to
TEACHING WITH THE POWER OF OBJECTS Smithsonian Institution September/OctoberFall 1996 RT OO(Updated Fall 2007)
Inside Subjects Art Lesson Plan Geography
Take-Home Language Page in Arts English/ Social Spanish Studies
Grades 4–9
Publication of Winning Art to Zoo is the Vote: made possible through the How generous support of the Americans Pacific Mutual Elect Their Foundation. President CONTENTS
Introduction Page 3 Lesson Plan Step 1 Page 6 Activity Page 1A Page 7 Activity Page 1B Page 8 Lesson Plan Step 2 Page 9 Activity Page 2A Page 10 Activity Page 2B Page 11 Activity Page 2C Page 12 Lesson Plan Step 3 Page 13 Take-Home Page in English/Spanish Page 14 Resources Page 15
Art to Zoo’s purpose is to help teachers bring into You may request a Cover photo William Jennings their classrooms the educational power of museums large-print or disk Bryan presidential campaign game, 1908. and other community resources. version of Art to Zoo Art to Zoo draws on the Smithsonian’s hundreds by writing to the Above photo Abraham Lincoln of exhibitions and programs—from art, history, and address listed on the campaign biography, 1860. During science to aviation and folklife—to create classroom- back cover or by faxing the nineteenth century, political parties emphasized the character ready materials for grades four through nine. to (202) 357-2116. and accomplishments of their Each of the four annual issues explores a single candidates in carefully crafted topic through an interdisciplinary, multicultural campaign biographies. approach. Opposite photo William The Smithsonian invites teachers to duplicate Jennings Bryan paper hat, 1896. Art to Zoo materials for educational use. Democratic newspapers distributed this elaborate paper hat during the 1896 presidential campaign. Winning the Vote: How Americans Elect Their President
During the long, explore in the Smithsonian’s single individual or perhaps of the Revolution and now sweltering summer of 1787 National Museum of a panel of executives? the presiding officer of the a delegation of more than American History. The Would the federal legislature Philadelphia Convention, fifty men from twelve former activities that follow include (Congress) elect the presi- was to many a living embod- British colonies cloistered objects from that museum dent or would the nation’s iment of the presidency. In themselves behind the locked and encourage your students voters? Should the president no small measure the powers doors of Philadelphia’s to consider the powers of serve only a single, lengthy granted to the Executive are Independence Hall. The the presidency as well as term or be eligible for reelec- a testimony to the confidence stated purpose of their the informal methods that tion to several shorter terms? placed in Washington’s meeting was to amend the have evolved to select These were difficult issues personal qualities of Articles of Confederation, a candidates for America’s for the Founders to resolve. leadership and integrity. loose framework for our highest elected office. Many had resented the The institution of the young nation’s government. powerful royal governors presidency as created by the However, when the delega- Defining the Office who had presided over their Constitution represented a tion adjourned in September The Founders at states before the Revolution. bold new experiment in gov- its members had instead Philadelphia in 1787 were Others had equally strong ernment. The president was fashioned an entirely new confronted with a series of feelings about the perceived to be many things—the head Constitution and with it fundamental questions as weaknesses of the Executive of the executive branch, the the uniquely American they fashioned their execu- under the Articles of commander-in-chief of the institution of the presidency. tive creation. Would the Confederation. Despite their armed forces, and the head The office of the presiden- president possess almost differences, however, the of state. His powers were cy and the informal process monarchical authority, or Founders agreed on who wide-ranging and included of electing the president are would his powers be more should serve as the first the authority to command the the themes of this issue of like those of the state president—he was sitting in armed forces, veto congres- Art to Zoo and are among the governors? Should the the same room with them. sional legislation, negotiate many topics visitors can presidency encompass a George Washington, the hero treaties with foreign powers, Benjamin Harrison presidential campaign ribbon, 1888. The party faithful often wore ribbons like this one to show their support for a candidate.
could determine the disagreed and went on to In addition to changing outcome; they feared that form America’s first the dynamics of elections, voters might select regional political parties. the emergence of national candidates lacking in Historians continue to political parties created a national perspective. debate the precise evolution new role for the president— To prevent this possibility, of American political parties that of party leader. It was a the Founders created the but generally agree that a position that many presidents Electoral College. In viable national party system found uncomfortable but this body, each state was had emerged by the late necessary to assume in their allocated as many electors 1830s. National political pursuit and exercise of the as it had senators and parties brought together Executive office. representatives in Congress. diverse local and regional Members of the Electoral coalitions who wanted to Selecting the Candidates College were chosen through voice their opinions in a Political parties methods determined by the national forum. An important introduced to American state legislatures. To elect a part of their strategy was to presidential elections several president, electors would gain control of Congress informal practices that have meet in their respective and the presidency. no constitutional definition. states to cast their votes. The broadly based Instead, they complement The candidate with the Democratic, Whig, and the Constitution by providing appoint officials (including greatest number of votes (later) Republican Parties an effective means to select ambassadors and Supreme would be named president, were products of the steadily candidates of proven ability Court justices), grant and the candidate with the expanding franchise, or right and national reputation. pardons and reprieves, second greatest number of to vote, during the early Early on, presidential receive foreign ambassadors, votes would be named vice nineteenth century. By candidates were chosen by and call Congress into president. (This procedure 1840, property restrictions a few influential party special session. was modified in 1804 by the for voting had largely been members who assembled The constitutional process Twelfth Amendment, which repealed, enabling most in state and congressional that they established for placed the president and white males over the age caucuses. It became clear by electing the president reflect- vice president as a “team” of twenty-one to vote. the late 1830s, however, that ed the Founders’ concern that running on the same ticket.) Throughout the nineteenth this process did not appear the right person be selected and twentieth centuries the democratic enough to the for a job with a four-year Political Parties electorate continued to thousands of newly enfran- term of office and unlimited A gradual development expand as people outside chised voters. Thus was born possibility for reelection. in the American process of the system struggled to the curiously American ritual The ideal candidate would electing a president was the obtain the vote. The of the quadrennial national be, like Washington, a leader formation of political parties. franchise was extended to party convention. of national stature who Some of the Founders did African American males in From the beginning, con- possessed the experience not welcome parties; there is the 1870s (although later ventions were highly stylized and maturity necessary to no mention of the role or severely restricted in some and emotive affairs, partly carry out his duties. With so function of national parties in states), to women and Native reminiscent of religious much power entrusted to the the Constitution. They shared Americans by the 1920s, revival meetings and attend- presidency, the delegates the eighteenth-century notion and to all eighteen-year-olds ed by an enthusiastic cross chose not to enact a system that parties, or “factions,” in the 1970s. Each influx section of the party’s faithful. in which popular votes alone were injurious to a represen- of new voters added strength A convention’s primary tative government. Others to the political parties. function was not always to select a candidate but to
4 Art to ZooZoo Winning Winning the the Vote: Vote: How How Americans Americans Elect Elect Their Their President President September/October September/October 19961996 (Updated October 2007) Franklin Delano Roosevelt delivering a radio address, 1936. Our thirty-second president was the first Chief Executive to make extensive use of radio to communicate with American voters.
The Changing successfully marketed to Campaign the electorate. During most of the Televised debates between nineteenth century, the major party candidates presidential became a part of the national candidates were presidential campaign in not expected to 1960. Historians and political play a public role scientists continue to in the national study the electoral impact campaign. The of televised debates, and lack of efficient millions of voters watch reconcile competing factions the national campaign pitted transportation made it diffi- them each election year. and unite the party behind the major parties in a titanic cult for candidates to interact More recently, television the nominee. As part of battle to market their with voters outside their introduced the “electronic this reconciliation process, respective candidates to the immediate regions. Not until town meeting” to the convention delegates wider electorate. 1928 did national speaking presidential contest. In drafted a statement of party Around 1840, national tours by both major party this increasingly popular principles—a platform— campaigns began to surround candidates become a staple broadcast forum, candidates that represented the views of the presidential election of the presidential race. The answer questions from those assembled. Candidates process in an atmosphere only significant exception voters across the nation. would pledge to uphold their of unrestrained hoopla. to this general inertia was And,Presidential of course, politics presidential have party platforms, but seldom The party faithful marched the whirlwind eighteen- politicseven moved have intomoved the intorealm the have elected presidents used in torchlight parades; sang thousand–mile speaking realmof cyberspace. of cyberspace. Major Majorand these principles as a basis for official campaign songs; tour in 1896 of the andminor minor parties parties have have eagerly enacting their legislative devoured adoring campaign Democratic candidate eagerlyset up World set up Wide websites Web to agendas. biographies; subscribed to William Jennings Bryan. disseminatesites to disseminate their candidate’s their National conventions party newspapers; and The technological viewscandidate’s on a wideviews range on a of became less important in the displayed buttons, banners, progress of the twentieth domesticwide range and of foreigndomestic policy and candidate selection process ashtrays, mugs, and every century brought profound issues.foreign policy issues. by the mid-twentieth century, manner of memorabilia changes in the style of These changes remind us as reformers within both emblazoned with the name the national presidential that the process ofof electingelecting major parties advocated a and image of their candidate. campaign. By the 1930s, the president will nono doubtdoubt series of state primaries as These seemingly frivolous radio carried the voices of continue to evolve, as itit hashas a means of more actively efforts were directed toward the candidates directly into over the past two centuries.centuries. involving the party rank a very serious end: convinc- millions of American homes. In a manner befittingbefitting aa freefree and file. Once they became ing as many voters as Within a generation, and open society, Americans widely adopted, primaries possible to cast their ballot television had completed will determine how to virtually guaranteed to for the party’s nominee. the picture by providing the select those most qualifiedqualified establish major party nomi- Because of peculiarities in voters with visual images to compete for ourour nation’snation’s nees well before the national the Electoral College system, of the candidates. Thus highest office: thethe conventions took place. a difference of only a few presidential politics had presidency. American political parties thousand popular votes was merged with the media also transformed the national often enough to garner a revolution. It was now presidential campaign into candidate the total count of desirable that candidates a colorful spectacle. An a state’s electoral votes— have both a polished speak- eclectic mixture of American and possibly the presidency. ing voice and a photogenic popular culture and politics, quality if they were to be
5 Art to Zoo Winning the Vote: How Americans Elect Their President ArtSeptember/October to Zoo Winning the 1996 Vote: (Updated How Americans October 2007) Elect Their President September/October 1996 5 enough and have lived in the your students to write LESSON PLAN United States long enough to answers to the questions on have had a wide range of the activity page. Next, tell Step 1 experience with national them that the small numbers issues. (Life expectancy was on the map represent the significantly shorter during electoral votes of the states. the eighteenth and nineteenth (Use the Introduction as a centuries than it is today, guide to discuss the concept LEARNING ABOUT THE although it is not a sporting making thirty-five a relatively of the Electoral College). Be PRESIDENCY event, some people have mature age then.) sure to stress that a state’s described it as being like a 4. Direct students to the number of electors is equal Objectives long-distance race. Your stu- section entitled “Some duties to its number of senators and ■ Identify the powers of the dents will probably conclude of the president.” Choose representatives. presidency as defined by the that you have described the volunteers to read the para- 7. Ask your students to U.S. Constitution. election of the president of graphs aloud and then have add up the numbers in the ■ Interpret an electoral map the United States. students write their responses states with dark shading of a presidential contest. 2. Ask students why to the questions that follow (electoral votes for Benjamin ■ Examine the function of Americans show so much each paragraph. Encourage Harrison) and the numbers in the Electoral College. interest in the election of the them to compare their the states with light shading president. They will probably answers to the class’ list of (electoral votes for Grover Materials conclude that Americans presidential duties (on the Cleveland). (You may have ■ Copies of Activity Pages want to pick the right person chalkboard). students add the numbers on 1A and 1B, pages 7 and 8. for the most powerful elected 5. Ask students to the chalkboard.) Which can- ■ Copies of maps of the office in America. Ask them describe how they think the didate had the greater num- United States. to describe the president’s president is elected. Students ber of electoral votes? ■ Chalkboard, chalk. job—what does the president will probably conclude that Students should conclude ■ Pens or pencils. do? Have a volunteer list the the president is elected by a that Harrison did. Tell them class’ responses on the chalk- majority of popular votes in that as a result, Harrison won Subjects board. the general election. Give the election even though he Geography, language arts, 3. Give each student a each student a copy of had fewer popular votes than math, social studies copy of Activity Page 1A and Activity Page 1B, “The Cleveland. tell the class that they will be Electoral College” and a U.S. 8. Conclude the lesson by Procedure reading part of the presi- map (with states’ names). initiating a discussion on the 1. Tell your students that dent’s job description from Tell them that they will be relative merits of the you are going to describe an the U.S. Constitution. Direct learning about the presiden- Electoral College system. Is important national event for them to the section entitled tial election of 1888 and that it a fair way of electing the them to guess. Give these “Who can be president?” and the result might surprise president? Does it still work? details: This event takes choose a few volunteers to them. (To establish a context, Should the system be place once every four years read the paragraph aloud. you may wish to tell your changed? (Students might in November; many (Some students might find the students that this election not see the benefits of having Americans take an interest in eighteenth-century language occurred between the Civil the Electoral College. You it; the press begins to cover of the Constitution difficult to War and World War I.) may wish to mention that the this event at least one year understand and may need 6. Tell students to mark system encourages the stabil- before it happens; if you extra coaching.) Have your the electoral map on Activity ity of well-organized, locally watch television, listen to the students answer the questions Page 1B with the names or based parties at the expense radio, or read the newspapers that follow the paragraph. U.S. Postal Service abbrevia- of less-established, third- you see many advertisements Encourage them to consider tions of each state in 1888 party movements.) Be sure to and hear stories about it; why the president must be at (territories are already emphasize that the 1888 thousands of people meet least thirty-five years old and marked). Be sure to stress election was an exceptional every four years during the have lived in the United that the electoral map shad- case and that candidates who summer to prepare for it; and States for fourteen years. ings indicate which candidate garner the greatest number of Answers may vary, but stu- won which states. Direct popular votes also usually dents will probably conclude win the Electoral College that the president must be old vote.
6 Art to ZooZoo Winning Winning the the Vote: Vote: How How Americans Americans Elect Elect Their Their President President September/October September/October 19961996 (Updated October 2007) ACTIVITY PAGE 1A The President on Paper
WHO CAN BE PRESIDENT? Senators present concur; and he shall nominate, and by (From Article II, Section 1 of the U. S. Constitution) and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall No Person except a natural born Citizen, or a Citizen of appoint Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls, the United States, at the time of the Adoption of this Judges of the Supreme Court, and all other Officers of Constitution, shall be eligible to the Office of President; the United States, whose Appointments are not herein neither shall any Person be eligible to that Office who shall otherwise provided for. not have attained to the Age of thirty-five Years, and been fourteen Years a Resident within the United States. What can the president do, if he or she receives the Senate’s approval? How old must one be to run for president?
How many years must one be a resident of the United
States to run for president?
(Excerpted from Article II, Section 3) He shall from time to time give to the Congress SOME DUTIES OF THE PRESIDENT Information of the State of the Union, and recommend to (Excerpted from Article II, Section 2) their Consideration such Measures as he shall judge The President shall be Commander in Chief of the Army and necessary and expedient; he may, on extraordinary Navy of the United States, and of the Militia of the several Occasions, convene both Houses, or either of them . . . he States, when called into the actual Service of the United shall receive Ambassadors and other public Ministers; he States . . . and he shall have Power to Grant Reprieves and shall take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed, and Pardons for Offences against the United States. shall Commission all the Officers of the United States.
What duties of the president are described in this paragraph? What can Congress expect the president to do?
What other duties of the president does this paragraph
SOME DUTIES OF THE PRESIDENT continued describe? He shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two-thirds of the
7 Art to Zoo Winning the Vote: How Americans Elect Their President ArtSeptember/October to Zoo Winning the 1996 Vote: (Updated How Americans October 2007) Elect Their President September/October 1996 7 ACTIVITY PAGE 1B The Electoral College
Who were the candidates? Which candidate had the most popular votes? Who do you think won the election? Count up the number of electoral votes: ___ Cleveland ___ Harrison
Washington Territory Montana