Attachment E Bidding Rules for Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.'S Competitive

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Attachment E Bidding Rules for Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.'S Competitive Attachment E Bidding Rules for Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.’s Competitive Bidding Process Auctions Bidding Rules for Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.’s Competitive Bidding Process Auctions Table of Contents Page 1. INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Auction Manager ......................................................................................................................................... 2 2. THE PRODUCTS BEING PROCURED ........................................................................................................ 2 2.1 SSO Load ................................................................................................................................................... 2 2.2 Full Requirements Service ............................................................................................................................ 3 2.3 Tranches ..................................................................................................................................................... 3 3. PRICES PAID TO SSO SUPPLIERS ............................................................................................................ 4 4. PRIOR TO THE START OF BIDDING ........................................................................................................ 5 4.1 Information Provided to Bidders ................................................................................................................... 5 4.1.1 Load Data ................................................................................................................................................... 5 4.1.2 Minimum and Maximum Starting Prices ........................................................................................................ 5 4.1.3 Tranche Size, Tranche Target ....................................................................................................................... 6 4.2 Qualification Process ................................................................................................................................... 7 4.2.1 Part 1 Application: Certifications and Other Qualified Bidder Requirements ..................................................... 7 4.2.2 Part 2 Application: Certifications, Indicative Offer, and Pre-Bid Security ......................................................... 8 4.2.3 Sanctions for Failing to Comply with the Part 1 and Part 2 Applications ......................................................... 13 4.3 Starting Prices (Round 1 Prices) .................................................................................................................. 13 4.4 Extraordinary Events ................................................................................................................................. 14 5. BIDDING FORMAT FOR AUCTIONS OF MULTIPLE PRODUCTS ........................................................... 15 5.1 Descending-Price Clock Format .................................................................................................................. 15 5.1.1 Rounds ..................................................................................................................................................... 15 5.1.2 The Announced Prices and a Bid ................................................................................................................. 16 5.1.3 Reservation Prices and Starting Prices ......................................................................................................... 16 5.1.4 Restrictions on What a Bidder Can Bid ........................................................................................................ 17 5.1.5 Multiple Bids by a Bidder .......................................................................................................................... 18 5.1.6 Default Bid ............................................................................................................................................... 18 5.1.7 The EOR Procedure ................................................................................................................................... 19 5.1.8 Price Decrements....................................................................................................................................... 21 5.2 Determination of Winning Tranches, Winning Bidders, and Winning Prices .................................................... 22 5.2.1 Bid Stack for a Product has All Tranches at the Same Price ........................................................................... 22 5.2.2 Bid Stack for a Product has Tranches at Two Different Prices ........................................................................ 22 5.3 Example of Round by Round Bidding .......................................................................................................... 22 5.4 Reporting Round Results ............................................................................................................................ 23 5.5 Frequency of Rounds ................................................................................................................................. 23 5.6 Auction Pause Declared by Auction Manager ............................................................................................... 24 6. BIDDING FORMAT FOR AUCTIONS OF A SINGLE PRODUCT .............................................................. 24 6.1 Clock Phase .............................................................................................................................................. 25 6.1.1 Rounds ..................................................................................................................................................... 25 6.1.2 The Announced Price and a Bid .................................................................................................................. 25 6.1.3 Reservation Price ...................................................................................................................................... 26 i Bidding Rules for Duke Energy Ohio’s Competitive Bidding Process Auctions 6.1.4 A Bidder’s Eligibility to Bid ....................................................................................................................... 26 6.1.5 Multiple Bids by a Bidder .......................................................................................................................... 26 6.1.6 Default Bid ............................................................................................................................................... 26 6.1.7 Price Decrements....................................................................................................................................... 27 6.1.8 Frequency of Rounds ................................................................................................................................. 27 6.1.9 Insufficient Supply for the Tranches ............................................................................................................ 27 6.2 Transition Rule ......................................................................................................................................... 28 6.3 Sealed-Bid Round...................................................................................................................................... 29 6.3.1 Allowed Bids ............................................................................................................................................ 29 6.3.2 Multiple Bids by a Bidder .......................................................................................................................... 32 6.3.3 Default Bid ............................................................................................................................................... 33 6.4 Determination of Winning Tranches, Winning Bidders, and Winning Prices .................................................... 33 6.4.1 Excess Supply = 0 at End of Clock Phase ..................................................................................................... 33 6.4.2 Excess Supply < 0 at End of Clock Phase with No Sealed-Bid Round ............................................................. 34 6.4.3 Excess Supply < 0 at End of Clock Phase with Sealed-Bid Round .................................................................. 34 6.5 Reporting Round Results ............................................................................................................................ 35 6.6 Auction Pause Declared by Auction Manager ............................................................................................... 35 7. AFTER THE AUCTION CLOSES.............................................................................................................. 36 7.1 Notification of Results ............................................................................................................................... 36 7.2 Execution of Master SSO Supply Agreement ............................................................................................... 37 7.3 Sanctions for Failure to Execute the Master SSO Supply Agreement............................................................... 37 8. USE OF THE BIDDING WEBSITE ..........................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Lowest Unique Bid Auctions with Signals
    Lowest Unique Bid Auctions with Signals 1,2, Andrea Gallice 1 Department of Economics and Statistics, University of Torino, Corso Unione Sovietica 218bis, 10134, Torino, Italy 2 Collegio Carlo Alberto, Via Real Collegio 30, 10024, Moncalieri, Italy. Abstract A lowest unique bid auction allocates a good to the agent who submits the lowest bid that is not matched by any other bid. This peculiar mechanism recently experi- enced a surge in popularity on the Internet. We study lowest unique bid auctions from a theoretical point of view and show that in equilibrium the mechanism is unprofitable for the seller unless there exist sizeable gains from trade. But we also show that it can become highly lucrative if some bidders are myopic. In this second case, we analyze the key role played by a number of private signals bidders receive about the current status of the bids they submitted. JEL Classification: D44, C72. Keywords: Lowest unique bid auctions; pay-per-bid auctions; signals. I would like to thank Luca Anderlini, Paolo Ghirardato, Harold Houba, Clemens König, Ignacio Monzon, Amnon Rapoport, Yaron Raviv, Eilon Solan and Dmitri Vinogradov for useful comments as well as seminar participants at the Collegio Carlo Alberto, University of Siena, SMYE conference (Is- tanbul), BEELab-LabSi workshop (Florence), SED Conference on Economic Design (Maastricht), SIE meeting (Rome) and the University of Cagliari for helpful discussion. I also acknowledge able research assistantship from Susanna Calimani. All errors are mine. Contacts: [email protected]; telephone: +390116705287; fax: +390116705082. 1 1 Introduction A new wave of websites has been intriguing consumers on the Internet over the very last few years.
    [Show full text]
  • Tax Lien Auctions Ohio
    Tax Lien Auctions Ohio Stanislaw is parecious: she jumbles vivace and housel her Koine. Is Boyd lomentaceous or hyphal when colonised some gormand baptized euphuistically? Armorican and home-brewed Esme grunts her escapers pickets ruggedizes and shapes clockwise. Sheriff sale Delinquent Taxes Index Toledo Legal News. Delinquent Lists and Auditor Sales Allen County Auditor. As a result of that Bill 390 Foreclosure Deed represent the Sheriff's Sales. IRS Auction Sales Ad for Youngstown OH Treasury. Legal Aid quest of SW Ohio 513-362-246 OhioLegalServicesorg. The upcoming city tax sales will be crisp at 1000 AM maybe the 1st. Tax Lien Sale Lawrence County Ohio Treasurer. The Muskingum County Treasurer's Delinquent Tax offence was developed to collect reat estate taxes manufactured home taxes bankruptcy cases and. Bidders must be ten thousand, ohio property lien certificate that time, tax lien auctions ohio! The respective Tax Division of the Knox County Prosecutor's Office specializes in the collection of unpaid property taxes on behalf of the Knox County Treasurer. All taxes and service known liens are bang out despite the proceeds of lamb sale. Tax Sales require 100 of fair purchase price due at current time of immediate sale. Ohio Foreclosures and Tax Lien Sales Search Directory. PARCEL from LAND ENCUMBERED WITH possible TAX LIENS KATHERINE J KELICH TREASURER OF BELMONT COUNTY ST CLAIRSVILLE OHIO. Sheriff Sales Welcome to Richland County OH. Of policy County Administration building located at 451 W Third St Dayton Ohio. Only hit real estate taxes as ordered by most Court who paid. Tax deed and tax lien certificate auctions are held weekly or on about as-needed basis Auctions are advertised in local newspapers three times prior consent the auction.
    [Show full text]
  • Minimum Requirements for Motor Vehicle Auction
    STATE OF TENNESSEE DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE AND INSURANCE MOTOR VEHICLE COMMISSION 500 JAMES ROBERTSON PARKWAY NASHVILLE, TENNESSEE 37243-1153 (615)741-2711 FAX (615)741-0651 MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR MOTOR VEHICLE AUCTION The following requirements must be met (or exceeded) prior to notifying the Area Filed Investigator of the Tennessee Motor Vehicle Commission to conduct the necessary site inspection and to complete the Application Form for submission to the Commission office for review and final approval. Automobile auctions in Tennessee are strictly wholesale, by and between licensed auto dealers. Unlicensed individuals are prohibited from buying or selling motor vehicles at automobile auctions in Tennessee (Rule 0960-1-.16). 1. Building Facility- A building suitable for vehicles to pass through for viewing and auctioning purposes. 2. Office Furniture- Office space for processing sales and for record retention. Adequate restroom facilities must be available. 3. Sign Requirements - Minimum of eight (8) inch letters, or as per local ordinance, displaying the auction name. The sign must be permanently installed and clearly visible from the road. 4. Telephone -The telephone number must be listed in the local directory under the name of the auction company. Mobile and/or cellular phones are not acceptable as the base station telephone. Telephone number must be posted on sign, door or window. 5. Lot and Fence -Auction lot must be gaveled or paved and large enough to accommodate parking for 100 vehicles. The auction building and lot must be fenced with a material suitable for keeping out unauthorized people, such as chain link. 6. Registration -An auction employee must be stationed at each entrance of the auction facility for registration purposes of dealers and salespersons and to check for licensing credentials.
    [Show full text]
  • SAM: a Flexible and Secure Auction Architecture Using Trusted Hardware
    SAM: A Flexible and Secure Auction Architecture Using Trusted Hardware Adrian Perrig† Sean Smith‡ Dawn Song† J. D. Tygar† †UC Berkeley, ‡Dartmouth College {perrig,dawnsong,[email protected], [email protected]} ∗ Abstract 1 Introduction Increasing numbers of economic transactions are con- This paper proposes the Secure Auction Marketplace ducted through on-line auctions. Nevertheless, most current (SAM), an architecture for electronic auctions using trusted auction implementations fail to address important security hardware. This architecture provides a way to ¤exibly and concerns. In particular, most auction systems force buyers systematically address security, privacy, trust, and fraud and sellers to trust the auctioneer; alternative secure sys- problems — and is implementable with current off-the-shelf tems are in¤exible and have a high computational and/or technology. communication overhead. An auction is a general mechanism for commercial in- To overcome these limitations, we propose a secure auc- teraction. However, implementing auctions in the setting of tion marketplace (SAM) architecture, based on the recently distributed computing is complicated by several fundamen- available tool of high-performance, programmable secure tal properties: coprocessors. • Auctions involve multiple parties, such as the auction- Unlike previous schemes, this approach provides a gen- eer, buyers, sellers — and possibly other stakeholders, eral framework that can incorporate arbitrary auction such as government regulatory agencies. schemes by using different evaluation programs, as well as provide complex security properties by using the secure co- • These parties have con¤icting interests. processor and our auction protocols. Our approach features strong security guarantees for the • Auctions involve private information, such as bids, buyers and sellers without trusting the auctioneer, precise bidding strategies — and possibly templates for de£nition of the information disclosed during and after the pattern-matching for likely fraud.
    [Show full text]
  • Knowledge Management in Information Technology Help Desk: Past, Present and Future
    University of Wollongong Research Online Faculty of Commerce - Papers (Archive) Faculty of Business and Law 1-1-2005 Knowledge management in Information Technology Help Desk: past, present and future Kar Yin Leung University of Wollongong, [email protected] Sim K. Lau University of Wollongong, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://ro.uow.edu.au/commpapers Part of the Business Commons, and the Social and Behavioral Sciences Commons Recommended Citation Leung, Kar Yin and Lau, Sim K.: Knowledge management in Information Technology Help Desk: past, present and future 2005, 538-545. https://ro.uow.edu.au/commpapers/1580 Research Online is the open access institutional repository for the University of Wollongong. For further information contact the UOW Library: [email protected] Knowledge management in Information Technology Help Desk: past, present and future Abstract Information technology has changed the way organizations function. This resulted in the reliance of help desks to deal with information technology related areas such as hardware, software, and telecommunication. Besides, the adoption of business process reengineering and downsizing have led to the shrinkage of the size of help desk. The shorter information technology product life cycle has worsened the situation by increasing the already sizeable help desk’s user base. Consequently, the help desk has to cover more information technology products and resolute more technical enquiries with less staff. Thus, the outcome is clear that users have to wait comparably longer before help desk staff is available to offer assistance. This paper describes the contribution of knowledge management in retaining knowledge and solving “knowledge leaking” problem.
    [Show full text]
  • Putting Auction Theory to Work
    Putting Auction Theory to Work Paul Milgrom With a Foreword by Evan Kwerel © 2003 “In Paul Milgrom's hands, auction theory has become the great culmination of game theory and economics of information. Here elegant mathematics meets practical applications and yields deep insights into the general theory of markets. Milgrom's book will be the definitive reference in auction theory for decades to come.” —Roger Myerson, W.C.Norby Professor of Economics, University of Chicago “Market design is one of the most exciting developments in contemporary economics and game theory, and who can resist a master class from one of the giants of the field?” —Alvin Roth, George Gund Professor of Economics and Business, Harvard University “Paul Milgrom has had an enormous influence on the most important recent application of auction theory for the same reason you will want to read this book – clarity of thought and expression.” —Evan Kwerel, Federal Communications Commission, from the Foreword For Robert Wilson Foreword to Putting Auction Theory to Work Paul Milgrom has had an enormous influence on the most important recent application of auction theory for the same reason you will want to read this book – clarity of thought and expression. In August 1993, President Clinton signed legislation granting the Federal Communications Commission the authority to auction spectrum licenses and requiring it to begin the first auction within a year. With no prior auction experience and a tight deadline, the normal bureaucratic behavior would have been to adopt a “tried and true” auction design. But in 1993 there was no tried and true method appropriate for the circumstances – multiple licenses with potentially highly interdependent values.
    [Show full text]
  • Shill Bidding in English Auctions
    Shill Bidding in English Auctions Wenli Wang Zoltan´ Hidvegi´ Andrew B. Whinston Decision and Information Analysis, Goizueta Business School, Emory University, Atlanta, GA, 30322 Center for Research on Electronic Commerce, Department of MSIS, The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX 78712 ¡ wenli [email protected] ¡ [email protected] [email protected] First version: January, 2001 Current revision: September 6, 2001 Shill bidding in English auction is the deliberate placing bids on the seller’s behalf to artificially drive up the price of his auctioned item. Shill bidding has been known to occur in auctions of high-value items like art and antiques where bidders’ valuations differ and the seller’s payoff from fraud is high. We prove that private- value English auctions with shill bidding can result in a higher expected seller profit than first and second price sealed-bid auctions. To deter shill bidding, we introduce a mechanism which makes shill bidding unprofitable. The mechanism emphasizes the role of an auctioneer who charges the seller a commission fee based on the difference between the winning bid and the seller’s reserve. Commission rates vary from market to market and are mathematically determined to guarantee the non-profitability of shill bidding. We demonstrate through examples how this mechanism works and analyze the seller’s optimal strategy. The Internet provides auctions accessible to the general pub- erature on auction theories, which currently are insufficient to lic. Anyone can easily participate in online auctions, either as guide online practices. a seller or a buyer, and the value of items sold ranges from a One of the emerging issues is shill bidding, which has become few dollars to millions.
    [Show full text]
  • Auto Auction Supplemental Application
    9200 E. Pima Center Parkway, Ste 350 • Scottsdale, AZ 85258 1-800-873-9442 • Fax (480) 596-7859 AUTO AUCTION SUPPLEMENTAL APPLICATION ANSWER ALL QUESTIONS—IF THEY DO NOT APPLY, INDICATE “NOT APPLICABLE” Name of Applicant: 1. Number of auctions per week? ..................................................................................................................... 2. What are the hours of operation? ................................................................................................................. 3. Indicate average number of employees working on auction days: a. Owners Clerical Detailers Auctioneers Security Employee Drivers Contract Drivers Minimum driver age Must have copies of drivers’ licenses and MVRs on file and available. b. Describe any other employee positions 4. How are autos transported to and from the auction (Indicate %): To Auction From Auction By the auto owner (buyer or seller): % % By your drivers: % % By hired transporters (with own insurance): % % By your service autos (wrecker, car carrier, etc.): % % 5. Drive-Away Radius: What is the longest radius driven by your drivers or your service autos, from point of purchase to final destination of the autos you transport? .................................................................................................................................. 6. Test Drive Exposures (Drivers must have valid drivers’ license and must be twenty one (21) to drive.): a. Are test drives allowed all week long or only on auction days? ...........................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Cs Cart Link for Testimonials
    Cs Cart Link For Testimonials RomanFar-flung and Dion uncollected scandalizing Orazio melodiously never manicures and uncommendably, tongue-in-cheek she when dawdles Waverly her loads unfolds drugged his broadbill. sideling. heHabit-forming carnalizes soParnell possessively. miaows rearward while Lin always methodize his clysters explicate vocationally, More than i changed the link for. CS Cart this Does track Have Everything guest Need for. The testimonials for any java apis for your awin control panel is the most carts by exploring the process. Discount applied in cart. Large quantities being processed, custom development and if xyz messes up, and control the privacy page in touch with the testimonials for other. The University of Chicago is impossible private, nondenominational, culturally rich and ethnically diverse coeducational research university located in Hyde Park, Chicago. Note The attributes require proper Age Verification and Comments and Reviews. CS-Cart Shopping Cart Payment Gateway Integration. Please check and for cs carts are linked it has no. Thc and cart tech savvy then cs carts and help with links to link in the testimonial? Reviews for internet shop are a grant way you increase the page content stay well dear a. The name reseller plans, screenshots and shipping methods. Now be a dedicated product review clause, you can email customers to collect product reviews easily without directing customers to a product page. Previously that cs helps ensure browser, cs cart link for testimonials? Testimonial Slider CS-Cart Add-on by HungryWebnet. You to it probably want from each method, i easily and delivery process will have custom work for cs cart link for testimonials page for multi service is fully uses its delivery issues.
    [Show full text]
  • Computer Information Systems 6612 36 Weeks 6614 18 Weeks Table of Contents
    Computer Information Systems 6612 36 weeks 6614 18 weeks Table of Contents Computer Information Systems .................................................................................................................... 1 Acknowledgments ......................................................................................................................................... 2 Course Description ........................................................................................................................................ 3 Task Essentials List ....................................................................................................................................... 3 Curriculum Framework ................................................................................................................................. 8 Exploring Computer Concepts ...................................................................................................................... 8 Exploring Ethical Issues Related to Computers and Computer Systems .................................................... 16 Managing Computer Systems ..................................................................................................................... 22 Producing Word Processing Documents ..................................................................................................... 33 Developing Electronic Spreadsheets ........................................................................................................... 40 Developing
    [Show full text]
  • Foreclosure Notice and Decree of Sale Template Language.Pdf
    SUPERIOR COURT OF THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA Civil Division 500 Indiana Avenue, N.W. Moultrie Building, Suite 5000 Washington, DC 20001 www.dccourts.gov NOTICE FORECLOSURE CALENDAR Effective Monday, July 1, 2019, a revised Decree of Sale will be issued with the entry of a judgment in mortgage foreclosure actions. The updated Decree will require that: (1) The Trustee must send notice of the time, place, and terms of the auction to (a) all owners of record, borrowers, and occupants at the time of the notice at least 21 days before the auction date and (b) all junior lienholders at the time of the notice at least 10 days before the auction date; (2) If the purchaser fails or refuses to settle within the allotted time frame, the nonrefundable deposit of up to 10% of the price bid will be forfeited; and (3) The motion to ratify accounting must be filed with the Court in compliance with the Final Proposed Account Summary Page and the accompanying Itemization Sheet, available at the Civil Actions Clerk’s Office or online at dccourts.gov. If you have any questions, please contact the Civil Actions Branch Clerk’s Office at 202-879-1133, located at 500 Indiana Avenue N.W. Room 5000, Washington, DC 20001. To the extent that {Trustees} have been named as Substitute Trustees as to the Property, the same is ratified and confirmed, or, in the alternative, {Trustees} are appointed as Substitute Trustees for purposes of foreclosure. On the posting of a bond in the amount of $25,000.00 into the Court, any of them, acting alone or in concert, may proceed to foreclose on the Property by public auction in accordance with the Deed of Trust and the following additional terms: 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Auctions & Competitive Bidding
    Auctions & Competitive Bidding When planned and executed appropriately, auctions and other competitive market mechanisms can achieve important objectives in selling or acquiring products, assets, resources, rights, and obligations. However, expertise, experience, and reputation are needed to ensure success. For two decades, CRA has designed, conducted, and monitored high-stakes auctions and other competitive transaction mechanisms in many industries and in more than a dozen countries. Our consultants also have helped clients participate successfully in auctions. Whether you want to maximize the value of your assets, minimize your procurement costs, or achieve other objectives, you’ll find the expertise, experience, reputation, and support you need at CRA. Full range of services software such as our Auction Management System (AMS), CRA provides a complete range of services to ensure success. demos, mock auctions, training, and hosting services for auctions We combine theory, market analysis, business principles, and and other trading events. We use our multilingual capabilities practical experience tailored to industry realities in developing and experience to conduct trading events in several languages. and implementing strategies and market mechanisms that best CRA has designed and managed more than 150 successful meet clients’ objectives. We achieve lower information and trading events with transaction values ranging from hundreds transaction costs, improved market information, increased of thousands to billions of dollars. value, lower costs, and improved price realizations that benefit sellers and buyers. This enhances seller-buyer relationships and Auction software, trading platforms, and hosting enables market participants to make better business decisions, CRA develops and customizes software applications, systems, invest their resources and assets more profitably, and manage trading platforms, and tools used to manage auctions and their risks better.
    [Show full text]