Fit for Life

Home , Fit for Life, Quackwatch

Critical Evaluation of Harvey & Marilyn Diamond's Book, Flt For Life, by Dr. Victor Herbert Professor of Medicine Mt. Sinai and Bronx Veterans Administration Medical Centers, New York @ 1988 - Victor Herbert, MD, JD Preamble The snake-oil promoters of nutrition frauds claim Information Committee I chaired from 1982 to 1986). that "physicians only get about 3 hours of nutrition in FASEB consists of the American Physiological Society, medical school, so listen to us--we have had years of the American Society of Biological Chemists, the study of nutrition." Their study, of course, is of American Society for Pharmacology and Experimental pseudonutrition - basically, how to deceive the public Therapeutics, the American Association of Pathologists, with pseudoscientific double-talk. the American Institute of Nutrition [AIN], the Experimental psychologist Tom Creed of St. John's American Association of Immunologists, and the University (Collegeville, MN) writing about American Society for Cell Biology. "Pseudoscience on the college lecture circuit," in the Within the past decade, there has been a strong Summer 1987 issue of The Skeptical Inquirer stated: swing to include in the medical school curriculum more "The inability to benefit from feedback appears to be courses � nutrition, coincident with the formal the primary cause of pseudoscience. Pseudoscientists recognition of clinical nutrition as a subspecialty of retain their beliefs and ignore or distort contradictory medicine. This formal recognition occurred in 1980, evidence rather than modify or reject a flawed theory. when ASCN (of which this reviewer was 1980 Because of their strong biases, they seem to lack the President) by letter dated May 27, 1980, secured self-correcting mechanisms scientists must employ in official recognition by the AMA as a national scientific their work. Science can be viewed as a special medical society. In the same year, ASCN brought to situation in which scientists acknowledge their human fruition at our concurrent annual meeting jointly with frailties and, through experimental design, construct the American Federation for Clinical Research (AFCR), situations in which their biases will have as little the American Society for Clinical Investigation (ASCI), impact as possible. This process is even more critical and the Association of American Physicians (AAP), a in the social sciences, since the subject matter, namely formal joint subsection of the latter 3 organizations ourselves, is one on which we all have strong opinions (of which the author is also a member) on Clinical and biases." Nutrition, which Robert Herman and a core group of us Pseudonutritionists state the literal truth that had sought for years, and which took its place at physicians in a number of medical schools only get every subsequent annual meeting, alongside the joint about 3 hours labeled nutrition, in order to convey the AFCR/ASCI/AAP subsections on Cardiology, Clinical false message that physicians do not learn nutrition in Epidemiology and Health Care Research, Clinical medical school. Physicians dQ learn nutrition in medical Pharmacology, Dermatology, Endocrinology, school, and learn it intensively and extensively. What Gastroenterology, Hematology, Hypertension, they don't learn is dietetics, which is why physicians Immunology, Infectious Diseases, Metabolism, Oncology, should work with registered dietitians as an integral Pulmonary, and Renal and Electrolyte. part of the patient care team. Nutrition is an integral Perhaps the single most effective force for more part of almost every course taught in medical schools. courses labeled "nutrition" in medical schools has been This reviewer's entire career in nutrition patient care, Maurice Shils, an outstanding leader in clinical teaching, and research was solidly grounded on the nutrition, now Professor Emeritus (and still active) at nutrition learned as a medical student at Columbia Cornell Medical College and Sloan-Kettering Institute University College of Physicians and Surgeons, which, at in New York City. His views were reflected almost the time I earned my MD degree there, had no � verbatim in the recent National Academy of Sciences labeled nutrition, but extensively taught bisi.c nutrition repo� on nutrition teaching in medical schools. as an integral part of courses labeled biochemistry, physiology, embryology, microbiology, pharmacology, and [Pertinent to this review is Webster's Ninth New pathology, and extensively taught � nutrition as Collegiate Dictionary (1987) definition of "liar": an integral part of courses labeled medicine, surgery, iar. One who tells lies. pediatrics, obstetrics/gynecology, neurology, and ie(verb): 1. To make an untrue statement with intent psychiatry. From this solid grounding, I proceeded to to deceive. win both the 1972 McCollum and the 1986 Herman 2. To create a false or misleading impression. Awards of the American Society for Clinical Nutrition ie (noun): 1. A:. an assertion of something known or (ASCN), the highest awards for clinical nutrition believed by the speaker to be untrue with intent to research given in the US. ASCN is the clinical deceive. B: an untrue or inaccurate statement that nutrition arm of the Federation of American Societies may or may not be believed true by the speaker. for Experimental Biology (FASEB) (whose Public 2. Something that misleads or deceives.] 2

REVIEW adverse facts which destroy their claims). With this book and their media tour promoting it, Living Health, like Fit for Life before it, is an the Diamonds keep up their relentless sustained salvo of example of the big lie - lie up front, lie big, and lie pseudoscientific deception, misrepresentation, and often. Publishers know that titles sell books: character assassination. Such character assassination, sensational titles sell sensationally. The biggest lies in imputing evil and mercenary motives to responsible both books are their titles. Fit for Life is unfit for health professionals, is a necessary part of the act of life. Living Health teaches you how to destroy your snake oil promoters, for only by making good seem evil health. The Living Health book jacket deceives that can they make bad seem good. "the Fij for Life series puts you in control of your The quackery mafia-type litany of character health." It puts you in control of destroying your assassinations of responsible dietitians and physicians in health. Double-talk characterizes both the book and this book and in the Diamonds' media appearances the promotional tour for it. Both seemingly ignorant reflects the similar behavior of the organized quackery (despite the "pop psychology" in their books) of mafia in the US and reminds one of the attempted psychosomatic medicine (knowledge of which explains assassinations of Elliot Ness and other lawmen by Al their recurrent symptoms), Marilyn, a divorced mother Capone, Frank Nitti, and the Chicago Mafia. The book of two, met Harvey in a health food store; they shared is right out of Orwell's .1SM - evil is good, good is their neurotic histories of similar psychosomatic evil; black is white, white is black. problems (periodic stomach pains and low energy) and Few recognize the breadth and coordination of the a partnership was born. The result is a cunning delivery of misinformation by the quackery mafia in the exploitation of the vulnerable and the unsophisticated. US. A succinct but complete expose of the quackery As this reviewer stated at the beginning of the mafia was this reviewer's testimony, pages 88-105 and King Show, "It's a quack book, full of deceptions, 131-133, at the Hearing, "Quackery: A $10-Billion misinformation, and fabrications, with a lot of advice Scandal." Subcommittee on Health and Long Term Care harmful to your health if you follow it. Children can (Chair: Congressman Claude Pepper, D-FL) of the Select be killed by the advice in this book," and, about the Committee on Aging, US House of Representatives, 98th Diamonds, "They are charismatic. They are charming. Congress, 2nd Session, May 31, 1984. Committee They are smiling. They are liars." Masters of pseudo Publication #98-463 (509 Cong. Rec.). A free copy of scientific double-talk and double-speak, and ruthless this 250-page book is available from House Documents exploiters of the gullible, the Diamonds are phony Room, US Capitol, Washington, DC 20515 (send self health scientists, complete with sham credentials from addressed label). Also available by telephoning Pepper a sham college, run by a high school drop-out cult Subcommittee in Washington, DC, at 202/226-3375). leader named T.C. Fry, whom the State of Texas In Living Health, the Diamonds display the same forbade in 1986 to continue calling his diploma mill a hatred toward health professionals that Al Capone had college. In 1983, the US Senate Committee on aging for lawmen. In her cover story interview of the described such operations as "schools for scoundrels, Diamonds in USA Today (June 1, 1987), Karen S. run by con artists to teach other con artists how to Peterson states: "The Diamonds ... are visceral in their make a sting." hatred for the medical community. Harvey contends The problem with the Diamonds is not only what treatment for his father's cancer helped kill him. 'That's they don't know, but what they claim to know for sure what started me on this thing."' Their character that is dead wrong. They display an appalling assassination of responsible health professionals, ignorance of epistemology, the science of "how do we particularly dietitians (R.D.s) and physicians (M.D.s), know the things that we know," and they prey on the consists largely of blatant lies claiming a non-existent · wlnerable and the millions unsophisticated in the economic interest in the processed food industry epistemology of health science. For two people who overrides interest in patient welfare. For example, in claim a combined 29 years of self-study of health an interview in a magazine which promotes nutrition science, they display the grossest ignorance of scams (East/West. February, 1987 issue), the Diamonds physiology and biochemistry, which sciences are lied when they stated that this reviewer "is on the fundamental to understanding and giving intelligent board of the sugar industry." I have never had any advice about nutrient intake, both of which every such relationship, and have never received a penny of medical student learns in his/her first year of medical salary or honorarium from the sugar industry. school, and every dietitian must learn before getting In the opening segment of the "Larry King Live" his/her RD credential. show, the Diamonds summarized the reason for the The loony cult diploma mill that sold the Diamonds popularity of their books as "the power of truth," but their nutrition credentials publishes Healthful Living. this reviewer summarized it as "the lure of lies." The In the October/November/December, 1985, issue of that frauds are both of �mission and of Q!J'lission (omitting publication (for my copy of which I thank quackbuster 3

Kurt Butler of Hawaii), T.C. Fry (indicated by the attorneys would not allow us to say anything Diamonds to be their guru) writes that viruses do not foolhardy") attempted to forestall redress to consumers exist, and that AIDS, polio, and cancer are inventions by inserting a "see your doctor" disclaimer on the back of a government-drug industry conspiracy designed to of the title page. I do not believe this will protect foist dangerous and expensive drugs and vaccines on the the Diamonds or their pµblisher, because the Diamonds, public. funded by their publisher .. to appear, gave the same As background to this second book of fabrications advice on the Larry King national TV show, with no about health, one should read "Fit for Life: Some Notes such blanket disclaimer. Furthermore, they assassinate on the Book and Its Roots" by James J. Kenney, PhD, the character of your doctor in the book, undermining RD, in Nutrition Forum 3(8):57-59, 1986, in relation to the disclaimer "See your doctor" by indicating your the first book by the Diamonds. doctor is untrustworthy and should be avoided. The The authors are masters of double-talk, ignoring the disclaimer creates neither an informed consent nor an dictionary meaning of words, and give words their own assumption of risk by the reader, since there is fraud private meanings. They write of "health science" as if in the inducement (i.e., deception for profit) in the it were distinguished from, and opposed to, medical title, the Warner press release (further discussed science. (Harvey on the King show: "Health science is below), and the text, and fraud in the inducement a totally different field from medical science"). In fact, voids both consent and assumption of risk. The two medical science is a health science. The Diamonds' elements of fraud are deceit and profit. Criminal fraud private meaning of "health science" is pseudoscience, a adds the element of scienter (i.e., knowledge). The denial of science. Judging by their output, their Diamonds and their publisher cannot claim lack of "combined 29 years of self study of health science" was knowledge of potential harms from following their 29 years of "garbage in," resulting in two books of advice after the Larry King show - all the plaintiff "garbage out." It reminds one of the computer need do is play the King show videotape iur the jury mnemonic "GIGO" (Garbage In, Garbage Out) - feed a and point out that the Diamonds' appearance with no computer garbage and all it can spit out is garbage. disclaimer was funded by Warner Books as advertising Feed your brain only pseudoscientific garbage like the for the books. Plaintiff's lawyers can also point out Diamond books and the Fry teachings they "studied," that even if you bring the book to a "health and all it can spit out is garbage. professional," the book maliciously and repeatedly Among the more notorious snake oil peddlers the defames M.D.s and R.D.s, thereby suggesting your Diamonds indicate they have read, and fraudulently "health practitioner" should be a phony like the represent in their book to be reliable sources of Diamonds with no responsible credentials in separating information on the health sciences, are T.C. Fry, fact from fiction. Herbert Shelton, Dean Burk and Maureen Kennedy On the King show, Harvey stated, "Here we have Salaman (look in the book's index to easily locate these information that I have studied for 17 years and the people). Salaman, a leader in the quackery mafia (see V medical profession lashes out at it." When physician Herbert testimony on the quackery mafia and on the Jack Yetiv on the same show pointed out they should Salamans before Congressman Claude Pepper's May 31, have done a study comparing their unbalanced weight 1984 Quackery Hearing), is President of the quackery loss diet for safety with an equally low calorie promoting National Health Federation (NHF), which the balanced diet, Marilyn responded (giggling), "We've book promotes (page 309) as a reliable source of already sold the book." nutrition information. Those in the media who give the Diamonds an Warner Books and their public relations people (see audience, by providing that audience, promote the the Warner Books "News from the Trade Division" press Diamond books and aid and abet a scam dangerous to release on Living Health) appear to be co-conspirators the public health, even if they put on responsible in this fraud on the public, and those whose children health professionals (like Dr. Yetiv) to oppose them. are harmed by having the Diamonds' advice imposed on Old PT Barnum had it right when he said, "There is no them should sue them all for redress, and include a such thing as bad publicity" (i.e., mention the book on RICO conspiracy claim (see Herbert testimony before the air and you sell the book), and followed that Pepper Committee, May 31, 1984). This is what parents aphorism with, "There's a sucker born every minute." successfully did when their children were permanently The book is falsely represented as providing new damaged or killed by the advice in an Adelle Davis book information. In fact, it combines generally recognized (for details see: Herbert and Barrett: Vttamins and truisms with false, deceptive and misleading information "Health" Foods: The Great American Hustle. Stickley, and blatant fabrications - there are no new health Philadelphia, 1985 paperback, $8.95). facts in this book. It follows in the footsteps of a The publisher's lawyers, possible co-defendants in a long line of writings by other scam artists for whom, RICO attack (Harvey on the King show: "Warner Books' like the Diamonds, defamation of responsible health 4

professionals is an essential ingredient in the "formula What Kleckley was describing in his book was the of fakers" to lend credibility to themselves. classic psychopath, also known as the "pathologic liar" Seeing the disingenuous and ingratiating Diamonds (renamed "personality disorder" in the newest American on the King show brought to mind the description of Psychiatric Association classification). Recent work in cult believers and cult gurus on page · 44 of Nutrition the U.S. and Canada indicates that 2 to 3% of people Cultism: Facts and Fictions (V. Herbert, George F. are psychopaths, and they gravitate into careers and Stickley Company, Philadelphia, 1981), to wit: "Nutrition appear as fringe health professionals, shyster lawyers, quackery feeds on specious slogans and beliefs which and shady business people. In an article entitled appeal to needs for control of one's own destiny and of "Brain defect tied to utter amorality of the the environment, such as the sophistic concept that psychopath," (New York Times, July 7, 1987, p.C1), natural is good and synthetic is bad. This need for Daniel Goleman reviews "the slippery ease with which control is accompanied by lack of respect for psychopaths lie, twist language, and manipulate and knowledge, repudiation of knowledge, and perception of destroy people in the pursuit of their own ends." established experts as hated paternal authority figures, Psychologist Robert Hare indicates that the psychopath whereas promoters of quackery are seen as courageous, "can use words any way he wants. If you catch him independent persons with the foresight to penetrate the lying, he'll jsut shift gears and go on as if nothing fakery of the establishment. Those most vulnerable to had happened" (Herbert, V: Scientific Fraud. Chem. nutrition quackery are unable to perceive the difference Eng. News, 65(47):3, 1987). between a genuine authority and expert, i.e., someone On the King show, the Diamonds defended their who has earned, by disciplined controlled study, "education by self-learning" by invoking self-learners scientific training, and experience, the right to make a Mark Twain, George Bernard Shaw, and Thomas Edison. judgment, and persons who do not follow the basic If I had been Larry King, at that point I would have scientific canons for evaluating medical information, and said, "Interesting, but irrelevant. Although Twain and thus are not authorities and have not earned the right Shaw also wrote fiction, they didn't try to pass it off to be classified as experts. Many lay persons are blind as fact, like you do. Additionally, their fictions are to the difference between creative originality and more realistic than your 'facts.' Also, unlike Edison's, intemperate rebelliousness and unable to recognize the your 'inventions' are not useful, but harmful." many characteristics which, taken together, define nutrition quackery." Among the deceptions, misinformation, and fabrications "Psychiatrist A.J. Mandell considers Hervey in the book are: Kleckley's book, The Mask of Sanity. a classical Page xvi: "This book will show you how to take psychiatric explanation of certain cult gurus. He notes care of your health. With the same confidence, you they are 'apparently sane, often dynamic ... almost always can assure yourself a pain-free, disease-free existence." seductive.. .impress others with their sincere motives and Fact: The Diamonds lie in small letters. positive intentions and wind up causing great Following the advice in this book can be harmful to institutional and personal harm. With an unexplainable your health. capacity to engender trust, even an experienced and Page 5: "FIT FOR LIFE WAS A HEAVY DOSE OF cynical observers, these people create chaos ...the single NEW INFORMATION." most powerful diagnostic test was his own willingness to Fact: THE DIAMONDS LIE IN CAPITAL LETTERS. cash their checks... charm, a quick sensitivity to the Fit for Life was a heavy dose of misinformation, some unspoken needs of others, and a certain flexibility with of it harmful to health (see Kenney article in Nutrition the facts, are woven into a personal charisma that Forum). entrances.' They are confidence men par excellence. Page 6: "A GREAT DEAL OF WHAT IS PRESENTED Kleckley speaks of the psychopath's immunity from IN THIS BOOK IS NEW LY UNCOVERED anxiety, extraordinary poise, sense of well-being, and INFORMATION. II remorselessness. The people around usually think, 'He's Fact: There is no newly uncovered information found it."' The Diamonds, displaying themselves on (i.e., facts) in this book; what is passed off as new is the King Show to be as cool, cunning, and evasive (a misinformation, disinformation, and fabrication (both caller pointed out they evaded every question by Dr. falsehoods and lies). Yetiv) a pair as ever came down the pike, appears to fit Page 39: "Fruit contains all of the necessary the Nutrition Cultism description to a "T." On the King nutrients required by your body for sustaining life." show, they demonstrated themselves perfectly willing to Fact: Vitamin 8-12 is a necessary nutrient required distort the truth whenever it suited their fancy and by the body for sustaining health and life; there is no whenever it served their economic interest in selling vitamin B-12 in fruit (Herbert V: Recommended their book. Only a publisher blinded by dollar signs dietary intakes (RDI) of vitamin 8-12 in humans. Amer could fail to see this, or, seeing it, ignore it. J Clin Nutr 45:671-8, 1987 [April]). There are other 5

nutrients also missing from fruit, or present below plague so many people." Page 34: "PROTEINS AND adequate quantities. A diet of just fruit will shorten ST ARCHES CANNOT DIGEST EFFICIENTLY IN THE your life. STOMACH AT THE SAME TIME." Page 41: EAT Page 49: "ALL HEALTH PROBLEMS ARISE FROM EXCLUSIVELY FRESH FRUIT AND FRESH FRUIT THE ABUSE OF NATURAL LAWS." Fact: Fat a I JUICE FROM THE TIME YOU AWAKEN IN THE salmonella infections from drinking raw milk (which is MORNING UNTIL 12:00 NOON. Exclusively! Anything promoted by the Diamonds on page 236) do not arise else will stay in your stomach and hamper the from "the abuse of natural laws," to name just one of elimination cycle." Page 35: "Undigested protein thousands of illnesses which do not "arise from the putrefies and undigested starch ferments" when you eat abuse of natural laws." a protein with a starch. The food "spoils" in the Page 50: "You don't just get sick. You have to stomach. Anyone who makes the statement that food work hard at it." can't rot in the stomach is guilty of the most abysmal, Fact: This pernicious lie implies that if you get a unforgivable ignorance of physiology." bacterial infection (like a strep throat, diphtheria, Fact: Diamonds, meet the "ignorant" William tuberculosis, etc.), it's your fault and you "worked hard Beaumont, father of American physiology. There is no to get it." This is the "blame the victim" strategy of basis in reality for these grossly ignorant statements. many health quacks. The Diamonds display total ignorance of human Page 62: If a newborn infant is given a whack on digestive physiology, a health-related science the behind, "this is a contributing factor to asthma and fundamental to understanding human nutrition, which other respiratory impairments later on in life ... the all medical students and registered dietitians (R.D.) are ignorant whack of the physician breaks blood vessels in taught. The Diamonds either don't read or don't the spine, and that contributes to sudden infant death comprehend any of the extensive studies of the syndrome in too many cases." physiology of human digestion, starting with the Fact: This is a combination of fabrication and studies by US Army doctor William Beaumont on soldier character assassination of responsible health Alexis St. Martin. In 1833, William Beaumont published professionals. his classic studies on his patient, St. Martin, who had Page 63: Claim: The post-birth whack on the a gunshot wound opening to his stomach. Beaumont behind "affects our breathing for the rest of our lives." had put a variety of foods on strings in St. Martin's Fact: This is a lie. stomach and later pulled them out by their strings and Page 67: "ALTERNATIVE NOSTRIL showed that all were digested equally well regardless BREATHING ...Alternative nostril breathing ...breathing in of the ratio of starch to protein. There was no one nostril and out the other, then in the second selective "spoiling in the stomach" of combined proteins nostril and out the first...can be used as a highly and starches. effective tool to balance your nervous system ...Each Beaumont was the father of American physiology. nostril connects to the opposite side of the brain and His name graces the Bethesda, Maryland, headquarters using this information in a breathing exercise, you can of the Federation of American Societies for actually balance the two sides of the brain, and the Experimental Biology (FASEB). FASEB is the largest result is an amazing sense of equilibrium." non-governmental association of basic scientists in Fact: This is a pure fabrication, revealing gross health-related subjects in the world. (This reviewer ignorance of human anatomy (a first year medical school was, for 5 years (1981-1986) Chair of the Public subject). The air breathed through either nostril goes Information Committee of FASEB). to the back of our throat and then direct to the lungs. In 1902, Pavlov published in London his classic Ajr breathed through either nostril goes to the brain book The Work of the Digestive Glands showing that only through our lungs. That breathed through the the seeing or chewing of any appetizing foods resulted right nostril carries no label saying to the lungs, "Take in generalized salivary enzyme secretion and gastric me only to the left side of the brain." Either the secretion of acid and enzymes, and that any food in Diamonds' "years of self study of health science" the stomach stimulates more gastric secretion. The included no anatomy, or they are incompetent to same year, Bayliss and Starling published their classic understand pictures in anatomy texts. The reader need study showing that gastric juice hitting the upper not study anatomy to know the Diamonds are wrong intestine caused release of "secretagogues" which about breathing - all you have to do is notice that traveled through the blood stream to the pancreas when you inhale, it is your chest that swells, and not causing the pancreas to release its many digestive your brain. enzymes. That the various pancreatic enzymes for Page 88: "Drinking liquid, any liquid, with or digestion of carbohydrates and proteins are synthesized after the meal...severely slows the digestive process, and secreted simultaneously regardless of the type of giving rise to many of the digestive complaints that food eaten was published by Baxter in an article 6

entitled "The Parallel Concentration of Enzymes in the The Diamonds' knowledge of human digestive Pancreatic Juice" in the American Journal of Digestive physiology is back in the pre-Beaumont age. Diseases and Nutrition 2:10 8, 1935. By 1935, it was Physiology is a course taught in first-year medical established that carbohydrate digestion is started by a school, and all dietitians are required to learn digestive carbohydrate digesting enzyme in the saliva, protein physiology before they can be registered (i.e., become digestion is started by protein digesting enzymes in the an R.D.), but apparently digestive physiology was not stomach, with both the saliva enzymes and the stomach taught (or not learned) in the diploma mill which gave enzymes aided in their work by gastric acid, and major Mr. Diamond his "Ph.D." Incidentally, New York State digestion continued in the small intestine. All of this Education Law forbids Mr. Diamond calling himself was laid out, for anyone who knew how to read, in the "doctor" or "Ph.D." in this state. In New York, it is a 1938 edition of Mountcastle's Medical Physiology, crime (a consumer fraud) to call yourself "doctor" or published by the CV Mosby Company of St. Louis, and "Ph.D." if your degree is from an unaccredited every digestive physiology text since. Either the institution (see pp. 1937-8 and references 57-59 of: Diamonds don't understand what they read, or they Herbert V: Unproven [questionable] dietary and don't read any competent physiology texts, or they read nutritional methods in cancer prevention and treatment. them and lie about the significance of what they read. Cancer 58:1930-41, 1986). I believe it was after I Since they claim Pavlov supports their ridiculous pointed this out as a consumer crime, which New York physiology claims, they are either lying about having State had just started prosecuting, on the Regis Philbin read Pavlov, or lying about what Pavlov wrote, just as TV "Morning Show" the day before the Diamonds were they lied on the King show about what articles in the his guests in 1986 that the Diamonds and their American Journal of Clinical Nutrition proved. publisher stopped calling him "doctor." (In a letter All of the above information on the studies of dated July 29, 1987, Harvey Diamond represents I was Beaumont, Pavlov, Bayliss and Starling, and Baxter was scheduled to appear with him--1 do not knowingly provided by me to Marian Burros of the New York appear with phonies). Times, to whom I sent it, for her New York Times Today we can study food digestion in anyone by review of the first Diamond book. The Diamonds slipping a fiberoptic gastroscope through the mouth responded as the liars they are by indicating the studies into the stomach (and beyond). As did Beaumont, we did not exist, stating I was on the board of the sugar see no evidence of the protein-carbohydrate industry (a lie) and Marian Burros was jealous because incompatibility the Diamonds claim exists. The their book sold better than hers (see interview with the Diamonds write as if they have not caught up with the Diamonds in East/West Magazine, February, 1987). physiology studies of 150 years ago, 1 00 years ago, or Additionally, over the past half-century, there has 50 years ago, much less those of today. been published in the responsible (peer-reviewed) There is no evidence that liquid gyg__ liquid slows scientific literature a large body of work showing other the digestive process or produces digestive complaints. w,ays in which the presence of carbohydrate aids in the Of course, excesses of anything are harmful, but the assimilation (digestion and absorption) of protein, and Diamonds seem oblivious to that concept as well, as the presence of protein aids in the assimilation of witness their promotion of excessive quantities of raw carbohydrate. fruit (violating all three of the basic rules of sound As anyone can read in the US Department of nutrition: moderation, variety, and balance). Agriculture (USDA) tables of food content, it is almost Page 91: "Since it is pure water that your body impossible to find a vegetarian food without protein in needs, there is only one type of water suitable for it, so the only way one could eat only carbohydrates your body - distilled." and no protein before lunch is to extract from each Fact: Pure fabrication. If this were so, how did fruit and vegetable the protein in it before putting it in Adam and Eve, and millions of their descendants, one's mouth. The Diamonds' book does not discuss the survive without a still? The body needs water; the necessity of having a protein-extraction laboratory in "pure water" claim is pseudoscientific babble that sells your kitchen in order to follow their advice. expensive distilled water nobody needs, and sells stills Is it possible that the Diamonds never heard of a nobody needs. Pavlovian reflex? That was Pavlov's classic work Page 92: "THE BODY CAN USE ONLY ORGANIC showing that if you could make a dog (or a human) MINERALS ...Minerals are only usable as they are found think they were getting � appetizing food (regardless in organic forms of 6fe... the human cannot use of carbohydrate/protein ratio), you stimulated secretion inorganic minerals." of saliva. One of Pavlov's students then showed that Fact: This is a fabrication based on gross this "Pavlov reflex" also caused the autonomic nervous ignorance of human digestive physiology of minerals. system to trigger all our digestive secretions in mouth, · �'. :Thousands: of studies in the peer-reviewed scientific stomach, and pancreas. :,i · literature demonstrate the absorption of inorganic · L 7

minerals (and not just those minerals found in organic Page 102: "THE GREATEST THREAT TO YOUR forms of life). If the Diamonds would like to learn a HEALTH IS PROCESSED FOODS." little nutrition �e (as opposed to scam, which is Fact: This is a lie. People don't get ill or die their strength), they might start with: Herbert V: from responsibly processed foods. Many get ill and die Recommended dietary intakes (RDI) of iron in humans. from bacteria and viruses in raw foods. (Distilled Amer J Clin Nutr 45:679-686, 1987 [April]. There they water is a processed food� the Diamonds promote it on will learn that the mineral iron is found in plants page 91. Can't they remember on page 102 what they primarily in nonorganic forms and, in animal protein, said on page 91?) (which the Diamonds tell us not to eat) in organic Pages 122 through 212: Consists largely of filler forms, and that the iron in meat (which they tell us not "pop" material on rest, sleep, exercise, sunshine, loving to eat) is absorbed much better than that in the fruits relationships, cleanliness, pleasant surroundings, and and vegetables they tell us to eat, and that the quiet moments. absorption of vegetable iron is improved by eating it Page 216: "ANIMAL PRODUCTS WILL MAKE YOU with meat. This is another case of animal protein SICK." and Page 229: "Actually, the list of ailments improving the absorption of a nutrient in plant that can be linked to dairy products is so extensive, products, a fact the Diamonds deny occurs. there is hardly a problem it doesn't at least contribute Page 100: "From 1981 to 1986 ...a whopping one to." quarter of a million people died from fluoride poisoning" Fact: Dairy and other animal products are among from fluoridated water. On page 99, they imply these the pillars of sound nutrition. See "Nutrition and Your deaths are from cancer. Health: Dietary Guidelines for Americans," second Fact: This is a blatant lie, compounded by omission edition, 1985, Publication HG 232 ($1.50), USDA and of contrary facts such as the extensive information USDHHS, and "Dietary Guidelines and Your Diet," a published in Consumer Reports that fluoridated water is packet of 7 information bulletins on nutrition and your sate. Consumers Union, publisher of Consumer Reports health from the USDA, Washington, DC 20250 is a responsible consumer protection organization. The (Publications HG-232-1 through HG-232- 7, $4.50, April Diamonds promote cavities in your teeth and inadequate 1986). fluoride in your bone structure as part of the Page 218: "Ever hear of high blood cholesterol, antifluoridation campaign of fear, largely by a arthritis, or osteoporosis?... The only reason they exist miscellaneous assortment of crackpots and entrepreneurs is because of the consumption of animal products." and who make money selling unneeded expensive stills and Marilyn Diamond, on the King show: "There are lots of distilled water. (Note the promotion of distilled water journals proving that milk causes all these diseases." on page 91 as the "only type of water suitable for your Fact: These are blatant lies. All three of these body.") would exist if there were no animal products, and The pseudostatistics of Burk and Yiamouyannis many people with genetically determined (see article by (quoted by the Diamonds on page 99) were long since Ahrens and the Rockefeller University group in the destroyed by the real statistics available to the May 1987 Journal of Clinical Investigation) high blood Diamonds or any other layman from the National cholesterol would still have it if they ate no animal Institute of Dental Health, Consumers Union, and the products. Genetics is another health-related science American Dental Association. On the King television (taught in all medical schools) of which the Diamonds show, Marilyn lied that "Dr. Dean Burk from the appear ignorant. An average of 85% of our blood National Cancer Institute gave testimony on that" (i.e., cholesterol is synthesized in our own livers. There is that fluoridated water causes cancer). In fact, when no relation of animal products to any form of arthritis Dean Burk "gave testimony on that," he was no longer (except gouty arthritis), and whole animal products "from the National Cancer Institute." He is a Ph.D. have no relation to osteoporosis. Purified amino acids, biochemist who retired at age 70 in 197 4 from his job such as those sold in health food stores, or gelatin, or as head of the small 4-person cytochemistry section of egg albumin eaten alone, may pull calcium out in the the Laboratory of Biochemistry of the National Cancer urine, but studies such as those of Herta Spencer (in Institute. Since then, as head of the Dean Burk American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. 1983) Foundation, he has had a lucrative career working with demonstrate this does not occur when one eats whole the quackery mafia promoting nutrition frauds, including foods. "vitamin B-15" ("pangamate") and "vitamin B-17" When Dr. Yetiv demanded on the King show that ("laetrile"), plus the claim that fluoridated water causes the Diamonds name just one study proving that dairy cancer (see: Herbert V: Nutrition Cultism: Facts and products cause osteoporosis, Harvey replied, "I don't Fictions. Stickley, Philadelphia, 1981; see chapter "The have to name one. Look in the back of our book. Assault on Fluoridation" in the 1980 Consumers Union There's a bibliography of over 400 citations." Harvey, book Health Quackery). as usual, was deceiving. Not one of the 423 references 8

present evidence proving that dairy products cause respiratory problems and other human disorders, a osteoporosis, and, among others, Professor Robert subject every medical student studies in great depth. Heaney of Creighton University (Diamond references 172 Instead of admitting ignorance, the Diamonds make up and 173) has published extensive evidence that dairy lies. They should read a textbook of pulmonary products are major protectors against osteoporosis. The disease to learn how grossly ignorant they are about Diamonds not only lie, they lie in spades. respiratory problems. Page 229: "While SIDS (sudden infant death Page 247: Claim: "Over 30,000 children under the syndrome) can't be blamed on any one cause, dairy age of 5 die of respiratory disease each year. Fifteen products are unquestionably partially to blame." thousand of these unfortunates die in the first month Fact: This is a blatant lie. of life. Over 5,000 die in the first week from Page 237: DAIRY PRODUCTS ARE A MAJOR respiratory disease syndrome (RDS) or what is called CAUSE OF OSTEOPOROSIS and Harvey on the King hyaline membrane disease... The massive amounts of show: "I took the information out of very specific dairy products that pregnant women are routinely journals that proves that osteoporosis is contributed to terrorized into consuming is the cause of this national by high protein foods such as milk." tragedy... Ever wonder why it's necessary to have a Fact: How does one deal with a lie so profound? suction tube at every birth to such the thick mucus Dairy products constitute 72% of the absorbable calcium from the infant's throat and nose immediately upon in the average American diet, and constitute the main delivery so it can breathe? Babies born of women who bulwark in female American children against future do not consume dairy products during pregnancy do not osteoporosis. Read the studies of Prof. Heaney of need this suction, because they breathing passages are Creighton University, or any other genuine expert. On clear." the Larry King show on June 10, 1987, the Diamonds Fact: This is part of the Diamond blatant lie that blatantly lied that studies published in the American dairy products produce mucus (page 226: "Cow's milk Journal of Clinical Nutrition and "many other scientific causes more mucus than any food you can eat.") - they journals" "proved" that dairy products cause don't. To look for the truth, look in the peer osteoporosis. There is no such study in .any_responsible reviewed scientific literature. If a woman follows this scientific journal. advice and does not consume dairy products during Marilyn on the King show: "The calcium we take in pregnancy and consumes only fruits and vegetables, from the plant kingdom is easily absorbed." thereby suffering inadequate nutrition and promoting Fact: The fiber and phytate in grains markedly osteoporosis, and then tells a midwife mucus need not reduces the absorbability of their calcium, as compared be sucked from the infant's throat and nose on to the much greater absorbability of calcium from milk. delivery, it is possible that infant may die as a result. Harvey, defending himself against Dr. Yetiv on the Here again we see the Diamonds' gross ignorance of King show: "We are not telling people not to eat dairy biochemistry. Airway mucus (mucins) are products." Compare this lie with the text: Page 59: carbohydrate-rich proteins which comprise the major "WHAT'S NOT GOOD IS NOT GOOD IN ANY AMOUNT." portion of the mucosa! layer lining the respiratory and Page 216: "ANIMAL PRODUCTS WILL MAKE YOU epithelium. They are synthesized equally well from SICK! Page 220: Animal products cause cancer." Page building blocks absorbed after digestion of plant 224: "THE CASE AGAINST DIARY PRODUCTS... The fact products as they are after digestion of animal products. is that the majority of people on earth react to cow's Were the Diamonds not so ignorant of human milk by getting sick. It's an insult to nature's grand physiology, they would know that airway mucins scheme to go to another species for milk." and Page provide the first line of defense of the lung from 225: "DAIRY PRODUCTS ARE DISEASE-PRODUCING. inhaled (through either nostril!) foreign matter, through They're harmful. They � suffering. They're the well-defined functions including mucociliary clearance perfect thing to eat if you want to be sick and have a and prevention of epithelial desiccation. Were they diseased body... To say that dairy products are a good not so ignorant of human pathology (another basic food for humans is evidence of unpardonable ignorance health-related science every medical student learns in of the facts. There is simply too much evidence proving his/her second year of medical school and which is dairy products to be a clear and present danger." and essential to understanding human disease), they would Page 231: "DEAD FOOD CAN NOT SUPPORT LIFE. know that there is increased synthesis and/or secretion Pasterization kills." and Page 236: "DAIRY PRODUCTS, of airway mucins during various pulmonary diseases IF EATEN AT ALL, SHOULD BE CONSUMED RAW such as asthma, chronic bronchitis, and cystic fibrosis, BUT CLEAN!" and Page 247: "Dairy products are and their secretion is unrelated to whether we eat implicated in all respiratory problems." plant products or animal products. For tru.ts (instead Fact: These statements are fabrications. The of Diamond fictions), on airway mucins, write: Chief, Diamonds display ignorance of the pathogenesis of Airways Diseases Branch, Division of Lung Diseases, 9

National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute (NHLBI), NIH, chronic distortion of the truth whenever it suits their Westwood Building, Room 6A 15, Bethesda, MD 20892, or fancy and serves their economic interest in selling read any modern text of pulmonary physiology and their books and other products and services. It is pathology. impossible for a reader of the Diamond book to know Page 260: In a typical example of deception by they are lying, since the reader does not have a misrepresentation, fabrication, character assassination, videotape or transcript pf the Donahue show to and omission of facts adverse to their claims, it is compare with the Diamond lies about what transpired. stated that "Dr. Victor Herbert must have thought he Donahue profits from promoting scam artists like was talking to a bunch of nitwits (on the Donahue the Diamonds - their sensational lies make for exciting Show)... He ...practically got hooted off the stage when he shows with bigger audiences, and bigger audiences tried to tell the audience - with a straight face, mind mean more dollars for every second of advertising time you - that some tests had been done that showed that sold. His staff deliberately seed the audience with sugar actually calms kids down ... Then Dr. Herbert supporters of cult nutrition. In the show on which I attempted to defend his asinine position, explaining appeared, his staff had culled from letters written in himself in terms that no one in the audience could over the past year those people who had written that understand. Fortunately, Donahue saved him and went they believed that sugar and additives cause on to another subject. I must admit that watching him hyperactivity and planted them in the audience, plus squirm while trying to defend himself against this more pl anting a naturopath cultist to whom Donahue gave enlightened audience was enormously encouraging." the microphone as if it was a spontaneous gesture. Fact: What actually transpired (Donahue transcript The man then spewed out a grocery list of lies about #09013, pages 8 and 9) was: nutrition, presenting them as facts, while Donahue Dr. Victor Herbert: "There were good studies at stood there smiling. After the show, the cultist the NIH by Judy Rapoport... walked back to the "Green Room" with me and the Plant in audience (interrupting): "Ask the teachers!" other invited guests. When I asked him where he Dr. Victor Herbert: " ...and those kids were studied thought he was going, he told me he was an invited by Judy Rapoport at the National Institute of Mental guest also and pointed out the Donahue staff member Health and she showed that sugar actually calmed the who invited him and to whom he was "personal kids down." nutritionist." He even gave me his business card, Plant in audience (interrupting): "I'm a teacher." "nutrition consultant to doctors," which I kept as a Dr. Victor Herbert: " ... also Richard Wurtman and souvenir of how the Donahue staff fixes the shows. others at MIT... " When you sit at home and view the Donahue show "live Dr. Victor Herbert: "They have found it raises the from Chicago," you believe the studio audience walked level of brain serotonin. If you eat carbohydrate, you in off the street and are impartial judges - not so. can raise the level of brain serotonin, which calms kids The live audience is hand-picked by the Donahue staff down." from the thousands who wrote in over the past year or Donahue: "You took the words right out of my so, and they are selected for the cult beliefs they mouth." state in their letters to be invited to the specific show Audience (laughter). DonahueI wants them on. The show is taped and what (Note the Diamond deception by om1ss1on which is seen in Chicago and elsewhere as "live from characterizes quacks. The Diamonds left out the names Chicago" was, in fact, "taped" weeks before. The and institutions Herbert gave of those who conducted Donahue show I was on, for example, was taped in the relevant sugar studies maliciously conveying there Chicago on August 18, 1983, and shown "live from were no such studies ["he tried to tell the audience, Chicago" in Chicago on September 1, New York and with a straight face, that some tests had been done"], Los Angeles on September 5, Boston on September 15, so readers will believe the Diamond lies conveying that Omaha on September 22, and in New Orleans on Herbert is a mercenary 6ar [Diamond lie: Herbert is "on September 29. In contrast, when the much more the board of the sugar industry").) honest Oprah Winfrey show says "live from Chicago," Thus, in fact, Dr. Herbert responsibly addressed the my experience is that they mean !ML- not videotape. audience as intelligent people, and was comfortable and As quackbuster Kurt Butler of Haleiwa, Hawaii relaxed with the audience, contrary to the Diamond lies 96712, wrote, under the heading "The Diamonds are that he was "squirming" and "trying to defend himseH." Quacks:" "Harvey and Marilyn Diamond ...are absolute It is the Diamonds who address audiences as if they are quacks who have been made millionaires by "a bunch of nitwits," feeding them misinformation, lies, irresponsible talk-show hosts and the gullible public... lt and character assassination of responsible health is a national disgrace that the media have helped these professionals. Their misrepresentation of what snake-oil salesmen rip off the public with their transpired on the Donahue show is typical of their dangerous hoax. Talk-show stars like Phil Donahue 10

and Michael Jackson have hosted the Diamonds provide data on their guantity when we are repeatedly without asking them tough, skeptical "autointoxicated," as compared to when we are not is questions, putting them on the spot about their phony because the "autointoxicants" they speak of do not credentials, or raking them over the coals for their exist. What do exist are the causative bacteria and preposterous and dangerous diet advice. Instead viruses which Fry and his College of Life Science Donahue et al. have given them a million-dollar forum teach do not exist. Where toxins exist, real health to freely propagandize. On one show, Donahue defended scientists (not phonies like the Diamonds) name them their 'education' as being just as good as that of any and guantitate their presence in the human body, such nutrition graduate from an accredited college... as the toxicants in tobacco smoke, which the Diamonds Donahue's activities promoting health frauds from A copy on pages 71 and 72 from the real toxicology to laetrile through megavitamins to zinc may make him literature. and his network appropriate co-defendants in an action Their advice on page 283, that, if you get a sore by anyone harmed by following the advice of the snake throat or diarrhea, the treatment is rest and sleep, can oil promoters on his show, as we pointed out by analogy lead to rheumatic fever and rheumatic heart disease to the California case of Weirum vs. RKO General, Inc., from a strep throat, death from salmonella diarrhea, discussed on pages 156-7 of Vitamins and 'Health' and a host of other harms from untreated curable Foods: The Great American Hustle. infectious diseases and from toxins released by a Page 242: "STUDIES SHOW THAT THE MORE variety of harmful bacteria, such as potentially lethal PROTEIN YOU CONSUME, THE MORE CALCIUM YOU Clostridia toxins (which killed some babies fed raw LOSE!" honey contaminated with it in California), as well as Fact: What studies show is that you lose calcium if harms from ignored viral infections. They promote you eat purified protein separated from foods, such as disease and death in the guise of promoting health. health food store purified protein powders, or gelatin, Their guru, T.C. Fry, teaches that viruses do not exist; or egg albumin. Protein in whole food does not produce the word "virus" does not appear in their extensive this problem (see the studies of Dr. Herta Spencer at index, and on page 19, they revere T.C. Fry as "a man Hines VA Medical Center in Illinois, cited above). This interested in truth, not accolades. He simply does his subtle distinction between the effects of purified work and lets his results speak for themselves." proteins and of protein in whole foods has escaped a Raw fruits worsen diarrhea; continuous diarrhea in number of legitimate nutrition professionals, so it is far infants and small children can be lethal in 24 to 72 beyond the grasp of nutrition phonies like the hours (diarrhea due to cholera toxins can be lethal in Diamonds. 24 hours if untreated and only "rest and sleep" Book: All of chapter 17 (pp. 283 et seq.) is devoted prescribed). Clear liquids, including appropriate to the myth that illness is due to "auto-intoxification, electrolyte solutions, are mandatory and life-saving. or sett-poisoning, brought on by enervation." For non-cholera diarrhea, and for nausea and vomiting, Fact: For people who claim a "combined 29 years clear liquids, particularly colas (flat or fizzy) and of self study of health science," the Diamonds display soups are usually good to start with. abysmal ignorance of toxicology (a branch of pathology) Page 291: "Chiropractic adjustments realign the and of bacteriology. All medical students study both spine and normalize the flow of energy." these health-related sciences. "Auto-intoxication" and Fact: This is a blatant lie, and you could be the "detoxification crisis," as they describe them, are seriously harmed by believing it. Chiropractors do not figments of the imagination of scam artists. The produce x-rays showing "before" pictures of misaligned College of Life Sciences, the credential mill from which spines and "after" pictures showing the spine the Diamonds purchased their nutrition credentials, "realigned" after chiropractic adjustment. Their teaches that every ill is a waste matter "elimination patients are not sophisticated enough to demand to see crisis," and contagious diseases do not exist (see such pictures, which would reveal the fraud (i.e., the Healthful Living. published "monthly" by the Diamonds' "before" and "after" x-rays are the same); it takes guru, Fry, and his College of Life Science, more pressure than even a 500-pound chiropractor can October/November/December 1985 issue, page 3: exert to alter the relation of one normal spine bone to "Contagion is a myth;" page 14: "Up to a point, another. Patients with damage to the bones, making elimination crises called the measles, mumps, a cold, the the spine "adjustable," have been permanently paralyzed flu, pneumonia, etc., are a blessing inasmuch as they from the neck down by chiropractors doing neck forestall the development of chronic ailments." (They "adjustments." These devastated quadraplegics are sure do, if you die from lack of appropriateI medical reported both in court cases and in the scientific care.) literature - the Diamonds omit them from their book. The reason the Diamonds don't name the toxins See the chapter "Chiropractors: Healers or Quacks?" in with which we allegedly become "autointoxicated" or the 1980 Consumers Union book Health Quackery. 11

On June 14, 1987, "Doctor Dan," D.C. (recent proper treatment. graduate of Atlanta [Georgia] Chiropractic College) was Page 309: To "keep you up to date with what is handing out at a New York City street fair (The Turtle really happening in the world of health," the Diamonds Bay Festival) "get your spine adjusted" cards (sold by recommend "Health Freedom News... put out by the the thousands to chiropractors by Si-Nel Publishing National Health Federation." Company in Atlanta (Telephone 404/422-8836). A typical Fact: This is an organization characterized by card was titled "Help for HIGH BLOOD PRESSURE. Stephen Barrett as "promoters fighting for the right to Chiropractic ...FEEL GOOD NATURALL Y ... Since the cheat and victims fighting for the right to be cheated." nervous system controls the mechanics of blood For facts on this major arm of the quackery mafia, pressure, a misaligned vertebra can produce an read the chapter "The Unhealthy Alliance" in Vitamins abnormality in nerve impulses... We can realign your and "Health" Foods: The Great American Hustle by V. spine and help your body restore health." This is a Herbert and S. Barrett (George F. Stickley Company, gross deception; chiropractic adjustments are worthless Philadelphia, 1981, and the Herbert 1984 Pepper for treating hypertension, beyond the effect of testimony). suggestion. Page 291: "Swedish and lymphatic Page 311: If you have a hysterectomy, "when this massage and reflexology both facilitate the lymphatic channel of elimination is lost, body wastes tend to drainage," and Page 148: "SPECIAL EXERCISE FOR build in the body." THE ELDERLY OR WHEN HEALTH IS IMPAIRED. Fact: The uterus is not a "channel of elimination." LYMPHATIC BOUND: Works to pump and cleanse the Again, the Diamonds reveal their ignorance of basic lymph system, your body's in-house 'vacuum cleaner.'" anatomy. This lie falsely represents to a woman who Fact: There is no data in the peer-reviewed has a hysterectomy that she has placed herself in scientific literature demonstrating a "facilitation of danger of "body wastes building in the body." lymphatic drainage" by bouncing up and down on a Page 311: "For those of you who have had a trampoline ("THE LYMPHATIC BOUNCE") or that either hysterectomy, lost your thyroid, or both and massage or reflexology "move the waste material subsequently ballooned up ... there is an emergency through." All a reader need do is look up the lymphatic measure you can take ...Eat only raw vegetables." system in any modern textbook of anatomy (a health Fact: Following this ignorant advice will deprive related science of which the Diamonds, "students of you of essential nutrients, producing disease, and health science," display an appalling ignorance) to eventually produce death from undernutrition. realize there is no way you can "pump and cleanse the Page 312: "The appendix detoxifies poisons in the lymph system" by "the LYMPHATIC BOUND," "bouncing colon. Losing the appendix is a severe blow. This is lightly on a trampoline without your feet leaving the why people who have had appendectomies frequently mat, keeping your hands at your sides" (page 148). complain of becoming bloated and/or constipated... For Additionally, the infirm elderly, neither in wheelchairs those who have lost their appendix, it is crucial to or bedridden, are subject to many episodes of falling take whatever steps possible to keep the colon clean. (extensive studies of this phenomenon have been It is dangerous not tol ... Rely heavily on high-water conducted at our geriatric center at Mount Sinai in New content foods and minimize the amount of more York City), and telling such people to get on a concentrated foods." trampoline with their arms at their sides places them in Fact: The statement is pure fabrication, revealing great jeopardy. gross ignorance of the health sciences of Page 292: "Accupuncture [sic) ...can be used to repair gastrointestinal tract physiology, biochemistry, and shorts in electrical energy." toxicology. Fact: Pure fabrication. There has never been any The book is dedicated "for God and for all God's demonstration in the peer-reviewed scientific literature children." What a sacrilege! A book of fabrications of the existence of such a "short" or its "repair" by dangerous to your health dedicated to God! Nothing acupuncture. The Diamonds don't even spell the word makes clearer this is health cultism, than the cultists' "acupuncture" correctly. characteristic sacrilegious inference of an alliance with Page 298: If you have a Candida infection, "if you God. properly combine your foods, eat fresh fruit correctly, Should responsible health professionals debate folks and avoid fermented foods (alcohol, vinegar, miso, like these on the air? I think not. One can't yogurt), your Candida problem will become a thing of effectively debate fabricators and character assassins in the past." a forum with no penalties for fabrication or character Fact: Food has nothing to do with Candida assassination (especially when, as on the Donahue infection. Anyone who has thrush (a severe Candida show, the host favors snake oil promoters and plants infection of the throat), can die of untreated candidiasis their disciples in the audience). In addition, the if they follow this worthless advice instead of getting endorsement represented by giving them air time sells 12

their books and other products. For responsible health Yetiv on the King show, Harvey stated, "Jack likes to professionals to debate the likes of the Diamonds about talk loud and call names." Dr. Yetiv is a non nutrition and health matters is like Bliot Ness and confrontational person who never once called the other law enforcement officials debating Al Capone and Diamonds any names; he even gently volunteered "she the Chicago Mafia about legal ethics. (I counseled looks OK to me," in response to a caller's observation physician Jack Yetiv against debating the Diamonds on that Marilyn looked anorexic. On the show, Harvey the Larry King show, with him in a Chicago studio and referred to Dr. Yetiv as "Mr. Yetiv" and "Jack," falsely them in the Washington, DC, studio with host King. I conveying that Dr. Yetiv was at Mr. Harvey Diamond's warned him the Diamonds would exploit such a set-up to incompetent level of knowledge of health science. He keep interrupting him and he would not be able to do did likewise when Yetiv pointed out the frequency of likewise, and that is exactly what happened.) stomach cancer in the US was about 2.6%, and not the The Diamonds fill the airwaves with anecdotes and 33% the Diamonds allege - Harvey lied that he had testimonials about themselves and their disciples. The statistics as good as Yetiv's (which were from the life-blood of the snake oil peddler is the anecdote and American Cancer Society that there were an estimated the testimonial. Anecdotes and testimonials do not 965,000 cancer cases in 1987, of which 24,600 were separate truth from erroneous belief, because they do stomach cancer). not separate cause-and-effect from either coincidence or The Diamonds' pathologic hatred of responsible suggestibility or the natural history of the disorder. The health professionals combines with their gross word "anecdote" is from the Greek "anekdota," meaning distortion and misrepresentation of reality to cause not published. To a health professional, "published" them to devote pages 14-16 to lying about the Flexner means published in the peer-reviewed scientific report which revolutionized medical education in the literature, which will not take a study unless the United States. The superb 1910 Flexner report conclusions are adequately supported by the data. It (fraudulently characterized by the Diamonds on page 15 does not mean published in the lay press or on the as an "infamous report") described the fact that most media, whose cause and effect are not separated from of the health teaching of the day was based on coincidence, suggestibility, or the natural history of the worthless anecdote and testimonial (the phony disorder. Diamond-Fry approach), instead of objective studies If you believe something will make you feel better, separating cause and effect from coincidence, you will feel better, even if it is slowly and insidiously suggestibility, and the natural history of the disorder destroying your health. Examples of worthless (i.e., the scientific method). The Flexner report testimonials and anecdotes on the King show: brought about a public outcry against incompetent Marilyn: If our advice doesn't work," how come we health science teaching, resulting in the closing of the feel so good? What about us personally? What about majority of the medical schools in the U.S. Those that all the (Ed: laudatory) letters from readers of our survived were those that gave up the unscientific book?" Contrary to their testimony and anecdotal eye approach in favor of the scientific one. The Diamonds wash, if she in fact has been following the Diamond either haven't read or deliberately ignore all the advice for 17 years, she has slowly and insidiously responsible medical education literature about the become depleted of iron, zinc, calcium, and vitamin B- Flexner era. One wonders if their "research at various 12. On the King show, Harvey stated "Every word in institutions" (page 12) included any in any medical our book is backed up." He lied. school library or the National Library of Medicine. In their USA Today interview on June 1, 1987, Page 270: 0 When you cut down on cows' milk and Harvey is quoted as saying, " The issue has never been cheese and yogurt and ice cream, (your children's) our credentials. Our credentials are the truth." Their little bodies, which have been clogged up from foods "truths" are lies, and what they call "lies" is the truth. that they cannot efficiently metabolize, will sing for The Diamonds are right out of George Orwell's book joy and spew out all that is clogging them. That stage �- The Diamonds use the same deception on pages will pass quickly and your children will be practically 17-18: "The dietitians' all-time favorite smokescreen, the 'cold-free' from that point on, if you keep them away issue of credentials, should not even be the issue. The from dairy." real issue is truth. HAVING "CREDENTIALS" DOES Fact: The whole statement is a fabrication. The NOT MAKE THE TRUTH MORE THE TRUTH AND NOT vast majority of children efficiently metabolize all HAVING "CREDENTIALS" DOES NOT MAKE THE TRUTH their food, including cows' milk, cheeses, yogurt, and LESS THE TRUTH." ice cream. The "clogging" does not exist. It is pure As part of their cover-up for their malicious fabrication that keeping children away from dairy defamation of responsible health professionals, the products protects them from colds, which are caused Diamonds lie that they are the victims of unwarranted by viruses. This fabrication may reflect the teachings defamation. For example, in countering physician Jack of Fry (guru to the Diamonds) that viruses do not 13

exist. Frightful odds in inner city," each year, a quarter Page 271: After breast feeding, instead of cows' million babies are born dangerously underweight in this milk, mothers should give their children "nut and seed country and face a 1-in-10 chance that they will not milks ... excellent sources of usable... vitamins." live to their first birthday... They are the children of Fact: There is no vitamin B-12 in nut or seed milk. unwanted pregnancies and fractured homes, born to Page 272: Avoid giving children animal protein for mothers who may not have seen a doctor until they as long as you can. Never is best... Leukemia and intake went into labor. These thousands of underdeveloped of animal protein are related, without a doubt. .. Fruits babies are more likely than other infants to suffer and vegetables are the most ideal foods in a young brain hemorrhages, infection, pneumonia, or dozens of child's diet." other life-threatening complications ... poverty, Fact: H you never give children animal protein and ignorance, lack of proper care... At least 20 percent of only give them fruits and vegetables, their growth will these babies must be hospitalized again in the first probably be permanently stunted, many will get a year of life, and others bear handicaps that require variety of serious mineral deficiencies, and all will get costly surgery and medical care for life ... ldeally, a vitamin B-12 deficiency (see Proceedings, First pregnant woman sees a doctor once a month through International Congress of Vegetarian Nutrition, the seventh month, then weekly until delivery to sponsored by Loma Linda University [Seventh Day monitor fetal progress, to insure that the mother eats Adventists], March, 1987, including paper by Herbert). properly, and to detect problems such as anemia, high The fabrication that leukemia and intake of animal blood pressure or diabetes, which can endanger the protein are related appears to be stated to promote unborn child. Yet each year about 300,000 women give their brand of extreme vegetarianism (Marilyn on page birth after little or no prenatal care, and their babies 249: "The last seventeen years [of my life] have account for two-thirds of all infant deaths." Imagine included a minimal amount of animal products [raw the carnage if the Diamonds or their disciples were put butter and sour cream]"). Luckily for the health of in charge of a national state or local program of Adventist vegetarians, less than 2% of them eat no health for the poverty-stricken, with their hatred of animal protein, 29% add milk and egg products, 25% also physicians and advice to avoid milk and eat inadequate eat meat less than once a week, 29% eat meat one to nourishment. four times a week, and 15% five or more times a week, On page 16, Harvey Diamond states "I received my according to Dr. Roland PhiUips of the Adventist Health Ph.D. in nutritional science from the American College Study at Loma Linda University. of Health Science in February, 1983." He deceives by The caller on the King show who said Marilyn omitting the fact that, in 1986, the school's dean, a looked anorexic was correct. She certainly appeared so high school dropout named T.C. Fry, agreed to a in her skin-tight body suit on her exercise bike. She permanent injunction barring him from representing the appears there to be substantially below desirable weight school as a college or selling any more "degrees" or for height by either the old or the new Metropolitan "academic credits" such as those he sold to the Life tables, and the diet she describes for herself and Diamonds unless he acquires a certificate of authority her son is one which promotes iron, zinc, calcium, and from the Texas Department of Higher Education. He 8-12 deficiencies. has renamed his operation "Life Science Institute" ("a When she claims good health, talk show hosts non-profit educational organization"). The Diamonds should ask her some serious questions: What is her (page 330) refer to this high school dropout as height? What is her weight? Her serum iron and serum "Professor T.C. Fry, the Dean of the American College iron binding capacity? Her serum ferritin? Her serum of Health Science," deceiving their readers by omitting vitamin B-12 level? Her bone density? Her zinc status? the fact that, since 1986, Mr. Fry has been forbidden Does she know? Does she care? Does Harvey know? to call his operation a "college." Fry is "mister" on Does Warner Books know? Why isn't the data in their page 19 but "professor" on page 330. On the Larry book? If. the Diamonds have been feeding their son as King television show, physician Jack Yetiv, author of they claim, there is a good chance they are stunting his Popular Nutritional Practices: Sense and Nonsense (Dell growth and are predisposing him to zinc and calcium Publishing, New York, NY, $4.95 softcover), stated he deficiency. Is he in a low percentage of the growth had a tape-recorded conversation with Fry in which curve for his age? What is � iron, zinc, calcium, and Fry told him the only people who couldn't pass the B-12 status? Do the Diamonds or Warner Books know? courses the Diamonds passed were those who can't If so, why isn't the data in the book? The book � read. the Diamonds are healthy, but gives no supporting proof The 423-item bibliography in the Diamond book is of health (i.e., does not give any of the above data). useless. The cited articles in the peer-reviewed As the New York Tjmes pointed out in the June 26, literature do not prove any of the fabrications alleged 1987 Isabel Wilkerson page-one story "Infant mortality: as facts in the book, none of the references are keyed 14

in the text, and many are from the garbage literature first distinguished fat-soluble from water-soluble the Diamonds self-studied (egregious examples: vitamins by lying that he was "sacrificing the health of References 13 to 16: (13) Allen, Hannah: Lesson #33: the people for the almighty dollar." People who live in Why we should not eat animal products in any form. glass houses shouldn't throw stones. In: The Life Science Health System by T.C. Fry. The Diamonds defend the Fit for Life weight-loss Austin, Texas: Life Sciences, 1984; also, (14) "The happy diet on the grounds that "it works." That is not the truth about protein," (15) "Why we should not eat question. Any diet, no ·· matter how dangerous and meat," (16) "Why we should not eat animal products," all irresponsible, "works" to bring about weight loss so by the same Hannah Allen. long as it results in eating each day less calories than On page 17, the Diamonds state "The real issue is one burns. The consumer protection question is not truth." Since they are chronic liars, one can only say, "Does it work?", but "Is it safe?" The Diamonds' Fit "Amen." for Life diet is more accurately characterized as Unfit The final fabrication in the book is the statement for Life - it is unsafe. Living Health is more in the conclusion (page 410) that "there is no money to accurately characterized as Lies about Health be made" in promoting health misinformation. The following its advice can harm you or your child, and, millions the Diamonds and their publisher have made in some situations, leave your child maimed or dead. from their disinformative writings and public appearances, tapes, and charts (which they offer for Final Comment sale on page 412 of the book), as well as the profits As health science phonies, the Diamonds should they will undoubtedly make from their "sweet bar" change their name to Zircon. By publishing this (replacement for a candy bar; page 276) give the lie to second Diamond book with full knowledge that the that claim, as they and their irresponsible publisher and Diamonds are health phonies, Warner Books displays public relations agents (with the millions they have itself as an irresponsible publisher, interested only in made selling the Diamonds' fabrications) well know.On money, with a reckless disregard of the harm they may the Larry King show, the Diamonds claimed the millions cause. I hope their victims sue them, as victims of copies sold of their diet book, Fit for Life, proved it successfully sued the publisher of the Adelle Davis was true. Larry King replied that the best selling diet books. book of all time, Calories Don't Count, with more than 6 million copies sold, was a pure fraud. Amen to Larry Postscript King! Like Fit for Life and Living Health, the biggest On August 11, 1987 Harvey Diamond wrote to lie is the title of the book. (The lyingest title sold the Michael Botts, Dr. Herbert's attorney, complaining that most books.) charges that "children can be killed by the advise (sic) When a caller asked, "How come the authorities in this book" were baseless. Dr. Herbert responded by didn't take action against it if the book is lies," King citing advice regarding sore throats by the Diamonds pointed out that freedom of speech includes the freedom on their page 283, and enclosing an article on the to lie, and only a victim (a financially or physically resurgence of rheumatic fever (" Mysterious return of a injured party) can sue. At the top of the book's childhood scourge" U.S. News & World Report, August jacket, it is stated "by the authors of American's all 31, 1987) underlining the words "parents should take time #1 health and diet book." - It is not #1, the precaution of getting their children to a doctor [deception by �mmission], and it is a health and diet right away if they have sore throats." Further, misinformation book [deception by QD1ission of the word Herbert cites a recent epidemic of salmonella diarrhea "misinformation"].) deaths in New York City and points to Diamonds' On page 230, the Diamonds assassinate the advice that diarrhea be treated only with "rest and character of the great nutritionist, E.V. McCollum, who sleep" which could make salmonella diarrhea lethal.

Herbert, V.: Critical Evaluation of Harvey & Marilyn Diamond'sBook, Fit For Life. Loma Linda, CA, 92354: The National Council Against Health Fraud, Inc., 1988.