sustainability Review A Review of Methods to Improve Nitrogen Use Efficiency in Agriculture Lakesh K. Sharma 1,2,* and Sukhwinder K. Bali 1,2,* 1 Department of Cooperative Extension, University of Maine, 57 Houlton Rd., Presque Isle, ME 04769, USA 2 Department of Art and Science, University of Maine at Presque Isle, 181 Main St, Presque Isle, ME 04769, USA * Correspondence: [email protected] (L.K.S.); [email protected] (S.K.B.) Received: 16 November 2017; Accepted: 23 December 2017; Published: 26 December 2017 Abstract: Management of nitrogen (N) is a challenging task and several methods individually and in combination are in use to manage its efficiency. However, nitrogen use efficiency (NUE) has not been improved to a level, only 33%, as predicted by the researchers while developing nitrogen management tools and methods. The primary objective of this review article is to evaluate methods and tools available to manage nitrogen. Several methods, soil testing, plant tissue testing, spectral response, fertilizer placement and timing and vegetative indexes (leaf area index, and NDVI) through drones, handheld sensors, and satellite imagery were reviewed on the subject of user-friendly and effectiveness towards NUE. No single method was found sufficient to counter the nitrogen loss. Some methods were found time consuming and unsynchronized with N uptake behavior of particular crop, for example, plant tissue testing. Use of precision agriculture tools, such as GreenSeeker, Holland Crop Circle, drone, and satellite imagery, were found better compared to conventional methods such as soil testing, but these tools can only be used when the crop is up. Therefore, N management is possible only through inseason N application methods. When 70% of the applied nitrogen is used by the crops within 25–30 days after planting, for example, corn and potatoes, it is required to apply major N rates through inseason approach and some N at planting using soil test reports. In conclusion, this article strongly advocates using two or more methods in combination when managing N. Keywords: nitrogen; NUE; soil; precision agriculture tools 1. Introduction Nitrogen (N), an essential nutrient for growth and development of plants, is added to agricultural fields to boost crop yields but is also limiting in the aquatic ecosystems. For example, accelerated surface water eutrophication, algal blooms, hypoxia, and public health issues due to consumption of contaminated groundwater have been linked to enrichment of excess use of N (and/or phosphorous, P) that can be lost to the environment through leaching to the groundwater, and transportation to the nearby surface waters via surface runoff or directly via tile drainage bypassing stream buffer [1]. In addition, significant fractions of the applied N are lost in the air through emission of ammonia (NH3), which contributes to eutrophication and acidification when redeposited on the land; nitrous oxide (N2O) is a potent greenhouse gas; and nitric oxide (NO) plays a role in tropospheric ozone chemistry [2]. These losses can be reduced by adoption of appropriate methods or best management practices (BMPs) that increase the accessibility of N for plant use, enhance plants’ N uptake ability, and match nutrient applications with agronomic needs. Thus, the challenge with farming would be balancing crop-nutrient requirements while minimizing losses to maintain a sustainable environment and economic benefits to the farmers. Sustainability 2018, 10, 51; doi:10.3390/su10010051 www.mdpi.com/journal/sustainability Sustainability 2018, 10, 51 2 of 23 Sustainability 2018, 10, 51 2 of 22 Use of any fertilizer, bothboth inorganic and organic form, can pose a threat to the environmentenvironment if misused. Total Total global global consumption consumption of of N N fertilizer fertilizer wa wass 112.5 112.5 million million tons tons in in2015 2015 and and is projected is projected to toreach reach 118.2 118.2 million million tonnes tonnes in 2019 in 2019 (see (see Figure Figure 1A)1 A)with with world world population population growth growth (likely (likely to reach to reach 7.9– 7.9–10.510.5 billion billion by 2050; by 2050; Zhang Zhang et al., et al.,2017) 2017) and and the the need need for for food, food, feed, feed, fiber, fiber, and and fuel fuel (FAO, (FAO, Washington, Washington, DC, USA,USA, 2016).2016). OfOf which,which, North North America America constituted constituted 14.1 14.1 million million tonnes tonnes in 2015,in 2015, and and the the demand demand for Nfor fertilizer N fertilizer is expected is expected to reach to reach 14.6 million 14.6 million tonnes tonnes in 2019 in (see 2019 Figure (see1 B).Figure Although 1B). Although large amounts large ofamounts N fertilizers of N fertilizers were used were throughout used throughout the world, the the wo recoveryrld, the orrecovery efficiency or efficiency of N fertilizers of N fertilizers by crops inby arablecrops landsin arable is relatively lands is low,relatively ranging low, from ranging 25% to from 50% 25% of the to applied50% of Nthe [3 ,applied4]. Low N nitrogen [3,4]. Low use efficiencynitrogen use (NUE) efficiency may lead(NUE) to may an alarming lead to an situation alarming from situation environmental, from environmental, economic, economic, and resource and conservationresource conservation points of points view, andof view, suggests and ansuggest urgents an need urgent for improvingneed for improving N use efficiency N use efficiency (NUE) of fertilizers.(NUE) of fertilizers. Apart from Apart the increasedfrom the increased use of N, theuse rapidof N, increasethe rapid of increase fertilizer of prices fertilizer is a significantprices is a concernsignificant for concern farmers. for For farmers. example, For in example, maize, 3.6 in million maize, metric3.6 million tons metric of N fertilizer tons of N are fertilizer used per are annum used withinper annum the Northwithin Central the North US, Central about 12US, states, about at12 a states cost of, at 600–800 a cost ofmillion 600–800 USD million [5]. USD In 2014, [5]. In the 2014, use ofthe total use Nof fertilizertotal N fertilizer reached reached to 5 million to 5 million metric tonsmetric (Mg) tons at (Mg) an estimated at an estimated cost of cost 500 of $/Mg 500 $/Mg or USD or 2.5USD billion 2.5 billion for 15 for US 15 StatesUS States [6]. [6]. Thus, Thus, the the increased increased use use and and cost cost of of N N fertilizers fertilizers in in cropcrop productionproduction is alarming.alarming. Improved NUE has the potential to increase yields and pro profitsfits by $18.75 per acre withwith minimal environmental impacts when growing grain cropscrops [[7].7]. Other crops should have similar benefitsbenefits as well. In this review,review, wewe discussdiscuss variousvarious factorsfactors controllingcontrolling NN useuse efficiencyefficiency (NUE)(NUE) andand thethe methodsmethods which cancan improveimprove NUENUE inin agricultureagriculture minimizingminimizing environmentalenvironmental losses.losses. To ourour knowledge,knowledge, this review isis thethe first first to to include include a comprehensivea comprehensive assessment assessment of researchof research on methodson methods associated associated with with both organicboth organic and inorganic and inorganic sources sources of supplemental of supplemental N to improveN to improve NUE inNUE different in different crops incrops a single in a single work. Wework. specify We specify possible possible ways to ways improve to improve NUE for NUE future for research.future research. Figure 1.1.( A(A) World) World demand demand for thefor totalthe fertilizertotal fertilizer and three and main three plant main nutrients plant (nitrogen,nutrients phosphate,(nitrogen, andphosphate, potash) and forecasts, potash) 2015–2019. forecasts, (B )2015–2019. The world and(B) The regional world demand and regional for nitrogen demand fertilizer for forecasts,nitrogen 2015–2019.fertilizer forecasts, Adapted 2015–2019. from FAO Adapted (2016). from FAO (2016). 2. Sources of Nitrogen and Interaction with Plant-Soil System Nitrogen is an element that can theoretically appear almost everywhere. In the atmosphere, N is dinitrogen gas (N2), about 78% (4000 trillion tons) of the total gas. Dinitrogen is converted to different forms such as ammonium and nitrate by organisms [8]. About 95% of nitrogen is found in Sustainability 2018, 10, 51 3 of 23 2. Sources of Nitrogen and Interaction with Plant-Soil System Nitrogen is an element that can theoretically appear almost everywhere. In the atmosphere, N is dinitrogen gas (N2), about 78% (4000 trillion tons) of the total gas. Dinitrogen is converted to different forms such as ammonium and nitrate by organisms [8]. About 95% of nitrogen is found in undisturbed natural soil organic matter [8]. However, when considering this element from an agricultural point of view, specific sources of nitrogen contribute the vast majority of the nitrogen available to crops and other plants. These sources include natural or organic sources and those generated from artificial processes. Natural sources of nitrogen include those found sequestered in soils via mineralization and bacterial fixation [9]. The forms of nitrogen available to plants in soil are ammonium and nitrate [10]. Nitrite, nitrous oxide, and atmospheric nitrogen are also found in soil, although these are not forms of nitrogen that are naturally accessible by plants unless they are altered to ammonium or nitrate via bacterial fixation or lightning fixation [10]. Another natural source of nitrogen is sequestered in living organisms. When organisms die, they begin to decay and deposit nitrogen back into soils. Leguminous crops and animal carcasses both tend to contain more nitrogen than most other organisms and therefore serve well as natural fertilizers [11,12]. Leguminous crops are used in crop rotations, that is, to fix atmospheric nitrogen and later deposit it into the upper layers of agricultural soils. High levels of nitrogen in animal bones or bone meal are used as an effective alternative fertilizer to chemical ones [13,14].