dylan finally accepted the prize at a private ceremony in Stockholm and gave his Nobel lecture. Again, he reflected upon the nature of songs and literature, and concluded mentioning Shakespeare together with Homer: Our songs are alive in the land of the living. But songs are unlike literature. They’re meant to be sung, not read. The words in Shakespeare’s plays were meant to be acted on the stage. Just as lyrics in songs are meant to be sung, not read on a page. […] I return once again to Homer, who says, ‘Sing in me, oh Muse, and through me tell the story’. (Dylan 2017) All this further legitimizes a study of popular rock music adaptations of Shakespeare’s women, which in fact needs no justification at the present time academically speaking – neither for studying musical products nor for considering a subject belonging to popular culture in relation to Shakespeare. Time has passed and things have changed since the 1930s, when Cecil Arthur Lewis, one of the BBC’s co-founders, used Shakespeare as a symbol of elitism to denigrate popular music and praise classical music, instead, asserting: “The music doesn’t wear. It cannot be repeated, whereas good music lasts, mellows and gains fresh beauties at every hearing. It stands, like Shakespeare, through the centuries. No passing craze can shake it” (Lewis, cited in Hansen 2011: 219). More recently, popular music has been approached as a text in the field of cultural studies (see, Bennett, Shank and Toynbee (eds.) 2006), and radical, influential literary critics have provided the academy with inclusive research into the Shakespeare myth and into popular culture adaptations of Shakespeare’s words and characters, including musical ones. 2 This correlation between the means of production and consumption of Shakespeare’s and Bob Dylan’s works is also highlighted by Ricks (2003: 149). Saggi/Ensayos/Essais/Essays Will forever young! Shakespeare & Contemporary Culture – 11/2017 108 In 2014 Graham Holderness recalled the development of Shakespeare studies in his book Tales from Shakespeare. Creative Collisions, acknowledging the work that has been done so far (by himself first of all, see, Holderness 2001) to eliminate or at least reduce the drastic distinction between academic and popular Shakespeare, two dimensions that exist in a continuum, and must be considered as a whole to examine the Shakespeare phenomenon effectively. Holderness actually opened up the way for a new critical approach, according to which “criticism [meets] creative work on its own ground” (2014: 138), taking the form of creative writing. The protean subject area of Shakespeare and popular culture has been widely explored and theorized by Douglas Lanier, through different kinds of studies (investigations into Shakespearean advertisements, films, tourism and musical adaptations). His main theories on this issue can be found in a monograph published in 2002, which provides crucial reflections upon the type of terminology and the methodologies of analysis to be used in such an intricate field of research. Perfectly in tune with the purpose of this paper is his 2005 essay entitled "Minstrelsy / Jazz / Rap: Shakespearean Legitimation and African-American Culture", which specifically focuses on the role of the Bard in ennobling and inspiring African American Music. Lanier brilliantly emphasizes the relevance of the interplay between these two elements, which can be seen as tokens of two poles apart (although, on closer analysis, this might not be the case): white vs black culture, highbrow vs lowbrow art, colonizing vs colonized traditions, thoughtfully literary vs improvisational creative products. “[I]n such exchanges” – Lanier reminds the reader – “Shakespeare is often as much the object as agent of legitimation, particularly from the perspective of popular culture, within which Shakespeare so often serves as its ambivalent high-cultural Other” (Lanier 2005: 2; on this topic see also Hansen 2010: 22-23). Julie Sanders (2006) has devoted several studies to the topic of adaptation (mainly in reference to Shakespeare). In 2007 she published Shakespeare and Music: Afterlives and Borrowings, in which she analyses “the reception and interpretation of Shakespeare’s work by later ages and cultures, and […] the wholesale reimagining of that work in a musical idiom and context” (Sanders 2007: 1). Her research ranges across different genres, and considers proper adaptations of Shakespeare’s plays in the form of operas, film scores, Broadway musicals and ballets, but also musical products in which the Renaissance playwright and his literature are simply alluded to. The last chapter of Sanders’s book expressly deals with contemporary popular music, providing an outline of the influence Shakespeare has exerted, through his sonnets and characters, in this kind of song. A good number of essays and chapters on the interlinks between Shakespeare and contemporary songs and on the didactic potential of such an appealing topic can be enumerated (See, Marshall 2000; Folkerth 2002a, 2002b, 2006; and Ko 2006). Of particular importance is Stephen M. Buhler’s research into the topic (2002, 2007, 2016), which highlights the multiple intertextual nature of these appropriations: songs which rewrite Shakespeare do not simply rework a Renaissance play, but an individual play as it has been received and re-mediated in all kinds of mass-media till that moment in history. Saggi/Ensayos/Essais/Essays Will forever young! Shakespeare & Contemporary Culture – 11/2017 109 An entire volume on Shakespeare and Popular Music was written by Adam Hansen in 2010. It is a book which – starting from a fruitful reflection upon Shakespeare’s own use of early modern popular music – examines the issue from different perspectives. It goes on to investigate the reception of Shakespeare’s literature in contemporary songs, but also into the consequences of this act of appropriation for both popular music and dramatic literature. In Hansen’s own words, the book studies how Shakespeare exists and becomes popular music, [and also challenges] a few myths and misconceptions about Shakespeare, popular music, and how they may relate, [… addressing] several questions. How have Shakespearean characters, words, texts and images been represented in popular music? Do all types of popular music represent Shakespeare in the same ways? If not, why? And how do the links between Shakespeare and popular music alter what we think we know about Shakespeare, and what we think we know about popular music? (2010: 1-2) The Shakespearean references in the work of singer-songwriters are of different kinds and involve different types of music. Whatever the genre of the song and the extent of the intertextual relation are, these offshoots have been recently considered worth analyzing and ‘legitimate’ anyway. Critics have drawn an interesting parallelism between the interactive reception of a Shakespearean work and the creative reading of lead sheets in jazz, where a player finds just one stave of music with the melody, it is then up to him or her to add chord extensions and alterations (See Bristol 1996: 23, Hawkes 1986).
Recommended publications
  • Unforgiven Bio
    Unforgiven Bio GIVE ME FUEL, GIVE ME FIRE, GIVE ME THE UNFORGIVEN METALLICA SHOW!!! Metallica is widely considered to be the most popular and influential heavy metal band of the past two decades. During the 1980s the group sold millions of albums through relentless touring and positive word of mouth, despite virtually no radio play or publicity. During the 1990s their sound became more complex and the group embraced radio and MTV to further expand their enormous fan base. The Unforgiven Metallica Show recreates the journey of the 25 years of Metallica mayhem from there debut album Kill Em All to their current raw produced album St Anger, Be prepared for tracks like Seek and Destroy, Ride the Lightning, Creeping Death, Master of Puppets, Blackened, One, Sandman, Fuel, Frantic etc. Fronted by Johnny, the vocalist/guitarist of The Unforgiven captures all the stage antics and high energy required to emulate Jaymz Hetfield, while the rest of the band carry out the very essence of Metallica through the attention to musical detail and a stunning visual performance worthy of the famous Bay area­based quartet, in an outstanding Non Stop 2 hour Show.. ARE YOU READY!! Be prepared to experience the no1 tribute THE UNFORGIVEN ­ METALLICA SHOW. Coming soon to a venue near you! Not for the faint hearted. Band will not be held responsible for health conditions. Song List Kill 'Em All released 1983 Songs performed by Unforgiven: • Seek & Destroy • Four Horsemen • Motor Breath • Whiplash Ride the Lightning released 1984 Songs performed by Unforgiven • For
    [Show full text]
  • Education Pack
    Education Pack 1 Contents Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 3 Section 1: Shakespeare and the Original Twelfth Night ..................................................... 4 William Shakespeare 1564 - 1616 ...................................................................................... 5 Elizabethan and Jacobean Theatre ..................................................................................... 6 Section 2: The Watermill’s Production of Twelfth Night .................................................. 10 A Brief Synopsis .............................................................................................................. 11 Character Map ................................................................................................................ 13 1920s and Twelfth Night.................................................................................................. 14 Meet the Cast ................................................................................................................. 16 Actor’s Blog .................................................................................................................... 20 Two Shows, One Set ........................................................................................................ 24 Rehearsal Diary ............................................................................................................... 26 Rehearsal Reports ..........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • A Distinctive BBC
    A distinctive BBC April 2016 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Foreword 1. Executive Summary 2. What is distinctiveness 3. Measuring distinctiveness today – what the audience thinks 4. Measuring distinctiveness today – comparisons to other services 5. Enhancing distinctiveness in the future 2 FOREWORD I believe that the case for the BBC is a very straightforward, pragmatic one. We have produced, and continue to produce, some of the very best programmes and services in the world. That is why people like the BBC. That is why they enjoy it. That is why they trust it. That is why they value it. That is what they pay us to do. If the BBC stands for anything, it stands for quality. In just the last month, we have seen Panorama’s exposé of the Panama Papers; Radio 4’s previously unseen footage of Kim Philby speaking to the Stasi; the domestic abuse storyline on The Archers; Inside Obama’s White House and Behind Closed Doors; The Night Manager, Undercover and Cuckoo. We have just launched the 2016 BBC Proms. And those are just a few highlights. This is the BBC I believe in. A beacon of cultural excellence in a world increasingly awash with media of all kinds. A trusted voice in a crowded arena, accountable to the public and focused on their interests, independent of both government and market. A benchmark of quality. But the unique way the BBC is funded places two further obligations on us. Because the BBC’s funding is independent, that gives us creative freedom. That means a BBC that must be more prepared than ever to take risks.
    [Show full text]
  • 3448 Shakespeare Comedies
    DOST THOU THINK, BECAUSE THOU ART VIRTUOUS, THERE SHALL BE NO MORE CAKES AND ALE? —Twelfth Night, 2.3.106–107 Unit 1—Lesson 1 Twelfth Night INTRODUCTION You’re probably familiar with the Christmas carol “The Twelve Days of Christmas.” These twelve days refer to the twelve days after Christmas, and particularly the twelfth day, which in myth (not in the Bible) is the day when the Magi first saw Jesus. This day (January 6) is also called Epiphany (which means “manifestation”). Shakespeare probably wrote Twelfth Night for an Epiphany celebration; you should not take the title as referring in any way to when the play is set or the passage of time in the play. Although the title does not refer to the setting, in Twelfth Night characters do have revelations or epiphanies. Another reason the title is fitting is that in Elizabethan England, Epiphany was a day of festivals and celebrations. The mood of Twelfth Night is celebratory, and one of the themes of the play is to assert the fundamental goodness of celebration and festival. Those who would interfere with such happiness are either converted from their position or dealt with harshly. WHILE YOU READ Here are some questions to consider while reading the play: What types of love are shown? Who is having fun and who isn’t? Who hides or disguises themselves in some way? Who speaks in prose and who speaks in blank verse? Why do you think that is? 39 Lightning Literature and Composition—Shakespeare: Comedies and Sonnets PLOT SUMMARY 1.1 The duke is pining away for Olivia, who is in mourning for her brother.
    [Show full text]
  • 09-25-2019 Macbeth.Indd
    GIUSEPPE VERDI macbeth conductor Opera in four acts Marco Armiliato Libretto by Francesco Maria Piave production Adrian Noble and Andrea Maffei, based on the play by William Shakespeare set and costume designer Mark Thompson Wednesday, September 25, 2019 lighting designer 8:00–11:10 PM Jean Kalman choreographer Sue Lefton First time this season The production of Macbeth was made possible by a generous gift from Mr. and Mrs. Paul M. Montrone Additional funding was received from Mr. and Mrs. William R. Miller; Hermione Foundation, Laura Sloate, Trustee; and The Gilbert S. Kahn & John J. Noffo Kahn Endowment Fund Revival a gift of Rolex general manager Peter Gelb jeanette lerman-neubauer music director Yannick Nézet-Séguin 2019–20 SEASON The 106th Metropolitan Opera performance of GIUSEPPE VERDI’S macbeth conductor Marco Armiliato in order of appearance macbeth fle ance Plácido Domingo Misha Grossman banquo a murderer Ildar Abdrazakov Richard Bernstein l ady macbeth apparitions Anna Netrebko a warrior Christopher Job l ady-in-waiting Sarah Cambidge DEBUT a bloody child Meigui Zhang** a servant DEBUT Bradley Garvin a crowned child duncan Karen Chia-Ling Ho Raymond Renault DEBUT a her ald malcolm Yohan Yi Giuseppe Filianoti This performance is being broadcast a doctor macduff live on Metropolitan Harold Wilson Matthew Polenzani Opera Radio on SiriusXM channel 75. Wednesday, September 25, 2019, 8:00–11:10PM MARTY SOHL / MET OPERA A scene from Chorus Master Donald Palumbo Verdi’s Macbeth Assistants to the Set Designer Colin Falconer and Alex Lowde Assistant to the Costume Designer Mitchell Bloom Musical Preparation John Keenan, Yelena Kurdina, Bradley Moore*, and Jonathan C.
    [Show full text]
  • Shakespeare in the Music Library (PDF)
    If music be the food of love: Shakespeare in the Music Library An exhibit in commemoration of the 400th anniversary of the death of William Shakespeare Curated and written by John Bewley, Ph.D. Associate Librarian Music Library University at Buffalo April 2016-June 2016 Music provides a kaleidoscopic array of perspectives through which scholars can view the works and influences of William Shakespeare. While many people are familiar with the most famous uses of Shakespeare in music in such works as Tchaikovsky’s Romeo and Juliet Overture-Fantasy, Verdi’s Shakespeare operas (Falstaff, Macbeth, and Otello), Mendelssohn’s incidental music for A Midsummer Night’s Dream, and Prokofiev’s Romeo and Juliet ballet, this exhibit will highlight some of the most significant topics related to the intersections of Shakespeare and music with some lesser-known examples from the holdings of the Music Library. The use of music in Shakespeare’s plays Music plays a significant role in Shakespeare’s plays through three guises: music performed as part of the play, references in the text to song titles, and the use of words with musical connotations. Shakespeare’s use of performed music in his plays was so extensive that only The Comedy of Errors is without music. One of the remarkable aspects of Shakespeare’s use of music is how integral it is to the dramatic structure in the plays. Some of the music serves as a direct part of the action, such as fanfares associated with processions or to mark royal entrances. In other instances Shakespeare used music as an agent for an action, such as when a lullaby is sung to put a character to sleep.
    [Show full text]
  • Shakespeare, Madness, and Music
    45 09_294_01_Front.qxd 6/18/09 10:03 AM Page i Shakespeare, Madness, and Music Scoring Insanity in Cinematic Adaptations Kendra Preston Leonard THE SCARECROW PRESS, INC. Lanham • Toronto • Plymouth, UK 2009 46 09_294_01_Front.qxd 6/18/09 10:03 AM Page ii Published by Scarecrow Press, Inc. A wholly owned subsidiary of The Rowman & Littlefield Publishing Group, Inc. 4501 Forbes Boulevard, Suite 200, Lanham, Maryland 20706 http://www.scarecrowpress.com Estover Road, Plymouth PL6 7PY, United Kingdom Copyright © 2009 by Kendra Preston Leonard All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means, including information storage and retrieval systems, without written permission from the publisher, except by a reviewer who may quote passages in a review. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Information Available Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Leonard, Kendra Preston. Shakespeare, madness, and music : scoring insanity in cinematic adaptations, 2009. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-8108-6946-2 (pbk. : alk. paper) — ISBN 978-0-8108-6958-5 (ebook) 1. Shakespeare, William, 1564–1616—Film and video adaptations. 2. Mental illness in motion pictures. 3. Mental illness in literature. I. Title. ML80.S5.L43 2009 781.5'42—dc22 2009014208 ™ ϱ The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences—Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI/NISO Z39.48-1992. Printed
    [Show full text]
  • Guitar Hero® Metallica® Thrashes Its Way Into the Guitar Hero® Music Library
    Guitar Hero® Metallica® Thrashes its Way Into the Guitar Hero® Music Library --For One Week Only, Buy Guitar Hero(R): Warriors of Rock and Import Your Guitar Hero(R) Metallica(R) Tracks for Free --Select Tracks From Guitar Hero(R) World Tour, Guitar Hero(R) Smash Hits, Guitar Hero (R) 5 and Band Hero(R) Also Importable Into This Fall's Guitar Hero: Warriors of Rock SANTA MONICA, Calif., Sept 14, 2010 /PRNewswire via COMTEX News Network/ -- Legendary musical icons and heavy metal pioneers, Metallica, are returning for an encore this fall by bringing their skill, intensity and passion to the Guitar Hero(R) music library. In conjunction with the launch of Guitar Hero(R): Warriors of Rock, fans who own Guitar Hero(R) Metallica(R) will be able to import 39 of the game's on-disc tracks directly into their Guitar Hero music library beginning September 28. Additionally, head-banging, guitar-shredding rockers who buy Guitar Hero: Warriors of Rock between September 28 and October 5 will be able to import these tracks from their copy of Guitar Hero Metallica for free*. The disc import will feature the following tracks: ● Bob Seger & the Silver Bullet Band - "Turn The Page (Live)" ● Diamond Head - "Am I Evil?" ● Kyuss - "Demon Cleaner" ● Lynyrd Skynyrd - "Tuesday's Gone" ● Machine Head - "Beautiful Mourning" ● Mastodon - "Blood & Thunder" ● Mercyful Fate - "Evil" ● Metallica - "Battery" ● Metallica - "Creeping Death" ● Metallica - "Disposable Heroes" ● Metallica - "Dyers Eve" ● Metallica - "Enter Sandman" ● Metallica - "Fade To Black" ● Metallica
    [Show full text]
  • Songs by Artist
    Songs by Artist Title Title (Hed) Planet Earth 2 Live Crew Bartender We Want Some Pussy Blackout 2 Pistols Other Side She Got It +44 You Know Me When Your Heart Stops Beating 20 Fingers 10 Years Short Dick Man Beautiful 21 Demands Through The Iris Give Me A Minute Wasteland 3 Doors Down 10,000 Maniacs Away From The Sun Because The Night Be Like That Candy Everybody Wants Behind Those Eyes More Than This Better Life, The These Are The Days Citizen Soldier Trouble Me Duck & Run 100 Proof Aged In Soul Every Time You Go Somebody's Been Sleeping Here By Me 10CC Here Without You I'm Not In Love It's Not My Time Things We Do For Love, The Kryptonite 112 Landing In London Come See Me Let Me Be Myself Cupid Let Me Go Dance With Me Live For Today Hot & Wet Loser It's Over Now Road I'm On, The Na Na Na So I Need You Peaches & Cream Train Right Here For You When I'm Gone U Already Know When You're Young 12 Gauge 3 Of Hearts Dunkie Butt Arizona Rain 12 Stones Love Is Enough Far Away 30 Seconds To Mars Way I Fell, The Closer To The Edge We Are One Kill, The 1910 Fruitgum Co. Kings And Queens 1, 2, 3 Red Light This Is War Simon Says Up In The Air (Explicit) 2 Chainz Yesterday Birthday Song (Explicit) 311 I'm Different (Explicit) All Mixed Up Spend It Amber 2 Live Crew Beyond The Grey Sky Doo Wah Diddy Creatures (For A While) Me So Horny Don't Tread On Me Song List Generator® Printed 5/12/2021 Page 1 of 334 Licensed to Chris Avis Songs by Artist Title Title 311 4Him First Straw Sacred Hideaway Hey You Where There Is Faith I'll Be Here Awhile Who You Are Love Song 5 Stairsteps, The You Wouldn't Believe O-O-H Child 38 Special 50 Cent Back Where You Belong 21 Questions Caught Up In You Baby By Me Hold On Loosely Best Friend If I'd Been The One Candy Shop Rockin' Into The Night Disco Inferno Second Chance Hustler's Ambition Teacher, Teacher If I Can't Wild-Eyed Southern Boys In Da Club 3LW Just A Lil' Bit I Do (Wanna Get Close To You) Outlaw No More (Baby I'ma Do Right) Outta Control Playas Gon' Play Outta Control (Remix Version) 3OH!3 P.I.M.P.
    [Show full text]
  • 12Night-Script.Pdf
    twelfth Night Script Playing Shakespeare with Deutsche Bank 2016 2016.playingshakespeare.org ACT 1 SCENE 1 ACT 1 SCENE 1 Music is playing. Enter Duke Orsino, Curio, and other Lords. Orsino If music be the food of love, play on. Give me excess of it, that surfeiting, 2 that: so that The appetite may sicken and so die. 2 surfeiting: over-indulging That strain again, it had a dying fall. 3 appetite: hunger for it 4 That strain again: play that part O, it came o’er my ear like the sweet sound 5 again That breathes upon a bank of violets, 4 dying fall: falling rhythm Stealing and giving odour. Enough! No more! ’Tis not so sweet now as it was before. [Music stops.] O spirit of love, how quick and fresh art thou 9 quick: lively That, notwithstanding thy capacity, 10 9 fresh: vigorous Receiveth as the sea. Naught enters there, 10–11 notwithstanding thy … sea: whatever your size, can hold any Of what validity and pitch soe’er, amount But falls into abatement and low price 11 Naught: nothing Even in a minute. So full of shapes is fancy 12 Of what validity … soe’er: That it alone is high fantastical. 15 whatever its value or quality 13 falls into … price: loses value Curio Will you go hunt, my lord? 14 shapes: images 14 fancy: love Orsino What, Curio? 14 is high fantastical: stretches imagination the most Curio The hart. 18 hart: male deer [a pun on ‘heart’] Orsino Why so I do, the noblest that I have.
    [Show full text]
  • The Music of Gender in Shakespeare's
    “HERE I AM … YET CANNOT HOLD THIS VISIBLE SHAPE”: THE MUSIC OF GENDER IN SHAKESPEARE’S TWELFTH NIGHT by Marcus Cheng Chye Tan THE ELUSIVE NATURE OF TWELFTH NIGHT Taken as Shakespeare’s farewell to romantic comedy and written around the same time as Hamlet, Twelfth Night presents a high comedy of elusive complexity that preempts the problem plays. Contesting a “universal consent [that] the very height of gay comedy is attained in Twelfth Night,”1 modern critics note that Twelfth Night possesses “darker” features of the problem plays but, as C. L. Barber suggests in Shakespeare’s Festive Comedy, the play manages to restore the festive through its comic resolution,2 affirming what Jonathan Dollimore terms “the telos of harmonic integration.”3 Elements of “dark tragedy” constantly complicate the “sunny iden- tity of spirit.”4 The gulling of Malvolio is often seen by modern sensibilities as an excessively cruel prank passing into the domain of sadism. The latter’s ignored plea for help while locked in the dark room, exacerbated by Feste’s cruel taunting, becomes a comic joke that proves excessive for the audience.5 In addition, Orsino’s unsettling “murderous” rage and Viola’s swooning acceptance of a love death cause the play to “walk the edge of violence”6 till the arrival of Sebas- tian in Act V. Malvolio’s unresolved vow of vengeance (V.i.376),7 sworn after the union of the lovers, threatens a newly established har- mony, prompting the audience to speculate on his possible return, which could turn comedy into tragedy.
    [Show full text]
  • Positive Affect in Renaissance Literature SAA 2015 Abstracts Roya
    Seminar 27: Positive Affect in Renaissance Literature SAA 2015 Abstracts Roya Biggie City University of New York, Graduate Center [email protected] “A touch more rare”: Acute Sensation and Numbness in Cymbeline This paper considers Robert Burton’s The Anatomy of Melancholy alongside Innogen’s sensual experience of love in Cymbeline. As Burton describes the effects of love on the senses, he suggests two seemingly contradictory experiences. At times, love heightens sensual awareness while, at others, the lover experiences numbness or a dulling of the senses. Though Burton tends to warn his readers against the dangerous effects of lovesickness, he is playfully ambivalent throughout the text. Love, he argues, is an illness; yet, it is also one that enlivens the body. I argue that Innogen takes pleasure in a bodily experience of love that embraces acute sensual awareness and numbness simultaneously. She attempts to recreate this cotemporaneous acuteness and numbness first through her servant, Pisanio, and, somewhat later, as she imagines her reunion with Posthumus. Although this paper is in its very early stages, I attempt to shed light on the complicated phenomological experience of love as understood by early moderns. Piers Brown Kenyon College “Hadst thou sway'd as kings should do”: Affect, Influence and Authority In my paper, I will consider 'sway' as a form of afect, with special emphasis on its appearance in Shakespeare's Henriad and his Roman tragedies. Tis is part of a longer project on 'Shakespeare's Moving Language', in which I am investigating the relationship between motion and emotion. I start from the observation that Shakespeare uses the language of moving in two diferent ways in his plays: it refers primarily to the arousal of the passions ('Are you not moved?'), and only occasionally is used to describe abstract spatial motion.
    [Show full text]