Female genital tract infections involving anaerobes
Elisabeth Nagy MD, PhD, DSc
Institute of Clinical© by Microbiology, author University of Szeged Anaerobe Reference Laboratory for Hungary ESCMID Online Lecture Library
ESCMID Postgraduate Course on Anaerobes 2014, Groningen Normal flora of the female genital tract
Vaginal fluid of 79 control women Culture method (48h CO2) investigated by NGS
~90%
© by author ESCMID Online Lecture Library
E. Shipitsyna et al : PLOSone 2013 Summary of 63 articles dealing with vaginal microbiome studies on health and BV.
Many different molecular techniques were used during the last 10 years: NGS,© by author Sequencing of colonies ESCMID OnlineFingerprinting, Lecture Library qPCR Infections of the female genital tract involving anaerobes
Anaerobes of the normal flora are involved (mixed infections) Bacterial vaginosis (infection??) Postoperative infections Non-puerperal and postpartum endometritis PID (salpingitis)© by author Chorioamnionitis ESCMID Premature Online rupture Lecture of membranes Library Premature labour IUD related infections
History of bacterial vaginosis
Non-specific vaginitis (Krönig 1892) Haemophilus vaginitis (Gardner and Dukes 1954) Corynebacterium vaginitis (Zimmerman and Turner 1969) Gardnerella vaginitis (Greenwood and Pickett 1980) Anaerobic vaginosis© by (1982) author Non-specific vaginosis (1984) ESCMID Bacterial vaginosis Online (Spigel Lecture and Roberts 1984) Library Signal bacterium of BV: Gardnerella vaginalis versus Atopobium vaginae Bacterial vaginosis (BV)
Flora change (dysbiosis) characterized by disappearance of the lactobacillus flora and predominance of a mixed bacterial (anaerobic) flora Endogenous infection? Reservoire of some BV associated bacteria in the gut (Holst E, JCM 1990)© by author G. vaginalis in the oral biofilm ((Marrazzo JM et al.: JID 2012)
ESCMID Changed ‘normal Online flora’? Lecture (Mard PA. Infect Library Dis Obstet Gynecol 1997; Witkin SS. CID 2007) STD/STI? Epidemiology of bacterial vaginosis
In the industrialized world among symptomatic women: BV > candidiasis or trichomoniasis
BV is common in the developing world too (Rakai, Uganda 1997) Prevalence of among patients with symptoms BV 51% trichomoniasis © by 24%author yeast <5%
ESCMID Prevalence of BV Online among pregnant Lecture women in the Library USA blacks > hispanic > whites (22%) (16%) (8%) Epidemiology of bacterial vaginosis
BV is more prevalent among women attending an STD clinic IUD users women who are using regular douching frequent Candida infection sexually experienced© by womenauthor female sex workers ESCMID lesbians Online(extremely highLecture rates of BV) Library women who practice oral sex
Berg 1984; Eschenbach 1988; Hillier 1990; Skinner 1996; Schmid 1999; CDC 2000; Fethers 2000; Joesoef 2001; Morris 2001; August 2004; Vaginal ecosystem
Normal versus Bacterial vaginosis
- Lactobacillus predominance - Few H2O2 producing Lactobacillus - Usually 107 CFU/g - 109 CFU/g - Ratio of anaerobes/aerobes - Ratio of anaerobes/aerobes 2-5:1 © by author 100 -1000 : 1 - G. vaginalis (5-60%) - G. vaginalis (95%) - MobiluncusESCMID (0-5%) Online Lecture- Mobiluncus Library(50-70%) - M. hominis (15-30%) - M. hominis (60-75%) E. Shipitsyna et al : PLOSone 2013
Categories were determined by relative abundance of taxa measured by NGS and bacterial load measured by qPCR
© by author ESCMID Online Lecture Library Development of bacterial vaginosis
NORMAL BV Lactobacillus
Increasing pH
Gardnerella Increasing symptomes © by author Anaerobes
NormalESCMID conditions Possible Online reasons LectureBacterial vaginosis Library intercorse (Amsel’s criteria) use of spermicids hormonal effects use of vaginal dushes use of IUD other infections Pathogenesis of bacterial vaginosis
32% of vaginal lactobacilli has lytic phages
© by author ESCMID Online Lecture Library
(C. Spiegel: Reviews Med. Microbiol. 2002) New concept in the pathogenesis of BV
S.S. Witkin et al.: Hypothesis of an altered immunity for the development of symptomatic bacterial vaginosis (CID; 2007)
Components of innate immunity Toll-like receptors (TLRs) Inducible heat shock© proteinby author (70-kDs) (hsp70) Mannose-binding lectin (MBL) ESCMID Online Lecture Library BV develops as a result of inhibition of TLRs, decrease in hsp70 production, and inadequate MBL function.
Possibilities of the diagnosis
Diagnostics: Amsel’s criteria - clinical symptoms Nugent’s scores - based on Gram-staining Culture in an anaerobic environment (48-72h) Detection of signalling bacterium: Gardnerella vaginalis vs. Atopobium vaginae © by author Recently 16S rRNA-based amplification, sequencing, followed by broad-range clone library analyses of vaginal ESCMID flora Online Lecture Library Fredricks DN, et al: N. Eng. J. Med (2005) Hyman RW, et al: Proc. Natl.Acad. Sci. USA (2005) Shioitsyna E, et al: PLOSone (2013)
Amsel`s criteria (1983)
A homogenous discharge (not always seen by the clinicians) pH >4.5 (only if the sample is taken from the proper place of the vagina) Positive amine „whiff” test in the presence of 10% KOH (may be positive also in trichomoniasis) Fishy vaginal odor during menstruation after intercourse © by author Presence of clue cells (WBC can be also present) ESCMIDMinimal itching Online or irritation Lecture Library Detection of „clue” cells (Gram)
Lactobacillus dominanted vaginal flora
© by author ESCMID Online Lecture Library Typical „clue cells” = BV Detection of the „clue” cells (wet-mount slide)
© by author ESCMID Online Lecture Library Epithelial cells covered by coccobacilli Diagnosis of BV based on the Nugent scores (Gram-sataining)
Points scored per morphotype* Bacterial morphotype None 1+ 2+ 3+ 4+
Large gram-positive rods 4 3 2 1 0
Small gram-neg/var. rods 0 1 2 3 4
Curved gram-neg/var.© rodbys author0 1 2 3 4
*Score 0-3 points – Normal ESCMID 4-6 points Online – Intermediate Lecture Library 7-10 points – Bacterial vaginosis
Nugent RP, et al.:: Reliability of diagnosing bacterial vaginosis is improved by a standardized method of gram stain interpretation. J Clin Microbiol 1991, 29:297-301.
Culture - based diagnosis of BV
Media:
Human blood agar (48 h in CO2 / anaerobically) Gardrenella vaginalis
Columbia blood agar (24 h in CO2) lactobacilli, aerobic bacteria © by author Columbia blood agar with vitamin K1 and hemine ESCMID(4-5 days Onlinein an anaerobic Lecture environment Library)
Frequently isolated and identified anaerobic (aerobic) bacteria: Gardnerella vaginalis Mobiluncus mulieris (long curved rod) Mobiluncus curtisii (short curved rod) Bacteroides urealyticus and other spp Prevotella bivia and other spp Prophyromonas spp Fusobacterium nucleatum Peptostreptococcus© by spp author Streptococcus morbillorumBV flora after incubation for 96 h in an anaerobic environment ESCMIDAtopobium Online vaginae Lecture Library Mycoplasma hominis etc. G. vaginalis
© by author ESCMID Online Lecture Library BV flora on human blood agar incubated in an anaerobic chamber © by author ESCMID Online Lecture Library Gardnerella vaginalis
Gram-labil coccobacillus, „surface pathogen”
Produce hemolysin – cytolytic activity
Synergism with P. bivia*
Production of the biofilm!!! © by author *P. bivia utilizes aminoacids and produce ammonia and Gardrenella utilizesESCMID ammonia to produceOnline amino Lecture Library acids
Mobiluncus spp
Gram-variable, anaerobic, mobile, curved rods Produce trimethylamine - responsible for the fishy odor They are involved in intra- and extra-genital infections The reservoir is the gastrointestinal tact M. mulieris (long curved© byrod) author M. curtisii- (short curved rod) – more virulent ESCMID the IgG titre is higherOnline Lecture Library „escape” from phagocytosis Variable resistance to metronidazole Atopobium vaginale
Newly detected species (Rodriguez Jovita M. et al. 1999)
Gram-positive elliptic cocci in pairs or short chains
Anaerobic (however it is growing slowly in CO2)
55% of BV patients had a positive signal in the vaginal fluid using 16S rRNA© PCRby +author sequencing (Ferris MJ et al. 2004) Some isolates are highly resistant to metronidazole, but all ESCMIDsusceptible to clindamycin Online (BackerLecture E.D. 2006) Library During research on bacterial vaginosis
The results are influenced by „what is compared with what?” Clinical symptoms (Amsel criteria) with molecular testing Gram-staining (Nugent score) with molecular testing © by author What about culturing the samples in anaerobic ESCMIDenvironment Online for 4 -Lecture5 days? MALDI Library-TOF MS will provide identification in real-time. (2013)
Amsel criteria versus NGS and 16 species/genus specific RT-PCR
© by author ESCMID Online Lecture Library
Conclusion: Amsel criteria can be used by clinicens for diagnosis of BV 16S rRNA gene based amplification, sequencing, followed by broad-range clone library analyses of vaginal flora is used. (Dara compared with Nugent scores) © by author Quantitative PCR assay was used to detect the metronidazole- resistant, newly described anaerobic bacterium Atopodium ESCMIDvaginae Online Lecture Library *Fredricks DN., et al.: N. Eng. J. Med (2005) *Hyman RW., et al.: Proc. Natl.Acad. Sci. USA (2005) Six patients with BV were treated with metronidazole and the vaginal flora was analysed before and after treatment (one month) by PCR-based 16S rRNS gene sequencing
Before treatment After treatment
Failure according to © by author clinical symptoms ESCMID Online Lecture Library
Before After metronidazole treatment
Cure according to clinical symptoms © by author ESCMID Online Lecture Library
Treatment of BV
Main goal is to re-establish normal vaginal lactobacillus flora decrease the pH of the vagina Antibiotics Local or systemic metronidazole Cure rate 75-85% Local or systemic clindamycin Other methods © by author Lyophilized H2O2 producing Lactobacillus locally with or without antibiotics ESCMID To destroy extracellularOnline DNALecture (biofilm) Libraryby DNAse (Hymes et al 2013) Synthetic retrocyclin (defensins) inhibits biofilm formation of G. vaginalis (Hooven et al 2012)
Consequences of BV
Bacterial vaginosis may cause adverse pregnancy outcomes (McGregor JA. et al. 2000) pelvic infection (Sweet RL. 2000) biofilm formation on the surface of IUDs (Pál Z. et al. 2005) post surgical© infection by author (Guaschino S. 2002) acquisition of sexually transmitted microorganisms ESCMIDincluding Online HIV (Sewankombo Lecture N. 1997) Library
© by author ESCMID Online Lecture Library 40
© by author 183 ESCMID Online Lecture Library Biofilm formation on the surface of a 10 years in situ IUD.
2.5x108 CFU/ml Scenning electron microscopy A. viscosus A. naeslundii Bifidobacterium sp Fingoldia magna Anaerococcus prevotii © by author Prevotella disiens P. ESCMIDasacharolyticus Online Lecture Library B. urealyicus Mobiluncus sp. Questions still to be answered
BV flora is a stable or transient flora? Can BV flora considered STI? Transmission to the male partner? Can BV associated bacteria be involved in chronic prostatitis or male infertility? What about the parallel treatment of the partners? What is the ideal© antibiotic,by author which can lead to the re- establishment of the Lactobacillus flora? ESCMID ?L. chrispatus Online - good Lecture/ L. iners – bad? Library Is there any connection between BV flora and the parodontitis flora? Pelvic inflammatory disease
Distribution of the pathogens Often associated with BV Mostly clinical diagnosis In case of surgery anaerobe culturing is mandatory !!!© by author ESCMID Online Lecture Library
! Thank you for your attention!!
© by author ESCMID Online Lecture Library Case report 2.
• Ny. V. 5 and half year old girl, • recurrent problems, complants: • Itching, discharge Culture results E. coli Enterococcus faecalis B. fragilis B. caccae, B. merdae Clostridium sp. © by author Bifidobacterium sp. Eubacterium sp. SutterrellaESCMID sp. Online Lecture Library Porphyromonas sp.
Széklet flóra!!! Hyginic problems