A Study of Philip K. Dick´S Science Fiction Dystopias

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

A Study of Philip K. Dick´S Science Fiction Dystopias Podlesny, Damian. "Utopias Turned Sour: A Study of Philip K. Dick's Science Fiction Dystopias." US American Expressions of Utopian and Dystopian Visions. Ed. Saskia Fürst, Yvonne Kaisinger, and Ralph J. Poole. Vienna: LIT Verlag, 2017. 161-174. ISBN 978-3-643-90931-2 (pb). Utopias Turned Sour: A Study of Philip K. Dick's Science Fiction Dystopias Damian Podlesny Chad Walsh announced the gradual but imminent decline of utopian fiction in 1962, stressing that "most 20th century writers who care to speculate about possible societies seem to have lost their utopian dreams" (16). The decline of utopia and the rise of its "nightmare cousin" (15) is strikingly, but perhaps not surprisingly, parallel to the history of the strangely surrealist 20th century. The 20th and 2! 51 centuries have seen an immense production of imaginary societies. The overwhelming majority are negative utopias or dystopias; some of them have the luck to have appeared in hard cover, most of them were published in cheesy covers of pulp Science Fiction paperbacks or cheap Science Fiction magazines, where they went out of print never having reached wider readership. Still among these 'trashy' fantasies many works exist that are worth deeper analysis, as they propose ideas powerfully plausible; and what is more important, because they try to give answers to the questions which mankind has asked for a long time: 'Where do we come from? Wl1ere are we heading?' The early prose of Philip K. Dick, whose oeuvre has never been easy to classify or label, belongs to the tradition of dystopian Science Fiction. Dick projects his societies into the future (usually not too distant) and invents amazing forms of the 'perfect' means of governing societies. However these inventions always tum more or less sour and the utopia subtly shifts toward dystopia or in extreme cases absolute paranoia. Thus this chapter analyzes the elements of dystopian Science Fiction in Dick's early short stories and novels, presenting how the utopias go wrong and how easy it is to sabotage the ideas that initially appear to be innocent idealistic concepts. Science Fiction in part is a direct descendant of utopian and dystopian traditions and speculation is the tour de force of the genre. Dystopias in general reveal the rigidity and over-ratiocination of the utopian concept; 162 DAMIAN POOi.ES Y they ridicule a somewhat mechanistic vi ion of society and the individual. Dystopian Science Fiction focuses mostly on alternative structures as such using them as a warning, a sort of future projection of the "ultimate maladies to be expected from the extension of a scientist or collectivist ethos" (Aldridge 66). It is however extremely difficult to make hard and fast distinctions among certain types of utopias, dystopias, and Science Fiction, as they overlap in many areas. One may argue that George Orwell's 1984, Aldous Huxley's Brave New World, or Yevgeny Zamyatin 's We belong to the tradition of Science Fiction, but they would rather fall into a category of the 'anti-scientistic' dystopias (Aldridge 66), where society is ordered according to instrumental values and on the assumption that people are standardized and manageable. Robert Scholes and Eric S. Rabkin provide a more precise division of at least two distinct strands of dystopian fiction. One which considers more fully what Wells called 'human ecology' and is central to science; and another, more purely political, which is less concerned with scientific development and the impact of technology on man, and more inlerested in making concrete certain tendencies in political thought. (34-5) In the age of technology it is only natural that dystopias have become more preoccupied with the use of technology; fittingly dystopian Science Fiction has always been skeptical about the application of scientific development. Scholes and Rabkin stress that it is "the tendency among later British and American writers of dystopian fictions to assume that technological and biological processes have extended beyond governmental control and will effectively shape human life regardless of the nominal system of government" (35). Dystopian Science Fiction then does not focus on an activated and thus corrupted version of utopia; its central theme is actually the destrnctiveness and the maleficent impact of science and technology on society (Aldridge 67). The novels and sho1t stories discussed in this chapter all come from the early stage of Dick's career. They deal with the problem of mechanical devices that have started thinking independently and eventually go amiss. Dick's fear of the mechanization of human life is clearly discernible, but what seems most fearsome is how Dick sees the threat that artificial intelligence poses. Vulcan's Hammer, "Second Philip K. Dick's Science Fiction Dystopias 163 Variety," "The Defenders," and "Autofac" represent the notion that an artificial brain is unable to empathize, and that once it becomes independent it will strive to eliminate all inconsistencies and illogicalities, thus trying to limit or even eradicate human life. Dick's stories swarm with interesting technological innovations; his wonders of teclrnology are not much more imaginative than those of many other Science Fiction writers, it is Dick's crooked imagination, as far as the implementation of those ingenuities is concerned that makes the difference. Usually technology is not implemented as means to secure a breakthrough in society's development; rather it is introduced to improve the operation of existing practices. Dick leaves no place forideal ism; it is the struggle for profit and power that gives bi11h to such systems of corrupt and business-infiltrated governments. For example in "Minority Report" (1956), the Police apparatus is aided by an elaborate facility that makes use of tlu·ee clairvoyants foreseeing future or possible crimes. Yet the supposedly unbiased and incorruptible system may also become corrupted as the machines have adopted terrifyingly human traits such as self-awareness, will of self-preservation, guile, or paranoia. As a result, Dick's seemingly utopian mechanical devices serve the authorities to keep society under control, thus becoming dystopias, which warrants the label dystopian Science Fiction forhis early work. Dick's Early Oeuvre as Dystopian Science Fiction [n the shol1 story "Second Variety" (1953), which evidently is Cold-War paranoia, the fighting is ca1Tied out by robots, which leaves humans as irrelevant bystanders at best or collateral damage at worst. Robots, here named claws, 1 have evolved to a point where it is impossible to discern if a person is a machine or a man. In underground factories, robots devise newer varieties in order to fool the enemy. Variety I is a wounded soldier appealing to the feeling of charity and compassion in people, only to brutally annihilate his opponents. Variety Ill is a young, innocent boy, a killer kid, which provides a horrific touch to the story, especially when a whole army of them marches towards enemy positions. There is a 1 The same motif is used in Dick's time-travel fantasy "Jon's World" where the claws eventually wipe out nearly the entire human population. 164 DAMIAN PODLESNY profound feeling that humans have eventually been 'outevolved' by their creations. Every single element of imminent human catastrophe however stems, with the cold brutal logic of a machine, from the original assignment of defeating the enemy. In this way, the utopian dream of creating an army that could annihilate the enemy without any damage to humans crumbles dramatically as the mechanization of warfare, i1Tespective of intentions, inadvertently leads to the inescapable destruction of mankind. A morbidly cynical twist is given to this theme in the short story "The Defenders" ( 1953), where the warring humans are forced to move underground into huge 'tanks,' leaving the robots to continue the war on the evidently radio-active surface. This time, as the robots' main credo is to serve their creators, the robot logic assumes that war is antithetical to human wellbeing and, as a consequence, the machines decide to stop the war, repair the damage, and wait until humans lose their hatred and obsessions. The robots understand that this will take time, so they decide to keep the entire human population misled until the war craze ends. With this in mind, they report continuous nuclear fighting on the dead, barren surface while at the same time preparing an ideal envirnnment for human life. This time it is the logic-driven machine that realizes the downright stupidity of senseless war. This is one of the few stories where Dick finishes on a hopeful note, but at the same time, the utopian vision is attributed not to humans but to robots. Although such denouement contradicts the overall tone of the writer's early fiction, the story proves Dick's belief that human beings are not able to create a truly utopian society, no matter what technological means they might posses. Another striking example of robot technology possessing utopian capacity, but implemented for the wrong purposes, is found in the story "Autofac" ( 1955). A homeostatic factory set up during an apocalyptic war continues its production of now useless goods even after the war decimated the population. The factory is one more projection of utopian thought: a fully automated plant which assesses demands, collects raw materials, and distributes finished products. Moreover it sends out robot representatives and repairmen to deal with complaints. Human beings are free from work routines and everything is taken care of by machines. One problem which arises is the lack of demand because of the destructive war-there are hardly any (human) consumers left. Another complication Philip K. Dick's Science Fiction Dystopias 165 is that the factory maintains a total monopoly of the raw materials, leaving nothing forthe remnants of the human race that would rather use the natural resources for different purposes.
Recommended publications
  • Television Academy Awards
    2018 Primetime Emmy® Awards Ballot Outstanding Cinematography For A Multi-Camera Series Alexa & Katie Ungroundable March 23, 2018 Alexa goes out of her way to prove she can't be punished. Jennifer surprises Jack with a backyard campout, but has a hard time getting him to unplug. Christian La Fountaine, ASC, Director of Photography The Big Bang Theory The Explosion Implosion October 16, 2017 Howard and Sheldon bond when they drive to the desert to shoot off a model rocket; When Leonard’s Mom finds a new best friend in Penny, it rubs Leonard the wrong way. Steven V. Silver, ASC, Director of Photography The Carmichael Show Support The Troops June 01, 2017 Jerrod gets into a fight with a soldier in front of Joe and Bobby. Joe tries to make it up to the soldier, but complications result. George Mooradian, ASC, Director of Photography Disjointed 4/20 Fantasy January 12, 2018 While the gang celebrates 4/20, Ruth helps Olivia with a contract, Pete loses confidence in his growing abilities, and Jenny and Carter share a secret. Peter Smokler, Director of Photography Fuller House My Best Friend's Japanese Wedding December 22, 2017 In Japan, Steve and CJ's wedding dishes up one disaster after another - from a maid of honor who's MIA to a talking toilet with an alarming appetite. Gregg Heschong, Director of Photography K.C. Undercover Coopers On The Run, Parts 1 & 2 July 15, 2017 - July 15, 2017 K.C. and the Cooper family of spies, along with K.C.'s Best Friend for Life, Marisa, are on the run from their arch enemy Zane in Rio de Janeiro, when they must take on - the fierce and slightly bizarre enemy agent Sheena, after capturing Passaro Grande, an exotic bird smuggler.
    [Show full text]
  • The Android and the Human" (N.P.), (N.D.)
    Ken Lopez, Bookseller Catalog . DICK, Philip K. "The Android and the Human" (n.p.), (n.d.). First. Original manuscript for a speech given by Dick at the Vancouver SF Convention at the University of British Columbia, in March 1972. 42 ribbon-copy typewritten pages, with corrections and emendations throughout in Dick's hand. The speech was later published in SF Commentary in December, 1972 and then reprinted in Vector in March-April 1973. In a letter that accompanied its publication in SF Commentary, Dick wrote that "this speech [tried]... to sum up an entire lifetime of developing thought." He concluded that it contained, "I hope, the seed for my novels to come." An important piece of writing, which anticipated the themes and concerns of the novels of Dick's last decade. Manuscript material by Dick is very scarce, particularly of such significant content. The Android and The Human Philip K. Dick, 1972 It is the tendency of the so-called primitive mind to animate its environment. Modern depth psychology has requested us for years to withdraw these anthropomorphic projections from what is actually inanimate reality, to introject -- that is, to bring back into our own heads -- the living quality which we, in ignorance, cast out onto the inert things surrounding us. Such introjection is said to be the mark of true maturity in the individual, and the authentic mark of civilization in contrast to mere social culture, such as one find in a tribe. A native of Africa is said to view his surroundings as pulsing with a purpose, a life, which is actually within himself; once these childish projections are withdrawn, he sees that the world is dead, and that life resides solely within himself.
    [Show full text]
  • Politics, Religion, and Philosophy in the Fiction of Philip K. Dick
    City University of New York (CUNY) CUNY Academic Works Publications and Research New York City College of Technology 2005 How Much Does Chaos Scare You?: Politics, Religion, and Philosophy in the Fiction of Philip K. Dick Aaron Barlow CUNY New York City College of Technology How does access to this work benefit ou?y Let us know! More information about this work at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu/ny_pubs/25 Discover additional works at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu This work is made publicly available by the City University of New York (CUNY). Contact: [email protected] How Much Does Chaos Scare You? Politics, Religion, and Philosophy in the Fiction of Philip K. Dick Aaron Barlow Shakespeare’s Sister, Inc. Brooklyn, NY & lulu.com 2005 © Aaron Barlow, Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike Foreword n 1989, while I was serving in Peace Corps in West Africa, II received a letter from an American academic publisher asking if I were interested in submitting for publication the doctoral dissertation I had completed the year before at the University of Iowa. “Why would I want to do that?” I asked. One disserta- tion on Philip K. Dick had already appeared as a book (by Kim Stanley Robinson) and Dick, though I loved his work, just wasn’t that well known or respected (not then). Plus, I was liv- ing in a mud hut and teaching people to use oxen for plowing: how would I ever be able to do the work that would be needed to turn my study from dissertation to book? When I defended the dissertation, I had imagined myself finished with studies of Philip K.
    [Show full text]
  • Selected Stories of Philip K. Dick Free
    FREE SELECTED STORIES OF PHILIP K. DICK PDF Philip K Dick,Jonathan Lethem | 466 pages | 16 Apr 2013 | HOUGHTON MIFFLIN | 9780544040540 | English | Boston, United States Selected Stories of Philip K. Dick - Wikipedia Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Want to Read saving…. Want to Read Currently Reading Read. Other editions. Enlarge cover. Error rating book. Refresh and try again. Open Preview See a Problem? Dick by Philip K. Details if other :. Thanks for telling us about the problem. Return to Book Page. Preview — Selected Stories of Philip K. Selected Stories of Philip K. Philip K. Dick was a master of science fiction, but he was also a writer whose work transcended genre to examine the nature of reality and what it means to be human. A writer of great complexity and subtle humor, his work belongs on the shelf of great twentieth-century literature, next to Kafka and Vonnegut. Collected here are twenty-one of Dick's most dazzling and resonan Philip K. Collected here are twenty-one of Dick's most dazzling and resonant stories, which span his entire career and show a world-class writer working at the peak of his powers. In "The Days of Perky Pat," people spend their time playing with dolls who manage to live an idyllic life no longer available to the Earth's real inhabitants. In "Autofac," one community must battle benign machines to take back control of their lives. And in "I Hope I Shall Arrive Soon," we follow the story of one man whose very reality may be nothing more than a nightmare.
    [Show full text]
  • The Apocalyptic Vision of Philip K. Dick
    The Apocalyptic Vision of Philip K. Dick By Steven Best and Douglas Kellner ([email protected] and [email protected]) The past several decades have exhibited vertiginous change, surprising novelties, and upheaval in an era marked by technological revolution and the global restructuring of capitalism.1 This "great transformation," comparable in scope to the shifts produced by the Industrial Revolution, is moving the world into a postindustrial, infotainment, and biotech mode of global capitalism, organized around new information, communications, and genetic technologies. The scientific-technological-economic revolutions of the era and spread of the global economy are providing new financial opportunities, openings for political amelioration, and a wealth of ingenious products and technologies that might improve the human condition. Yet these developments are accompanied by explosive conflict, crisis, and even catastrophe. The post-September 11 world reveals the contradictory dialectic of globalization in which the wide-reaching circulation of people, technology, media, and ideologies can have destructive as well as beneficial consequences. Hence, the turbulent transmutations of the contemporary situation are highly contradictory and ambiguous, with both hopeful and threatening features being played out on political, economic, social, and cultural fronts. Consequently, critical social theory that seeks a "dialectics of the present" must deploy a multiplicity of optics to attempt to capture the complexity and conflicts of the contemporary
    [Show full text]
  • PHILIP K. DICK EN MINOTAURO DEL VISIONARIO AUTOR CUYO TRABAJO INSPIRÓ Sigue La Serie En PHILIP K
    14mm Los relatos que inspiraron la nueva serie antológica OBRAS DE PHILIP K. DICK EN MINOTAURO DEL VISIONARIO AUTOR CUYO TRABAJO INSPIRÓ Sigue la serie en PHILIP K. DICK Amazon Prime Video Cuentos completos I-V BLADE RUNNER, DESAFÍO TOTAL, EL HOMBRE EN nació en Chicago en 1928 y residió la mayor EL CASTILLO Y MINORITY REPORT LLEGA UNA parte de su vida en California. Asistió a la Dr. Bloodmoney ANTOLOGÍA DE DIEZ HISTORIAS PENSADAS PARA PHILIP K. DICK universidad pero no llegó a finalizar sus Esperando el año pasado estudios. Creador precoz, empezó a escribir REPROGRAMAR TU MENTE. profesionalmente en 1952 y llegó a publicar El hombre en el castillo Electric Dreams Cuentos donde encontramos desde una esposa que un total de treinta y seis novelas y cinco Fluyan mis lágrimas, dijo el policía sospecha que su marido no es el mismo tras haber viajado colecciones de relatos a lo largo de su vida. rústica al espacio profundo, hasta un agente del gobierno en PHILIP K. DICK En 1963 ganó el premio Hugo a la mejor novela La invasión divina busca de la verdad tras la aparición de capuchas ilegales con El hombre en el castillo, y en 1975, el La penúltima verdad que inhiben la telepatía. Estos relatos, que exploran qué premio John W. Campbell con Fluyan mis 152 x 230 mm 152 x 230 mm La pistola de rayos significa ser humano en un mundo cambiante, han inspirado lágrimas, dijo el policía. Murió el 2 de marzo de los diez episodios de Electric Dreams, de Philip K.
    [Show full text]
  • Collection on Philip K. Dick
    http://oac.cdlib.org/findaid/ark:/13030/kt0c6034t4 No online items Collection on Philip K. Dick Finding aid prepared by Julianna Gil, Student Processing Assistant. Special Collections & University Archives The UCR Library P.O. Box 5900 University of California Riverside, California 92517-5900 Phone: 951-827-3233 Fax: 951-827-4673 Email: [email protected] URL: http://library.ucr.edu/libraries/special-collections-university-archives © 2017 The Regents of the University of California. All rights reserved. Collection on Philip K. Dick MS 199 1 Descriptive Summary Title: Collection on Philip K. Dick Date (inclusive): 1952-1992, undated Collection Number: MS 199 Extent: 2.50 linear feet(2 boxes) Repository: Rivera Library. Special Collections Department. Riverside, CA 92517-5900 Abstract: The Collection on Philip K. Dick consists of press clippings, publications, short stories and manuscripts regarding Philip K. Dick, an American novelist who has published almost entirely in the science fiction genre. His works have been published in numerous literary magazines, such as Galaxy, Amazing Stories, and Fantasy and Science Fiction. The collection also consists of newsletters from the Philip K. Dick Society, and photographs and press booklets from the film Blade Runner. Languages: The collection is in English, French, and German. Access The collection is open for research. Publication Rights Copyright Unknown: Some materials in these collections may be protected by the U.S. Copyright Law (Title 17, U.S.C.). In addition, the reproduction, and/or commercial use, of some materials may be restricted by gift or purchase agreements, donor restrictions, privacy and publicity rights, licensing agreement(s), and/or trademark rights.
    [Show full text]