Fraserburgh & Peterhead to Aberdeen Strategic Transport Study Nestrans, Aberdeenshire Council, and Aberdeen City Council Part 1 Appraisal Report 77919 March 2016 FRASERBURGH & PETERHEAD TO ABERDEEN STRATEGIC TRANSPORT STUDY Description: Part 1 Appraisal Report Date: 21 March 2016 Project Manager: Emily Seaman Project Director: Bob Nicol Report Authors: Emily Seaman Chris Paterson Henry Collin Report Reviewers: Bob Nicol Dougie McDonald Paul McCartney Annie Say SIAS Limited 37 Manor Place Edinburgh EH3 7EB UK tel: 0131-225 7900 fax: 0131-225 9229
[email protected] www.sias.com \\coral\tpxneeng$\3 part 1 appraisal\3 reporting\77919 fraserburgh peterhead to aberdeen strategic transport study - part 1 appraisal report_revised_v2.doc FRASERBURGH & PETERHEAD TO ABERDEEN STRATEGIC TRANSPORT STUDY CONTENTS : Page SUMMARY 1 1 INTRODUCTION 41 1.1 Options for appraisal 45 1.2 Appraisal scoring 57 2 BACKGROUND INFORMATION 59 2.1 Geographical Context 59 2.2 Social Context 61 2.3 Economic Context 62 3 APPRAISAL OF OPTIONS AGAINST TRANSPORT PLANNING OBJECTIVES 67 3.1 Introduction 67 3.2 Option 1 69 3.3 Option 2 74 3.4 Option 3 79 3.5 Option 4 83 3.6 Option 5 87 3.7 Option 6 92 3.8 Option 7 97 3.9 TPO Appraisal Summary 103 4 APPRAISAL OF OPTIONS AGAINST THE STAG CRITERIA 105 4.1 Introduction 105 4.2 STAG Criteria Appraisal Methodology and Key Appraisal Points by Criteria 107 5 STAG APPRAISAL SUMMARY 113 5.1 Introduction 113 5.2 STAG Criteria Appraisal Overview 113 6 ESTABLISHED POLICY DIRECTIVES APPRAISAL 117 7 FEASIBILITY, AFFORDABILITY, AND PUBLIC ACCEPTABILITY