Geoffrey M Gould Dissertation
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
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`!F!:&%(!";!/&30!0S.0%(0(!&!(0$200!*4!/*6@#.&'#.A!./&.!4&2! 0S-00(0(!./&.!R/#-/!R*,'([email protected](!*4!&%A*%0!#%!./0#2!@*6#.#*%H!P!&+!6#+@'A!%*.!,60(!.*! 3! ! ! 0S@02#0%-#%$!./0!'030'!*4!9#%(%066!&%(!&66#6.&%-0!./0A!6/*R0(!.*R&2(6!+A60'4!&%(!0302A*%0! #%3*'30(!R#./!./0!@2*Y0-.H!C*!6&A!./&.!+A!2060&2-/!-*,'(!%*.!/&30!O00%!-*%(,-.0(!R#./*,.!./0#2!