The Grand Game: a Celebration of Sherlockian Scholarship Volume Two: 1960–2010
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Grand Game: A Celebration of Sherlockian Scholarship Volume Two: 1960–2010 Edited by Laurie R. King, BSI and Leslie S. Klinger, BSI Order it at: www.bakerstreetjournal.com 408 pages, hardcover, January 2012 With more than 60 photographs & illustrations Editor Biographies LAURIE R. KING (“The Red Circle”) is the author of twenty-one novels, most of them crime fiction, many of them bestselling, award-winning, or both. Eleven of the stories (from 1994’s The Beekeeper’s Apprentice to the 2011 Pirate King ) feature Mary Russell, a young English-American orphan who meets Sherlock Holmes during the Great War, becoming his student, his partner, and very nearly his equal. Russell’s exploits have spawned a lesser version of The Game among her own readers, including a website (www.MaryRussellHolmes.com) and Twitter presence. Like Miss Russell, King’s background is theology, with a B.A. in Comparative Religion from the University of California, Santa Cruz, a Masters in Old Testament theology from Berkeley’s Graduate Theological Union, and an honorary doctorate from the Church Divinity School of the Pacific. Like Russell and Holmes, King travels a great deal – curiously enough, often to places later visited by her characters. She and Leslie Klinger are co-editing a collection of original Sherlock Holmes-inspired short stories called A Study in Sherlock , due out from Random House in October 2011. King’s own vast and ever-growing website may be explored at www.LaurieRKing.com. LESLIE S. KLINGER (“The Abbey Grange”) is the editor of the three-volume The New Annotated Sherlock Holmes , published by W.W. Norton in 2004 and 2005. He is also the editor of the ten- volume Sherlock Holmes Reference Library, aimed at the serious student of Sherlock Holmes. Klinger has written numerous books and articles on Sherlockiana and co-edited (with Andrew Jay Peck) the revised edition of The Date Being—?: A Compendium of Sherlockian Chronologies and (with S. E. Dahlinger) Sherlock Holmes, Conan Doyle & The Bookman: An Anthology of Literary Treasures (1895-1933) . He has taught several UCLA Extension courses on “Sherlock Holmes and His World” and is consulting with Warner Bros. on the film “Sherlock Holmes 2: A Game of Shadows,” due out in December 2011. He is also editing an anthology of Victorian detective stories for IDW Publishing. He has also written The New Annotated Dracula (2008) and numerous articles about Dracula and vampires and is editing an anthology of Victorian vampire stories for IDW Publishing. Klinger holds the Two-Shilling Award and several Editors’ Medals from The Baker www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 1 of 4 The Grand Game Volume Two Street Irregulars. He served as Series Editor for the BSI’s Manuscript Series and is currently Series Editor for the History Series. Table of Contents Publisher’s Preface MICHAEL F. WHELAN viii A Note on the Texts and Acknowledgements JOHN BERGQUIST xii Introduction LESLIE S. KLINGER 1 1960 The Curious Behavior of the Ritual in the Daytime POUL AND KAREN ANDERSON 5 1961 The Blue Enigma S. TUPPER BIGELOW 10 1962 Dr. John H. Watson at Netley (excerpt) ELLIOT KIMBALL 19 1962 Meeting in Montenegro: June 1891 WILLIAM S. BARING -GOULD 26 1962 Baker Street Finance A.M. ROBERTSON 31 1962 The Mews of Marylebone BERNARD DAVIES 40 1963 Lunatic Banker’s Royal Client — Dr. Watson Tries Semi-Fiction LORD DONEGALL 47 1963 The Unknown Watson H.B. WILLIAMS 52 1963 Where Was the ‘Bar of Gold’? ALAN WILSON 55 1964 Some Chemical Problems in the Canon DONALD A. REDMOND 58 1964 Seventeen Out of Twenty-Three HENRY T. FOLSOM 65 1966 The Jezail Bullet W.B. HEPBURN 68 1967 Conan Doyle’s Dying Detective WILLIAM OBER 70 1967 “I Have My Eye on a Suite in Baker Street” (excerpt) WILLIAM S. BARING -GOULD 76 1967 The Truth About Moriarty W.S. BRISTOWE 85 1967 Baskerville Hall ROGER LANCELYN GREEN 96 1968 Reflections on The Sign of Four , or, Oreamnosis Once Removed PERCY METCALFE 98 1969 Sherlock Holmes and the Railways B.D.J. WALSH 116 www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 2 of 4 The Grand Game Volume Two 1969 The Early Years of Sherlock Holmes TREVOR H. HALL 128 1970 A Tourist Guide to the London of Sherlock Holmes (excerpt) CHARLES O. MERRIMAN 142 1971 “Our Client’s Foot upon the Stair” JAMES EDWARD HOLROYD 147 1972 The Engineer’s Thumb D. MARTIN DAKIN 154 1972 Mr. Holmes Comes to Town MICHAEL HARRISON 157 1974 A Note on “The Five Orange Pips” IAN MCQUEEN 163 1975 The Guns of Sherlock Holmes SCOTT MCMILLAN AND GARRY JAMES 166 1975 Who Was Tonga? JULIA CARLSON ROSENBLATT 172 1976 The Case Against Mr. Holmes ANDREW G. FUSCO 174 1976 The Amoral Mr. Holmes BELDEN WIGGLESWORTH 184 1976 “The Matter Is a Perfectly Trivial One...” PETER E. BLAU 188 1976 Who Was Mrs. Turner? MICHAEL CLARK 193 1980 Who was Porlock DONALD ALAN WEBSTER 194 1980 The Commonplace Murder of Mary Sutherland HOWARD BRODY 196 1982 “Tra-la-la-lira-lira-lay” ROBERT E. ROBINSON 199 1983 Cornwall and the Devil’s Foot DAVID L. HAMMER 201 1984 The Priory School Map: A Re-Examination IRVING KAMIL 206 1985 The True Identity of Stapleton SHIN -ICHI KANTO 210 1987 Your Department, Watson? GRANT EUSTACE 215 1988 Ballarat Revisited ALAN OLDING 219 1988 The Secret Life of Mycroft Holmes STEVEN ROTHMAN 222 1988 A Suggested Two-Thirds of “The Missing Three-Quarter” MARSHALL S. BERDAN 226 1989 “It Is Horribly Contagious” ROBERT KATZ 231 1991 The Martha Myth WILLIAM HYDER 233 1991 Silver Blaze — A Corrected Identification WAYNE B. SWIFT 243 www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 3 of 4 The Grand Game Volume Two 1994 “I came to Baker-street by the Underground” ROGER JOHNSON 253 1994 The Polyphonic Motets of Lassus EDWARD R. STAUBACH 263 1995 Scandal And Reunion JUNE THOMSON 266 1996 “What Was the Month?” JOHN HALL 273 1996 The Odessa File — Sherlock Holmes and Imperial Russia WLADIMIR V. BOGOMOLETZ 278 1996 Headlines and Deadlines: How Sherlock Holmes Used the Press PETER CALAMAI 289 1997 The Boys in the (Speckled) Band CHRIS REDMOND 297 1998 Who Was Bruce-Partington? (excerpt) MICHAEL KEAN 302 1999 Operation Bruce-Partington REGGIE MUSGRAVE 308 2001 The Path of the Colonel’s Bullet LESLIE S. KLINGER 326 2002 A Vindication of Stapleton DONALD A. YATES 329 2003 “The Politician, The Lighthouse, and the Trained Cormorant” NICHOLAS UTECHIN 335 2005 A GLORious History ROSANE MCNAMARA 340 2006 A Norwegian Named Sigerson NILS NORDBERG 353 2006 Case Closed — The Long Island Cave Mystery Solved STEVEN T. DOYLE 361 2007 Watson’s War Wound LAURIE R. KING 373 2008 “Angels of Darkness” and A Study in Scarlet : Can They Both Be True? GREG DARAK 375 2009 Controversity Debate NICHOLAS UTECHIN AND GUY MARRIOTT 383 Sources 389 About BSI Publications The Baker Street Irregulars, the literary society focused on Sherlock Holmes and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, publishes the BSI Manuscript Series, the International Series, the History Series, The Baker Street Journal , and select non-series works. All of these can be ordered at our website: http://www.bakerstreetjournal.com www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 4 of 4 .