HARROWING JOURNEYS Children and youth on the move across the Mediterranean Sea, at risk of trafficking and exploitation 1 © United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) © International Organization for Migration (IOM) September 2017, final Permission is required to reproduce any part of this publication. Permission will be freely granted to educational or nonprofit organizations. Please contact: United Nations Children’s Fund The opinions expressed in the report are those of the authors and do not 3 United Nations Plaza, New York, NY 10017, USA necessarily reflect the views of the International Organization for Migration (IOM). The designations employed and the presentation of material throughout the International Organization for Migration report do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of IOM 17 route des Morillons, 1211 Geneva 19, P.O. Box 17, concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area, or of its Switzerland authorities, or concerning its frontiers or boundaries. This report, additional online content and corrigenda IOM is committed to the principle that humane and orderly migration benefits are available at: migrants and society. As an intergovernmental organization, IOM acts with its www.unicef.org/publications/index_100621.html partners in the international community to: assist in meeting the operational www.publications.iom.int challenges of migration; advance understanding of migration issues; encourage social and economic development through migration; and uphold the human dignity ISBN: 978-92-806-4897-3 and well-being of migrants. Harrowing Journeys Children and youth on the move across the Mediterranean Sea, at risk of trafficking and exploitation September 2017 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS EDITORIAL, DATA AND ANALYSIS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS UNICEF Core report team: Jan Beise, Helena Cruz Castanheira, Anna Grojec, This report would not have been possible had it not been for the Claus Bech Hansen, Danzhen You invaluable inputs of many colleagues throughout UNICEF and IOM, Managing editor and writing: Anna Grojec in particular colleagues from Regional Offices, Headquarters, Research and writing: Claus Bech Hansen National Committees and Country Offices throughout the world. Data analysis and writing: Jan Beise, Helena Cruz Castanheira, Danzhen You Guidance and coordination: Danzhen You Within UNICEF, specific thanks go to Justin Forsyth, Policy analysis and writing: Saskia Blume Laurence Chandy, Hongwei Gao, Nicole Bates, Ted Chaiban, Additional research and production support: Laura Healy Paloma Escudero, Caroline den Dulk, Mark Hereward, Priscilla Idele, Human interest stories: John Budd, Christopher Tidey, Ashley Gilbertson, David Anthony, Jens Matthes, Kerry Neal, John Budd, Najwa Mekki, Priyanka Pruthi, Alessio Romenzi Sarah Crowe, Marta Arias, Kendra Gregson, Jean François Basse, Isabella Castrogiovanni, Lori Bell, Inoussa Kabore, Sarah Rosengaertner, IOM Core report team: Laura Bartolini, Harry Cook, Eliza Galos Claudia Cappa, Irene de Lorenzo-Caceres Cantero, Khin Wityee Oo, Editing, guidance, coordination and writing: Harry Cook Emmanuelle Compingt, Ayano Suzumura, Attila Hancioglu, Data analysis and writing: Laura Bartolini, Eliza Galos Bina D’Costa, Milena Harizanova, Nona Zicherman, Pierre Ngom, Guidance and policy analysis: Mathieu Luciano Jean Nsonjiba Lokenga, Jeremy Hopkins, Issa Ahmed Nur, Policy analysis and writing: Anjali Fleury Khaled Khaled, Jean Lieby, Hala Berbara, Berina Arslanagic-Ibisevic, DESIGN AND CONTENT STRATEGY Neeraj Malhotra, Silvia Mestroni, Francesca Moneti, Landry Dongmo UNICEF Design and content strategy: Olga Oleszczuk, Shangning Wang, Cecilia Beatriz Silva Tsague, Rupert Leighton, Milen Kidane, Denis Jobin, Daniela Baro, Data visualizations: Olga Oleszczuk, Shangning Wang, Cecilia Beatriz Silva, Lucia Hug, Elsa Rovai, Sylvester Ndorbor Morlue, Abdul Khaliq Sultani, Jan Beise, Helena Cruz Castanheira, Danzhen You Melanie Teff, Diana Vakarelska, Marija Mokrova, Karoline Hassfurter, Fact-checking: Yasmine Hage, Xinyi Ge Anshana Arora, Rada Noeva, Michael Sidwell, Rebecca Obstler, Copy-editing and proofreading: Alison Raphael, Anna Mukerjee Lely Djuhari. Within IOM, specific thanks go to Naomi Grant, Erda Qazim, PHOTOGRAPH CREDITS Natasha Vidova, Michela Macchiavello, Carlotta Santarossa, Cover: © UNICEF/UN020035/Gilbertson VII Photo Paola Sandra Alvarez, Laura Lungarotti, Euan McDougall, Page 10: © UNICEF/UN057939/Gilbertson VII Photo Elda Goci, Saira Atlaf, Nuno Nunes, Vlatko Avramovski, Page 13: © UNICEF/UN020047/Gilbertson VII Photo Ivona Zakoska, Kristina Uzelac, Maria Fedorova, Marie McAuliffe, Page 20: © UNICEF/UN058548/Holt Frank Laczko, Kate Deardon, Valerie Hagger, Carlo Mendes, Page 26: © UNICEF/UN052604/Romenzi Federico Soda, Irina Todorova, Toby Greenfield, Denise Lassar, Page 30: © UNICEF/UN057977/Gilbertson VII Photo Sacha Chan Kam, Kristina Touzenis, Fanny Dufvenmark, Page 37: © UNICEF/UNI197645/Gilbertson VII Photo Carlotta Panchetti, Anastasia Saglam, Anna Janssen, Balazs Lehel, Page 38: © UNICEF/UN051556/Tremeau Kelly Namia, Simona Moscarelli, Andromachi Lazaridi, Amina Saoudi. Page 41: © UNICEF/UN072192/Phelps Page 43: © UNICEF/UN057978/Gilbertson VII Photo Special thanks go to IOM’s Displacement Tracking Matrix enumerators Page 44: © UNICEF/UN052642/Romenzi and migrant respondents. Page 53: © UNICEF/UN052608/Romenzi Page 61: © UNICEF/UN057976/Gilbertson VII Photo Page 62: © UNICEF/UN020034/Gilbertson VII Photo TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive summary 6 CHAPTER 2 CHAPTER 3 Easy prey for traffickers Vulnerability and resilience emerge CHAPTER 1 and other exploiters 20 from an interplay of variables 30 Tracking some of the world’s Infographic: Trafficking is a serious risk Alone and vulnerable .................................... 31 10 most dangerous migration routes for children on the move ................................ 21 Education protects ........................................ 33 Box 1: Adolescents and youth .......................... 11 More vulnerable than adults ........................ 22 Infographic: On the move and out of school .... 34 The surveys .................................................... 12 Box 3: Across the world, or right next door .... 22 Prolonged journeys and detention .............. 34 Vignette: A chance to tell their stories ............. 12 Held against their will .................................. 24 Vignettes: Detained ......................................... 35 Survey limitations .......................................... 14 Exploitative work .......................................... 24 Two routes, different stories .......................... 14 Vignettes: “We were like slaves” ................... 26 Box 2: Bangladeshis in Libya............................. 16 Infographic: What factors make adolescents and youth more likely to be exploited? ............ 28 CHAPTER 4 CHAPTER 5 Xenophobia and racism Protecting children on the move contribute to exploitation 38 from trafficking and exploitation 44 Vignette: Racism in Europe ....................................... 39 Outside the law ....................................................... 45 Sub-Saharan Africans are especially vulnerable .... 39 Infographic: Without safe and regular migration Echoing first-person accounts pathways, children and youth are at risk .................. 46 from the Central route ............................................. 40 Vignette: “Everybody has an AK-47”.......................... 47 Infographic: Layers of protection – and their limits ... 41 Unanswered questions, clear imperatives ............ 48 Vignette: Treated differently as a result of racism ..... 42 Box 4: Promising practices ....................................... 49 Unheard stories on the Eastern route .................... 42 Policy recommendations ........................................ 50 Annex ....................................................................... 54 References ................................................................... 56 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Young migrants and refugees set out to escape harm or secure On both routes, additional years of education and travelling in better futures – and face staggering risks in the process. For 17-year- a group, whether with family or not, afford young migrants and old Mohammad, who travelled through Libya to seek asylum in Italy, refugees a measure of protection. But where they come from violence and persecution back home meant the choice was clear: outweighs either of these factors. An adolescent boy from sub- “We risked our lives to come here,” he says, “we crossed a sea. We Saharan Africa, who has secondary education and travels in a group knew it is not safe, so we sacrificed. We do it, or we die.”1 along the Central Mediterranean route, faces a 73 per cent risk of being exploited. If he came from another region, the risk would drop For children and youth on the move via the Mediterranean Sea to 38 per cent. routes to Europe, the journey is marked by high levels of abuse, trafficking and exploitation. Some are more vulnerable than others: Anecdotal reports and qualitative research from the Mediterranean those travelling alone, those with low levels of education and those region and elsewhere suggest that racism underlies this difference. undertaking longer journeys. Most vulnerable of all are those who, Countless testimonies from young migrants and refugees from like Mohammad, come from sub-Saharan Africa.2 sub-Saharan Africa make clear that they are treated more harshly and targeted