Musical Identity and Arranging Styles of Drum Corps Front Ensembles
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MUSICAL IDENTITY AND ARRANGING STYLES OF DRUM CORPS FRONT ENSEMBLES Musical Identity and Arranging Styles of Drum Corps Front Ensembles by Leah Meredith Dunbar A thesis presented for the B.A. Degree with Honors in Music Kenyon College March 2020 ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS First and foremost, I thank Mark Sachetta, who has seen this project grow from the very beginning: starting with my first corps rehearsals, and later from the many conversations that helped formulate this idea over a year ago. Without his encouragement and suggestions, this project would have never been started or completed. I am incredibly grateful to the arrangers and staff (James Ancona, Omar Carmenates, Brian Dinkel, Matthew Jordan, Iain Moyer and Tom Rarick) who generously gave of their time, knowledge, and scores. I am so thankful to have had the chance to learn directly from those who have made such an impact in DCI. Thanks also to Emma Carpenter, Sarah Culbertson, and Nina Smith for sharing their experiences, and Matthew McGuire for writing pit books that sparked my love and interest in the pit and arranging. It goes without saying how thankful I am to the Spartans organization and for the many friends I have met through drum corps. Thanks especially to those who have supported this project in numerous ways: Lindsey Augustine, Sam Bodo, Shay Brooks, Matt Duguay, Ryan Enos, Gabe Klavans, Gabe Labell, Austin McKinlay, Coleman Moore, Danny Nguyen, Sean O’Rourke, Matt Pantanella, and KT Taylor. Thank you to my amazing parents who have encouraged my interest and love for all things music from the beginning, even when it involves adding a marimba to our living room or understanding when I spend far too many hours driving to/arranging for/writing about band. Your love and support mean the world to me. Finally and most significantly, thank you to the Kenyon College Music Department for encouraging my ideas and giving me the words, knowledge and support to achieve them. I am so grateful for everything I have learned at Kenyon. Thanks most especially to my honors advisors, Prof. Buehrer and Prof. Mendonça, for their wisdom in discussing and shaping ideas, and for their dedicated patience in editing pages of this long project over the course of the year. iii ABSTRACT Drum corps is a competitive music activity that has evolved from its militaristic origins into a theatrical activity that uses brass and percussion instruments in exciting musical performances. Through focusing on the percussion subsection of the front ensemble, I examine the practices, traditions, and controversies of drum corps, studying the ways which individual corps develop a musical identity that balances tradition and innovation. Part of this involves researching the structure of drum corps shows, incorporating Turner’s theory of communitas and Csikszentmihalyi’s concept of flow to describe how this structure interacts with the development of the activity and the creation of corps identity. Using this understanding of corps traditions, and incorporating ethnographic interviews with arrangers, I then analyze the arranging styles of five World Class front ensembles (Bluecoats, Blue Devils, Boston Crusaders, Cadets, and Santa Clara Vanguard), illustrating how the front ensemble contributes to corps identity and becomes an integral part of the modern drum corps. Finally, I reflect on a drum corps arrangement of my own and the techniques and arranging styles which influenced it. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS Section I: INTRODUCTION Introduction…….……………………………………………………………….……..1 History………….………………………………………………………….……….….2 The Front Ensemble…………………………………………………………….……..3 Basics of Front Ensemble Arranging………..…………………………….……….….5 Section II: TRADITION AND IDENTITY Drum Corps Traditions……..…………………………………………………………8 Instrumentation………………..………………………………………………..……10 The Amplification Controversy………..…………………………………………….12 Shared Flow, Communitas, and Drum Corps…..……………………………………14 Show Structure………….………….……………….……………………………..…16 Openers, Closers, Ballads, Production Numbers, Percussion Features….…………..17 Drum Corps “Moments” and the Importance of Flow……..……..…………………19 Evaluating Shared Flow: General Effect…….……….…..………………………….24 Corps Identity…………………………………………………………………….….25 Programming…………………….….….……………………………………………29 Corps Songs……….….….…….…………………………………………………….29 Arrangers, Identity, and Intentionality…….….….….……………………………….33 Section III: FRONT ENSEMBLE CASE STUDIES v Introduction……….………………………………………………….38 BLUECOATS……….….…….………………………………………………….….42 Auxiliary Instruments & Layering……………………………………46 Vibraphones…….…………………………….………………………50 Electronics……….…….………….………………………………….52 Setup & Pod Orchestration………..………………………………….54 BLUE DEVILS……………………….…………………………………………….60 Drums & Hand Percussion….……..………………………………….62 Keyboards……….…………………………….………………………65 Runs…………………….………….………………………………….66 Density & Space…………..……..…..……………………………….71 BOSTON CRUSADERS………………………..….………………………………77 Percussive Approach…………….….…………………………………78 Technique…….………………………….…….………………………83 Ballads………………….………….………………………………….84 Featured Instruments & Storytelling……….…………………………88 CADETS…………………..……..……………..…………………..………..…….91 Cadets 2009-2016: Iain Moyer……….……………..…………………93 Instrumentation & Sound Palette…….…….……………………..……95 Cadets 2017-2019: Omar Carmenates….…………………………….96 vi Instrumentation……….…….……………..……………………………97 Electronics & Live Delay…..……………….………………………..…98 Keyboards…….…………..….………………..………………………..99 SANTA CLARA VANGUARD……………………….…………..………..…….105 Percussion Foundation…………..…………………..…………………106 Instrumentation…………………………….……………………..……108 Keyboards……………………….……….…………………………….109 Runs……………….……………..…….………………………………111 Octave Grip……….……………….….……………………………..…114 CONCLUSION…………..……..…………………..……………………………117 AREAS OF FUTURE RESEARCH……………..………………………………119 Section IV: ARRANGING "Sky Above”……….……………….……………………………..…120 GLOSSARY………….…………………………………………………………………………129 BIBLIOGRAPHY………………………………………………………………………………135 INTERVIEWS.…………………………………………………………………………………139 1 INTRODUCTION During hot summer nights on football fields across the country, thousands watch excitedly as America’s drum and bugle corps take the field for thrilling musical competition. The thunder of drums and the blast of the hornline can be heard from blocks away, while sitting in the stands brings the performers and fans face-to-face. The music is irresistible, building to climactic moments that bring the audience to their feet, captivating them with the outpouring of expression, musicality and talent. Drum corps looks similar to marching band, but it is often referred to as the “NFL” or “Major Leagues” of the marching arts.1 The members, who are all under the age of 22, are expressive performers and athletes, and above all, excellent musicians. They balance emotional and theatrical expression, technical precision, and musical skill to perform eleven-minute shows that entertain, excite, and strive to raise the competitive standard. The marching members play brass instruments (hornline), marching drums (drumline, also called the battery) or dance while spinning flags, rifles, sabres, or other props (color guard). At the front of the field are players who perform as part of a stationary ensemble of percussion and electronic instruments, called the front ensemble or the “pit." History Drum and bugle corps began within veterans organizations following World War I. These early ensembles used traditional drums and bugles to continue a connection to the military 1 “About Drum Corps International," accessed March 6, 2020, https://www.dci.org/static/about-drum- corps-international 2 history that was important to their adult, military veteran members. It was not uncommon for small communities to have their own drum corps, with thousands existing around the country.2 As these local corps became more common, there was an increased attention on competition as well as forming junior corps to "keep kids off the streets.”3 Competitions were offered by numerous groups including the American Legion and the Veterans of Foreign Wars.4 In 1972, Drum Corps International (DCI) was formed with the intent of creating a unified governing body for junior corps across the country and the world. Due to an increased focus on a competitive touring schedule by DCI, there was a large decrease in local corps as groups merged to form more economically stable groups who could afford to travel. There are currently forty- five competing drum corps registered with DCI, each fielding a membership of up to 154 players between the ages of 13 and 22.5 In recent years, corps from Ireland, Indonesia, and the Netherlands have come to the United States to compete in the International division.6 The corps are now split into Open and World Class, somewhat comparable to the minor and major leagues of baseball, respectively. The twenty-four Open Class corps attract a membership of mostly high school students and accommodate school schedules, traveling for around a month, while the twenty-two World Class corps attract a membership of mostly college students and spend 85 consecutive days rehearsing, competing, and touring with the corps. Both 2 Lane Summerlin, “The History and Development of the Front Ensemble in Drum Corps International," PhD diss, Ohio State University, 2016, 10 3 Summerlin, “The History and Development of the Front Ensemble," 9 4 Dennis E. Cole, “What is a Drum and Bugle Corps? Reinterpreting Tradition Inside the Musical Community," PhD diss, Kent State University, 2009, 8 5 5 “About Drum Corps International," accessed March 6, 2020, https://www.dci.org/static/about-drum-