UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations Title The Acoustics of Narrative Involvement: Modernism, Subjectivity, Voice Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/1ws2f1tr Author Napolin, Julie Beth Publication Date 2010 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California The Acoustics of Narrative Involvement: Modernism, Subjectivity, Voice By Julie Beth Napolin A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Rhetoric in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Ramona Naddaff, Chair Professor Trinh T. Minh-ha Professor Carolyn Porter Professor Ramona Naddaff Fall 2010 The Acoustics of Narrative Involvement: Modernism, Subjectivity, Voice by Julie Beth Napolin Doctor of Philosophy in Rhetoric University of California, Berkeley Professor Ramona Naddaff, Chair The theory and history of the modernist novel traditionally emphasizes a shift away from “telling” towards “showing.” The project argues that the overly visual account of modernism misses a crucial opportunity to “hear” modernist narrative and composition. The project is an acoustics of modernist narrative backed by two case studies, the work of Joseph Conrad and William Faulkner. These writers propose a way of listening to the modernist novel and to the neglected importance of sounds and voices within it. I attend to Conrad’s peculiar transnational voice, Faulkner’s regional, southern voice, and their shared sensitivity to the physical, rhetorical, and musical properties of speech and writing. In Chapter One, “The Incanted Image: Vision, Silence, and Belonging in Conrad’s Theory of the Novel,” I pose an alternative reading of Conrad’s famous 1897 preface to The Nigger of the “Narcissus” . I argue that Conrad’s theory articulates his struggle to realize a form of narrative vision that might neutralize the most troubling effects of embodied voice. His theory of the novel, his struggle with voice, isolated him from his contemporaries while opening up new possibilities for the genre. Chapter Two, “Waiting for the Voice: Echo, Trope, and Narrative as Acoustic Displacement,” recuperates the acoustical and rhetorical dimension of Conradian narrative voice, largely illustrated by his famous storyteller, Marlow. I argue that in Conrad’s early narratives, a dramatic voice is separated from the speaker’s body in order to occupy the listener’s own. This voice is one effect of Conrad’s attempts both to theorize and craft a narrative that might appeal to his English reader’s sense of kinship. Exterior to that voice, however, is a pulsing world of sound. On the one hand, Conrad’s problems concerning his perceived foreign voice appear in “displaced,” racialized form through the sonic register of his novels, particularly those of non-European domains. On the other hand, there is a sonic imaginary “echoing” throughout letters, memoirs, and early novels that allow us to rethink the phrase, “the author’s voice.” In Chapter Three, “An Unorchestrated Voice: Faulkner, Song, and The Politics of Archival Listening,” I argue that Conrad’s sense of readerly involvement with the acoustical influenced Faulkner to a radical extent. Faulkner develops the novel as what I call an “archival” phenomenon, a haunting of narrative and the act of composition by sounds and voices. He registers the echoes of any one voice as it is accompanied by other voices that condition it, Faulkner tarrying in particular with sonic legacy of slavery. In his practice of composition, Faulkner revisits several voices and sounds that move between bodies, across gender and race. At the level of acoustics, this movement composes a compelling, modernist critique of racial identity. In that way, I conclude the project with a theory of an acoustical approach to literary history, one with significance beyond modernism. 1 For Mom Acknowledgments This project was made possible through the generous support of the Woodrow Wilson Foundation Mellon Fellowship, the Jacob K. Javits Fellowship in the Humanities, the Dean’s Normative Time Fellowship, The Rhetoric Department Block Grant, The School of Criticism and Theory at Cornell University, and numerous Wollenburg Grants. I thank these foundations for their belief in my work since the earliest stages. I would like to extend my deepest thanks to my committee for their help and support, for overseeing this project at every stage, at times reading numerous drafts, and for offering wisdom when both the project and the profession seemed most terrifying and elusive. My dissertation represents the incredible chance to work with the scholars who most move, challenge, and excite me. There is no way to locate the origin of a project, but each of committee member represents a beginning: Narrative Involvement: I first met my chair, Ramona Naddaff, in her Modern Rhetoric Theory seminar. I was immediately struck by her rigor, style, grace of thinking, and unparalleled warmth. She is among the most supportive intellectuals I have encountered, exhibiting a dedication to the nuances of a given project, attending to and reading with deep respect and care for how those nuances might be best vivified and pronounced. When speaking with her, I find I cannot write quickly enough to keep up with the ideas. She is brimming with intellectual vitality. She has a way of reflecting your ideas back to you such the fragmentary starts taking real shape, and you leave the conversation wanting immediately to set to work. I thank her in particular for the warmth and strength with which she pushes my thinking, and the sympathy with which she reads and converses, what has sustained my belief that scholarship is a most ethical pursuit. Acoustics: I first met Trinh T. Minh-ha in a voicemail that accepted me to Berkeley, and then again in her Image, Music, Text and Film Deaesthetics seminars, two beginnings of my project on sound. I had read her work in college, a moment when I was first experimenting with new ways of writing about sound, music, and voice, and I saw in her scholarship a model of someone who was both an artist and a rigorous thinker, someone who, in refusing to choose between two seeming opposed modalities, changed what was possible in writing. The delicacy, care, and sensitivity with which she thinks, writes, and speaks often involves finding a small, ignored, or forgotten place in the life of the concept and crafting a place where it might speak to its fullest potential. It is that sense of artistic care for the detail, the passing notes of thought as they might be paused, heard differently, and allowed the space to live their own life that is among the moment influential forces in my thinking. Modernism and Voice: I first met Carolyn Porter in her Faulkner seminar. There I was awakened to the richness of modern literature, an experience that changed my intellectual course. She lives and breathes Faulkner in a way that could seduce even the most befuddled or skeptical; there is a certain regality of character and grace of thinking that convinces one that, in reading literature, he or she is doing something noble. I spent many afternoons at her dining room table where she went page by page responding to my drafts, providing guidance, clarity, and confidence. These meetings will be included amongst my happiest memories of Berkeley. I thank her for her groundbreaking scholarship and, most kindly, for the numerous Scarlet O’Hara impressions and old school critic anecdotes that provided much needed sanity. I thank her for an evocative speaking voice, one that I hear to myself when write of Faulkner; it is a voice that pushes me to be a better writer; I know when I hear it that I’ve hit on something worth pursuing. i Subjectivity: I first met Judith Butler when I turned over my copy of Bodies that Matter , shattered after reading it in college, and saw that she taught in Rhetoric in Berkeley. This convinced me of my growing sense that I must get myself to this place on the other side of the country as quickly as possible. My interest in what it means to be a critical listener started to take shape in her numerous public lectures and the Theories of the Subject seminar where I was introduced to some of the most central critics in my project. To say that she is a most rigorous, generous, athletic, and explosive thinker would be a gross understatement. To listen to her lecture, for even a few minutes, is so expansive and challenging that one feels a deeper space for thought carved out in the synapses. I thank her in particular for the art of the question: I learned in listening to and reading her that critical thought begins in the question, asking the ones that seem most unaskable, such that posing the question is an act of overturning. This project has been many years in the making and culminates work that began long before I arrived at Berkeley. I would like to thank my parents, and my brother and sister for their unconditional love and for supporting my education and all of my pursuits. I also thank my grandpa, and Leah Napolin and family for their support and encouragement. I would like to thank the Rhetoric Department, what remains one of the most exciting and important centers of thought in the country, for its initial and continued support of my work and study. It is composed of some of the most unique, gifted, and exciting scholars. In the Rhetoric Department, I thank Marianne Constable, Maxine Fredericksen, and Jane Taylorson for their support, advice, and warm care. At Berkeley, I had the opportunity to take seminars with gifted thinkers from around the world. I thank Adriana Cavarero, Shannon Jackson, Victoria Kahn, Catherine Malabou, Denise Riley, and Kaja Silverman for giving me the opportunity to study with them.
Recommended publications
  • Corse-Matin Du 29 Décembre 2009
    L’INFORMATEUR Corse Nouvelle www.corse-information.info 1e Hebdomadaire régional habilité à publier les annonces judiciaires et légales année ème - 59 N° 6296 Journal du 8 au 14 janvier 2010 - DISPARITION DE ME VINCENT STAGNARA ÉNERGIE DISTINCTION SOLIDARITÉ Le point de vue du citoyen José Stromboni Laure Degiovani, onze ans, originaire de En ce début 2010, l’Etablissement Français sur l’avancement du dossier GALSI Casinca, remporte le concours de Mini-Star du Sang appelle plus que jamais à donner zAPPROVISIONNEMENT ÉNERGÉTIQUE / PROPOS RECUEILLIS PAR M.V. JOSÉ STROMBONI : «LE GALSI, UN VRAI SERPENT DE MER » elon José Stromboni qui, depuis le début, suit attentivement le dossier, la réunion qui s’est tenue à Cagliari le 23 novembre dernier a permis de S faire, pour la Corse, un point bien négatif sur l’avancée du projet de gazoduc entre l’Algérie d’une part, la Sardaigne et l’Italie, d’autre part (projet qui doit, à terme, alimenter le continent européen avec du gaz algérien dont les réserves sahariennes sont actuellement estimées à plus de 70 ans d’exploitation). uJosé Stromboni, en tant qu’observateur îles dépendent de la Métropole. Pendant ces ment cette traversée ne coûterait pas un centi- avisé du dossier Galsi, que vous paraît-il événements, le professeur Jacques Marseille me, mais elle pourrait engendrer pas mal de important de rappeler à l’aube de cette nou- avait dénoncé cette constante de l’économie retombées. Le passage terrestre favoriserait velle année ? captive dans laquelle il incluait d’ailleurs la les branchements tout au long du parcours, Lors de la visite en 2003 provoquée par Nico- Corse.
    [Show full text]
  • Lita Ford and Doro Interviewed Inside Explores the Brightest Void and the Shadow Self
    COMES WITH 78 FREE SONGS AND BONUS INTERVIEWS! Issue 75 £5.99 SUMMER Jul-Sep 2016 9 771754 958015 75> EXPLORES THE BRIGHTEST VOID AND THE SHADOW SELF LITA FORD AND DORO INTERVIEWED INSIDE Plus: Blues Pills, Scorpion Child, Witness PAUL GILBERT F DARE F FROST* F JOE LYNN TURNER THE MUSIC IS OUT THERE... FIREWORKS MAGAZINE PRESENTS 78 FREE SONGS WITH ISSUE #75! GROUP ONE: MELODIC HARD 22. Maessorr Structorr - Lonely Mariner 42. Axon-Neuron - Erasure 61. Zark - Lord Rat ROCK/AOR From the album: Rise At Fall From the album: Metamorphosis From the album: Tales of the Expected www.maessorrstructorr.com www.axonneuron.com www.facebook.com/zarkbanduk 1. Lotta Lené - Souls From the single: Souls 23. 21st Century Fugitives - Losing Time 43. Dimh Project - Wolves In The 62. Dejanira - Birth of the www.lottalene.com From the album: Losing Time Streets Unconquerable Sun www.facebook. From the album: Victim & Maker From the album: Behind The Scenes 2. Tarja - No Bitter End com/21stCenturyFugitives www.facebook.com/dimhproject www.dejanira.org From the album: The Brightest Void www.tarjaturunen.com 24. Darkness Light - Long Ago 44. Mercutio - Shed Your Skin 63. Sfyrokalymnon - Son of Sin From the album: Living With The Danger From the album: Back To Nowhere From the album: The Sign Of Concrete 3. Grandhour - All In Or Nothing http://darknesslight.de Mercutio.me Creation From the album: Bombs & Bullets www.sfyrokalymnon.com www.grandhourband.com GROUP TWO: 70s RETRO ROCK/ 45. Medusa - Queima PSYCHEDELIC/BLUES/SOUTHERN From the album: Monstrologia (Lado A) 64. Chaosmic - Forever Feast 4.
    [Show full text]
  • Qello Concerts List.Xlsx
    Artist Concert 3 Doors Down Live at the Download Festival 3 Doors Down Live At The Tabernacle 2014 30 Odd Foot Of Grunts Live at Soundstage 30 Seconds To Mars Live At Download Festival 2013 5 Seconds of Summer How Did We End Up Here? 6ft Hick Notes from the Underground A House Live on Stage A Thousand Horses Real Live Performances A Thousand Horses Real Live Performances ABBA Arrival: The Ultimate Critical Review ABBA The Gold Singles Above And Beyond Acoustic AC/DC In Performance AC/DC Live at the Circus Krone AC/DC AC/DC - No Bull AC/DC Live At River Plate\t Acid Angels 101 A Concert - Band in Seattle Acid Angels And Big Sur 101 Episode - Band in Seattle Adam Jensen Live at Kiss FM Boston Adam Lambert Glam Nation Live Aerosmith Videobiography Aerosmith Rock for the Rising Sun After The Fire Live at the Greenbelt Against Me! Live at the Key Club: West Hollywood Aiden From Hell with Love Air Eating Sleeping Waiting and Playing Air Supply Air Supply Live in Toronto Air Supply Air Supply Live in Toronto Air Supply Live in Hong Kong Akhenaton Live Aux Docks Des Sud Al Green Everything's Going To Be Alright Alabama and Friends Live at the Ryman Alain Souchon J'veux Du Live Part 2 Alanis Morissette Live at Soundstage Alanis Morissette Live at Montreux 2012 Alanis Morissette Guitar Center Sessions Albert Collins Live at Montreux Albert Collins Live at Montreux Alberta Cross Live At The ATO Cabin Alejandro Fernández Confidencias Reales Alejandro Sanz El Alma al Aire en Concierto Ali Campbell Live at the Shepherds Bush Empire Alice Cooper Live
    [Show full text]
  • David Byron from Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia
    Log in / create account article discussion edit this page history David Byron From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia For other persons named David Garrick, see David Garrick (disambiguation). David Byron David Byron (born 29 January 1947 – 28 February 1985, born as David Garrick[1]) was the original navigation Birth name David Garrick lead vocalist for Spice (from 1967 through 1969) and is most famous for singing in the legendary Main page Born 29 January 1947 English rock band Uriah Heep between 1969 and 1976. Contents Origin Epping, Essex, England Featured content Contents Died 28 February 1985 (aged 38) Current events 1 Background Genre(s) Rock , Hard rock, Progressive Random article 2 Discography rock, Heavy Metal search 2.1 With Uriah Heep Instrument(s) vocals 2.2 Solo Website david­byron.com 2.3 With Rough Diamond Go Search 2.4 With The Byron Band interaction 3 References 4 External links About Wikipedia Community portal Recent changes Background [edit] Contact Wikipedia Donate to Wikipedia Despite his vocal range (paired with a sense of dynamics), and a charismatic stage presence, Byron was dismissed from Uriah Heep in 1976, at the Help demand of keyboardist Ken Hensley (the band's primary songwriter), who gave the ultimatum "it's him or me" to band manager Gerry Bron, citing [citation needed] toolbox Byron's increasingly erratic behaviour due to alcohol abuse. What links here He unsuccessfully attempted to revive his career with Rough Diamond (a band also featuring former members of Humble Pie and Wings), a second Related changes solo album (Baby Faced Killer), and The Byron Band.
    [Show full text]
  • For Immediate Release URIAH HEEP Announces the Release of Obscure
    For Immediate Release URIAH HEEP Announces the Release of Obscure Re-Recordings Anthology, Now Re-Branded Totally Driven - OUT NOW ! London, UK - Legendary band URIAH HEEP was formed in 1969 and still actively tours the world today. This release re-brands a previously released obscure re-recordings anthology as TOTALLY DRIVEN. The album features 27 re-recordings made in 2001 including the HITS Lady in Black, July Morning and Easy Livin’. This album features the band’s longest running line-up of MICK BOX, LEE KERSLAKE, PHIL LANZON, BERNIE SHAW and the late TREVOR BOLDER. This release is the first on the band’s own URIAH HEEP RECORDS. Of the release, Mick Box said “The 'Totally Driven' recordings were made while we were in preparation for the 'Acoustically Driven' and 'Electrically Driven' concerts. Previously these 2001 recordings were released under the confusing name 'Remasters', but that title went out of print very quickly. This re-release has had the band’s full input, including in its re-branding as 'Totally Driven' and will be the very first release on our own Uriah Heep Records. ‘Appy Days!” Totally Driven is housed in a 6 panel digi-pack with new custom artwork by Igor Morski. Amazon CD Order Link: http://geni.us/3tfL Amazon Digital Link: http://geni.us/3j0m iTunes Link: http://geni.us/3ZRO Official Website: www.uriah-heep.com Official Facebook: www.facebook.com/uriahheepofficial Track Listing: DISC ONE 1. GYPSY 2. TRAVELLER IN TIME 3. BIRD OF PREY 4. SUNRISE 5. RAIN 6. COME AWAY MELINDA 7. RETURN TO FANTASY 8.
    [Show full text]
  • Modernism, Subjectivity, Voice by Julie Beth Napolin a Dissertation
    The Acoustics of Narrative Involvement: Modernism, Subjectivity, Voice By Julie Beth Napolin A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Rhetoric in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Ramona Naddaff, Chair Professor Trinh T. Minh-ha Professor Carolyn Porter Professor Ramona Naddaff Fall 2010 The Acoustics of Narrative Involvement: Modernism, Subjectivity, Voice by Julie Beth Napolin Doctor of Philosophy in Rhetoric University of California, Berkeley Professor Ramona Naddaff, Chair The theory and history of the modernist novel traditionally emphasizes a shift away from “telling” towards “showing.” The project argues that the overly visual account of modernism misses a crucial opportunity to “hear” modernist narrative and composition. The project is an acoustics of modernist narrative backed by two case studies, the work of Joseph Conrad and William Faulkner. These writers propose a way of listening to the modernist novel and to the neglected importance of sounds and voices within it. I attend to Conrad’s peculiar transnational voice, Faulkner’s regional, southern voice, and their shared sensitivity to the physical, rhetorical, and musical properties of speech and writing. In Chapter One, “The Incanted Image: Vision, Silence, and Belonging in Conrad’s Theory of the Novel,” I pose an alternative reading of Conrad’s famous 1897 preface to The Nigger of the “Narcissus” . I argue that Conrad’s theory articulates his struggle to realize a form of narrative vision that might neutralize the most troubling effects of embodied voice. His theory of the novel, his struggle with voice, isolated him from his contemporaries while opening up new possibilities for the genre.
    [Show full text]
  • Uriah Heep Albums
    UURRIIAAHH HHEEEEPP DDIISSCCOOGGRRAAPPHHYY 11997700 -- 22002200 DDIISSCCOOGGRRAAPPHHYY ((UUKK)) Page 2 LLIINNEE--UUPPSS Page 5 AALLBBUUMM RREELLEEAASSEESS Page 8 SSPPEECCIIAALL RREELLEEAASSEESS,, BBOOXX SSEETTSS EETTCC.. Page 17 SSIINNGGLLEESS RREELLEEAASSEESS Page 21 CCOOLLLLEECCTTIIOONNSS Page 30 VVIIDDEEOOSS Page 40 SSOONNGGSS AALLPPHHAABBEETTIICCAALLLLYY Page 43 SSOONNGGSS CCHHRROONNOOLLOOGGIICCAALLLLYY Page 50 DDIIFFFFEERREENNTT VVEERRSSIIOONNSS OOFF SSOONNGGSS Page 56 AALLBBUUMM RREELLEEAASSEESS && RREEIISSSSUUEESS Page 87 Compiled by Tapio Minkkinen With help from Stay On Top, The Official Uriah Heep Appreciation Society, Roy Landgren and other Heep fans too many to mention here & © 1996 - 2020 Tapio Minkkinen - www.heepfiles.net For personal use only Do not copy or distribute without permission U R I A H H E E P D I S C O G R A P H Y 1 9 7 0 - 2 0 2 0 & © 1996 – 2020 Tapio Minkkinen. www.heepfiles.net . For personal use only. Do not copy or distribute without permission. URIAH HEEP U.K. DISCOGRAPHY STUDIO ALBUMS VERY ‘EAVY ... VERY ‘UMBLE Vertigo 6360006 (1970) SALISBURY Vertigo 6360028 (1971) LOOK AT YOURSELF Bronze ILPS 9169 (1971) DEMONS AND WIZARDS Bronze ILPS 9193 (1972) THE MAGICIAN’S BIRTHDAY Bronze ILPS 9213 (1972) SWEET FREEDOM Bronze ILPS 9245 (1973) WONDERWORLD Bronze ILPS 9280 (1974) RETURN TO FANTASY Bronze ILPS 9335 (1975) HIGH AND MIGHTY Bronze ILPS 9384 (1976) FIREFLY Bronze ILPS 9483 (1977) INNOCENT VICTIM Bronze BRON 504 (1977) FALLEN ANGEL Bronze BRNA 512 (1978) CONQUEST Bronze BRON 524 (1980) ABOMINOG Bronze
    [Show full text]