Dynamics of the Control of Body Pattern in the Development of Xenopus Laevis 1
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
J. Embryol. exp. Morph. 88, 85-112 (1985) 85 Printed in Great Britain © The Company of Biologists Limited 1985 Dynamics of the control of body pattern in the development of Xenopus laevis 1. Timing and pattern in the development of dorsoanterior and posterior blastomere pairs, isolated at the 4-cell stage JONATHAN COOKE AND JOHN A. WEBBER National Institute for Medical Research, The Ridgeway, Mill Hill, London NW7, U.K SUMMARY Xenopus embryos have been selected in which the second cleavage is occuring in a frontal plane, i.e one tending to lie at right angles to the prospective plane of bilateral symmetry for the body pattern. Some of these have been used to deduce a map of the disposition of materials for the normal mesodermal pattern (the normal 'fate map') by injecting blastomeres to found fluorescently marked clones from 4- to 32-cell stages. Other such 4-cell embryos have been separated into two isolates across this second cleavage; in fate-map terms, prospective dorsoanterior and posterior isolates. These have been allowed to develop to control axial larval stages, with examination of the time schedule of their gastrulation movements in relation to cofertilized whole controls. The patterns of mesoderm produced have been examined and interpreted in the light of quantitative knowledge about the normal pattern, and our current understanding of the map. A meaningful fate map exists for the egg material even at this early, essentially acellular stage, and it differs appreciably from what might have been expected in view of that traditionally shown for early gastrula stages. The patterns developed in the isolates show that at least in many eggs, widespread information that positively specifies material as to its body position is available from at most 1 h after the events that give rise to bilateral symmetry upon fertilization. This information usually leads to a mosaic development of the appropriate mesodermal part-pattern in dorsoanterior isolates, and frequently allows development that approximates to this in the reciprocal posterior part. Regulation, i.e. the replacement of removed information to specify a development more complete than the normal contribution in isolates, is not observed. The results suggest a revision of former claims for regulative ability in at least this amphibian embryo. They also imply that systems for ascribing position value (positional information) to early embryonic tissue can be diverse in dynamics, even among embryos whose body plans are obviously homologous as are those of vertebrates. INTRODUCTION This is the first of a series of papers which will report a re-appraisal of pattern formation in the development of an anuran amphibian, using the contemporary techniques of cell lineage marking and the quantitative measurement of anatomy at a particular early larval stage. These techniques have been used alongside various traditional experimental manipulations, performed on newly fertilized Key words: egg organization, pattern specification, gastrulation, fate mapping, non-equivalence, Xenopus laevis. 86 J. COOKE AND J. A. WEBBER eggs and early embryos of the African Clawed Frog, Xenopus laevis. An overall attempt to introduce these studies in terms of the inherited beliefs and concepts of experimental embryology would result, rather, in a lengthy review. The reader is referred instead to reviews by Holtfreter & Hamburger (1955), Nieuwkoop (1973) and Gerhart (1980, especially relevant for the events before first cleavage). In each of the present papers, revisions of particular previously held beliefs that are indicated by results to be described will be emphasized in the appropriate discussion sections. Attempts will be made at appropriate points to inter-relate the findings as a whole. This and the next paper deal with the traditional separation of the fertilized egg into defined fragments at very early cleavage stages, and their development in isolation. The results are partly at variance with the traditional reports, and resemble those recently documented by Kageura & Yamana (1983). They may help in understanding the nature of the information that underlies development of the body plan in embryos of this general type (Wolpert, 1971; Cooke, 1983a, b). Spemann and his students, working with urodele embryos, recorded that a special limited region of the egg could be defined, at least from soon after fertilization (Spemann, 1902, 1938). Constrictions were made, at times up to the onset of gastrulation, to produce developing fragments each reasonably balanced for constituents in the animal-vegetal axis. Any such fragment that included the region destined to become the dorsal midline in the normal course of embryo- genesis, could apparently develop an essentially complete, balanced body pattern though of reduced tissue dimensions (i.e regulation). Fragments lacking this region revealed, by their retention of radial symmetry and lack of dorsal axial histogenesis, a profound loss of developmental information. The crucial 'pre-localized' region was originally believed to be quite limited, subtending some 60° of arc in the egg, but later experiments of similar sorts revealed that the situation was more complex (Brice, 1958; Dollander, 1950; Fankhauser, 1948) and that a wider region was capable of organizing at least a significant partial degree of development. The extent to which the experimental patterns were analysed histologically and quantitatively, to see if they accorded with their 'gestalt' appearance, is also unclear. This work has nevertheless been the classic evidence for the idea that prolonged interactions or signalling processes across tissue, extending through blastula and into gastrula phases (104 cells), set up the body pattern by progressive regionalization during the normal development. This development has in its turn been treated as a model system in which to study early pattern formation in vertebrates generally. The mechanism has been thought of sometimes as a hierarchy or succession of specific inductions (Spemann, 1938; Nieuwkoop, 1973; Slack, 1983; see Cooke, 1983a) and sometimes as the setting up of a physiological gradient interpreted as positional information of some kind (Cooke, 1912a, 1973; Wolpert, 1971). We have re-investigated the states of specification for patterned development across the egg by capitalizing upon the recently expanded knowledge of the immediate postfertilization events in anuran amphibians, particularly Xenopus Pattern in Xenopus blastomere pairs 87 (Gerhart et al. 1981; Kirschner, Gerhart, Hara & Ubbels, 1980). By appropriate early manipulation and selection of eggs, preparations can be made in which the two pairs of blastomeres separated at the 4-cell stage will constitute, respectively, that part of the egg surrounding the presumptive dorsal midline and the remainder. It is known that the system organizing the future pattern is first orientated during the precleavage period by reorganization of plasms within the egg. This normally occurs in relation to the position of sperm entry which can be used as a marker. At second cleavage (orientated vertically like the first but orthogonal to it), we have selected eggs with a bilaterally symmetrical cleavage pattern lying orthogonal to the presumptive plane of symmetry of the embryo. Some were then used to fill particular bilateral pairs of blastomeres with a cell- lineage tracer (Gimlich & Cooke, 1983), and thus trace their relative contributions to mesodermal body pattern in normal development. Those contributions turn out to be quite characteristic and constant, so that a fate-mapping exercise has been performed, and the deduced map for mesoderm differs from what might be expected in view of previously published fate maps for amphibian early gastrula stages. The remaining eggs were used to perform separations into the two presumed bilaterally symmetrical pairs of blastomeres, followed by their devel- opment as isolates. The partial body plans developed by these reciprocal isolates were observed and representative samples examined histologically. Their meso- dermal component was studied in relation to our understanding of the fate map for whole development, and our knowledge of certain quantitative regularities in the normal pattern (Webber & Cooke, in preparation). We conclude that, by onset of the 4-cell stage, the informational system across the egg is frequently in such a condition as to lead to stable retention, by the separated parts, of the ability to develop in a near-mosaic way their reciprocal contributions to the normal whole mesoderm. Regulative behaviour - that is, production by a fragment of a greater part of the pattern than its presumptive contribution in the intact embryo - was not observed. Mosaic behaviour is not the invariable outcome however, and the whole spectrum of results is discussed in terms of the possible nature of the primary system of spatial information in the egg. Our understanding of the flow of developmental information that sets up and co-ordinates the principal layers of the body structure (germ layers) is also discussed in relation to the present results, in order to justify our concentration upon mesoderm as the most direct expression of the original system coding for 'body position'. We stress that the results reveal an early specification for position within the body plan (see Slack, 1983 for a defined usage of this term), and in no sense a set of determinations for tissue types. The behaviour which is described indeed precedes by several hours the origin of