The Daily News Publishing Co. Opposition to Senate Bill 1299 May 2011

1. Company History

• The Daily News is a 125-year-old, family-owned small business that publishes The Daily News in Memphis and The Nashville Ledger in Nashville, including print editions, Web sites and email editions.

• We cover business and the community, with a particular emphasis on real estate, construction and banking, including regular reporting on the foreclosure crisis.

• We also run a statewide real estate information service that provides detailed data and analysis to Realtors, appraisers, and banks.

2. This is a Business Problem, Not a Legislative Problem

• The bankers have brought this bill because they believe the price of running public notices of foreclosure is too high. The are asking you to solve their problem, rather than using the marketplace to solve their problem.

• The bankers have admitted that the banks, not the homeowner, pay this cost. “If you’re in foreclosure, you don’t have any money,” said Amy Smith, TN Bankers Association lobbyist, during testimony in the House Judiciary Committee. “The banks might get a judgment against them [the homeowners], but they’ll never see that money.” Asked if the cost comes off the banks’ bottom line, Smith said, “Yes. Immediately.”

3. Public Notice is Cost-Effective

• Statewide, the average cost for public notice over the last three years was $212 per notice. For Q1 2011, the cost was $199 per notice.

• There are examples of high-priced notices. However, these are anomalies, not the norm.

4. Let Competition – Not Legislation – Solve This Business Problem

• Banks can and should shop for better newspaper rates, rather than looking to the legislature to solve what banks see as a pricing issue. There is heated competition in Memphis and, as a result, price has fallen.

• Only 13 counties in Tennessee lack competition between newspapers. Those counties represented less than 2% of foreclosures in the state in 2010. See Attachment A.

5. This is Not a Local Bank Issue

• The vast majority of foreclosures are conducted by large, out-of-state banks and financial entities. In Shelby County in 2010, for instance, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and similar governmental entities accounted for 73% of the foreclosures. See Attachment B.

6. We Have Proposed a Compromise

• We are open to compromise and have agreed to language that clarifies that the full legal description (i.e., metes and bounds) is not required in the notice.

7. Reducing Foreclosure Notice Does Not Help the Homeowner/Consumer

• Not a single non-profit or government agency working on the foreclosure crisis in Memphis agrees that a reduction in notice will help the consumer. See Attachment C.

p. 1 of 14 The Daily News Publishing Co. Opposition to Senate Bill 1299 May 2011 8. Public Notice Works

• Statewide in 2010, 56% of homeowners who started the foreclosure notice process were able to avoid foreclosure. In Memphis, Nashville and Chattanooga alone since Jan. 1, 2011, 1,445 people have avoided foreclosure after the 3 notices ran. See Attachment D.

• Public notice is not only a means of contacting the homeowner, it’s also the means by which family, friends, neighbors, non-profits, and other groups learn about a foreclosure and try to prevent it.

p. 2 of 14 The Daily News Publishing Co. Opposition to Senate Bill 1299 May 2011

Attachment A

Let Competition – Not Legislation – Solve This Business Problem

• Banks can and should shop for better newspaper rates, rather than looking to the legislature to solve what is simply a pricing issue.

• Only 13 counties in Tennessee lack competition between newspapers. Those counties represented less than 2% of foreclosures in the state in 2010.

Counties with the most Foreclosures 2010 These counties represent:

• 79% of foreclosures

• 65% of the population

% of Total No. County Population Foreclosures of Papers Shelby 908,175 23% 4 Davidson 572,475 12% 6 Knox 400,061 6% 4 Rutherford 210,025 6% 4 Hamilton 310,371 5% 3 Sevier 77,270 3% 4 Sumner 141,611 3% 6 Williamson 146,935 3% 6 Montgomery 142,204 2% 2 Blount 113,744 2% 3 Wilson 97,891 2% 4 Madison 94,397 2% 4 Maury 74,692 2% 2 Sullivan 152,498 1% 2 Bradley 91,196 1% 2 Tipton 54,722 1% 2 Washington 110,996 1% 2 Robertson 59,322 1% 2 Hamblen 59,489 1% 2 Anderson 72,244 1% 5

p. 3 of 14 The Daily News Publishing Co. Opposition to Senate Bill 1299 May 2011

Attachment B

This is Not a Local Bank Issue

• The vast majority of foreclosures are conducted by large, out-of-state banks and financial entities.

• In Shelby County in 2010, for instance, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and similar governmental entities accounted for 73% of the foreclosures.

Shelby County - 2010:

• The top 6 banks and financial entities conducting foreclosures (3,355 out of 4,231, or 79%):

Bank/Financial Entity Total % of all Fannie/Freddie/Government Entities 2,461 58% Deutsche Bank 263 6% US Bank 255 6% Bank of New York 167 4% Wells Fargo 119 3% HSBC Bank 90 2% Top 6 Foreclosing Entities 3,355 79%

• All banks and financial entities conducting foreclosures, by type:

Type of Bank/Entity Total % Fannie/Freddie/Government Entities 2,461 58% Out of State Banks 1,198 28% In‐State Banks 245 6% Other 317 7% Total 4,231

p. 4 of 14 The Daily News Publishing Co. Opposition to Senate Bill 1299 May 2011

Attachment C

Reducing Foreclosure Notice Does Not Help the Homeowner/Consumer

• Not a single non-profit or government agency working on the foreclosure crisis in Memphis agrees that a reduction in notice will help the consumer.

Comments from Consumer Advocates in Memphis & Shelby County: …………………………………………………………………………………………………………

“The real effect would be to further lessen the chance that a Tennessee homeowner would be able to avert the foreclosure. For example, it would lessen the chance that a friend or neighbor of a homeowner who has been told not to worry about a notice of foreclosure might see the publication and urge them to contact an attorney.

“Reduction in the publication of notices of foreclosure would also reduce the number of people who might come to a foreclosure sale to bid on the property if a homeowner is not able to avert the sale.”

-- Webb Brewer, attorney and former Litigation Director, Memphis Area Legal Services …………………………………………………………………………………………………………

“Our problem with something like this is we are a non-judicial foreclosure state, so people don’t have to be taken to court. All they get is a notice in the mail or someone tells them there’s a notice in the paper.

“The public notice requirement actually slows the process down a little bit so there is time for a homeowner to try to work something out. When you shorten that timeframe, it just means more people are going to get foreclosed on faster -- and lose their homes.”

-- Sapna Raj, managing attorney of the Memphis Fair Housing Center, which is part of Memphis Area Legal Services …………………………………………………………………………………………………………

“Any protection being taken away is absurd at this point.”

-- Steve Lockwood, executive director of the Frayser Community Development Corp. …………………………………………………………………………………………………………

“This would mean Tennessee would have the least public notice requirement of any state. The Tennessee foreclosure process is far too quick as it now stands, and the entire process needs some revision in order to allow time for mortgage modifications.”

-- Corky Neale, research and innovation director for the RISE (Responsibility, Initiative, Solutions, Empowerment) Foundation

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………

p. 5 of 14 The Daily News Publishing Co. Opposition to Senate Bill 1299 May 2011

Attachment D

Homeowners Who Avoided Foreclosure AFTER the 3rd Notice Since Jan 1, 2011

• Statewide in 2010, 56% of homeowners who started the foreclosure notice process were able to avoid foreclosure. In Memphis, Nashville and Chattanooga alone since Jan. 1, 2011, 1,445 people have avoided foreclosure after the 3 notices ran. That’s nearly 500 per month.

Douglas Richardson Mildred P. Hancock a/k/a Mildred Patricia Chattanooga/Hamilton County: Kelly D. Clodfelter Bonvillain, John Mark Hancock 173 Homeowners Sherlin A. Clark Barbara J. Steinmetz, Ray Steinmetz, Donna Spivey, Michael A. Spivey Belinda Steinmetz Carolyn Leamon Kelly R. Madewell, Bruce E. Madewell Susan P. Woodall, Gary D. Woodall Frank Tramble Louise H. Corkern Rahela S. Conway, Kevin Conway Jennings W. Scott Patsy Holland, Charlton W. Holland Lesley Gayle Shutters Lori L. Howell, David Lee Howell Cheryll A. Yoshida Douglas Richardson Tina Ruth Olson, Jeffrey Loren Olson Rachel Lynn Sadowitz Stephanie C. Hunneke, Jeffery J. Hunneke Peggy Obrien Gregory T. Lamberth Margie Morton, Timothy Morton Shahnaz N. Rajpari, Nooruddin R. Rajpari Charles R. Mayhew, Janice Jean Mayhew Lynn M. Williams, Culver S. Gidden Michael Edward Nicely Mollie R. Lawson, Robert Anthony Paula Carter Hodge, Paul Randall Hodge Brenda M. Hollingsworth Lawson Deborah A. Coleman Natalie D. Carmichael, Charles D. Tamera G. Hurst, Mark A. Hurst Erin Holt Newcomb, Robert Charles Carmichael Melodie L. Smith Newcomb DBA Lawn Doctor of Hixson Anthony D. Parker, Kirsten Ridge-Parker C. Cheryl Archer Gwendoline Kingsnort Charles E. Schaerer, Jr., Deborah G. Grover C. Harding, Jr. Stephen S. Hall Tankersley Ashley Hensley, Justin Mason Thomas E. Johnson Tara L. Hewlett Robbyn A. Loach, Larry D. Loach John W. Althoff Stacy Artress, Henry Artress Trudy D. Towe Marcia A. Barrett, Jack D. Barrett Katherine Moore Lisa Williamson, Darryl Williamson Ida R. Brown Wanda Benton Sheila A. Jones, James E. Jones Louise Blackwell, Antonio L Blackwell Jessica Wiley, Zachary Wiley Nancy M. Tucker, Joseph Tucker Herbert L. Hancock, Karen D. Hancock Susan D. Houston, Joseph Michael Magdolna Turucz, Sandor Turucz Jimmy Watts, Stephanie I. Watts Houston aka J. Michael Houston Kenneth Combs, Pauline V. Combs Lori Baldbridge a/k/a Lori Sanford Deborah Moses aka Deborah Anderson Christopher L. Brock Jerry W. Belcher, Cathy I. Belcher Jeffrey Brannon Reames, Sandra Lynn Cynthia D. Vandergriff, Sean D. Kimberly A. Witt, Jimmy J. Witt Reames Vandergriff Angela White Leffew, Donnie Leon Thomas R. Moore Deanna Lynn Akers, Rondal D. Akers, III Leffew Rachel M. Owens Karen S. Ray, Mark S. Ray Philip C. Burke, Nekolia Swope Burke Pamela Weaver AKA Pamela D. Weaver Pamela Jean Penny, Martin Roy Penny Tina Ruth Olson, Jeffrey Loren Olson Nancy D. Gillispie, Anthony G. Gillispie Jeffrey B. Mathis, Tiffany A. Mathis Rachele T. Watkins, Joshua David Belinda S. Moore, Eric L. Moore Donna Jean Corboy Watkins Leotis Harris Jr. Georgia Ann Mayweather aka Georgia Joy P. James, Michael R. James Samuel D. Burchard, Pamela S. Burchard Ann Foster Martha A. Thirkill James Kumbar Jr. Thomas R. Moore Princella Allgood, Robert E. Allgood Vickie Moore, David Charles Moore Mary Tucker, Paul Johnson Tucker Annette Arnold, Eugene Arnold Amanda N. Varnell, Phillip K. Varnell Olivia D. Swingle, Theodore M. Swingle, Jorge Arellano Cora Patricnella H. White, Herbert White, Jr. Cheri Grant, David H. Cass, Jr. Jr. Patrick Swanson, Mame Sene Steve Wesley Welch Sheila R. Higgins Ronald E. Calloway, Neshawn Y. Amanda Weeks, Joseph Weeks Angela M. Richey, John W. Richey, II Calloway Raymond L. Hassler, Angela M. Hassler Kevin Clay, Melissa Clay Ty Vincent Beeman, Judy Beeman Ginger F. Jones Bettie Ringer, A. D. Ringer Terry L. Brown aka Terry Lee Brown Sarah Shannon Rogers, James Erwin Kerwin Arthur Maeghan Montgomery, Terrence L. Rogers Doris Gail Akridge Montgomery Renee McDonald, Zachary McDonald Anthony L. Flemister, Althea J. Flemister Esther Rangel, Jose L. Rangel Nancy M. Tucker, Joseph Tucker Amanda Brooks, Timothy H. Brooks, Jr. Donna Smith Mosteller Charles R. Mayhew, Janice Jean Mayhew Lucy Heater, David Heater Kendra Dawn Shepard Teri J. Sims Crystal Joyner, Jeffrey R. Joyner Anna M. Byrd, Brian R. Byrd Tonya N. Templeton, Llewellyn L. Rachele T. Watkins, Joshua David Templeton aka L. Lee Templeton Watkins p. 6 of 14 The Daily News Publishing Co. Opposition to Senate Bill 1299 May 2011

William Lacy Linebarger, Anita Diane Alyson Leigh Eddins Chanda Laurine Cleggett, Michael R. Miller Vahid Derakhshanian, Navid Cason Amalia Garcia, Alexander Garcia Derakhshanian June C. Blackwell, Jeff T. Blackwell, Wilma Pack-Martin, Johnny Martin Kyung M. Chung, Suk Won Chung, Soon Bennie E. Blackwell June Denise Atkins, James Leonard Atkins Ja Chung Jason B. McReynolds Deborah Moses aka Deborah Anderson Elizabeth E. Carter Carolyn Marable James Kumbar Jr. Carlton R. Boleyjack, Nikki Von Jenna Minnie P. Rogers, Dowlen B. Rogers Viola Lawrence, Perry Lawrence Boleyjack a.k.a. Nikki Von Jenne Margrit Lockett, Rodney Lockett Tana L Nifong, Lance P Nifong Boleyjack Stephanie Powers Paul R. Pickett Saul Jenkins, Carol Jenkins Telisa J. Amrozowicz Billie G. Adams Del-le A. Colvin, Nickita D. Bonner Sarah Scruggs, Tom W. Scruggs, Jr. Kristie L. Leonard, Christopher J. Leonard Angelo M. White Ada L. Smith Tina D Boykin, Aaron Boykin Emilia Aguilar De - Lara, Mario Jose Lara Chris Waller, Yavonne Renee Waller Theresa R. Artime, Michael G. Artime Katherine Ramos, Selvyn N Amaya Phillip Carlton Carolyn Jean Bradford, Kareem M. Michael P. Osman Joshua C. Leonard Bradford Jeffrey S. Wells Kenneth Bowers Brierley H. Hall, Michael E. Hall Ralph W. Harris, Joyce Harris Manuel C. Juncal Kenneth A. Cooper, Natalie Cooper Debra J. Holt, James P. Holt Deaundra Holder Pamela J. Pritchard, Phil Pritchard Jeffrey S. Wells Michael Ewin Ginger R. Fillers, Christopher M. Fillers Robert I. Bush, Elaine K. Bush Rose M. Mann, John J. Mann Julisa Flores Richter, Alejandro Richter Kendell C. Kirby aka Kendell Cheville Stephanie Barksdale Henry F. Tipton, Jr. aka Henry Tipton, Kirby, Larry E. Kirby Carolyn Washington, Larry Gordon Scarlette Tipton Mary M. Hansel Devi L. Brown, Terry P. Brown, Jr. Fallon B. Garrett Judith S. Wahlstrom David Hilderbrand Tiffany L. Fox, David E. Fox Timothy D. Fettroll, Stayce J. Fettroll LaShanda Mott, George Mott Deborah K. Swearengin, Jerry Dorothy Barber Carlos Mauricio Swearengin, Sr. Martin V. Meador Sabrina L. Lane, Timothy D. Lane Jeannie K. Mathely, Larry G. Mathely James O. Bandy, Erica Y. Bandy a/k/a Heidi Arana Judith Ann Whitaker , Harris G. Whitaker, Erica Yolanda Oglesby Margarida Azevedo-Weaver Jr. Ratsamy Phothirath, Sithpraseuth Susan E. Buck Daniel L. Dodson Phothirath Mary E. Franklin-Conway, James J. Leland Ross Wilson, Melanie Messengale Freddirico Pye, Richlyn Vaughn-Pye Conway Jr Wilson Tabatha D. Chapman, Eric L. Chapman Karen M. Graham aka Karen Graham, Amanda F. Neal , James T. Neal IV Cassandra J. Rucker Albert Graham, Jr. Duangdeuane Vongsiri Philisa Gatlin, Patrick Ladell Gatlin Dawn J. Carraway, Gerald A. Carraway Elizabeth Johnson, Benjamin Johnson Leonard Hewlett James D. Armstrong Jessica Ann Harvey , Perry Jonathan Emery Ward, Tabetha R. Ward Spencer Randolph Sr. Harvey Lauri James, Timothy James Melinda D. Herring, Philip B. Herring Casey Michelle Zipperer, Samuel Alex Anna K. Yi, Samuel U. Yi Tommy White Pak, Eun A Pak Zipperer Manuel A. Cuevas Damond E. Bragg, Karita A. Bragg Lesley Gayle Shutters James R. Dickens, Lauren K. Frey AKA Jimmy Brooks Trudy D. Towe Lauren Kendall Frey Bradley M. Bolton, Teresa B. Bolton Thea J. Wilson, Timothy C. Wilson Erlene Holland, Paul Holland Otelia Ann Peterson Cynthia D. Vandergriff, Sean D. Decotus Sims, Dawn Sims Max Desir, Johana Desir Vandergriff Michael S. Walker Tiffany Johnson, Andre Johnson Rhonda J. Penny, Michael V. Penny Debra Juhl DeMarkus Doss, Regina Doss Elizabeth M. Christopher, Gary Shirley Ahlquist Ramona G. Richards Christopher William E. Brents Mary F. Townsend, Walter E. Townsend Renee Demange, Donielle A. Dean Edward Faria Kenneth C. Weinkle Marcy Holloway, Mark T. Holloway Krista Newman Kevin W. Lovell, Kimberly D. Lovell aka Kelly D. Clodfelter Lawrence A. White Kimberly Denise Doman Jean Hughes, Jim Hughes Jerry Michael Jones Donna Maria Laura L. Heck, Andrew J. Heck Carole Brady Kenneth D. Curry, Wilma J. Curry Nick Jordan, Delores Jordan Eric J. Douglas Nashville/Davidson County: 451 Kim D. Vaughan Cynthia M. Wiseman Homeowners Florence Gahoun, Vincent Dahoegnon Rudy Giron, Oscar M. Nieto Gwendolyn Holt, Michael Holt Tommie C. Sweeney Cathy M. Brown, Michael R. Brown Stephen Barbe, Jessica Barbe Earl F. Ballard John D. Doyle Phyllis K. McGee, Patrick K. McGee Leonard Hill Merrick C. Francis Herbert M. Estes aka Herbert Estes, Tomoko Carter, Ty Carter Randy Reed Patricia Chapman Estes Tomoko Carter, Ty Carter Amber Bennett Ciara L. North Tabitha M. Stackhouse, James Stackhouse Jamie L. Morgan Karli S. Carroll Kum A. Yi, Song U. Yi Maggie Frank McReynolds Joseph W. Robertson, III Jessica Cheatham, Matthew Cheatham p. 7 of 14 The Daily News Publishing Co. Opposition to Senate Bill 1299 May 2011

Kelly J Ellis, Thomas W. Ellis Rhonda Smart, Jack Smart Jack Williams, Ralph D. Stevens Janice M. Marlowe, Earl Jones Donna M. Quarles Robert Whitley Donaldson, Jr. aka Rudo Jonas Swanson, III, Angelia Swanson aka Helga D. Thordsen, Joseph W. Thordsen Tendaji Bey Angelia Y. Swanson Stephen E. Chaisson Rebecca K. Fielder, Mitchell G. Fielder Betty A. Autry Stephanie Powers Oveda Allen Jose Arturo Lopez Jerry A. Kennon Rebecca L. Barnes, Christopher D Barnes David K. Adams Candace Brown, Weylin Brown Marc Chevalier, Amanda J. Daeger Joseph F. Simonik, Jr. Kimberly Hunter, Eric Hunter Peggy J. Rudolph Ray E. Warren, Patricia A. Warren, Larry Lori E. Gross, John K. Gross Georgia Welch, Walter L. Welch W. Davy Christopher R. Atkins Delores A. Townsend Willie Wilson, Preston L. Campbell, Joyce Jessica Cheatham, Matthew Cheatham Amy B. Fagan, Larry Fagan, Jr. Wilson Leslie Shaffer Vanessa C. Barbour Donella Marsh Kenneth R. Baskin Hope Drake-Bolton Janet C. Patterson, William M. Patterson Raoul A. Russell Arthur F. Dukellis, Raymond A. Dukellis Brian A. Eason aka Brian Eason, Patricia Marco Asselin, Lisa Asselin Jimmy M. Barnes A. Eason Phoka M. Inta Yvonne E. Rogers David S. Humphrey, Nicole Elliott Wendell R. Tabor, Teri L.Tabor aka Teri Elizabeth M. Austin Tanna E. Miller, Charles L. Miller Lisa Fardello Mitchell Pollard Gina D. Raybourn, Michael D. Raybourn Mollie E. Fannon Sinead M. Huff Amanda M. Swift, Debbie J. Swift Elvin E. Williams, Sr. Calvin J. Linzy, Dorothy L. Linzy Edward Faria Dottie Megibben, Charles Megibben Laura Dove Rippon, Michael L. Stevens Melanie S. Behrens, Keith W. Behrens Sherree Cone, Cecil W. Cone, II Inocente Quevedo, Marcela Castelan Lucy D. Kurz, Frederick L. Kurz Thomas C. Jordan, Hazel E. Washington Angel L. Roman Khatoon Haji, Saleem M. Abdy Dorothy J. Fore Blanca Saguay, Milton Quezada Erikka Nichole Benning Douglas Gary Jones Sharon R. Greer, James V. Greer Gregory Christie Amy Cole, Jeffrey Cole Maria H. Butler Sarah Shay Randall Goins Jose DeLeon, Diana DeLeon Graciela Toney, Fred Toney Lori Donnell Gordan W. Gardner, Kelly A. Carlisle Katherine Mattingly, Thomas Mattingly II Patrick Ladell Gatlin Nora James William D. Fitzgerald David Hilderbrand James B. Whitehead Donna L. Cartwright James Yates Sedigheh Tahriri, Hossein Tahriri Lata T. Surti, Tarun N. Surti Charles A. Harrison Cynthia Kahanek, Elroy D. Kahanek Marina Falzone, James Falzone Betty Trayner Ricky L. Mitchell Beyan Yasin, Basheer Abdullatif Virginia R. Stephenson Leonard Hewlett Heather Bobb, John B. Bobb Betty C. Johnson a/k/a Vermel B. Johnson Stephen Barbe, Jessica Barbe Veronica Kolczynski Ronald Wilson aka Ronald C. Wilson, Lauri James, Timothy James Clark Edwards, Donna Edwards, Bryan Frances Wilson aka Frances M. Wilson Patrick J. Nelson Edwards Suzanne M. Ausili, James A. Ausili Mary A. Noonan Anna D. Young, Will Young, Jr. Christopher Esquilla Larry E. Hurley, Jr. Beverly A. Adcock Stephanie Beasly Lori P. Gittler, Brian T. Gittler Janet Morgan, John Morgan Lydia McDonald Robert Mack Cooper Bridgette Upchurch, Terry R. Upchurch, James Andrew House, Sharon Corbitt- Kelly J Ellis, Thomas W. Ellis Jr. house Berhanu S. Marut Louis M. Zappulla Nayyreh Keakajouri, Iraj K. Rahimi Alireza Hajjafar Jimmy Wilson, Ava Wilson Watina F Hillery, Jarrick L. Hillery Kathy Ann Leslie Mary Trigueros, Joe Trigueros Jeremy Adams, Tracie Adams Moo Jack Chon, Jung Hee Chon Shelia Sharpe Michael Booker Leonard Hill Briggette Ochoa, Joseph Ochoa Judith Ann Conditt, John Richard Conditt Sarah Scruggs, Tom W. Scruggs, Jr. Deanna S. Brown, Donald P. Brown Mario Castillo aka Mario Castillo Barbara D. Smith David Dantes, Lisa D. Dantes Rodriguez, Angela Castillo Linda M Pittman, Bruce H Pittman Gerald C. Finney, III Kirk Bayer Paula Webb John T. Kuhlman Debra J. Holt, James P. Holt Ciara L. North Fred J. Happel, Alice F. Happel Scott J. McIntosh Wanda Y. Douglas Jeremy Michael Gearheart Charmaine Johnson, Bobby Hendon Mary E. Cunningham, Charles E. Donald B. Neal Alisha M. Lampley, Jeffrey S. Lampley Cunningham Jason Hornsby Lori P. Driggs, David Driggs, Jr. Phyllis Turner, Shirley Turner Judith S. Wahlstrom Jennie Joanna Camp, Jennifer Michelle Richard Ice Adolfo Antonio Beltran Cripps E. Annette Harding, Sam E. Harding, Jr. Sylvia A. Catlett, John W. Catlett Charles T. Hoffman Laurel L. Garnett fka Laurel G. Johnson Robert I. Bush, Elaine K. Bush Nickita D. Bonner Arlene Ann Votra Mia J. Gladney, Derick T. Gladney Kyung M. Chung, Suk Won Chung, Soon Louis A. Austin, Sr. Catherine Richie, Jim Richie Ja Chung Rudy Giron, Oscar M. Nieto Pedro M.R. Gutierrez, Aldo A. Noriega Gloria A. Evans, Roger W. Evans James W Batey Steven D. Green, Jennifer L. Green Curtis Long, Shirley Long Huyen Le p. 8 of 14 The Daily News Publishing Co. Opposition to Senate Bill 1299 May 2011

Lara J. Long, Walter R. Long Jimmy Brooks Claudia E. Wright, Mirna E. Barillas Karyl M. Smith, Lance T. Smith Jason Ponciroli, Kimberly Ponciroli Stephanie J. Spradlin Jayme R. Bernero Korina Stanley, John Stanley Karen Lawrence Shahin Mohsenin, Beatrix Mohsenin Connie H. Robinson, Robert E. Robinson Robert P. Beals Roberta M Seneff as trustee of both the Jackie Mayton Jimmy M. Barnes Vance O. Seneff Living Trust and the Beverly Joann Napier Ralph Richard Lewis III, Julia C. Lewis Roberta M. Seneff Living Trust, Vance O Hattie J. Dewalt Louis M. Zappulla Senff as trustee of both the Vance O. Sandra R. Booker Mary Jacqueline Ward, John V. Seneff Living Trust and the Roberta M. Marvin W. Bonner Richardson Seneff Living Trust, Gregory E. Seneff, Rochelle L. Meadows, Glenn A. Meadows Michael F. Randall Cheryl E. Seneff James A. Lightman Lori Donnell Michele Stayton, Andre K. Williams Theodore S. Mullins Richard Ice Heather L Baker, Kevin E Baker Dayna M. Powell, Carl J. Powell David Beyers Trina London Buck Mills Philip John Weber James M. Brewington, Jr. aka James M. Jane Mears Malone Kim R. Hemphill Brewington Lloyd Eugene Yates Stephen H. Harrison, Mary M. Harrison Kena Darby, Russell Darby Catherine Richie, Jim Richie Randall Goins Jacqueline E. Franklin Catrena Thompson Collotta Johnson David C. Lunn Donna S. Hobbs Joseph Sheffield a/k/a Joseph A. Sheffield, Hizkias T. Woldegabriel, Tsigereda Tiffany N. Gilder Latonya Sheffield Aberha Candace Paull Marcy Selph Stephanie D. Vestal Gino Joseph Lacayo, Cynthia T. Lacayo Johnny Holmes Moses Maxen James Clifton Smith Wanda Harbin Bowman, Betty F. Harbin Ayman Soliman Abu Taleb Thomas J. Tsanadis, Jr. Jed H. Irwin Kia D. Hathaway Jamie Goodwin Frances Gaddis Arnetta Woodard Jamesena Johnson Robin G. Dillon Michael Dimitroff Randy A. Grisham, Suzanne P. Riva Kenjila C. Hammonds, Philip Hammonds Evella Renee Eddy, William G. Eddy Donna L. Shutt, James W. Shutt Mary E. Hull, Leighanne T. Calvert William Mastin Franklin E. Platt Charles T. Hoffman Shari Black Chiticia Woodard, Chiticia Woodard Catarina V Blitz Tania Borrelli, Tom C. Borrelli Kevin Lennon Sylvia A. Catlett, John W. Catlett Janet C. Patterson, William M. Patterson Robert D. Dean II Evelyn H. Hagy, Billy W. Hagy Joshua C. Leonard Michelle L. Thomas Amy L. Winsett Cynthia Rodgers, David Rodgers James O. Bandy, Erica Y. Bandy a/k/a Kenneth B. Ratliff Ebony R. Davis Erica Yolanda Oglesby Lori P. Driggs, David Driggs, Jr. Tyrone Montgomery, Maggie R. Jones, Mehrrooz Ghahdarijani, Pejman Carolyn J. King Rebecca A. Montgomery Najafabadi Don Thornberry Francois J Miquet Francis Anthony Dulcich, Jr. Hung Minh Son AKA Kevin Son Anna R. Woodard, Thomas W. Woodard, Regina R. Cotton, Malcolm Cotton Mary Jan Jones Jr. Damala A. Sengmany AKA Damala A. Roger Merritt, Judy Merritt Amy Patterson, Robert Patterson Dines Angel L. Roman Lisa Jean Goodrich Gloria Faye Gatewood Jonathan Bosworth Kenneth Bowers Robert N. Latham Leondo W. Smith, Donita R. Smith Nina Hawk Sean Galvin Ed Simpson, Delois Simpson Henry Monger, Tara Monger Jacqueline Y. Bumpas Lewis R Garrison David Bryan Wood Susan Forrest, Ronald Mack Forrest David Walton Betty A. Autry Memphis/Shelby County: Julie A. Goad, Kenneth M. Goad Cecil K. Thomas 821 Homeowners Jacqueline D. Croom, Wydell Croom William D. Rodgers, Carol R. Rodgers Ida Macon, Terry L. Macon Pricilla Harris, Thomas R. Harris, Barbara Joshua J. Bell Theodore R. Branch, Elsie T. Branch Harris Amy Cole, Jeffrey Cole Celeste C. Kelly Karen Soto, Juan Soto Cintron Rhea Johnson Judy G. Tullos AKA Judy Gibson Tullos, Minna Evans Ronnie Walker Temp Tullos, Jr. Teresa C. Wright Danielle Eloi Demetria W Taylor Teresa Davenport, Jerry Davenport Donna Russell, Michael W. Russell James D. Freeman Willie Wilson, Preston L. Campbell, Joyce Gina R. Clark, Robert R. Clark, Christine Marlon A. Malbrough Wilson Williams, James Williams Dale Green Mary Trigueros, Joe Trigueros Margo Buschek aka Margo S. Buschek, R. Dennis Casper, Lisa K. Casper James Maitland Jurgen Buschek Robin Y. Regester Marsha Stovall, Danny W. Stovall, Paul Wooden, Jr., Donna L. Robertson Cynthia Holifield, William Martin Melissa D. Stovall Wooden Sherry Wakeford, Addison A. Wakeford, Tommy White Pak, Eun A Pak Yvonne E. Rogers III Marcia Flowers Simms, John Jay Simms Rickie Lee Shell Shirley Wells Linn B. Taylor Terri N. Wallace Channon M Mickens p. 9 of 14 The Daily News Publishing Co. Opposition to Senate Bill 1299 May 2011

Bruce A. Stein, Elisa R. Stein Lawanda Minor T. C. Haynes Carlin McGlown, Adrian McGlown William Earl Phillips Wiley Sherman Snyder Brandy C. Bailey Amy Davis Young Tara Veandria Oliver, Kendrick Kenell Alonzo Bolden Tuwana N. Mitchell Oliver Natasha Reese Martha Miller Debra D. Denny Kenneth Rosemond Janet S. Koen, Phil Koen aka Phillip V. Judy Blackburn aka Judy Blackburn Andrea M. Smith Koen Paudert Greta M. Nowley Ben W. Holland Delaina G. Roberts, Malcolm L. Roberts Sharonda Sufaye Hampton Agnes M. Danielson Lisa McCrainey aka Lisa L. McCrainey Dion Tarrell Fisher Isiah McCray, III Sherry Hall Thompson Brenda Stallings, Gregory Stallings Elena L. Cadle, Thomas H. Cadle Lisa White Earl Shelton Donna S. Meeks, Larry W. Meeks Jerrita Boyland, Sherman Boyland Claudia M. Payne Jacqueline A. James Thelma Avert Cowan, Joshua Cowan Mehdi Sadeghi Ghahroodl, Mahboubeh S. Adrienne R. Downs-Shepherd Kimberly Wright Fenner, Kendall Fenner Taghavi Brandi Turner Gail S. Blocker AKA Gail Sanders Marie Donelson, Bennie L. Donelson Barbara Clothier Charles Spencer, Sr. Delawn A. Scott Frank A. Pereira Monika C Kieffer Ann R. Hays Davis, Robert S. Davis Olivia L. Sykes, Jason F. Sykes Courtney Selmon Amanda F. Doan, Jesse J. Doan Louise Reed Kay C. Gordon Marcus Shelton Jeffrey S. U'ren, Jennifer N. U'ren Summer L. Martinez, Jose Martinez Hugo Mayen Sieta M. Giles Bettie Truly Eileen Paternostro Cedrick D. Wooten James Williams, Adrice Williams Patrick Robinson Carl A Camper aka Carl Camper Ella B. Jones Pam Benson, Rickey L. Benson David L. Thompson Lula Mae Hinton Quandra Nichols, Randy Nichols Robert L. Hunt Jr., Vickie Y. Hunt Deborah Croft, Kenneth Croft Tracey McCotter, Thomas McCotter Valencia Quay Jordan Shannon Lofties, Scott L. Lofties aka Scott Rick Beaty, Lekecha Sykes Miriam E. Rodriguez, Juan Carlos Lofties Stephen W. Patterson, Angela Patterson Calderon Patrick Johnson, Kesha C. Hawthorne Catrina R. Wiseman Savage Woodard, Joyce Woodard Johnson aka Kesha Hawthorne Christina M. Shaw, Jason Shaw Raphael A Scott, Dannise Hopson Scott Garmer Currie, III Carmon J. Booker Angles Johnson Murilo Peres Citlalli M. McBee Heidi Harding, Rodrigues Bradshaw Donna L. Greenland Lesia Lonberger AKA Lesia D. Lonberger, Frances Cooper Laura J. Holley, Joseph E. Holley James Lonberger Gracie M. McDaniel James Gartrell, Jr. Wendy Gerregano, David A Gerregano Rickey D. Sturdivant Allen White, Jennifer Call Bettye Williams, Vincent E. Williams Linda C Morgan, Bret Morgan Melonie B. Kelley Joel C. Oliver Sr. aka Joel Oliver, Phyllis Corey Early Enrique L. Plunkett, Jewel Fason-plunkett Denise Oliver aka Phyllis Oliver Rotunda Rewa Lawson Kim Grandberry, Gregory Grandberry Phyllis P. Osburn, James Lawrence Raushanah A. Chapital, Shaun Chapital Michael A. Hunter, Melanie M. Hunter Osburn Robert Schuerman Vanessa L. Miller Nancy C. Spencer, Howard A. Spencer Cora Bogard, Edward Bogard Annette Webb Jonathan G. Hardin aka Jonathan Hardin Elisabeth E Frye, O. F. Frye Maria A. Dower Robin L. Harris, Eric Harris, Earnest Lee Marcine A Robinson, Patrick Robinson Kandice Fernstrom Key Denise Lee Ward Toney R. Hughes Doras C. Beckham, Eugenia D. Beckham Alma L. Martin, John Martin Corey Bennett, Vanessa Bennett Jenna Faye Jones Janice A. Banks, David King Shirley P. Franklin Heather M. Brown, George L. Brown Jason T. Craig, Libby Dust Meegan Barrett Adair, Delvin Adair Tonya Yvette Taylor Janet M Lawson, Jimmy L Lawson Dell Crawford, Veronica K. Paige Maria R. Harbert Leon Stewart Thomas Anthony Stupka Jacqueline Faye Meeks A/K/A Jacqueline Terry Stark, Anita Morris Avery White aka Avery Tyrone White F. Meeks Louis B. Summers Carolyn D. Banks Vivian Thompson, Jimmie Thompson Leslie Webster, Phillip S Webster Teresita Pinon Calvin E. Hence Charles Kenneth Henry Parrish L. Throckmorton, Kurt B. Horace Pruitt Wauskieshia Hunt Throckmorton Michele D. Young James E. Washam Jr., Glenda F. Washam Doris Taylor, Regina Powell Alicia Gonzalez, Javier Real-Hernandez Calandra T. Wilson, Joseph Wilson III Latricha Williams Jennifer Delores Bradford AKA Jennifer Leonard E. Shannon Tracy Davis, Kimmie P. Davis, Jr. Delores Arnold Gary E. Powell, Johnnie M. Lilly Charles A. Chapuis Sylvester Gailes, Rosetta Gailes Vanessa Braxton Robert J. Liles, Barbara Liles Albert Hartjen, Monica Hartjen Hung V. Bui Irish Denise Elder Calvin L. Eubanks Jr. Ervin Woodfork, Cletea Woodfork Allison Banks Michelle Johnson Remonda F. Watson, Marcus C. Watson Almeta Rogers, Devin Rogers Aloma Ray Keith Lowe, Dorothy A. Johnson, Dorothy Carla Clay Eric Conway, Deborah Conway M. Johnson Celia Guevara, Gilberto Guevara p. 10 of 14 The Daily News Publishing Co. Opposition to Senate Bill 1299 May 2011

Odell Sanders Shelton Robert Parks Petra Zuno Ramirez, Cristobal Lomeli, Scott Vankirk Lindsey L. Cox Miguel Zuno Rose A. Harris Patrick Robinson Timothy S. Strickland Norma L. Roberts, Alexander M. Roberts Lazaro Castaneda Juan Sanchez Tracey McCotter, Thomas McCotter Cynthia Kemp Parker, Carl Howard Parker St. Roland Jeancharles Mehdi Sadeghi Ghahroodl, Mahboubeh S. Mamadou Pame Chrishawn Tyler Taghavi Marcie L. Wright Matzke, Brian W. Tamula Sinkfield Kevin Ingram, Yolanda Ingram Matzke Carene M. Weide, Randy H. Evans Bernice Whitfield Kelvin Lee Bates, Monica Onethia Bates Terri L. Rowland, James B. Rowland Donald Ray Gayden aka Don Gayden Sylvia Mason Sherrita F. Foster Amanda Smith, Curtis Earl Smith David Guevara Debra E. Gaddy, James N. Gaddy Eli Sabir, Derotha Moten Adunaser Umer, Muniray Yusuf Ahmed Marvin Gilliam aka Marvin M. Gilliam Quannah L. Harris, Hanalei Y. Harris Maxine W. Murrell, James O. Murrell Michelle L. Metz, John C. Metz Carolina Carvajal Vicki Williams, Stephen Paul Williams Diann Jones, Cassie Z. Smith, Vernola Frank Lopez, Jr. Stephen McSpadden aka Stephen Kelly Buchanan Carolina Carvajal McSpadden Chandre B. Smyth Phyllis Black Ruth Lofton, Daryl Lofton Samuel Bonner, Felicia Bonner Mildred B. Smith, Debra S. Smith, Lisa K. Stewart, Glenn Stewart, Jr. Clarice McPherson Michael R. Smith Lawrence Gaines Wilma Blaylock Susanne Marie Gray, John Norman Gray J. W. Roby Ali Leonard, Asta Leonard Zarah Hopper Errol L. Raspberry Gregory Hyche Dorothy Mae Collins, Ruben Collins Cynthia Lynn Collins Gladys Elaine Young Gregory G. Underwood Donald R. Hutchinson Sammie Vester Joy J Cunningham, Demetrius Albert Deidre Catron Joe Frank Hill Cunningham Ricki Perry Smart, Oscar N.Smartt, Jr. Sarah Brown, Albert L. Brown Clyde Manuel Bell Caroline Lyman, Karl B. Lyman Virginia R Solano, David L. Solano, Valarie B. Prigg Carolyn D. Mooney Virginia R. Solano Jeanette Johnson, Cordell L. Johnson Jr. Johnny Lawson, Jean G. Amos-Lawson Marilyn Barker, James A. Barker Kenda Campbell Latanua K. Rudd Celia Paulino, Mark Paulino, Brian Demetria L. Sharp Percrystal Swift Paulino Stephanie V. Haake, Daniel R. Haake Brenda H. Jones James Hall Roy A Pierce, Janiece T Pierce Floyd Williams Reginald E. Williams Augusta Baker Maggie Ward, Irving Ward Dorothy Topps Gilbert Garcia, Rhonda Minor Warren Graham, Carolyn Graham Lee Jones, Virginia Jones Gail J. Austin, Lee Austin, Jr. Archie Guest Charles R. Barrom Robert C. Hoshall, Deborah D. Hoshall Patrick Robinson Maxine Harrison, Lenard Wayne Harrison Lee C. Bass, Jr., Betty Bass Doris Edwards Dion Tarrell Fisher Leonard McGee, Betty Ann McGee Mary Lee Wells Cynthia Cote, Silas Carpenter Janet M. Williams, Dobby O. Williams Rebecca E. Ventrini, Stella Ventrini Mario Auvert, Kira Auvert, Edgardo V. Debra D. Mayes, Robert E. Mayes, III James Joulwan Auvert Victoria E. Robin Charlene B. Dearing, William A. Dearing Kimberly Rodgers, Elgin Vandell Rodgers Lachell Boyd Tamara Denise McDonald, Melvin Ray Sahar Abbas, Basem J. Al-sultan Charlene A Latimer, Robert L Latimer McDonald Calvin Jones Rhonda F. Dion, Jeffrey W. Dion Noel C. Brown Tracy Y. Brittmon, James P. Brittmon Patrick J. Trainor, Elizabeth R. Trainor Tiffanie White, Jose Joiner Rise D. Rivera aka Rise D. Gibson Charlene Turner Wanda J. Vaccaro Jayceette Boger, Michael D. Boger, Jr. Lasondra Jones Claudia K. Pew Jana Norrell Brandie Chism Daryl K. Isabel Nicola Chapman, Paul Chapman Mack G. Walker Thelma Conway, Edwin Conway Sharonda Sufaye Hampton John T. Akins Latanya Stephens, Alvin D. Stephens Marcus Springer, Melanie Springer LaCarla Gray, Winston Gray Gregory L. Morris Katherine Earnest, Waymon Earnest, Jr. Barbara Roe, Roger Roe Brenda McGowan Kari D. Williams Sharon Couch Era M. Wilson Jamie D. Reece, Laura F. Reece Robert G. Poore Teresa G. Jones, Robert L. Jones Angus Macdonald Timothy E. Briggs, Amy S. Lee Ruthie Wilson Myrtle Hall Lisa K. Burks, Douglas E. Burks Jessica Walker aka Jessica D. Walker, James E. Crowder, Heather M. Crowder Nerlan E. Meade Matthew Walker aka Matthew Paul Barbara Clothier Christine Kaufman Walker John C. Mercer, Edna R. Mercer Tarrikia Cleaves Carlos Cabrera, Ana Avila Kywane Johnson Kelly Murphy, Brandon L. Murphy Mary E. Padron Shelton Robert Parks Hamid Mortazavi Troy A. Vandyke, Jr., Jennifer Vandyke Margaret A. Kirkland, Roy E. Kirkland Thomas S. Wilkinson William L. Barnett Lawrence Cartwright Anterial Mitchell Curtis Arrington Jadranka Perisic, Zoran Perisic Shelby Sellers Paul Harris p. 11 of 14 The Daily News Publishing Co. Opposition to Senate Bill 1299 May 2011

Clara M Green, Larry L Green Ida V. Macon, Terry L. Macon Donna M. Chipman, James W. Chipman Mary A. George Debra D. Stout, Charles Edward Stout Anthony Yates, Stephanie Yates Magda Garcia a/k/a Magda Beatriz Garcia, Ruby Louise Thomas, Frank Thomas, Melissa A. Ruparatne, Yohan S. Ruparatne Luis O. Ardon Mattie B. Wright, Leroy Ward Clyde Manuel Bell Leon Boddie Josephine S. Powell Zarah Hopper Patty Williams Gary L. Little, Tarji A. Little Louise Reed Latin Mathes, Mario Mathes Mary Bradshaw, Thelma Jean Giaminetti Channon Washington, Eric Washington William R. Durden Sabrina Jackson, Frank T. Jackson Dorothy Mae Collins, Ruben Collins Katherine W. Enochs , Christopher Enochs Linda R. Cunningham Lamonte Harlin, Sr. Michele D. Young Linda D. Henderson, Virgil D. Henderson Tonya Yvette Taylor Dale Green Daniel R. Taylor, Waltricia Blair Maria Andrade, Anselmo Andrade Kimberly Daughty, Kevin Daughty Marylin Johnson Meeks, John Meeks Carlin McGown, Adrian McGown, Amy Shirley J Hawkins Sandra K. Williams, Dan Williams Fisher, Ghyrane A. Fisher Catrina R. Wiseman Crystal Ford Jarvis Gooden Jeannine D. Jefferson Darrel Gibson Pamela Gillum, Barrow Gillum Carlos J. Herrera Ruth M. Bogard Carolyn S. Covington Johnnie Mae Jeffries Carol Vernita Gibbs Michelle D. Perry, Ray R. Perry Darryll A. Alexander Kelvin Wiseman Joyce A. Stewart Tyrone Smith Dung Duong, Hoa C. Lam Rosie Crawford Raymond Eddings, Jeanette E. Eddings Maria Hernandez, Noe Alvarado Luanne G. Hearn Chandre B. Smyth William M. George, Rachel J. George Mark P. Griffin Toni H. Hoag, Eldon M. Hoag, Jr. Keli Y. Loveland, David R. Loveland Latasha Hart Mileydi Ricardo Tracey N. Ford Emma Tutton, James Luster Tutton Antonio L. Herman Amy P. Bland, Joseph V. Bland Nephateria Moorehead, Kindal Moorehead Annie J. Wilhite aka Annie Wilhite Rhonda Thomas Diane M. Baumgartner, James R. Jodi M. Russell Carolyn J. Brown Baumgartner Fred D. Roberts, Jr. Corry Jackson Delreco Sumler Tamika Wheeler aka Tamika M. Beal Angela Richmond Darrell W. Branch Clayette Yvette Dorse Charles Frencher, Valery Frencher William Earl Phillips Torrin M. Watkins, Tammy S. Jones Terry Chamness, Terry Chamness Kimberly Wright Fenner, Kendall Fenner Debra Pryor, Kenneth Pryor Jacqueline Denise Odomes Kenneth A. Woods Ashley Reid Douglas, Jonathan Alan Pam Benson, Rickey L. Benson Mary Corkren Douglas Roy Marcel Repelin, Olga Victoria Wendy Bellou, Andre Bellou Gina Kasa aka Gina McClenton Repelin Bettie J. Fisher Columbus Nevels, Ernestine Nevels Lisa L. Sharp, William C. Sharp, Patricia Earnest B. Crutcher, Jr. Leonard D. Abrams G. Signer Tracy Smith Helen P. Baucom Crystal Lynn Woody aka Crystal Woody David King Frank Buford Edelmira Gooden, Brunell Gooden Sharon Griffiin, Marcus D Griffin Eliza Boucher, Lloyd Boucher Ronald L. House Francisco J. Amador, Reyna Amador Cliffer Tarnard Blackmon Shelley L. Rodgers aka Shelley Volkman Eugene Pratcher Venus Strickland, Kenneth Aaron Dianne G. Hawkins Carmelita F Pacheco Strickland, Jr. Elaine Cohen Rhonda L. Holliday Anita Cook, Ellis Cook Rickey Sturdivant Ana Fajardo Fannie K. Bredow, Natalie S. Diamond Almeta Rogers, Devin Rogers Keddren Payne, Monica Payne Shannon White Letitia Lemons Wendell Bonner Katrena Brinkley Trice, Uleches L. Trice Ronald V. Pope Daniel Hernandez, Griselda Hernandez Jonathan G. Hardin aka Jonathan Hardin Gerry Finney, Rachel Rodriguez Finney Latoya Ester, Anthony Dewayne Ester Joyce Nicholson, Jessie Nicholson Alma Torres, Miguel Torres Sherri C. Pettigrew, Antonio R. Dean Beverly J. Barber Frances Cooper Bevanne Bowers Ronald Harris, Selica Ingram Anita Romrell, Ron Romrell Anita Finch aka Anita L. Mull Verbia L. Gibson Joshua A. Frase Anner J. Echols, Charles E. Echols Odde Williamson aka Odde O. LaToya Malone, Wendale B. Malone W. E. Phillips Williamson, Jr. Margaret L. Williams, Gordon E Williams James Downing, Martha Downing Philip Hendren Heather M. Brown, George L. Brown Deborah J. Cochran, Glenn Elvin Cochran Barbara Roe, Roger Roe Roger K. Williams, Sr. Didi L. Watts, Peter Watts, Jr. Karen Y Wright Amber D Yobak, John Lee Yobak Twoine Sesley Michael D. Robinson Lois Davis Joy J Cunningham, Demetrius Albert Christina M. Shaw, Jason Shaw Sheon McLeod, Simone R. Shields Cunningham Kay C. Gordon Ahmad Bruce Deborah M. Claxton Randall Felts Quandra Nichols, Randy Nichols David Ricks Leslie Johnson Ingram, Dale T. Ingram Carmon J. Booker Tracy Davis, Kimmie P. Davis, Jr. Kay Johnson, Dale S. Johnson Steven M Butler, Nicole M Butler Calvin E. Hence Sheryl M. Wells Devin D. Love Cassandra Bryant Myron Strickland Rebecca Goodwin Noreena Chance, Emanueal Thomas p. 12 of 14 The Daily News Publishing Co. Opposition to Senate Bill 1299 May 2011

Virginia V. Moss, William C Moss Jr Larry Robinson Gladys F. Crutcher, Kelvin Crutcher Eli Sabir, Derotha Moten Darlene Vu, Ginsues Vu Alma L. Martin, John Martin John Dovel Clyde David Ruble Ashley Mooney Andrew Neil Howsden Gary L Erving Rose Harris Valerie Peeples, Vernard Peeples William Earl Phillips Carla D. McKinley, Marlon F. McKinley Donna Michelle Flynt, David Scott Flynt Berta Wheeler Era M. Wilson Nivea Gonzales Louis B. Summers Leigh Ann Riedel, Lawrence J. Riedel Bradley Chafin, Allan Chafin Michael Taylor, Sr. William Earl Phillips Vanessa Wilkes, George Wilkes Cedric Dwayne Cook, Constance Cook Scott Sever, Barbara A. Sever Brandi Turner Brandon J. Daley Amanda C. Lee, Johnny R. Chenault Floyd Williams Marvin Hammond, Kimberly L. Hammond Michael J. Dugan, Oscie Dugan Margaret A. Blankenship Alonzo Sullivan Rebecca Lewis, Jeremy Lewis Robin Shields Courtney Selmon Leslie A. Hershberger, Robert L. Edna M. Jeter aka Edna Jeter, William H. Johnny Lawson, Jean G. Amos-Lawson Hershberger, John R. Hershberger Jeter Roseta H Harris Gloria F. Jones Patricia Basey, David Basey Katherine Littlewood Kimberly S. Scott, Jerry F. Scott Lynnetta K. Pierce Fallene M. Woods, Curtis L. Woods Richard Taylor, Linda Madison Taylor Tamika Nelson, Renwick Bryant Sherry Betton Vonnie Hill aka Vonnie C. Greer, Johnny Jenna Faye Jones Louise Parker T. Hill Lisa K. Burks, Douglas E. Burks Mary Brooks, Bobby E. Brooks Katrina A. Riley Natalie R Adamson, Joseph Adamson Christobal Gonzales Nancy K. Miller, Mark E. Miller Miriam Shaw, Henry Shaw Peter Ronald Larkin Allison Banks Cremolia Louise Mathews, Ronald Potts Steven Payton, Joannettee Payton Bonnie B. Maloney, Joseph Mark Maloney Jorge Juarez Vega Donna K. Franklin, Hubert Dale Franklin Kevin Dwayne Slate, Carman D. Slate Debra A. Myhand, Andre L. Myhand John Alan Field Calvin Wright Patricia Reaves Laura Annunziata, Brian Annunziata Michael Young aka Michael Harper Lester C. Hubbard, Regina H. Hubbard Mark A. Harrison Young Desiree D. Glasper, Darrick L. Glasper Victoria P. Tipton Melissa Baines, Randy Baines Latonia R. Finley Shekita L. Brown Shay Kimble, Nia Kimble aka Nia M. Christine Kaufman Sheri P. Dorsey Kimble Helowease S. Blocker, Prentice C. Gail S. Blocker AKA Gail Sanders S. S. Christian aka Sarojani Christian, Coppage Donald D. Swain, Sr. Solomon K. Christian Jessica Walker aka Jessica D. Walker, Brandie Chism Willie L. Brooks Sr. Matthew Walker aka Matthew Paul Meegan Barrett Adair, Delvin Adair Vera C. Wooten Walker Ulysses Chaffin, Amy Marie Albright Samuel McClenton Walter Anderson AKA Amy Marie Chaffin Genevieve S. Giannini, Don Giannini aka Ervin Woodfork, Cletea Woodfork Lucretia Danner Don M. Giannini Monica Martin Marsena G. Parham, Andrae J. Parham George T. Simpson Gerald W. McRae, Mary J McRae Maria M. Longoria, Marcelino Longoria Mario R. Becerril, Maria Isabel Santos aka Christel V. Glass Sammie McClanahan Maria Isabel Becerril Tena E. Coleman Paul Harris Ashli M. Brown Dorothy Jean Lynn aka Dorothy Lynn, Robin Regester Cynthia Graham, Wayne Graham, Cynthia James Lynn Carrie L. Robinson a/k/a Carrie R. Jones N. Graham, Wayne Graham Leighsa A. McCommon aka Leighsa a/k/a Carrie L. Jones, Larry C. Jones Judy G. Tullos, Temp Tullos, Jr. Anderson McCommon, Robert Anderson Sidney W. Collier, Oscar Collier Kathryn R. Mobley, Joshua Grey Mobley McCommon Marjorie Marshall, Dennis J. Marshall Starry Knox, Sandra Jones Robert W.Jackson Tara R. Stephenson, Eugene Stephenson, Michael W. Brewer Gregory G. Underwood III Misty Neese, David Neese Laverne W. Nelson Ossie Boyd Kandice Fernstrom Kenneth Turner Carlos Cabrera, Ana Avila Cornell Trotter Charlene B. Dearing, William Dearing Michelle L. Metz, John C. Metz Chandra Bowens, Ronnie Ray Bowens Thomas Tice Darlene Presley, Lathan J. Presley Barbara Roe, Roger Roe Terry Stark, Anita Morris Marlinee Iverson NKA Marlinee Clark, Barby Kratt Leon Stewart Eric Iverson Latricha Williams Adam Cox, Lorrie Cox Cathy M. Ross, Gregory L. Ross Horace Griffin, Annie Griffin Rickey Sturdivant Edwina S. Cummings Dollisha Shore, Jeremy Tyrone Shore Jennifer Willoughby, Christopher Howard D. Watts Jr., Donald Wolfe Rose Pinkney Simmons Willoughby Esther Tankersley, Michael J. Tankersley Amy R. Hammonds, Steven B. Hammonds Sheila Regina Harrell, Donald Ray Harrell Avery White aka Avery Tyrone White Robert Oliver Phillips, Susan B Vincent Lula Pryor Denise Lee Ward aka Susan Boone Vincent Michele Lynn Davis, Robert L. Davis Debra A. Long Amy Turner Leslie Webster, Phillip S Webster Rodrick Morris, Suzanne Morris Devin Derrell Carroll Jason M. Hovendick Sandra F Rasch, William A. Rasch, Jr. Diana Jones, James Jones, Jr. Charles Kenneth Henry Lila Williams Regina A. Goodwin p. 13 of 14 The Daily News Publishing Co. Opposition to Senate Bill 1299 May 2011

Roddrick D. Collier Tony Alexander Mary C. Ealy, Gary Ealy William C Howard aka William Clifton Dawn Davis, Robert Perry Howard, Jr. Neola Danielle Bice, Zachary Eldon Bice Marilyn Barker, James A. Barker Dion Wallace, Tijuana Lewis aka Tijuana Virginia R Solano, David L. Solano, Wallace Virginia R. Solano Ioma L. McVay Anthony P. Bell, Alisa J. Bell Audrey F. Mathes James Hall Barbara Malone, Harvey Malone Shirley J Hawkins Cora Bogard, Edward Bogard Cynthia Cote, Silas Carpenter Arthur Williams Reginald E. Williams Patricia M. Hobson, Howard Scott Terry Calvin Jones Marcus Rufus Foreman Robert Joiner Nerlan E. Meade Robert M. Turner George C. Lipscomb Lawrence Jay Fields Jessica Harris Reyna, Bryan Reyna Esmeralda Hernandez Bolanos, Jose Wanda J. Vaccaro Trinidad Amezquita Mary Grace L. Tidwell, Odell Tidwell, Jr. Sally Lane Wright Amy R. Thomas, Bobby E. Thomas Arnette Allen Linda Boyd Nikita Nichols, Alandre Nichols Kristin B. Weber Sharon McGee Patricia A. Peoples Linda N. Brumley Patricia A. Larry, Katie M. Price Michelle P. Gibbons aka Michelle Kenneth Johnson, Felicia Johnson Gibbons, Jacob Gibbons Patricia W. McCaleb, Parker L. McCaleb William Sasfrass Cynthia Uhlhorn, William Uhlhorn aka JoAnne Peake, James C. Peake William V. Uhlhorn Marales Mobley Melissa C. Hoover Christine S. Matseas, William B. Matseas Eva Sombathy, Timothy A. Sombathy Dennis Wayne Nicholson, Mary B. Christine A. Rowe aka Christine E. Rowe, Nicholson Floyd D. Rowe, III Wm E. Phillips aka William E. Phillips Allan Phillips Gladys Elaine Young Maria Hernandez, Noe Alvarado Yasmine Issa Kharwish, Mohammed R. Lester R. Toliver, Joyce Toliver Kharwish Tammy R. Stevens, Boyce K. Stevens Jr. Ruth Day, Jerry Day Peter Boyd, Detroit Boyd Johnny Harper, Jr. Anthony D. Keller Magda Garcia a/k/a Magda Beatriz Garcia, Debra D. Stout, Charles Edward Stout Luis O. Ardon Warren A. Dotson, Warren A. Dotson Barbara Roe, Roger Roe Hiam Saad, Jihad M. Karakira Walter Anderson Travis Scott, Karen L. Washington aka Juanita Jackson, Keath Jackson Karen L. Scott Anthony Chapman, Amy S. Chapman Carita H. Reaves Alfonzie Briggs Jr., Ruby Winters Briggs Eugene Pratcher aka Ruby J. Briggs Dennis M. Farley, Tineke Farley Tonnette Henderson, Kevin Henderson Robert Brad Kline Michael D. Jeffers Lashawn Carter, Austin H. Carter Mary Wenzler, Tom Wenzler Natasha Orlantha Stewart Dung Duong, Hoa C. Lam Sherma F. Regan, Richard D. Regan Kimberly K. Barrom, Richard L. Barrom Vince Abston Beverly Conner, Douglas E. Conner Melanie Williams, Marcel Williams Jamie Murphy, Shameka Murphy Sammie Vester Celia Paulino, Mark Paulino, Brian Paulino Ferris Hooshmand, Terrie Hooshmand William Harris, Carla O. Harris Shirley Rhynes Sheveta Hoof Jacquelin A. Catrun Bennie Gailey, Jr., Judith E. Gailey Quannah L. Harris, Hanalei Y. Harris p. 14 of 14