Luca Signorelli's Veturia Persuading Coriolanus to Spare Rome

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Luca Signorelli's Veturia Persuading Coriolanus to Spare Rome chapter 4 Luca Signorelli’s Veturia Persuading Coriolanus to Spare Rome and Viewers in the Palazzo Petrucci, Siena Stephanie C. Leone Introduction: Methodology and Renaissance Domestic Painting With a focus on the fresco Veturia Persuading Coriolanus to Spare Rome (c. 1509–11), attributed to Luca Signorelli, this essay investigates the multiple responses of viewers to depictions of ancient Roman history and the impact of gender on spectatorship of Renaissance domestic art. Now detached from its original context, the painting was once part of a decorative ensemble in the so-called camera bella of the Palazzo Petrucci in Siena.1 The full ensemble comprised eight narrative wall paintings from ancient history, literature, and mythology attributed to Pinturicchio, Luca Signorelli, and Girolamo Genga; carved woodwork pilasters between the narrative scenes, with a carved wood- work cornice above and benches below; an all’antica stucco-framework ceiling with frescoed panels of ancient gods, goddesses and heroes by Pinturicchio; and a majolica tile floor. This reception room appears to have been decorated for the 1511 marriage between Borghese Petrucci (1490–1526) and Vittoria Todeschini Piccolomini (1494–1570).2 No satisfactory programmatic meaning * I wish to thank Cristelle Baskins, Elizabeth Mellyn, Vernon Hyde Minor, Sarah Gwenyth Ross, and editors Alison Poe and Marice Rose for their insightful suggestions that have improved my essay. I am also grateful for the helpful comments of the participants in the Radical Readings Workshop, organized by Virginia Reinburg and Sarah Gwenyth Ross at Boston College in May 2013. 1 The history of and bibliography on the painting is available in Tom Henry and Laurence B. Kanter, Luca Signorelli: The Complete Paintings (London: Thames and Hudson, 2002), 224–5. It was detached by 1876, and now resides in the National Gallery, London, inv. no. NG3929. 2 In most sources the date of marriage is given as 1509, as recorded by the contemporary historian Sigismondo Tizio (Historiarum Senensium ab initio urbis Senarum usque ad annum 1528, pub- lished as Historiae senenses [Rome: Istituto storico italiano per l’età moderna e contemporanea, 1992], vii, 152) and repeated by such early historians as G.A. Pecci, Memorie storico-critiche della città di Siena che servono alla vita civile di Pandolfo Petrucci (Siena: 1755), 241–2. The marriage contract, however, is dated 1511; see “Agnese Farnese,” Dizionario biografico degli italiani, 1995, http://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/agnese-farnese_%28Dizionario-Biografico%29/; © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, 2015 | doi 10.1163/9789004289697_006 <UN> 132 Leone has been discerned for the complex iconography of the paintings, a problem exacerbated by the dismantling of the room. Rather than pursuing the positiv- ist aim of decoding a single programmatic meaning as intended by artist and patron, I am interested in the concept of Norman Bryson, Michael Ann Holly, and Keith Moxey in Visual Culture: Images and Interpretations (1994): how a work of art “… actively engages in organizing and structuring the social and cultural environment in which it was located.”3 Reception theory and recent studies of Renaissance domestic art offer an alternative model of interpreta- tion by privileging the responses of original viewers as conditioned by indi- vidual predispositions and preconceptions. In this essay I analyze one scene from the camera bella—the Roman matron Veturia’s intercession to save Rome from the attack of her son, Coriolanus (Fig. 4.1)—to test the value of investigat- ing the responses of sixteenth-century viewers as a means of understanding how the work of art interacts with its original socio-cultural context. Since Hans Robert Jauss coined the phrase Rezeptionsästhetik in 1967, there has been much discussion about the uses, interpretations, and adaptations of reception theory in his field of literature and in other disciplines. Across the debate, however, it is generally agreed that the “point of reception,” that is, the subjectivity of the reader, plays an essential and active role in the process of making meaning, and that as a result, meaning is not fixed and stable but rather changeable, mediated, and contingent.4 Stanley Fish has expanded the reader-response discourse by addressing the differences among readers and and Konrad Eisenbichler, The Sword and the Pen: Women, Politics, and Poetry in Sixteenth- Century Siena (Notre Dame, in: University of Notre Dame Press, 2012), 59. 3 Norman Bryson, Michael Ann Holly, and Keith Moxey, “Introduction,” in Visual Culture: Images and Interpretations, ed. Bryson, Holly, and Moxey (Middletown, ct: Wesleyan University Press, 1994), xviii. The editors argue against a work of art as a simple mirror of its culture in which the context serves as a mere background to the work of art and instead seek to interpret the object as fully integrated into its socio-cultural context. Moxey, “Hieronymus Bosch and the ‘World Upside Down’,” in Bryson, Holly, and Moxey, Visual Culture: Images and Interpretations, 104–40, offers an instructive example in his essay on Bosch’s Garden of Earthly Delights. Rather than trying to identify and interpret symbols in the painting, as scholars have done since Erwin Panofsky, Moxey argues that Bosch used the notion of “world upside down,” represented through inverting the natural scale and order of things, to satirize the very class of people, the aristocracy, for whom he worked. As such, Bosch sought to demon- strate his inimitable genius as an appeal to patrons in this educated and wealthy milieu. 4 Charles Martindale, “Introduction,” in Classics and the Uses of Reception, ed. Martindale and Richard F. Thomas (Malden, ma: Blackwell Publishing, 2006), 1–13; William W. Batstone, “Provocation: The Point of Reception Theory,” in Martindale and Thomas, Classics and the Uses of Reception, 14–20. <UN>.
Recommended publications
  • Visual Exegesis and Eschatology in the Sistine Chapel
    TYPOLOGY AT ITS LIMITS: VISUAL EXEGESIS AND ESCHATOLOGY IN THE SISTINE CHAPEL Giovanni Careri Typology is a central device in the Sistine chapel frescoes of the fifteenth century where it works, in a quite canonical way, as a model of histori- cal temporality with strong institutional effects. In the frescoes by Luca Signorelli and Bartolomeo della Gatta representing various episodes from the life of Moses, including his death, every gesture and action of Moses is an announcement – a figura – of Jesus Christ’s institutional accomplish- ments represented on the opposite wall [Fig. 1]. Some of these devices operate on a figural level rather than in mere iconographical terms; the death of Moses, for instance, is a Pathosformel: the leader of the Israelites dies in the pose of the dead body of Christ, while his attendants adum- brate the Lamentation of Christ. Here, the attitude of the defunct Moses is ‘intensified’ by the return of the pathetic formula embodied by Christ’s Fig. 1. Luca Signorelli and Bartolomeo della Gatta, Last Acts and Death of Moses (1480–1482). Oil on panel, 21.6 × 48 cm. Vatican City, Sistine Chapel. 74 giovanni careri corpse, that is, by the paradoxical return of the figure who is prefigured by Moses himself. As Leopold Ettlinger extensively showed, the main ideological purpose of the Quattrocento cycle is to support and incontrovertibly to adduce papal primacy.1 Nevertheless, if we look at these frescoes from an anthro- pological point of view, we are compelled to observe the extent to which they appropriate the history of the ‘Other’ – in this case the history of the Jews – entirely transforming it into a sort of prophetical premise for Christian history itself.
    [Show full text]
  • Patronage and Dynasty
    PATRONAGE AND DYNASTY Habent sua fata libelli SIXTEENTH CENTURY ESSAYS & STUDIES SERIES General Editor MICHAEL WOLFE Pennsylvania State University–Altoona EDITORIAL BOARD OF SIXTEENTH CENTURY ESSAYS & STUDIES ELAINE BEILIN HELEN NADER Framingham State College University of Arizona MIRIAM U. CHRISMAN CHARLES G. NAUERT University of Massachusetts, Emerita University of Missouri, Emeritus BARBARA B. DIEFENDORF MAX REINHART Boston University University of Georgia PAULA FINDLEN SHERYL E. REISS Stanford University Cornell University SCOTT H. HENDRIX ROBERT V. SCHNUCKER Princeton Theological Seminary Truman State University, Emeritus JANE CAMPBELL HUTCHISON NICHOLAS TERPSTRA University of Wisconsin–Madison University of Toronto ROBERT M. KINGDON MARGO TODD University of Wisconsin, Emeritus University of Pennsylvania MARY B. MCKINLEY MERRY WIESNER-HANKS University of Virginia University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee Copyright 2007 by Truman State University Press, Kirksville, Missouri All rights reserved. Published 2007. Sixteenth Century Essays & Studies Series, volume 77 tsup.truman.edu Cover illustration: Melozzo da Forlì, The Founding of the Vatican Library: Sixtus IV and Members of His Family with Bartolomeo Platina, 1477–78. Formerly in the Vatican Library, now Vatican City, Pinacoteca Vaticana. Photo courtesy of the Pinacoteca Vaticana. Cover and title page design: Shaun Hoffeditz Type: Perpetua, Adobe Systems Inc, The Monotype Corp. Printed by Thomson-Shore, Dexter, Michigan USA Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Patronage and dynasty : the rise of the della Rovere in Renaissance Italy / edited by Ian F. Verstegen. p. cm. — (Sixteenth century essays & studies ; v. 77) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN-13: 978-1-931112-60-4 (alk. paper) ISBN-10: 1-931112-60-6 (alk. paper) 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Disapproving Renaissance Blasphemous Fake News – La Voce Di New York
    Disapproving Renaissance Blasphemous Fake News – La Voce di N... http://www.lavocedinewyork.com/en/arts/2017/07/19/disapproving-... Sections Close DONA VNY PROUD Arts Commenta per primoShared: 55!"#$%& Disapproving Renaissance Blasphemous Fake News The exhibition of 33 Renaissance Artworks: "Pinturicchio, the Borgia’s Painter: Unveiling the Mystery Concerning Giulia Farnese" by Lucy Gordan Jul 19 2017 Utilizziamo i cookie per offrirti servizi e informazioni in linea con le tue preferenze. Continuando a scorrere e a navigare ne consenti l'uso. OK Maggiori informazioni 1 of 10 10/12/17, 11:28 AM Disapproving Renaissance Blasphemous Fake News – La Voce di N... http://www.lavocedinewyork.com/en/arts/2017/07/19/disapproving-... The exhibition is on in Rome's Capitoline Museums until September 10th and it shows the story of the painter Bernardino di Betto, nicknamed “Pinturicchio.” Between 1492 and 1494, he decorated a suite of rooms in the Apostolic Palace for the apartments of the controversial Pope Alexander VI. Bernardino di Betto Betti, nicknamed “Pinturicchio” (1452-1513) October 12, 1492 is one of the first dates that American school children learn. It marks the date that explorer/navigator Christopher Columbus (c. 1451-1506) landed on one of the islands (which is still unknown) in the Bahamas and “discovered” America. The year 1492 is also important to Italy because Columbus was born and grew up in Genoa and to Spain because King Ferdinand and his wife Queen Isabella of Spain subsidized Christopher Columbus voyage intended to be a search for a new route to India and because another famous but unscrupulous Spaniard Rodrigo de Borgia, a well-known womanizer, already the father of seven children, was elected Pope Alexander VI.
    [Show full text]
  • Comunicato Stampa Inglese
    PRESS RELEASE For the first time in Rome, at the Musei Capitolini Luca Signorelli and Rome. Oblivion and rediscovery From 19th July to 3rd November 2019 at Palazzo Caffarelli, a celebration of one of the greatest stars of the Italian Renaissance Rome, 18th July 2019 - as the 500th anniversary of the death of Raphael draws near, the Musei Capitolini pays tribute to Luca Signorelli (Cortona, around 1450 - 1523) in the rooms of the Palazzo Caffarelli with the exhibition, Luca Signorelli and Rome . Oblivion and rediscovery . For the first time in Rome , this is a celebration of one of the Italian Renaissance’s leading lightsHis remarkable artistic star was obscured only by the unforeseeable arrival of two giants of the following generation: Michelangelo (1475-1564) and Raphael (1483-1520), who were, however, inspired by the master of Cortona to reach the unsurpassed pinnacle of painting that their contemporaries attribute to them. In fact, as Giorgio Vasari wrote, Luca Signorelli “ was more famous in his day, and his works were held in higher esteem, than any other previous artist no matter the period ”. The exhibition, curated by Federica Papi and Claudio Parisi Presicce , is supported by Roma Capitale, Assessorato alla Crescita culturale - Sovrintendenza Capitolina ai Beni Culturali , and organised by Zètema Progetto Cultura. The catalogue is edited by De Luca Editori d’Arte. Showing a careful selection of around 60 prestigious works from Italian and foreign collections, many of which are exhibited for the first time in Rome , the exhibition highlights the historical artistic context in which the artist made his first visit to Rome and offers new interpretations on the artist’s direct and indirect ties with Rome .
    [Show full text]
  • On the Exhibition Policies for Raphael's Masterpieces
    Renaissance 3/2015 - 1 /lessandra Galiz6i Kroegel “3a.e space #or the great Raphael9& :n the ;*hibition Policies #or Raphael1s 3asterpieces Fig. 1= >iew of the current installation of the 2istine 3adonna in the +emäldegalerie /lte 3eister ?resden @0erbert -oswan., ?resden, 2taatliche 8unstsammlungen ?resdenA. “Raphael, or Ingres, or Picasso are meant Raphael in German and Italian museums during to be meditated upon. !" In order to med- the nineteenth centur) and up to the #irst hal# o# itate on a painting, it is essential to present the t%entieth century.[2] ,his stud) %as inspired it in a #avorable location and %ithin a calm b) (laudia -rin. and /ndreas 0enning1s care#ul atmosphere.& reconstruction o# the various hangings o# the 'e (orbusier[1] 2istine 3adonna #rom 1455, %hen the altarpiece arrived in 2a*on) a#ter its removal #rom the In this essa) I %ill discuss the e*hibition policies church o# 2an 2isto in Piacenza, to the present that %ere developed #or a #e% altarpieces b) day in its current location in the Gem7ldegalerie /lessandra +ali66i 8roegel 3a.e space #or the great Raphael9 .unstte*te.de 3/2015 - 2 <ig. 2= /dol# von 3en6el, Plat6 #Br den groβen Raf#ael9, Raphael in ?resden 1D55/5E, +ouache and pastel on paper, 5F * F2 cm, +er- manisches Gationalmuseum Gurnberg, 'oan o# the cit) of Gurnberg, @3oni.a Runge, +ermanisches Gationalmuseum “3ake space #or the great Raphael9&= a #amous Gurnberg). gouache b) /dolph 3en6el bearing this title (1D55/1D5EA @#ig. 2A illustrates an anecdote %hich ma) have circulated at the court o# 2a*on) #rom /lte 3eister in ?resden, %here it is e*hibited as the middle o# the eighteenth century, and %hich the clima* o# the %estern %ing1s stunning en#i- became %ell-.no%n not onl) in +erman) but to lade o# Italian galleries @#ig.
    [Show full text]
  • Santa Maria Del Popolo Piazza Del Popolo Metro Station: Flaminio, Line a 7 AM – 12 PM (Closed Sunday) 4 PM – 7 PM (Closed Sunday)
    Santa Maria del Popolo Piazza del Popolo Metro station: Flaminio, line A 7 AM – 12 PM (Closed Sunday) 4 PM – 7 PM (Closed Sunday) Sculpture of Habakkuk and the Angel by Bernini (after 1652) in the Chigi Chapel Crucifixion of St. Peter (1600-01) by Caravaggio in the Cerasi Chapel. Baroque facade added by Bernini in 1600 Standing on the Piazza del Popolo, near the northern gate of the Aurelian Wall, the Basilica of Santa Maria del Popolo is a small temple with a splendid Renaissance decoration in its interior. In its interior Santa Maria del Popolo’s decoration is unlike any other church in Rome. The ceiling, less high than most built during the same period, is practically bare, while the decoration of each of the small chapels is especially remarkable. Among the beautiful art work found in the church, it is worth highlighting the Chapel Cerasi, which houses two canvases by Caravaggio from 1600, and the Chapel Chigi, built and decorated by Raphael. If you look closely at the wooden benches, you’ll be able to see inscriptions with the names of the people the benches are dedicated to. This custom is also found in a lot of English speaking countries like Scotland or Edinburgh, where the families of the person deceased buy urban furniture in their honour. ******************************************** Located next to the northern gate of Rome on the elegant Piazza del Popolo, the 15th-century Santa Maria del Popolo is famed for its wealth of Renaissance art. Its walls and ceilings are decorated with paintings by some of the greatest artists ever to work in Rome: Pinturicchio, Raphael, Carracci, Caravaggio and Bernini.
    [Show full text]
  • Christian Mysteries of the Italian Renaissance
    xiii 49. Botticelli, Castello Annunciation, Galleria degli Uffizi, Florence .................... 158 50. Alessio Baldovinetti, Annunciation, Galleria degli Uffizi, Florence ................. 159 51. Francesco Traini, Triumph of St. Thomas, Santa Caterina, Pisa ........................ 185 52. Francesco Traini, Triumph of St. Thomas, detail showing Christ with nine rays of inspiration descending from his mouth Santa Caterina, Pisa ................. 186 53. Francesco Traini, Triumph of St. Thomas, detail showing St. Mark and the ray of inspiration from Christ, which is visible crossing the halo of the Saint, Santa Caterina, Pisa ................................................................................. 187 54. Francesco Traini, Triumph of St. Thomas, detail showing Plato and the absence of a ray of inspiration from Christ, Santa Caterina, Pisa ...................... 188 55. Pietro Perugino, Lunette with Prudence, Justice, and Six Uomini Famosi, from the Collegio del Cambio, Perugia ............................................................. 189 56. View of the Collegio del Cambio, with fresco decoration by Pietro Perugino, Perugia. The lunette depicting God the Father over Jewish Uomini and the Sibyls is to the right and the Nativity is at right center ............ 190 57. Pinturicchio, Dialectic, from the Sala delle Arti Liberali, the Borgia Apartments, the Vatican..................................................................................... 191 58. Pinturicchio, Geometry, from the Sala delle Arti Liberali, the Borgia Apartments,
    [Show full text]
  • Miniatore Singularissimo
    Quotidiano Data 06-02-2014 L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO Pagina 5 Foglio 1 / 2 Un protagonista della Sistina quttrocentesca Miniatore singularissimo la rapidità con la quale un impegno di così grandi dimensioni fu portato a termine e neppure la coerenza che, pur nella riconoscibile varietà delle declinazioni stilistiche, stringe in unità le due serie di affreschi. Secondo il costume delle botteghe pittoriche di allora, ogni maestro titolare di contratto portava con sé la sua squadra, fatta di associati a vario titolo, di collaboratori, di allievi. Dobbiamo immaginare la Cappella Sistina negli anni fra il 1481 e il 1483 come un ronzante cantiere dove si incrociavano i dialetti di mezza Italia e dove maestri e allievi di varia formazione, passando da una pontata all’altra, si scambiavano opinioni e commenti, qualche volta consigli, qualche volta critiche. Qualcuno dei minori collaboratori ha avuto l’onore di dipingere in proprio un intero riquadro, come nel caso di Biagio di Antonio autore del Passaggio dal Mar Rosso nella serie dedicata a Mosè. Poteva anche accadere che i maestri più rinomati abbandonassero il cantiere per periodi più o meno lunghi perché chiamati altrove da commissioni importanti. Accadde, nell’autunno del 1482, a Botticelli, a Perugino e a Ghirlandaio invitati a Firenze a dipingere in Palazzo Vecchio. A quell’epoca la gran parte delle Storie di Cristo e di Mosè doveva essere conclusa, ma Bartolomeo della Gatta, «Testamento e morte di Mosè» (1482, particolare) a completare i due cicli contrapposti mancavano ancora alcune scene. È a questo punto che entrarono in campo due new entries: Luca Signorelli e Bartolomeo della ANTONIO PAOLUCCI Gatta.
    [Show full text]
  • LUCA SIGNORELLI and ROME. OBLIVION and REDISCOVERY Musei Capitolini Pay Homage to One of the Major Artists of Italian Renaissance
    September 2019 32 checkinrome.net September 2019 | ongoing events The monthly guide for your free time LUCA SIGNORELLI AND ROME. OBLIVION AND REDISCOVERY Musei Capitolini pay homage to one of the major artists of Italian Renaissance As quincentenary of Raphael’s death (1471-1484) Rome, among the Capitoline approaches, Musei Capitolini, in the Antiquities, to admire works by the Mater halls of Palazzo Caffarelli, pay tribute of Cortona portraying Roman monuments, to Luca Signorelli. For the first time in Christian antiquities and classical statuary, Rome is celebrated one of the greatest including the Martyrdom of Saint Sebastian, protagonists of the Italian Renaissan- the Christ on the Cross with Mary Magdale- ce, whose high pictorial parabola was obscu- ne, the Munich Tondo, and the Altarpiece of red only by the imponderable arrival of two Arcevia. giants of the next generation: Michelangelo The exhibition’s path then moves into Orvie- (1475-1564) and Raphael (1483 -1520), to’s Cappella Nova, here carefully rendered both inspired by the master of Cortona in re- by backlit reproductions, to display Signorel- aching that unsurpassable vertex of painting li’s masterpieces focused on the theme of that his very contemporaries attributed to grace and maternal love, including the Virgin him. Through a careful selection of about 60 and Child of the Metropolitan Museum of Art works of great prestige, coming from Italian in New York and the precious table owned by as well as foreign collections, the exhibition Princess Pallavicini. highlights the historical and artistic context Following, the sections dedicated to Si- of the Signorelli’s first roman sojourn, and gnorelli’s Roman sojourn under Pope Leo X offers new interpretations of the direct and (1513-1521) papacy, and his relations with indirect connections he established with the Bramante and Michelangelo.
    [Show full text]
  • Lives of the Most Eminent Painters Sculptors and Architects
    Lives of the Most Eminent Painters Sculptors and Architects Giorgio Vasari Lives of the Most Eminent Painters Sculptors and Architects Table of Contents Lives of the Most Eminent Painters Sculptors and Architects.......................................................................1 Giorgio Vasari..........................................................................................................................................2 LIFE OF FILIPPO LIPPI, CALLED FILIPPINO...................................................................................9 BERNARDINO PINTURICCHIO........................................................................................................13 LIFE OF BERNARDINO PINTURICCHIO.........................................................................................14 FRANCESCO FRANCIA.....................................................................................................................17 LIFE OF FRANCESCO FRANCIA......................................................................................................18 PIETRO PERUGINO............................................................................................................................22 LIFE OF PIETRO PERUGINO.............................................................................................................23 VITTORE SCARPACCIA (CARPACCIO), AND OTHER VENETIAN AND LOMBARD PAINTERS...........................................................................................................................................31
    [Show full text]
  • FIGUREHEAD Nicola Dale
    FIGUREHEAD Nicola Dale In consolidating Curation and Library Services at Leeds Arts University, it is fitting that our first exhibition in the new gallery should explore a contemporary revision of Saint Jerome — the patron saint of libraries and an enduring figure of intrigue for artists, especially during the Renaissance. As part of our commitment to Northern artists, we have invited Nicola Dale to be our first resident researcher. In her practice, Dale has been consistently interested in the potential connections between libraries and curation as primary sites of knowledge making. In April 2016 she held the role of ‘library interventionist’, and her return to the University acknowledges the growing portfolio of artist-led activities in our specialist arts library. Primarily working in the realms of sculpture, installation and performance, Dale’s practice is conceptually rooted. She is chiefly concerned with how knowledge is made visible. Many of her recent artworks have investigated the physical activity of reading, or, more precisely, the ways in which the reader’s eyes move across the page. Figurehead is contemplative and deeply art historical. The exhibition and related performances present the findings of Dale’s research trip to Rome in October 2018. Thirteen contemporary portraits of Saint Jerome are drawn with an innovative use of chenille stems and based on a series of Renaissance paintings. One revelation for Dale was that Jerome is almost always depicted distracted from reading, with his body often contorted into a performative twist. Viewers are invited, in turn, to contemplate their own reading habits and physical encounters with text and images.
    [Show full text]
  • Reading Raphael: "The School of Athens" and Its Pre-Text Author(S): Glenn W
    Reading Raphael: "The School of Athens" and Its Pre-Text Author(s): Glenn W. Most Reviewed work(s): Source: Critical Inquiry, Vol. 23, No. 1 (Autumn, 1996), pp. 145-182 Published by: The University of Chicago Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1344080 . Accessed: 01/06/2012 12:49 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. The University of Chicago Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Critical Inquiry. http://www.jstor.org Reading Raphael: The School of Athens and Its Pre-Text Glenn W. Most At least since the winter of 1786, when Goethe stood in the Stanza della Segnatura in the Vatican and struggled to decipher the so-called Schoolof Athens (1509-10) as though he were trying "to study Homer in a partially obliterated, damaged manuscript," the question of how this painting is to be understood has often been formulated in terms of whether, and if so how, it is to be read.' The aesthetic appeal of the elegance and vivacity of its colors and forms stands in remarkable tension with the cognitive challenge the figures and their dramatic activity seem to pose.
    [Show full text]