The Writer's Art: Tao Yuanqing and the Formation of Modern Chinese Design (1900-1930)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Writer's Art: Tao Yuanqing and the Formation of Modern Chinese Design (1900-1930) The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Ren, Wei. 2015. The Writer's Art: Tao Yuanqing and the Formation of Modern Chinese Design (1900-1930). Doctoral dissertation, Harvard University, Graduate School of Arts & Sciences. Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:17465116 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA The Writer’s Art: Tao Yuanqing and the Formation of Modern Chinese Design (1900-1930) A dissertation presented by Ren, Wei to The Department of History of Art and Architecture in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the subject of History of Art and Architecture Harvard University Cambridge, Massachusetts April 2015 © 2015 Ren,Wei All rights reserved. Dissertation Advisor: Professor Eugene Y. Wang Ren, Wei The Writer’s Art: Tao Yuanqing and the Formation of Modern Chinese Design (1900-1930) Abstract The dissertation examines the history of modern design in early 20th-century China. The emergent field of design looked to replace the specific cultural and historical references of visual art with an international language of geometry and abstraction. However, design practices also, encouraged extracting culturally unique visual forms by looking inward at a nation’s constructed past. The challenge of uniting these dual, and seemingly contradictory, goals was met in a collaborative book cover design project between Lu Xun (1881-1936), China’s most influential modern writer, and Tao Yuanqing (1893-1929), a painter who transformed ancient motifs into a transnational vocabulary of modern design. As the title suggests, the dissertation provides a history of modern Chinese design in four chapters, with the Lu Xun-Tao Yuanqing collaboration at its core. The investigation begins with the moment of culmination, wherein Lu Xun and Tao Yuanqing’s intersubjective dynamic allowed for evocative yet inscrutable book cover designs to be created. In the new medium of design, the writer’s anxiety regarding the inadequacy of language converged with the artist’s desire for ambiguity in art. The critical analysis then moves back to earlier instances of design and examines how the history of design in China was inflected by the World Exposition, Japan, art education, and commercial art. The inquiry finally moves forward to the discussion of Tao Yuanqing’s art and design’s relationship with a range of discursive fields in aesthetics and iii literary criticism, including modern notions of beauty, childlikeness, empathy, the native soil movement, cosmopolitanism, symbolism, and ambiguity in art. This part reveals how Tao Yuanqing’s innovations ironically endorsed while simultaneously subverting contemporary interpretive efforts. iv Table of Contents List of figures ................................................................................................................................. vii Acknowledgements ......................................................................................................................... xi Note on Chinese and Japanese terms ............................................................................................ xiii Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 1 1 Lost and Found: Lu Xun’s Dilemma and Tao Yuanqing’s Design Solution ......................... 18 Introduction: The encounter 18 The ineffable image 21 “Writing characters is drawing pictures” 25 Old image, new context 35 The versatile female body 39 Form versus formless 42 Coda: Double vision 51 2 Loss and Gain in Translation: The Advent of Modern Chinese Design ............................... 56 Introduction: Chinese Ancient Designs (1925) 56 The price of self-orientalizing 59 Lessons from Paris 63 The weight of painting 68 The beginning – All-purpose design 73 Design and the aesthetic education 78 Design versus painting 82 The early pioneers of design 92 Coda: Growth and metabolism 98 3 The Games of Vision: Line, Linearity, and Lineage ................................................................ 105 Introduction: A beautiful book 105 Dis-enchantment and re-enchantment 108 Beauty and childlikeness 119 Perception over judgment 127 “Motion picture” 136 Coda: Figure, figuration and reconfiguration 145 v 4 Spellbound: Roots, Ruins, and Surface ...................................................................................... 152 Introduction: Tale gone awry 152 Spellbound 155 Enigma of the Big Red Robe 160 Xiangtu, volkskunde, and the nation 163 Provincial versus cosmopolitan 169 Apathy against affect 176 Coda: All about surface 184 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................... 191 Bibliography ................................................................................................................................. 196 Appendix – Chronology of Tao Yuanqing .................................................................................. 207 Figures ......................................................................................................................................... 208 vi List of Figures 1. Tao Yuanqing, Cover design of Guxiang (Hometown) by Xu Qinwen, published by Beixin Book Company, 1925. 2. Tao Yuanqing, Cover design of Kumen de xiangzheng (Symbols of Depression) by Kuriyagawa Hakuson, Lu Xun trans., published by Xinchao Society, 1924. 3. Photograph of Students at the Shanghai Fine Arts School, 1930. 4. Ding Song, Cover design of Saturday, issue 104, published by Shanghai Zhonghua Library, 1921. 5. Cover of Young Companion, first issue, published by Shanghai Liangyou Printing Company, February 15, 1926. 1.1 Cover of Didi lüxing (Voyage au Centre de la Terre) by Jules Verne, Lu Xun trans., published by Puji Book Company, 1906. 1.2 Cover of Dixin lüxing (Voyage au Centre de la Terre) by Jules Verne, published by Guangzhi Book Company, 1906. 1.3 Lu Xun and Chen Shizeng, Cover design of Yuwai xiaoshuo ji (Collected Stories from Abroad) by Zhou Shuren (Lu Xun), and Zhou Zuoren, published in Tokyo, 1909. 1.4 Lu Xun, Cover design of Nahan (Call to Arms) by Lu Xun, published by Beixin Book Company, 1924. 1.5 Lu Xun, Cover design of Er yi ji (And That’s That) by Lu Xun, published by Beixin Book Company, 1928. 1.6 Tao Yuanqing, Cover design of Zhaohua xishi (Dawn Blossoms Plucked at Dusk) by Lu Xun, published by Weiming Society, 1928. 1.7 Wu Changshi, Cover calligraphy of Shenzhou guoguang ji (Chinese National Glory), vol. 11, no. 5, published by Shanghai shenzhou guoguangshe, 1909. 1.8 Tao Yuanqing, Cover design of Chule xiangya zhi ta (Out of the Ivory Tower) by Kuriyagawa Hakuson, Lu Xun trans., published by Weiming Society, 1925. 1.9 Lu Xun, Cover design of Tao se de yun (The Pink Cloud) by Vasili Eroshenko, Lu Xun trans., published by Xinchao Society, 1923. 1.10 Ink rubbing of carvings from Wu Family Shrine in Jiaxiang, collected by Lu Xun, undated. 1.11 Lu Xun, Cover design of Guoxue jikan (National Learning Quarterly), edited by Gu Jiegang, published by Peking University, 1923. 1.12 Illustration page, Shenzhou guoguang ji (Chinese National Glory), vol.8, no.2, published by Shanghai shenzhou guoguangshe, 1909. 1.13 Ding Song, Cover design of Libai liu (Saturday), no.22, published by Shanghai Zhongguo Book Company, 1914. 1.14 Lu Xun, Vignettes traced from Ausgewählte Gedichte Paul Verlaine, edited by Graf Wolf v. Kalckreuth, published by Leipzig Insel-Verlag, 1906. 1.15 Lu Xun, Border designs traced from Germany publications including the cover of Ausgewählte Gedichte Paul Verlaine, edited by Graf Wolk v. Kalckreuth, published by Leipzig Insel-Verlag, 1906. vii 1.16 Xu Beihong, Female Nude, charcoal and white chalk on paper, 50 x 32 cm, Xu Beihong Memorial Museum Beijing, 1924. 1.17 Dan Duyu, Page from Shizhuang Duyu baimeitu zheng ji (Duyu’s Fashionable One Hundred Beauties), published by Shanghai xinmin tushuguan xiongdi gongsi, 1923. 1.18 Tao Yuanqing, Cover design of Fangfu ruci (It Seems Like That) by Xu Qinwen, published by Beixin Book Company, 1928. 1.19 Tao Yuanqing, Cover design of Wang xing zhong (To the Stars) by Leonid Andreyev, Li Jiye trans., published by Weiming Society, 1926. 1.20 Tao Yuanqing, Cover design of Fen (The Grave) by Lu Xun, published by Weiming Society, 1927. 2.1 Ge Gongzhen, Chinese Ancient Designs, published by Shanghai Youzheng Book Company, 1925. 2.2 Catalogue of the Collection of Chinese Exhibits at the Louisiana Purchase Exposition, 1904. 2.3 Catalogue Spécial des Objets Exposés dans la Section Chinoise, Liège, 1905. 2.4 Catalogue Section de Chine Exposition Internationale des Arts Décoratifs et Industriels Modernes à Paris, 1925. 2.5 Rubbing of stone carving of mythical bird from Xinjin cliff tombs, Xinjin County, Sichuan, China, 206 BCE – 220 AD, Han dynasty. 2.6 Entrance to the Chinese Section, L’Exposition Internationale des Arts Décoratifs et Industriels Modernes à Paris, 1925. 2.7 Detail of the Chinese Section, L’Exposition Internationale des Arts Décoratifs et Industriels Modernes à Paris, 1925. 2.8 Detail of