BC Law Magazine Spring/Summer 2013 Boston College Law School
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Boston College Law School Digital Commons @ Boston College Law School Boston College Law School Magazine 4-1-2013 BC Law Magazine Spring/Summer 2013 Boston College Law School Follow this and additional works at: http://lawdigitalcommons.bc.edu/bclsm Part of the Legal Education Commons Recommended Citation Boston College Law School, "BC Law Magazine Spring/Summer 2013" (2013). Boston College Law School Magazine. Book 43. http://lawdigitalcommons.bc.edu/bclsm/43 This Book is brought to you for free and open access by Digital Commons @ Boston College Law School. It has been accepted for inclusion in Boston College Law School Magazine by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ Boston College Law School. For more information, please contact [email protected]. • Justice O’Connor’s Civics Lesson • Crime Writer Gets Day in Court • Gov. Malloy Helps Newtown Heal www.bc.edu/bclawmagazine BOSTON COLLEGE LAW SCHOOL MAGAZINE Spring | Summer 2013 Tim McLaughlin ’09 His War, His Diary, and His Afterword Faculty Lunch Friday, 12–1:15 PM. Keynote speaker: former dean Daniel Coquillette. Assembly & Reunion Luncheon Saturday, 12–2 PM. Open Featuring former Classrooms President of Ireland Mary Friday, 1:30–3:00 PM. Has anything changed? McAleese. See first-hand how we teach students today. Alumni Assembly BC Law Goes to Saturday, 11–11:45 AM. the Ballet Gather for Dean’s state- Sunday, 1:00 PM. of-the-school address Join fellow reunioners for and Alumni Board a performance of elections. “La Bayadere” by the Boston Ballet. “Bar Review” Reunion Dinner Happy Hour Saturday, 7–10:30 PM. Ritz-Carlton, Boston. Friday, 7–9 PM. Celebrate at a festive Come home to a BC evening of cocktails and Law tradition. conversation. Special Receptions & Presentations REUNION 2013 Friday afternoon & evening. So much more Celebrate. Socialize. Reconnect. Learn about than you ever BC Law today. imagined! NOVEMBER 1–3 Alumni from classes ending in 3 or 8 look for more information in the coming months at www.bc.edu/lawreunion, but Maureen Canavan ’87 (left) and Kathryn Barton ’87 please SAVE THE DATE NOW! Contents SPRING / SUMMER 2013 VOLUME 21 | NUMBER 2 30 AP IMAGES FEATURES DEPARTMENTS 2 In Limine 14 ‘His Horse Was Named Death....’ 3 Behind the Columns The raw, vivid diary of Tim McLaughin ’09, a young 4 In Brief warrior on the frontlines of the Iraq invasion—and the life that he lives one decade later. By Peter Maass 10 Legal Currents REFRAMING A GENDER ISSUE BC Law closes achievement gap GREAT CASES 22 Stranger than Fiction RIGHTS ON ICE When mystery writer Patricia Cornwell began to Student challenges LSAC policy suspect that her financial management company was 12 Hot Topics mishandling her money, she became the protagonist Justice Sandra Day O’Connor in an all-too-real crime story. By Milton J. Valencia advocates for civics education 34 Global Engagement 27 ‘Wide Awake and Dreaming’ 36 Faculty Julie Flygare’s memoir chronicles her triumph over NEWS narcolepsy. By Julie Flygare ’09 ACADEMIC VITAE PROFILE Professor Joseph P. Liu 30 The Making of a Humanist 44 Esquire Enduring childhood travails that could have soured a ALUMNI NEWS lesser man, Connecticut Governor Dannel Malloy ’80 CLASS NOTES was tested again by the Newtown massacre. GENERATIONS By Jeri Zeder 53 Commencement 55 Reunion Giving Report 60 In Closing cover: Photo of Timothy McLaughlin ’09 by Gary Knight WWW.BC.EDU/LAWALUMNI 1 [ I N L imine ] SPRING / SUMMER 2013 VOLUME 21 NUMBER 2 Make Peace, Not War Dean Vincent Rougeau Valor and victories speak of personal risk and community strength Editor in Chief Vicki Sanders t seems that war and peace—on the battlefield, on the political stage, in the ([email protected]) legal profession, even at the Boston Marathon’s finish line—have dominated I the public agenda in recent months. Art Director In response, BC Law Magazine acknowledges the tenth anniversary of the US Annette Trivette invasion of Iraq with a profile of Timothy McLaughlin ’09 and an exploration of the diary that this lieutenant and tank driver in the Third Battalion, Fourth Contributing Editor Marines, kept as he entered the war in 2003 (page 14). Deborah J. Wakefield We try to understand the source of alumnus and Connecticut Governor Dannel Malloy’s compassionate leadership and steely political resolve as he carried out two Contributing Writers seemingly impossible tasks: telling the families of Sandy Hook Elementary that their Thomas A. Barnico ’80 children were never coming home, and passing one of the nation’s toughest gun Edward Dunn ’13 control laws (page 30). Lauren Graber ’10 We marvel at how the student group Lambda turned an act of homophobic van- Louise Kennedy dalism of their office into an opportunity to show the warmth and unity of the Law Peter Maass School community (page 7). We also shudder at the hate behind the Boston Mara- thon bombings, which leads us to ponder the price of freedom in America (page 3). Stephanie Schorow We learn about battles large and small that members of the Law School are fight- Milton J. Valencia ing on paper, in courtrooms, and wherever injustice emerges, be it in a privileged Jane Whitehead world where millions are counted—and stolen—like pennies or simply a principled Jeri Zeder one where righting a wrong is the prevailing currency. Example: A wealthy crime novelist was defrauded by her management company and, with the help of Joan Photographers Lukey ’74, won a judgment worth over $50 million (page 22). Example: Spurned Suzi Camarata without explanation by the Law School Admission Council when he Caitlin Cunningham asked for accommodation on the LSAT for his reading disability, student Charles Gauthier Theodore Dunn ’13 later drew on what he learned in law school to write Rose Lincoln a law review article providing a novel solution that could ensure fairness Michael Manning for future test-takers (page 11). Judy Sanders/Wildsands Julie Flygare’s body is at war with itself, but her struggle to make peace Dana Smith with a debilitating disease has been rewarded. Not only has she recently Christopher Soldt, MTS, BC published a memoir about the narcolepsy that made a living nightmare of her law school years, 2006-2009, she has also enjoyed some renewal of health and Printing found her purpose in life as an effective advocate for awareness and research of the R. C. Brayshaw & Company sleeping disorder (page 27). Visiting professor Thomas Barnico ’80 has the last word in his In Closing col- Boston College Law School of Newton, Massachusetts 02459-1163, publishes umn (page 60). He offers a rather bemused inquiry into why the Supreme Court is BC Law Magazine two times a year: in allowed to decide, by a bare majority, cases involving the laws of the land. Perhaps January and June. BC Law Magazine is printed by R. C. Brayshaw & Company if a super majority were required, he suggests, a truce could replace those take-no- in Warner and West Lebanon, NH. We prisoners political contests between the right and left over judicial appointments welcome readers’ comments. Contact us and nominations. by phone at 617-552-2873; by mail at Boston College Law School, Barat House, —Vicki Sanders 885 Centre Street, Newton, MA 02459- Editor 1163; or by email at [email protected]. Copyright © 2013, Boston College Law School. All publication rights reserved. Opinions expressed in BC Law Magazine do not necessarily reflect the views of E T I Boston College Law School or Boston -WH College. ING D IL Y W AN FF I T 2 BC LAW MAGAZINE | SPRING / SUMMER 2013 [ B E H ind T H E C O lumns ] The Power of Our Values Even the Marathon bombings shouldn’t alter our belief in the promise of newcomers e in Boston now understand viscer- homogenous communities and, frankly, homogeneity ally what many around the world have may well increase safety. It is certainly easier to keep lived with for a long time. Vibrant tabs on a person when everyone in the neighborhood W cities in open societies are tempting tar- knows a lot about him and his background. Not so gets for terrorist attacks. Eerily, the bombing in Bos- long ago, certain codes were used to signal this knowl- ton came just as the nation was renewing debate about edge: “good” families, “our kind of people,” “not its immigration laws. Columnist E. J. Dionne noted one of us,” just to name a few. These were the more recently in the Washington Post that, “opponents of benign phrases. Other labels were much more judg- immigration reform used the fact that the [bombing mental or derogatory. suspects] are immigrants as a lever to derail the rapidly forming consensus in favor of broad repairs to the system. Supporters countered, defensively, that if there Along with other important is any lesson here, it’s that our approach to immigra- tion needs to be modernized. In truth, this horrifying social changes, immigration has episode has little to do with immigration reform one stimulated the economy, revived way or the other.” decaying neighborhoods and Dionne is absolutely right to reject a connection cities, and, yes, opened America between the bombings and immigration in any mean- ingful sense. As a symbolic matter, however, the two to the world in ways that are not are intricately linked. Politicians seized the moment to always positive. question the nation’s comfort with “strangers” and the media wasted no time in asking shocked Bosto- nians whether they thought it was time to pull up the One of the reasons we do not hear that kind of talk ladders a bit for immigrants.