ING Technical Note No. 134 “ING Bibliography and Analysis 2002-2011” - Page 2
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ING LA PALMA TECHNICAL NOTE NO. 134 ING Bibliography and Analysis 2002-2011 Javier Méndez (ING) May 2012 Contents 1. Introduction .................................................................................................................................................................... 3 2. Analysis. .......................................................................................................................................................................... 4 2.1. Paper counts. .......................................................................................................................................................... 4 2.2. Paper authorship. .................................................................................................................................................... 7 2.3. Paper instrument use. ............................................................................................................................................. 7 2.4. Paper count check. .................................................................................................................................................. 8 Appendix 1. “ING Bibliography 2002-2011”. ........................................................................................................................ 10 2002 .................................................................................................................................................................................. 10 2003 .................................................................................................................................................................................. 18 2004 .................................................................................................................................................................................. 24 2005 .................................................................................................................................................................................. 33 2006 .................................................................................................................................................................................. 41 2007 .................................................................................................................................................................................. 50 2008 .................................................................................................................................................................................. 58 2009 .................................................................................................................................................................................. 67 2010 .................................................................................................................................................................................. 75 2011 .................................................................................................................................................................................. 84 ING Technical Note No. 134 “ING Bibliography and Analysis 2002-2011” - Page 2 1. Introduction An important metric of the the success of ING telescopes is the count of papers published in refereed journals. Before reporting on the results of this exercise, it is worth commenting on and clarifying the selection process. One of the first decisions to make is that of choosing which journals to scan for ING articles. We have restricted the search to the core journals in which most of the ING papers are published, ie. the British journal MNRAS (including Letters), the American journals ApJ, ApJ Letters, ApJ Suppl, AJ and PASP, plus the European journal A&A (including Letters), although many other publications have appeared elsewhere, notably in workshop and conference proceedings and in PhD theses. We also searched Nature and Science as due to the perceived high impact of these journals. The bibliography for the years 2002 to 2011 were therefore compiled from only the core journals listed above. Online search engines were used to select papers containing a set of strings in the paper text: "William Herschel Telescope" OR "William Herschel Telescopes" OR "WHT" OR "Isaac Newton Telescope" OR "Isaac Newton Telescopes" OR "INT telescope" OR "Jacobus Kapteyn Telescope" OR "Jacobus Kapteyn Telescopes" OR "JKT" OR "ING Wide Field Survey" OR "INT Wide Field Survey" OR "La Palma archive" OR "ING archive” OR "Wide Field Survey" OR "Isaac Newton Group (ING) Archive" OR "WFS archive" OR "ING@WFS" OR "INT WFS" OR "Isaac Newton Group" OR "IPHAS OR La Palma" OR "Canary Islands" OR "WFC@INT" OR "INT/WFC" Papers were manually searched for proofs of having used ING data. To some extent this assessment is subjective since it is not always clear what constitutes making use of data from our telescopes. In principal and in general a paper should make direct use of observations in order to qualify. Papers which refer to data presented in earlier papers (derivative papers) are not counted. For every paper the following information was recorded: author list, year of publication, title, journal name, volume, first page, nationality of first author’s institution, telescope used and instrument. If the data came from one of the ING data archives then this was recorded in the instrument field as follows: “archive” refers to the ING archive, “WFS” refers to the INT Wide-Field Survey archive, and “IPHAS” refers to the archive of the INT/WFC photometric Hα survey of the northern Galactic plane. If the observations were obtained as part of an ING service or override proposal, then this is shown as “service” or “O/R” respectively in the instrument field. Appendix A shows the bibliography compiled this way. Papers are sorted by year and telescope and in alphabetical order of the first author. Nationalities appear in brackets and instruments in parentheses. What follows is an analysis of this bibliography. Note that if a paper makes use of more than one telescope we count that paper for each telescope. Similarly, if a paper makes use of more than one instrument, that paper is counted against each instrument. ING Technical Note No. 134 “ING Bibliography and Analysis 2002-2011” - Page 3 2. Analysis. 2.1. Paper counts. Number of refereed papers per year from first light. Number of refereed papers per year. ING Technical Note No. 134 “ING Bibliography and Analysis 2002-2011” - Page 4 Number of refereed papers per year. Cumulative number of refereed published papers per year and telescope. ING Technical Note No. 134 “ING Bibliography and Analysis 2002-2011” - Page 5 Cumulative number of refereed papers per year from first light. Year WHT INT JKT Total Year WHT INT JKT Total 1984 — 1 — 1 2001 91 46 25 162 1985 — 10 3 13 2002 93 72 26 191 1986 — 24 8 32 2003 82 44 17 143 1987 — 36 16 52 2004 103 69 26 198 1988 5 52 12 69 2005 77 80 18 175 1989 15 58 15 88 2006 104 67 12 183 1990 37 54 26 117 2007 85 72 10 167 1991 39 63 19 121 2008 94 50 16 160 1992 42 56 25 123 2009 98 67 7 172 1993 55 70 30 155 2010 90 60 3 153 1994 78 63 44 185 2011 122 72 3 197 1995 90 81 29 200 Total 1924 1631 592 4147 1996 100 84 52 236 1997 113 77 35 225 1998 118 72 38 228 1999 115 78 46 239 Paper counts per telescope and year. ING Technical Note No. 134 “ING Bibliography and Analysis 2002-2011” - Page 6 2.2. Paper authorship. Nationality of first author's main institution in refereed papers that used data from the ING telescopes. Other nationalities contribute ~27% (1984-1997) and ~36% (1998-2011) to the total number of papers. 2.3. Paper instrument use. Use of instrument data in WHT's refereed papers (papers are counted as many times as used instruments). All private includes INTEGRAL. Archives means papers that use data retrieved from the ING Archive, and not included in the other categories. INGRID refers to when it was used without adaptive optics. NAOMI includes INGRID, OASIS and OSCA in combination with adaptive optics. ING Technical Note No. 134 “ING Bibliography and Analysis 2002-2011” - Page 7 Use of instrument data in INT's refereed papers (papers are counted as many times as used instruments). The archival papers mostly use data from the WFC. All private includes the private instruments. Other ING includes other common- user instruments not listed individually. 2.4. Paper count check. Paper counts by ING (blue) and retrieved from ADSLabs (red, http://labs.adsabs.harvard.edu/fulltext/) as a result of scanning the refereed journals listed below, and searching for a list of specific keywords: "William Herschel Telescope" OR "William Herschel Telescopes" OR "WHT". While the ING counts only include papers that make a direct use of the data, the ADS counts include all the papers that contain the searched keywords. The dashed line shows the ADS paper count but including all the refereed journals in the ADS database. ING Technical Note No. 134 “ING Bibliography and Analysis 2002-2011” - Page 8 Paper counts by ING (blue) and retrieved from ADSLabs (red, http://labs.adsabs.harvard.edu/fulltext/) as a result of scanning the refereed journals listed below, and searching for a list of specific keywords: "Isaac Newton Telescope" OR "Isaac Newton Telescopes" OR "INT telescope". While the ING counts only include papers that make a direct use of the data, the ADS counts include all the papers that contain the searched keywords. The dashed line shows