Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Albee Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,603 Election Day Turnout 1,013 63.19% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,013 63.19% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 423 42.30% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 566 56.60% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 4 0.40% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 5 0.50% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.10% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,000 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 318 32.78% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 619 63.81% LIBR - Scotty Boman 18 1.86% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 9 0.93% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 3 0.31% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.21% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 970 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 524 54.87% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 402 42.09% LIBR - John Gelineau 8 0.84% USTAX - George M Zimmer 11 1.15% GRN - Pat Timmons 9 0.94% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 955 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 384 41.60% DEM - Judith Lincoln 533 57.75% Write-In 6 0.65% Total... 923 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 287 18.42% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 271 17.39% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 449 28.82% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 401 25.74% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 29 1.86% USTAX - Karen Adams 49 3.15% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 31 1.99% GRN - Candace R Caveny 24 1.54% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 13 0.83% Write-In 4 0.26% Total... 1,558 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 286 18.69% REP - Robert Steele 255 16.67% DEM - Mark Bernstein 464 30.33% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 414 27.06% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 14 0.92% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 17 1.11% USTAX - Joe Sanger 25 1.63% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 24 1.57% GRN - Eric Borregard 13 0.85% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 15 0.98% Write-In 3 0.20% Total... 1,530 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 287 19.06% REP - Jeff Sakwa 251 16.67% DEM - Joel Ferguson 458 30.41% DEM - Brian Mosallam 389 25.83% LIBR - Michael H Miller 26 1.73% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 36 2.39% USTAX - Stephen J Young 37 2.46% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 15 1.00% Write-In 7 0.46% Total... 1,506 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 270 18.33% REP - Satish B Jasti 217 14.73% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 464 31.50% DEM - Kim Trent 413 28.04% USTAX - Robert Gale 35 2.38% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 33 2.24% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 26 1.77% GRN - Latham Redding 13 0.88%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 1 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Albee Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS Write-In 2 0.14% Total... 1,473 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 347 38.99% DEM - John McColgan Jr 540 60.67% Write-In 3 0.34% Total... 890 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 749 98.17% Write-In 14 1.83% Total... 763 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 321 35.51% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 580 64.16% Write-In 3 0.33% Total... 904 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 291 33.41% DEM - Tim Novak 576 66.13% Write-In 4 0.46% Total... 871 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 743 99.46% Write-In 4 0.54% Total... 747 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 723 98.10% Write-In 14 1.90% Total... 737 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 7 REP - Dana Young 320 36.04% DEM - Cheryl Marie Hadsall 566 63.74% Write-In 2 0.23% Total... 888 100.00% ALBEE TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR DEM - Leon R Turnwald 743 98.80% Write-In 9 1.20% Total... 752 100.00% ALBEE TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Thomas Gasser 747 99.20% Write-In 6 0.80% Total... 753 100.00% ALBEE TOWNSHIP TREASURER DEM - Ronald Kulhanek 744 99.20% Write-In 6 0.80% Total... 750 100.00% ALBEE TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Judy A Guymer 419 26.79% DEM - Gary L Briggs 561 35.87% DEM - Joseph Wasmiller 582 37.21% Write-In 2 0.13% Total... 1,564 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 63 5.04% Connie Marie Kelley 315 25.20% Stephen Markman 269 21.52% Bridget Mary McCormack 271 21.68% Kerry L Morgan 47 3.76% Colleen O'Brien 247 19.76% Bob Roddis 32 2.56% Write-In 6 0.48% Total... 1,250 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 79 11.77% Shelia Johnson 284 42.32% Brian Zahra 302 45.01% Write-In 6 0.89% Total... 671 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 481 52.17% Peter D O'Connell 432 46.85% Write-In 9 0.98% Total... 922 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 531 97.97% Write-In 11 2.03% Total... 542 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 458 48.52% Darnell Jackson 479 50.74%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 2 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Albee Township Precinct 1 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Write-In 7 0.74% Total... 944 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 568 98.61% Write-In 8 1.39% Total... 576 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 575 98.46% Write-In 9 1.54% Total... 584 100.00% CHESANING UNION SCHOOLS 4 YR Brian W Lewis 486 47.74% Julia Schultz Sadilek 522 51.28% Write-In 10 0.98% Total... 1,018 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 543 98.73% Write-In 7 1.27% Total... 550 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 203 38.09% Michael D Rowley 322 60.41% Write-In 8 1.50% Total... 533 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 480 97.96% Write-In 10 2.04% Total... 490 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 341 36.71% NO 588 63.29% Total... 929 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 425 44.22% NO 536 55.78% Total... 961 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 348 36.63% NO 602 63.37% Total... 950 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 442 46.82% NO 502 53.18% Total... 944 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 316 33.69% NO 622 66.31% Total... 938 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 517 54.02% NO 440 45.98% Total... 957 100.00% Albee Township YES 443 46.63% NO 507 53.37% Total... 950 100.00% Delta College YES 407 44.48% NO 508 55.52% Total... 915 100.00% Birch Run Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 2,062 Election Day Turnout 1,406 68.19% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,406 68.19% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 653 46.78% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 715 51.22% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 9 0.64% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 7 0.50% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.14% Write-In 10 0.72% Total... 1,396 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 512 37.45% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 812 59.40% LIBR - Scotty Boman 24 1.76% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 8 0.59%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 3 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Birch Run Township Precinct 1 US SENATOR GRN - Harley Mikkelson 8 0.59% NATLAW - John D Litle 3 0.22% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,367 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 740 54.77% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 567 41.97% LIBR - John Gelineau 20 1.48% USTAX - George M Zimmer 8 0.59% GRN - Pat Timmons 16 1.18% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,351 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 645 49.39% DEM - Judith Lincoln 652 49.92% Write-In 9 0.69% Total... 1,306 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 487 21.14% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 497 21.57% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 634 27.52% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 518 22.48% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 50 2.17% USTAX - Karen Adams 47 2.04% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 19 0.82% GRN - Candace R Caveny 31 1.35% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 18 0.78% Write-In 3 0.13% Total... 2,304 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 465 20.29% REP - Robert Steele 433 18.89% DEM - Mark Bernstein 669 29.19% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 560 24.43% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 25 1.09% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 23 1.00% USTAX - Joe Sanger 40 1.75% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 18 0.79% GRN - Eric Borregard 30 1.31% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 26 1.13% Write-In 3 0.13% Total... 2,292 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 518 23.21% REP - Jeff Sakwa 437 19.58% DEM - Joel Ferguson 617 27.64% DEM - Brian Mosallam 512 22.94% LIBR - Michael H Miller 46 2.06% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 34 1.52% USTAX - Stephen J Young 41 1.84% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 23 1.03% Write-In 4 0.18% Total... 2,232 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 471 21.89% REP - Satish B Jasti 388 18.03% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 621 28.86% DEM - Kim Trent 548 25.46% USTAX - Robert Gale 40 1.86% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 30 1.39% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 27 1.25% GRN - Latham Redding 24 1.12% Write-In 3 0.14% Total... 2,152 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 551 43.22% DEM - John McColgan Jr 720 56.47% Write-In 4 0.31% Total... 1,275 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 1,007 98.82% Write-In 12 1.18% Total... 1,019 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 524 41.23% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 743 58.46% Write-In 4 0.31% Total... 1,271 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 507 40.50% DEM - Tim Novak 743 59.35%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 4 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Birch Run Township Precinct 1 TREASURER Write-In 2 0.16% Total... 1,252 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 984 98.60% Write-In 14 1.40% Total... 998 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 956 98.56% Write-In 14 1.44% Total... 970 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 7 REP - Dana Young 486 37.53% DEM - Cheryl Marie Hadsall 806 62.24% Write-In 3 0.23% Total... 1,295 100.00% BIRCH RUN TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Ray Letterman 713 55.31% DEM - CJ Norris 527 40.88% Write-In 49 3.80% Total... 1,289 100.00% BIRCH RUN TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Blaike Stafford 385 29.30% DEM - Corey Trinklein 757 57.61% NPA - DeAnna Geisenhaver 170 12.94% Write-In 2 0.15% Total... 1,314 100.00% BIRCH RUN TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Tara DiBerardino 506 39.62% DEM - Debbie Trevino 769 60.22% Write-In 2 0.16% Total... 1,277 100.00% BIRCH RUN TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Michael Marr 514 11.57% REP - Pam Moore 552 12.42% REP - Fred Sheridan 587 13.21% DEM - Fred Jimenez 613 13.79% DEM - Edward Magnus 714 16.07% DEM - William D Nelson 612 13.77% DEM - Brady J Totten 845 19.01% Write-In 7 0.16% Total... 4,444 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 60 3.06% Connie Marie Kelley 499 25.45% Stephen Markman 469 23.92% Bridget Mary McCormack 448 22.85% Kerry L Morgan 80 4.08% Colleen O'Brien 325 16.57% Bob Roddis 73 3.72% Write-In 7 0.36% Total... 1,961 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 81 7.68% Shelia Johnson 466 44.17% Brian Zahra 504 47.77% Write-In 4 0.38% Total... 1,055 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 717 49.90% Peter D O'Connell 712 49.55% Write-In 8 0.56% Total... 1,437 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 819 98.67% Write-In 11 1.33% Total... 830 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 728 50.38% Darnell Jackson 706 48.86% Write-In 11 0.76% Total... 1,445 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 840 99.06% Write-In 8 0.94% Total... 848 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 855 99.07% Write-In 8 0.93% Total... 863 100.00% BIRCH RUN AREA SCHOOLS Todd Ferguson 744 38.10%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 5 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Birch Run Township Precinct 1 BIRCH RUN AREA SCHOOLS Steve Griggs 248 12.70% Nan Haley 730 37.38% Travis Maginity 225 11.52% Write-In 6 0.31% Total... 1,953 100.00% CLIO AREA Bob Gaffney 6 50.00% Stephen A Nordstrom 2 16.67% Eric Wood 4 33.33% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 12 0.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 829 99.28% Write-In 6 0.72% Total... 835 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 270 32.57% Michael D Rowley 557 67.19% Write-In 2 0.24% Total... 829 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 783 99.49% Write-In 4 0.51% Total... 787 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 528 38.97% NO 827 61.03% Total... 1,355 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 615 44.83% NO 757 55.17% Total... 1,372 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 474 34.60% NO 896 65.40% Total... 1,370 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 613 44.91% NO 752 55.09% Total... 1,365 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 471 34.97% NO 876 65.03% Total... 1,347 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 685 50.15% NO 681 49.85% Total... 1,366 100.00% Delta College YES 653 50.12% NO 650 49.88% Total... 1,303 100.00% Birch Run Township Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 1,115 Election Day Turnout 704 63.14% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 704 63.14% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 313 44.97% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 374 53.74% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 2 0.29% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 3 0.43% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 4 0.57% Total... 696 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 220 32.12% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 440 64.23% LIBR - Scotty Boman 15 2.19% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 4 0.58% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 5 0.73% NATLAW - John D Litle 1 0.15% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 685 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 374 55.65% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 281 41.82% LIBR - John Gelineau 6 0.89%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 6 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Birch Run Township Precinct 2 US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST USTAX - George M Zimmer 7 1.04% GRN - Pat Timmons 3 0.45% Write-In 1 0.15% Total... 672 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 301 45.61% DEM - Judith Lincoln 357 54.09% Write-In 2 0.30% Total... 660 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 240 20.53% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 233 19.93% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 333 28.49% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 273 23.35% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 22 1.88% USTAX - Karen Adams 34 2.91% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 9 0.77% GRN - Candace R Caveny 11 0.94% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 10 0.86% Write-In 4 0.34% Total... 1,169 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 241 20.88% REP - Robert Steele 214 18.54% DEM - Mark Bernstein 352 30.50% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 279 24.18% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 9 0.78% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 10 0.87% USTAX - Joe Sanger 9 0.78% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 11 0.95% GRN - Eric Borregard 10 0.87% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 15 1.30% Write-In 4 0.35% Total... 1,154 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 252 22.50% REP - Jeff Sakwa 206 18.39% DEM - Joel Ferguson 330 29.46% DEM - Brian Mosallam 262 23.39% LIBR - Michael H Miller 20 1.79% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 19 1.70% USTAX - Stephen J Young 15 1.34% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 12 1.07% Write-In 4 0.36% Total... 1,120 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 235 21.46% REP - Satish B Jasti 183 16.71% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 329 30.05% DEM - Kim Trent 286 26.12% USTAX - Robert Gale 19 1.74% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 16 1.46% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 12 1.10% GRN - Latham Redding 11 1.00% Write-In 4 0.37% Total... 1,095 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 246 37.39% DEM - John McColgan Jr 410 62.31% Write-In 2 0.30% Total... 658 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 512 98.46% Write-In 8 1.54% Total... 520 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 265 40.64% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 385 59.05% Write-In 2 0.31% Total... 652 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 232 36.65% DEM - Tim Novak 398 62.88% Write-In 3 0.47% Total... 633 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 515 97.91% Write-In 11 2.09% Total... 526 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 507 98.64%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 7 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Birch Run Township Precinct 2 PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER Write-In 7 1.36% Total... 514 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 7 REP - Dana Young 213 32.47% DEM - Cheryl Marie Hadsall 439 66.92% Write-In 4 0.61% Total... 656 100.00% BIRCH RUN TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Ray Letterman 358 54.82% DEM - CJ Norris 277 42.42% Write-In 18 2.76% Total... 653 100.00% BIRCH RUN TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Blaike Stafford 184 27.84% DEM - Corey Trinklein 411 62.18% NPA - DeAnna Geisenhaver 62 9.38% Write-In 4 0.61% Total... 661 100.00% BIRCH RUN TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Tara DiBerardino 263 40.21% DEM - Debbie Trevino 389 59.48% Write-In 2 0.31% Total... 654 100.00% BIRCH RUN TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Michael Marr 242 10.86% REP - Pam Moore 309 13.87% REP - Fred Sheridan 295 13.24% DEM - Fred Jimenez 354 15.89% DEM - Edward Magnus 301 13.51% DEM - William D Nelson 281 12.61% DEM - Brady J Totten 438 19.66% Write-In 8 0.36% Total... 2,228 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 28 2.87% Connie Marie Kelley 186 19.08% Stephen Markman 212 21.74% Bridget Mary McCormack 259 26.56% Kerry L Morgan 43 4.41% Colleen O'Brien 209 21.44% Bob Roddis 35 3.59% Write-In 3 0.31% Total... 975 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 72 13.79% Shelia Johnson 186 35.63% Brian Zahra 262 50.19% Write-In 2 0.38% Total... 522 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 398 52.09% Peter D O'Connell 360 47.12% Write-In 6 0.79% Total... 764 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 428 98.17% Write-In 8 1.83% Total... 436 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 384 50.53% Darnell Jackson 370 48.68% Write-In 6 0.79% Total... 760 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 455 98.48% Write-In 7 1.52% Total... 462 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 449 98.25% Write-In 8 1.75% Total... 457 100.00% VILLAGE OF BIRCH RUN TRUSTEE Patrick Gillett 384 33.36% Marianne D Nelson 381 33.10% Matthew Welch 369 32.06% Write-In 17 1.48% Total... 1,151 100.00% BIRCH RUN AREA SCHOOLS Todd Ferguson 355 35.43% Steve Griggs 151 15.07% Nan Haley 389 38.82%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 8 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Birch Run Township Precinct 2 BIRCH RUN AREA SCHOOLS Travis Maginity 98 9.78% Write-In 9 0.90% Total... 1,002 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 447 98.03% Write-In 9 1.97% Total... 456 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 141 31.90% Michael D Rowley 298 67.42% Write-In 3 0.68% Total... 442 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 422 97.24% Write-In 12 2.76% Total... 434 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 300 44.18% NO 379 55.82% Total... 679 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 288 42.35% NO 392 57.65% Total... 680 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 284 41.52% NO 400 58.48% Total... 684 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 329 48.45% NO 350 51.55% Total... 679 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 250 37.09% NO 424 62.91% Total... 674 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 331 48.39% NO 353 51.61% Total... 684 100.00% Delta College YES 359 55.32% NO 290 44.68% Total... 649 100.00% Birch Run Township Precinct 3 Registration & Turnout 1,478 Election Day Turnout 1,131 76.52% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,131 76.52% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 745 66.22% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 370 32.89% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 4 0.36% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 2 0.18% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 4 0.36% Total... 1,125 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 620 55.71% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 468 42.05% LIBR - Scotty Boman 18 1.62% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 4 0.36% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 3 0.27% NATLAW - John D Litle 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,113 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 786 71.91% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 276 25.25% LIBR - John Gelineau 19 1.74% USTAX - George M Zimmer 4 0.37% GRN - Pat Timmons 8 0.73% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,093 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 725 67.95% DEM - Judith Lincoln 342 32.05%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 9 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Birch Run Township Precinct 3 STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,067 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 602 31.31% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 587 30.53% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 358 18.62% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 269 13.99% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 28 1.46% USTAX - Karen Adams 35 1.82% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 16 0.83% GRN - Candace R Caveny 18 0.94% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 10 0.52% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,923 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 582 30.70% REP - Robert Steele 570 30.06% DEM - Mark Bernstein 377 19.88% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 280 14.77% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 22 1.16% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 16 0.84% USTAX - Joe Sanger 11 0.58% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 13 0.69% GRN - Eric Borregard 11 0.58% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 14 0.74% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,896 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 617 33.32% REP - Jeff Sakwa 548 29.59% DEM - Joel Ferguson 343 18.52% DEM - Brian Mosallam 264 14.25% LIBR - Michael H Miller 32 1.73% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 14 0.76% USTAX - Stephen J Young 17 0.92% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 17 0.92% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,852 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 581 32.37% REP - Satish B Jasti 498 27.74% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 361 20.11% DEM - Kim Trent 285 15.88% USTAX - Robert Gale 27 1.50% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 12 0.67% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 19 1.06% GRN - Latham Redding 12 0.67% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,795 0.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 640 62.26% DEM - John McColgan Jr 387 37.65% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,028 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 705 98.88% Write-In 8 1.12% Total... 713 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 599 58.96% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 417 41.04% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,016 0.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 600 59.94% DEM - Tim Novak 400 39.96% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,001 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 681 98.98% Write-In 7 1.02% Total... 688 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 659 98.95% Write-In 7 1.05% Total... 666 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 8 REP - Dennis Krafft 824 98.10% Write-In 16 1.90% Total... 840 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 10 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Birch Run Township Precinct 3 BIRCH RUN TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Ray Letterman 676 66.54% DEM - CJ Norris 301 29.63% Write-In 39 3.84% Total... 1,016 100.00% BIRCH RUN TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Blaike Stafford 484 47.13% DEM - Corey Trinklein 431 41.97% NPA - DeAnna Geisenhaver 111 10.81% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,027 100.00% BIRCH RUN TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Tara DiBerardino 586 57.56% DEM - Debbie Trevino 430 42.24% Write-In 2 0.20% Total... 1,018 100.00% BIRCH RUN TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Michael Marr 620 18.39% REP - Pam Moore 614 18.21% REP - Fred Sheridan 611 18.12% DEM - Fred Jimenez 315 9.34% DEM - Edward Magnus 414 12.28% DEM - William D Nelson 321 9.52% DEM - Brady J Totten 477 14.15% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 3,372 0.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 57 3.54% Connie Marie Kelley 254 15.79% Stephen Markman 423 26.29% Bridget Mary McCormack 357 22.19% Kerry L Morgan 72 4.47% Colleen O'Brien 397 24.67% Bob Roddis 49 3.05% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,609 0.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 79 9.21% Shelia Johnson 264 30.77% Brian Zahra 514 59.91% Write-In 1 0.12% Total... 858 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 627 52.34% Peter D O'Connell 566 47.25% Write-In 5 0.42% Total... 1,198 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 637 99.07% Write-In 6 0.93% Total... 643 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 595 50.13% Darnell Jackson 586 49.37% Write-In 6 0.51% Total... 1,187 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 673 99.12% Write-In 6 0.88% Total... 679 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 675 98.97% Write-In 7 1.03% Total... 682 100.00% BIRCH RUN AREA SCHOOLS Todd Ferguson 221 37.71% Steve Griggs 90 15.36% Nan Haley 223 38.05% Travis Maginity 51 8.70% Write-In 1 0.17% Total... 586 100.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS Lori Ettema 325 32.02% David E Harris 335 33.00% Karen Uebler 352 34.68% Write-In 3 0.30% Total... 1,015 100.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS PARTIAL Al Zehnder 508 99.41% Write-In 3 0.59% Total... 511 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 11 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Birch Run Township Precinct 3 DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 667 99.40% Write-In 4 0.60% Total... 671 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 186 28.70% Michael D Rowley 461 71.14% Write-In 1 0.15% Total... 648 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 637 99.84% Write-In 1 0.16% Total... 638 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 571 52.43% NO 518 47.57% Total... 1,089 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 322 29.30% NO 777 70.70% Total... 1,099 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 275 25.05% NO 823 74.95% Total... 1,098 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 338 30.87% NO 757 69.13% Total... 1,095 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 321 29.37% NO 772 70.63% Total... 1,093 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 439 39.80% NO 664 60.20% Total... 1,103 100.00% Delta College YES 524 49.86% NO 527 50.14% Total... 1,051 100.00% Blumfield Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,560 Election Day Turnout 1,190 76.28% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,190 76.28% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 868 73.25% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 303 25.57% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 6 0.51% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 3 0.25% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 3 0.25% Write-In 2 0.17% Total... 1,185 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 725 61.81% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 427 36.40% LIBR - Scotty Boman 9 0.77% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 7 0.60% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 1 0.09% NATLAW - John D Litle 4 0.34% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,173 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST REP - Jim Slezak 739 64.60% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 378 33.04% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 13 1.14% NPA - David Davenport 14 1.22% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,144 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 861 75.07% DEM - Judith Lincoln 283 24.67% Write-In 3 0.26% Total... 1,147 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 728 35.44% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 704 34.27% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 287 13.97%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 12 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Blumfield Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 217 10.56% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 25 1.22% USTAX - Karen Adams 40 1.95% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 22 1.07% GRN - Candace R Caveny 19 0.93% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 12 0.58% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 2,054 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 714 35.10% REP - Robert Steele 680 33.43% DEM - Mark Bernstein 319 15.68% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 226 11.11% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 11 0.54% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 13 0.64% USTAX - Joe Sanger 16 0.79% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 22 1.08% GRN - Eric Borregard 15 0.74% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 18 0.88% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 2,034 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 729 36.27% REP - Jeff Sakwa 665 33.08% DEM - Joel Ferguson 303 15.07% DEM - Brian Mosallam 226 11.24% LIBR - Michael H Miller 26 1.29% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 29 1.44% USTAX - Stephen J Young 22 1.09% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 10 0.50% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 2,010 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 703 36.09% REP - Satish B Jasti 606 31.11% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 308 15.81% DEM - Kim Trent 237 12.17% USTAX - Robert Gale 43 2.21% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 23 1.18% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 19 0.98% GRN - Latham Redding 9 0.46% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,948 0.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 770 69.87% DEM - John McColgan Jr 332 30.13% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,102 0.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 700 98.18% Write-In 13 1.82% Total... 713 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 707 63.87% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 398 35.95% Write-In 2 0.18% Total... 1,107 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 781 70.61% DEM - Tim Novak 325 29.39% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,106 0.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 691 98.71% Write-In 9 1.29% Total... 700 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 662 98.37% Write-In 11 1.63% Total... 673 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 8 REP - Dennis Krafft 947 99.06% Write-In 9 0.94% Total... 956 100.00% BLUMFIELD TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Wesley A Reinbold 976 99.19% Write-In 8 0.81% Total... 984 100.00% BLUMFIELD TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Lisa Roethlisberger 968 99.08%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 13 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Blumfield Township Precinct 1 BLUMFIELD TOWNSHIP CLERK Write-In 9 0.92% Total... 977 100.00% BLUMFIELD TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Sandra J Daenzer 980 99.09% Write-In 9 0.91% Total... 989 100.00% BLUMFIELD TOWNHIP TRUSTEES REP - Eric Frahm 906 50.19% REP - Kenneth Huber 889 49.25% Write-In 10 0.55% Total... 1,805 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 50 2.99% Connie Marie Kelley 254 15.17% Stephen Markman 428 25.57% Bridget Mary McCormack 238 14.22% Kerry L Morgan 146 8.72% Colleen O'Brien 498 29.75% Bob Roddis 55 3.29% Write-In 5 0.30% Total... 1,674 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 50 5.52% Shelia Johnson 295 32.56% Brian Zahra 558 61.59% Write-In 3 0.33% Total... 906 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 700 50.91% Peter D O'Connell 663 48.22% Write-In 12 0.87% Total... 1,375 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 736 99.19% Write-In 6 0.81% Total... 742 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 700 50.87% Darnell Jackson 663 48.18% Write-In 13 0.94% Total... 1,376 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 759 99.22% Write-In 6 0.78% Total... 765 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 781 99.24% Write-In 6 0.76% Total... 787 100.00% VILLAGE OF REESE PRESIDENT Jerry Ellison 3 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 3 0.00% VILLAGE OF REESE TRUSTEES Pete Bouvy 2 28.57% Denise Fielbrandt 2 28.57% John Weber 3 42.86% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 7 0.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS Lori Ettema 234 28.92% David E Harris 250 30.90% Karen Uebler 321 39.68% Write-In 4 0.49% Total... 809 100.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS PARTIAL Al Zehnder 407 99.51% Write-In 2 0.49% Total... 409 100.00% REESE PUBLIC SCHOOLS Jill Palm Lynch 462 95.06% Write-In 24 4.94% Total... 486 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 751 98.95% Write-In 8 1.05% Total... 759 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 281 39.52% Michael D Rowley 424 59.63%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 14 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Blumfield Township Precinct 1 DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY Write-In 6 0.84% Total... 711 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 708 99.02% Write-In 7 0.98% Total... 715 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 624 53.89% NO 534 46.11% Total... 1,158 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 270 23.14% NO 897 76.86% Total... 1,167 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 195 16.74% NO 970 83.26% Total... 1,165 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 279 24.22% NO 873 75.78% Total... 1,152 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 266 23.01% NO 890 76.99% Total... 1,156 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 382 32.85% NO 781 67.15% Total... 1,163 100.00% Blumfield Township YES 484 42.68% NO 650 57.32% Total... 1,134 100.00% Delta College YES 569 51.22% NO 542 48.78% Total... 1,111 100.00% Brady Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,655 Election Day Turnout 1,044 63.08% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,044 63.08% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 492 47.91% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 514 50.05% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 6 0.58% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 8 0.78% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.10% Write-In 6 0.58% Total... 1,027 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 341 33.83% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 618 61.31% LIBR - Scotty Boman 27 2.68% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 14 1.39% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.40% NATLAW - John D Litle 4 0.40% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,008 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 613 61.73% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 349 35.15% LIBR - John Gelineau 13 1.31% USTAX - George M Zimmer 15 1.51% GRN - Pat Timmons 2 0.20% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 993 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 85 TH DIST REP - Ben Glardon 524 54.13% DEM - Paul Ray 365 37.71% NPA - Matthew Shepard 75 7.75% Write-In 4 0.41% Total... 968 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 362 21.57% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 364 21.69% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 432 25.74%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 15 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Brady Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 354 21.10% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 43 2.56% USTAX - Karen Adams 57 3.40% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 21 1.25% GRN - Candace R Caveny 21 1.25% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 19 1.13% Write-In 5 0.30% Total... 1,678 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 347 21.12% REP - Robert Steele 327 19.90% DEM - Mark Bernstein 438 26.66% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 388 23.62% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 25 1.52% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 16 0.97% USTAX - Joe Sanger 31 1.89% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 24 1.46% GRN - Eric Borregard 16 0.97% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 24 1.46% Write-In 7 0.43% Total... 1,643 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 376 23.12% REP - Jeff Sakwa 298 18.33% DEM - Joel Ferguson 431 26.51% DEM - Brian Mosallam 365 22.45% LIBR - Michael H Miller 46 2.83% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 39 2.40% USTAX - Stephen J Young 37 2.28% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 27 1.66% Write-In 7 0.43% Total... 1,626 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 341 21.50% REP - Satish B Jasti 276 17.40% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 449 28.31% DEM - Kim Trent 398 25.09% USTAX - Robert Gale 45 2.84% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 30 1.89% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 20 1.26% GRN - Latham Redding 21 1.32% Write-In 6 0.38% Total... 1,586 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 444 47.64% DEM - John McColgan Jr 481 51.61% Write-In 7 0.75% Total... 932 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 752 97.54% Write-In 19 2.46% Total... 771 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 383 40.88% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 548 58.48% Write-In 6 0.64% Total... 937 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 363 39.33% DEM - Tim Novak 555 60.13% Write-In 5 0.54% Total... 923 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 750 98.43% Write-In 12 1.57% Total... 762 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 726 98.11% Write-In 14 1.89% Total... 740 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 6 REP - Ron Sholtz 438 44.60% DEM - Katie Greenfelder 541 55.09% Write-In 3 0.31% Total... 982 100.00% BRADY TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Steven K Kienitz 448 45.53% DEM - Ronald Gasper 531 53.96% Write-In 5 0.51% Total... 984 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 16 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Brady Township Precinct 1 BRADY TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Beverly Wenzlick 794 98.76% Write-In 10 1.24% Total... 804 100.00% BRADY TOWNSHIP TREASURER DEM - Patricia A Goodrich 806 99.02% Write-In 8 0.98% Total... 814 100.00% BRADY TOWNHP TRUSTEES REP - Glen Reeves 581 49.03% DEM - Sue Peterson 594 50.13% Write-In 10 0.84% Total... 1,185 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 72 5.22% Connie Marie Kelley 267 19.35% Stephen Markman 274 19.86% Bridget Mary McCormack 266 19.28% Kerry L Morgan 58 4.20% Colleen O'Brien 370 26.81% Bob Roddis 63 4.57% Write-In 10 0.72% Total... 1,380 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 102 13.35% Shelia Johnson 279 36.52% Brian Zahra 376 49.21% Write-In 7 0.92% Total... 764 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 517 48.59% Peter D O'Connell 535 50.28% Write-In 12 1.13% Total... 1,064 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 630 98.28% Write-In 11 1.72% Total... 641 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 530 50.43% Darnell Jackson 509 48.43% Write-In 12 1.14% Total... 1,051 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 639 98.46% Write-In 10 1.54% Total... 649 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 647 98.63% Write-In 9 1.37% Total... 656 100.00% VILLAGE OF OAKLEY PRESIDENT Shannon Bitterman 60 41.38% Douglas Shindorf 85 58.62% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 145 0.00% VILLAGE OF OAKLEY CLERK Cheryl Bolf 116 98.31% Write-In 2 1.69% Total... 118 100.00% VILLAGE OF OAKLEY TREASURER Write-In 37 100.00% Total... 37 100.00% VILLAGE OF OAKLEY TRUSTEES Dennis Bitterman 69 18.06% Art Early 61 15.97% Richard Fish 62 16.23% James Frelitz 48 12.57% Francis Koski 72 18.85% Norm Wolfe 69 18.06% Write-In 1 0.26% Total... 382 100.00% VILLAGE OF OAKLEY TRUSTEE 2 PARTIAL Susan M Dingo 103 94.50% Write-In 6 5.50% Total... 109 100.00% CHESANING UNION SCHOOLS 4 YR Brian W Lewis 540 44.15% Julia Schultz Sadilek 669 54.70% Write-In 14 1.14% Total... 1,223 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 17 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Brady Township Precinct 1 DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 634 98.29% Write-In 11 1.71% Total... 645 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 243 37.67% Michael D Rowley 393 60.93% Write-In 9 1.40% Total... 645 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 597 98.84% Write-In 7 1.16% Total... 604 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 361 36.46% NO 629 63.54% Total... 990 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 363 35.80% NO 651 64.20% Total... 1,014 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 340 33.83% NO 665 66.17% Total... 1,005 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 381 38.02% NO 621 61.98% Total... 1,002 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 341 34.00% NO 662 66.00% Total... 1,003 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 541 54.05% NO 460 45.95% Total... 1,001 100.00% Delta College YES 420 44.35% NO 527 55.65% Total... 947 100.00% Brant Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,495 Election Day Turnout 991 66.29% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 991 66.29% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 531 54.02% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 433 44.05% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 5 0.51% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 5 0.51% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 4 0.41% Write-In 5 0.51% Total... 983 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 429 44.50% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 503 52.18% LIBR - Scotty Boman 17 1.76% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 6 0.62% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.41% NATLAW - John D Litle 5 0.52% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 964 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 643 67.33% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 282 29.53% LIBR - John Gelineau 11 1.15% USTAX - George M Zimmer 12 1.26% GRN - Pat Timmons 7 0.73% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 955 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 85 TH DIST REP - Ben Glardon 513 56.13% DEM - Paul Ray 320 35.01% NPA - Matthew Shepard 78 8.53% Write-In 3 0.33% Total... 914 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 407 25.96%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 18 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Brant Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Melanie A Kurdys 392 25.00% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 358 22.83% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 274 17.47% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 26 1.66% USTAX - Karen Adams 45 2.87% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 27 1.72% GRN - Candace R Caveny 24 1.53% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 13 0.83% Write-In 2 0.13% Total... 1,568 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 379 24.76% REP - Robert Steele 378 24.69% DEM - Mark Bernstein 339 22.14% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 314 20.51% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 15 0.98% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 14 0.91% USTAX - Joe Sanger 31 2.02% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 26 1.70% GRN - Eric Borregard 14 0.91% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 19 1.24% Write-In 2 0.13% Total... 1,531 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 416 27.68% REP - Jeff Sakwa 351 23.35% DEM - Joel Ferguson 343 22.82% DEM - Brian Mosallam 279 18.56% LIBR - Michael H Miller 27 1.80% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 33 2.20% USTAX - Stephen J Young 36 2.40% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 17 1.13% Write-In 1 0.07% Total... 1,503 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 382 26.06% REP - Satish B Jasti 323 22.03% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 350 23.87% DEM - Kim Trent 300 20.46% USTAX - Robert Gale 42 2.86% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 30 2.05% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 24 1.64% GRN - Latham Redding 13 0.89% Write-In 2 0.14% Total... 1,466 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 457 50.83% DEM - John McColgan Jr 438 48.72% Write-In 4 0.44% Total... 899 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 661 98.07% Write-In 13 1.93% Total... 674 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 424 47.32% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 469 52.34% Write-In 3 0.33% Total... 896 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 448 50.85% DEM - Tim Novak 428 48.58% Write-In 5 0.57% Total... 881 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 645 98.02% Write-In 13 1.98% Total... 658 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 605 96.65% Write-In 21 3.35% Total... 626 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 6 REP - Ron Sholtz 504 54.55% DEM - Katie Greenfelder 420 45.45% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 924 0.00% BRANT TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR DEM - Raymond Walker 688 97.73% Write-In 16 2.27% Total... 704 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 19 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Brant Township Precinct 1 BRANT TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Theresa Schroeder 747 97.77% Write-In 17 2.23% Total... 764 100.00% BRANT TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Paula J Cooper 717 98.90% Write-In 8 1.10% Total... 725 100.00% BRANT TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Barbara Fowler 576 52.55% DEM - Ken Smith 515 46.99% Write-In 5 0.46% Total... 1,096 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 87 6.56% Connie Marie Kelley 263 19.82% Stephen Markman 313 23.59% Bridget Mary McCormack 254 19.14% Kerry L Morgan 61 4.60% Colleen O'Brien 269 20.27% Bob Roddis 75 5.65% Write-In 5 0.38% Total... 1,327 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 99 13.83% Shelia Johnson 250 34.92% Brian Zahra 363 50.70% Write-In 4 0.56% Total... 716 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 521 52.31% Peter D O'Connell 465 46.69% Write-In 10 1.00% Total... 996 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 554 98.58% Write-In 8 1.42% Total... 562 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 484 49.24% Darnell Jackson 490 49.85% Write-In 9 0.92% Total... 983 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 575 98.46% Write-In 9 1.54% Total... 584 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 595 98.18% Write-In 11 1.82% Total... 606 100.00% VILLAGE OF ST. CHARLES PRESIDENT Doug Holem 11 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 11 0.00% VILLAGE OF ST. CHARLES 4 YR TRUSTEES Gary Breidinger 6 28.57% Marie Roe 7 33.33% Lois Theile 8 38.10% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 21 0.00% CHESANING UNION SCHOOLS 4 YR Brian W Lewis 170 46.07% Julia Schultz Sadilek 198 53.66% Write-In 1 0.27% Total... 369 100.00% MERRILL COMMUNITY SCHOOLS Matthew H Miller 5 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 5 0.00% MERRILL SCHOOL PARTIAL Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 0 0.00% ST CHARLES COMM SCHOOL 6 YR BD MEMBER6 Laurasue Hensel Holcomb 417 91.05% Write-In 41 8.95% Total... 458 100.00% ST CHARLES COMM SCHOOLS 2YR Ronald Gonzales 449 97.82% Write-In 10 2.18% Total... 459 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 20 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Brant Township Precinct 1 DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 551 98.75% Write-In 7 1.25% Total... 558 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 206 38.43% Michael D Rowley 322 60.07% Write-In 8 1.49% Total... 536 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 518 98.85% Write-In 6 1.15% Total... 524 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 391 41.16% NO 559 58.84% Total... 950 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 370 38.78% NO 584 61.22% Total... 954 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 267 27.70% NO 697 72.30% Total... 964 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 368 38.49% NO 588 61.51% Total... 956 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 336 35.22% NO 618 64.78% Total... 954 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 470 48.76% NO 494 51.24% Total... 964 100.00% Delta College YES 434 48.06% NO 469 51.94% Total... 903 100.00% Bridgeport Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 942 Election Day Turnout 462 49.04% AV Polling Turnout 150 15.92% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 612 64.97% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 235 38.71% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 359 59.14% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.16% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 3 0.49% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.16% Write-In 8 1.32% Total... 607 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 183 30.86% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 385 64.92% LIBR - Scotty Boman 14 2.36% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 3 0.51% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.67% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.34% Write-In 2 0.34% Total... 593 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 187 31.97% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 375 64.10% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 6 1.03% NPA - David Davenport 15 2.56% Write-In 2 0.34% Total... 585 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 195 33.85% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 378 65.63% Write-In 3 0.52% Total... 576 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 186 17.68% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 184 17.49% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 324 30.80%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 21 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Bridgeport Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 293 27.85% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 11 1.05% USTAX - Karen Adams 19 1.81% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 10 0.95% GRN - Candace R Caveny 12 1.14% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 9 0.86% Write-In 4 0.38% Total... 1,052 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 166 15.66% REP - Robert Steele 174 16.42% DEM - Mark Bernstein 360 33.96% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 311 29.34% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 6 0.57% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 10 0.94% USTAX - Joe Sanger 7 0.66% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 7 0.66% GRN - Eric Borregard 7 0.66% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 10 0.94% Write-In 2 0.19% Total... 1,060 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 184 17.90% REP - Jeff Sakwa 166 16.15% DEM - Joel Ferguson 325 31.61% DEM - Brian Mosallam 299 29.09% LIBR - Michael H Miller 8 0.78% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 18 1.75% USTAX - Stephen J Young 12 1.17% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 13 1.26% Write-In 3 0.29% Total... 1,028 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 176 17.41% REP - Satish B Jasti 156 15.43% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 334 33.04% DEM - Kim Trent 301 29.77% USTAX - Robert Gale 13 1.29% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 7 0.69% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 13 1.29% GRN - Latham Redding 8 0.79% Write-In 3 0.30% Total... 1,011 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 183 31.88% DEM - John McColgan Jr 387 67.42% Write-In 4 0.70% Total... 574 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 463 98.72% Write-In 6 1.28% Total... 469 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 178 31.34% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 386 67.96% Write-In 4 0.70% Total... 568 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 184 32.74% DEM - Tim Novak 376 66.90% Write-In 2 0.36% Total... 562 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 458 99.35% Write-In 3 0.65% Total... 461 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 459 98.92% Write-In 5 1.08% Total... 464 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 8 (Final) REP - Dennis Krafft 301 92.05% Write-In 26 7.95% Total... 327 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) REP - Sean Connors 167 29.09% DEM - Augie Tausend 405 70.56% Write-In 2 0.35% Total... 574 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) DEM - Darlene Miller 462 98.93%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 22 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Bridgeport Township Precinct 1 BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) Write-In 5 1.07% Total... 467 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) DEM - Walter LaShore 442 98.88% Write-In 5 1.12% Total... 447 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) DEM - Vanessa Guerra 412 25.70% DEM - Jim Secord 405 25.27% DEM - Darrell Thayer 383 23.89% DEM - Heather Wilson 394 24.58% Write-In 9 0.56% Total... 1,603 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 35 4.13% Connie Marie Kelley 220 25.97% Stephen Markman 168 19.83% Bridget Mary McCormack 232 27.39% Kerry L Morgan 28 3.31% Colleen O'Brien 146 17.24% Bob Roddis 13 1.53% Write-In 5 0.59% Total... 847 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 41 8.45% Shelia Johnson 252 51.96% Brian Zahra 190 39.18% Write-In 2 0.41% Total... 485 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 360 54.63% Peter D O'Connell 287 43.55% Write-In 12 1.82% Total... 659 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 367 97.87% Write-In 8 2.13% Total... 375 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 299 44.89% Darnell Jackson 362 54.35% Write-In 5 0.75% Total... 666 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 402 98.53% Write-In 6 1.47% Total... 408 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 421 98.59% Write-In 6 1.41% Total... 427 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP LIBRARY BOARD (Final) Charles Booth 261 15.86% Portia Drusilla Brown 271 16.46% William J Cannon 261 15.86% Juanita Foxx 287 17.44% Gerardo Gonzalez 290 17.62% Marlene Muhlenkamp 266 16.16% Write-In 10 0.61% Total... 1,646 100.00% BRIDGEPORT-SPAULDING COMM 4 YR SCHOOLS (Final) Martha A Sageman 316 47.09% Andrea J LaBean 324 48.29% Write-In 31 4.62% Total... 671 100.00% BRIDGEPORT-SPAULDING COMM 2 YR SCHOOL PARTIAL (Final) Write-In 74 100.00% Total... 74 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 375 99.21% Write-In 3 0.79% Total... 378 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 137 37.85% Michael D Rowley 220 60.77% Write-In 5 1.38% Total... 362 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 332 97.94% Write-In 7 2.06% Total... 339 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 23 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Bridgeport Township Precinct 1 State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 200 34.78% NO 375 65.22% Total... 575 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 301 50.84% NO 291 49.16% Total... 592 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 240 41.03% NO 345 58.97% Total... 585 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 316 53.92% NO 270 46.08% Total... 586 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 177 30.15% NO 410 69.85% Total... 587 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 318 53.90% NO 272 46.10% Total... 590 100.00% Bridgeport Township Fire (Final) YES 277 48.60% NO 293 51.40% Total... 570 100.00% Bridgeport Township Law (Final) YES 271 48.13% NO 292 51.87% Total... 563 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 327 58.92% NO 228 41.08% Total... 555 100.00% Bridgeport Township Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 1,964 Election Day Turnout 788 40.12% AV Polling Turnout 230 11.71% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,018 51.83% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 314 31.18% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 684 67.92% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 2 0.20% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 4 0.40% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.10% Write-In 2 0.20% Total... 1,007 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 229 23.42% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 717 73.31% LIBR - Scotty Boman 10 1.02% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 7 0.72% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 6 0.61% NATLAW - John D Litle 8 0.82% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 978 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 242 25.10% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 679 70.44% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 14 1.45% NPA - David Davenport 27 2.80% Write-In 2 0.21% Total... 964 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 258 27.02% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 690 72.25% Write-In 7 0.73% Total... 955 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 231 13.32% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 215 12.40% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 600 34.60% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 570 32.87% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 22 1.27% USTAX - Karen Adams 46 2.65% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 18 1.04% GRN - Candace R Caveny 18 1.04%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 24 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Bridgeport Township Precinct 2 MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 6 0.35% Write-In 8 0.46% Total... 1,734 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 224 12.89% REP - Robert Steele 214 12.31% DEM - Mark Bernstein 606 34.87% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 582 33.49% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 20 1.15% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 14 0.81% USTAX - Joe Sanger 23 1.32% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 13 0.75% GRN - Eric Borregard 15 0.86% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 22 1.27% Write-In 5 0.29% Total... 1,738 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 243 14.15% REP - Jeff Sakwa 212 12.35% DEM - Joel Ferguson 611 35.59% DEM - Brian Mosallam 549 31.97% LIBR - Michael H Miller 22 1.28% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 24 1.40% USTAX - Stephen J Young 28 1.63% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 19 1.11% Write-In 9 0.52% Total... 1,717 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 216 12.89% REP - Satish B Jasti 171 10.20% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 620 36.99% DEM - Kim Trent 575 34.31% USTAX - Robert Gale 27 1.61% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 23 1.37% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 23 1.37% GRN - Latham Redding 12 0.72% Write-In 9 0.54% Total... 1,676 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 255 26.87% DEM - John McColgan Jr 690 72.71% Write-In 4 0.42% Total... 949 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 801 97.68% Write-In 19 2.32% Total... 820 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 247 26.42% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 681 72.83% Write-In 7 0.75% Total... 935 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 237 25.43% DEM - Tim Novak 691 74.14% Write-In 4 0.43% Total... 932 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 797 98.27% Write-In 14 1.73% Total... 811 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 780 98.36% Write-In 13 1.64% Total... 793 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 8 (Final) REP - Dennis Krafft 431 85.35% Write-In 74 14.65% Total... 505 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) REP - Sean Connors 262 27.84% DEM - Augie Tausend 670 71.20% Write-In 9 0.96% Total... 941 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) DEM - Darlene Miller 770 97.84% Write-In 17 2.16% Total... 787 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) DEM - Walter LaShore 756 97.42%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 25 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Bridgeport Township Precinct 2 BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) Write-In 20 2.58% Total... 776 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) DEM - Vanessa Guerra 713 25.79% DEM - Jim Secord 671 24.27% DEM - Darrell Thayer 667 24.12% DEM - Heather Wilson 684 24.74% Write-In 30 1.08% Total... 2,765 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 35 2.58% Connie Marie Kelley 385 28.33% Stephen Markman 249 18.32% Bridget Mary McCormack 398 29.29% Kerry L Morgan 51 3.75% Colleen O'Brien 184 13.54% Bob Roddis 48 3.53% Write-In 9 0.66% Total... 1,359 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 73 9.48% Shelia Johnson 397 51.56% Brian Zahra 290 37.66% Write-In 10 1.30% Total... 770 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 553 54.54% Peter D O'Connell 437 43.10% Write-In 24 2.37% Total... 1,014 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 599 95.23% Write-In 30 4.77% Total... 629 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 438 42.20% Darnell Jackson 579 55.78% Write-In 21 2.02% Total... 1,038 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 631 96.63% Write-In 22 3.37% Total... 653 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 680 97.56% Write-In 17 2.44% Total... 697 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP LIBRARY BOARD (Final) Charles Booth 376 16.23% Portia Drusilla Brown 373 16.11% William J Cannon 366 15.80% Juanita Foxx 410 17.70% Gerardo Gonzalez 399 17.23% Marlene Muhlenkamp 356 15.37% Write-In 36 1.55% Total... 2,316 100.00% BRIDGEPORT-SPAULDING COMM 4 YR SCHOOLS (Final) Martha A Sageman 519 48.69% Andrea J LaBean 480 45.03% Write-In 67 6.29% Total... 1,066 100.00% BRIDGEPORT-SPAULDING COMM 2 YR SCHOOL PARTIAL (Final) Write-In 157 100.00% Total... 157 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 598 97.24% Write-In 17 2.76% Total... 615 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 260 42.14% Michael D Rowley 343 55.59% Write-In 14 2.27% Total... 617 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 562 96.56% Write-In 20 3.44% Total... 582 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 308 34.00% NO 598 66.00% Total... 906 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 26 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Bridgeport Township Precinct 2 State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 513 54.17% NO 434 45.83% Total... 947 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 401 43.54% NO 520 56.46% Total... 921 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 556 59.53% NO 378 40.47% Total... 934 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 292 31.53% NO 634 68.47% Total... 926 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 558 59.62% NO 378 40.38% Total... 936 100.00% Bridgeport Township Fire (Final) YES 400 43.96% NO 510 56.04% Total... 910 100.00% Bridgeport Township Law (Final) YES 345 37.83% NO 567 62.17% Total... 912 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 457 51.29% NO 434 48.71% Total... 891 100.00% Bridgeport Township Precinct 3 Registration & Turnout 1,875 Election Day Turnout 968 51.63% AV Polling Turnout 263 14.03% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,231 65.65% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 588 48.28% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 610 50.08% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 5 0.41% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 5 0.41% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 4 0.33% Write-In 6 0.49% Total... 1,218 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 462 38.31% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 709 58.79% LIBR - Scotty Boman 18 1.49% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 8 0.66% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 5 0.41% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.17% Write-In 2 0.17% Total... 1,206 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 475 40.25% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 653 55.34% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 24 2.03% NPA - David Davenport 27 2.29% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,180 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 512 43.91% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 651 55.83% Write-In 3 0.26% Total... 1,166 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 456 21.55% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 460 21.74% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 560 26.47% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 469 22.16% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 33 1.56% USTAX - Karen Adams 60 2.84% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 35 1.65% GRN - Candace R Caveny 25 1.18% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 13 0.61% Write-In 5 0.24% Total... 2,116 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 27 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Bridgeport Township Precinct 3 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 433 20.67% REP - Robert Steele 424 20.24% DEM - Mark Bernstein 570 27.21% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 504 24.06% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 27 1.29% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 21 1.00% USTAX - Joe Sanger 35 1.67% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 40 1.91% GRN - Eric Borregard 16 0.76% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 21 1.00% Write-In 4 0.19% Total... 2,095 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 483 23.30% REP - Jeff Sakwa 417 20.12% DEM - Joel Ferguson 555 26.77% DEM - Brian Mosallam 471 22.72% LIBR - Michael H Miller 33 1.59% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 38 1.83% USTAX - Stephen J Young 50 2.41% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 22 1.06% Write-In 4 0.19% Total... 2,073 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 434 21.53% REP - Satish B Jasti 384 19.05% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 568 28.17% DEM - Kim Trent 498 24.70% USTAX - Robert Gale 47 2.33% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 35 1.74% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 30 1.49% GRN - Latham Redding 16 0.79% Write-In 4 0.20% Total... 2,016 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 489 42.12% DEM - John McColgan Jr 667 57.45% Write-In 5 0.43% Total... 1,161 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 869 97.09% Write-In 26 2.91% Total... 895 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 448 38.42% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 713 61.15% Write-In 5 0.43% Total... 1,166 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 484 42.46% DEM - Tim Novak 650 57.02% Write-In 6 0.53% Total... 1,140 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 876 98.87% Write-In 10 1.13% Total... 886 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 839 97.33% Write-In 23 2.67% Total... 862 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 7 (Final) REP - Dana Young 453 39.43% DEM - Cheryl Marie Hadsall 687 59.79% Write-In 9 0.78% Total... 1,149 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) REP - Sean Connors 506 43.89% DEM - Augie Tausend 640 55.51% Write-In 7 0.61% Total... 1,153 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) DEM - Darlene Miller 855 97.71% Write-In 20 2.29% Total... 875 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) DEM - Walter LaShore 823 98.33% Write-In 14 1.67% Total... 837 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) DEM - Vanessa Guerra 741 25.14%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 28 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Bridgeport Township Precinct 3 BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) DEM - Jim Secord 752 25.51% DEM - Darrell Thayer 712 24.15% DEM - Heather Wilson 729 24.73% Write-In 14 0.47% Total... 2,948 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 58 3.40% Connie Marie Kelley 294 17.23% Stephen Markman 399 23.39% Bridget Mary McCormack 454 26.61% Kerry L Morgan 54 3.17% Colleen O'Brien 377 22.10% Bob Roddis 63 3.69% Write-In 7 0.41% Total... 1,706 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 113 12.28% Shelia Johnson 378 41.09% Brian Zahra 422 45.87% Write-In 7 0.76% Total... 920 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 690 52.67% Peter D O'Connell 605 46.18% Write-In 15 1.15% Total... 1,310 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 727 97.85% Write-In 16 2.15% Total... 743 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 667 50.84% Darnell Jackson 630 48.02% Write-In 15 1.14% Total... 1,312 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 775 98.23% Write-In 14 1.77% Total... 789 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 789 98.26% Write-In 14 1.74% Total... 803 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP LIBRARY BOARD (Final) Charles Booth 533 17.24% Portia Drusilla Brown 482 15.59% William J Cannon 509 16.47% Juanita Foxx 500 16.18% Gerardo Gonzalez 509 16.47% Marlene Muhlenkamp 538 17.41% Write-In 20 0.65% Total... 3,091 100.00% BRIDGEPORT-SPAULDING COMM 4 YR SCHOOLS (Final) Martha A Sageman 653 49.85% Andrea J LaBean 598 45.65% Write-In 59 4.50% Total... 1,310 100.00% BRIDGEPORT-SPAULDING COMM 2 YR SCHOOL PARTIAL (Final) Write-In 162 100.00% Total... 162 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 723 97.97% Write-In 15 2.03% Total... 738 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 258 35.01% Michael D Rowley 466 63.23% Write-In 13 1.76% Total... 737 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 681 97.99% Write-In 14 2.01% Total... 695 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 465 40.22% NO 691 59.78% Total... 1,156 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 510 42.86% NO 680 57.14% Total... 1,190 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 29 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Bridgeport Township Precinct 3 State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 396 33.53% NO 785 66.47% Total... 1,181 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 499 42.25% NO 682 57.75% Total... 1,181 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 413 35.42% NO 753 64.58% Total... 1,166 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 623 52.31% NO 568 47.69% Total... 1,191 100.00% Bridgeport Township Fire (Final) YES 472 40.62% NO 690 59.38% Total... 1,162 100.00% Bridgeport Township Law (Final) YES 458 39.41% NO 704 60.59% Total... 1,162 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 479 42.39% NO 651 57.61% Total... 1,130 100.00% Bridgeport Township Precinct 4 Registration & Turnout 2,352 Election Day Turnout 1,176 50.00% AV Polling Turnout 426 18.11% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,602 68.11% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 283 17.73% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 1,307 81.89% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 0 0.00% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 2 0.13% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.06% Write-In 3 0.19% Total... 1,596 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 217 13.73% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 1,346 85.19% LIBR - Scotty Boman 10 0.63% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 3 0.19% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 2 0.13% NATLAW - John D Litle 1 0.06% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,580 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 221 14.22% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 1,303 83.85% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 11 0.71% NPA - David Davenport 18 1.16% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,554 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 233 14.91% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 1,324 84.71% Write-In 6 0.38% Total... 1,563 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 218 7.42% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 219 7.45% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 1,209 41.14% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 1,182 40.22% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 11 0.37% USTAX - Karen Adams 33 1.12% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 20 0.68% GRN - Candace R Caveny 24 0.82% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 18 0.61% Write-In 5 0.17% Total... 2,939 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 218 7.45% REP - Robert Steele 217 7.42% DEM - Mark Bernstein 1,218 41.63% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 1,194 40.81%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 30 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Bridgeport Township Precinct 4 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 15 0.51% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 8 0.27% USTAX - Joe Sanger 12 0.41% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 9 0.31% GRN - Eric Borregard 13 0.44% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 16 0.55% Write-In 6 0.21% Total... 2,926 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 240 8.27% REP - Jeff Sakwa 200 6.89% DEM - Joel Ferguson 1,220 42.04% DEM - Brian Mosallam 1,143 39.39% LIBR - Michael H Miller 24 0.83% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 17 0.59% USTAX - Stephen J Young 28 0.96% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 22 0.76% Write-In 8 0.28% Total... 2,902 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 216 7.49% REP - Satish B Jasti 185 6.41% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 1,227 42.55% DEM - Kim Trent 1,180 40.92% USTAX - Robert Gale 23 0.80% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 12 0.42% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 23 0.80% GRN - Latham Redding 13 0.45% Write-In 5 0.17% Total... 2,884 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 230 14.93% DEM - John McColgan Jr 1,307 84.82% Write-In 4 0.26% Total... 1,541 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,399 99.01% Write-In 14 0.99% Total... 1,413 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 217 14.04% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 1,321 85.45% Write-In 8 0.52% Total... 1,546 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 234 15.32% DEM - Tim Novak 1,284 84.09% Write-In 9 0.59% Total... 1,527 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,402 99.64% Write-In 5 0.36% Total... 1,407 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,373 99.21% Write-In 11 0.79% Total... 1,384 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 7 (Final) REP - Dana Young 229 14.99% DEM - Cheryl Marie Hadsall 1,288 84.29% Write-In 11 0.72% Total... 1,528 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) REP - Sean Connors 226 14.71% DEM - Augie Tausend 1,297 84.44% Write-In 13 0.85% Total... 1,536 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) DEM - Darlene Miller 1,392 99.22% Write-In 11 0.78% Total... 1,403 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) DEM - Walter LaShore 1,368 98.84% Write-In 16 1.16% Total... 1,384 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) DEM - Vanessa Guerra 1,302 25.43% DEM - Jim Secord 1,273 24.86% DEM - Darrell Thayer 1,265 24.71% DEM - Heather Wilson 1,260 24.61%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 31 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Bridgeport Township Precinct 4 BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) Write-In 20 0.39% Total... 5,120 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 44 1.86% Connie Marie Kelley 687 29.10% Stephen Markman 244 10.33% Bridget Mary McCormack 908 38.46% Kerry L Morgan 107 4.53% Colleen O'Brien 307 13.00% Bob Roddis 49 2.08% Write-In 15 0.64% Total... 2,361 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 54 4.09% Shelia Johnson 977 73.96% Brian Zahra 278 21.04% Write-In 12 0.91% Total... 1,321 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 971 55.71% Peter D O'Connell 757 43.43% Write-In 15 0.86% Total... 1,743 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 1,006 98.34% Write-In 17 1.66% Total... 1,023 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 724 38.90% Darnell Jackson 1,124 60.40% Write-In 13 0.70% Total... 1,861 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 1,075 98.26% Write-In 19 1.74% Total... 1,094 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 1,231 98.95% Write-In 13 1.05% Total... 1,244 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP LIBRARY BOARD (Final) Charles Booth 669 15.24% Portia Drusilla Brown 789 17.97% William J Cannon 659 15.01% Juanita Foxx 876 19.95% Gerardo Gonzalez 726 16.54% Marlene Muhlenkamp 628 14.31% Write-In 43 0.98% Total... 4,390 100.00% BRIDGEPORT-SPAULDING COMM 4 YR SCHOOLS (Final) Martha A Sageman 851 46.94% Andrea J LaBean 846 46.66% Write-In 116 6.40% Total... 1,813 100.00% BRIDGEPORT-SPAULDING COMM 2 YR SCHOOL PARTIAL (Final) Write-In 244 100.00% Total... 244 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 1,067 98.43% Write-In 17 1.57% Total... 1,084 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 500 50.40% Michael D Rowley 478 48.19% Write-In 14 1.41% Total... 992 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 962 98.57% Write-In 14 1.43% Total... 976 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 410 28.18% NO 1,045 71.82% Total... 1,455 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 1,072 70.34% NO 452 29.66% Total... 1,524 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 858 57.31%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 32 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Bridgeport Township Precinct 4 State Proposal 12-3 (Final) NO 639 42.69% Total... 1,497 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 1,097 72.70% NO 412 27.30% Total... 1,509 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 418 28.02% NO 1,074 71.98% Total... 1,492 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 930 62.00% NO 570 38.00% Total... 1,500 100.00% Bridgeport Township Fire (Final) YES 669 47.25% NO 747 52.75% Total... 1,416 100.00% Bridgeport Township Law (Final) YES 637 45.40% NO 766 54.60% Total... 1,403 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 891 63.83% NO 505 36.17% Total... 1,396 100.00% Bridgeport Township Precinct 5 Registration & Turnout 1,243 Election Day Turnout 654 52.61% AV Polling Turnout 234 18.83% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 888 71.44% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 441 49.89% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 431 48.76% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 2 0.23% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 6 0.68% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.23% Write-In 2 0.23% Total... 884 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 342 39.31% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 495 56.90% LIBR - Scotty Boman 19 2.18% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 3 0.34% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 7 0.80% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.23% Write-In 2 0.23% Total... 870 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 356 41.83% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 463 54.41% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 12 1.41% NPA - David Davenport 17 2.00% Write-In 3 0.35% Total... 851 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 371 44.17% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 466 55.48% Write-In 3 0.36% Total... 840 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 341 22.76% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 327 21.83% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 390 26.03% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 341 22.76% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 22 1.47% USTAX - Karen Adams 30 2.00% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 14 0.93% GRN - Candace R Caveny 17 1.13% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 9 0.60% Write-In 7 0.47% Total... 1,498 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 323 21.97% REP - Robert Steele 305 20.75% DEM - Mark Bernstein 417 28.37% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 332 22.59% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 10 0.68%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 33 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Bridgeport Township Precinct 5 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 13 0.88% USTAX - Joe Sanger 22 1.50% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 17 1.16% GRN - Eric Borregard 12 0.82% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 14 0.95% Write-In 5 0.34% Total... 1,470 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 349 23.92% REP - Jeff Sakwa 298 20.42% DEM - Joel Ferguson 392 26.87% DEM - Brian Mosallam 331 22.69% LIBR - Michael H Miller 28 1.92% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 20 1.37% USTAX - Stephen J Young 20 1.37% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 15 1.03% Write-In 6 0.41% Total... 1,459 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 322 22.60% REP - Satish B Jasti 271 19.02% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 404 28.35% DEM - Kim Trent 349 24.49% USTAX - Robert Gale 24 1.68% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 17 1.19% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 15 1.05% GRN - Latham Redding 17 1.19% Write-In 6 0.42% Total... 1,425 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 350 42.37% DEM - John McColgan Jr 470 56.90% Write-In 6 0.73% Total... 826 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 645 97.58% Write-In 16 2.42% Total... 661 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 325 39.35% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 499 60.41% Write-In 2 0.24% Total... 826 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 357 43.97% DEM - Tim Novak 452 55.67% Write-In 3 0.37% Total... 812 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 622 98.57% Write-In 9 1.43% Total... 631 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 612 97.45% Write-In 16 2.55% Total... 628 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 8 (Final) REP - Dennis Krafft 518 97.37% Write-In 14 2.63% Total... 532 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) REP - Sean Connors 353 43.05% DEM - Augie Tausend 461 56.22% Write-In 6 0.73% Total... 820 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) DEM - Darlene Miller 613 97.77% Write-In 14 2.23% Total... 627 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) DEM - Walter LaShore 590 97.68% Write-In 14 2.32% Total... 604 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) DEM - Vanessa Guerra 549 25.68% DEM - Jim Secord 524 24.51% DEM - Darrell Thayer 511 23.90% DEM - Heather Wilson 520 24.32% Write-In 34 1.59% Total... 2,138 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 34 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Bridgeport Township Precinct 5 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 59 4.64% Connie Marie Kelley 261 20.52% Stephen Markman 250 19.65% Bridget Mary McCormack 289 22.72% Kerry L Morgan 74 5.82% Colleen O'Brien 296 23.27% Bob Roddis 37 2.91% Write-In 6 0.47% Total... 1,272 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 62 8.99% Shelia Johnson 286 41.45% Brian Zahra 336 48.70% Write-In 6 0.87% Total... 690 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 507 51.58% Peter D O'Connell 463 47.10% Write-In 13 1.32% Total... 983 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 533 97.98% Write-In 11 2.02% Total... 544 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 462 46.62% Darnell Jackson 515 51.97% Write-In 14 1.41% Total... 991 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 574 98.46% Write-In 9 1.54% Total... 583 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 592 98.34% Write-In 10 1.66% Total... 602 100.00% BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP LIBRARY BOARD (Final) Charles Booth 393 16.28% Portia Drusilla Brown 391 16.20% William J Cannon 396 16.40% Juanita Foxx 384 15.91% Gerardo Gonzalez 417 17.27% Marlene Muhlenkamp 401 16.61% Write-In 32 1.33% Total... 2,414 100.00% BRIDGEPORT-SPAULDING COMM 4 YR SCHOOLS (Final) Martha A Sageman 482 49.08% Andrea J LaBean 457 46.54% Write-In 43 4.38% Total... 982 100.00% BRIDGEPORT-SPAULDING COMM 2 YR SCHOOL PARTIAL (Final) Write-In 84 100.00% Total... 84 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 513 98.46% Write-In 8 1.54% Total... 521 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 196 38.06% Michael D Rowley 313 60.78% Write-In 6 1.17% Total... 515 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 486 98.38% Write-In 8 1.62% Total... 494 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 363 42.86% NO 484 57.14% Total... 847 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 397 46.00% NO 466 54.00% Total... 863 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 296 34.22% NO 569 65.78% Total... 865 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 35 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Bridgeport Township Precinct 5 State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 388 45.33% NO 468 54.67% Total... 856 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 261 30.63% NO 591 69.37% Total... 852 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 442 51.70% NO 413 48.30% Total... 855 100.00% Bridgeport Township Fire (Final) YES 417 50.98% NO 401 49.02% Total... 818 100.00% Bridgeport Township Law (Final) YES 383 46.65% NO 438 53.35% Total... 821 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 429 52.77% NO 384 47.23% Total... 813 100.00% Buena Vista Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,166 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 151 12.95% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 493 42.28% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 644 55.23% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 272 42.57% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 356 55.71% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 5 0.78% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 2 0.31% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 4 0.63% Total... 639 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 199 31.69% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 412 65.61% LIBR - Scotty Boman 8 1.27% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 3 0.48% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 5 0.80% NATLAW - John D Litle 1 0.16% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 628 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 207 33.50% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 381 61.65% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 13 2.10% NPA - David Davenport 15 2.43% Write-In 2 0.32% Total... 618 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 218 35.91% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 387 63.76% Write-In 2 0.33% Total... 607 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 187 17.27% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 193 17.82% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 324 29.92% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 292 26.96% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 19 1.75% USTAX - Karen Adams 32 2.95% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 12 1.11% GRN - Candace R Caveny 14 1.29% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 7 0.65% Write-In 3 0.28% Total... 1,083 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 201 18.54% REP - Robert Steele 193 17.80% DEM - Mark Bernstein 335 30.90% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 290 26.75% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 9 0.83% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 10 0.92% USTAX - Joe Sanger 11 1.01% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 11 1.01% GRN - Eric Borregard 6 0.55%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 36 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Buena Vista Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 15 1.38% Write-In 3 0.28% Total... 1,084 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 212 20.13% REP - Jeff Sakwa 184 17.47% DEM - Joel Ferguson 307 29.15% DEM - Brian Mosallam 284 26.97% LIBR - Michael H Miller 22 2.09% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 13 1.23% USTAX - Stephen J Young 9 0.85% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 18 1.71% Write-In 4 0.38% Total... 1,053 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 195 18.66% REP - Satish B Jasti 168 16.08% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 327 31.29% DEM - Kim Trent 299 28.61% USTAX - Robert Gale 12 1.15% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 13 1.24% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 18 1.72% GRN - Latham Redding 10 0.96% Write-In 3 0.29% Total... 1,045 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 226 37.86% DEM - John McColgan Jr 370 61.98% Write-In 1 0.17% Total... 597 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 467 97.09% Write-In 14 2.91% Total... 481 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 218 36.39% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 377 62.94% Write-In 4 0.67% Total... 599 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 236 39.60% DEM - Tim Novak 356 59.73% Write-In 4 0.67% Total... 596 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 457 98.70% Write-In 6 1.30% Total... 463 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 449 97.82% Write-In 10 2.18% Total... 459 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 8 (Final) REP - Dennis Krafft 350 92.35% Write-In 29 7.65% Total... 379 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Dwayne A Parker 432 94.32% Write-In 26 5.68% Total... 458 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) DEM - Gloria Platko 444 97.58% Write-In 11 2.42% Total... 455 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) DEM - Chris Dillard 423 97.24% Write-In 12 2.76% Total... 435 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) DEM - Gregory K Carter 377 25.10% DEM - Bruce McKinney 393 26.17% DEM - Cheryl Payton Merrill 377 25.10% DEM - Cedric Townsel 348 23.17% Write-In 7 0.47% Total... 1,502 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 37 4.37% Connie Marie Kelley 209 24.68% Stephen Markman 134 15.82% Bridget Mary McCormack 196 23.14% Kerry L Morgan 25 2.95%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 37 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Buena Vista Township Precinct 1 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Colleen O'Brien 214 25.27% Bob Roddis 28 3.31% Write-In 4 0.47% Total... 847 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 45 9.74% Shelia Johnson 222 48.05% Brian Zahra 191 41.34% Write-In 4 0.87% Total... 462 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 323 52.27% Peter D O'Connell 286 46.28% Write-In 9 1.46% Total... 618 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 368 97.87% Write-In 8 2.13% Total... 376 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 309 48.36% Darnell Jackson 321 50.23% Write-In 9 1.41% Total... 639 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 374 98.68% Write-In 5 1.32% Total... 379 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 389 98.48% Write-In 6 1.52% Total... 395 100.00% BUENA VISTA SCHOOLS (Final) Barbara Amon-Weigandt 99 25.32% Rhonda L Burton 96 24.55% Beverley Ford 96 24.55% Frances L Hayes 98 25.06% Write-In 2 0.51% Total... 391 100.00% BUENA VISTA SCHOOLS PARTIAL (Final) Mary L Haynie 145 97.32% Write-In 4 2.68% Total... 149 100.00% BAY CITY PUBLIC SCHOOLS 4 YR (Final) Pauline Helmling 30 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 30 100.00% REESE PUBLIC SCHOOLS (Final) Jill Palm Lynch 220 95.65% Write-In 10 4.35% Total... 230 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 366 98.65% Write-In 5 1.35% Total... 371 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 142 37.57% Michael D Rowley 230 60.85% Write-In 6 1.59% Total... 378 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 356 98.34% Write-In 6 1.66% Total... 362 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 222 37.50% NO 370 62.50% Total... 592 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 290 48.49% NO 308 51.51% Total... 598 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 225 37.56% NO 374 62.44% Total... 599 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 307 51.17% NO 293 48.83% Total... 600 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 38 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Buena Vista Township Precinct 1 State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 185 31.20% NO 408 68.80% Total... 593 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 303 50.75% NO 294 49.25% Total... 597 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 335 57.56% NO 247 42.44% Total... 582 100.00% Buena Vista Township Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 1,543 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 263 17.04% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 561 36.36% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 824 53.40% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 38 4.66% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 775 94.98% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 3 0.37% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 0 0.00% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 816 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 38 4.70% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 771 95.30% LIBR - Scotty Boman 0 0.00% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 0 0.00% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 0 0.00% NATLAW - John D Litle 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 809 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 40 4.98% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 747 93.03% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 5 0.62% NPA - David Davenport 11 1.37% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 803 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 43 5.32% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 763 94.43% Write-In 2 0.25% Total... 808 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 35 2.24% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 39 2.50% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 726 46.51% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 705 45.16% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 10 0.64% USTAX - Karen Adams 21 1.35% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 10 0.64% GRN - Candace R Caveny 4 0.26% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 7 0.45% Write-In 4 0.26% Total... 1,561 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 33 2.12% REP - Robert Steele 36 2.32% DEM - Mark Bernstein 724 46.56% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 720 46.30% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 4 0.26% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 5 0.32% USTAX - Joe Sanger 8 0.51% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 8 0.51% GRN - Eric Borregard 5 0.32% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 8 0.51% Write-In 4 0.26% Total... 1,555 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 43 2.78% REP - Jeff Sakwa 33 2.13% DEM - Joel Ferguson 722 46.70% DEM - Brian Mosallam 712 46.05% LIBR - Michael H Miller 10 0.65% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 5 0.32% USTAX - Stephen J Young 9 0.58% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 10 0.65%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 39 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Buena Vista Township Precinct 2 MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) Write-In 2 0.13% Total... 1,546 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 37 2.40% REP - Satish B Jasti 26 1.69% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 729 47.28% DEM - Kim Trent 717 46.50% USTAX - Robert Gale 9 0.58% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 10 0.65% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 7 0.45% GRN - Latham Redding 3 0.19% Write-In 4 0.26% Total... 1,542 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 37 4.65% DEM - John McColgan Jr 756 95.09% Write-In 2 0.25% Total... 795 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 758 98.70% Write-In 10 1.30% Total... 768 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 41 5.19% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 747 94.56% Write-In 2 0.25% Total... 790 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 42 5.30% DEM - Tim Novak 749 94.45% Write-In 2 0.25% Total... 793 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 768 99.10% Write-In 7 0.90% Total... 775 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 764 98.96% Write-In 8 1.04% Total... 772 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 9 (Final) DEM - Robert Moe Woods 766 99.09% Write-In 7 0.91% Total... 773 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Dwayne A Parker 751 96.65% Write-In 26 3.35% Total... 777 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) DEM - Gloria Platko 767 98.59% Write-In 11 1.41% Total... 778 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) DEM - Chris Dillard 767 99.22% Write-In 6 0.78% Total... 773 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) DEM - Gregory K Carter 728 24.70% DEM - Bruce McKinney 734 24.91% DEM - Cheryl Payton Merrill 737 25.01% DEM - Cedric Townsel 733 24.87% Write-In 15 0.51% Total... 2,947 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 29 2.44% Connie Marie Kelley 413 34.74% Stephen Markman 115 9.67% Bridget Mary McCormack 449 37.76% Kerry L Morgan 48 4.04% Colleen O'Brien 117 9.84% Bob Roddis 15 1.26% Write-In 3 0.25% Total... 1,189 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 31 4.45% Shelia Johnson 574 82.35% Brian Zahra 90 12.91% Write-In 2 0.29% Total... 697 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 509 55.57%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 40 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Buena Vista Township Precinct 2 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Peter D O'Connell 392 42.79% Write-In 15 1.64% Total... 916 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 531 96.02% Write-In 22 3.98% Total... 553 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 323 33.89% Darnell Jackson 619 64.95% Write-In 11 1.15% Total... 953 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 560 96.22% Write-In 22 3.78% Total... 582 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 645 97.14% Write-In 19 2.86% Total... 664 100.00% BUENA VISTA SCHOOLS (Final) Barbara Amon-Weigandt 277 17.78% Rhonda L Burton 393 25.22% Beverley Ford 466 29.91% Frances L Hayes 405 25.99% Write-In 17 1.09% Total... 1,558 100.00% BUENA VISTA SCHOOLS PARTIAL (Final) Mary L Haynie 586 97.99% Write-In 12 2.01% Total... 598 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 580 97.64% Write-In 14 2.36% Total... 594 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 237 42.86% Michael D Rowley 302 54.61% Write-In 14 2.53% Total... 553 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 539 97.29% Write-In 15 2.71% Total... 554 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 154 21.15% NO 574 78.85% Total... 728 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 597 80.35% NO 146 19.65% Total... 743 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 475 64.89% NO 257 35.11% Total... 732 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 623 83.62% NO 122 16.38% Total... 745 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 209 28.63% NO 521 71.37% Total... 730 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 499 67.89% NO 236 32.11% Total... 735 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 535 74.93% NO 179 25.07% Total... 714 100.00% Buena Vista Township Precinct 3 Registration & Turnout 1,826 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 276 15.12% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 641 35.10% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 917 50.22%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 41 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Buena Vista Township Precinct 3 PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 8 0.88% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 897 98.90% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 0 0.00% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 1 0.11% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 907 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 7 0.78% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 885 98.44% LIBR - Scotty Boman 0 0.00% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 1 0.11% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.44% NATLAW - John D Litle 1 0.11% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 899 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 6 0.67% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 871 97.43% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 3 0.34% NPA - David Davenport 11 1.23% Write-In 3 0.34% Total... 894 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 11 1.23% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 876 97.77% Write-In 9 1.00% Total... 896 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 11 0.64% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 11 0.64% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 839 48.84% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 814 47.38% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 10 0.58% USTAX - Karen Adams 14 0.81% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 4 0.23% GRN - Candace R Caveny 5 0.29% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 8 0.47% Write-In 2 0.12% Total... 1,718 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 8 0.47% REP - Robert Steele 14 0.82% DEM - Mark Bernstein 827 48.28% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 822 47.99% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 9 0.53% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 8 0.47% USTAX - Joe Sanger 6 0.35% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 4 0.23% GRN - Eric Borregard 2 0.12% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 10 0.58% Write-In 3 0.18% Total... 1,713 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 15 0.88% REP - Jeff Sakwa 6 0.35% DEM - Joel Ferguson 838 48.89% DEM - Brian Mosallam 809 47.20% LIBR - Michael H Miller 12 0.70% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 5 0.29% USTAX - Stephen J Young 15 0.88% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 8 0.47% Write-In 6 0.35% Total... 1,714 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 9 0.53% REP - Satish B Jasti 6 0.35% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 833 48.86% DEM - Kim Trent 827 48.50% USTAX - Robert Gale 9 0.53% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 4 0.23% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 9 0.53% GRN - Latham Redding 3 0.18% Write-In 5 0.29% Total... 1,705 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 16 1.81% DEM - John McColgan Jr 860 97.40% Write-In 7 0.79% Total... 883 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 42 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Buena Vista Township Precinct 3 SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 865 98.18% Write-In 16 1.82% Total... 881 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 16 1.80% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 866 97.30% Write-In 8 0.90% Total... 890 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 11 1.25% DEM - Tim Novak 863 98.07% Write-In 6 0.68% Total... 880 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 878 99.43% Write-In 5 0.57% Total... 883 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 874 98.98% Write-In 9 1.02% Total... 883 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 9 (Final) DEM - Robert Moe Woods 867 99.09% Write-In 8 0.91% Total... 875 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Dwayne A Parker 861 97.84% Write-In 19 2.16% Total... 880 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) DEM - Gloria Platko 867 98.86% Write-In 10 1.14% Total... 877 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) DEM - Chris Dillard 854 98.61% Write-In 12 1.39% Total... 866 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) DEM - Gregory K Carter 834 25.12% DEM - Bruce McKinney 824 24.82% DEM - Cheryl Payton Merrill 824 24.82% DEM - Cedric Townsel 822 24.76% Write-In 16 0.48% Total... 3,320 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 22 1.83% Connie Marie Kelley 445 37.11% Stephen Markman 98 8.17% Bridget Mary McCormack 484 40.37% Kerry L Morgan 44 3.67% Colleen O'Brien 88 7.34% Bob Roddis 8 0.67% Write-In 10 0.83% Total... 1,199 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 36 5.00% Shelia Johnson 597 82.92% Brian Zahra 78 10.83% Write-In 9 1.25% Total... 720 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 517 55.59% Peter D O'Connell 396 42.58% Write-In 17 1.83% Total... 930 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 553 96.34% Write-In 21 3.66% Total... 574 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 324 32.60% Darnell Jackson 656 66.00% Write-In 14 1.41% Total... 994 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 601 96.94% Write-In 19 3.06% Total... 620 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 703 97.91%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 43 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Buena Vista Township Precinct 3 JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Write-In 15 2.09% Total... 718 100.00% BUENA VISTA SCHOOLS (Final) Barbara Amon-Weigandt 232 14.69% Rhonda L Burton 380 24.07% Beverley Ford 555 35.15% Frances L Hayes 400 25.33% Write-In 12 0.76% Total... 1,579 100.00% BUENA VISTA SCHOOLS PARTIAL (Final) Mary L Haynie 638 97.55% Write-In 16 2.45% Total... 654 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 607 97.28% Write-In 17 2.72% Total... 624 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 319 54.53% Michael D Rowley 253 43.25% Write-In 13 2.22% Total... 585 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 562 96.56% Write-In 20 3.44% Total... 582 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 177 21.85% NO 633 78.15% Total... 810 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 676 82.04% NO 148 17.96% Total... 824 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 549 67.03% NO 270 32.97% Total... 819 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 710 86.06% NO 115 13.94% Total... 825 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 199 24.84% NO 602 75.16% Total... 801 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 534 65.68% NO 279 34.32% Total... 813 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 571 74.54% NO 195 25.46% Total... 766 100.00% Buena Vista Township Precinct 4 Registration & Turnout 1,718 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 123 7.16% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 599 34.87% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 722 42.03% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 44 6.23% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 658 93.20% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 0 0.00% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 3 0.42% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 1 0.14% Total... 706 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 34 4.85% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 655 93.44% LIBR - Scotty Boman 3 0.43% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 3 0.43% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.57% NATLAW - John D Litle 1 0.14% Write-In 1 0.14% Total... 701 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 35 5.01%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 44 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Buena Vista Township Precinct 4 US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) DEM - Daniel T Kildee 649 92.85% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 10 1.43% NPA - David Davenport 3 0.43% Write-In 2 0.29% Total... 699 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 37 5.29% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 658 94.13% Write-In 4 0.57% Total... 699 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 42 3.14% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 40 2.99% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 618 46.15% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 602 44.96% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 3 0.22% USTAX - Karen Adams 17 1.27% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 3 0.22% GRN - Candace R Caveny 6 0.45% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 5 0.37% Write-In 3 0.22% Total... 1,339 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 40 3.00% REP - Robert Steele 43 3.22% DEM - Mark Bernstein 605 45.32% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 600 44.94% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 10 0.75% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 7 0.52% USTAX - Joe Sanger 6 0.45% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 7 0.52% GRN - Eric Borregard 8 0.60% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 6 0.45% Write-In 3 0.22% Total... 1,335 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 47 3.54% REP - Jeff Sakwa 39 2.94% DEM - Joel Ferguson 613 46.23% DEM - Brian Mosallam 587 44.27% LIBR - Michael H Miller 9 0.68% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 3 0.23% USTAX - Stephen J Young 12 0.90% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 12 0.90% Write-In 4 0.30% Total... 1,326 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 43 3.23% REP - Satish B Jasti 38 2.85% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 621 46.66% DEM - Kim Trent 599 45.00% USTAX - Robert Gale 9 0.68% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 5 0.38% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 9 0.68% GRN - Latham Redding 4 0.30% Write-In 3 0.23% Total... 1,331 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 54 7.77% DEM - John McColgan Jr 635 91.37% Write-In 6 0.86% Total... 695 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 653 98.49% Write-In 10 1.51% Total... 663 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 48 6.91% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 641 92.23% Write-In 6 0.86% Total... 695 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 40 5.76% DEM - Tim Novak 650 93.66% Write-In 4 0.58% Total... 694 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 664 98.96% Write-In 7 1.04% Total... 671 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 45 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Buena Vista Township Precinct 4 PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 659 98.95% Write-In 7 1.05% Total... 666 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 9 (Final) DEM - Robert Moe Woods 663 99.10% Write-In 6 0.90% Total... 669 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Dwayne A Parker 665 98.96% Write-In 7 1.04% Total... 672 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) DEM - Gloria Platko 664 99.10% Write-In 6 0.90% Total... 670 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) DEM - Chris Dillard 658 98.95% Write-In 7 1.05% Total... 665 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) DEM - Gregory K Carter 621 24.97% DEM - Bruce McKinney 625 25.13% DEM - Cheryl Payton Merrill 619 24.89% DEM - Cedric Townsel 615 24.73% Write-In 7 0.28% Total... 2,487 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 10 0.99% Connie Marie Kelley 338 33.47% Stephen Markman 132 13.07% Bridget Mary McCormack 372 36.83% Kerry L Morgan 39 3.86% Colleen O'Brien 98 9.70% Bob Roddis 7 0.69% Write-In 14 1.39% Total... 1,010 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 34 5.71% Shelia Johnson 457 76.81% Brian Zahra 95 15.97% Write-In 9 1.51% Total... 595 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 427 54.74% Peter D O'Connell 334 42.82% Write-In 19 2.44% Total... 780 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 473 94.41% Write-In 28 5.59% Total... 501 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 282 35.47% Darnell Jackson 496 62.39% Write-In 17 2.14% Total... 795 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 480 94.30% Write-In 29 5.70% Total... 509 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 552 96.34% Write-In 21 3.66% Total... 573 100.00% BUENA VISTA SCHOOLS (Final) Barbara Amon-Weigandt 222 17.05% Rhonda L Burton 333 25.58% Beverley Ford 357 27.42% Frances L Hayes 367 28.19% Write-In 23 1.77% Total... 1,302 100.00% BUENA VISTA SCHOOLS PARTIAL (Final) Mary L Haynie 524 97.22% Write-In 15 2.78% Total... 539 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 521 96.84% Write-In 17 3.16% Total... 538 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 46 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Buena Vista Township Precinct 4 DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 219 43.03% Michael D Rowley 274 53.83% Write-In 16 3.14% Total... 509 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 474 95.76% Write-In 21 4.24% Total... 495 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 164 25.95% NO 468 74.05% Total... 632 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 499 76.65% NO 152 23.35% Total... 651 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 403 62.87% NO 238 37.13% Total... 641 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 550 84.62% NO 100 15.38% Total... 650 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 191 30.17% NO 442 69.83% Total... 633 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 379 59.87% NO 254 40.13% Total... 633 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 468 75.12% NO 155 24.88% Total... 623 100.00% Buena Vista Township Precinct 5 Registration & Turnout 1,843 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 341 18.50% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 689 37.38% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,030 55.89% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 132 12.84% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 894 86.96% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.10% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 1 0.10% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,028 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 93 9.11% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 921 90.21% LIBR - Scotty Boman 2 0.20% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 2 0.20% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 1 0.10% NATLAW - John D Litle 1 0.10% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,021 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 96 9.44% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 909 89.38% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 1 0.10% NPA - David Davenport 10 0.98% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,017 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 103 10.14% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 908 89.37% Write-In 5 0.49% Total... 1,016 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 100 5.13% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 108 5.54% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 864 44.31% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 839 43.03% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 7 0.36% USTAX - Karen Adams 14 0.72% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 4 0.21%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 47 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Buena Vista Township Precinct 5 MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) GRN - Candace R Caveny 6 0.31% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 6 0.31% Write-In 2 0.10% Total... 1,950 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 104 5.37% REP - Robert Steele 102 5.27% DEM - Mark Bernstein 853 44.04% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 837 43.21% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 6 0.31% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 4 0.21% USTAX - Joe Sanger 14 0.72% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 5 0.26% GRN - Eric Borregard 4 0.21% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 7 0.36% Write-In 1 0.05% Total... 1,937 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 118 6.10% REP - Jeff Sakwa 96 4.96% DEM - Joel Ferguson 864 44.63% DEM - Brian Mosallam 818 42.25% LIBR - Michael H Miller 7 0.36% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 12 0.62% USTAX - Stephen J Young 7 0.36% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 12 0.62% Write-In 2 0.10% Total... 1,936 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 107 5.54% REP - Satish B Jasti 89 4.60% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 872 45.11% DEM - Kim Trent 834 43.15% USTAX - Robert Gale 7 0.36% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 8 0.41% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 7 0.36% GRN - Latham Redding 7 0.36% Write-In 2 0.10% Total... 1,933 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 110 10.88% DEM - John McColgan Jr 900 89.02% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,011 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 939 99.37% Write-In 6 0.63% Total... 945 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 106 10.55% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 898 89.35% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,005 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 120 11.94% DEM - Tim Novak 883 87.86% Write-In 2 0.20% Total... 1,005 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 940 99.47% Write-In 5 0.53% Total... 945 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 935 99.47% Write-In 5 0.53% Total... 940 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 9 (Final) DEM - Robert Moe Woods 927 99.14% Write-In 8 0.86% Total... 935 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Dwayne A Parker 923 98.19% Write-In 17 1.81% Total... 940 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) DEM - Gloria Platko 924 99.04% Write-In 9 0.96% Total... 933 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) DEM - Chris Dillard 924 99.25%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 48 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Buena Vista Township Precinct 5 BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) Write-In 7 0.75% Total... 931 100.00% BUENA VISTA TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) DEM - Gregory K Carter 880 24.93% DEM - Bruce McKinney 885 25.07% DEM - Cheryl Payton Merrill 880 24.93% DEM - Cedric Townsel 870 24.65% Write-In 15 0.42% Total... 3,530 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 30 2.01% Connie Marie Kelley 437 29.29% Stephen Markman 167 11.19% Bridget Mary McCormack 600 40.21% Kerry L Morgan 56 3.75% Colleen O'Brien 177 11.86% Bob Roddis 19 1.27% Write-In 6 0.40% Total... 1,492 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 18 2.13% Shelia Johnson 671 79.22% Brian Zahra 154 18.18% Write-In 4 0.47% Total... 847 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 627 56.18% Peter D O'Connell 480 43.01% Write-In 9 0.81% Total... 1,116 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 646 97.88% Write-In 14 2.12% Total... 660 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 434 36.69% Darnell Jackson 744 62.89% Write-In 5 0.42% Total... 1,183 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 707 98.19% Write-In 13 1.81% Total... 720 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 803 99.14% Write-In 7 0.86% Total... 810 100.00% BUENA VISTA SCHOOLS (Final) Barbara Amon-Weigandt 472 24.47% Rhonda L Burton 487 25.25% Beverley Ford 520 26.96% Frances L Hayes 446 23.12% Write-In 4 0.21% Total... 1,929 100.00% BUENA VISTA SCHOOLS PARTIAL (Final) Mary L Haynie 744 98.28% Write-In 13 1.72% Total... 757 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 731 99.05% Write-In 7 0.95% Total... 738 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 337 48.91% Michael D Rowley 346 50.22% Write-In 6 0.87% Total... 689 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 664 98.37% Write-In 11 1.63% Total... 675 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 234 25.03% NO 701 74.97% Total... 935 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 719 75.76% NO 230 24.24% Total... 949 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 49 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Buena Vista Township Precinct 5 State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 539 57.40% NO 400 42.60% Total... 939 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 735 77.12% NO 218 22.88% Total... 953 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 287 31.06% NO 637 68.94% Total... 924 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 611 64.66% NO 334 35.34% Total... 945 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 636 71.22% NO 257 28.78% Total... 893 100.00% Carrollton Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,823 Election Day Turnout 1,191 65.33% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,191 65.33% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 372 31.31% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 795 66.92% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 3 0.25% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 9 0.76% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 4 0.34% Write-In 5 0.42% Total... 1,188 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 303 25.90% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 825 70.51% LIBR - Scotty Boman 16 1.37% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 5 0.43% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 14 1.20% NATLAW - John D Litle 5 0.43% Write-In 2 0.17% Total... 1,170 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST REP - Jim Slezak 289 25.24% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 784 68.47% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 23 2.01% NPA - David Davenport 46 4.02% Write-In 3 0.26% Total... 1,145 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST REP - Jeff Baker 338 29.94% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 784 69.44% Write-In 7 0.62% Total... 1,129 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 285 13.63% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 285 13.63% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 717 34.29% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 641 30.66% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 29 1.39% USTAX - Karen Adams 45 2.15% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 24 1.15% GRN - Candace R Caveny 33 1.58% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 21 1.00% Write-In 11 0.53% Total... 2,091 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 268 13.00% REP - Robert Steele 262 12.71% DEM - Mark Bernstein 733 35.57% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 669 32.46% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 20 0.97% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 17 0.82% USTAX - Joe Sanger 21 1.02% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 16 0.78% GRN - Eric Borregard 27 1.31% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 20 0.97% Write-In 8 0.39% Total... 2,061 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 50 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Carrollton Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 293 14.33% REP - Jeff Sakwa 249 12.18% DEM - Joel Ferguson 743 36.35% DEM - Brian Mosallam 639 31.26% LIBR - Michael H Miller 34 1.66% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 25 1.22% USTAX - Stephen J Young 26 1.27% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 26 1.27% Write-In 9 0.44% Total... 2,044 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 287 14.26% REP - Satish B Jasti 215 10.69% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 727 36.13% DEM - Kim Trent 670 33.30% USTAX - Robert Gale 28 1.39% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 25 1.24% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 29 1.44% GRN - Latham Redding 26 1.29% Write-In 5 0.25% Total... 2,012 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 323 28.74% DEM - John McColgan Jr 797 70.91% Write-In 4 0.36% Total... 1,124 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 971 98.58% Write-In 14 1.42% Total... 985 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 300 26.67% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 822 73.07% Write-In 3 0.27% Total... 1,125 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 287 25.40% DEM - Tim Novak 840 74.34% Write-In 3 0.27% Total... 1,130 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 962 98.87% Write-In 11 1.13% Total... 973 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 949 99.16% Write-In 8 0.84% Total... 957 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 2 REP - Alex Boese 355 31.95% DEM - Chuck Stack 750 67.51% Write-In 6 0.54% Total... 1,111 100.00% CARROLLTON TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR DEM - Marvin Kozara 975 98.78% Write-In 12 1.22% Total... 987 100.00% CARROLLTON TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Jerry Fritz 954 98.86% Write-In 11 1.14% Total... 965 100.00% CARROLLTON TOWNSHIP TREASURER DEM - Timothy Riley 953 99.06% Write-In 9 0.94% Total... 962 100.00% CARROLLTON TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Timothy Gnatkowski 470 24.62% DEM - Richard Dudek 825 43.22% DEM - Joe Manuel Loperena Jr 608 31.85% Write-In 6 0.31% Total... 1,909 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 49 2.81% Connie Marie Kelley 361 20.74% Stephen Markman 243 13.96% Bridget Mary McCormack 571 32.80% Kerry L Morgan 95 5.46% Colleen O'Brien 352 20.22% Bob Roddis 58 3.33% Write-In 12 0.69% Total... 1,741 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 51 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Carrollton Township Precinct 1 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 121 12.59% Shelia Johnson 417 43.39% Brian Zahra 411 42.77% Write-In 12 1.25% Total... 961 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 727 52.99% Peter D O'Connell 628 45.77% Write-In 17 1.24% Total... 1,372 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 797 97.79% Write-In 18 2.21% Total... 815 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 639 46.00% Darnell Jackson 731 52.63% Write-In 19 1.37% Total... 1,389 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 837 97.78% Write-In 19 2.22% Total... 856 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION Terry L Clark 873 97.32% Write-In 24 2.68% Total... 897 100.00% CARROLLTON SCHOOLS PARTIAL Anthony J McDonald 879 97.88% Write-In 19 2.12% Total... 898 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 836 97.66% Write-In 20 2.34% Total... 856 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 300 36.41% Michael D Rowley 503 61.04% Write-In 21 2.55% Total... 824 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 753 96.54% Write-In 27 3.46% Total... 780 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 393 35.34% NO 719 64.66% Total... 1,112 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 641 56.98% NO 484 43.02% Total... 1,125 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 465 41.44% NO 657 58.56% Total... 1,122 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 658 59.23% NO 453 40.77% Total... 1,111 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 306 27.57% NO 804 72.43% Total... 1,110 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 589 52.50% NO 533 47.50% Total... 1,122 100.00% Carrollton Schools YES 644 59.30% NO 442 40.70% Total... 1,086 100.00% Delta College YES 661 60.92% NO 424 39.08% Total... 1,085 100.00% Carrollton Township Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 2,713 Election Day Turnout 1,586 58.46% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 52 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Carrollton Township Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 2,713 Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,586 58.46% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 580 36.94% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 959 61.08% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 10 0.64% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 4 0.25% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 17 1.08% Total... 1,570 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 438 28.42% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 1,050 68.14% LIBR - Scotty Boman 32 2.08% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 10 0.65% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 9 0.58% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.13% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,541 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST REP - Jim Slezak 407 27.06% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 1,025 68.15% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 32 2.13% NPA - David Davenport 40 2.66% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,504 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST REP - Jeff Baker 499 34.08% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 958 65.44% Write-In 7 0.48% Total... 1,464 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 436 16.09% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 443 16.35% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 877 32.36% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 766 28.27% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 53 1.96% USTAX - Karen Adams 61 2.25% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 25 0.92% GRN - Candace R Caveny 33 1.22% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 16 0.59% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 2,710 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 431 16.06% REP - Robert Steele 420 15.65% DEM - Mark Bernstein 898 33.47% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 763 28.44% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 35 1.30% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 35 1.30% USTAX - Joe Sanger 27 1.01% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 21 0.78% GRN - Eric Borregard 20 0.75% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 27 1.01% Write-In 6 0.22% Total... 2,683 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 488 18.48% REP - Jeff Sakwa 380 14.39% DEM - Joel Ferguson 862 32.65% DEM - Brian Mosallam 743 28.14% LIBR - Michael H Miller 65 2.46% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 32 1.21% USTAX - Stephen J Young 38 1.44% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 27 1.02% Write-In 5 0.19% Total... 2,640 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 455 17.53% REP - Satish B Jasti 356 13.72% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 878 33.83% DEM - Kim Trent 769 29.63% USTAX - Robert Gale 39 1.50% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 34 1.31% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 39 1.50% GRN - Latham Redding 21 0.81% Write-In 4 0.15% Total... 2,595 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 476 32.12%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 53 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Carrollton Township Precinct 2 PROSECUTING ATTORNEY DEM - John McColgan Jr 1,000 67.48% Write-In 6 0.40% Total... 1,482 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 1,257 97.14% Write-In 37 2.86% Total... 1,294 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 436 29.46% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 1,041 70.34% Write-In 3 0.20% Total... 1,480 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 431 28.98% DEM - Tim Novak 1,054 70.88% Write-In 2 0.13% Total... 1,487 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,251 98.66% Write-In 17 1.34% Total... 1,268 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,235 98.72% Write-In 16 1.28% Total... 1,251 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 2 REP - Alex Boese 499 34.53% DEM - Chuck Stack 943 65.26% Write-In 3 0.21% Total... 1,445 100.00% CARROLLTON TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR DEM - Marvin Kozara 1,255 98.51% Write-In 19 1.49% Total... 1,274 100.00% CARROLLTON TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Jerry Fritz 1,242 98.42% Write-In 20 1.58% Total... 1,262 100.00% CARROLLTON TOWNSHIP TREASURER DEM - Timothy Riley 1,216 98.46% Write-In 19 1.54% Total... 1,235 100.00% CARROLLTON TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Timothy Gnatkowski 694 28.02% DEM - Richard Dudek 1,062 42.87% DEM - Joe Manuel Loperena Jr 711 28.70% Write-In 10 0.40% Total... 2,477 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 102 4.50% Connie Marie Kelley 474 20.90% Stephen Markman 391 17.24% Bridget Mary McCormack 514 22.66% Kerry L Morgan 157 6.92% Colleen O'Brien 535 23.59% Bob Roddis 86 3.79% Write-In 9 0.40% Total... 2,268 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 170 13.62% Shelia Johnson 539 43.19% Brian Zahra 530 42.47% Write-In 9 0.72% Total... 1,248 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 1,011 54.68% Peter D O'Connell 824 44.56% Write-In 14 0.76% Total... 1,849 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 1,060 98.06% Write-In 21 1.94% Total... 1,081 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 895 48.38% Darnell Jackson 936 50.59% Write-In 19 1.03% Total... 1,850 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 1,122 98.42%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 54 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Carrollton Township Precinct 2 JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Write-In 18 1.58% Total... 1,140 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION Terry L Clark 1,165 98.73% Write-In 15 1.27% Total... 1,180 100.00% CARROLLTON SCHOOLS PARTIAL Anthony J McDonald 1,183 98.83% Write-In 14 1.17% Total... 1,197 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 1,127 99.03% Write-In 11 0.97% Total... 1,138 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 440 40.67% Michael D Rowley 623 57.58% Write-In 19 1.76% Total... 1,082 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 988 97.73% Write-In 23 2.27% Total... 1,011 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 546 36.64% NO 944 63.36% Total... 1,490 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 753 49.93% NO 755 50.07% Total... 1,508 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 579 38.27% NO 934 61.73% Total... 1,513 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 793 52.83% NO 708 47.17% Total... 1,501 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 488 32.62% NO 1,008 67.38% Total... 1,496 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 784 51.61% NO 735 48.39% Total... 1,519 100.00% Carrollton Schools YES 902 61.95% NO 554 38.05% Total... 1,456 100.00% Delta College YES 939 64.36% NO 520 35.64% Total... 1,459 100.00% Chapin Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 718 Election Day Turnout 427 59.47% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 427 59.47% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 213 50.35% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 202 47.75% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.24% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 3 0.71% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.47% Write-In 2 0.47% Total... 423 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 166 40.19% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 232 56.17% LIBR - Scotty Boman 9 2.18% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 4 0.97% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 1 0.24% NATLAW - John D Litle 1 0.24% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 413 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 55 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Chapin Township Precinct 1 US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 279 68.55% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 116 28.50% LIBR - John Gelineau 7 1.72% USTAX - George M Zimmer 3 0.74% GRN - Pat Timmons 2 0.49% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 407 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 85 TH DIST REP - Ben Glardon 240 59.70% DEM - Paul Ray 136 33.83% NPA - Matthew Shepard 26 6.47% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 402 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 175 25.58% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 173 25.29% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 156 22.81% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 126 18.42% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 13 1.90% USTAX - Karen Adams 20 2.92% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 10 1.46% GRN - Candace R Caveny 6 0.88% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 4 0.58% Write-In 1 0.15% Total... 684 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 169 25.38% REP - Robert Steele 152 22.82% DEM - Mark Bernstein 162 24.32% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 133 19.97% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 11 1.65% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 12 1.80% USTAX - Joe Sanger 11 1.65% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 9 1.35% GRN - Eric Borregard 1 0.15% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 5 0.75% Write-In 1 0.15% Total... 666 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 182 26.92% REP - Jeff Sakwa 155 22.93% DEM - Joel Ferguson 166 24.56% DEM - Brian Mosallam 122 18.05% LIBR - Michael H Miller 14 2.07% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 12 1.78% USTAX - Stephen J Young 15 2.22% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 8 1.18% Write-In 2 0.30% Total... 676 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 165 24.92% REP - Satish B Jasti 137 20.69% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 170 25.68% DEM - Kim Trent 143 21.60% USTAX - Robert Gale 21 3.17% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 11 1.66% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 8 1.21% GRN - Latham Redding 7 1.06% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 662 0.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 199 52.09% DEM - John McColgan Jr 180 47.12% Write-In 3 0.79% Total... 382 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 285 97.94% Write-In 6 2.06% Total... 291 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 203 53.42% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 177 46.58% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 380 0.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 166 44.74% DEM - Tim Novak 204 54.99% Write-In 1 0.27% Total... 371 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 281 98.60%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 56 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Chapin Township Precinct 1 REGISTER OF DEEDS Write-In 4 1.40% Total... 285 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 271 98.19% Write-In 5 1.81% Total... 276 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 6 REP - Ron Sholtz 225 57.11% DEM - Katie Greenfelder 168 42.64% Write-In 1 0.25% Total... 394 100.00% CHAPIN TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Robb Maynard 266 64.72% DEM - Alvin S Coon 144 35.04% Write-In 1 0.24% Total... 411 100.00% CHAPIN TOWNSHIP CLERK Write-In 24 100.00% Total... 24 100.00% CHAPIN TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Michelle L Kettler 319 99.07% Write-In 3 0.93% Total... 322 100.00% CHAPIN TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Jason Keck 286 55.00% REP - Brenda Radabaugh 229 44.04% Write-In 5 0.96% Total... 520 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 28 5.30% Connie Marie Kelley 99 18.75% Stephen Markman 117 22.16% Bridget Mary McCormack 84 15.91% Kerry L Morgan 11 2.08% Colleen O'Brien 156 29.55% Bob Roddis 32 6.06% Write-In 1 0.19% Total... 528 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 34 11.60% Shelia Johnson 106 36.18% Brian Zahra 153 52.22% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 293 0.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 179 46.86% Peter D O'Connell 202 52.88% Write-In 1 0.26% Total... 382 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 233 99.15% Write-In 2 0.85% Total... 235 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 208 52.13% Darnell Jackson 188 47.12% Write-In 3 0.75% Total... 399 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 241 99.18% Write-In 2 0.82% Total... 243 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 232 98.72% Write-In 3 1.28% Total... 235 100.00% CHESANING UNION SCHOOLS 4 YR Brian W Lewis 65 44.83% Julia Schultz Sadilek 80 55.17% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 145 0.00% ASHLEY COMMUNITY SCHOOLS Anmarie E Andrews 44 22.22% Kurt J Densmore 74 37.37% Melissa Payne 80 40.40% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 198 0.00% OVID-ELSIE AREA SCHOOLS 6 David Huff 111 39.93% Michael D Schiffer 68 24.46%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 57 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Chapin Township Precinct 1 OVID-ELSIE AREA SCHOOLS 6 Steven Mark Sopocy 96 34.53% Write-In 3 1.08% Total... 278 100.00% OVID-ELSIE AREA SCHOOLS 4 Lee D Helmer 17 12.98% Jamie Perrien 56 42.75% Brooke Wooley 57 43.51% Write-In 1 0.76% Total... 131 100.00% OVID-ELSIE AREA SCHOOLS PARTIAL Stacie Rulison 94 97.92% Write-In 2 2.08% Total... 96 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 234 98.73% Write-In 3 1.27% Total... 237 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 88 37.45% Michael D Rowley 145 61.70% Write-In 2 0.85% Total... 235 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 227 99.13% Write-In 2 0.87% Total... 229 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 162 39.71% NO 246 60.29% Total... 408 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 141 34.47% NO 268 65.53% Total... 409 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 129 31.85% NO 276 68.15% Total... 405 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 159 38.69% NO 252 61.31% Total... 411 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 154 38.02% NO 251 61.98% Total... 405 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 249 61.79% NO 154 38.21% Total... 403 100.00% Ashley Schools YES 71 51.08% NO 68 48.92% Total... 139 100.00% Ovid-Elsie Millage YES 53 36.81% NO 91 63.19% Total... 144 100.00% Ovid-Elsie Sinking Fund YES 43 29.25% NO 104 70.75% Total... 147 100.00% Delta College YES 143 38.86% NO 225 61.14% Total... 368 100.00% Chesaning Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,779 Election Day Turnout 1,128 63.41% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,128 63.41% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 460 41.11% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 645 57.64% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 3 0.27% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 7 0.63% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 58 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Chesaning Township Precinct 1 PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES Write-In 4 0.36% Total... 1,119 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 362 32.91% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 706 64.18% LIBR - Scotty Boman 17 1.55% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 6 0.55% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 6 0.55% NATLAW - John D Litle 3 0.27% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,100 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 602 55.64% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 440 40.67% LIBR - John Gelineau 12 1.11% USTAX - George M Zimmer 10 0.92% GRN - Pat Timmons 18 1.66% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,082 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 85 TH DIST REP - Ben Glardon 470 44.21% DEM - Paul Ray 510 47.98% NPA - Matthew Shepard 81 7.62% Write-In 2 0.19% Total... 1,063 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 362 19.71% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 363 19.76% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 517 28.14% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 436 23.73% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 38 2.07% USTAX - Karen Adams 52 2.83% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 18 0.98% GRN - Candace R Caveny 32 1.74% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 17 0.93% Write-In 2 0.11% Total... 1,837 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 359 19.90% REP - Robert Steele 347 19.24% DEM - Mark Bernstein 511 28.33% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 448 24.83% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 24 1.33% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 23 1.27% USTAX - Joe Sanger 23 1.27% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 22 1.22% GRN - Eric Borregard 26 1.44% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 20 1.11% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,804 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 397 22.02% REP - Jeff Sakwa 341 18.91% DEM - Joel Ferguson 512 28.40% DEM - Brian Mosallam 426 23.63% LIBR - Michael H Miller 35 1.94% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 25 1.39% USTAX - Stephen J Young 28 1.55% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 38 2.11% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,803 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 365 21.00% REP - Satish B Jasti 299 17.20% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 509 29.29% DEM - Kim Trent 446 25.66% USTAX - Robert Gale 29 1.67% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 23 1.32% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 37 2.13% GRN - Latham Redding 28 1.61% Write-In 2 0.12% Total... 1,738 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 408 39.69% DEM - John McColgan Jr 616 59.92% Write-In 4 0.39% Total... 1,028 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 814 98.67% Write-In 11 1.33% Total... 825 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 59 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Chesaning Township Precinct 1 CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 390 38.39% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 624 61.42% Write-In 2 0.20% Total... 1,016 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 353 35.16% DEM - Tim Novak 648 64.54% Write-In 3 0.30% Total... 1,004 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 822 99.16% Write-In 7 0.84% Total... 829 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 810 99.26% Write-In 6 0.74% Total... 816 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 6 REP - Ron Sholtz 375 34.95% DEM - Katie Greenfelder 697 64.96% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,073 100.00% CHESANING TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR DEM - Robert J Corrin 830 98.81% Write-In 10 1.19% Total... 840 100.00% CHESANING TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Frances Kukulis 818 99.15% Write-In 7 0.85% Total... 825 100.00% CHESANING TOWNSHIP TREASURER DEM - Cathy L Gross 826 99.16% Write-In 7 0.84% Total... 833 100.00% CHESANING TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES DEM - Kevin Carlton 698 24.35% DEM - Bill Hedrich 710 24.77% DEM - Peter Hemgesberg 752 26.24% DEM - Ken J Hornak 691 24.11% Write-In 15 0.52% Total... 2,866 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 86 5.94% Connie Marie Kelley 313 21.60% Stephen Markman 304 20.98% Bridget Mary McCormack 308 21.26% Kerry L Morgan 63 4.35% Colleen O'Brien 311 21.46% Bob Roddis 63 4.35% Write-In 1 0.07% Total... 1,449 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 99 12.27% Shelia Johnson 308 38.17% Brian Zahra 398 49.32% Write-In 2 0.25% Total... 807 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 591 49.83% Peter D O'Connell 593 50.00% Write-In 2 0.17% Total... 1,186 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 663 99.55% Write-In 3 0.45% Total... 666 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 588 50.04% Darnell Jackson 583 49.62% Write-In 4 0.34% Total... 1,175 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 685 99.13% Write-In 6 0.87% Total... 691 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 675 99.26% Write-In 5 0.74% Total... 680 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 60 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Chesaning Township Precinct 1 VILLAGE OF CHESANING PRESIDENT Joseph F Sedlar Jr 777 98.23% Write-In 14 1.77% Total... 791 100.00% VILLAGE OF CHESANING CLERK Denise Ebenhoeh 810 98.90% Write-In 9 1.10% Total... 819 100.00% VILLAGE OF CHESANING TREASURER Kenneth L Valentine 830 99.40% Write-In 5 0.60% Total... 835 100.00% VILLAGE OF CHESANING TRUSTEES Michael W Cicalo 634 28.71% Matthew Hoover 656 29.71% Pavel A Mendlik 420 19.02% Donald F Swartzmiller 493 22.33% Write-In 5 0.23% Total... 2,208 100.00% CHESANING UNION SCHOOLS 4 YR Brian W Lewis 662 46.33% Julia Schultz Sadilek 759 53.11% Write-In 8 0.56% Total... 1,429 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 651 98.94% Write-In 7 1.06% Total... 658 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 264 42.04% Michael D Rowley 361 57.48% Write-In 3 0.48% Total... 628 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 623 99.05% Write-In 6 0.95% Total... 629 100.00% RIVER RAPIDS DISTRICT LIBRARY Meredith L Adelman 573 14.48% Amie S Auten 491 12.41% Mary Baese 613 15.50% Susan Cannon 565 14.28% Mechelle A Kuchar 529 13.37% Paul F Martin 598 15.12% Christi L Schubert 572 14.46% Write-In 15 0.38% Total... 3,956 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 428 40.45% NO 630 59.55% Total... 1,058 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 463 42.21% NO 634 57.79% Total... 1,097 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 421 38.66% NO 668 61.34% Total... 1,089 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 480 44.94% NO 588 55.06% Total... 1,068 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 319 29.73% NO 754 70.27% Total... 1,073 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 483 44.52% NO 602 55.48% Total... 1,085 100.00% Delta College YES 547 56.05% NO 429 43.95% Total... 976 100.00% Chesaning Township Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 1,780 Election Day Turnout 1,249 70.17% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 61 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Chesaning Township Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 1,780 SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,249 70.17% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 568 45.99% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 646 52.31% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 8 0.65% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 7 0.57% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.16% Write-In 4 0.32% Total... 1,235 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 414 33.99% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 764 62.73% LIBR - Scotty Boman 19 1.56% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 11 0.90% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 5 0.41% NATLAW - John D Litle 4 0.33% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,218 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 720 60.10% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 449 37.48% LIBR - John Gelineau 14 1.17% USTAX - George M Zimmer 7 0.58% GRN - Pat Timmons 7 0.58% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,198 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 85 TH DIST REP - Ben Glardon 596 50.81% DEM - Paul Ray 511 43.56% NPA - Matthew Shepard 66 5.63% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,173 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 405 20.44% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 382 19.28% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 554 27.97% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 479 24.18% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 36 1.82% USTAX - Karen Adams 61 3.08% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 22 1.11% GRN - Candace R Caveny 28 1.41% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 13 0.66% Write-In 1 0.05% Total... 1,981 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 397 20.39% REP - Robert Steele 386 19.83% DEM - Mark Bernstein 538 27.63% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 479 24.60% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 23 1.18% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 18 0.92% USTAX - Joe Sanger 30 1.54% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 26 1.34% GRN - Eric Borregard 18 0.92% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 30 1.54% Write-In 2 0.10% Total... 1,947 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 437 22.95% REP - Jeff Sakwa 348 18.28% DEM - Joel Ferguson 539 28.31% DEM - Brian Mosallam 450 23.63% LIBR - Michael H Miller 32 1.68% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 36 1.89% USTAX - Stephen J Young 41 2.15% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 18 0.95% Write-In 3 0.16% Total... 1,904 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 386 20.92% REP - Satish B Jasti 310 16.80% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 538 29.16% DEM - Kim Trent 476 25.80% USTAX - Robert Gale 49 2.66% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 34 1.84% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 32 1.73% GRN - Latham Redding 17 0.92% Write-In 3 0.16% Total... 1,845 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 62 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Chesaning Township Precinct 2 PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 499 45.28% DEM - John McColgan Jr 600 54.45% Write-In 3 0.27% Total... 1,102 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 893 98.89% Write-In 10 1.11% Total... 903 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 442 39.78% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 667 60.04% Write-In 2 0.18% Total... 1,111 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 395 36.47% DEM - Tim Novak 687 63.43% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,083 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 889 98.67% Write-In 12 1.33% Total... 901 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 867 98.30% Write-In 15 1.70% Total... 882 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 6 REP - Ron Sholtz 475 40.49% DEM - Katie Greenfelder 697 59.42% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,173 100.00% CHESANING TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR DEM - Robert J Corrin 914 99.02% Write-In 9 0.98% Total... 923 100.00% CHESANING TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Frances Kukulis 907 99.45% Write-In 5 0.55% Total... 912 100.00% CHESANING TOWNSHIP TREASURER DEM - Cathy L Gross 906 99.45% Write-In 5 0.55% Total... 911 100.00% CHESANING TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES DEM - Kevin Carlton 766 25.00% DEM - Bill Hedrich 788 25.72% DEM - Peter Hemgesberg 787 25.69% DEM - Ken J Hornak 714 23.30% Write-In 9 0.29% Total... 3,064 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 94 5.65% Connie Marie Kelley 397 23.87% Stephen Markman 367 22.07% Bridget Mary McCormack 373 22.43% Kerry L Morgan 50 3.01% Colleen O'Brien 328 19.72% Bob Roddis 47 2.83% Write-In 7 0.42% Total... 1,663 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 108 12.36% Shelia Johnson 368 42.11% Brian Zahra 394 45.08% Write-In 4 0.46% Total... 874 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 621 49.29% Peter D O'Connell 627 49.76% Write-In 12 0.95% Total... 1,260 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 716 99.31% Write-In 5 0.69% Total... 721 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 639 50.63% Darnell Jackson 615 48.73% Write-In 8 0.63% Total... 1,262 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 63 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Chesaning Township Precinct 2 JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 738 99.06% Write-In 7 0.94% Total... 745 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 734 99.19% Write-In 6 0.81% Total... 740 100.00% CHESANING UNION SCHOOLS 4 YR Brian W Lewis 695 46.06% Julia Schultz Sadilek 805 53.35% Write-In 9 0.60% Total... 1,509 100.00% NEW LOTHROP PUBLIC SCHOOLS Adam Green 11 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 11 0.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 691 98.86% Write-In 8 1.14% Total... 699 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 241 35.55% Michael D Rowley 431 63.57% Write-In 6 0.88% Total... 678 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 663 98.96% Write-In 7 1.04% Total... 670 100.00% RIVER RAPIDS DISTRICT LIBRARY Meredith L Adelman 592 14.52% Amie S Auten 511 12.54% Mary Baese 625 15.33% Susan Cannon 582 14.28% Mechelle A Kuchar 568 13.94% Paul F Martin 611 14.99% Christi L Schubert 575 14.11% Write-In 12 0.29% Total... 4,076 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 425 36.17% NO 750 63.83% Total... 1,175 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 536 44.78% NO 661 55.22% Total... 1,197 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 441 36.90% NO 754 63.10% Total... 1,195 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 499 42.22% NO 683 57.78% Total... 1,182 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 367 31.02% NO 816 68.98% Total... 1,183 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 593 49.66% NO 601 50.34% Total... 1,194 100.00% New Lothrop Schools YES 11 84.62% NO 2 15.38% Total... 13 100.00% Delta College YES 559 49.51% NO 570 50.49% Total... 1,129 100.00% Frankenmuth Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 798 Election Day Turnout 619 77.57% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 619 77.57% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 499 80.88%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 64 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Frankenmuth Township Precinct 1 PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 112 18.15% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 0 0.00% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 2 0.32% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 4 0.65% Total... 617 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 400 65.79% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 190 31.25% LIBR - Scotty Boman 7 1.15% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 7 1.15% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.66% NATLAW - John D Litle 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 608 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 522 86.57% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 66 10.95% LIBR - John Gelineau 7 1.16% USTAX - George M Zimmer 3 0.50% GRN - Pat Timmons 5 0.83% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 603 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 504 86.01% DEM - Judith Lincoln 82 13.99% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 586 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 415 39.79% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 417 39.98% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 95 9.11% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 66 6.33% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 11 1.05% USTAX - Karen Adams 17 1.63% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 9 0.86% GRN - Candace R Caveny 6 0.58% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 6 0.58% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,043 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 412 40.08% REP - Robert Steele 404 39.30% DEM - Mark Bernstein 97 9.44% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 72 7.00% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 7 0.68% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 11 1.07% USTAX - Joe Sanger 7 0.68% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 8 0.78% GRN - Eric Borregard 4 0.39% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 5 0.49% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,028 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 424 41.37% REP - Jeff Sakwa 380 37.07% DEM - Joel Ferguson 105 10.24% DEM - Brian Mosallam 76 7.41% LIBR - Michael H Miller 14 1.37% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 9 0.88% USTAX - Stephen J Young 8 0.78% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 8 0.78% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,025 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 397 40.18% REP - Satish B Jasti 363 36.74% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 118 11.94% DEM - Kim Trent 76 7.69% USTAX - Robert Gale 13 1.32% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 7 0.71% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 7 0.71% GRN - Latham Redding 6 0.61% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 988 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 452 80.14% DEM - John McColgan Jr 112 19.86% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 564 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 65 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Frankenmuth Township Precinct 1 SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 310 98.73% Write-In 4 1.27% Total... 314 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 406 71.86% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 159 28.14% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 565 0.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 442 79.78% DEM - Tim Novak 112 20.22% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 554 0.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 309 98.41% Write-In 5 1.59% Total... 314 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 286 97.95% Write-In 6 2.05% Total... 292 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 8 REP - Dennis Krafft 534 99.44% Write-In 3 0.56% Total... 537 100.00% FRANKENMUTH TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Tim Hildner 538 99.63% Write-In 2 0.37% Total... 540 100.00% FRANKENMUTH TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Sandra K Humpert 528 99.44% Write-In 3 0.56% Total... 531 100.00% FRANKENMUTH TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Kathy Marshall 510 99.61% Write-In 2 0.39% Total... 512 100.00% FRANKENMUTH TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Thomas Bierlein 500 50.56% REP - Jeff Frahm 488 49.34% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 989 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 21 2.35% Connie Marie Kelley 154 17.26% Stephen Markman 305 34.19% Bridget Mary McCormack 120 13.45% Kerry L Morgan 25 2.80% Colleen O'Brien 238 26.68% Bob Roddis 27 3.03% Write-In 2 0.22% Total... 892 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 21 4.38% Shelia Johnson 112 23.38% Brian Zahra 344 71.82% Write-In 2 0.42% Total... 479 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 378 50.74% Peter D O'Connell 366 49.13% Write-In 1 0.13% Total... 745 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 387 99.23% Write-In 3 0.77% Total... 390 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 368 50.07% Darnell Jackson 366 49.80% Write-In 1 0.14% Total... 735 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 401 99.01% Write-In 4 0.99% Total... 405 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 405 99.02% Write-In 4 0.98% Total... 409 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 66 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Frankenmuth Township Precinct 1 FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS Lori Ettema 300 32.02% David E Harris 273 29.14% Karen Uebler 361 38.53% Write-In 3 0.32% Total... 937 100.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS PARTIAL Al Zehnder 471 99.37% Write-In 3 0.63% Total... 474 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 387 99.49% Write-In 2 0.51% Total... 389 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 127 35.18% Michael D Rowley 232 64.27% Write-In 2 0.55% Total... 361 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 354 99.72% Write-In 1 0.28% Total... 355 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 419 68.80% NO 190 31.20% Total... 609 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 90 14.80% NO 518 85.20% Total... 608 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 62 10.18% NO 547 89.82% Total... 609 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 85 13.91% NO 526 86.09% Total... 611 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 118 19.28% NO 494 80.72% Total... 612 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 139 22.75% NO 472 77.25% Total... 611 100.00% Delta College YES 325 54.53% NO 271 45.47% Total... 596 100.00% Frankenmuth Township Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 823 Election Day Turnout 653 79.34% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 653 79.34% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 467 71.96% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 177 27.27% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.15% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 3 0.46% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 1 0.15% Total... 649 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 391 61.09% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 239 37.34% LIBR - Scotty Boman 6 0.94% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 1 0.16% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 3 0.47% NATLAW - John D Litle 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 640 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 504 80.25% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 116 18.47% LIBR - John Gelineau 3 0.48% USTAX - George M Zimmer 4 0.64% GRN - Pat Timmons 1 0.16%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 67 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Frankenmuth Township Precinct 2 US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 628 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 476 77.02% DEM - Judith Lincoln 142 22.98% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 618 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 393 35.69% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 391 35.51% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 149 13.53% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 116 10.54% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 9 0.82% USTAX - Karen Adams 17 1.54% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 8 0.73% GRN - Candace R Caveny 11 1.00% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 7 0.64% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,101 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 380 34.89% REP - Robert Steele 369 33.88% DEM - Mark Bernstein 165 15.15% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 132 12.12% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 11 1.01% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 8 0.73% USTAX - Joe Sanger 4 0.37% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 8 0.73% GRN - Eric Borregard 7 0.64% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 5 0.46% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,089 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 401 37.41% REP - Jeff Sakwa 362 33.77% DEM - Joel Ferguson 149 13.90% DEM - Brian Mosallam 121 11.29% LIBR - Michael H Miller 13 1.21% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 8 0.75% USTAX - Stephen J Young 10 0.93% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 8 0.75% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,072 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 375 35.99% REP - Satish B Jasti 344 33.01% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 156 14.97% DEM - Kim Trent 125 12.00% USTAX - Robert Gale 14 1.34% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 8 0.77% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 13 1.25% GRN - Latham Redding 7 0.67% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,042 0.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 411 68.73% DEM - John McColgan Jr 187 31.27% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 598 0.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 367 99.19% Write-In 3 0.81% Total... 370 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 367 60.76% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 237 39.24% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 604 0.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 409 69.09% DEM - Tim Novak 183 30.91% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 592 0.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 368 99.73% Write-In 1 0.27% Total... 369 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 346 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 346 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 68 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Frankenmuth Township Precinct 2 COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 8 REP - Dennis Krafft 519 99.43% Write-In 3 0.57% Total... 522 100.00% FRANKENMUTH TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Tim Hildner 522 99.24% Write-In 4 0.76% Total... 526 100.00% FRANKENMUTH TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Sandra K Humpert 512 99.42% Write-In 3 0.58% Total... 515 100.00% FRANKENMUTH TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Kathy Marshall 493 99.40% Write-In 3 0.60% Total... 496 100.00% FRANKENMUTH TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Thomas Bierlein 470 50.92% REP - Jeff Frahm 451 48.86% Write-In 2 0.22% Total... 923 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 26 2.79% Connie Marie Kelley 91 9.77% Stephen Markman 353 37.92% Bridget Mary McCormack 150 16.11% Kerry L Morgan 21 2.26% Colleen O'Brien 263 28.25% Bob Roddis 27 2.90% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 931 0.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 31 6.39% Shelia Johnson 80 16.49% Brian Zahra 374 77.11% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 485 0.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 394 53.10% Peter D O'Connell 347 46.77% Write-In 1 0.13% Total... 742 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 381 99.48% Write-In 2 0.52% Total... 383 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 369 50.83% Darnell Jackson 355 48.90% Write-In 2 0.28% Total... 726 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 402 99.50% Write-In 2 0.50% Total... 404 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 414 99.52% Write-In 2 0.48% Total... 416 100.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS Lori Ettema 347 36.56% David E Harris 300 31.61% Karen Uebler 300 31.61% Write-In 2 0.21% Total... 949 100.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS PARTIAL Al Zehnder 490 99.59% Write-In 2 0.41% Total... 492 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 382 99.74% Write-In 1 0.26% Total... 383 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 109 30.45% Michael D Rowley 248 69.27% Write-In 1 0.28% Total... 358 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 365 99.73%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 69 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Frankenmuth Township Precinct 2 DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Write-In 1 0.27% Total... 366 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 419 66.83% NO 208 33.17% Total... 627 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 126 20.06% NO 502 79.94% Total... 628 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 110 17.46% NO 520 82.54% Total... 630 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 119 18.77% NO 515 81.23% Total... 634 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 130 20.63% NO 500 79.37% Total... 630 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 162 25.63% NO 470 74.37% Total... 632 100.00% Delta College YES 360 58.92% NO 251 41.08% Total... 611 100.00% Fremont Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,638 Election Day Turnout 1,145 69.90% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,145 69.90% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 682 60.09% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 436 38.41% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 6 0.53% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 6 0.53% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.09% Write-In 4 0.35% Total... 1,135 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 528 47.91% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 537 48.73% LIBR - Scotty Boman 18 1.63% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 7 0.64% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 10 0.91% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.18% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,102 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 747 68.34% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 310 28.36% LIBR - John Gelineau 18 1.65% USTAX - George M Zimmer 12 1.10% GRN - Pat Timmons 6 0.55% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,093 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 85 TH DIST REP - Ben Glardon 566 54.84% DEM - Paul Ray 380 36.82% NPA - Matthew Shepard 85 8.24% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,032 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 498 27.32% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 477 26.17% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 376 20.63% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 295 16.18% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 37 2.03% USTAX - Karen Adams 72 3.95% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 22 1.21% GRN - Candace R Caveny 23 1.26% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 23 1.26% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,823 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 70 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Fremont Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 501 27.93% REP - Robert Steele 474 26.42% DEM - Mark Bernstein 362 20.18% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 323 18.00% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 17 0.95% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 19 1.06% USTAX - Joe Sanger 24 1.34% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 24 1.34% GRN - Eric Borregard 20 1.11% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 29 1.62% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,794 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 543 30.52% REP - Jeff Sakwa 458 25.74% DEM - Joel Ferguson 360 20.24% DEM - Brian Mosallam 290 16.30% LIBR - Michael H Miller 27 1.52% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 37 2.08% USTAX - Stephen J Young 36 2.02% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 26 1.46% Write-In 2 0.11% Total... 1,779 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 485 28.51% REP - Satish B Jasti 409 24.04% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 376 22.10% DEM - Kim Trent 310 18.22% USTAX - Robert Gale 40 2.35% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 29 1.70% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 32 1.88% GRN - Latham Redding 18 1.06% Write-In 2 0.12% Total... 1,701 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 542 51.82% DEM - John McColgan Jr 503 48.09% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,046 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 764 98.58% Write-In 11 1.42% Total... 775 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 494 47.68% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 541 52.22% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,036 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 561 54.68% DEM - Tim Novak 465 45.32% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,026 0.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 723 98.91% Write-In 8 1.09% Total... 731 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 702 98.46% Write-In 11 1.54% Total... 713 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 6 REP - Ron Sholtz 619 59.63% DEM - Katie Greenfelder 418 40.27% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,038 100.00% FREMONT TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Donald LaClair 840 98.36% Write-In 14 1.64% Total... 854 100.00% FREMONT TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Patricia J Wesener 835 98.70% Write-In 11 1.30% Total... 846 100.00% FREMONT TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Elaine M Zelinko 875 99.09% Write-In 8 0.91% Total... 883 100.00% FREMONT TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Richard G Kushion 649 38.00% REP - Gordon G Turner 632 37.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 71 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Fremont Township Precinct 1 FREMONT TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES DEM - Duane J Brown 425 24.88% Write-In 2 0.12% Total... 1,708 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 58 4.02% Connie Marie Kelley 210 14.55% Stephen Markman 310 21.48% Bridget Mary McCormack 354 24.53% Kerry L Morgan 87 6.03% Colleen O'Brien 358 24.81% Bob Roddis 62 4.30% Write-In 4 0.28% Total... 1,443 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 119 15.30% Shelia Johnson 241 30.98% Brian Zahra 414 53.21% Write-In 4 0.51% Total... 778 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 619 54.88% Peter D O'Connell 504 44.68% Write-In 5 0.44% Total... 1,128 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 630 98.90% Write-In 7 1.10% Total... 637 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 542 48.48% Darnell Jackson 568 50.81% Write-In 8 0.72% Total... 1,118 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 668 98.96% Write-In 7 1.04% Total... 675 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 670 99.26% Write-In 5 0.74% Total... 675 100.00% HEMLOCK PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD MEMBER Mary Ann Ling 416 30.25% Larry Long 276 20.07% Dennis D McMahan 299 21.75% Matthew Wesener 381 27.71% Write-In 3 0.22% Total... 1,375 100.00% MERRILL COMMUNITY SCHOOLS Matthew H Miller 83 98.81% Write-In 1 1.19% Total... 84 100.00% MERRILL SCHOOL PARTIAL Write-In 14 100.00% Total... 14 100.00% ST CHARLES COMM SCHOOL 6 YR BD MEMBER6 Laurasue Hensel Holcomb 188 89.95% Write-In 21 10.05% Total... 209 100.00% ST CHARLES COMM SCHOOLS 2YR Ronald Gonzales 213 98.16% Write-In 4 1.84% Total... 217 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 604 98.85% Write-In 7 1.15% Total... 611 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 257 42.20% Michael D Rowley 348 57.14% Write-In 4 0.66% Total... 609 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 586 98.65% Write-In 8 1.35% Total... 594 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 493 45.73% NO 585 54.27% Total... 1,078 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 72 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Fremont Township Precinct 1 State Proposal 12-2 YES 372 33.97% NO 723 66.03% Total... 1,095 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 283 25.96% NO 807 74.04% Total... 1,090 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 353 32.47% NO 734 67.53% Total... 1,087 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 348 32.10% NO 736 67.90% Total... 1,084 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 495 45.29% NO 598 54.71% Total... 1,093 100.00% Delta College YES 502 47.86% NO 547 52.14% Total... 1,049 100.00% James Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,565 Election Day Turnout 1,097 70.10% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,097 70.10% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 606 55.65% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 463 42.52% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 7 0.64% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 5 0.46% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 5 0.46% Write-In 3 0.28% Total... 1,089 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 451 42.07% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 598 55.78% LIBR - Scotty Boman 12 1.12% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 6 0.56% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 3 0.28% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.19% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,072 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 683 64.62% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 341 32.26% LIBR - John Gelineau 14 1.32% USTAX - George M Zimmer 10 0.95% GRN - Pat Timmons 9 0.85% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,057 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST REP - Jeff Baker 516 51.50% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 484 48.30% Write-In 2 0.20% Total... 1,002 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 433 24.81% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 411 23.55% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 430 24.64% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 336 19.26% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 32 1.83% USTAX - Karen Adams 50 2.87% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 22 1.26% GRN - Candace R Caveny 17 0.97% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 12 0.69% Write-In 2 0.11% Total... 1,745 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 411 24.09% REP - Robert Steele 382 22.39% DEM - Mark Bernstein 435 25.50% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 362 21.22% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 15 0.88% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 12 0.70% USTAX - Joe Sanger 23 1.35% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 23 1.35%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 73 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

James Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS GRN - Eric Borregard 18 1.06% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 23 1.35% Write-In 2 0.12% Total... 1,706 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 441 26.22% REP - Jeff Sakwa 367 21.82% DEM - Joel Ferguson 420 24.97% DEM - Brian Mosallam 352 20.93% LIBR - Michael H Miller 26 1.55% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 30 1.78% USTAX - Stephen J Young 26 1.55% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 17 1.01% Write-In 3 0.18% Total... 1,682 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 401 24.60% REP - Satish B Jasti 326 20.00% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 425 26.07% DEM - Kim Trent 361 22.15% USTAX - Robert Gale 38 2.33% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 31 1.90% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 26 1.60% GRN - Latham Redding 18 1.10% Write-In 4 0.25% Total... 1,630 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 434 42.76% DEM - John McColgan Jr 575 56.65% Write-In 6 0.59% Total... 1,015 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 777 98.35% Write-In 13 1.65% Total... 790 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 419 41.20% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 595 58.51% Write-In 3 0.29% Total... 1,017 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 438 45.15% DEM - Tim Novak 527 54.33% Write-In 5 0.52% Total... 970 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 739 99.06% Write-In 7 0.94% Total... 746 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 706 98.06% Write-In 14 1.94% Total... 720 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 4 REP - Sandra Klopf Lichon 475 45.85% DEM - Susan McInerney 558 53.86% Write-In 3 0.29% Total... 1,036 100.00% JAMES TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Rhonda M Hart 488 46.92% DEM - Edward Hak 550 52.88% Write-In 2 0.19% Total... 1,040 100.00% JAMES TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Thomas J Dierich 769 97.96% Write-In 16 2.04% Total... 785 100.00% JAMES TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Joanne E Boehler 807 98.41% Write-In 13 1.59% Total... 820 100.00% JAMES TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Kathy A Hoeppner 573 35.24% DEM - Gary G Hakes 563 34.62% DEM - Donald P McInerney 486 29.89% Write-In 4 0.25% Total... 1,626 100.00% JAMES TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION REP - Shari Lynn Avila 479 14.23% REP - Sarah Johnson 476 14.14% REP - Jessica L Taylor 485 14.41%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 74 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

James Township Precinct 1 JAMES TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION DEM - Sherri Ballosh-Hancock 487 14.47% DEM - Carl Bohn 423 12.57% DEM - Julie Minor-Pangborn 384 11.41% DEM - Shelly M Taylor 624 18.54% Write-In 8 0.24% Total... 3,366 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 52 3.47% Connie Marie Kelley 240 16.00% Stephen Markman 346 23.07% Bridget Mary McCormack 300 20.00% Kerry L Morgan 84 5.60% Colleen O'Brien 405 27.00% Bob Roddis 65 4.33% Write-In 8 0.53% Total... 1,500 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 68 8.19% Shelia Johnson 309 37.23% Brian Zahra 448 53.98% Write-In 5 0.60% Total... 830 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 664 54.65% Peter D O'Connell 543 44.69% Write-In 8 0.66% Total... 1,215 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 671 98.68% Write-In 9 1.32% Total... 680 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 609 51.26% Darnell Jackson 568 47.81% Write-In 11 0.93% Total... 1,188 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 718 99.17% Write-In 6 0.83% Total... 724 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 712 98.75% Write-In 9 1.25% Total... 721 100.00% SWAN VALLEY SCHOOLS 6 YR Amy Dwyer 776 99.23% Write-In 6 0.77% Total... 782 100.00% SWAN VALLEY SCHOOLS 4 YR Christy L Boehler 769 58.08% Charleen K Boland 550 41.54% Write-In 5 0.38% Total... 1,324 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 662 99.25% Write-In 5 0.75% Total... 667 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 219 34.01% Michael D Rowley 419 65.06% Write-In 6 0.93% Total... 644 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 610 98.55% Write-In 9 1.45% Total... 619 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 458 43.54% NO 594 56.46% Total... 1,052 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 413 38.74% NO 653 61.26% Total... 1,066 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 292 27.50% NO 770 72.50% Total... 1,062 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 407 38.14%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 75 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

James Township Precinct 1 State Proposal 12-4 NO 660 61.86% Total... 1,067 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 348 32.99% NO 707 67.01% Total... 1,055 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 513 47.99% NO 556 52.01% Total... 1,069 100.00% Delta College YES 597 57.85% NO 435 42.15% Total... 1,032 100.00% Jonesfield Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,255 Election Day Turnout 840 66.93% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 840 66.93% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 455 54.49% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 366 43.83% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 4 0.48% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 7 0.84% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.12% Write-In 2 0.24% Total... 835 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 337 40.90% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 441 53.52% LIBR - Scotty Boman 22 2.67% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 9 1.09% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 13 1.58% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.24% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 824 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 552 66.91% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 236 28.61% LIBR - John Gelineau 15 1.82% USTAX - George M Zimmer 14 1.70% GRN - Pat Timmons 6 0.73% Write-In 2 0.24% Total... 825 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 85 TH DIST REP - Ben Glardon 341 44.23% DEM - Paul Ray 320 41.50% NPA - Matthew Shepard 109 14.14% Write-In 1 0.13% Total... 771 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 317 23.43% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 334 24.69% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 308 22.76% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 243 17.96% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 33 2.44% USTAX - Karen Adams 59 4.36% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 21 1.55% GRN - Candace R Caveny 25 1.85% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 9 0.67% Write-In 4 0.30% Total... 1,353 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 317 23.78% REP - Robert Steele 319 23.93% DEM - Mark Bernstein 295 22.13% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 260 19.50% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 15 1.13% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 22 1.65% USTAX - Joe Sanger 37 2.78% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 21 1.58% GRN - Eric Borregard 16 1.20% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 28 2.10% Write-In 3 0.23% Total... 1,333 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 347 26.23% REP - Jeff Sakwa 284 21.47% DEM - Joel Ferguson 312 23.58%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 76 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Jonesfield Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES DEM - Brian Mosallam 253 19.12% LIBR - Michael H Miller 46 3.48% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 29 2.19% USTAX - Stephen J Young 28 2.12% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 20 1.51% Write-In 4 0.30% Total... 1,323 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 319 24.73% REP - Satish B Jasti 260 20.16% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 321 24.88% DEM - Kim Trent 262 20.31% USTAX - Robert Gale 45 3.49% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 33 2.56% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 32 2.48% GRN - Latham Redding 16 1.24% Write-In 2 0.16% Total... 1,290 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 412 52.96% DEM - John McColgan Jr 363 46.66% Write-In 3 0.39% Total... 778 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 604 98.05% Write-In 12 1.95% Total... 616 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 360 45.98% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 419 53.51% Write-In 4 0.51% Total... 783 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 365 47.71% DEM - Tim Novak 396 51.76% Write-In 4 0.52% Total... 765 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 597 98.84% Write-In 7 1.16% Total... 604 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 578 99.14% Write-In 5 0.86% Total... 583 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 5 REP - Jim Theisen 367 47.72% DEM - Dave Adams 400 52.02% Write-In 2 0.26% Total... 769 100.00% JONESFIELD TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Larry P Fleming 646 97.44% Write-In 17 2.56% Total... 663 100.00% JONESFIELD TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Rochelle Siler 671 98.10% Write-In 13 1.90% Total... 684 100.00% JONESFIELD TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Mildred M Parker 671 97.67% Write-In 16 2.33% Total... 687 100.00% JONESFIELD TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Julie A Foye 613 54.83% REP - Larry Tibbits 492 44.01% Write-In 13 1.16% Total... 1,118 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 60 5.23% Connie Marie Kelley 201 17.51% Stephen Markman 226 19.69% Bridget Mary McCormack 218 18.99% Kerry L Morgan 52 4.53% Colleen O'Brien 316 27.53% Bob Roddis 70 6.10% Write-In 5 0.44% Total... 1,148 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 88 13.77% Shelia Johnson 185 28.95% Brian Zahra 361 56.49%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 77 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Jonesfield Township Precinct 1 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Write-In 5 0.78% Total... 639 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 501 52.85% Peter D O'Connell 438 46.20% Write-In 9 0.95% Total... 948 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 534 98.71% Write-In 7 1.29% Total... 541 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 477 50.05% Darnell Jackson 468 49.11% Write-In 8 0.84% Total... 953 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 552 98.92% Write-In 6 1.08% Total... 558 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 560 99.12% Write-In 5 0.88% Total... 565 100.00% VILLAGE OF MERRILL PRESIDENT Gary J Siler 272 98.19% Write-In 5 1.81% Total... 277 100.00% VILLAGE OF MERRILL CLERK Janice M Wazny 263 96.34% Write-In 10 3.66% Total... 273 100.00% VILLAGE OF MERRILL TREASURER Write-In 77 100.00% Total... 77 100.00% VILLAGE OF MERRILL TRUSTEES Barry F Playford 233 34.26% Leija Wale 203 29.85% Delynn Wenzel 238 35.00% Write-In 6 0.88% Total... 680 100.00% VILLAGE OF MERRILL TRUSTEE PARTIAL Monica Latoski 244 97.21% Write-In 7 2.79% Total... 251 100.00% MERRILL COMMUNITY SCHOOLS Matthew H Miller 570 90.62% Write-In 59 9.38% Total... 629 100.00% MERRILL SCHOOL PARTIAL Write-In 73 100.00% Total... 73 100.00% BRECKENRIDGE COMM SCHOOL 6 DISTRICT BOARD MEMBER 6 Bridget Bushre-Suhr 2 50.00% Lori Sue Cross 1 25.00% Richard W Stewart 1 25.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 4 0.00% BRECKENRIDGE COMM SCHOOL 2 DISTRICT BOARD MEMBER 4 Karmen Sanders 2 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 2 0.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 499 98.42% Write-In 8 1.58% Total... 507 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 192 38.25% Michael D Rowley 301 59.96% Write-In 9 1.79% Total... 502 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 483 98.17% Write-In 9 1.83% Total... 492 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 353 43.63% NO 456 56.37% Total... 809 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 78 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Jonesfield Township Precinct 1 State Proposal 12-2 YES 326 39.76% NO 494 60.24% Total... 820 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 208 25.40% NO 611 74.60% Total... 819 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 324 39.75% NO 491 60.25% Total... 815 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 290 35.71% NO 522 64.29% Total... 812 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 404 49.33% NO 415 50.67% Total... 819 100.00% Delta College YES 396 51.16% NO 378 48.84% Total... 774 100.00% Kochville Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,790 Election Day Turnout 1,178 65.81% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,178 65.81% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 651 55.40% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 507 43.15% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 6 0.51% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 5 0.43% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.17% Write-In 4 0.34% Total... 1,175 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 504 44.02% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 611 53.36% LIBR - Scotty Boman 15 1.31% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 6 0.52% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 2 0.17% NATLAW - John D Litle 7 0.61% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,145 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 716 63.42% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 373 33.04% LIBR - John Gelineau 18 1.59% USTAX - George M Zimmer 14 1.24% GRN - Pat Timmons 8 0.71% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,129 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST REP - Jeff Baker 552 51.93% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 505 47.51% Write-In 6 0.56% Total... 1,063 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 482 25.69% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 481 25.64% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 444 23.67% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 347 18.50% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 32 1.71% USTAX - Karen Adams 36 1.92% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 12 0.64% GRN - Candace R Caveny 26 1.39% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 15 0.80% Write-In 1 0.05% Total... 1,876 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 434 23.63% REP - Robert Steele 438 23.84% DEM - Mark Bernstein 471 25.64% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 379 20.63% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 21 1.14% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 23 1.25% USTAX - Joe Sanger 20 1.09% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 16 0.87%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 79 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Kochville Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS GRN - Eric Borregard 13 0.71% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 19 1.03% Write-In 3 0.16% Total... 1,837 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 480 26.70% REP - Jeff Sakwa 413 22.97% DEM - Joel Ferguson 422 23.47% DEM - Brian Mosallam 341 18.97% LIBR - Michael H Miller 54 3.00% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 26 1.45% USTAX - Stephen J Young 37 2.06% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 21 1.17% Write-In 4 0.22% Total... 1,798 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 457 26.07% REP - Satish B Jasti 369 21.05% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 444 25.33% DEM - Kim Trent 375 21.39% USTAX - Robert Gale 29 1.65% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 41 2.34% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 20 1.14% GRN - Latham Redding 13 0.74% Write-In 5 0.29% Total... 1,753 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 487 45.56% DEM - John McColgan Jr 581 54.35% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,069 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 825 99.16% Write-In 7 0.84% Total... 832 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 429 40.13% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 629 58.84% Write-In 11 1.03% Total... 1,069 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 606 55.75% DEM - Tim Novak 476 43.79% Write-In 5 0.46% Total... 1,087 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 768 99.10% Write-In 7 0.90% Total... 775 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 744 98.54% Write-In 11 1.46% Total... 755 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 1 REP - Patrick Wurtzel 523 49.86% DEM - Ruth M Averill 524 49.95% Write-In 2 0.19% Total... 1,049 100.00% KOCHVILLE TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Ken Bayne 399 35.69% DEM - Jim Loiacano 716 64.04% Write-In 3 0.27% Total... 1,118 100.00% KOCHVILLE TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Kevin Machata 711 78.65% Write-In 193 21.35% Total... 904 100.00% KOCHVILLE TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Lyle Brewster 617 55.29% DEM - Cynthia L Bourdow 496 44.44% Write-In 3 0.27% Total... 1,116 100.00% KOCHVILLE TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Edward Thon 579 47.34% DEM - Rhonda A Ferrell 636 52.00% Write-In 8 0.65% Total... 1,223 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 77 4.90% Connie Marie Kelley 303 19.26% Stephen Markman 396 25.17%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 80 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Kochville Township Precinct 1 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Bridget Mary McCormack 315 20.03% Kerry L Morgan 46 2.92% Colleen O'Brien 362 23.01% Bob Roddis 69 4.39% Write-In 5 0.32% Total... 1,573 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 82 9.57% Shelia Johnson 327 38.16% Brian Zahra 444 51.81% Write-In 4 0.47% Total... 857 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 647 53.83% Peter D O'Connell 549 45.67% Write-In 6 0.50% Total... 1,202 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 670 99.26% Write-In 5 0.74% Total... 675 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 599 49.30% Darnell Jackson 607 49.96% Write-In 9 0.74% Total... 1,215 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 723 98.64% Write-In 10 1.36% Total... 733 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 716 98.90% Write-In 8 1.10% Total... 724 100.00% FREELAND COMM 6 YR SCHOOL Janet M Alexander 38 8.14% Kristin Anderson 55 11.78% Michele Daniels 34 7.28% David Dennis 53 11.35% Melissa Lickly 30 6.42% Shawnette Markey 38 8.14% Toni Riffel 41 8.78% Charles Snider 43 9.21% Holli Wallace 25 5.35% Pete Wiltse 61 13.06% David Youngstrom 46 9.85% Write-In 3 0.64% Total... 467 100.00% FREELAND COMMUNITY 4 YR SCHOOLS PARTIAL Dennis J Argyle 69 40.59% Michelle Vanamburg Rankin 29 17.06% Holly Roenicke 49 28.82% Candace Stowell 22 12.94% Write-In 1 0.59% Total... 170 100.00% BAY CITY PUBLIC SCHOOLS 4 YR Pauline Helmling 19 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 19 0.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 653 98.34% Write-In 11 1.66% Total... 664 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 264 38.43% Michael D Rowley 417 60.70% Write-In 6 0.87% Total... 687 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 609 98.38% Write-In 10 1.62% Total... 619 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 500 44.37% NO 627 55.63% Total... 1,127 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 410 36.16% NO 724 63.84% Total... 1,134 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 81 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Kochville Township Precinct 1 State Proposal 12-3 YES 321 28.31% NO 813 71.69% Total... 1,134 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 384 34.16% NO 740 65.84% Total... 1,124 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 299 26.46% NO 831 73.54% Total... 1,130 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 456 40.28% NO 676 59.72% Total... 1,132 100.00% Saginaw City Schools YES 334 41.54% NO 470 58.46% Total... 804 100.00% Delta College YES 637 57.96% NO 462 42.04% Total... 1,099 100.00% Lakefield Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 772 Election Day Turnout 539 69.82% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 539 69.82% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 285 53.27% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 236 44.11% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 4 0.75% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 4 0.75% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 3 0.56% Write-In 3 0.56% Total... 535 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 193 37.48% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 302 58.64% LIBR - Scotty Boman 12 2.33% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 2 0.39% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 6 1.17% NATLAW - John D Litle 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 515 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 343 65.71% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 155 29.69% LIBR - John Gelineau 8 1.53% USTAX - George M Zimmer 8 1.53% GRN - Pat Timmons 8 1.53% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 522 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 85 TH DIST REP - Ben Glardon 236 49.06% DEM - Paul Ray 206 42.83% NPA - Matthew Shepard 39 8.11% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 481 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 200 23.53% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 189 22.24% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 200 23.53% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 155 18.24% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 20 2.35% USTAX - Karen Adams 44 5.18% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 19 2.24% GRN - Candace R Caveny 13 1.53% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 9 1.06% Write-In 1 0.12% Total... 850 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 188 23.07% REP - Robert Steele 190 23.31% DEM - Mark Bernstein 184 22.58% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 166 20.37% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 11 1.35% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 13 1.60% USTAX - Joe Sanger 21 2.58%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 82 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Lakefield Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 17 2.09% GRN - Eric Borregard 14 1.72% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 11 1.35% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 815 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 211 25.99% REP - Jeff Sakwa 168 20.69% DEM - Joel Ferguson 188 23.15% DEM - Brian Mosallam 154 18.97% LIBR - Michael H Miller 21 2.59% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 23 2.83% USTAX - Stephen J Young 26 3.20% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 20 2.46% Write-In 1 0.12% Total... 812 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 195 24.62% REP - Satish B Jasti 158 19.95% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 195 24.62% DEM - Kim Trent 177 22.35% USTAX - Robert Gale 16 2.02% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 20 2.53% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 18 2.27% GRN - Latham Redding 13 1.64% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 792 0.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 247 51.24% DEM - John McColgan Jr 235 48.76% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 482 0.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 379 98.19% Write-In 7 1.81% Total... 386 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 200 42.02% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 276 57.98% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 476 0.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 224 46.47% DEM - Tim Novak 258 53.53% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 482 0.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 360 98.63% Write-In 5 1.37% Total... 365 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 341 98.84% Write-In 4 1.16% Total... 345 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 5 REP - Jim Theisen 250 52.63% DEM - Dave Adams 224 47.16% Write-In 1 0.21% Total... 475 100.00% LAKEFIELD TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Terry T Crevia 375 97.15% Write-In 11 2.85% Total... 386 100.00% LAKEFIELD TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Barbara A Reist 396 99.25% Write-In 3 0.75% Total... 399 100.00% LAKEFIELD TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Mary Lou Fischer 410 99.27% Write-In 3 0.73% Total... 413 100.00% LAKEFIELD TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Donald F Rohn Jr 343 60.18% NPA - Beth A Foye 225 39.47% Write-In 2 0.35% Total... 570 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 49 6.78% Connie Marie Kelley 163 22.54% Stephen Markman 156 21.58% Bridget Mary McCormack 175 24.20%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 83 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Lakefield Township Precinct 1 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Kerry L Morgan 29 4.01% Colleen O'Brien 128 17.70% Bob Roddis 20 2.77% Write-In 3 0.41% Total... 723 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 27 6.96% Shelia Johnson 168 43.30% Brian Zahra 192 49.48% Write-In 1 0.26% Total... 388 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 282 52.51% Peter D O'Connell 248 46.18% Write-In 7 1.30% Total... 537 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 313 98.43% Write-In 5 1.57% Total... 318 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 276 51.30% Darnell Jackson 256 47.58% Write-In 6 1.12% Total... 538 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 322 99.38% Write-In 2 0.62% Total... 324 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 322 99.08% Write-In 3 0.92% Total... 325 100.00% MERRILL COMMUNITY SCHOOLS Matthew H Miller 351 94.86% Write-In 19 5.14% Total... 370 100.00% MERRILL SCHOOL PARTIAL Write-In 30 100.00% Total... 30 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 312 99.36% Write-In 2 0.64% Total... 314 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 98 32.89% Michael D Rowley 197 66.11% Write-In 3 1.01% Total... 298 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 296 99.00% Write-In 3 1.00% Total... 299 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 221 42.58% NO 298 57.42% Total... 519 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 205 39.20% NO 318 60.80% Total... 523 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 130 25.05% NO 389 74.95% Total... 519 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 206 39.39% NO 317 60.61% Total... 523 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 180 34.95% NO 335 65.05% Total... 515 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 255 49.04% NO 265 50.96% Total... 520 100.00% Delta College YES 236 47.68%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 84 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Lakefield Township Precinct 1 Delta College NO 259 52.32% Total... 495 100.00% Maple Grove Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 2,031 Election Day Turnout 1,515 74.59% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,515 74.59% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 686 45.82% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 789 52.71% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 7 0.47% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 11 0.73% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.07% Write-In 3 0.20% Total... 1,497 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 489 33.49% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 926 63.42% LIBR - Scotty Boman 18 1.23% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 13 0.89% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 9 0.62% NATLAW - John D Litle 4 0.27% Write-In 1 0.07% Total... 1,460 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 853 59.86% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 532 37.33% LIBR - John Gelineau 11 0.77% USTAX - George M Zimmer 14 0.98% GRN - Pat Timmons 14 0.98% Write-In 1 0.07% Total... 1,425 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 85 TH DIST REP - Ben Glardon 720 52.10% DEM - Paul Ray 575 41.61% NPA - Matthew Shepard 85 6.15% Write-In 2 0.14% Total... 1,382 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 453 19.90% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 433 19.02% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 665 29.22% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 527 23.15% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 39 1.71% USTAX - Karen Adams 69 3.03% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 32 1.41% GRN - Candace R Caveny 31 1.36% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 23 1.01% Write-In 4 0.18% Total... 2,276 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 464 20.59% REP - Robert Steele 406 18.02% DEM - Mark Bernstein 651 28.89% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 565 25.08% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 25 1.11% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 23 1.02% USTAX - Joe Sanger 33 1.46% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 27 1.20% GRN - Eric Borregard 28 1.24% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 28 1.24% Write-In 3 0.13% Total... 2,253 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 486 21.92% REP - Jeff Sakwa 403 18.18% DEM - Joel Ferguson 627 28.28% DEM - Brian Mosallam 552 24.90% LIBR - Michael H Miller 49 2.21% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 28 1.26% USTAX - Stephen J Young 38 1.71% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 31 1.40% Write-In 3 0.14% Total... 2,217 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 422 19.86% REP - Satish B Jasti 337 15.86% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 653 30.73% DEM - Kim Trent 579 27.25%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 85 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Maple Grove Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS USTAX - Robert Gale 44 2.07% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 30 1.41% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 32 1.51% GRN - Latham Redding 27 1.27% Write-In 1 0.05% Total... 2,125 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 552 42.86% DEM - John McColgan Jr 732 56.83% Write-In 4 0.31% Total... 1,288 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 1,126 99.03% Write-In 11 0.97% Total... 1,137 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 504 37.95% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 820 61.75% Write-In 4 0.30% Total... 1,328 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 430 33.36% DEM - Tim Novak 856 66.41% Write-In 3 0.23% Total... 1,289 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,138 99.04% Write-In 11 0.96% Total... 1,149 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,175 98.16% Write-In 22 1.84% Total... 1,197 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 7 REP - Dana Young 508 40.09% DEM - Cheryl Marie Hadsall 756 59.67% Write-In 3 0.24% Total... 1,267 100.00% MAPLE GROVE TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR NPA - Kevin M Krupp 1,035 99.52% Write-In 5 0.48% Total... 1,040 100.00% MAPLE GROVE TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Richard J Maxa 1,195 99.01% Write-In 12 0.99% Total... 1,207 100.00% MAPLE GROVE TOWNSHIP TREASURER NPA - Cheryl L Bishop 1,089 99.63% Write-In 4 0.37% Total... 1,093 100.00% MAPLE GROVE TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Ralph Krupp 625 25.78% DEM - Douglas W Birchmeier 910 37.54% DEM - Gregory J Wendling 882 36.39% Write-In 7 0.29% Total... 2,424 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 60 3.14% Connie Marie Kelley 503 26.29% Stephen Markman 428 22.37% Bridget Mary McCormack 454 23.73% Kerry L Morgan 55 2.88% Colleen O'Brien 362 18.92% Bob Roddis 48 2.51% Write-In 3 0.16% Total... 1,913 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 113 10.91% Shelia Johnson 388 37.45% Brian Zahra 533 51.45% Write-In 2 0.19% Total... 1,036 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 709 48.36% Peter D O'Connell 747 50.95% Write-In 10 0.68% Total... 1,466 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 839 99.17% Write-In 7 0.83% Total... 846 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 86 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Maple Grove Township Precinct 1 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 751 50.34% Darnell Jackson 731 48.99% Write-In 10 0.67% Total... 1,492 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 886 99.22% Write-In 7 0.78% Total... 893 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 875 98.87% Write-In 10 1.13% Total... 885 100.00% CHESANING UNION SCHOOLS 4 YR Brian W Lewis 99 47.83% Julia Schultz Sadilek 108 52.17% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 207 0.00% NEW LOTHROP PUBLIC SCHOOLS Adam Green 971 99.49% Write-In 5 0.51% Total... 976 100.00% MONTROSE COMMUNITY Kevin Briggs 37 55.22% Ronald Loafman 30 44.78% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 67 0.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 869 99.31% Write-In 6 0.69% Total... 875 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 277 35.79% Michael D Rowley 492 63.57% Write-In 5 0.65% Total... 774 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 757 99.08% Write-In 7 0.92% Total... 764 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 551 38.56% NO 878 61.44% Total... 1,429 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 689 47.39% NO 765 52.61% Total... 1,454 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 498 34.25% NO 956 65.75% Total... 1,454 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 622 43.28% NO 815 56.72% Total... 1,437 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 429 29.65% NO 1,018 70.35% Total... 1,447 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 737 50.93% NO 710 49.07% Total... 1,447 100.00% New Lothrop Schools YES 756 63.91% NO 427 36.09% Total... 1,183 100.00% Delta College YES 658 48.78% NO 691 51.22% Total... 1,349 100.00% Marion Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 619 Election Day Turnout 401 64.78% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 401 64.78% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 232 58.29%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 87 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Marion Township Precinct 1 PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 156 39.20% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.25% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 4 1.01% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.50% Write-In 3 0.75% Total... 398 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 164 42.38% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 199 51.42% LIBR - Scotty Boman 11 2.84% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 4 1.03% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 7 1.81% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.52% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 387 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 259 67.80% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 105 27.49% LIBR - John Gelineau 8 2.09% USTAX - George M Zimmer 5 1.31% GRN - Pat Timmons 5 1.31% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 382 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 85 TH DIST REP - Ben Glardon 211 56.87% DEM - Paul Ray 128 34.50% NPA - Matthew Shepard 31 8.36% Write-In 1 0.27% Total... 371 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 150 25.00% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 143 23.83% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 127 21.17% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 105 17.50% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 15 2.50% USTAX - Karen Adams 27 4.50% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 12 2.00% GRN - Candace R Caveny 10 1.67% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 10 1.67% Write-In 1 0.17% Total... 600 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 147 25.09% REP - Robert Steele 144 24.57% DEM - Mark Bernstein 133 22.70% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 108 18.43% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 7 1.19% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 6 1.02% USTAX - Joe Sanger 12 2.05% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 10 1.71% GRN - Eric Borregard 7 1.19% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 11 1.88% Write-In 1 0.17% Total... 586 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 167 28.89% REP - Jeff Sakwa 132 22.84% DEM - Joel Ferguson 131 22.66% DEM - Brian Mosallam 100 17.30% LIBR - Michael H Miller 9 1.56% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 11 1.90% USTAX - Stephen J Young 17 2.94% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 10 1.73% Write-In 1 0.17% Total... 578 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 149 26.23% REP - Satish B Jasti 120 21.13% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 137 24.12% DEM - Kim Trent 117 20.60% USTAX - Robert Gale 14 2.46% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 5 0.88% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 14 2.46% GRN - Latham Redding 11 1.94% Write-In 1 0.18% Total... 568 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 185 52.41% DEM - John McColgan Jr 167 47.31% Write-In 1 0.28% Total... 353 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 88 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Marion Township Precinct 1 SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 286 98.28% Write-In 5 1.72% Total... 291 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 173 47.66% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 189 52.07% Write-In 1 0.28% Total... 363 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 160 45.45% DEM - Tim Novak 191 54.26% Write-In 1 0.28% Total... 352 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 274 98.92% Write-In 3 1.08% Total... 277 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 265 98.15% Write-In 5 1.85% Total... 270 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 6 REP - Ron Sholtz 257 67.63% DEM - Katie Greenfelder 121 31.84% Write-In 2 0.53% Total... 380 100.00% MARION TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Ray Sholtz 325 97.89% Write-In 7 2.11% Total... 332 100.00% MARION TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Seth T Goschka 311 97.19% Write-In 9 2.81% Total... 320 100.00% MARION TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Heidi S Behnke 313 98.74% Write-In 4 1.26% Total... 317 100.00% MARION TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Brad Becker 205 34.69% DEM - Joe Pine 148 25.04% DEM - Gerald Starke 235 39.76% Write-In 3 0.51% Total... 591 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 20 3.93% Connie Marie Kelley 87 17.09% Stephen Markman 138 27.11% Bridget Mary McCormack 107 21.02% Kerry L Morgan 34 6.68% Colleen O'Brien 104 20.43% Bob Roddis 19 3.73% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 509 0.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 41 14.14% Shelia Johnson 105 36.21% Brian Zahra 143 49.31% Write-In 1 0.34% Total... 290 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 198 50.38% Peter D O'Connell 192 48.85% Write-In 3 0.76% Total... 393 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 236 98.33% Write-In 4 1.67% Total... 240 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 186 48.69% Darnell Jackson 194 50.79% Write-In 2 0.52% Total... 382 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 245 98.00% Write-In 5 2.00% Total... 250 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 250 98.81%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 89 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Marion Township Precinct 1 JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Write-In 3 1.19% Total... 253 100.00% CHESANING UNION SCHOOLS 4 YR Brian W Lewis 1 50.00% Julia Schultz Sadilek 1 50.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 2 0.00% MERRILL COMMUNITY SCHOOLS Matthew H Miller 227 96.19% Write-In 9 3.81% Total... 236 100.00% MERRILL SCHOOL PARTIAL Write-In 18 100.00% Total... 18 100.00% ST CHARLES COMM SCHOOL 6 YR BD MEMBER6 Laurasue Hensel Holcomb 9 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 9 0.00% ST CHARLES COMM SCHOOLS 2YR Ronald Gonzales 9 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 9 0.00% ASHLEY COMMUNITY SCHOOLS Anmarie E Andrews 16 21.05% Kurt J Densmore 24 31.58% Melissa Payne 36 47.37% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 76 0.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 221 97.79% Write-In 5 2.21% Total... 226 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 83 36.89% Michael D Rowley 139 61.78% Write-In 3 1.33% Total... 225 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 208 98.11% Write-In 4 1.89% Total... 212 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 132 34.46% NO 251 65.54% Total... 383 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 153 39.64% NO 233 60.36% Total... 386 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 107 27.86% NO 277 72.14% Total... 384 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 150 39.06% NO 234 60.94% Total... 384 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 165 43.54% NO 214 56.46% Total... 379 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 250 65.10% NO 134 34.90% Total... 384 100.00% Ashley Schools YES 18 33.33% NO 36 66.67% Total... 54 100.00% Delta College YES 144 39.67% NO 219 60.33% Total... 363 100.00% Richland Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,719 Election Day Turnout 1,169 68.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,169 68.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 90 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Richland Township Precinct 1 PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 726 62.86% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 420 36.36% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.09% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 0 0.00% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.17% Write-In 6 0.52% Total... 1,155 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 573 50.40% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 536 47.14% LIBR - Scotty Boman 20 1.76% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 5 0.44% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 2 0.18% NATLAW - John D Litle 1 0.09% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,137 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 799 71.15% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 308 27.43% LIBR - John Gelineau 8 0.71% USTAX - George M Zimmer 6 0.53% GRN - Pat Timmons 2 0.18% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,123 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 85 TH DIST REP - Ben Glardon 581 55.18% DEM - Paul Ray 382 36.28% NPA - Matthew Shepard 90 8.55% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,053 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 541 28.88% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 529 28.24% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 374 19.97% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 277 14.79% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 36 1.92% USTAX - Karen Adams 57 3.04% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 28 1.49% GRN - Candace R Caveny 19 1.01% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 9 0.48% Write-In 3 0.16% Total... 1,873 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 511 28.40% REP - Robert Steele 479 26.63% DEM - Mark Bernstein 364 20.23% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 306 17.01% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 23 1.28% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 22 1.22% USTAX - Joe Sanger 25 1.39% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 27 1.50% GRN - Eric Borregard 18 1.00% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 22 1.22% Write-In 2 0.11% Total... 1,799 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 543 30.15% REP - Jeff Sakwa 491 27.26% DEM - Joel Ferguson 362 20.10% DEM - Brian Mosallam 296 16.44% LIBR - Michael H Miller 38 2.11% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 23 1.28% USTAX - Stephen J Young 30 1.67% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 16 0.89% Write-In 2 0.11% Total... 1,801 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 508 29.23% REP - Satish B Jasti 439 25.26% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 368 21.17% DEM - Kim Trent 302 17.38% USTAX - Robert Gale 41 2.36% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 27 1.55% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 31 1.78% GRN - Latham Redding 18 1.04% Write-In 4 0.23% Total... 1,738 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 574 53.54% DEM - John McColgan Jr 497 46.36%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 91 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Richland Township Precinct 1 PROSECUTING ATTORNEY Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,072 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 784 98.37% Write-In 13 1.63% Total... 797 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 551 51.83% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 510 47.98% Write-In 2 0.19% Total... 1,063 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 587 55.96% DEM - Tim Novak 457 43.57% Write-In 5 0.48% Total... 1,049 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 732 97.73% Write-In 17 2.27% Total... 749 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 727 97.85% Write-In 16 2.15% Total... 743 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 5 REP - Jim Theisen 596 56.44% DEM - Dave Adams 456 43.18% Write-In 4 0.38% Total... 1,056 100.00% RICHLAND TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Brian R Frederick 501 46.26% DEM - Fred Clark 316 29.18% NPA - Kevin Kreger 265 24.47% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,083 100.00% RICHLAND TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Joel Wardin 730 74.11% NPA - Ronald A Wenzel 251 25.48% Write-In 4 0.41% Total... 985 100.00% RICHLAND TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Daniel R Preuss 814 98.55% Write-In 12 1.45% Total... 826 100.00% RICHLAND TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - David B Earley 650 36.89% REP - Susan K Neuenfeldt 620 35.19% DEM - Matthew B Bray 488 27.70% Write-In 4 0.23% Total... 1,762 100.00% RICHLAND TOWNSHIP PARK BOARD REP - Lisa Smith Hagarty 664 15.27% REP - Mark Hingston 660 15.18% REP - Chuck Koons 588 13.53% REP - Virginia A Lisik 614 14.12% REP - Dana Preuss 619 14.24% REP - James W Schultz 575 13.23% REP - Ann Marie L Wudel 611 14.06% Write-In 16 0.37% Total... 4,347 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 72 4.84% Connie Marie Kelley 212 14.26% Stephen Markman 320 21.52% Bridget Mary McCormack 365 24.55% Kerry L Morgan 93 6.25% Colleen O'Brien 355 23.87% Bob Roddis 63 4.24% Write-In 7 0.47% Total... 1,487 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 63 7.75% Shelia Johnson 306 37.64% Brian Zahra 437 53.75% Write-In 7 0.86% Total... 813 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 615 53.81% Peter D O'Connell 518 45.32% Write-In 10 0.87% Total... 1,143 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 92 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Richland Township Precinct 1 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 638 98.46% Write-In 10 1.54% Total... 648 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 570 50.04% Darnell Jackson 557 48.90% Write-In 12 1.05% Total... 1,139 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 678 98.98% Write-In 7 1.02% Total... 685 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 670 98.67% Write-In 9 1.33% Total... 679 100.00% RICHLAND TOWNSHIP LIBRARY BOARD Carl Bruse 430 13.15% Margaret P Cramer 369 11.28% Heidi Kanouse 423 12.94% Marilyn Ludgin 377 11.53% Joe Shlien 236 7.22% Phyllis Shlien 248 7.58% Sara Wardin 576 17.61% Judith A Zastrow 603 18.44% Write-In 8 0.24% Total... 3,270 100.00% HEMLOCK PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD MEMBER Mary Ann Ling 666 32.46% Larry Long 375 18.27% Dennis D McMahan 461 22.47% Matthew Wesener 543 26.46% Write-In 7 0.34% Total... 2,052 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 643 98.62% Write-In 9 1.38% Total... 652 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 210 33.60% Michael D Rowley 408 65.28% Write-In 7 1.12% Total... 625 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 600 99.01% Write-In 6 0.99% Total... 606 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 480 44.16% NO 607 55.84% Total... 1,087 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 375 33.66% NO 739 66.34% Total... 1,114 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 269 24.02% NO 851 75.98% Total... 1,120 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 362 32.64% NO 747 67.36% Total... 1,109 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 330 30.05% NO 768 69.95% Total... 1,098 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 469 42.10% NO 645 57.90% Total... 1,114 100.00% Delta College YES 567 54.05% NO 482 45.95% Total... 1,049 100.00% Richland Township Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 1,567 Election Day Turnout 1,130 72.11% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 93 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Richland Township Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 1,567 SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,130 72.11% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 694 62.02% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 410 36.64% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 2 0.18% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 8 0.71% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 5 0.45% Total... 1,119 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 517 47.09% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 544 49.54% LIBR - Scotty Boman 29 2.64% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 1 0.09% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 3 0.27% NATLAW - John D Litle 4 0.36% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,098 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 779 71.14% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 289 26.39% LIBR - John Gelineau 14 1.28% USTAX - George M Zimmer 9 0.82% GRN - Pat Timmons 4 0.37% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,095 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 85 TH DIST REP - Ben Glardon 581 56.41% DEM - Paul Ray 362 35.15% NPA - Matthew Shepard 87 8.45% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,030 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 539 28.96% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 531 28.53% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 371 19.94% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 292 15.69% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 34 1.83% USTAX - Karen Adams 45 2.42% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 18 0.97% GRN - Candace R Caveny 16 0.86% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 15 0.81% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,861 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 524 28.65% REP - Robert Steele 514 28.10% DEM - Mark Bernstein 371 20.28% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 307 16.79% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 23 1.26% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 22 1.20% USTAX - Joe Sanger 16 0.87% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 19 1.04% GRN - Eric Borregard 17 0.93% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 16 0.87% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,829 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 551 30.71% REP - Jeff Sakwa 481 26.81% DEM - Joel Ferguson 364 20.29% DEM - Brian Mosallam 291 16.22% LIBR - Michael H Miller 39 2.17% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 21 1.17% USTAX - Stephen J Young 26 1.45% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 21 1.17% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,794 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 508 29.16% REP - Satish B Jasti 440 25.26% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 378 21.70% DEM - Kim Trent 317 18.20% USTAX - Robert Gale 35 2.01% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 16 0.92% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 25 1.44% GRN - Latham Redding 23 1.32% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,742 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 94 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Richland Township Precinct 2 PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 555 53.62% DEM - John McColgan Jr 478 46.18% Write-In 2 0.19% Total... 1,035 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 710 97.66% Write-In 17 2.34% Total... 727 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 520 50.10% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 516 49.71% Write-In 2 0.19% Total... 1,038 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 572 56.35% DEM - Tim Novak 441 43.45% Write-In 2 0.20% Total... 1,015 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 681 99.27% Write-In 5 0.73% Total... 686 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 658 98.95% Write-In 7 1.05% Total... 665 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 5 REP - Jim Theisen 580 56.31% DEM - Dave Adams 449 43.59% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,030 100.00% RICHLAND TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Brian R Frederick 534 50.09% DEM - Fred Clark 285 26.74% NPA - Kevin Kreger 247 23.17% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,066 0.00% RICHLAND TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Joel Wardin 736 76.11% NPA - Ronald A Wenzel 228 23.58% Write-In 3 0.31% Total... 967 100.00% RICHLAND TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Daniel R Preuss 827 98.69% Write-In 11 1.31% Total... 838 100.00% RICHLAND TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - David B Earley 648 36.94% REP - Susan K Neuenfeldt 608 34.66% DEM - Matthew B Bray 495 28.22% Write-In 3 0.17% Total... 1,754 100.00% RICHLAND TOWNSHIP PARK BOARD REP - Lisa Smith Hagarty 658 15.04% REP - Mark Hingston 674 15.41% REP - Chuck Koons 606 13.85% REP - Virginia A Lisik 593 13.55% REP - Dana Preuss 654 14.95% REP - James W Schultz 582 13.30% REP - Ann Marie L Wudel 598 13.67% Write-In 10 0.23% Total... 4,375 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 73 4.75% Connie Marie Kelley 246 15.99% Stephen Markman 388 25.23% Bridget Mary McCormack 235 15.28% Kerry L Morgan 95 6.18% Colleen O'Brien 439 28.54% Bob Roddis 60 3.90% Write-In 2 0.13% Total... 1,538 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 83 9.99% Shelia Johnson 231 27.80% Brian Zahra 515 61.97% Write-In 2 0.24% Total... 831 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 658 54.70% Peter D O'Connell 541 44.97%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 95 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Richland Township Precinct 2 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Write-In 4 0.33% Total... 1,203 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 662 99.55% Write-In 3 0.45% Total... 665 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 608 50.46% Darnell Jackson 590 48.96% Write-In 7 0.58% Total... 1,205 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 698 98.87% Write-In 8 1.13% Total... 706 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 670 98.67% Write-In 9 1.33% Total... 679 100.00% RICHLAND TOWNSHIP LIBRARY BOARD Carl Bruse 427 12.56% Margaret P Cramer 381 11.21% Heidi Kanouse 419 12.32% Marilyn Ludgin 467 13.74% Joe Shlien 225 6.62% Phyllis Shlien 225 6.62% Sara Wardin 625 18.38% Judith A Zastrow 627 18.44% Write-In 4 0.12% Total... 3,400 100.00% FREELAND COMM 6 YR SCHOOL Janet M Alexander 0 0.00% Kristin Anderson 0 0.00% Michele Daniels 0 0.00% David Dennis 0 0.00% Melissa Lickly 0 0.00% Shawnette Markey 0 0.00% Toni Riffel 0 0.00% Charles Snider 0 0.00% Holli Wallace 0 0.00% Pete Wiltse 0 0.00% David Youngstrom 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 0 0.00% FREELAND COMMUNITY 4 YR SCHOOLS PARTIAL Dennis J Argyle 0 0.00% Michelle Vanamburg Rankin 0 0.00% Holly Roenicke 0 0.00% Candace Stowell 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 0 0.00% HEMLOCK PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD MEMBER Mary Ann Ling 681 31.63% Larry Long 380 17.65% Dennis D McMahan 528 24.52% Matthew Wesener 563 26.15% Write-In 1 0.05% Total... 2,153 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 649 98.78% Write-In 8 1.22% Total... 657 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 251 39.97% Michael D Rowley 372 59.24% Write-In 5 0.80% Total... 628 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 606 99.02% Write-In 6 0.98% Total... 612 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 508 47.65% NO 558 52.35% Total... 1,066 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 369 33.67% NO 727 66.33% Total... 1,096 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 252 22.95%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 96 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Richland Township Precinct 2 State Proposal 12-3 NO 846 77.05% Total... 1,098 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 320 29.47% NO 766 70.53% Total... 1,086 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 314 29.18% NO 762 70.82% Total... 1,076 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 465 42.70% NO 624 57.30% Total... 1,089 100.00% Delta College YES 567 54.62% NO 471 45.38% Total... 1,038 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 2,111 Election Day Turnout 1,005 47.61% AV Polling Turnout 275 13.03% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,280 60.63% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 476 37.63% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 772 61.03% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 4 0.32% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 6 0.47% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.08% Write-In 6 0.47% Total... 1,265 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 383 30.76% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 819 65.78% LIBR - Scotty Boman 24 1.93% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 6 0.48% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 8 0.64% NATLAW - John D Litle 4 0.32% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,245 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 368 30.14% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 798 65.36% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 26 2.13% NPA - David Davenport 24 1.97% Write-In 5 0.41% Total... 1,221 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 468 38.30% DEM - Judith Lincoln 744 60.88% Write-In 10 0.82% Total... 1,222 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 382 17.19% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 366 16.47% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 686 30.87% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 629 28.31% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 40 1.80% USTAX - Karen Adams 41 1.85% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 22 0.99% GRN - Candace R Caveny 34 1.53% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 16 0.72% Write-In 6 0.27% Total... 2,222 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 360 16.33% REP - Robert Steele 345 15.65% DEM - Mark Bernstein 690 31.31% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 638 28.95% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 35 1.59% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 33 1.50% USTAX - Joe Sanger 23 1.04% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 24 1.09% GRN - Eric Borregard 19 0.86% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 28 1.27% Write-In 9 0.41% Total... 2,204 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 397 18.19%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 97 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Jeff Sakwa 350 16.04% DEM - Joel Ferguson 681 31.21% DEM - Brian Mosallam 608 27.86% LIBR - Michael H Miller 42 1.92% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 36 1.65% USTAX - Stephen J Young 28 1.28% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 30 1.37% Write-In 10 0.46% Total... 2,182 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 371 17.41% REP - Satish B Jasti 317 14.88% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 683 32.05% DEM - Kim Trent 632 29.66% USTAX - Robert Gale 39 1.83% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 35 1.64% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 23 1.08% GRN - Latham Redding 23 1.08% Write-In 8 0.38% Total... 2,131 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 380 31.40% DEM - John McColgan Jr 822 67.93% Write-In 8 0.66% Total... 1,210 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 986 97.72% Write-In 23 2.28% Total... 1,009 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 358 30.03% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 828 69.46% Write-In 6 0.50% Total... 1,192 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 374 31.43% DEM - Tim Novak 809 67.98% Write-In 7 0.59% Total... 1,190 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 963 98.67% Write-In 13 1.33% Total... 976 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 944 98.44% Write-In 15 1.56% Total... 959 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 4 (Final) REP - Sandra Klopf Lichon 394 33.14% DEM - Susan McInerney 791 66.53% Write-In 4 0.34% Total... 1,189 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 979 98.00% Write-In 20 2.00% Total... 999 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 717 92.40% Write-In 59 7.60% Total... 776 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 643 90.31% Write-In 69 9.69% Total... 712 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 424 11.28% REP - Jon R Howell 411 10.93% REP - James S Kelly 457 12.15% REP - Matthew Starke 360 9.57% DEM - Mark T Gorney 712 18.94% DEM - Richard Honig 686 18.24% DEM - Vince Mosca 686 18.24% Write-In 24 0.64% Total... 3,760 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 445 20.58% REP - Jack Cleveland 444 20.54% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 410 18.96% DEM - Martin Dahl 801 37.05% Write-In 62 2.87% Total... 2,162 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 98 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 1 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 68 4.05% Connie Marie Kelley 386 23.02% Stephen Markman 306 18.25% Bridget Mary McCormack 429 25.58% Kerry L Morgan 65 3.88% Colleen O'Brien 349 20.81% Bob Roddis 62 3.70% Write-In 12 0.72% Total... 1,677 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 101 10.72% Shelia Johnson 458 48.62% Brian Zahra 373 39.60% Write-In 10 1.06% Total... 942 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 701 53.92% Peter D O'Connell 578 44.46% Write-In 21 1.62% Total... 1,300 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 752 97.66% Write-In 18 2.34% Total... 770 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 634 47.24% Darnell Jackson 690 51.42% Write-In 18 1.34% Total... 1,342 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 818 98.44% Write-In 13 1.56% Total... 831 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 823 97.28% Write-In 23 2.72% Total... 846 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 619 42.78% Donald J McAnelly 344 23.77% Kristina Lord Schnepf 456 31.51% Write-In 28 1.94% Total... 1,447 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 771 96.62% Write-In 27 3.38% Total... 798 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 294 38.28% Michael D Rowley 458 59.64% Write-In 16 2.08% Total... 768 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 729 96.68% Write-In 25 3.32% Total... 754 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 494 41.72% NO 690 58.28% Total... 1,184 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 601 49.79% NO 606 50.21% Total... 1,207 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 493 40.85% NO 714 59.15% Total... 1,207 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 629 52.42% NO 571 47.58% Total... 1,200 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 353 29.42% NO 847 70.58% Total... 1,200 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 562 46.68% NO 642 53.32% Total... 1,204 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 99 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 1 Delta College (Final) YES 741 64.89% NO 401 35.11% Total... 1,142 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 1,510 Election Day Turnout 797 52.78% AV Polling Turnout 407 26.95% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,204 79.74% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 702 58.45% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 487 40.55% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 3 0.25% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 6 0.50% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 3 0.25% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,201 0.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 615 52.52% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 524 44.75% LIBR - Scotty Boman 19 1.62% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 7 0.60% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 2 0.17% NATLAW - John D Litle 3 0.26% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,171 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 617 54.03% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 493 43.17% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 15 1.31% NPA - David Davenport 15 1.31% Write-In 2 0.18% Total... 1,142 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 717 61.86% DEM - Judith Lincoln 439 37.88% Write-In 3 0.26% Total... 1,159 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 600 29.23% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 613 29.86% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 389 18.95% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 330 16.07% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 30 1.46% USTAX - Karen Adams 28 1.36% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 19 0.93% GRN - Candace R Caveny 19 0.93% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 19 0.93% Write-In 6 0.29% Total... 2,053 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 595 29.37% REP - Robert Steele 582 28.73% DEM - Mark Bernstein 405 19.99% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 345 17.03% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 16 0.79% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 17 0.84% USTAX - Joe Sanger 17 0.84% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 15 0.74% GRN - Eric Borregard 19 0.94% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 11 0.54% Write-In 4 0.20% Total... 2,026 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 627 31.30% REP - Jeff Sakwa 567 28.31% DEM - Joel Ferguson 390 19.47% DEM - Brian Mosallam 326 16.28% LIBR - Michael H Miller 25 1.25% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 26 1.30% USTAX - Stephen J Young 18 0.90% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 21 1.05% Write-In 3 0.15% Total... 2,003 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 594 30.51% REP - Satish B Jasti 538 27.63% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 391 20.08% DEM - Kim Trent 348 17.87% USTAX - Robert Gale 21 1.08%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 100 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 2 MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 18 0.92% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 18 0.92% GRN - Latham Redding 15 0.77% Write-In 4 0.21% Total... 1,947 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 452 39.37% DEM - John McColgan Jr 694 60.45% Write-In 2 0.17% Total... 1,148 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 801 99.01% Write-In 8 0.99% Total... 809 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 448 39.47% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 683 60.18% Write-In 4 0.35% Total... 1,135 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 625 56.51% DEM - Tim Novak 471 42.59% Write-In 10 0.90% Total... 1,106 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 768 99.35% Write-In 5 0.65% Total... 773 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 743 98.41% Write-In 12 1.59% Total... 755 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 11 (Final) REP - David Bechard 476 42.65% DEM - Michael J Hanley 476 42.65% NPA - John H Cammin 160 14.34% Write-In 4 0.36% Total... 1,116 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 825 99.16% Write-In 7 0.84% Total... 832 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 868 98.86% Write-In 10 1.14% Total... 878 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 791 97.17% Write-In 23 2.83% Total... 814 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 665 17.93% REP - Jon R Howell 642 17.31% REP - James S Kelly 664 17.90% REP - Matthew Starke 574 15.48% DEM - Mark T Gorney 414 11.16% DEM - Richard Honig 360 9.71% DEM - Vince Mosca 382 10.30% Write-In 8 0.22% Total... 3,709 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 632 25.48% REP - Jack Cleveland 686 27.66% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 608 24.52% DEM - Martin Dahl 529 21.33% Write-In 25 1.01% Total... 2,480 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 64 3.68% Connie Marie Kelley 319 18.33% Stephen Markman 509 29.25% Bridget Mary McCormack 336 19.31% Kerry L Morgan 44 2.53% Colleen O'Brien 419 24.08% Bob Roddis 48 2.76% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,740 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 52 5.45% Shelia Johnson 343 35.95% Brian Zahra 558 58.49%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 101 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 2 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 954 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 736 54.84% Peter D O'Connell 603 44.93% Write-In 3 0.22% Total... 1,342 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 712 99.44% Write-In 4 0.56% Total... 716 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 695 49.05% Darnell Jackson 717 50.60% Write-In 5 0.35% Total... 1,417 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 830 99.28% Write-In 6 0.72% Total... 836 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 779 99.36% Write-In 5 0.64% Total... 784 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 599 37.18% Donald J McAnelly 477 29.61% Kristina Lord Schnepf 530 32.90% Write-In 5 0.31% Total... 1,611 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 703 99.01% Write-In 7 0.99% Total... 710 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 274 41.20% Michael D Rowley 388 58.35% Write-In 3 0.45% Total... 665 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 639 98.92% Write-In 7 1.08% Total... 646 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 675 58.85% NO 472 41.15% Total... 1,147 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 342 29.38% NO 822 70.62% Total... 1,164 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 290 25.09% NO 866 74.91% Total... 1,156 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 311 27.00% NO 841 73.00% Total... 1,152 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 265 23.16% NO 879 76.84% Total... 1,144 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 378 32.70% NO 778 67.30% Total... 1,156 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 712 63.51% NO 409 36.49% Total... 1,121 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 3 Registration & Turnout 1,552 Election Day Turnout 867 55.86% AV Polling Turnout 330 21.26% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,197 77.13% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 629 52.90%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 102 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 3 PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 551 46.34% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 3 0.25% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 2 0.17% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.08% Write-In 3 0.25% Total... 1,189 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 503 43.07% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 637 54.54% LIBR - Scotty Boman 14 1.20% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 5 0.43% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 7 0.60% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.17% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,168 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 487 43.14% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 589 52.17% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 22 1.95% NPA - David Davenport 31 2.75% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,129 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 590 52.07% DEM - Judith Lincoln 541 47.75% Write-In 2 0.18% Total... 1,133 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 481 24.05% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 490 24.50% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 485 24.25% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 405 20.25% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 44 2.20% USTAX - Karen Adams 44 2.20% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 16 0.80% GRN - Candace R Caveny 18 0.90% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 12 0.60% Write-In 5 0.25% Total... 2,000 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 474 24.09% REP - Robert Steele 447 22.71% DEM - Mark Bernstein 487 24.75% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 418 21.24% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 33 1.68% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 25 1.27% USTAX - Joe Sanger 23 1.17% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 20 1.02% GRN - Eric Borregard 20 1.02% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 19 0.97% Write-In 2 0.10% Total... 1,968 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 512 26.65% REP - Jeff Sakwa 436 22.70% DEM - Joel Ferguson 463 24.10% DEM - Brian Mosallam 384 19.99% LIBR - Michael H Miller 42 2.19% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 25 1.30% USTAX - Stephen J Young 25 1.30% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 28 1.46% Write-In 6 0.31% Total... 1,921 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 462 24.99% REP - Satish B Jasti 399 21.58% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 474 25.64% DEM - Kim Trent 410 22.17% USTAX - Robert Gale 29 1.57% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 23 1.24% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 29 1.57% GRN - Latham Redding 17 0.92% Write-In 6 0.32% Total... 1,849 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 416 37.01% DEM - John McColgan Jr 707 62.90% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,124 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 858 98.39%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 103 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 3 SHERIFF (Final) Write-In 14 1.61% Total... 872 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 397 35.64% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 716 64.27% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,114 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 513 46.85% DEM - Tim Novak 576 52.60% Write-In 6 0.55% Total... 1,095 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 827 98.92% Write-In 9 1.08% Total... 836 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 802 98.40% Write-In 13 1.60% Total... 815 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 11 (Final) REP - David Bechard 355 32.18% DEM - Michael J Hanley 531 48.14% NPA - John H Cammin 216 19.58% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,103 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 869 98.97% Write-In 9 1.03% Total... 878 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 808 97.58% Write-In 20 2.42% Total... 828 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 740 96.61% Write-In 26 3.39% Total... 766 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 540 15.46% REP - Jon R Howell 516 14.77% REP - James S Kelly 579 16.58% REP - Matthew Starke 447 12.80% DEM - Mark T Gorney 502 14.37% DEM - Richard Honig 440 12.60% DEM - Vince Mosca 460 13.17% Write-In 9 0.26% Total... 3,493 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 520 23.41% REP - Jack Cleveland 546 24.58% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 493 22.20% DEM - Martin Dahl 632 28.46% Write-In 30 1.35% Total... 2,221 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 84 4.83% Connie Marie Kelley 377 21.69% Stephen Markman 432 24.86% Bridget Mary McCormack 418 24.05% Kerry L Morgan 42 2.42% Colleen O'Brien 349 20.08% Bob Roddis 29 1.67% Write-In 7 0.40% Total... 1,738 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 86 9.13% Shelia Johnson 325 34.50% Brian Zahra 528 56.05% Write-In 3 0.32% Total... 942 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 717 53.99% Peter D O'Connell 601 45.26% Write-In 10 0.75% Total... 1,328 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 719 98.49% Write-In 11 1.51% Total... 730 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 104 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 3 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 702 50.65% Darnell Jackson 675 48.70% Write-In 9 0.65% Total... 1,386 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 815 99.15% Write-In 7 0.85% Total... 822 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 783 98.74% Write-In 10 1.26% Total... 793 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 600 39.40% Donald J McAnelly 354 23.24% Kristina Lord Schnepf 560 36.77% Write-In 9 0.59% Total... 1,523 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 725 98.91% Write-In 8 1.09% Total... 733 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 225 33.19% Michael D Rowley 447 65.93% Write-In 6 0.88% Total... 678 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 662 98.66% Write-In 9 1.34% Total... 671 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 543 47.72% NO 595 52.28% Total... 1,138 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 450 39.34% NO 694 60.66% Total... 1,144 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 374 32.30% NO 784 67.70% Total... 1,158 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 442 38.43% NO 708 61.57% Total... 1,150 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 262 22.86% NO 884 77.14% Total... 1,146 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 439 37.84% NO 721 62.16% Total... 1,160 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 773 69.58% NO 338 30.42% Total... 1,111 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 4 Registration & Turnout 1,293 Election Day Turnout 663 51.28% AV Polling Turnout 287 22.20% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 950 73.47% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 508 54.10% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 420 44.73% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.11% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 8 0.85% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 2 0.21% Total... 939 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 426 45.86% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 476 51.24% LIBR - Scotty Boman 16 1.72% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 4 0.43% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 5 0.54%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 105 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 4 US SENATOR (Final) NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.22% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 929 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 409 45.14% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 466 51.43% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 11 1.21% NPA - David Davenport 19 2.10% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 906 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 491 54.02% DEM - Judith Lincoln 415 45.65% Write-In 3 0.33% Total... 909 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 397 25.16% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 380 24.08% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 374 23.70% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 316 20.03% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 24 1.52% USTAX - Karen Adams 37 2.34% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 14 0.89% GRN - Candace R Caveny 14 0.89% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 17 1.08% Write-In 5 0.32% Total... 1,578 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 382 24.66% REP - Robert Steele 368 23.76% DEM - Mark Bernstein 376 24.27% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 337 21.76% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 13 0.84% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 12 0.77% USTAX - Joe Sanger 14 0.90% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 9 0.58% GRN - Eric Borregard 20 1.29% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 15 0.97% Write-In 3 0.19% Total... 1,549 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 409 26.91% REP - Jeff Sakwa 361 23.75% DEM - Joel Ferguson 366 24.08% DEM - Brian Mosallam 311 20.46% LIBR - Michael H Miller 18 1.18% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 13 0.86% USTAX - Stephen J Young 18 1.18% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 20 1.32% Write-In 4 0.26% Total... 1,520 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 389 26.14% REP - Satish B Jasti 320 21.51% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 379 25.47% DEM - Kim Trent 325 21.84% USTAX - Robert Gale 24 1.61% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 15 1.01% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 19 1.28% GRN - Latham Redding 13 0.87% Write-In 4 0.27% Total... 1,488 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 358 40.18% DEM - John McColgan Jr 529 59.37% Write-In 4 0.45% Total... 891 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 651 98.19% Write-In 12 1.81% Total... 663 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 345 39.29% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 532 60.59% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 878 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 397 46.11% DEM - Tim Novak 460 53.43% Write-In 4 0.46% Total... 861 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 106 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 4 REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 630 98.44% Write-In 10 1.56% Total... 640 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 603 97.42% Write-In 16 2.58% Total... 619 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 3 (Final) REP - Kirk Kilpatrick 469 55.77% DEM - Phillip Barnett 369 43.88% Write-In 3 0.36% Total... 841 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 666 98.09% Write-In 13 1.91% Total... 679 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 611 96.98% Write-In 19 3.02% Total... 630 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 564 94.79% Write-In 31 5.21% Total... 595 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 429 15.36% REP - Jon R Howell 402 14.39% REP - James S Kelly 461 16.51% REP - Matthew Starke 375 13.43% DEM - Mark T Gorney 399 14.29% DEM - Richard Honig 355 12.71% DEM - Vince Mosca 360 12.89% Write-In 12 0.43% Total... 2,793 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 414 23.90% REP - Jack Cleveland 425 24.54% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 394 22.75% DEM - Martin Dahl 467 26.96% Write-In 32 1.85% Total... 1,732 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 34 2.68% Connie Marie Kelley 306 24.11% Stephen Markman 335 26.40% Bridget Mary McCormack 262 20.65% Kerry L Morgan 35 2.76% Colleen O'Brien 263 20.72% Bob Roddis 25 1.97% Write-In 9 0.71% Total... 1,269 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 65 9.30% Shelia Johnson 253 36.19% Brian Zahra 375 53.65% Write-In 6 0.86% Total... 699 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 554 54.42% Peter D O'Connell 455 44.70% Write-In 9 0.88% Total... 1,018 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 556 98.23% Write-In 10 1.77% Total... 566 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 496 47.78% Darnell Jackson 535 51.54% Write-In 7 0.67% Total... 1,038 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 637 98.61% Write-In 9 1.39% Total... 646 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 617 97.78% Write-In 14 2.22% Total... 631 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 455 40.30%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 107 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 4 SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Donald J McAnelly 317 28.08% Kristina Lord Schnepf 348 30.82% Write-In 9 0.80% Total... 1,129 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 557 98.58% Write-In 8 1.42% Total... 565 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 224 42.26% Michael D Rowley 299 56.42% Write-In 7 1.32% Total... 530 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 517 98.85% Write-In 6 1.15% Total... 523 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 414 45.75% NO 491 54.25% Total... 905 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 357 39.06% NO 557 60.94% Total... 914 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 249 27.12% NO 669 72.88% Total... 918 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 358 39.13% NO 557 60.87% Total... 915 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 252 27.91% NO 651 72.09% Total... 903 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 391 42.78% NO 523 57.22% Total... 914 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 557 62.58% NO 333 37.42% Total... 890 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 5 Registration & Turnout 2,456 Election Day Turnout 1,292 52.61% AV Polling Turnout 441 17.96% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,733 70.56% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 856 49.74% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 842 48.93% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 3 0.17% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 7 0.41% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.12% Write-In 11 0.64% Total... 1,721 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 683 40.95% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 938 56.24% LIBR - Scotty Boman 24 1.44% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 3 0.18% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 15 0.90% NATLAW - John D Litle 5 0.30% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,668 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 681 42.25% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 883 54.78% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 19 1.18% NPA - David Davenport 27 1.67% Write-In 2 0.12% Total... 1,612 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 818 50.31% DEM - Judith Lincoln 805 49.51%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 108 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 5 STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) Write-In 3 0.18% Total... 1,626 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 654 23.26% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 628 22.33% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 728 25.89% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 612 21.76% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 47 1.67% USTAX - Karen Adams 49 1.74% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 22 0.78% GRN - Candace R Caveny 40 1.42% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 28 1.00% Write-In 4 0.14% Total... 2,812 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 655 23.33% REP - Robert Steele 619 22.04% DEM - Mark Bernstein 735 26.18% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 640 22.79% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 28 1.00% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 27 0.96% USTAX - Joe Sanger 24 0.85% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 21 0.75% GRN - Eric Borregard 30 1.07% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 23 0.82% Write-In 6 0.21% Total... 2,808 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 676 24.40% REP - Jeff Sakwa 607 21.91% DEM - Joel Ferguson 706 25.48% DEM - Brian Mosallam 626 22.59% LIBR - Michael H Miller 53 1.91% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 22 0.79% USTAX - Stephen J Young 34 1.23% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 41 1.48% Write-In 6 0.22% Total... 2,771 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 645 23.84% REP - Satish B Jasti 535 19.78% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 728 26.91% DEM - Kim Trent 653 24.14% USTAX - Robert Gale 43 1.59% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 34 1.26% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 33 1.22% GRN - Latham Redding 29 1.07% Write-In 5 0.18% Total... 2,705 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 642 40.33% DEM - John McColgan Jr 947 59.48% Write-In 3 0.19% Total... 1,592 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,178 98.25% Write-In 21 1.75% Total... 1,199 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 630 40.08% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 940 59.80% Write-In 2 0.13% Total... 1,572 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 699 44.95% DEM - Tim Novak 852 54.79% Write-In 4 0.26% Total... 1,555 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,152 99.05% Write-In 11 0.95% Total... 1,163 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,125 99.03% Write-In 11 0.97% Total... 1,136 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 4 (Final) REP - Sandra Klopf Lichon 721 46.91% DEM - Susan McInerney 810 52.70% Write-In 6 0.39% Total... 1,537 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 109 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 5 SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 1,190 99.00% Write-In 12 1.00% Total... 1,202 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 1,084 96.87% Write-In 35 3.13% Total... 1,119 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 999 94.87% Write-In 54 5.13% Total... 1,053 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 723 14.45% REP - Jon R Howell 713 14.25% REP - James S Kelly 790 15.79% REP - Matthew Starke 636 12.71% DEM - Mark T Gorney 743 14.85% DEM - Richard Honig 703 14.05% DEM - Vince Mosca 681 13.61% Write-In 13 0.26% Total... 5,002 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 728 23.65% REP - Jack Cleveland 758 24.63% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 686 22.29% DEM - Martin Dahl 868 28.20% Write-In 38 1.23% Total... 3,078 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 67 2.97% Connie Marie Kelley 392 17.35% Stephen Markman 626 27.71% Bridget Mary McCormack 533 23.59% Kerry L Morgan 81 3.59% Colleen O'Brien 507 22.44% Bob Roddis 49 2.17% Write-In 4 0.18% Total... 2,259 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 91 7.25% Shelia Johnson 519 41.32% Brian Zahra 642 51.11% Write-In 4 0.32% Total... 1,256 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 1,003 55.02% Peter D O'Connell 811 44.49% Write-In 9 0.49% Total... 1,823 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 1,009 98.82% Write-In 12 1.18% Total... 1,021 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 876 48.03% Darnell Jackson 936 51.32% Write-In 12 0.66% Total... 1,824 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 1,115 99.46% Write-In 6 0.54% Total... 1,121 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 1,109 98.75% Write-In 14 1.25% Total... 1,123 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 749 37.17% Donald J McAnelly 574 28.49% Kristina Lord Schnepf 679 33.70% Write-In 13 0.65% Total... 2,015 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 998 98.91% Write-In 11 1.09% Total... 1,009 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 330 33.85% Michael D Rowley 641 65.74% Write-In 4 0.41% Total... 975 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 110 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 5 DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 956 99.17% Write-In 8 0.83% Total... 964 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 718 44.54% NO 894 55.46% Total... 1,612 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 696 42.11% NO 957 57.89% Total... 1,653 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 516 31.48% NO 1,123 68.52% Total... 1,639 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 666 41.01% NO 958 58.99% Total... 1,624 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 431 26.67% NO 1,185 73.33% Total... 1,616 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 684 42.01% NO 944 57.99% Total... 1,628 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 995 63.34% NO 576 36.66% Total... 1,571 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 6 Registration & Turnout 2,427 Election Day Turnout 1,192 49.11% AV Polling Turnout 596 24.56% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,788 73.67% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 940 52.99% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 822 46.34% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.06% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 8 0.45% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.06% Write-In 2 0.11% Total... 1,774 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 754 43.23% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 955 54.76% LIBR - Scotty Boman 18 1.03% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 7 0.40% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 6 0.34% NATLAW - John D Litle 3 0.17% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,744 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 752 44.31% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 888 52.33% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 18 1.06% NPA - David Davenport 37 2.18% Write-In 2 0.12% Total... 1,697 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 871 51.09% DEM - Judith Lincoln 823 48.27% Write-In 11 0.65% Total... 1,705 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 751 24.98% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 741 24.64% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 740 24.61% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 627 20.85% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 35 1.16% USTAX - Karen Adams 47 1.56% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 24 0.80% GRN - Candace R Caveny 20 0.67% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 16 0.53% Write-In 6 0.20% Total... 3,007 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 111 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 6 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 718 24.18% REP - Robert Steele 694 23.37% DEM - Mark Bernstein 752 25.33% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 654 22.03% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 28 0.94% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 25 0.84% USTAX - Joe Sanger 24 0.81% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 25 0.84% GRN - Eric Borregard 14 0.47% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 28 0.94% Write-In 7 0.24% Total... 2,969 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 767 26.04% REP - Jeff Sakwa 679 23.06% DEM - Joel Ferguson 726 24.65% DEM - Brian Mosallam 638 21.66% LIBR - Michael H Miller 37 1.26% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 29 0.98% USTAX - Stephen J Young 31 1.05% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 28 0.95% Write-In 10 0.34% Total... 2,945 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 707 24.75% REP - Satish B Jasti 603 21.11% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 771 26.99% DEM - Kim Trent 658 23.03% USTAX - Robert Gale 36 1.26% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 40 1.40% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 22 0.77% GRN - Latham Redding 13 0.46% Write-In 7 0.25% Total... 2,857 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 616 36.41% DEM - John McColgan Jr 1,072 63.36% Write-In 4 0.24% Total... 1,692 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,287 98.55% Write-In 19 1.45% Total... 1,306 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 607 36.39% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 1,058 63.43% Write-In 3 0.18% Total... 1,668 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 737 44.80% DEM - Tim Novak 902 54.83% Write-In 6 0.36% Total... 1,645 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,256 98.82% Write-In 15 1.18% Total... 1,271 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,227 98.63% Write-In 17 1.37% Total... 1,244 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 4 (Final) REP - Sandra Klopf Lichon 776 47.61% DEM - Susan McInerney 851 52.21% Write-In 3 0.18% Total... 1,630 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 1,305 98.86% Write-In 15 1.14% Total... 1,320 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 1,159 96.91% Write-In 37 3.09% Total... 1,196 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 1,088 95.27% Write-In 54 4.73% Total... 1,142 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 803 15.05% REP - Jon R Howell 791 14.82%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 112 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 6 SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - James S Kelly 832 15.59% REP - Matthew Starke 694 13.01% DEM - Mark T Gorney 770 14.43% DEM - Richard Honig 705 13.21% DEM - Vince Mosca 728 13.64% Write-In 13 0.24% Total... 5,336 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 806 23.94% REP - Jack Cleveland 838 24.89% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 758 22.51% DEM - Martin Dahl 917 27.23% Write-In 48 1.43% Total... 3,367 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 81 3.20% Connie Marie Kelley 435 17.20% Stephen Markman 579 22.89% Bridget Mary McCormack 660 26.10% Kerry L Morgan 118 4.67% Colleen O'Brien 571 22.58% Bob Roddis 80 3.16% Write-In 5 0.20% Total... 2,529 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 115 8.44% Shelia Johnson 455 33.38% Brian Zahra 788 57.81% Write-In 5 0.37% Total... 1,363 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 1,092 55.40% Peter D O'Connell 864 43.84% Write-In 15 0.76% Total... 1,971 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 1,096 98.65% Write-In 15 1.35% Total... 1,111 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 987 48.64% Darnell Jackson 1,025 50.52% Write-In 17 0.84% Total... 2,029 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 1,227 99.19% Write-In 10 0.81% Total... 1,237 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 1,213 98.46% Write-In 19 1.54% Total... 1,232 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 923 40.89% Donald J McAnelly 569 25.21% Kristina Lord Schnepf 745 33.01% Write-In 20 0.89% Total... 2,257 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 1,108 98.49% Write-In 17 1.51% Total... 1,125 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 439 42.13% Michael D Rowley 591 56.72% Write-In 12 1.15% Total... 1,042 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 1,043 98.49% Write-In 16 1.51% Total... 1,059 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 839 49.47% NO 857 50.53% Total... 1,696 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 650 37.95% NO 1,063 62.05% Total... 1,713 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 518 30.26%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 113 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 6 State Proposal 12-3 (Final) NO 1,194 69.74% Total... 1,712 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 681 40.01% NO 1,021 59.99% Total... 1,702 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 420 24.59% NO 1,288 75.41% Total... 1,708 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 663 38.79% NO 1,046 61.21% Total... 1,709 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 1,084 65.62% NO 568 34.38% Total... 1,652 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 7 Registration & Turnout 2,728 Election Day Turnout 1,366 50.07% AV Polling Turnout 583 21.37% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,949 71.44% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 982 50.64% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 936 48.27% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 5 0.26% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 11 0.57% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 5 0.26% Total... 1,939 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 801 42.36% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 1,043 55.16% LIBR - Scotty Boman 28 1.48% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 8 0.42% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 8 0.42% NATLAW - John D Litle 1 0.05% Write-In 2 0.11% Total... 1,891 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 782 42.55% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 999 54.35% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 26 1.41% NPA - David Davenport 29 1.58% Write-In 2 0.11% Total... 1,838 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 904 48.89% DEM - Judith Lincoln 938 50.73% Write-In 7 0.38% Total... 1,849 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 783 23.53% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 763 22.93% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 871 26.18% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 718 21.58% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 45 1.35% USTAX - Karen Adams 64 1.92% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 21 0.63% GRN - Candace R Caveny 36 1.08% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 20 0.60% Write-In 6 0.18% Total... 3,327 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 765 23.34% REP - Robert Steele 740 22.57% DEM - Mark Bernstein 877 26.75% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 727 22.18% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 30 0.92% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 26 0.79% USTAX - Joe Sanger 25 0.76% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 26 0.79% GRN - Eric Borregard 31 0.95% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 22 0.67% Write-In 9 0.27% Total... 3,278 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 821 25.33%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 114 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 7 MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Jeff Sakwa 712 21.97% DEM - Joel Ferguson 830 25.61% DEM - Brian Mosallam 709 21.88% LIBR - Michael H Miller 55 1.70% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 33 1.02% USTAX - Stephen J Young 30 0.93% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 43 1.33% Write-In 8 0.25% Total... 3,241 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 766 24.27% REP - Satish B Jasti 658 20.85% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 849 26.90% DEM - Kim Trent 739 23.42% USTAX - Robert Gale 35 1.11% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 30 0.95% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 42 1.33% GRN - Latham Redding 28 0.89% Write-In 9 0.29% Total... 3,156 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 710 39.10% DEM - John McColgan Jr 1,102 60.68% Write-In 4 0.22% Total... 1,816 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,391 97.89% Write-In 30 2.11% Total... 1,421 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 675 37.58% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 1,116 62.14% Write-In 5 0.28% Total... 1,796 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 802 45.13% DEM - Tim Novak 967 54.42% Write-In 8 0.45% Total... 1,777 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,344 98.75% Write-In 17 1.25% Total... 1,361 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,314 98.80% Write-In 16 1.20% Total... 1,330 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 3 (Final) REP - Kirk Kilpatrick 904 52.07% DEM - Phillip Barnett 826 47.58% Write-In 6 0.35% Total... 1,736 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 1,416 98.95% Write-In 15 1.05% Total... 1,431 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 1,300 96.87% Write-In 42 3.13% Total... 1,342 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 1,181 94.56% Write-In 68 5.44% Total... 1,249 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 826 14.26% REP - Jon R Howell 855 14.76% REP - James S Kelly 890 15.37% REP - Matthew Starke 747 12.90% DEM - Mark T Gorney 868 14.99% DEM - Richard Honig 790 13.64% DEM - Vince Mosca 799 13.79% Write-In 17 0.29% Total... 5,792 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 887 23.86% REP - Jack Cleveland 903 24.29% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 833 22.41% DEM - Martin Dahl 1,051 28.28% Write-In 43 1.16% Total... 3,717 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 115 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 7 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 85 3.13% Connie Marie Kelley 492 18.14% Stephen Markman 619 22.82% Bridget Mary McCormack 584 21.53% Kerry L Morgan 162 5.97% Colleen O'Brien 671 24.74% Bob Roddis 89 3.28% Write-In 10 0.37% Total... 2,712 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 152 10.20% Shelia Johnson 583 39.13% Brian Zahra 749 50.27% Write-In 6 0.40% Total... 1,490 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 1,156 52.81% Peter D O'Connell 1,016 46.41% Write-In 17 0.78% Total... 2,189 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 1,222 98.87% Write-In 14 1.13% Total... 1,236 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 1,056 48.44% Darnell Jackson 1,110 50.92% Write-In 14 0.64% Total... 2,180 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 1,354 99.19% Write-In 11 0.81% Total... 1,365 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 1,312 98.57% Write-In 19 1.43% Total... 1,331 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 957 40.35% Donald J McAnelly 680 28.67% Kristina Lord Schnepf 721 30.40% Write-In 14 0.59% Total... 2,372 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 1,202 99.09% Write-In 11 0.91% Total... 1,213 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 408 35.82% Michael D Rowley 717 62.95% Write-In 14 1.23% Total... 1,139 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 1,106 99.10% Write-In 10 0.90% Total... 1,116 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 843 46.07% NO 987 53.93% Total... 1,830 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 745 40.25% NO 1,106 59.75% Total... 1,851 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 615 32.96% NO 1,251 67.04% Total... 1,866 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 768 41.54% NO 1,081 58.46% Total... 1,849 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 520 28.18% NO 1,325 71.82% Total... 1,845 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 796 42.93% NO 1,058 57.07% Total... 1,854 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 116 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 7 Delta College (Final) YES 1,164 65.61% NO 610 34.39% Total... 1,774 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 8 Registration & Turnout 1,381 Election Day Turnout 780 56.48% AV Polling Turnout 292 21.14% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,072 77.62% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 553 51.83% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 503 47.14% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 5 0.47% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 2 0.19% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 4 0.37% Total... 1,067 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 436 42.08% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 569 54.92% LIBR - Scotty Boman 14 1.35% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 8 0.77% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.39% NATLAW - John D Litle 4 0.39% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,036 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 419 42.62% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 536 54.53% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 13 1.32% NPA - David Davenport 15 1.53% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 983 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 489 48.51% DEM - Judith Lincoln 512 50.79% Write-In 7 0.69% Total... 1,008 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 401 23.45% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 405 23.68% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 428 25.03% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 345 20.18% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 34 1.99% USTAX - Karen Adams 42 2.46% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 21 1.23% GRN - Candace R Caveny 19 1.11% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 11 0.64% Write-In 4 0.23% Total... 1,710 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 408 24.16% REP - Robert Steele 375 22.20% DEM - Mark Bernstein 444 26.29% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 357 21.14% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 16 0.95% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 15 0.89% USTAX - Joe Sanger 23 1.36% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 17 1.01% GRN - Eric Borregard 13 0.77% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 21 1.24% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,689 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 426 25.60% REP - Jeff Sakwa 359 21.57% DEM - Joel Ferguson 426 25.60% DEM - Brian Mosallam 350 21.03% LIBR - Michael H Miller 30 1.80% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 23 1.38% USTAX - Stephen J Young 29 1.74% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 20 1.20% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,664 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 405 25.23% REP - Satish B Jasti 321 20.00% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 428 26.67% DEM - Kim Trent 362 22.55% USTAX - Robert Gale 27 1.68%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 117 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 8 MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 27 1.68% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 22 1.37% GRN - Latham Redding 12 0.75% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,605 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 399 40.97% DEM - John McColgan Jr 573 58.83% Write-In 2 0.21% Total... 974 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 761 98.32% Write-In 13 1.68% Total... 774 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 373 38.14% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 604 61.76% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 978 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 431 44.66% DEM - Tim Novak 532 55.13% Write-In 2 0.21% Total... 965 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 729 99.18% Write-In 6 0.82% Total... 735 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 714 99.03% Write-In 7 0.97% Total... 721 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 3 (Final) REP - Kirk Kilpatrick 522 56.37% DEM - Phillip Barnett 402 43.41% Write-In 2 0.22% Total... 926 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 788 98.87% Write-In 9 1.13% Total... 797 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 688 98.57% Write-In 10 1.43% Total... 698 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 634 96.65% Write-In 22 3.35% Total... 656 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 456 14.95% REP - Jon R Howell 464 15.21% REP - James S Kelly 492 16.13% REP - Matthew Starke 395 12.95% DEM - Mark T Gorney 452 14.81% DEM - Richard Honig 416 13.63% DEM - Vince Mosca 373 12.23% Write-In 3 0.10% Total... 3,051 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 475 24.43% REP - Jack Cleveland 481 24.74% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 418 21.50% DEM - Martin Dahl 545 28.03% Write-In 25 1.29% Total... 1,944 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 57 3.82% Connie Marie Kelley 269 18.04% Stephen Markman 374 25.08% Bridget Mary McCormack 325 21.80% Kerry L Morgan 49 3.29% Colleen O'Brien 360 24.14% Bob Roddis 54 3.62% Write-In 3 0.20% Total... 1,491 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 60 7.44% Shelia Johnson 320 39.70% Brian Zahra 423 52.48%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 118 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 8 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Write-In 3 0.37% Total... 806 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 623 53.38% Peter D O'Connell 540 46.27% Write-In 4 0.34% Total... 1,167 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 631 98.75% Write-In 8 1.25% Total... 639 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 560 47.46% Darnell Jackson 616 52.20% Write-In 4 0.34% Total... 1,180 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 722 99.31% Write-In 5 0.69% Total... 727 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 702 99.15% Write-In 6 0.85% Total... 708 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 489 38.00% Donald J McAnelly 346 26.88% Kristina Lord Schnepf 449 34.89% Write-In 3 0.23% Total... 1,287 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 611 98.55% Write-In 9 1.45% Total... 620 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 247 40.43% Michael D Rowley 357 58.43% Write-In 7 1.15% Total... 611 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 587 98.82% Write-In 7 1.18% Total... 594 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 466 45.82% NO 551 54.18% Total... 1,017 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 384 37.17% NO 649 62.83% Total... 1,033 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 297 28.98% NO 728 71.02% Total... 1,025 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 395 38.54% NO 630 61.46% Total... 1,025 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 263 25.78% NO 757 74.22% Total... 1,020 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 416 40.59% NO 609 59.41% Total... 1,025 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 624 63.22% NO 363 36.78% Total... 987 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 9 Registration & Turnout 2,034 Election Day Turnout 1,054 51.82% AV Polling Turnout 548 26.94% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,602 78.76% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 900 56.36%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 119 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 9 PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 679 42.52% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 6 0.38% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 5 0.31% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.06% Write-In 6 0.38% Total... 1,597 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 770 49.45% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 763 49.00% LIBR - Scotty Boman 19 1.22% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 1 0.06% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 3 0.19% NATLAW - John D Litle 1 0.06% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,557 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 754 49.80% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 725 47.89% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 19 1.25% NPA - David Davenport 16 1.06% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,514 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 823 53.76% DEM - Judith Lincoln 705 46.05% Write-In 3 0.20% Total... 1,531 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 717 26.48% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 720 26.59% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 624 23.04% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 522 19.28% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 40 1.48% USTAX - Karen Adams 41 1.51% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 16 0.59% GRN - Candace R Caveny 15 0.55% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 11 0.41% Write-In 2 0.07% Total... 2,708 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 718 26.59% REP - Robert Steele 698 25.85% DEM - Mark Bernstein 617 22.85% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 542 20.07% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 22 0.81% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 28 1.04% USTAX - Joe Sanger 19 0.70% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 18 0.67% GRN - Eric Borregard 18 0.67% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 20 0.74% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 2,700 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 757 28.38% REP - Jeff Sakwa 677 25.38% DEM - Joel Ferguson 604 22.65% DEM - Brian Mosallam 535 20.06% LIBR - Michael H Miller 28 1.05% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 31 1.16% USTAX - Stephen J Young 19 0.71% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 16 0.60% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 2,667 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 730 28.00% REP - Satish B Jasti 632 24.24% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 615 23.59% DEM - Kim Trent 538 20.64% USTAX - Robert Gale 33 1.27% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 23 0.88% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 25 0.96% GRN - Latham Redding 11 0.42% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 2,607 0.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 653 42.93% DEM - John McColgan Jr 867 57.00% Write-In 1 0.07% Total... 1,521 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,095 98.65%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 120 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 9 SHERIFF (Final) Write-In 15 1.35% Total... 1,110 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 660 43.77% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 847 56.17% Write-In 1 0.07% Total... 1,508 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 762 51.21% DEM - Tim Novak 721 48.45% Write-In 5 0.34% Total... 1,488 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,054 99.43% Write-In 6 0.57% Total... 1,060 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,023 99.22% Write-In 8 0.78% Total... 1,031 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 3 (Final) REP - Kirk Kilpatrick 838 58.36% DEM - Phillip Barnett 597 41.57% Write-In 1 0.07% Total... 1,436 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 1,104 99.01% Write-In 11 0.99% Total... 1,115 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 1,083 98.10% Write-In 21 1.90% Total... 1,104 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 1,007 97.29% Write-In 28 2.71% Total... 1,035 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 819 16.65% REP - Jon R Howell 815 16.57% REP - James S Kelly 835 16.97% REP - Matthew Starke 712 14.47% DEM - Mark T Gorney 633 12.87% DEM - Richard Honig 564 11.46% DEM - Vince Mosca 531 10.79% Write-In 11 0.22% Total... 4,920 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 812 25.53% REP - Jack Cleveland 834 26.23% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 750 23.58% DEM - Martin Dahl 765 24.06% Write-In 19 0.60% Total... 3,180 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 85 3.78% Connie Marie Kelley 438 19.50% Stephen Markman 631 28.09% Bridget Mary McCormack 463 20.61% Kerry L Morgan 60 2.67% Colleen O'Brien 492 21.91% Bob Roddis 73 3.25% Write-In 4 0.18% Total... 2,246 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 78 6.46% Shelia Johnson 378 31.29% Brian Zahra 750 62.09% Write-In 2 0.17% Total... 1,208 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 958 54.96% Peter D O'Connell 776 44.52% Write-In 9 0.52% Total... 1,743 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 938 99.05% Write-In 9 0.95% Total... 947 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 876 48.11%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 121 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 9 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Darnell Jackson 935 51.35% Write-In 10 0.55% Total... 1,821 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 1,090 99.00% Write-In 11 1.00% Total... 1,101 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 1,025 98.65% Write-In 14 1.35% Total... 1,039 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 712 36.27% Donald J McAnelly 508 25.88% Kristina Lord Schnepf 739 37.65% Write-In 4 0.20% Total... 1,963 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 942 99.16% Write-In 8 0.84% Total... 950 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 286 32.99% Michael D Rowley 575 66.32% Write-In 6 0.69% Total... 867 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 877 99.43% Write-In 5 0.57% Total... 882 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 802 53.40% NO 700 46.60% Total... 1,502 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 524 33.94% NO 1,020 66.06% Total... 1,544 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 425 27.83% NO 1,102 72.17% Total... 1,527 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 496 32.57% NO 1,027 67.43% Total... 1,523 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 348 22.92% NO 1,170 77.08% Total... 1,518 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 561 36.55% NO 974 63.45% Total... 1,535 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 977 65.84% NO 507 34.16% Total... 1,484 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 10 Registration & Turnout 2,432 Election Day Turnout 1,153 47.41% AV Polling Turnout 502 20.64% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,655 68.05% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 734 44.46% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 895 54.21% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 5 0.30% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 9 0.55% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 8 0.48% Total... 1,651 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 584 36.16% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 988 61.18% LIBR - Scotty Boman 27 1.67% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 5 0.31% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 9 0.56% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.12%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 122 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 10 US SENATOR (Final) Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,615 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 596 37.82% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 915 58.06% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 27 1.71% NPA - David Davenport 38 2.41% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,576 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 691 44.01% DEM - Judith Lincoln 872 55.54% Write-In 7 0.45% Total... 1,570 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 577 20.58% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 572 20.40% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 813 28.99% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 681 24.29% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 46 1.64% USTAX - Karen Adams 50 1.78% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 16 0.57% GRN - Candace R Caveny 24 0.86% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 19 0.68% Write-In 6 0.21% Total... 2,804 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 561 20.22% REP - Robert Steele 546 19.68% DEM - Mark Bernstein 794 28.61% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 711 25.62% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 29 1.05% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 26 0.94% USTAX - Joe Sanger 24 0.86% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 24 0.86% GRN - Eric Borregard 25 0.90% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 27 0.97% Write-In 8 0.29% Total... 2,775 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 604 22.04% REP - Jeff Sakwa 532 19.41% DEM - Joel Ferguson 789 28.79% DEM - Brian Mosallam 682 24.88% LIBR - Michael H Miller 45 1.64% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 23 0.84% USTAX - Stephen J Young 24 0.88% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 32 1.17% Write-In 10 0.36% Total... 2,741 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 567 21.19% REP - Satish B Jasti 462 17.26% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 824 30.79% DEM - Kim Trent 712 26.61% USTAX - Robert Gale 27 1.01% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 24 0.90% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 34 1.27% GRN - Latham Redding 16 0.60% Write-In 10 0.37% Total... 2,676 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 550 35.71% DEM - John McColgan Jr 986 64.03% Write-In 4 0.26% Total... 1,540 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,251 98.50% Write-In 19 1.50% Total... 1,270 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 520 33.74% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 1,016 65.93% Write-In 5 0.32% Total... 1,541 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 587 38.59% DEM - Tim Novak 926 60.88% Write-In 8 0.53% Total... 1,521 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 123 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 10 REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,212 99.02% Write-In 12 0.98% Total... 1,224 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,185 97.85% Write-In 26 2.15% Total... 1,211 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 2 (Final) REP - Alex Boese 650 44.01% DEM - Chuck Stack 820 55.52% Write-In 7 0.47% Total... 1,477 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 1,254 98.97% Write-In 13 1.03% Total... 1,267 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 1,006 94.73% Write-In 56 5.27% Total... 1,062 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 925 93.34% Write-In 66 6.66% Total... 991 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 630 12.82% REP - Jon R Howell 633 12.88% REP - James S Kelly 687 13.98% REP - Matthew Starke 549 11.17% DEM - Mark T Gorney 833 16.96% DEM - Richard Honig 806 16.41% DEM - Vince Mosca 751 15.29% Write-In 24 0.49% Total... 4,913 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 666 22.13% REP - Jack Cleveland 685 22.76% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 636 21.13% DEM - Martin Dahl 980 32.56% Write-In 43 1.43% Total... 3,010 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 108 4.68% Connie Marie Kelley 538 23.30% Stephen Markman 553 23.95% Bridget Mary McCormack 550 23.82% Kerry L Morgan 60 2.60% Colleen O'Brien 439 19.01% Bob Roddis 46 1.99% Write-In 15 0.65% Total... 2,309 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 123 9.76% Shelia Johnson 526 41.75% Brian Zahra 599 47.54% Write-In 12 0.95% Total... 1,260 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 977 54.83% Peter D O'Connell 788 44.22% Write-In 17 0.95% Total... 1,782 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 995 97.74% Write-In 23 2.26% Total... 1,018 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 867 47.53% Darnell Jackson 943 51.70% Write-In 14 0.77% Total... 1,824 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 1,098 98.65% Write-In 15 1.35% Total... 1,113 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 1,099 98.65% Write-In 15 1.35% Total... 1,114 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 783 39.21%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 124 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 10 SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Donald J McAnelly 542 27.14% Kristina Lord Schnepf 657 32.90% Write-In 15 0.75% Total... 1,997 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 1,038 98.95% Write-In 11 1.05% Total... 1,049 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 424 42.87% Michael D Rowley 551 55.71% Write-In 14 1.42% Total... 989 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 953 98.45% Write-In 15 1.55% Total... 968 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 685 44.14% NO 867 55.86% Total... 1,552 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 728 46.22% NO 847 53.78% Total... 1,575 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 575 36.65% NO 994 63.35% Total... 1,569 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 737 46.94% NO 833 53.06% Total... 1,570 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 440 28.31% NO 1,114 71.69% Total... 1,554 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 732 46.68% NO 836 53.32% Total... 1,568 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 978 64.64% NO 535 35.36% Total... 1,513 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 11 Registration & Turnout 2,349 Election Day Turnout 1,077 45.85% AV Polling Turnout 329 14.01% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,406 59.86% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 498 35.75% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 880 63.17% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 5 0.36% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 2 0.14% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 4 0.29% Write-In 4 0.29% Total... 1,393 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 366 26.87% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 949 69.68% LIBR - Scotty Boman 32 2.35% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 7 0.51% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 2 0.15% NATLAW - John D Litle 6 0.44% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,362 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 379 28.24% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 908 67.66% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 30 2.24% NPA - David Davenport 22 1.64% Write-In 3 0.22% Total... 1,342 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 506 37.90% DEM - Judith Lincoln 822 61.57%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 125 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 11 STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) Write-In 7 0.52% Total... 1,335 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 366 15.14% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 355 14.68% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 816 33.75% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 716 29.61% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 53 2.19% USTAX - Karen Adams 54 2.23% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 17 0.70% GRN - Candace R Caveny 26 1.08% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 12 0.50% Write-In 3 0.12% Total... 2,418 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 350 14.53% REP - Robert Steele 354 14.70% DEM - Mark Bernstein 806 33.47% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 743 30.86% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 29 1.20% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 38 1.58% USTAX - Joe Sanger 27 1.12% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 17 0.71% GRN - Eric Borregard 18 0.75% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 20 0.83% Write-In 6 0.25% Total... 2,408 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 387 16.25% REP - Jeff Sakwa 327 13.73% DEM - Joel Ferguson 811 34.06% DEM - Brian Mosallam 710 29.82% LIBR - Michael H Miller 58 2.44% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 30 1.26% USTAX - Stephen J Young 31 1.30% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 18 0.76% Write-In 9 0.38% Total... 2,381 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 369 15.74% REP - Satish B Jasti 291 12.41% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 828 35.31% DEM - Kim Trent 735 31.34% USTAX - Robert Gale 40 1.71% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 34 1.45% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 31 1.32% GRN - Latham Redding 11 0.47% Write-In 6 0.26% Total... 2,345 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 392 29.72% DEM - John McColgan Jr 921 69.83% Write-In 6 0.45% Total... 1,319 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,130 98.69% Write-In 15 1.31% Total... 1,145 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 379 28.82% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 931 70.80% Write-In 5 0.38% Total... 1,315 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 381 29.04% DEM - Tim Novak 921 70.20% Write-In 10 0.76% Total... 1,312 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,101 99.19% Write-In 9 0.81% Total... 1,110 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,090 99.18% Write-In 9 0.82% Total... 1,099 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 2 (Final) REP - Alex Boese 433 33.70% DEM - Chuck Stack 844 65.68% Write-In 8 0.62% Total... 1,285 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 126 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 11 SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 1,121 99.03% Write-In 11 0.97% Total... 1,132 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 766 91.74% Write-In 69 8.26% Total... 835 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 701 86.54% Write-In 109 13.46% Total... 810 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 435 10.61% REP - Jon R Howell 419 10.22% REP - James S Kelly 481 11.73% REP - Matthew Starke 381 9.29% DEM - Mark T Gorney 813 19.83% DEM - Richard Honig 808 19.71% DEM - Vince Mosca 743 18.13% Write-In 19 0.46% Total... 4,099 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 467 20.09% REP - Jack Cleveland 463 19.91% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 435 18.71% DEM - Martin Dahl 923 39.70% Write-In 37 1.59% Total... 2,325 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 48 2.57% Connie Marie Kelley 536 28.66% Stephen Markman 393 21.02% Bridget Mary McCormack 477 25.51% Kerry L Morgan 71 3.80% Colleen O'Brien 304 16.26% Bob Roddis 33 1.76% Write-In 8 0.43% Total... 1,870 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 82 7.64% Shelia Johnson 535 49.81% Brian Zahra 449 41.81% Write-In 8 0.74% Total... 1,074 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 793 53.91% Peter D O'Connell 656 44.60% Write-In 22 1.50% Total... 1,471 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 856 97.49% Write-In 22 2.51% Total... 878 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 686 46.57% Darnell Jackson 773 52.48% Write-In 14 0.95% Total... 1,473 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 921 98.19% Write-In 17 1.81% Total... 938 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 936 98.42% Write-In 15 1.58% Total... 951 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 667 41.25% Donald J McAnelly 400 24.74% Kristina Lord Schnepf 532 32.90% Write-In 18 1.11% Total... 1,617 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 889 98.45% Write-In 14 1.55% Total... 903 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 335 37.85% Michael D Rowley 534 60.34% Write-In 16 1.81% Total... 885 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 127 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 11 DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 840 98.13% Write-In 16 1.87% Total... 856 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 481 37.03% NO 818 62.97% Total... 1,299 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 652 49.43% NO 667 50.57% Total... 1,319 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 576 43.54% NO 747 56.46% Total... 1,323 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 760 57.58% NO 560 42.42% Total... 1,320 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 357 27.57% NO 938 72.43% Total... 1,295 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 700 52.91% NO 623 47.09% Total... 1,323 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 826 65.71% NO 431 34.29% Total... 1,257 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 12 Registration & Turnout 1,690 Election Day Turnout 906 53.61% AV Polling Turnout 411 24.32% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,317 77.93% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 668 51.03% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 630 48.13% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 3 0.23% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 6 0.46% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.08% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,309 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 540 42.25% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 701 54.85% LIBR - Scotty Boman 21 1.64% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 6 0.47% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.31% NATLAW - John D Litle 6 0.47% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,278 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 547 43.97% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 657 52.81% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 18 1.45% NPA - David Davenport 20 1.61% Write-In 2 0.16% Total... 1,244 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 625 49.88% DEM - Judith Lincoln 622 49.64% Write-In 6 0.48% Total... 1,253 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 526 23.56% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 522 23.38% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 573 25.66% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 485 21.72% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 33 1.48% USTAX - Karen Adams 37 1.66% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 20 0.90% GRN - Candace R Caveny 24 1.07% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 8 0.36% Write-In 5 0.22% Total... 2,233 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 128 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 12 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 518 23.45% REP - Robert Steele 509 23.04% DEM - Mark Bernstein 568 25.71% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 493 22.32% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 15 0.68% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 22 1.00% USTAX - Joe Sanger 21 0.95% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 14 0.63% GRN - Eric Borregard 18 0.81% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 28 1.27% Write-In 3 0.14% Total... 2,209 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 555 25.51% REP - Jeff Sakwa 493 22.66% DEM - Joel Ferguson 538 24.72% DEM - Brian Mosallam 487 22.38% LIBR - Michael H Miller 31 1.42% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 20 0.92% USTAX - Stephen J Young 26 1.19% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 24 1.10% Write-In 2 0.09% Total... 2,176 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 520 24.56% REP - Satish B Jasti 444 20.97% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 571 26.97% DEM - Kim Trent 493 23.29% USTAX - Robert Gale 20 0.94% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 26 1.23% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 28 1.32% GRN - Latham Redding 13 0.61% Write-In 2 0.09% Total... 2,117 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 489 40.11% DEM - John McColgan Jr 725 59.47% Write-In 5 0.41% Total... 1,219 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 935 98.42% Write-In 15 1.58% Total... 950 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 458 37.54% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 757 62.05% Write-In 5 0.41% Total... 1,220 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 518 42.46% DEM - Tim Novak 695 56.97% Write-In 7 0.57% Total... 1,220 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 902 98.69% Write-In 12 1.31% Total... 914 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 886 98.55% Write-In 13 1.45% Total... 899 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 1 (Final) REP - Patrick Wurtzel 573 47.55% DEM - Ruth M Averill 625 51.87% Write-In 7 0.58% Total... 1,205 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 939 98.22% Write-In 17 1.78% Total... 956 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 859 96.09% Write-In 35 3.91% Total... 894 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 771 93.80% Write-In 51 6.20% Total... 822 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 574 14.57% REP - Jon R Howell 577 14.64%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 129 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 12 SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - James S Kelly 613 15.56% REP - Matthew Starke 515 13.07% DEM - Mark T Gorney 581 14.75% DEM - Richard Honig 547 13.88% DEM - Vince Mosca 518 13.15% Write-In 15 0.38% Total... 3,940 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 602 23.61% REP - Jack Cleveland 605 23.73% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 580 22.75% DEM - Martin Dahl 707 27.73% Write-In 56 2.20% Total... 2,550 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 40 2.18% Connie Marie Kelley 324 17.69% Stephen Markman 512 27.95% Bridget Mary McCormack 426 23.25% Kerry L Morgan 73 3.98% Colleen O'Brien 408 22.27% Bob Roddis 47 2.57% Write-In 2 0.11% Total... 1,832 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 85 8.42% Shelia Johnson 360 35.64% Brian Zahra 561 55.54% Write-In 4 0.40% Total... 1,010 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 769 53.11% Peter D O'Connell 666 45.99% Write-In 13 0.90% Total... 1,448 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 794 98.15% Write-In 15 1.85% Total... 809 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 695 47.47% Darnell Jackson 760 51.91% Write-In 9 0.61% Total... 1,464 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 872 98.64% Write-In 12 1.36% Total... 884 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 859 98.40% Write-In 14 1.60% Total... 873 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 634 39.28% Donald J McAnelly 440 27.26% Kristina Lord Schnepf 527 32.65% Write-In 13 0.81% Total... 1,614 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 801 98.28% Write-In 14 1.72% Total... 815 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 314 40.52% Michael D Rowley 449 57.94% Write-In 12 1.55% Total... 775 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 750 98.68% Write-In 10 1.32% Total... 760 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 630 50.04% NO 629 49.96% Total... 1,259 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 516 40.47% NO 759 59.53% Total... 1,275 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 411 32.11%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 130 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 12 State Proposal 12-3 (Final) NO 869 67.89% Total... 1,280 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 512 40.41% NO 755 59.59% Total... 1,267 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 354 27.92% NO 914 72.08% Total... 1,268 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 522 40.81% NO 757 59.19% Total... 1,279 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 782 63.42% NO 451 36.58% Total... 1,233 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 13 Registration & Turnout 2,556 Election Day Turnout 1,351 52.86% AV Polling Turnout 430 16.82% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,781 69.68% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 844 47.63% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 905 51.07% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 5 0.28% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 7 0.40% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 3 0.17% Write-In 8 0.45% Total... 1,772 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 700 40.32% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 982 56.57% LIBR - Scotty Boman 39 2.25% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 0 0.00% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 8 0.46% NATLAW - John D Litle 6 0.35% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,736 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST (Final) REP - Dave Camp 971 56.65% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 698 40.72% LIBR - John Gelineau 22 1.28% USTAX - George M Zimmer 7 0.41% GRN - Pat Timmons 13 0.76% Write-In 3 0.18% Total... 1,714 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 804 47.91% DEM - Judith Lincoln 871 51.91% Write-In 3 0.18% Total... 1,678 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 675 22.78% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 641 21.63% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 790 26.66% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 677 22.85% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 48 1.62% USTAX - Karen Adams 48 1.62% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 22 0.74% GRN - Candace R Caveny 40 1.35% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 20 0.67% Write-In 2 0.07% Total... 2,963 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 669 22.68% REP - Robert Steele 624 21.15% DEM - Mark Bernstein 795 26.95% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 703 23.83% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 35 1.19% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 37 1.25% USTAX - Joe Sanger 17 0.58% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 16 0.54% GRN - Eric Borregard 27 0.92% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 24 0.81% Write-In 3 0.10% Total... 2,950 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 131 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 13 MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 699 24.06% REP - Jeff Sakwa 629 21.65% DEM - Joel Ferguson 779 26.82% DEM - Brian Mosallam 665 22.89% LIBR - Michael H Miller 48 1.65% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 25 0.86% USTAX - Stephen J Young 24 0.83% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 32 1.10% Write-In 4 0.14% Total... 2,905 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 641 22.93% REP - Satish B Jasti 558 19.96% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 778 27.83% DEM - Kim Trent 696 24.89% USTAX - Robert Gale 39 1.39% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 27 0.97% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 32 1.14% GRN - Latham Redding 22 0.79% Write-In 3 0.11% Total... 2,796 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 632 37.89% DEM - John McColgan Jr 1,033 61.93% Write-In 3 0.18% Total... 1,668 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,306 98.42% Write-In 21 1.58% Total... 1,327 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 605 36.78% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 1,040 63.22% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,645 0.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 711 43.51% DEM - Tim Novak 918 56.18% Write-In 5 0.31% Total... 1,634 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,247 99.20% Write-In 10 0.80% Total... 1,257 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,219 99.19% Write-In 10 0.81% Total... 1,229 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 3 (Final) REP - Kirk Kilpatrick 798 50.44% DEM - Phillip Barnett 782 49.43% Write-In 2 0.13% Total... 1,582 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 1,293 99.31% Write-In 9 0.69% Total... 1,302 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 1,126 95.67% Write-In 51 4.33% Total... 1,177 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 1,050 94.51% Write-In 61 5.49% Total... 1,111 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 750 14.40% REP - Jon R Howell 740 14.20% REP - James S Kelly 780 14.97% REP - Matthew Starke 663 12.73% DEM - Mark T Gorney 790 15.16% DEM - Richard Honig 745 14.30% DEM - Vince Mosca 737 14.15% Write-In 5 0.10% Total... 5,210 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 760 23.45% REP - Jack Cleveland 778 24.00% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 726 22.40% DEM - Martin Dahl 954 29.44%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 132 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 13 SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) Write-In 23 0.71% Total... 3,241 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 63 2.68% Connie Marie Kelley 434 18.44% Stephen Markman 476 20.22% Bridget Mary McCormack 658 27.95% Kerry L Morgan 106 4.50% Colleen O'Brien 556 23.62% Bob Roddis 52 2.21% Write-In 9 0.38% Total... 2,354 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 129 10.02% Shelia Johnson 537 41.69% Brian Zahra 615 47.75% Write-In 7 0.54% Total... 1,288 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 974 53.99% Peter D O'Connell 823 45.62% Write-In 7 0.39% Total... 1,804 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 1,018 98.45% Write-In 16 1.55% Total... 1,034 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 884 47.68% Darnell Jackson 958 51.67% Write-In 12 0.65% Total... 1,854 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 1,128 98.43% Write-In 18 1.57% Total... 1,146 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 1,129 98.52% Write-In 17 1.48% Total... 1,146 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 837 41.25% Donald J McAnelly 526 25.92% Kristina Lord Schnepf 656 32.33% Write-In 10 0.49% Total... 2,029 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 1,058 99.16% Write-In 9 0.84% Total... 1,067 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 334 32.94% Michael D Rowley 668 65.88% Write-In 12 1.18% Total... 1,014 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 991 98.71% Write-In 13 1.29% Total... 1,004 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 756 45.00% NO 924 55.00% Total... 1,680 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 732 42.83% NO 977 57.17% Total... 1,709 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 599 35.05% NO 1,110 64.95% Total... 1,709 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 748 43.90% NO 956 56.10% Total... 1,704 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 482 28.45% NO 1,212 71.55% Total... 1,694 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 133 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 13 State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 753 44.09% NO 955 55.91% Total... 1,708 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 1,115 68.15% NO 521 31.85% Total... 1,636 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 14 Registration & Turnout 2,250 Election Day Turnout 1,214 53.96% AV Polling Turnout 382 16.98% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,596 70.93% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 865 54.61% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 703 44.38% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 6 0.38% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 3 0.19% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.06% Write-In 6 0.38% Total... 1,584 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 745 48.03% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 771 49.71% LIBR - Scotty Boman 23 1.48% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 7 0.45% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 1 0.06% NATLAW - John D Litle 1 0.06% Write-In 3 0.19% Total... 1,551 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST (Final) REP - Dave Camp 948 62.16% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 546 35.80% LIBR - John Gelineau 13 0.85% USTAX - George M Zimmer 8 0.52% GRN - Pat Timmons 8 0.52% Write-In 2 0.13% Total... 1,525 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 811 53.64% DEM - Judith Lincoln 696 46.03% Write-In 5 0.33% Total... 1,512 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 692 25.72% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 696 25.87% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 625 23.23% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 521 19.37% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 43 1.60% USTAX - Karen Adams 45 1.67% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 19 0.71% GRN - Candace R Caveny 23 0.86% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 20 0.74% Write-In 6 0.22% Total... 2,690 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 678 25.52% REP - Robert Steele 646 24.31% DEM - Mark Bernstein 635 23.90% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 552 20.78% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 25 0.94% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 27 1.02% USTAX - Joe Sanger 22 0.83% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 22 0.83% GRN - Eric Borregard 22 0.83% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 22 0.83% Write-In 6 0.23% Total... 2,657 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 701 26.86% REP - Jeff Sakwa 645 24.71% DEM - Joel Ferguson 596 22.84% DEM - Brian Mosallam 529 20.27% LIBR - Michael H Miller 52 1.99% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 25 0.96% USTAX - Stephen J Young 28 1.07% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 26 1.00% Write-In 8 0.31% Total... 2,610 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 134 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 14 MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 666 26.15% REP - Satish B Jasti 592 23.24% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 635 24.93% DEM - Kim Trent 547 21.48% USTAX - Robert Gale 33 1.30% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 23 0.90% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 27 1.06% GRN - Latham Redding 18 0.71% Write-In 6 0.24% Total... 2,547 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 630 42.14% DEM - John McColgan Jr 861 57.59% Write-In 4 0.27% Total... 1,495 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,112 97.89% Write-In 24 2.11% Total... 1,136 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 605 41.35% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 851 58.17% Write-In 7 0.48% Total... 1,463 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 699 47.45% DEM - Tim Novak 766 52.00% Write-In 8 0.54% Total... 1,473 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,072 98.35% Write-In 18 1.65% Total... 1,090 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,047 98.49% Write-In 16 1.51% Total... 1,063 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 3 (Final) REP - Kirk Kilpatrick 807 56.71% DEM - Phillip Barnett 609 42.80% Write-In 7 0.49% Total... 1,423 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 1,127 98.51% Write-In 17 1.49% Total... 1,144 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 1,052 96.60% Write-In 37 3.40% Total... 1,089 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 983 94.88% Write-In 53 5.12% Total... 1,036 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 753 15.77% REP - Jon R Howell 753 15.77% REP - James S Kelly 767 16.06% REP - Matthew Starke 693 14.51% DEM - Mark T Gorney 650 13.61% DEM - Richard Honig 572 11.98% DEM - Vince Mosca 574 12.02% Write-In 14 0.29% Total... 4,776 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 754 24.58% REP - Jack Cleveland 755 24.62% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 707 23.05% DEM - Martin Dahl 807 26.31% Write-In 44 1.43% Total... 3,067 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 72 3.30% Connie Marie Kelley 350 16.06% Stephen Markman 537 24.63% Bridget Mary McCormack 430 19.72% Kerry L Morgan 142 6.51% Colleen O'Brien 578 26.51% Bob Roddis 64 2.94% Write-In 7 0.32% Total... 2,180 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 135 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 14 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 80 6.67% Shelia Johnson 426 35.53% Brian Zahra 683 56.96% Write-In 10 0.83% Total... 1,199 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 898 52.18% Peter D O'Connell 802 46.60% Write-In 21 1.22% Total... 1,721 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 957 97.95% Write-In 20 2.05% Total... 977 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 825 47.14% Darnell Jackson 908 51.89% Write-In 17 0.97% Total... 1,750 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 1,062 98.24% Write-In 19 1.76% Total... 1,081 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 1,038 98.67% Write-In 14 1.33% Total... 1,052 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 694 35.63% Donald J McAnelly 545 27.98% Kristina Lord Schnepf 688 35.32% Write-In 21 1.08% Total... 1,948 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 967 98.37% Write-In 16 1.63% Total... 983 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 401 43.73% Michael D Rowley 499 54.42% Write-In 17 1.85% Total... 917 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 901 98.15% Write-In 17 1.85% Total... 918 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 777 51.49% NO 732 48.51% Total... 1,509 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 557 36.67% NO 962 63.33% Total... 1,519 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 485 31.82% NO 1,039 68.18% Total... 1,524 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 565 37.34% NO 948 62.66% Total... 1,513 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 420 27.87% NO 1,087 72.13% Total... 1,507 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 579 38.07% NO 942 61.93% Total... 1,521 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 925 63.27% NO 537 36.73% Total... 1,462 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 15 Registration & Turnout 866 Election Day Turnout 530 61.20% AV Polling Turnout 159 18.36% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 136 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 15 Registration & Turnout 866 SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 689 79.56% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 434 63.17% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 249 36.24% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 0 0.00% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 1 0.15% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 3 0.44% Total... 687 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 377 56.69% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 283 42.56% LIBR - Scotty Boman 4 0.60% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 0 0.00% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 1 0.15% NATLAW - John D Litle 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 665 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST (Final) REP - Dave Camp 457 69.03% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 199 30.06% LIBR - John Gelineau 3 0.45% USTAX - George M Zimmer 2 0.30% GRN - Pat Timmons 1 0.15% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 662 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 403 62.29% DEM - Judith Lincoln 243 37.56% Write-In 1 0.15% Total... 647 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 348 29.39% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 345 29.14% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 237 20.02% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 204 17.23% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 18 1.52% USTAX - Karen Adams 16 1.35% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 7 0.59% GRN - Candace R Caveny 6 0.51% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 3 0.25% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,184 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 338 29.11% REP - Robert Steele 335 28.85% DEM - Mark Bernstein 238 20.50% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 208 17.92% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 7 0.60% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 5 0.43% USTAX - Joe Sanger 10 0.86% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 10 0.86% GRN - Eric Borregard 4 0.34% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 6 0.52% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,161 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 361 31.50% REP - Jeff Sakwa 332 28.97% DEM - Joel Ferguson 216 18.85% DEM - Brian Mosallam 195 17.02% LIBR - Michael H Miller 13 1.13% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 12 1.05% USTAX - Stephen J Young 10 0.87% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 6 0.52% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,146 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 344 30.74% REP - Satish B Jasti 310 27.70% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 222 19.84% DEM - Kim Trent 202 18.05% USTAX - Robert Gale 17 1.52% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 15 1.34% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 5 0.45% GRN - Latham Redding 4 0.36% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,119 0.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 319 49.69%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 137 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 15 PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) DEM - John McColgan Jr 323 50.31% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 642 0.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 440 99.32% Write-In 3 0.68% Total... 443 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 311 49.52% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 317 50.48% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 628 0.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 347 54.99% DEM - Tim Novak 283 44.85% Write-In 1 0.16% Total... 631 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 428 99.07% Write-In 4 0.93% Total... 432 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 408 98.79% Write-In 5 1.21% Total... 413 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 1 (Final) REP - Patrick Wurtzel 382 62.21% DEM - Ruth M Averill 232 37.79% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 614 0.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 448 98.68% Write-In 6 1.32% Total... 454 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 456 98.28% Write-In 8 1.72% Total... 464 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 439 98.21% Write-In 8 1.79% Total... 447 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 370 17.64% REP - Jon R Howell 358 17.07% REP - James S Kelly 382 18.22% REP - Matthew Starke 341 16.26% DEM - Mark T Gorney 231 11.02% DEM - Richard Honig 211 10.06% DEM - Vince Mosca 202 9.63% Write-In 2 0.10% Total... 2,097 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 347 25.74% REP - Jack Cleveland 357 26.48% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 329 24.41% DEM - Martin Dahl 299 22.18% Write-In 16 1.19% Total... 1,348 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 41 4.40% Connie Marie Kelley 157 16.85% Stephen Markman 252 27.04% Bridget Mary McCormack 162 17.38% Kerry L Morgan 21 2.25% Colleen O'Brien 252 27.04% Bob Roddis 46 4.94% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 932 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 43 8.45% Shelia Johnson 138 27.11% Brian Zahra 327 64.24% Write-In 1 0.20% Total... 509 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 380 53.15% Peter D O'Connell 333 46.57% Write-In 2 0.28% Total... 715 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 138 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 15 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 383 98.71% Write-In 5 1.29% Total... 388 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 355 48.04% Darnell Jackson 381 51.56% Write-In 3 0.41% Total... 739 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 443 99.55% Write-In 2 0.45% Total... 445 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 430 98.85% Write-In 5 1.15% Total... 435 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 316 38.16% Donald J McAnelly 214 25.85% Kristina Lord Schnepf 293 35.39% Write-In 5 0.60% Total... 828 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 406 99.02% Write-In 4 0.98% Total... 410 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 124 32.98% Michael D Rowley 249 66.22% Write-In 3 0.80% Total... 376 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 388 98.98% Write-In 4 1.02% Total... 392 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 373 57.30% NO 278 42.70% Total... 651 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 210 31.67% NO 453 68.33% Total... 663 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 187 28.51% NO 469 71.49% Total... 656 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 198 30.37% NO 454 69.63% Total... 652 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 190 29.19% NO 461 70.81% Total... 651 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 231 35.27% NO 424 64.73% Total... 655 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 400 62.31% NO 242 37.69% Total... 642 100.00% Saginaw Township Precinct 16 Registration & Turnout 2,482 Election Day Turnout 1,311 52.82% AV Polling Turnout 572 23.05% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,883 75.87% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 1,067 57.03% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 782 41.80% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 6 0.32% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 8 0.43% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.11% Write-In 6 0.32% Total... 1,871 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 861 46.97%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 139 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 16 US SENATOR (Final) DEM - Debbie Stabenow 936 51.06% LIBR - Scotty Boman 24 1.31% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 5 0.27% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 6 0.33% NATLAW - John D Litle 0 0.00% Write-In 1 0.05% Total... 1,833 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST (Final) REP - Dave Camp 1,216 67.29% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 558 30.88% LIBR - John Gelineau 16 0.89% USTAX - George M Zimmer 7 0.39% GRN - Pat Timmons 10 0.55% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,807 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 1,026 57.51% DEM - Judith Lincoln 753 42.21% Write-In 5 0.28% Total... 1,784 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 841 26.74% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 831 26.42% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 714 22.70% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 574 18.25% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 63 2.00% USTAX - Karen Adams 53 1.69% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 16 0.51% GRN - Candace R Caveny 28 0.89% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 22 0.70% Write-In 3 0.10% Total... 3,145 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 834 26.60% REP - Robert Steele 789 25.17% DEM - Mark Bernstein 738 23.54% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 617 19.68% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 28 0.89% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 32 1.02% USTAX - Joe Sanger 20 0.64% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 28 0.89% GRN - Eric Borregard 18 0.57% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 30 0.96% Write-In 1 0.03% Total... 3,135 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 872 28.05% REP - Jeff Sakwa 788 25.35% DEM - Joel Ferguson 710 22.84% DEM - Brian Mosallam 584 18.78% LIBR - Michael H Miller 54 1.74% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 37 1.19% USTAX - Stephen J Young 37 1.19% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 26 0.84% Write-In 1 0.03% Total... 3,109 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 819 27.10% REP - Satish B Jasti 725 23.99% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 710 23.49% DEM - Kim Trent 614 20.32% USTAX - Robert Gale 44 1.46% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 43 1.42% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 45 1.49% GRN - Latham Redding 20 0.66% Write-In 2 0.07% Total... 3,022 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 778 44.08% DEM - John McColgan Jr 984 55.75% Write-In 3 0.17% Total... 1,765 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,314 98.50% Write-In 20 1.50% Total... 1,334 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 752 43.22% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 985 56.61% Write-In 3 0.17% Total... 1,740 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 140 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 16 TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 864 49.91% DEM - Tim Novak 857 49.51% Write-In 10 0.58% Total... 1,731 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,226 98.79% Write-In 15 1.21% Total... 1,241 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,191 98.76% Write-In 15 1.24% Total... 1,206 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 3 (Final) REP - Kirk Kilpatrick 966 57.98% DEM - Phillip Barnett 697 41.84% Write-In 3 0.18% Total... 1,666 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) DEM - Timothy J Braun 1,296 99.23% Write-In 10 0.77% Total... 1,306 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Shirley M Wazny 1,297 98.86% Write-In 15 1.14% Total... 1,312 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Steven G Gerhardt 1,182 94.79% Write-In 65 5.21% Total... 1,247 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Florence P Connolly 918 16.24% REP - Jon R Howell 912 16.14% REP - James S Kelly 967 17.11% REP - Matthew Starke 795 14.07% DEM - Mark T Gorney 733 12.97% DEM - Richard Honig 663 11.73% DEM - Vince Mosca 656 11.61% Write-In 7 0.12% Total... 5,651 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNSHIP PARKS COMMISSION (Final) REP - David J Biver 935 25.18% REP - Jack Cleveland 956 25.74% REP - Lawrence V Patterson 890 23.96% DEM - Martin Dahl 901 24.26% Write-In 32 0.86% Total... 3,714 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 97 3.85% Connie Marie Kelley 496 19.68% Stephen Markman 647 25.67% Bridget Mary McCormack 516 20.48% Kerry L Morgan 73 2.90% Colleen O'Brien 593 23.53% Bob Roddis 93 3.69% Write-In 5 0.20% Total... 2,520 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 144 10.41% Shelia Johnson 462 33.41% Brian Zahra 773 55.89% Write-In 4 0.29% Total... 1,383 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 1,104 53.75% Peter D O'Connell 941 45.81% Write-In 9 0.44% Total... 2,054 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 1,131 99.04% Write-In 11 0.96% Total... 1,142 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 1,022 49.40% Darnell Jackson 1,038 50.17% Write-In 9 0.43% Total... 2,069 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 1,274 99.45% Write-In 7 0.55% Total... 1,281 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 141 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Saginaw Township Precinct 16 JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 1,234 98.88% Write-In 14 1.12% Total... 1,248 100.00% SAGINAW TOWNHIP SCHOOLS (Final) Lisa B Hall 866 37.55% Donald J McAnelly 657 28.49% Kristina Lord Schnepf 774 33.56% Write-In 9 0.39% Total... 2,306 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 1,116 99.11% Write-In 10 0.89% Total... 1,126 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 444 40.73% Michael D Rowley 637 58.44% Write-In 9 0.83% Total... 1,090 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 1,071 99.26% Write-In 8 0.74% Total... 1,079 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 935 53.22% NO 822 46.78% Total... 1,757 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 587 32.83% NO 1,201 67.17% Total... 1,788 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 527 29.26% NO 1,274 70.74% Total... 1,801 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 650 36.35% NO 1,138 63.65% Total... 1,788 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 512 28.86% NO 1,262 71.14% Total... 1,774 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 793 44.10% NO 1,005 55.90% Total... 1,798 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 1,107 64.74% NO 603 35.26% Total... 1,710 100.00% Spaulding Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,833 Election Day Turnout 1,119 61.05% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,119 61.05% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 455 41.18% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 631 57.10% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 3 0.27% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 11 1.00% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 5 0.45% Total... 1,105 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 326 29.96% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 722 66.36% LIBR - Scotty Boman 22 2.02% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 4 0.37% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 8 0.74% NATLAW - John D Litle 3 0.28% Write-In 3 0.28% Total... 1,088 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST REP - Jim Slezak 336 31.70% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 678 63.96% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 20 1.89% NPA - David Davenport 25 2.36%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 142 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Spaulding Township Precinct 1 US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,060 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST REP - Jeff Baker 350 33.27% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 699 66.44% Write-In 3 0.29% Total... 1,052 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 317 17.01% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 302 16.20% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 590 31.65% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 516 27.68% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 29 1.56% USTAX - Karen Adams 41 2.20% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 22 1.18% GRN - Candace R Caveny 22 1.18% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 22 1.18% Write-In 3 0.16% Total... 1,864 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 292 15.90% REP - Robert Steele 296 16.12% DEM - Mark Bernstein 577 31.43% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 545 29.68% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 16 0.87% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 16 0.87% USTAX - Joe Sanger 23 1.25% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 21 1.14% GRN - Eric Borregard 27 1.47% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 23 1.25% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,836 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 336 18.44% REP - Jeff Sakwa 273 14.98% DEM - Joel Ferguson 588 32.27% DEM - Brian Mosallam 502 27.55% LIBR - Michael H Miller 38 2.09% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 27 1.48% USTAX - Stephen J Young 33 1.81% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 24 1.32% Write-In 1 0.05% Total... 1,822 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 297 16.73% REP - Satish B Jasti 250 14.08% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 594 33.46% DEM - Kim Trent 537 30.25% USTAX - Robert Gale 26 1.46% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 23 1.30% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 28 1.58% GRN - Latham Redding 20 1.13% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,775 0.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 355 34.04% DEM - John McColgan Jr 687 65.87% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,043 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 840 98.36% Write-In 14 1.64% Total... 854 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 310 29.95% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 724 69.95% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,035 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 358 35.00% DEM - Tim Novak 664 64.91% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,023 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 828 98.92% Write-In 9 1.08% Total... 837 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 802 98.53% Write-In 12 1.47% Total... 814 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 143 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Spaulding Township Precinct 1 COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 4 REP - Sandra Klopf Lichon 380 36.82% DEM - Susan McInerney 650 62.98% Write-In 2 0.19% Total... 1,032 100.00% SPAULDING TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR DEM - Gerald A Fox 717 75.39% Write-In 234 24.61% Total... 951 100.00% SPAULDING TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Richard E Leach 636 93.26% Write-In 46 6.74% Total... 682 100.00% SPAULDING TOWNSHIP TREASURER DEM - Tiffany Fortier 813 98.67% Write-In 11 1.33% Total... 824 100.00% SPAULDING TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES DEM - Sheldon Matthews 630 36.29% DEM - Mark L Seamon 694 39.98% NPA - Cheryl M Schluckebier 408 23.50% Write-In 4 0.23% Total... 1,736 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 68 4.48% Connie Marie Kelley 389 25.64% Stephen Markman 316 20.83% Bridget Mary McCormack 400 26.37% Kerry L Morgan 45 2.97% Colleen O'Brien 266 17.53% Bob Roddis 27 1.78% Write-In 6 0.40% Total... 1,517 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 73 8.59% Shelia Johnson 424 49.88% Brian Zahra 352 41.41% Write-In 1 0.12% Total... 850 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 638 55.09% Peter D O'Connell 511 44.13% Write-In 9 0.78% Total... 1,158 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 657 98.21% Write-In 12 1.79% Total... 669 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 528 45.71% Darnell Jackson 615 53.25% Write-In 12 1.04% Total... 1,155 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 699 98.04% Write-In 14 1.96% Total... 713 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 712 97.67% Write-In 17 2.33% Total... 729 100.00% BRIDGEPORT-SPAULDING COMM 4 YR SCHOOLS Martha A Sageman 614 50.74% Andrea J LaBean 512 42.31% Write-In 84 6.94% Total... 1,210 100.00% BRIDGEPORT-SPAULDING COMM 2 YR SCHOOL PARTIAL Write-In 154 100.00% Total... 154 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 650 98.34% Write-In 11 1.66% Total... 661 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 289 42.81% Michael D Rowley 378 56.00% Write-In 8 1.19% Total... 675 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 617 98.25%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 144 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Spaulding Township Precinct 1 DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Write-In 11 1.75% Total... 628 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 394 37.45% NO 658 62.55% Total... 1,052 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 526 49.53% NO 536 50.47% Total... 1,062 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 407 38.84% NO 641 61.16% Total... 1,048 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 548 51.84% NO 509 48.16% Total... 1,057 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 319 30.58% NO 724 69.42% Total... 1,043 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 589 55.83% NO 466 44.17% Total... 1,055 100.00% Delta College YES 574 57.29% NO 428 42.71% Total... 1,002 100.00% St Charles Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,112 Election Day Turnout 733 65.92% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 733 65.92% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 380 52.49% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 331 45.72% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 5 0.69% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 4 0.55% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 4 0.55% Total... 724 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 276 38.87% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 408 57.46% LIBR - Scotty Boman 15 2.11% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 4 0.56% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 3 0.42% NATLAW - John D Litle 4 0.56% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 710 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 451 64.61% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 229 32.81% LIBR - John Gelineau 9 1.29% USTAX - George M Zimmer 4 0.57% GRN - Pat Timmons 5 0.72% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 698 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 388 58.08% DEM - Judith Lincoln 275 41.17% Write-In 5 0.75% Total... 668 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 277 24.91% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 261 23.47% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 265 23.83% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 214 19.24% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 22 1.98% USTAX - Karen Adams 35 3.15% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 15 1.35% GRN - Candace R Caveny 15 1.35% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 8 0.72% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,112 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 145 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

St Charles Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 276 25.11% REP - Robert Steele 257 23.38% DEM - Mark Bernstein 256 23.29% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 228 20.75% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 11 1.00% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 13 1.18% USTAX - Joe Sanger 16 1.46% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 23 2.09% GRN - Eric Borregard 7 0.64% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 12 1.09% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,099 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 282 26.31% REP - Jeff Sakwa 244 22.76% DEM - Joel Ferguson 257 23.97% DEM - Brian Mosallam 213 19.87% LIBR - Michael H Miller 22 2.05% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 20 1.87% USTAX - Stephen J Young 25 2.33% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 9 0.84% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,072 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 258 24.93% REP - Satish B Jasti 218 21.06% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 261 25.22% DEM - Kim Trent 232 22.42% USTAX - Robert Gale 26 2.51% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 20 1.93% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 13 1.26% GRN - Latham Redding 7 0.68% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,035 0.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 307 47.09% DEM - John McColgan Jr 343 52.61% Write-In 2 0.31% Total... 652 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 504 98.05% Write-In 10 1.95% Total... 514 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 287 43.82% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 367 56.03% Write-In 1 0.15% Total... 655 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 291 45.12% DEM - Tim Novak 354 54.88% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 645 0.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 501 99.01% Write-In 5 0.99% Total... 506 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 472 98.95% Write-In 5 1.05% Total... 477 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 6 REP - Ron Sholtz 321 47.63% DEM - Katie Greenfelder 353 52.37% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 674 0.00% ST CHARLES TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Lawrence J Mahoney 493 98.80% Write-In 6 1.20% Total... 499 100.00% ST CHARLES TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Joseph A Krawczyk 506 99.41% Write-In 3 0.59% Total... 509 100.00% ST CHARLES TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Anna Marie Loubert 287 43.62% DEM - Kathleen M Klein 370 56.23% Write-In 1 0.15% Total... 658 100.00% ST CHARLES TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Ann Buck 298 24.29%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 146 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

St Charles Township Precinct 1 ST CHARLES TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Stephanie Cervini 220 17.93% DEM - Bonnie K Hemgesberg 303 24.69% DEM - Vivian Vogelaar 337 27.47% NPA - Donald L Ackerman 69 5.62% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,227 0.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 25 2.44% Connie Marie Kelley 271 26.49% Stephen Markman 261 25.51% Bridget Mary McCormack 214 20.92% Kerry L Morgan 42 4.11% Colleen O'Brien 176 17.20% Bob Roddis 34 3.32% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,023 0.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 67 12.38% Shelia Johnson 164 30.31% Brian Zahra 310 57.30% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 541 0.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 381 51.49% Peter D O'Connell 351 47.43% Write-In 8 1.08% Total... 740 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 425 98.84% Write-In 5 1.16% Total... 430 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 363 50.28% Darnell Jackson 354 49.03% Write-In 5 0.69% Total... 722 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 444 98.89% Write-In 5 1.11% Total... 449 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 445 98.89% Write-In 5 1.11% Total... 450 100.00% CHESANING UNION SCHOOLS 4 YR Brian W Lewis 186 47.81% Julia Schultz Sadilek 203 52.19% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 389 0.00% ST CHARLES COMM SCHOOL 6 YR BD MEMBER6 Laurasue Hensel Holcomb 259 84.36% Write-In 48 15.64% Total... 307 100.00% ST CHARLES COMM SCHOOLS 2YR Ronald Gonzales 285 96.61% Write-In 10 3.39% Total... 295 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 418 98.58% Write-In 6 1.42% Total... 424 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 142 35.06% Michael D Rowley 258 63.70% Write-In 5 1.23% Total... 405 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 383 98.46% Write-In 6 1.54% Total... 389 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 297 42.25% NO 406 57.75% Total... 703 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 284 40.11% NO 424 59.89% Total... 708 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 207 29.03%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 147 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

St Charles Township Precinct 1 State Proposal 12-3 NO 506 70.97% Total... 713 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 284 40.00% NO 426 60.00% Total... 710 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 212 30.11% NO 492 69.89% Total... 704 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 343 48.38% NO 366 51.62% Total... 709 100.00% St Charles Township YES 336 49.19% NO 347 50.81% Total... 683 100.00% Delta College YES 331 49.63% NO 336 50.37% Total... 667 100.00% St Charles Township Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 1,368 Election Day Turnout 818 59.80% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 818 59.80% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 360 44.23% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 443 54.42% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 4 0.49% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 3 0.37% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.12% Write-In 3 0.37% Total... 814 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 256 32.82% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 495 63.46% LIBR - Scotty Boman 13 1.67% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 4 0.51% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 8 1.03% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.26% Write-In 2 0.26% Total... 780 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 471 60.38% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 284 36.41% LIBR - John Gelineau 11 1.41% USTAX - George M Zimmer 9 1.15% GRN - Pat Timmons 4 0.51% Write-In 1 0.13% Total... 780 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 355 46.77% DEM - Judith Lincoln 401 52.83% Write-In 3 0.40% Total... 759 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 249 19.12% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 254 19.51% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 369 28.34% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 293 22.50% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 31 2.38% USTAX - Karen Adams 55 4.22% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 18 1.38% GRN - Candace R Caveny 21 1.61% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 10 0.77% Write-In 2 0.15% Total... 1,302 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 244 18.78% REP - Robert Steele 227 17.47% DEM - Mark Bernstein 381 29.33% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 312 24.02% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 23 1.77% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 25 1.92% USTAX - Joe Sanger 24 1.85% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 17 1.31% GRN - Eric Borregard 20 1.54%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 148 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

St Charles Township Precinct 2 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 24 1.85% Write-In 2 0.15% Total... 1,299 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 275 21.74% REP - Jeff Sakwa 218 17.23% DEM - Joel Ferguson 361 28.54% DEM - Brian Mosallam 284 22.45% LIBR - Michael H Miller 38 3.00% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 24 1.90% USTAX - Stephen J Young 35 2.77% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 28 2.21% Write-In 2 0.16% Total... 1,265 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 241 19.69% REP - Satish B Jasti 199 16.26% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 380 31.05% DEM - Kim Trent 305 24.92% USTAX - Robert Gale 31 2.53% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 24 1.96% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 23 1.88% GRN - Latham Redding 19 1.55% Write-In 2 0.16% Total... 1,224 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 288 38.25% DEM - John McColgan Jr 462 61.35% Write-In 3 0.40% Total... 753 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 613 97.92% Write-In 13 2.08% Total... 626 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 273 36.50% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 469 62.70% Write-In 6 0.80% Total... 748 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 274 37.03% DEM - Tim Novak 462 62.43% Write-In 4 0.54% Total... 740 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 612 98.23% Write-In 11 1.77% Total... 623 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 595 98.67% Write-In 8 1.33% Total... 603 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 6 REP - Ron Sholtz 330 43.42% DEM - Katie Greenfelder 427 56.18% Write-In 3 0.39% Total... 760 100.00% ST CHARLES TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Lawrence J Mahoney 552 98.75% Write-In 7 1.25% Total... 559 100.00% ST CHARLES TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Joseph A Krawczyk 634 98.60% Write-In 9 1.40% Total... 643 100.00% ST CHARLES TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Anna Marie Loubert 290 38.82% DEM - Kathleen M Klein 452 60.51% Write-In 5 0.67% Total... 747 100.00% ST CHARLES TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Ann Buck 242 17.85% REP - Stephanie Cervini 204 15.04% DEM - Bonnie K Hemgesberg 407 30.01% DEM - Vivian Vogelaar 373 27.51% NPA - Donald L Ackerman 127 9.37% Write-In 3 0.22% Total... 1,356 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 43 4.03% Connie Marie Kelley 178 16.68%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 149 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

St Charles Township Precinct 2 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Stephen Markman 256 23.99% Bridget Mary McCormack 272 25.49% Kerry L Morgan 58 5.44% Colleen O'Brien 220 20.62% Bob Roddis 35 3.28% Write-In 5 0.47% Total... 1,067 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 80 13.56% Shelia Johnson 260 44.07% Brian Zahra 244 41.36% Write-In 6 1.02% Total... 590 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 459 53.87% Peter D O'Connell 386 45.31% Write-In 7 0.82% Total... 852 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 511 98.27% Write-In 9 1.73% Total... 520 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 418 47.99% Darnell Jackson 446 51.21% Write-In 7 0.80% Total... 871 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 537 98.53% Write-In 8 1.47% Total... 545 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 544 98.55% Write-In 8 1.45% Total... 552 100.00% VILLAGE OF ST. CHARLES PRESIDENT Doug Holem 626 98.43% Write-In 10 1.57% Total... 636 100.00% VILLAGE OF ST. CHARLES 4 YR TRUSTEES Gary Breidinger 477 35.73% Marie Roe 431 32.28% Lois Theile 406 30.41% Write-In 21 1.57% Total... 1,335 100.00% ST CHARLES COMM SCHOOL 6 YR BD MEMBER6 Laurasue Hensel Holcomb 534 85.17% Write-In 93 14.83% Total... 627 100.00% ST CHARLES COMM SCHOOLS 2YR Ronald Gonzales 588 98.66% Write-In 8 1.34% Total... 596 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 484 98.37% Write-In 8 1.63% Total... 492 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 176 35.70% Michael D Rowley 307 62.27% Write-In 10 2.03% Total... 493 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 473 97.93% Write-In 10 2.07% Total... 483 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 279 36.28% NO 490 63.72% Total... 769 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 327 41.87% NO 454 58.13% Total... 781 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 245 31.53% NO 532 68.47% Total... 777 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 318 41.30%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 150 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

St Charles Township Precinct 2 State Proposal 12-4 NO 452 58.70% Total... 770 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 270 35.16% NO 498 64.84% Total... 768 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 413 52.88% NO 368 47.12% Total... 781 100.00% St Charles Township YES 394 52.67% NO 354 47.33% Total... 748 100.00% Delta College YES 340 48.99% NO 354 51.01% Total... 694 100.00% Swan Creek Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,870 Election Day Turnout 1,374 73.48% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 1 0.05% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,375 73.53% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 820 59.85% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 535 39.05% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 4 0.29% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 5 0.36% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 4 0.29% Write-In 2 0.15% Total... 1,370 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 636 47.36% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 668 49.74% LIBR - Scotty Boman 18 1.34% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 6 0.45% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 8 0.60% NATLAW - John D Litle 6 0.45% Write-In 1 0.07% Total... 1,343 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 864 65.26% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 436 32.93% LIBR - John Gelineau 10 0.76% USTAX - George M Zimmer 8 0.60% GRN - Pat Timmons 5 0.38% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,324 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 735 56.89% DEM - Judith Lincoln 551 42.65% Write-In 6 0.46% Total... 1,292 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 630 27.61% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 625 27.39% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 494 21.65% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 387 16.96% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 26 1.14% USTAX - Karen Adams 53 2.32% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 20 0.88% GRN - Candace R Caveny 21 0.92% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 18 0.79% Write-In 8 0.35% Total... 2,282 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 608 26.88% REP - Robert Steele 599 26.48% DEM - Mark Bernstein 485 21.44% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 428 18.92% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 20 0.88% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 16 0.71% USTAX - Joe Sanger 25 1.11% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 33 1.46% GRN - Eric Borregard 25 1.11% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 17 0.75% Write-In 6 0.27% Total... 2,262 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 151 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Swan Creek Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 653 29.35% REP - Jeff Sakwa 577 25.93% DEM - Joel Ferguson 478 21.48% DEM - Brian Mosallam 389 17.48% LIBR - Michael H Miller 30 1.35% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 35 1.57% USTAX - Stephen J Young 32 1.44% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 25 1.12% Write-In 6 0.27% Total... 2,225 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 614 28.17% REP - Satish B Jasti 525 24.08% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 499 22.89% DEM - Kim Trent 407 18.67% USTAX - Robert Gale 42 1.93% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 32 1.47% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 29 1.33% GRN - Latham Redding 26 1.19% Write-In 6 0.28% Total... 2,180 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 634 49.34% DEM - John McColgan Jr 649 50.51% Write-In 2 0.16% Total... 1,285 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 937 98.42% Write-In 15 1.58% Total... 952 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 617 47.90% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 668 51.86% Write-In 3 0.23% Total... 1,288 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 653 51.58% DEM - Tim Novak 608 48.03% Write-In 5 0.39% Total... 1,266 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 896 98.68% Write-In 12 1.32% Total... 908 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 870 97.97% Write-In 18 2.03% Total... 888 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 6 REP - Ron Sholtz 701 55.28% DEM - Katie Greenfelder 557 43.93% Write-In 10 0.79% Total... 1,268 100.00% SWAN CREEK TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR DEM - Roland G Niederstadt 950 98.65% Write-In 13 1.35% Total... 963 100.00% SWAN CREEK TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Ronald G Blaine 952 98.96% Write-In 10 1.04% Total... 962 100.00% SWAN CREEK TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Thomas A Krzeszewski 929 98.72% Write-In 12 1.28% Total... 941 100.00% SWAN CREEK TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES DEM - Deward Beeler 773 49.30% DEM - Phillip J Schilling 778 49.62% Write-In 17 1.08% Total... 1,568 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 91 4.70% Connie Marie Kelley 301 15.53% Stephen Markman 428 22.08% Bridget Mary McCormack 484 24.97% Kerry L Morgan 114 5.88% Colleen O'Brien 450 23.22% Bob Roddis 66 3.41% Write-In 4 0.21% Total... 1,938 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 152 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Swan Creek Township Precinct 1 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 70 6.80% Shelia Johnson 391 38.00% Brian Zahra 563 54.71% Write-In 5 0.49% Total... 1,029 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 818 53.99% Peter D O'Connell 684 45.15% Write-In 13 0.86% Total... 1,515 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 809 98.78% Write-In 10 1.22% Total... 819 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 755 49.48% Darnell Jackson 759 49.74% Write-In 12 0.79% Total... 1,526 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 875 99.09% Write-In 8 0.91% Total... 883 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 887 98.67% Write-In 12 1.33% Total... 899 100.00% VILLAGE OF ST. CHARLES PRESIDENT Doug Holem 75 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 75 100.00% VILLAGE OF ST. CHARLES 4 YR TRUSTEES Gary Breidinger 67 36.61% Marie Roe 56 30.60% Lois Theile 56 30.60% Write-In 4 2.19% Total... 183 100.00% HEMLOCK PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD MEMBER Mary Ann Ling 28 31.11% Larry Long 18 20.00% Dennis D McMahan 20 22.22% Matthew Wesener 24 26.67% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 90 100.00% ST CHARLES COMM SCHOOL 6 YR BD MEMBER6 Laurasue Hensel Holcomb 748 90.89% Write-In 75 9.11% Total... 823 100.00% ST CHARLES COMM SCHOOLS 2YR Ronald Gonzales 815 99.39% Write-In 5 0.61% Total... 820 100.00% SWAN VALLEY SCHOOLS 6 YR Amy Dwyer 118 99.16% Write-In 1 0.84% Total... 119 100.00% SWAN VALLEY SCHOOLS 4 YR Christy L Boehler 116 56.86% Charleen K Boland 86 42.16% Write-In 2 0.98% Total... 204 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 809 98.90% Write-In 9 1.10% Total... 818 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 306 37.97% Michael D Rowley 493 61.17% Write-In 7 0.87% Total... 806 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 763 98.71% Write-In 10 1.29% Total... 773 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 602 45.43% NO 723 54.57% Total... 1,325 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 500 37.17%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 153 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Swan Creek Township Precinct 1 State Proposal 12-2 NO 845 62.83% Total... 1,345 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 339 25.32% NO 1,000 74.68% Total... 1,339 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 464 34.81% NO 869 65.19% Total... 1,333 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 407 30.56% NO 925 69.44% Total... 1,332 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 628 46.94% NO 710 53.06% Total... 1,338 100.00% Delta College YES 677 52.73% NO 607 47.27% Total... 1,284 100.00% Taymouth Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,439 Election Day Turnout 945 65.67% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 945 65.67% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 413 44.08% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 510 54.43% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.11% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 8 0.85% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.21% Write-In 3 0.32% Total... 937 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 303 33.08% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 582 63.54% LIBR - Scotty Boman 20 2.18% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 5 0.55% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 2 0.22% NATLAW - John D Litle 3 0.33% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 916 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 467 52.35% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 392 43.95% LIBR - John Gelineau 14 1.57% USTAX - George M Zimmer 18 2.02% GRN - Pat Timmons 1 0.11% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 892 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 385 44.51% DEM - Judith Lincoln 477 55.14% Write-In 3 0.35% Total... 865 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 303 20.16% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 264 17.56% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 435 28.94% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 380 25.28% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 38 2.53% USTAX - Karen Adams 34 2.26% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 17 1.13% GRN - Candace R Caveny 15 1.00% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 14 0.93% Write-In 3 0.20% Total... 1,503 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 264 17.69% REP - Robert Steele 259 17.36% DEM - Mark Bernstein 452 30.29% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 402 26.94% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 25 1.68% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 21 1.41% USTAX - Joe Sanger 20 1.34% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 17 1.14% GRN - Eric Borregard 11 0.74%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 154 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Taymouth Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 19 1.27% Write-In 2 0.13% Total... 1,492 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 291 19.85% REP - Jeff Sakwa 249 16.98% DEM - Joel Ferguson 453 30.90% DEM - Brian Mosallam 386 26.33% LIBR - Michael H Miller 26 1.77% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 28 1.91% USTAX - Stephen J Young 18 1.23% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 13 0.89% Write-In 2 0.14% Total... 1,466 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 284 20.03% REP - Satish B Jasti 225 15.87% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 448 31.59% DEM - Kim Trent 400 28.21% USTAX - Robert Gale 21 1.48% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 18 1.27% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 11 0.78% GRN - Latham Redding 9 0.63% Write-In 2 0.14% Total... 1,418 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 329 38.62% DEM - John McColgan Jr 521 61.15% Write-In 2 0.23% Total... 852 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 665 97.65% Write-In 16 2.35% Total... 681 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 312 37.19% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 525 62.57% Write-In 2 0.24% Total... 839 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 288 35.12% DEM - Tim Novak 529 64.51% Write-In 3 0.37% Total... 820 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 665 98.37% Write-In 11 1.63% Total... 676 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 636 98.15% Write-In 12 1.85% Total... 648 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 7 REP - Dana Young 290 33.84% DEM - Cheryl Marie Hadsall 566 66.04% Write-In 1 0.12% Total... 857 100.00% TAYMOUTH TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR DEM - Douglas E James 679 98.12% Write-In 13 1.88% Total... 692 100.00% TAYMOUTH TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Gail A Basner 686 98.28% Write-In 12 1.72% Total... 698 100.00% TAYMOUTH TOWNSHIP TREASURER DEM - Janell Dodak 640 98.01% Write-In 13 1.99% Total... 653 100.00% TAYMOUTH TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Steve Sawyer 330 23.37% DEM - Larry A Smith 529 37.46% DEM - Josh Woodward 548 38.81% Write-In 5 0.35% Total... 1,412 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 54 4.56% Connie Marie Kelley 248 20.93% Stephen Markman 212 17.89% Bridget Mary McCormack 265 22.36% Kerry L Morgan 62 5.23%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 155 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Taymouth Township Precinct 1 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Colleen O'Brien 304 25.65% Bob Roddis 34 2.87% Write-In 6 0.51% Total... 1,185 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 70 10.77% Shelia Johnson 259 39.85% Brian Zahra 317 48.77% Write-In 4 0.62% Total... 650 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 453 52.49% Peter D O'Connell 403 46.70% Write-In 7 0.81% Total... 863 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 492 98.01% Write-In 10 1.99% Total... 502 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 431 49.09% Darnell Jackson 436 49.66% Write-In 11 1.25% Total... 878 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 514 98.47% Write-In 8 1.53% Total... 522 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 525 98.50% Write-In 8 1.50% Total... 533 100.00% BIRCH RUN AREA SCHOOLS Todd Ferguson 462 37.90% Steve Griggs 183 15.01% Nan Haley 428 35.11% Travis Maginity 138 11.32% Write-In 8 0.66% Total... 1,219 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 489 98.39% Write-In 8 1.61% Total... 497 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 185 36.85% Michael D Rowley 311 61.95% Write-In 6 1.20% Total... 502 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 462 97.88% Write-In 10 2.12% Total... 472 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 336 37.84% NO 552 62.16% Total... 888 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 468 51.37% NO 443 48.63% Total... 911 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 341 37.89% NO 559 62.11% Total... 900 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 447 49.78% NO 451 50.22% Total... 898 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 282 31.86% NO 603 68.14% Total... 885 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 482 53.26% NO 423 46.74% Total... 905 100.00% Delta College YES 405 47.93% NO 440 52.07% Total... 845 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 156 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Taymouth Township Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 1,963 Election Day Turnout 1,294 65.92% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,294 65.92% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 566 44.15% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 689 53.74% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 5 0.39% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 11 0.86% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 4 0.31% Write-In 7 0.55% Total... 1,282 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 434 34.66% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 776 61.98% LIBR - Scotty Boman 19 1.52% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 11 0.88% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.32% NATLAW - John D Litle 7 0.56% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,252 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 654 52.83% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 546 44.10% LIBR - John Gelineau 21 1.70% USTAX - George M Zimmer 8 0.65% GRN - Pat Timmons 7 0.57% Write-In 2 0.16% Total... 1,238 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 553 45.85% DEM - Judith Lincoln 651 53.98% Write-In 2 0.17% Total... 1,206 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 430 20.30% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 392 18.51% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 619 29.23% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 510 24.08% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 43 2.03% USTAX - Karen Adams 56 2.64% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 27 1.27% GRN - Candace R Caveny 24 1.13% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 16 0.76% Write-In 1 0.05% Total... 2,118 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 415 19.28% REP - Robert Steele 395 18.35% DEM - Mark Bernstein 648 30.10% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 557 25.87% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 20 0.93% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 16 0.74% USTAX - Joe Sanger 29 1.35% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 26 1.21% GRN - Eric Borregard 17 0.79% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 25 1.16% Write-In 5 0.23% Total... 2,153 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 447 21.21% REP - Jeff Sakwa 384 18.22% DEM - Joel Ferguson 614 29.14% DEM - Brian Mosallam 520 24.68% LIBR - Michael H Miller 39 1.85% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 30 1.42% USTAX - Stephen J Young 38 1.80% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 30 1.42% Write-In 5 0.24% Total... 2,107 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 416 20.23% REP - Satish B Jasti 340 16.54% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 632 30.74% DEM - Kim Trent 545 26.51% USTAX - Robert Gale 37 1.80% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 27 1.31% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 25 1.22% GRN - Latham Redding 27 1.31%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 157 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Taymouth Township Precinct 2 MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS Write-In 7 0.34% Total... 2,056 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 451 37.77% DEM - John McColgan Jr 742 62.14% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,194 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 930 98.20% Write-In 17 1.80% Total... 947 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 471 39.78% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 712 60.14% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,184 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 428 36.46% DEM - Tim Novak 743 63.29% Write-In 3 0.26% Total... 1,174 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 902 98.15% Write-In 17 1.85% Total... 919 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 869 97.75% Write-In 20 2.25% Total... 889 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 7 REP - Dana Young 427 36.00% DEM - Cheryl Marie Hadsall 755 63.66% Write-In 4 0.34% Total... 1,186 100.00% TAYMOUTH TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR DEM - Douglas E James 921 98.08% Write-In 18 1.92% Total... 939 100.00% TAYMOUTH TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Gail A Basner 943 98.74% Write-In 12 1.26% Total... 955 100.00% TAYMOUTH TOWNSHIP TREASURER DEM - Janell Dodak 880 97.89% Write-In 19 2.11% Total... 899 100.00% TAYMOUTH TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Steve Sawyer 510 26.70% DEM - Larry A Smith 712 37.28% DEM - Josh Woodward 681 35.65% Write-In 7 0.37% Total... 1,910 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 61 3.46% Connie Marie Kelley 423 24.02% Stephen Markman 337 19.14% Bridget Mary McCormack 410 23.28% Kerry L Morgan 52 2.95% Colleen O'Brien 404 22.94% Bob Roddis 68 3.86% Write-In 6 0.34% Total... 1,761 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 114 11.86% Shelia Johnson 427 44.43% Brian Zahra 413 42.98% Write-In 7 0.73% Total... 961 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 668 51.66% Peter D O'Connell 613 47.41% Write-In 12 0.93% Total... 1,293 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 740 98.01% Write-In 15 1.99% Total... 755 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 648 49.96% Darnell Jackson 638 49.19%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 158 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Taymouth Township Precinct 2 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Write-In 11 0.85% Total... 1,297 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 772 98.47% Write-In 12 1.53% Total... 784 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 772 98.09% Write-In 15 1.91% Total... 787 100.00% BIRCH RUN AREA SCHOOLS Todd Ferguson 655 37.84% Steve Griggs 257 14.85% Nan Haley 635 36.68% Travis Maginity 178 10.28% Write-In 6 0.35% Total... 1,731 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 727 97.72% Write-In 17 2.28% Total... 744 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 220 29.18% Michael D Rowley 523 69.36% Write-In 11 1.46% Total... 754 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 703 97.50% Write-In 18 2.50% Total... 721 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 456 36.89% NO 780 63.11% Total... 1,236 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 611 48.96% NO 637 51.04% Total... 1,248 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 468 37.56% NO 778 62.44% Total... 1,246 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 591 47.82% NO 645 52.18% Total... 1,236 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 434 35.46% NO 790 64.54% Total... 1,224 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 690 55.38% NO 556 44.62% Total... 1,246 100.00% Delta College YES 584 48.50% NO 620 51.50% Total... 1,204 100.00% Thomas Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,303 Election Day Turnout 769 59.02% AV Polling Turnout 261 20.03% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,030 79.05% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 664 65.10% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 347 34.02% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 2 0.20% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 2 0.20% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.10% Write-In 4 0.39% Total... 1,020 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 546 55.15% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 422 42.63% LIBR - Scotty Boman 18 1.82% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 3 0.30% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 0 0.00% NATLAW - John D Litle 0 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 159 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 1 US SENATOR (Final) Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 990 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST (Final) REP - Dave Camp 714 72.56% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 255 25.91% LIBR - John Gelineau 9 0.91% USTAX - George M Zimmer 2 0.20% GRN - Pat Timmons 4 0.41% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 984 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 637 67.05% DEM - Judith Lincoln 312 32.84% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 950 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 515 31.10% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 515 31.10% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 312 18.84% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 227 13.71% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 24 1.45% USTAX - Karen Adams 22 1.33% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 10 0.60% GRN - Candace R Caveny 15 0.91% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 15 0.91% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,656 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 514 31.17% REP - Robert Steele 498 30.20% DEM - Mark Bernstein 303 18.37% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 252 15.28% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 16 0.97% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 9 0.55% USTAX - Joe Sanger 13 0.79% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 12 0.73% GRN - Eric Borregard 17 1.03% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 14 0.85% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,649 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 540 33.64% REP - Jeff Sakwa 476 29.66% DEM - Joel Ferguson 291 18.13% DEM - Brian Mosallam 236 14.70% LIBR - Michael H Miller 25 1.56% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 7 0.44% USTAX - Stephen J Young 14 0.87% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 15 0.93% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,605 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 512 33.14% REP - Satish B Jasti 428 27.70% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 296 19.16% DEM - Kim Trent 258 16.70% USTAX - Robert Gale 14 0.91% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 10 0.65% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 14 0.91% GRN - Latham Redding 12 0.78% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,545 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 542 57.97% DEM - John McColgan Jr 393 42.03% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 935 0.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 628 99.21% Write-In 5 0.79% Total... 633 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 486 52.54% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 437 47.24% Write-In 2 0.22% Total... 925 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 542 60.29% DEM - Tim Novak 355 39.49% Write-In 2 0.22% Total... 899 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 160 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 1 REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 591 99.33% Write-In 4 0.67% Total... 595 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 566 98.61% Write-In 8 1.39% Total... 574 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 1 (Final) REP - Patrick Wurtzel 635 67.77% DEM - Ruth M Averill 300 32.02% Write-In 2 0.21% Total... 937 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) REP - Robert A Weise 708 99.02% Write-In 7 0.98% Total... 715 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Edward Brosofski 697 99.15% Write-In 6 0.85% Total... 703 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Vern Weber 685 99.56% Write-In 3 0.44% Total... 688 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Thomas Radewahn 629 25.98% REP - Ellen Ryder-Petre 594 24.54% REP - Michael Thayer 596 24.62% REP - Chris Thompson 596 24.62% Write-In 6 0.25% Total... 2,421 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP PARKS REC (Final) REP - Angela Meatte Alworden 555 14.97% REP - Scott Branch 541 14.59% REP - Craig J Monahan 535 14.43% REP - Bryan G Mrozinski 538 14.51% REP - Carly Rusch 544 14.67% REP - Dean A Rusch 556 14.99% DEM - Craig Blower 434 11.70% Write-In 5 0.13% Total... 3,708 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 69 5.28% Connie Marie Kelley 231 17.69% Stephen Markman 363 27.79% Bridget Mary McCormack 215 16.46% Kerry L Morgan 50 3.83% Colleen O'Brien 316 24.20% Bob Roddis 60 4.59% Write-In 2 0.15% Total... 1,306 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 52 7.34% Shelia Johnson 229 32.34% Brian Zahra 425 60.03% Write-In 2 0.28% Total... 708 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 543 53.92% Peter D O'Connell 461 45.78% Write-In 3 0.30% Total... 1,007 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 538 99.45% Write-In 3 0.55% Total... 541 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 503 51.17% Darnell Jackson 475 48.32% Write-In 5 0.51% Total... 983 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 596 99.83% Write-In 1 0.17% Total... 597 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 563 99.12% Write-In 5 0.88% Total... 568 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP LIBRARY BOARD (Final) Douglas L Bird 350 14.39%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 161 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 1 THOMAS TOWNSHIP LIBRARY BOARD (Final) Stephen W Dunkle 311 12.78% Margaret Garabelli 373 15.33% Kathleen A Leach 367 15.08% Bette Syrek 333 13.69% Susan Taylor 378 15.54% Lynda Thayer 314 12.91% Write-In 7 0.29% Total... 2,433 100.00% FREELAND COMM 6 YR SCHOOL (Final) Janet M Alexander 116 6.84% Kristin Anderson 186 10.97% Michele Daniels 152 8.96% David Dennis 185 10.91% Melissa Lickly 110 6.49% Shawnette Markey 128 7.55% Toni Riffel 146 8.61% Charles Snider 143 8.43% Holli Wallace 113 6.66% Pete Wiltse 267 15.74% David Youngstrom 146 8.61% Write-In 4 0.24% Total... 1,696 100.00% FREELAND COMMUNITY 4 YR SCHOOLS PARTIAL (Final) Dennis J Argyle 177 28.78% Michelle Vanamburg Rankin 73 11.87% Holly Roenicke 262 42.60% Candace Stowell 100 16.26% Write-In 3 0.49% Total... 615 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 524 99.05% Write-In 5 0.95% Total... 529 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 178 35.32% Michael D Rowley 324 64.29% Write-In 2 0.40% Total... 504 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 513 99.23% Write-In 4 0.77% Total... 517 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 519 52.96% NO 461 47.04% Total... 980 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 305 30.47% NO 696 69.53% Total... 1,001 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 217 21.79% NO 779 78.21% Total... 996 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 274 27.82% NO 711 72.18% Total... 985 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 273 27.77% NO 710 72.23% Total... 983 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 309 31.18% NO 682 68.82% Total... 991 100.00% Thomas Township Public Safety (Final) YES 522 54.37% NO 438 45.63% Total... 960 100.00% Thomas Township Fire (Final) YES 592 62.51% NO 355 37.49% Total... 947 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 556 59.34% NO 381 40.66% Total... 937 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 162 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 1,562 Election Day Turnout 751 48.08% AV Polling Turnout 339 21.70% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,090 69.78% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 546 50.46% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 529 48.89% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.09% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 3 0.28% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 3 0.28% Total... 1,082 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 425 40.02% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 609 57.34% LIBR - Scotty Boman 18 1.69% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 4 0.38% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 6 0.56% NATLAW - John D Litle 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,062 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST (Final) REP - Dave Camp 624 59.49% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 393 37.46% LIBR - John Gelineau 15 1.43% USTAX - George M Zimmer 12 1.14% GRN - Pat Timmons 5 0.48% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,049 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 528 51.41% DEM - Judith Lincoln 497 48.39% Write-In 2 0.19% Total... 1,027 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 403 22.91% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 402 22.85% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 467 26.55% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 387 22.00% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 25 1.42% USTAX - Karen Adams 37 2.10% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 12 0.68% GRN - Candace R Caveny 12 0.68% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 12 0.68% Write-In 2 0.11% Total... 1,759 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 398 23.10% REP - Robert Steele 375 21.76% DEM - Mark Bernstein 458 26.58% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 404 23.45% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 14 0.81% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 13 0.75% USTAX - Joe Sanger 19 1.10% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 9 0.52% GRN - Eric Borregard 10 0.58% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 19 1.10% Write-In 4 0.23% Total... 1,723 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 421 25.00% REP - Jeff Sakwa 355 21.08% DEM - Joel Ferguson 444 26.37% DEM - Brian Mosallam 387 22.98% LIBR - Michael H Miller 27 1.60% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 17 1.01% USTAX - Stephen J Young 17 1.01% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 12 0.71% Write-In 4 0.24% Total... 1,684 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 392 23.84% REP - Satish B Jasti 313 19.04% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 467 28.41% DEM - Kim Trent 406 24.70% USTAX - Robert Gale 21 1.28% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 11 0.67% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 19 1.16% GRN - Latham Redding 10 0.61%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 163 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 2 MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) Write-In 5 0.30% Total... 1,644 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 381 37.76% DEM - John McColgan Jr 626 62.04% Write-In 2 0.20% Total... 1,009 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 779 99.11% Write-In 7 0.89% Total... 786 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 380 38.11% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 615 61.69% Write-In 2 0.20% Total... 997 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 399 41.09% DEM - Tim Novak 571 58.81% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 971 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 746 99.47% Write-In 4 0.53% Total... 750 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 729 99.45% Write-In 4 0.55% Total... 733 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 5 (Final) REP - Jim Theisen 413 40.25% DEM - Dave Adams 611 59.55% Write-In 2 0.19% Total... 1,026 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) REP - Robert A Weise 699 97.90% Write-In 15 2.10% Total... 714 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Edward Brosofski 697 98.45% Write-In 11 1.55% Total... 708 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Vern Weber 679 98.69% Write-In 9 1.31% Total... 688 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Thomas Radewahn 577 25.79% REP - Ellen Ryder-Petre 538 24.05% REP - Michael Thayer 552 24.68% REP - Chris Thompson 554 24.77% Write-In 16 0.72% Total... 2,237 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP PARKS REC (Final) REP - Angela Meatte Alworden 522 14.11% REP - Scott Branch 516 13.95% REP - Craig J Monahan 543 14.68% REP - Bryan G Mrozinski 499 13.49% REP - Carly Rusch 484 13.08% REP - Dean A Rusch 492 13.30% DEM - Craig Blower 636 17.19% Write-In 7 0.19% Total... 3,699 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 78 5.49% Connie Marie Kelley 326 22.96% Stephen Markman 351 24.72% Bridget Mary McCormack 296 20.85% Kerry L Morgan 44 3.10% Colleen O'Brien 283 19.93% Bob Roddis 35 2.46% Write-In 7 0.49% Total... 1,420 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 100 12.79% Shelia Johnson 234 29.92% Brian Zahra 446 57.03% Write-In 2 0.26% Total... 782 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 619 55.17%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 164 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 2 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Peter D O'Connell 499 44.47% Write-In 4 0.36% Total... 1,122 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 607 99.35% Write-In 4 0.65% Total... 611 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 550 50.18% Darnell Jackson 543 49.54% Write-In 3 0.27% Total... 1,096 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 657 99.55% Write-In 3 0.45% Total... 660 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 662 99.40% Write-In 4 0.60% Total... 666 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP LIBRARY BOARD (Final) Douglas L Bird 528 17.83% Stephen W Dunkle 315 10.64% Margaret Garabelli 461 15.57% Kathleen A Leach 408 13.78% Bette Syrek 417 14.08% Susan Taylor 403 13.61% Lynda Thayer 426 14.39% Write-In 3 0.10% Total... 2,961 100.00% SWAN VALLEY SCHOOLS 6 YR (Final) Amy Dwyer 727 99.59% Write-In 3 0.41% Total... 730 100.00% SWAN VALLEY SCHOOLS 4 YR (Final) Christy L Boehler 658 54.52% Charleen K Boland 547 45.32% Write-In 2 0.17% Total... 1,207 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 620 99.52% Write-In 3 0.48% Total... 623 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 249 41.16% Michael D Rowley 350 57.85% Write-In 6 0.99% Total... 605 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 592 99.50% Write-In 3 0.50% Total... 595 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 424 41.09% NO 608 58.91% Total... 1,032 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 447 42.21% NO 612 57.79% Total... 1,059 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 305 29.16% NO 741 70.84% Total... 1,046 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 421 40.33% NO 623 59.67% Total... 1,044 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 305 29.33% NO 735 70.67% Total... 1,040 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 472 45.08% NO 575 54.92% Total... 1,047 100.00% Thomas Township Public Safety (Final) YES 623 60.37% NO 409 39.63% Total... 1,032 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 165 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 2 Thomas Township Fire (Final) YES 708 69.48% NO 311 30.52% Total... 1,019 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 597 58.70% NO 420 41.30% Total... 1,017 100.00% Thomas Township Precinct 3 Registration & Turnout 1,823 Election Day Turnout 795 43.61% AV Polling Turnout 475 26.06% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,270 69.67% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 724 57.28% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 521 41.22% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 5 0.40% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 5 0.40% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.08% Write-In 8 0.63% Total... 1,264 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 581 46.78% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 629 50.64% LIBR - Scotty Boman 20 1.61% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 3 0.24% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 5 0.40% NATLAW - John D Litle 4 0.32% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,242 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST (Final) REP - Dave Camp 797 65.17% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 399 32.62% LIBR - John Gelineau 16 1.31% USTAX - George M Zimmer 7 0.57% GRN - Pat Timmons 4 0.33% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,223 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 682 56.79% DEM - Judith Lincoln 515 42.88% Write-In 4 0.33% Total... 1,201 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 570 26.44% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 545 25.28% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 496 23.01% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 411 19.06% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 39 1.81% USTAX - Karen Adams 48 2.23% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 25 1.16% GRN - Candace R Caveny 11 0.51% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 9 0.42% Write-In 2 0.09% Total... 2,156 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 540 25.45% REP - Robert Steele 519 24.46% DEM - Mark Bernstein 499 23.52% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 461 21.72% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 22 1.04% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 21 0.99% USTAX - Joe Sanger 18 0.85% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 15 0.71% GRN - Eric Borregard 15 0.71% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 12 0.57% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 2,122 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 573 27.04% REP - Jeff Sakwa 514 24.26% DEM - Joel Ferguson 509 24.02% DEM - Brian Mosallam 412 19.44% LIBR - Michael H Miller 43 2.03% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 22 1.04% USTAX - Stephen J Young 21 0.99% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 22 1.04% Write-In 3 0.14% Total... 2,119 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 166 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 3 MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 551 26.83% REP - Satish B Jasti 473 23.03% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 503 24.49% DEM - Kim Trent 439 21.37% USTAX - Robert Gale 37 1.80% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 16 0.78% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 20 0.97% GRN - Latham Redding 15 0.73% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 2,054 0.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 535 45.38% DEM - John McColgan Jr 643 54.54% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,179 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 855 98.28% Write-In 15 1.72% Total... 870 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 517 44.00% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 656 55.83% Write-In 2 0.17% Total... 1,175 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 581 50.30% DEM - Tim Novak 574 49.70% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,155 0.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 815 98.79% Write-In 10 1.21% Total... 825 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 803 98.65% Write-In 11 1.35% Total... 814 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 5 (Final) REP - Jim Theisen 634 54.28% DEM - Dave Adams 534 45.72% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,168 0.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) REP - Robert A Weise 847 98.37% Write-In 14 1.63% Total... 861 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Edward Brosofski 846 98.49% Write-In 13 1.51% Total... 859 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Vern Weber 821 98.32% Write-In 14 1.68% Total... 835 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Thomas Radewahn 735 25.51% REP - Ellen Ryder-Petre 701 24.33% REP - Michael Thayer 705 24.47% REP - Chris Thompson 714 24.78% Write-In 26 0.90% Total... 2,881 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP PARKS REC (Final) REP - Angela Meatte Alworden 639 14.04% REP - Scott Branch 650 14.28% REP - Craig J Monahan 655 14.39% REP - Bryan G Mrozinski 643 14.13% REP - Carly Rusch 640 14.06% REP - Dean A Rusch 667 14.66% DEM - Craig Blower 645 14.17% Write-In 12 0.26% Total... 4,551 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 52 2.99% Connie Marie Kelley 441 25.36% Stephen Markman 454 26.11% Bridget Mary McCormack 376 21.62% Kerry L Morgan 52 2.99% Colleen O'Brien 321 18.46% Bob Roddis 42 2.42% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,739 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 167 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 3 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 107 11.33% Shelia Johnson 337 35.70% Brian Zahra 499 52.86% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 944 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 741 54.85% Peter D O'Connell 604 44.71% Write-In 6 0.44% Total... 1,351 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 750 99.08% Write-In 7 0.92% Total... 757 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 679 50.45% Darnell Jackson 662 49.18% Write-In 5 0.37% Total... 1,346 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 809 99.51% Write-In 4 0.49% Total... 813 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 788 99.37% Write-In 5 0.63% Total... 793 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP LIBRARY BOARD (Final) Douglas L Bird 473 14.68% Stephen W Dunkle 318 9.87% Margaret Garabelli 472 14.65% Kathleen A Leach 526 16.33% Bette Syrek 450 13.97% Susan Taylor 506 15.71% Lynda Thayer 467 14.50% Write-In 9 0.28% Total... 3,221 100.00% HEMLOCK PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD MEMBER (Final) Mary Ann Ling 629 30.30% Larry Long 422 20.33% Dennis D McMahan 524 25.24% Matthew Wesener 494 23.80% Write-In 7 0.34% Total... 2,076 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 718 99.17% Write-In 6 0.83% Total... 724 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 241 33.80% Michael D Rowley 465 65.22% Write-In 7 0.98% Total... 713 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 689 99.28% Write-In 5 0.72% Total... 694 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 515 43.64% NO 665 56.36% Total... 1,180 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 465 38.05% NO 757 61.95% Total... 1,222 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 374 30.63% NO 847 69.37% Total... 1,221 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 510 42.11% NO 701 57.89% Total... 1,211 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 402 33.36% NO 803 66.64% Total... 1,205 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 543 44.69%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 168 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 3 State Proposal 12-6 (Final) NO 672 55.31% Total... 1,215 100.00% Thomas Township Public Safety (Final) YES 687 58.62% NO 485 41.38% Total... 1,172 100.00% Thomas Township Fire (Final) YES 765 65.11% NO 410 34.89% Total... 1,175 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 686 58.38% NO 489 41.62% Total... 1,175 100.00% Thomas Township Precinct 4 Registration & Turnout 1,149 Election Day Turnout 628 54.66% AV Polling Turnout 246 21.41% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 874 76.07% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 580 66.97% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 281 32.45% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.12% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 0 0.00% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 4 0.46% Total... 866 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 472 55.46% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 354 41.60% LIBR - Scotty Boman 17 2.00% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 3 0.35% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 1 0.12% NATLAW - John D Litle 4 0.47% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 851 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST (Final) REP - Dave Camp 613 72.72% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 208 24.67% LIBR - John Gelineau 14 1.66% USTAX - George M Zimmer 5 0.59% GRN - Pat Timmons 3 0.36% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 843 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 533 65.40% DEM - Judith Lincoln 280 34.36% Write-In 2 0.25% Total... 815 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 430 30.30% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 429 30.23% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 261 18.39% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 196 13.81% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 29 2.04% USTAX - Karen Adams 37 2.61% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 14 0.99% GRN - Candace R Caveny 13 0.92% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 10 0.70% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,419 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 426 30.56% REP - Robert Steele 415 29.77% DEM - Mark Bernstein 249 17.86% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 207 14.85% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 17 1.22% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 26 1.87% USTAX - Joe Sanger 15 1.08% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 13 0.93% GRN - Eric Borregard 11 0.79% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 15 1.08% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,394 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 454 32.99% REP - Jeff Sakwa 416 30.23% DEM - Joel Ferguson 228 16.57% DEM - Brian Mosallam 201 14.61%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 169 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 4 MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) LIBR - Michael H Miller 28 2.03% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 16 1.16% USTAX - Stephen J Young 18 1.31% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 15 1.09% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,376 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 425 31.76% REP - Satish B Jasti 385 28.77% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 250 18.68% DEM - Kim Trent 219 16.37% USTAX - Robert Gale 20 1.49% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 16 1.20% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 10 0.75% GRN - Latham Redding 11 0.82% Write-In 2 0.15% Total... 1,338 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 463 57.80% DEM - John McColgan Jr 337 42.07% Write-In 1 0.12% Total... 801 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 552 98.57% Write-In 8 1.43% Total... 560 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 425 53.53% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 369 46.47% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 794 0.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 470 59.95% DEM - Tim Novak 314 40.05% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 784 0.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 515 99.23% Write-In 4 0.77% Total... 519 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 502 98.43% Write-In 8 1.57% Total... 510 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 5 (Final) REP - Jim Theisen 485 61.63% DEM - Dave Adams 302 38.37% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 787 0.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) REP - Robert A Weise 642 99.23% Write-In 5 0.77% Total... 647 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Edward Brosofski 628 99.21% Write-In 5 0.79% Total... 633 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Vern Weber 613 99.19% Write-In 5 0.81% Total... 618 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Thomas Radewahn 548 26.21% REP - Ellen Ryder-Petre 509 24.34% REP - Michael Thayer 513 24.53% REP - Chris Thompson 515 24.63% Write-In 6 0.29% Total... 2,091 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP PARKS REC (Final) REP - Angela Meatte Alworden 489 14.61% REP - Scott Branch 490 14.64% REP - Craig J Monahan 490 14.64% REP - Bryan G Mrozinski 481 14.37% REP - Carly Rusch 488 14.58% REP - Dean A Rusch 518 15.47% DEM - Craig Blower 392 11.71% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 3,348 0.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 55 4.66% Connie Marie Kelley 161 13.63%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 170 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 4 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Stephen Markman 373 31.58% Bridget Mary McCormack 239 20.24% Kerry L Morgan 41 3.47% Colleen O'Brien 265 22.44% Bob Roddis 47 3.98% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,181 0.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 48 7.75% Shelia Johnson 174 28.11% Brian Zahra 396 63.97% Write-In 1 0.16% Total... 619 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 495 54.52% Peter D O'Connell 411 45.26% Write-In 2 0.22% Total... 908 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 480 99.59% Write-In 2 0.41% Total... 482 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 472 52.74% Darnell Jackson 423 47.26% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 895 0.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 545 99.63% Write-In 2 0.37% Total... 547 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 517 99.42% Write-In 3 0.58% Total... 520 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP LIBRARY BOARD (Final) Douglas L Bird 327 15.45% Stephen W Dunkle 236 11.15% Margaret Garabelli 297 14.03% Kathleen A Leach 320 15.12% Bette Syrek 300 14.17% Susan Taylor 326 15.40% Lynda Thayer 311 14.69% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 2,117 0.00% HEMLOCK PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD MEMBER (Final) Mary Ann Ling 417 30.39% Larry Long 279 20.34% Dennis D McMahan 356 25.95% Matthew Wesener 319 23.25% Write-In 1 0.07% Total... 1,372 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 468 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 468 0.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 183 40.22% Michael D Rowley 271 59.56% Write-In 1 0.22% Total... 455 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 437 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 437 0.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 428 51.44% NO 404 48.56% Total... 832 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 269 31.54% NO 584 68.46% Total... 853 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 198 23.35% NO 650 76.65% Total... 848 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 241 28.55% NO 603 71.45% Total... 844 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 171 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 4 State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 224 26.79% NO 612 73.21% Total... 836 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 318 37.32% NO 534 62.68% Total... 852 100.00% Thomas Township Public Safety (Final) YES 427 52.01% NO 394 47.99% Total... 821 100.00% Thomas Township Fire (Final) YES 506 61.63% NO 315 38.37% Total... 821 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 434 52.67% NO 390 47.33% Total... 824 100.00% Thomas Township Precinct 5 Registration & Turnout 1,546 Election Day Turnout 755 48.84% AV Polling Turnout 317 20.50% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,072 69.34% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 584 54.94% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 461 43.37% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 3 0.28% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 9 0.85% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.19% Write-In 4 0.38% Total... 1,063 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 464 44.57% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 545 52.35% LIBR - Scotty Boman 16 1.54% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 3 0.29% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 7 0.67% NATLAW - John D Litle 3 0.29% Write-In 3 0.29% Total... 1,041 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST (Final) REP - Dave Camp 673 65.53% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 331 32.23% LIBR - John Gelineau 9 0.88% USTAX - George M Zimmer 6 0.58% GRN - Pat Timmons 6 0.58% Write-In 2 0.19% Total... 1,027 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 564 56.18% DEM - Judith Lincoln 436 43.43% Write-In 4 0.40% Total... 1,004 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 446 25.07% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 446 25.07% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 437 24.56% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 333 18.72% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 31 1.74% USTAX - Karen Adams 37 2.08% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 13 0.73% GRN - Candace R Caveny 15 0.84% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 19 1.07% Write-In 2 0.11% Total... 1,779 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 431 25.10% REP - Robert Steele 412 24.00% DEM - Mark Bernstein 432 25.16% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 344 20.03% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 25 1.46% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 18 1.05% USTAX - Joe Sanger 14 0.82% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 11 0.64% GRN - Eric Borregard 12 0.70% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 15 0.87% Write-In 3 0.17% Total... 1,717 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 172 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 5 MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 461 26.94% REP - Jeff Sakwa 401 23.44% DEM - Joel Ferguson 421 24.61% DEM - Brian Mosallam 340 19.87% LIBR - Michael H Miller 21 1.23% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 22 1.29% USTAX - Stephen J Young 22 1.29% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 20 1.17% Write-In 3 0.18% Total... 1,711 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 424 25.76% REP - Satish B Jasti 352 21.39% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 420 25.52% DEM - Kim Trent 361 21.93% USTAX - Robert Gale 22 1.34% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 21 1.28% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 28 1.70% GRN - Latham Redding 15 0.91% Write-In 3 0.18% Total... 1,646 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 427 43.35% DEM - John McColgan Jr 556 56.45% Write-In 2 0.20% Total... 985 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 744 98.67% Write-In 10 1.33% Total... 754 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 405 40.87% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 584 58.93% Write-In 2 0.20% Total... 991 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 446 45.98% DEM - Tim Novak 520 53.61% Write-In 4 0.41% Total... 970 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 732 98.92% Write-In 8 1.08% Total... 740 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 721 98.63% Write-In 10 1.37% Total... 731 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 5 (Final) REP - Jim Theisen 500 49.60% DEM - Dave Adams 506 50.20% Write-In 2 0.20% Total... 1,008 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) REP - Robert A Weise 736 97.87% Write-In 16 2.13% Total... 752 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Edward Brosofski 736 97.74% Write-In 17 2.26% Total... 753 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Vern Weber 714 98.35% Write-In 12 1.65% Total... 726 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Thomas Radewahn 630 25.61% REP - Ellen Ryder-Petre 600 24.39% REP - Michael Thayer 611 24.84% REP - Chris Thompson 601 24.43% Write-In 18 0.73% Total... 2,460 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP PARKS REC (Final) REP - Angela Meatte Alworden 572 13.95% REP - Scott Branch 569 13.88% REP - Craig J Monahan 623 15.20% REP - Bryan G Mrozinski 562 13.71% REP - Carly Rusch 550 13.41% REP - Dean A Rusch 564 13.76% DEM - Craig Blower 645 15.73%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 173 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 5 THOMAS TOWNSHIP PARKS REC (Final) Write-In 15 0.37% Total... 4,100 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 54 3.59% Connie Marie Kelley 232 15.44% Stephen Markman 328 21.82% Bridget Mary McCormack 417 27.74% Kerry L Morgan 66 4.39% Colleen O'Brien 351 23.35% Bob Roddis 52 3.46% Write-In 3 0.20% Total... 1,503 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 124 15.40% Shelia Johnson 228 28.32% Brian Zahra 450 55.90% Write-In 3 0.37% Total... 805 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 642 53.37% Peter D O'Connell 553 45.97% Write-In 8 0.67% Total... 1,203 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 667 99.11% Write-In 6 0.89% Total... 673 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 593 49.01% Darnell Jackson 610 50.41% Write-In 7 0.58% Total... 1,210 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 718 99.17% Write-In 6 0.83% Total... 724 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 708 99.30% Write-In 5 0.70% Total... 713 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP LIBRARY BOARD (Final) Douglas L Bird 587 17.92% Stephen W Dunkle 357 10.90% Margaret Garabelli 471 14.38% Kathleen A Leach 401 12.24% Bette Syrek 496 15.15% Susan Taylor 456 13.92% Lynda Thayer 491 14.99% Write-In 16 0.49% Total... 3,275 100.00% SWAN VALLEY SCHOOLS 6 YR (Final) Amy Dwyer 742 99.07% Write-In 7 0.93% Total... 749 100.00% SWAN VALLEY SCHOOLS 4 YR (Final) Christy L Boehler 684 53.35% Charleen K Boland 591 46.10% Write-In 7 0.55% Total... 1,282 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 653 99.24% Write-In 5 0.76% Total... 658 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 225 35.27% Michael D Rowley 407 63.79% Write-In 6 0.94% Total... 638 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 633 99.06% Write-In 6 0.94% Total... 639 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 468 46.52% NO 538 53.48% Total... 1,006 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 402 38.84% NO 633 61.16% Total... 1,035 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 174 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 5 State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 296 28.88% NO 729 71.12% Total... 1,025 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 362 35.70% NO 652 64.30% Total... 1,014 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 271 26.73% NO 743 73.27% Total... 1,014 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 402 39.37% NO 619 60.63% Total... 1,021 100.00% Thomas Township Public Safety (Final) YES 594 59.70% NO 401 40.30% Total... 995 100.00% Thomas Township Fire (Final) YES 672 67.27% NO 327 32.73% Total... 999 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 589 59.74% NO 397 40.26% Total... 986 100.00% Thomas Township Precinct 6 Registration & Turnout 1,307 Election Day Turnout 470 35.96% AV Polling Turnout 451 34.51% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 921 70.47% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 571 62.40% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 335 36.61% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 2 0.22% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 4 0.44% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 3 0.33% Total... 915 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 473 52.44% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 421 46.67% LIBR - Scotty Boman 4 0.44% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 2 0.22% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 1 0.11% NATLAW - John D Litle 0 0.00% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 902 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST (Final) REP - Dave Camp 631 70.82% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 252 28.28% LIBR - John Gelineau 1 0.11% USTAX - George M Zimmer 3 0.34% GRN - Pat Timmons 3 0.34% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 891 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 554 63.03% DEM - Judith Lincoln 321 36.52% Write-In 4 0.46% Total... 879 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 486 30.66% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 460 29.02% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 318 20.06% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 248 15.65% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 20 1.26% USTAX - Karen Adams 25 1.58% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 6 0.38% GRN - Candace R Caveny 8 0.50% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 10 0.63% Write-In 4 0.25% Total... 1,585 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 473 30.07% REP - Robert Steele 451 28.67% DEM - Mark Bernstein 325 20.66%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 175 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 6 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 270 17.16% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 9 0.57% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 9 0.57% USTAX - Joe Sanger 9 0.57% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 10 0.64% GRN - Eric Borregard 6 0.38% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 7 0.45% Write-In 4 0.25% Total... 1,573 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 480 30.93% REP - Jeff Sakwa 439 28.29% DEM - Joel Ferguson 311 20.04% DEM - Brian Mosallam 261 16.82% LIBR - Michael H Miller 17 1.10% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 12 0.77% USTAX - Stephen J Young 18 1.16% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 9 0.58% Write-In 5 0.32% Total... 1,552 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 474 31.54% REP - Satish B Jasti 394 26.21% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 318 21.16% DEM - Kim Trent 267 17.76% USTAX - Robert Gale 12 0.80% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 13 0.86% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 11 0.73% GRN - Latham Redding 10 0.67% Write-In 4 0.27% Total... 1,503 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 436 49.43% DEM - John McColgan Jr 445 50.45% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 882 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 585 98.65% Write-In 8 1.35% Total... 593 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 429 48.97% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 444 50.68% Write-In 3 0.34% Total... 876 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 473 55.32% DEM - Tim Novak 378 44.21% Write-In 4 0.47% Total... 855 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 553 98.75% Write-In 7 1.25% Total... 560 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 548 98.74% Write-In 7 1.26% Total... 555 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 5 (Final) REP - Jim Theisen 497 57.66% DEM - Dave Adams 364 42.23% Write-In 1 0.12% Total... 862 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) REP - Robert A Weise 670 98.82% Write-In 8 1.18% Total... 678 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Edward Brosofski 655 98.64% Write-In 9 1.36% Total... 664 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Vern Weber 640 98.46% Write-In 10 1.54% Total... 650 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Thomas Radewahn 587 26.02% REP - Ellen Ryder-Petre 542 24.02% REP - Michael Thayer 555 24.60% REP - Chris Thompson 554 24.56%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 176 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 6 THOMAS TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) Write-In 18 0.80% Total... 2,256 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP PARKS REC (Final) REP - Angela Meatte Alworden 519 14.28% REP - Scott Branch 530 14.58% REP - Craig J Monahan 542 14.91% REP - Bryan G Mrozinski 521 14.34% REP - Carly Rusch 511 14.06% REP - Dean A Rusch 529 14.56% DEM - Craig Blower 462 12.71% Write-In 20 0.55% Total... 3,634 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 41 3.10% Connie Marie Kelley 239 18.08% Stephen Markman 343 25.95% Bridget Mary McCormack 224 16.94% Kerry L Morgan 86 6.51% Colleen O'Brien 348 26.32% Bob Roddis 34 2.57% Write-In 7 0.53% Total... 1,322 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 64 9.18% Shelia Johnson 225 32.28% Brian Zahra 404 57.96% Write-In 4 0.57% Total... 697 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 565 52.95% Peter D O'Connell 493 46.20% Write-In 9 0.84% Total... 1,067 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 565 99.30% Write-In 4 0.70% Total... 569 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 523 48.52% Darnell Jackson 548 50.83% Write-In 7 0.65% Total... 1,078 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 620 99.36% Write-In 4 0.64% Total... 624 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 591 99.33% Write-In 4 0.67% Total... 595 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP LIBRARY BOARD (Final) Douglas L Bird 458 16.48% Stephen W Dunkle 316 11.37% Margaret Garabelli 397 14.29% Kathleen A Leach 400 14.39% Bette Syrek 358 12.88% Susan Taylor 407 14.65% Lynda Thayer 432 15.55% Write-In 11 0.40% Total... 2,779 100.00% SWAN VALLEY SCHOOLS 6 YR (Final) Amy Dwyer 617 99.84% Write-In 1 0.16% Total... 618 100.00% SWAN VALLEY SCHOOLS 4 YR (Final) Christy L Boehler 572 52.82% Charleen K Boland 508 46.91% Write-In 3 0.28% Total... 1,083 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 573 99.65% Write-In 2 0.35% Total... 575 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 218 39.78% Michael D Rowley 327 59.67% Write-In 3 0.55% Total... 548 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 535 99.44%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 177 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 6 DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Write-In 3 0.56% Total... 538 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 443 51.04% NO 425 48.96% Total... 868 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 283 31.91% NO 604 68.09% Total... 887 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 229 25.82% NO 658 74.18% Total... 887 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 318 35.69% NO 573 64.31% Total... 891 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 253 28.75% NO 627 71.25% Total... 880 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 369 41.46% NO 521 58.54% Total... 890 100.00% Thomas Township Public Safety (Final) YES 546 63.41% NO 315 36.59% Total... 861 100.00% Thomas Township Fire (Final) YES 623 72.27% NO 239 27.73% Total... 862 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 549 64.44% NO 303 35.56% Total... 852 100.00% Thomas Township Precinct 7 Registration & Turnout 1,205 Election Day Turnout 658 54.61% AV Polling Turnout 281 23.32% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 939 77.93% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 595 63.84% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 325 34.87% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 3 0.32% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 4 0.43% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 3 0.32% Write-In 2 0.21% Total... 932 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 503 55.27% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 388 42.64% LIBR - Scotty Boman 12 1.32% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 3 0.33% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 3 0.33% NATLAW - John D Litle 1 0.11% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 910 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST (Final) REP - Dave Camp 648 72.40% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 230 25.70% LIBR - John Gelineau 9 1.01% USTAX - George M Zimmer 3 0.34% GRN - Pat Timmons 5 0.56% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 895 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST (Final) REP - Tim Kelly 575 65.49% DEM - Judith Lincoln 302 34.40% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 878 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 463 30.32% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 442 28.95% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 284 18.60% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 219 14.34%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 178 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 7 MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 28 1.83% USTAX - Karen Adams 48 3.14% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 18 1.18% GRN - Candace R Caveny 14 0.92% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 7 0.46% Write-In 4 0.26% Total... 1,527 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 443 29.05% REP - Robert Steele 433 28.39% DEM - Mark Bernstein 296 19.41% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 246 16.13% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 23 1.51% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 18 1.18% USTAX - Joe Sanger 23 1.51% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 18 1.18% GRN - Eric Borregard 9 0.59% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 14 0.92% Write-In 2 0.13% Total... 1,525 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 467 30.95% REP - Jeff Sakwa 421 27.90% DEM - Joel Ferguson 284 18.82% DEM - Brian Mosallam 241 15.97% LIBR - Michael H Miller 28 1.86% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 29 1.92% USTAX - Stephen J Young 23 1.52% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 14 0.93% Write-In 2 0.13% Total... 1,509 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 460 31.70% REP - Satish B Jasti 389 26.81% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 291 20.06% DEM - Kim Trent 230 15.85% USTAX - Robert Gale 27 1.86% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 27 1.86% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 16 1.10% GRN - Latham Redding 11 0.76% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,451 0.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 436 50.23% DEM - John McColgan Jr 432 49.77% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 868 0.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 589 98.33% Write-In 10 1.67% Total... 599 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 425 49.36% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 434 50.41% Write-In 2 0.23% Total... 861 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 475 56.35% DEM - Tim Novak 367 43.53% Write-In 1 0.12% Total... 843 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 543 98.73% Write-In 7 1.27% Total... 550 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 527 98.32% Write-In 9 1.68% Total... 536 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 5 (Final) REP - Jim Theisen 521 59.14% DEM - Dave Adams 360 40.86% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 881 0.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR (Final) REP - Robert A Weise 681 98.98% Write-In 7 1.02% Total... 688 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) REP - Edward Brosofski 690 99.28%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 179 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 7 THOMAS TOWNSHIP CLERK (Final) Write-In 5 0.72% Total... 695 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP TREASURER (Final) REP - Vern Weber 652 99.39% Write-In 4 0.61% Total... 656 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Thomas Radewahn 599 26.08% REP - Ellen Ryder-Petre 565 24.60% REP - Michael Thayer 566 24.64% REP - Chris Thompson 561 24.42% Write-In 6 0.26% Total... 2,297 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP PARKS REC (Final) REP - Angela Meatte Alworden 531 14.75% REP - Scott Branch 521 14.48% REP - Craig J Monahan 553 15.37% REP - Bryan G Mrozinski 500 13.89% REP - Carly Rusch 503 13.98% REP - Dean A Rusch 523 14.53% DEM - Craig Blower 462 12.84% Write-In 6 0.17% Total... 3,599 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 53 4.15% Connie Marie Kelley 203 15.90% Stephen Markman 348 27.25% Bridget Mary McCormack 228 17.85% Kerry L Morgan 48 3.76% Colleen O'Brien 350 27.41% Bob Roddis 44 3.45% Write-In 3 0.23% Total... 1,277 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 51 7.46% Shelia Johnson 213 31.14% Brian Zahra 418 61.11% Write-In 2 0.29% Total... 684 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 528 53.07% Peter D O'Connell 461 46.33% Write-In 6 0.60% Total... 995 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 531 98.88% Write-In 6 1.12% Total... 537 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 502 51.07% Darnell Jackson 474 48.22% Write-In 7 0.71% Total... 983 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 592 99.50% Write-In 3 0.50% Total... 595 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION (Final) Kyle Higgs Tarrant 575 98.80% Write-In 7 1.20% Total... 582 100.00% THOMAS TOWNSHIP LIBRARY BOARD (Final) Douglas L Bird 472 18.44% Stephen W Dunkle 281 10.98% Margaret Garabelli 365 14.26% Kathleen A Leach 380 14.85% Bette Syrek 343 13.40% Susan Taylor 303 11.84% Lynda Thayer 404 15.79% Write-In 11 0.43% Total... 2,559 100.00% SWAN VALLEY SCHOOLS 6 YR (Final) Amy Dwyer 611 99.35% Write-In 4 0.65% Total... 615 100.00% SWAN VALLEY SCHOOLS 4 YR (Final) Christy L Boehler 571 54.48% Charleen K Boland 470 44.85% Write-In 7 0.67% Total... 1,048 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 180 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Thomas Township Precinct 7 DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 531 98.88% Write-In 6 1.12% Total... 537 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 167 32.43% Michael D Rowley 342 66.41% Write-In 6 1.17% Total... 515 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 510 98.84% Write-In 6 1.16% Total... 516 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 488 55.33% NO 394 44.67% Total... 882 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 290 31.73% NO 624 68.27% Total... 914 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 209 22.94% NO 702 77.06% Total... 911 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 265 29.48% NO 634 70.52% Total... 899 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 244 27.29% NO 650 72.71% Total... 894 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 355 39.27% NO 549 60.73% Total... 904 100.00% Thomas Township Public Safety (Final) YES 537 60.34% NO 353 39.66% Total... 890 100.00% Thomas Township Fire (Final) YES 599 67.91% NO 283 32.09% Total... 882 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 485 55.56% NO 388 44.44% Total... 873 100.00% Tittabawassee Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,745 Election Day Turnout 1,267 72.61% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,267 72.61% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 723 57.52% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 518 41.21% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 4 0.32% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 5 0.40% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.08% Write-In 6 0.48% Total... 1,257 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 586 48.03% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 589 48.28% LIBR - Scotty Boman 34 2.79% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 6 0.49% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.33% NATLAW - John D Litle 1 0.08% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,220 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 812 66.94% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 361 29.76% LIBR - John Gelineau 21 1.73% USTAX - George M Zimmer 12 0.99% GRN - Pat Timmons 7 0.58% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,213 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 181 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Tittabawassee Township Precinct 1 STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 692 59.15% DEM - Judith Lincoln 478 40.85% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,170 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 545 26.72% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 541 26.52% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 438 21.47% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 347 17.01% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 57 2.79% USTAX - Karen Adams 55 2.70% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 22 1.08% GRN - Candace R Caveny 22 1.08% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 12 0.59% Write-In 1 0.05% Total... 2,040 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 534 26.29% REP - Robert Steele 517 25.46% DEM - Mark Bernstein 466 22.94% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 387 19.05% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 38 1.87% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 24 1.18% USTAX - Joe Sanger 17 0.84% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 14 0.69% GRN - Eric Borregard 14 0.69% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 16 0.79% Write-In 4 0.20% Total... 2,031 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 565 28.43% REP - Jeff Sakwa 494 24.86% DEM - Joel Ferguson 440 22.14% DEM - Brian Mosallam 361 18.17% LIBR - Michael H Miller 49 2.47% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 29 1.46% USTAX - Stephen J Young 25 1.26% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 23 1.16% Write-In 1 0.05% Total... 1,987 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 556 28.44% REP - Satish B Jasti 472 24.14% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 443 22.66% DEM - Kim Trent 378 19.34% USTAX - Robert Gale 36 1.84% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 27 1.38% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 26 1.33% GRN - Latham Redding 16 0.82% Write-In 1 0.05% Total... 1,955 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 569 49.35% DEM - John McColgan Jr 584 50.65% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,153 0.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 869 98.30% Write-In 15 1.70% Total... 884 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 530 47.03% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 596 52.88% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,127 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 583 51.82% DEM - Tim Novak 541 48.09% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,125 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 815 97.96% Write-In 17 2.04% Total... 832 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 792 97.18% Write-In 23 2.82% Total... 815 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 1 REP - Patrick Wurtzel 601 52.63% DEM - Ruth M Averill 539 47.20%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 182 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Tittabawassee Township Precinct 1 COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 1 Write-In 2 0.18% Total... 1,142 100.00% TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Rick Hayes 883 97.89% Write-In 19 2.11% Total... 902 100.00% TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Robert DuCharme 820 97.85% Write-In 18 2.15% Total... 838 100.00% TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Tracy L Reimus 863 98.40% Write-In 14 1.60% Total... 877 100.00% TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Tom Forsberg 772 25.44% REP - Thomas N Metiva 756 24.91% REP - Carl W Neuenfeldt 733 24.15% REP - Paul S Vasold 756 24.91% Write-In 18 0.59% Total... 3,035 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 100 6.11% Connie Marie Kelley 335 20.46% Stephen Markman 366 22.36% Bridget Mary McCormack 333 20.34% Kerry L Morgan 57 3.48% Colleen O'Brien 340 20.77% Bob Roddis 99 6.05% Write-In 7 0.43% Total... 1,637 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 84 9.35% Shelia Johnson 252 28.06% Brian Zahra 557 62.03% Write-In 5 0.56% Total... 898 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 684 52.41% Peter D O'Connell 612 46.90% Write-In 9 0.69% Total... 1,305 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 727 98.78% Write-In 9 1.22% Total... 736 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 660 50.97% Darnell Jackson 629 48.57% Write-In 6 0.46% Total... 1,295 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 770 99.48% Write-In 4 0.52% Total... 774 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 752 99.21% Write-In 6 0.79% Total... 758 100.00% FREELAND COMM 6 YR SCHOOL Janet M Alexander 151 6.33% Kristin Anderson 293 12.29% Michele Daniels 144 6.04% David Dennis 267 11.19% Melissa Lickly 136 5.70% Shawnette Markey 237 9.94% Toni Riffel 162 6.79% Charles Snider 150 6.29% Holli Wallace 241 10.10% Pete Wiltse 305 12.79% David Youngstrom 285 11.95% Write-In 14 0.59% Total... 2,385 100.00% FREELAND COMMUNITY 4 YR SCHOOLS PARTIAL Dennis J Argyle 281 32.22% Michelle Vanamburg Rankin 112 12.84% Holly Roenicke 326 37.39% Candace Stowell 147 16.86% Write-In 6 0.69% Total... 872 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 183 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Tittabawassee Township Precinct 1 BAY CITY PUBLIC SCHOOLS 4 YR Pauline Helmling 2 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 2 0.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 723 99.31% Write-In 5 0.69% Total... 728 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 343 48.45% Michael D Rowley 359 50.71% Write-In 6 0.85% Total... 708 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 695 99.14% Write-In 6 0.86% Total... 701 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 564 47.72% NO 618 52.28% Total... 1,182 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 417 34.46% NO 793 65.54% Total... 1,210 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 313 25.98% NO 892 74.02% Total... 1,205 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 434 36.23% NO 764 63.77% Total... 1,198 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 361 30.54% NO 821 69.46% Total... 1,182 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 510 42.04% NO 703 57.96% Total... 1,213 100.00% Delta College YES 721 61.73% NO 447 38.27% Total... 1,168 100.00% Tittabawassee Township Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 1,565 Election Day Turnout 1,205 77.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,205 77.00% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 770 64.27% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 419 34.97% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 0 0.00% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 4 0.33% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 5 0.42% Total... 1,198 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 650 56.23% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 468 40.48% LIBR - Scotty Boman 24 2.08% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 4 0.35% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 5 0.43% NATLAW - John D Litle 4 0.35% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,156 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 846 73.31% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 278 24.09% LIBR - John Gelineau 14 1.21% USTAX - George M Zimmer 6 0.52% GRN - Pat Timmons 9 0.78% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,154 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 724 64.87% DEM - Judith Lincoln 389 34.86%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 184 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Tittabawassee Township Precinct 2 STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST Write-In 3 0.27% Total... 1,116 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 572 29.50% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 579 29.86% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 362 18.67% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 293 15.11% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 34 1.75% USTAX - Karen Adams 41 2.11% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 21 1.08% GRN - Candace R Caveny 18 0.93% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 13 0.67% Write-In 6 0.31% Total... 1,939 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 567 29.61% REP - Robert Steele 547 28.56% DEM - Mark Bernstein 366 19.11% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 303 15.82% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 22 1.15% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 21 1.10% USTAX - Joe Sanger 30 1.57% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 17 0.89% GRN - Eric Borregard 16 0.84% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 23 1.20% Write-In 3 0.16% Total... 1,915 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 599 31.33% REP - Jeff Sakwa 543 28.40% DEM - Joel Ferguson 361 18.88% DEM - Brian Mosallam 287 15.01% LIBR - Michael H Miller 32 1.67% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 34 1.78% USTAX - Stephen J Young 31 1.62% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 20 1.05% Write-In 5 0.26% Total... 1,912 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 567 31.00% REP - Satish B Jasti 501 27.39% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 347 18.97% DEM - Kim Trent 307 16.79% USTAX - Robert Gale 41 2.24% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 29 1.59% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 15 0.82% GRN - Latham Redding 16 0.87% Write-In 6 0.33% Total... 1,829 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 615 56.63% DEM - John McColgan Jr 468 43.09% Write-In 3 0.28% Total... 1,086 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 759 97.94% Write-In 16 2.06% Total... 775 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 575 54.25% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 483 45.57% Write-In 2 0.19% Total... 1,060 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 636 60.00% DEM - Tim Novak 423 39.91% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,060 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 703 98.60% Write-In 10 1.40% Total... 713 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 679 97.98% Write-In 14 2.02% Total... 693 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 1 REP - Patrick Wurtzel 635 58.80% DEM - Ruth M Averill 442 40.93% Write-In 3 0.28% Total... 1,080 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 185 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Tittabawassee Township Precinct 2 TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Rick Hayes 844 97.01% Write-In 26 2.99% Total... 870 100.00% TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Robert DuCharme 716 98.35% Write-In 12 1.65% Total... 728 100.00% TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Tracy L Reimus 844 98.71% Write-In 11 1.29% Total... 855 100.00% TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Tom Forsberg 745 24.92% REP - Thomas N Metiva 738 24.69% REP - Carl W Neuenfeldt 720 24.09% REP - Paul S Vasold 761 25.46% Write-In 25 0.84% Total... 2,989 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 94 5.95% Connie Marie Kelley 324 20.52% Stephen Markman 454 28.75% Bridget Mary McCormack 294 18.62% Kerry L Morgan 43 2.72% Colleen O'Brien 324 20.52% Bob Roddis 39 2.47% Write-In 7 0.44% Total... 1,579 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 95 11.03% Shelia Johnson 251 29.15% Brian Zahra 512 59.47% Write-In 3 0.35% Total... 861 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 657 52.35% Peter D O'Connell 588 46.85% Write-In 10 0.80% Total... 1,255 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 673 99.12% Write-In 6 0.88% Total... 679 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 613 49.96% Darnell Jackson 603 49.14% Write-In 11 0.90% Total... 1,227 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 723 99.59% Write-In 3 0.41% Total... 726 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 711 99.30% Write-In 5 0.70% Total... 716 100.00% FREELAND COMM 6 YR SCHOOL Janet M Alexander 128 5.63% Kristin Anderson 249 10.95% Michele Daniels 134 5.89% David Dennis 259 11.38% Melissa Lickly 142 6.24% Shawnette Markey 228 10.02% Toni Riffel 179 7.87% Charles Snider 175 7.69% Holli Wallace 140 6.15% Pete Wiltse 310 13.63% David Youngstrom 322 14.15% Write-In 9 0.40% Total... 2,275 100.00% FREELAND COMMUNITY 4 YR SCHOOLS PARTIAL Dennis J Argyle 361 45.35% Michelle Vanamburg Rankin 110 13.82% Holly Roenicke 221 27.76% Candace Stowell 97 12.19% Write-In 7 0.88% Total... 796 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 658 98.65% Write-In 9 1.35% Total... 667 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 186 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Tittabawassee Township Precinct 2 DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 233 37.16% Michael D Rowley 386 61.56% Write-In 8 1.28% Total... 627 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 614 98.87% Write-In 7 1.13% Total... 621 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 599 52.09% NO 551 47.91% Total... 1,150 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 356 30.53% NO 810 69.47% Total... 1,166 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 261 22.38% NO 905 77.62% Total... 1,166 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 326 28.18% NO 831 71.82% Total... 1,157 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 269 23.43% NO 879 76.57% Total... 1,148 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 366 31.77% NO 786 68.23% Total... 1,152 100.00% Delta College YES 675 60.05% NO 449 39.95% Total... 1,124 100.00% Tittabawassee Township Precinct 3 Registration & Turnout 1,219 Election Day Turnout 851 69.81% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 851 69.81% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 497 59.17% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 332 39.52% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 5 0.60% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 0 0.00% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 6 0.71% Total... 840 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 398 48.24% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 404 48.97% LIBR - Scotty Boman 13 1.58% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 4 0.48% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 1 0.12% NATLAW - John D Litle 4 0.48% Write-In 1 0.12% Total... 825 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 565 68.65% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 232 28.19% LIBR - John Gelineau 12 1.46% USTAX - George M Zimmer 4 0.49% GRN - Pat Timmons 7 0.85% Write-In 3 0.36% Total... 823 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 442 56.81% DEM - Judith Lincoln 332 42.67% Write-In 4 0.51% Total... 778 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 363 27.44% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 352 26.61% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 287 21.69% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 221 16.70% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 30 2.27% USTAX - Karen Adams 34 2.57%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 187 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Tittabawassee Township Precinct 3 MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION USTAX - Gail M Graeser 13 0.98% GRN - Candace R Caveny 11 0.83% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 9 0.68% Write-In 3 0.23% Total... 1,323 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 358 27.14% REP - Robert Steele 355 26.91% DEM - Mark Bernstein 287 21.76% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 226 17.13% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 21 1.59% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 17 1.29% USTAX - Joe Sanger 11 0.83% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 12 0.91% GRN - Eric Borregard 12 0.91% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 17 1.29% Write-In 3 0.23% Total... 1,319 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 381 29.77% REP - Jeff Sakwa 328 25.62% DEM - Joel Ferguson 268 20.94% DEM - Brian Mosallam 220 17.19% LIBR - Michael H Miller 30 2.34% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 25 1.95% USTAX - Stephen J Young 13 1.02% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 12 0.94% Write-In 3 0.23% Total... 1,280 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 353 28.56% REP - Satish B Jasti 298 24.11% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 280 22.65% DEM - Kim Trent 231 18.69% USTAX - Robert Gale 31 2.51% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 17 1.38% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 13 1.05% GRN - Latham Redding 10 0.81% Write-In 3 0.24% Total... 1,236 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 390 51.05% DEM - John McColgan Jr 369 48.30% Write-In 5 0.65% Total... 764 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 569 98.10% Write-In 11 1.90% Total... 580 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 365 48.41% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 384 50.93% Write-In 5 0.66% Total... 754 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 415 54.61% DEM - Tim Novak 341 44.87% Write-In 4 0.53% Total... 760 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 542 97.83% Write-In 12 2.17% Total... 554 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 536 97.81% Write-In 12 2.19% Total... 548 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 1 REP - Patrick Wurtzel 428 55.95% DEM - Ruth M Averill 333 43.53% Write-In 4 0.52% Total... 765 100.00% TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Rick Hayes 589 96.72% Write-In 20 3.28% Total... 609 100.00% TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Robert DuCharme 552 98.05% Write-In 11 1.95% Total... 563 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 188 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Tittabawassee Township Precinct 3 TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Tracy L Reimus 564 97.75% Write-In 13 2.25% Total... 577 100.00% TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Tom Forsberg 507 25.39% REP - Thomas N Metiva 491 24.59% REP - Carl W Neuenfeldt 477 23.89% REP - Paul S Vasold 498 24.94% Write-In 24 1.20% Total... 1,997 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 42 3.75% Connie Marie Kelley 250 22.32% Stephen Markman 305 27.23% Bridget Mary McCormack 228 20.36% Kerry L Morgan 33 2.95% Colleen O'Brien 211 18.84% Bob Roddis 44 3.93% Write-In 7 0.63% Total... 1,120 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 57 9.39% Shelia Johnson 207 34.10% Brian Zahra 337 55.52% Write-In 6 0.99% Total... 607 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 452 50.84% Peter D O'Connell 431 48.48% Write-In 6 0.67% Total... 889 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 494 99.00% Write-In 5 1.00% Total... 499 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 444 50.80% Darnell Jackson 422 48.28% Write-In 8 0.92% Total... 874 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 518 99.04% Write-In 5 0.96% Total... 523 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 525 99.06% Write-In 5 0.94% Total... 530 100.00% FREELAND COMM 6 YR SCHOOL Janet M Alexander 101 6.32% Kristin Anderson 164 10.26% Michele Daniels 77 4.82% David Dennis 159 9.95% Melissa Lickly 85 5.32% Shawnette Markey 208 13.02% Toni Riffel 131 8.20% Charles Snider 110 6.88% Holli Wallace 137 8.57% Pete Wiltse 235 14.71% David Youngstrom 181 11.33% Write-In 10 0.63% Total... 1,598 100.00% FREELAND COMMUNITY 4 YR SCHOOLS PARTIAL Dennis J Argyle 194 32.44% Michelle Vanamburg Rankin 103 17.22% Holly Roenicke 219 36.62% Candace Stowell 77 12.88% Write-In 5 0.84% Total... 598 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 484 97.58% Write-In 12 2.42% Total... 496 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 219 45.44% Michael D Rowley 257 53.32% Write-In 6 1.24% Total... 482 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 457 97.86%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 189 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Tittabawassee Township Precinct 3 DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Write-In 10 2.14% Total... 467 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 378 47.07% NO 425 52.93% Total... 803 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 284 34.59% NO 537 65.41% Total... 821 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 213 25.79% NO 613 74.21% Total... 826 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 285 35.01% NO 529 64.99% Total... 814 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 257 31.50% NO 559 68.50% Total... 816 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 352 43.03% NO 466 56.97% Total... 818 100.00% Delta College YES 469 59.22% NO 323 40.78% Total... 792 100.00% Tittabawassee Township Precinct 4 Registration & Turnout 1,687 Election Day Turnout 1,273 75.46% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,273 75.46% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 783 61.70% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 475 37.43% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 2 0.16% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 3 0.24% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.16% Write-In 4 0.32% Total... 1,269 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 643 52.49% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 552 45.06% LIBR - Scotty Boman 19 1.55% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 5 0.41% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 6 0.49% NATLAW - John D Litle 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,225 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 838 68.46% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 359 29.33% LIBR - John Gelineau 18 1.47% USTAX - George M Zimmer 2 0.16% GRN - Pat Timmons 7 0.57% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,224 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 708 59.85% DEM - Judith Lincoln 471 39.81% Write-In 4 0.34% Total... 1,183 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 593 28.59% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 571 27.53% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 434 20.93% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 347 16.73% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 46 2.22% USTAX - Karen Adams 30 1.45% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 16 0.77% GRN - Candace R Caveny 20 0.96% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 12 0.58% Write-In 5 0.24% Total... 2,074 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 190 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Tittabawassee Township Precinct 4 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 550 26.99% REP - Robert Steele 556 27.28% DEM - Mark Bernstein 436 21.39% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 363 17.81% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 25 1.23% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 22 1.08% USTAX - Joe Sanger 21 1.03% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 20 0.98% GRN - Eric Borregard 19 0.93% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 20 0.98% Write-In 6 0.29% Total... 2,038 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 610 30.36% REP - Jeff Sakwa 544 27.08% DEM - Joel Ferguson 395 19.66% DEM - Brian Mosallam 331 16.48% LIBR - Michael H Miller 44 2.19% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 27 1.34% USTAX - Stephen J Young 29 1.44% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 25 1.24% Write-In 4 0.20% Total... 2,009 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 572 29.30% REP - Satish B Jasti 498 25.51% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 413 21.16% DEM - Kim Trent 359 18.39% USTAX - Robert Gale 32 1.64% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 27 1.38% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 26 1.33% GRN - Latham Redding 18 0.92% Write-In 7 0.36% Total... 1,952 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 620 53.82% DEM - John McColgan Jr 530 46.01% Write-In 2 0.17% Total... 1,152 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 813 98.07% Write-In 16 1.93% Total... 829 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 582 51.05% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 557 48.86% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,140 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 634 56.11% DEM - Tim Novak 493 43.63% Write-In 3 0.27% Total... 1,130 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 786 99.37% Write-In 5 0.63% Total... 791 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 755 99.21% Write-In 6 0.79% Total... 761 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 1 REP - Patrick Wurtzel 657 56.64% DEM - Ruth M Averill 499 43.02% Write-In 4 0.34% Total... 1,160 100.00% TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Rick Hayes 893 98.13% Write-In 17 1.87% Total... 910 100.00% TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP CLERK DEM - Robert DuCharme 807 98.53% Write-In 12 1.47% Total... 819 100.00% TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Tracy L Reimus 874 98.31% Write-In 15 1.69% Total... 889 100.00% TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Tom Forsberg 795 25.36% REP - Thomas N Metiva 774 24.69%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 191 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Tittabawassee Township Precinct 4 TITTABAWASSEE TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Carl W Neuenfeldt 755 24.08% REP - Paul S Vasold 777 24.78% Write-In 34 1.08% Total... 3,135 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 41 2.49% Connie Marie Kelley 260 15.79% Stephen Markman 484 29.39% Bridget Mary McCormack 377 22.89% Kerry L Morgan 73 4.43% Colleen O'Brien 355 21.55% Bob Roddis 50 3.04% Write-In 7 0.43% Total... 1,647 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 108 11.91% Shelia Johnson 262 28.89% Brian Zahra 531 58.54% Write-In 6 0.66% Total... 907 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 672 51.97% Peter D O'Connell 612 47.33% Write-In 9 0.70% Total... 1,293 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 696 98.72% Write-In 9 1.28% Total... 705 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 650 50.54% Darnell Jackson 626 48.68% Write-In 10 0.78% Total... 1,286 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 756 99.08% Write-In 7 0.92% Total... 763 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 759 99.35% Write-In 5 0.65% Total... 764 100.00% FREELAND COMM 6 YR SCHOOL Janet M Alexander 207 8.56% Kristin Anderson 235 9.72% Michele Daniels 121 5.00% David Dennis 264 10.92% Melissa Lickly 121 5.00% Shawnette Markey 234 9.68% Toni Riffel 209 8.64% Charles Snider 255 10.55% Holli Wallace 172 7.11% Pete Wiltse 303 12.53% David Youngstrom 284 11.75% Write-In 13 0.54% Total... 2,418 100.00% FREELAND COMMUNITY 4 YR SCHOOLS PARTIAL Dennis J Argyle 317 36.44% Michelle Vanamburg Rankin 110 12.64% Holly Roenicke 326 37.47% Candace Stowell 112 12.87% Write-In 5 0.57% Total... 870 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 710 99.44% Write-In 4 0.56% Total... 714 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 273 40.32% Michael D Rowley 399 58.94% Write-In 5 0.74% Total... 677 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 662 99.85% Write-In 1 0.15% Total... 663 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 602 49.83% NO 606 50.17% Total... 1,208 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 192 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Tittabawassee Township Precinct 4 State Proposal 12-2 YES 398 32.33% NO 833 67.67% Total... 1,231 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 294 23.92% NO 935 76.08% Total... 1,229 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 374 30.81% NO 840 69.19% Total... 1,214 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 298 24.47% NO 920 75.53% Total... 1,218 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 418 34.15% NO 806 65.85% Total... 1,224 100.00% Delta College YES 724 61.51% NO 453 38.49% Total... 1,177 100.00% Zilwaukee Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 59 Election Day Turnout 50 84.75% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 50 84.75% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 23 46.00% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 25 50.00% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 0 0.00% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 1 2.00% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 1 2.00% Total... 50 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 17 34.69% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 30 61.22% LIBR - Scotty Boman 1 2.04% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 0 0.00% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 0 0.00% NATLAW - John D Litle 0 0.00% Write-In 1 2.04% Total... 49 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST REP - Jim Slezak 14 32.56% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 27 62.79% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 1 2.33% NPA - David Davenport 0 0.00% Write-In 1 2.33% Total... 43 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST REP - Jeff Baker 17 41.46% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 23 56.10% Write-In 1 2.44% Total... 41 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 16 23.53% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 17 25.00% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 17 25.00% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 12 17.65% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 0 0.00% USTAX - Karen Adams 2 2.94% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 1 1.47% GRN - Candace R Caveny 0 0.00% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 2 2.94% Write-In 1 1.47% Total... 68 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 16 23.88% REP - Robert Steele 14 20.90% DEM - Mark Bernstein 18 26.87% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 18 26.87% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 0 0.00% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 0 0.00% USTAX - Joe Sanger 0 0.00% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 0 0.00% GRN - Eric Borregard 0 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 193 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Zilwaukee Township Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 0 0.00% Write-In 1 1.49% Total... 67 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 16 25.00% REP - Jeff Sakwa 14 21.88% DEM - Joel Ferguson 18 28.13% DEM - Brian Mosallam 13 20.31% LIBR - Michael H Miller 0 0.00% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 0 0.00% USTAX - Stephen J Young 1 1.56% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 1 1.56% Write-In 1 1.56% Total... 64 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 18 27.69% REP - Satish B Jasti 14 21.54% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 18 27.69% DEM - Kim Trent 14 21.54% USTAX - Robert Gale 0 0.00% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 0 0.00% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 0 0.00% GRN - Latham Redding 0 0.00% Write-In 1 1.54% Total... 65 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 14 32.56% DEM - John McColgan Jr 27 62.79% Write-In 2 4.65% Total... 43 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 33 97.06% Write-In 1 2.94% Total... 34 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 11 25.00% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 33 75.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 44 0.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 19 43.18% DEM - Tim Novak 22 50.00% Write-In 3 6.82% Total... 44 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 30 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 30 0.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 30 96.77% Write-In 1 3.23% Total... 31 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 2 REP - Alex Boese 17 41.46% DEM - Chuck Stack 23 56.10% Write-In 1 2.44% Total... 41 100.00% ZILWAUKEE TOWNSHIP SUPERVISOR REP - Scott Clark 24 52.17% Write-In 22 47.83% Total... 46 100.00% ZILWAUKEE TOWNSHIP CLERK REP - Patricia Bradt 33 89.19% Write-In 4 10.81% Total... 37 100.00% ZILWAUKEE TOWNSHIP TREASURER REP - Kristin M Schanck 38 95.00% Write-In 2 5.00% Total... 40 100.00% ZILWAUKEE TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES REP - Catherine VanBlarcom 27 44.26% DEM - David Bradt 33 54.10% Write-In 1 1.64% Total... 61 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 1 1.64% Connie Marie Kelley 11 18.03% Stephen Markman 17 27.87% Bridget Mary McCormack 8 13.11% Kerry L Morgan 3 4.92% Colleen O'Brien 19 31.15%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 194 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Zilwaukee Township Precinct 1 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Bob Roddis 1 1.64% Write-In 1 1.64% Total... 61 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 4 12.12% Shelia Johnson 8 24.24% Brian Zahra 20 60.61% Write-In 1 3.03% Total... 33 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 25 55.56% Peter D O'Connell 19 42.22% Write-In 1 2.22% Total... 45 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 25 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 25 0.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 18 46.15% Darnell Jackson 20 51.28% Write-In 1 2.56% Total... 39 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 26 96.30% Write-In 1 3.70% Total... 27 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION Terry L Clark 23 95.83% Write-In 1 4.17% Total... 24 100.00% BAY CITY PUBLIC SCHOOLS 4 YR Pauline Helmling 25 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 25 0.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 25 96.15% Write-In 1 3.85% Total... 26 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 10 35.71% Michael D Rowley 17 60.71% Write-In 1 3.57% Total... 28 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 23 95.83% Write-In 1 4.17% Total... 24 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 13 29.55% NO 31 70.45% Total... 44 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 12 27.27% NO 32 72.73% Total... 44 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 10 22.73% NO 34 77.27% Total... 44 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 14 33.33% NO 28 66.67% Total... 42 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 15 34.09% NO 29 65.91% Total... 44 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 18 40.00% NO 27 60.00% Total... 45 100.00% Delta College YES 21 50.00% NO 21 50.00% Total... 42 100.00% City of Frankenmuth Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 2,173 Election Day Turnout 1,794 82.56% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 195 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Frankenmuth Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 2,173 Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,794 82.56% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 1,287 72.38% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 476 26.77% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 2 0.11% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 4 0.22% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.11% Write-In 7 0.39% Total... 1,778 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 1,089 62.23% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 635 36.29% LIBR - Scotty Boman 21 1.20% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 1 0.06% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.23% NATLAW - John D Litle 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,750 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 1,370 78.65% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 343 19.69% LIBR - John Gelineau 15 0.86% USTAX - George M Zimmer 8 0.46% GRN - Pat Timmons 6 0.34% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,742 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 1,272 74.26% DEM - Judith Lincoln 441 25.74% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,713 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 1,116 36.07% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 1,093 35.33% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 438 14.16% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 343 11.09% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 38 1.23% USTAX - Karen Adams 25 0.81% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 10 0.32% GRN - Candace R Caveny 18 0.58% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 10 0.32% Write-In 3 0.10% Total... 3,094 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 1,080 35.11% REP - Robert Steele 1,050 34.14% DEM - Mark Bernstein 487 15.83% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 359 11.67% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 26 0.85% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 21 0.68% USTAX - Joe Sanger 15 0.49% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 16 0.52% GRN - Eric Borregard 11 0.36% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 10 0.33% Write-In 1 0.03% Total... 3,076 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 1,135 37.32% REP - Jeff Sakwa 1,042 34.27% DEM - Joel Ferguson 430 14.14% DEM - Brian Mosallam 333 10.95% LIBR - Michael H Miller 52 1.71% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 18 0.59% USTAX - Stephen J Young 15 0.49% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 15 0.49% Write-In 1 0.03% Total... 3,041 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 1,079 36.85% REP - Satish B Jasti 969 33.09% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 450 15.37% DEM - Kim Trent 358 12.23% USTAX - Robert Gale 25 0.85% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 12 0.41% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 24 0.82% GRN - Latham Redding 11 0.38% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 2,928 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 196 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Frankenmuth Precinct 1 PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 1,139 68.95% DEM - John McColgan Jr 512 30.99% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,652 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 941 98.95% Write-In 10 1.05% Total... 951 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 1,064 64.33% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 590 35.67% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,654 0.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 1,137 70.14% DEM - Tim Novak 484 29.86% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,621 0.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 935 99.57% Write-In 4 0.43% Total... 939 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 907 99.23% Write-In 7 0.77% Total... 914 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 8 REP - Dennis Krafft 1,453 99.05% Write-In 14 0.95% Total... 1,467 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 67 2.53% Connie Marie Kelley 369 13.95% Stephen Markman 792 29.94% Bridget Mary McCormack 402 15.20% Kerry L Morgan 150 5.67% Colleen O'Brien 796 30.09% Bob Roddis 67 2.53% Write-In 2 0.08% Total... 2,645 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 63 4.55% Shelia Johnson 435 31.41% Brian Zahra 885 63.90% Write-In 2 0.14% Total... 1,385 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 1,043 51.63% Peter D O'Connell 973 48.17% Write-In 4 0.20% Total... 2,020 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 1,090 99.73% Write-In 3 0.27% Total... 1,093 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 1,037 50.98% Darnell Jackson 994 48.87% Write-In 3 0.15% Total... 2,034 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 1,144 99.74% Write-In 3 0.26% Total... 1,147 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 1,147 99.65% Write-In 4 0.35% Total... 1,151 100.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS Lori Ettema 900 35.06% David E Harris 812 31.63% Karen Uebler 849 33.07% Write-In 6 0.23% Total... 2,567 100.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS PARTIAL Al Zehnder 1,358 99.41% Write-In 8 0.59% Total... 1,366 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 1,119 99.56%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 197 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Frankenmuth Precinct 1 DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY Write-In 5 0.44% Total... 1,124 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 302 29.90% Michael D Rowley 707 70.00% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,010 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 989 99.80% Write-In 2 0.20% Total... 991 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 1,115 64.27% NO 620 35.73% Total... 1,735 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 368 20.96% NO 1,388 79.04% Total... 1,756 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 333 19.04% NO 1,416 80.96% Total... 1,749 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 375 21.66% NO 1,356 78.34% Total... 1,731 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 367 21.08% NO 1,374 78.92% Total... 1,741 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 495 28.48% NO 1,243 71.52% Total... 1,738 100.00% Delta College YES 937 56.21% NO 730 43.79% Total... 1,667 100.00% City of Frankenmuth Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 1,794 Election Day Turnout 1,381 76.98% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,381 76.98% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 1,029 75.22% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 331 24.20% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.07% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 4 0.29% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.07% Write-In 2 0.15% Total... 1,368 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 892 66.42% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 425 31.65% LIBR - Scotty Boman 12 0.89% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 7 0.52% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.30% NATLAW - John D Litle 3 0.22% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,343 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 4TH DIST REP - Dave Camp 1,049 79.05% DEM - Debra Freidell Wirth 250 18.84% LIBR - John Gelineau 13 0.98% USTAX - George M Zimmer 10 0.75% GRN - Pat Timmons 5 0.38% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,327 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 94TH DIST REP - Tim Kelly 996 76.26% DEM - Judith Lincoln 309 23.66% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,306 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 883 37.18% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 851 35.83% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 314 13.22%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 198 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Frankenmuth Precinct 2 MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 233 9.81% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 31 1.31% USTAX - Karen Adams 29 1.22% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 17 0.72% GRN - Candace R Caveny 7 0.29% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 9 0.38% Write-In 1 0.04% Total... 2,375 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 847 35.50% REP - Robert Steele 829 34.74% DEM - Mark Bernstein 343 14.38% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 260 10.90% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 20 0.84% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 24 1.01% USTAX - Joe Sanger 17 0.71% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 19 0.80% GRN - Eric Borregard 16 0.67% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 8 0.34% Write-In 3 0.13% Total... 2,386 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 879 37.44% REP - Jeff Sakwa 820 34.92% DEM - Joel Ferguson 302 12.86% DEM - Brian Mosallam 232 9.88% LIBR - Michael H Miller 42 1.79% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 25 1.06% USTAX - Stephen J Young 26 1.11% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 18 0.77% Write-In 4 0.17% Total... 2,348 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 865 37.67% REP - Satish B Jasti 773 33.67% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 323 14.07% DEM - Kim Trent 247 10.76% USTAX - Robert Gale 32 1.39% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 21 0.91% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 18 0.78% GRN - Latham Redding 14 0.61% Write-In 3 0.13% Total... 2,296 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 924 72.93% DEM - John McColgan Jr 342 26.99% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,267 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 733 97.86% Write-In 16 2.14% Total... 749 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 863 68.28% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 400 31.65% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,264 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 906 72.36% DEM - Tim Novak 342 27.32% Write-In 4 0.32% Total... 1,252 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 718 98.09% Write-In 14 1.91% Total... 732 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 691 98.71% Write-In 9 1.29% Total... 700 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 8 REP - Dennis Krafft 1,121 99.38% Write-In 7 0.62% Total... 1,128 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 60 3.02% Connie Marie Kelley 288 14.52% Stephen Markman 620 31.25% Bridget Mary McCormack 273 13.76% Kerry L Morgan 50 2.52% Colleen O'Brien 597 30.09%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 199 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Frankenmuth Precinct 2 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Bob Roddis 94 4.74% Write-In 2 0.10% Total... 1,984 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 74 7.19% Shelia Johnson 199 19.34% Brian Zahra 754 73.28% Write-In 2 0.19% Total... 1,029 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 782 51.93% Peter D O'Connell 721 47.88% Write-In 3 0.20% Total... 1,506 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 818 99.39% Write-In 5 0.61% Total... 823 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 791 52.38% Darnell Jackson 714 47.28% Write-In 5 0.33% Total... 1,510 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 839 99.17% Write-In 7 0.83% Total... 846 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 2ND DIVISION Kyle Higgs Tarrant 842 99.06% Write-In 8 0.94% Total... 850 100.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS Lori Ettema 606 30.90% David E Harris 588 29.98% Karen Uebler 764 38.96% Write-In 3 0.15% Total... 1,961 100.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS PARTIAL Al Zehnder 1,023 99.42% Write-In 6 0.58% Total... 1,029 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 843 99.53% Write-In 4 0.47% Total... 847 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 292 38.42% Michael D Rowley 462 60.79% Write-In 6 0.79% Total... 760 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 747 99.47% Write-In 4 0.53% Total... 751 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 834 63.62% NO 477 36.38% Total... 1,311 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 257 19.34% NO 1,072 80.66% Total... 1,329 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 247 18.49% NO 1,089 81.51% Total... 1,336 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 285 21.66% NO 1,031 78.34% Total... 1,316 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 264 19.86% NO 1,065 80.14% Total... 1,329 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 YES 363 27.25% NO 969 72.75% Total... 1,332 100.00% Delta College YES 735 57.56%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 200 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Frankenmuth Precinct 2 Delta College NO 542 42.44% Total... 1,277 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 2,147 Election Day Turnout 732 34.09% AV Polling Turnout 187 8.71% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 1 0.05% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 920 42.85% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 15 1.64% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 892 97.81% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.11% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 3 0.33% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 912 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 19 2.11% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 874 97.11% LIBR - Scotty Boman 2 0.22% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 2 0.22% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 1 0.11% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.22% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 900 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 16 1.79% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 863 96.53% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 7 0.78% NPA - David Davenport 8 0.89% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 894 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 22 2.44% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 877 97.34% Write-In 2 0.22% Total... 901 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 25 1.44% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 22 1.27% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 832 47.87% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 812 46.72% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 13 0.75% USTAX - Karen Adams 12 0.69% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 3 0.17% GRN - Candace R Caveny 6 0.35% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 12 0.69% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,738 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 18 1.04% REP - Robert Steele 25 1.44% DEM - Mark Bernstein 826 47.58% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 821 47.29% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 8 0.46% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 8 0.46% USTAX - Joe Sanger 10 0.58% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 3 0.17% GRN - Eric Borregard 6 0.35% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 9 0.52% Write-In 2 0.12% Total... 1,736 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 26 1.49% REP - Jeff Sakwa 22 1.26% DEM - Joel Ferguson 842 48.39% DEM - Brian Mosallam 813 46.72% LIBR - Michael H Miller 16 0.92% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 5 0.29% USTAX - Stephen J Young 8 0.46% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 7 0.40% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,740 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 23 1.33% REP - Satish B Jasti 18 1.04% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 840 48.47% DEM - Kim Trent 822 47.43% USTAX - Robert Gale 12 0.69% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 5 0.29%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 201 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 1 MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) GRN - Margaret Guttshall 6 0.35% GRN - Latham Redding 7 0.40% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,733 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 23 2.56% DEM - John McColgan Jr 874 97.11% Write-In 3 0.33% Total... 900 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 858 98.73% Write-In 11 1.27% Total... 869 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 29 3.26% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 854 96.06% Write-In 6 0.67% Total... 889 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 21 2.36% DEM - Tim Novak 863 97.18% Write-In 4 0.45% Total... 888 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 866 99.43% Write-In 5 0.57% Total... 871 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 865 99.08% Write-In 8 0.92% Total... 873 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 10 (Final) REP - John J Milne 26 2.91% DEM - Carl E Ruth 860 96.09% Write-In 9 1.01% Total... 895 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 24 2.05% Connie Marie Kelley 425 36.23% Stephen Markman 107 9.12% Bridget Mary McCormack 428 36.49% Kerry L Morgan 49 4.18% Colleen O'Brien 110 9.38% Bob Roddis 15 1.28% Write-In 15 1.28% Total... 1,173 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 28 4.01% Shelia Johnson 600 85.96% Brian Zahra 62 8.88% Write-In 8 1.15% Total... 698 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 457 56.28% Peter D O'Connell 335 41.26% Write-In 20 2.46% Total... 812 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 505 96.01% Write-In 21 3.99% Total... 526 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 279 31.35% Darnell Jackson 598 67.19% Write-In 13 1.46% Total... 890 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 565 96.42% Write-In 21 3.58% Total... 586 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 676 98.26% Write-In 12 1.74% Total... 688 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 610 97.44% Write-In 16 2.56% Total... 626 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 224 39.30%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 202 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 1 DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) Michael D Rowley 332 58.25% Write-In 14 2.46% Total... 570 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 555 96.52% Write-In 20 3.48% Total... 575 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 163 21.50% NO 595 78.50% Total... 758 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 628 81.66% NO 141 18.34% Total... 769 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 485 64.15% NO 271 35.85% Total... 756 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 660 86.50% NO 103 13.50% Total... 763 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 193 25.39% NO 567 74.61% Total... 760 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 506 66.40% NO 256 33.60% Total... 762 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 506 70.18% NO 215 29.82% Total... 721 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 558 76.54% NO 171 23.46% Total... 729 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 2 Registration & Turnout 1,167 Election Day Turnout 548 46.96% AV Polling Turnout 151 12.94% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 699 59.90% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 6 0.87% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 684 98.84% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 0 0.00% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 0 0.00% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.29% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 692 0.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 3 0.44% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 670 98.53% LIBR - Scotty Boman 4 0.59% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 0 0.00% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 1 0.15% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.29% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 680 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 5 0.74% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 656 97.62% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 6 0.89% NPA - David Davenport 5 0.74% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 672 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 5 0.74% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 670 98.97% Write-In 2 0.30% Total... 677 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 3 0.23% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 3 0.23% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 629 48.72% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 621 48.10%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 203 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 2 MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 5 0.39% USTAX - Karen Adams 18 1.39% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 2 0.15% GRN - Candace R Caveny 7 0.54% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 3 0.23% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,291 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 3 0.23% REP - Robert Steele 6 0.46% DEM - Mark Bernstein 623 48.07% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 628 48.46% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 6 0.46% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 6 0.46% USTAX - Joe Sanger 9 0.69% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 5 0.39% GRN - Eric Borregard 1 0.08% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 8 0.62% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,296 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 8 0.62% REP - Jeff Sakwa 5 0.39% DEM - Joel Ferguson 633 48.84% DEM - Brian Mosallam 618 47.69% LIBR - Michael H Miller 15 1.16% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 2 0.15% USTAX - Stephen J Young 8 0.62% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 7 0.54% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,296 0.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 6 0.47% REP - Satish B Jasti 3 0.23% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 638 49.50% DEM - Kim Trent 621 48.18% USTAX - Robert Gale 7 0.54% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 6 0.47% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 3 0.23% GRN - Latham Redding 3 0.23% Write-In 2 0.16% Total... 1,289 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 6 0.90% DEM - John McColgan Jr 659 98.80% Write-In 2 0.30% Total... 667 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 654 99.24% Write-In 5 0.76% Total... 659 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 5 0.75% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 665 99.25% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 670 0.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 5 0.75% DEM - Tim Novak 664 99.25% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 669 0.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 666 99.85% Write-In 1 0.15% Total... 667 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 657 99.70% Write-In 2 0.30% Total... 659 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 9 (Final) DEM - Robert Moe Woods 663 99.70% Write-In 2 0.30% Total... 665 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 7 0.76% Connie Marie Kelley 349 38.06% Stephen Markman 71 7.74% Bridget Mary McCormack 358 39.04% Kerry L Morgan 39 4.25% Colleen O'Brien 86 9.38% Bob Roddis 4 0.44%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 204 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 2 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Write-In 3 0.33% Total... 917 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 9 1.66% Shelia Johnson 479 88.54% Brian Zahra 50 9.24% Write-In 3 0.55% Total... 541 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 399 59.64% Peter D O'Connell 256 38.27% Write-In 14 2.09% Total... 669 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 377 95.69% Write-In 17 4.31% Total... 394 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 221 30.23% Darnell Jackson 500 68.40% Write-In 10 1.37% Total... 731 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 422 97.01% Write-In 13 2.99% Total... 435 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 552 98.22% Write-In 10 1.78% Total... 562 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 478 98.15% Write-In 9 1.85% Total... 487 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 205 47.02% Michael D Rowley 223 51.15% Write-In 8 1.83% Total... 436 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 432 97.74% Write-In 10 2.26% Total... 442 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 121 19.61% NO 496 80.39% Total... 617 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 517 82.59% NO 109 17.41% Total... 626 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 405 65.43% NO 214 34.57% Total... 619 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 531 85.23% NO 92 14.77% Total... 623 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 147 23.94% NO 467 76.06% Total... 614 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 419 66.83% NO 208 33.17% Total... 627 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 411 68.96% NO 185 31.04% Total... 596 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 459 77.66% NO 132 22.34% Total... 591 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 3 Registration & Turnout 2,125 Election Day Turnout 884 41.60% AV Polling Turnout 279 13.13% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 1 0.05%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 205 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 3 Registration & Turnout 2,125 SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,164 54.78% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 15 1.29% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 1,144 98.54% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.09% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 0 0.00% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 1 0.09% Total... 1,161 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 12 1.04% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 1,129 98.26% LIBR - Scotty Boman 3 0.26% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 2 0.17% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 1 0.09% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.17% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,149 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 13 1.14% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 1,119 97.73% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 8 0.70% NPA - David Davenport 5 0.44% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,145 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 15 1.30% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 1,132 98.35% Write-In 4 0.35% Total... 1,151 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 16 0.72% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 25 1.13% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 1,077 48.49% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 1,055 47.50% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 5 0.23% USTAX - Karen Adams 16 0.72% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 5 0.23% GRN - Candace R Caveny 5 0.23% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 15 0.68% Write-In 2 0.09% Total... 2,221 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 13 0.59% REP - Robert Steele 13 0.59% DEM - Mark Bernstein 1,068 48.30% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 1,073 48.53% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 9 0.41% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 7 0.32% USTAX - Joe Sanger 12 0.54% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 3 0.14% GRN - Eric Borregard 2 0.09% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 8 0.36% Write-In 3 0.14% Total... 2,211 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 15 0.68% REP - Jeff Sakwa 8 0.36% DEM - Joel Ferguson 1,087 49.16% DEM - Brian Mosallam 1,072 48.48% LIBR - Michael H Miller 9 0.41% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 5 0.23% USTAX - Stephen J Young 10 0.45% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 3 0.14% Write-In 2 0.09% Total... 2,211 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 14 0.64% REP - Satish B Jasti 9 0.41% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 1,086 49.52% DEM - Kim Trent 1,064 48.52% USTAX - Robert Gale 5 0.23% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 6 0.27% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 4 0.18% GRN - Latham Redding 3 0.14% Write-In 2 0.09% Total... 2,193 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 20 1.75% DEM - John McColgan Jr 1,116 97.64%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 206 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 3 PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) Write-In 7 0.61% Total... 1,143 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,114 98.85% Write-In 13 1.15% Total... 1,127 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 19 1.67% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 1,114 97.89% Write-In 5 0.44% Total... 1,138 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 18 1.59% DEM - Tim Novak 1,110 97.88% Write-In 6 0.53% Total... 1,134 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,124 99.65% Write-In 4 0.35% Total... 1,128 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,121 99.47% Write-In 6 0.53% Total... 1,127 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 9 (Final) DEM - Robert Moe Woods 1,127 99.56% Write-In 5 0.44% Total... 1,132 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 18 1.07% Connie Marie Kelley 669 39.68% Stephen Markman 142 8.42% Bridget Mary McCormack 677 40.15% Kerry L Morgan 45 2.67% Colleen O'Brien 112 6.64% Bob Roddis 17 1.01% Write-In 6 0.36% Total... 1,686 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 53 5.42% Shelia Johnson 836 85.57% Brian Zahra 84 8.60% Write-In 4 0.41% Total... 977 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 624 57.62% Peter D O'Connell 445 41.09% Write-In 14 1.29% Total... 1,083 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 675 96.29% Write-In 26 3.71% Total... 701 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 352 31.01% Darnell Jackson 770 67.84% Write-In 13 1.15% Total... 1,135 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 711 97.66% Write-In 17 2.34% Total... 728 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 858 98.62% Write-In 12 1.38% Total... 870 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 772 98.72% Write-In 10 1.28% Total... 782 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 323 44.01% Michael D Rowley 396 53.95% Write-In 15 2.04% Total... 734 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 716 98.08% Write-In 14 1.92% Total... 730 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 207 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 3 State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 198 18.73% NO 859 81.27% Total... 1,057 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 916 84.81% NO 164 15.19% Total... 1,080 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 745 70.75% NO 308 29.25% Total... 1,053 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 931 88.00% NO 127 12.00% Total... 1,058 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 245 23.07% NO 817 76.93% Total... 1,062 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 781 73.89% NO 276 26.11% Total... 1,057 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 753 74.78% NO 254 25.22% Total... 1,007 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 840 82.51% NO 178 17.49% Total... 1,018 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 4 Registration & Turnout 1,130 Election Day Turnout 405 35.84% AV Polling Turnout 105 9.29% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 510 45.13% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 31 6.11% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 470 92.70% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 2 0.39% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 3 0.59% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 1 0.20% Total... 507 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 29 5.81% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 457 91.58% LIBR - Scotty Boman 5 1.00% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 4 0.80% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 3 0.60% NATLAW - John D Litle 1 0.20% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 499 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 27 5.48% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 446 90.47% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 10 2.03% NPA - David Davenport 9 1.83% Write-In 1 0.20% Total... 493 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 32 6.50% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 457 92.89% Write-In 3 0.61% Total... 492 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 24 2.52% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 33 3.47% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 433 45.53% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 417 43.85% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 6 0.63% USTAX - Karen Adams 13 1.37% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 2 0.21% GRN - Candace R Caveny 8 0.84% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 14 1.47% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 951 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 208 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 4 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 27 2.86% REP - Robert Steele 33 3.50% DEM - Mark Bernstein 426 45.13% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 427 45.23% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 6 0.64% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 6 0.64% USTAX - Joe Sanger 4 0.42% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 4 0.42% GRN - Eric Borregard 4 0.42% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 5 0.53% Write-In 2 0.21% Total... 944 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 34 3.62% REP - Jeff Sakwa 29 3.09% DEM - Joel Ferguson 436 46.38% DEM - Brian Mosallam 415 44.15% LIBR - Michael H Miller 11 1.17% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 2 0.21% USTAX - Stephen J Young 6 0.64% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 6 0.64% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 940 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 27 2.87% REP - Satish B Jasti 28 2.98% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 435 46.28% DEM - Kim Trent 421 44.79% USTAX - Robert Gale 7 0.74% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 7 0.74% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 10 1.06% GRN - Latham Redding 4 0.43% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 940 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 33 6.73% DEM - John McColgan Jr 457 93.27% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 490 0.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 464 97.89% Write-In 10 2.11% Total... 474 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 30 6.15% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 457 93.65% Write-In 1 0.20% Total... 488 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 33 6.78% DEM - Tim Novak 453 93.02% Write-In 1 0.21% Total... 487 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 472 98.74% Write-In 6 1.26% Total... 478 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 470 98.74% Write-In 6 1.26% Total... 476 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 10 (Final) REP - John J Milne 38 7.72% DEM - Carl E Ruth 450 91.46% Write-In 4 0.81% Total... 492 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 7 1.02% Connie Marie Kelley 232 33.77% Stephen Markman 57 8.30% Bridget Mary McCormack 287 41.78% Kerry L Morgan 19 2.77% Colleen O'Brien 78 11.35% Bob Roddis 4 0.58% Write-In 3 0.44% Total... 687 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 20 4.95% Shelia Johnson 333 82.43% Brian Zahra 48 11.88%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 209 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 4 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Write-In 3 0.74% Total... 404 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 289 57.34% Peter D O'Connell 210 41.67% Write-In 5 0.99% Total... 504 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 300 96.46% Write-In 11 3.54% Total... 311 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 194 35.99% Darnell Jackson 336 62.34% Write-In 9 1.67% Total... 539 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 310 97.48% Write-In 8 2.52% Total... 318 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 376 98.43% Write-In 6 1.57% Total... 382 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 335 96.54% Write-In 12 3.46% Total... 347 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 180 54.22% Michael D Rowley 147 44.28% Write-In 5 1.51% Total... 332 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 319 97.85% Write-In 7 2.15% Total... 326 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 107 23.73% NO 344 76.27% Total... 451 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 353 77.41% NO 103 22.59% Total... 456 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 285 63.76% NO 162 36.24% Total... 447 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 350 78.13% NO 98 21.88% Total... 448 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 115 25.56% NO 335 74.44% Total... 450 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 293 64.54% NO 161 35.46% Total... 454 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 309 71.86% NO 121 28.14% Total... 430 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 336 78.32% NO 93 21.68% Total... 429 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 5 Registration & Turnout 2,093 Election Day Turnout 677 32.35% AV Polling Turnout 190 9.08% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 867 41.42% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 17 1.97% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 843 97.80% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 2 0.23%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 210 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 5 PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 0 0.00% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 862 0.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 19 2.24% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 820 96.47% LIBR - Scotty Boman 3 0.35% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 3 0.35% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 3 0.35% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.24% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 850 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 15 1.79% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 810 96.43% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 7 0.83% NPA - David Davenport 8 0.95% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 840 0.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 19 2.25% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 812 96.21% Write-In 13 1.54% Total... 844 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 15 0.92% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 16 0.98% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 785 47.90% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 777 47.41% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 9 0.55% USTAX - Karen Adams 15 0.92% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 8 0.49% GRN - Candace R Caveny 7 0.43% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 6 0.37% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,639 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 20 1.23% REP - Robert Steele 17 1.04% DEM - Mark Bernstein 776 47.64% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 770 47.27% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 5 0.31% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 6 0.37% USTAX - Joe Sanger 10 0.61% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 5 0.31% GRN - Eric Borregard 2 0.12% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 11 0.68% Write-In 7 0.43% Total... 1,629 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 23 1.41% REP - Jeff Sakwa 14 0.86% DEM - Joel Ferguson 788 48.28% DEM - Brian Mosallam 767 47.00% LIBR - Michael H Miller 7 0.43% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 5 0.31% USTAX - Stephen J Young 15 0.92% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 10 0.61% Write-In 3 0.18% Total... 1,632 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 20 1.23% REP - Satish B Jasti 16 0.99% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 789 48.70% DEM - Kim Trent 769 47.47% USTAX - Robert Gale 13 0.80% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 5 0.31% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 0 0.00% GRN - Latham Redding 5 0.31% Write-In 3 0.19% Total... 1,620 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 22 2.62% DEM - John McColgan Jr 810 96.54% Write-In 7 0.83% Total... 839 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 807 98.66% Write-In 11 1.34% Total... 818 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 211 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 5 CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 23 2.75% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 809 96.89% Write-In 3 0.36% Total... 835 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 19 2.29% DEM - Tim Novak 805 96.87% Write-In 7 0.84% Total... 831 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 817 99.27% Write-In 6 0.73% Total... 823 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 810 98.90% Write-In 9 1.10% Total... 819 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 10 (Final) REP - John J Milne 21 2.51% DEM - Carl E Ruth 806 96.53% Write-In 8 0.96% Total... 835 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 16 1.47% Connie Marie Kelley 341 31.26% Stephen Markman 69 6.32% Bridget Mary McCormack 433 39.69% Kerry L Morgan 60 5.50% Colleen O'Brien 139 12.74% Bob Roddis 22 2.02% Write-In 11 1.01% Total... 1,091 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 22 3.41% Shelia Johnson 538 83.41% Brian Zahra 77 11.94% Write-In 8 1.24% Total... 645 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 438 56.08% Peter D O'Connell 318 40.72% Write-In 25 3.20% Total... 781 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 486 95.67% Write-In 22 4.33% Total... 508 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 267 31.90% Darnell Jackson 547 65.35% Write-In 23 2.75% Total... 837 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 515 95.19% Write-In 26 4.81% Total... 541 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 594 97.38% Write-In 16 2.62% Total... 610 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 550 98.04% Write-In 11 1.96% Total... 561 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 208 38.66% Michael D Rowley 317 58.92% Write-In 13 2.42% Total... 538 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 514 97.35% Write-In 14 2.65% Total... 528 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 161 21.30% NO 595 78.70% Total... 756 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 647 83.38%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 212 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 5 State Proposal 12-2 (Final) NO 129 16.62% Total... 776 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 505 66.89% NO 250 33.11% Total... 755 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 651 84.33% NO 121 15.67% Total... 772 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 178 23.24% NO 588 76.76% Total... 766 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 536 69.61% NO 234 30.39% Total... 770 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 484 66.57% NO 243 33.43% Total... 727 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 564 77.37% NO 165 22.63% Total... 729 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 6 Registration & Turnout 1,777 Election Day Turnout 626 35.23% AV Polling Turnout 215 12.10% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 841 47.33% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 16 1.91% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 818 97.85% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.12% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 1 0.12% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 836 0.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 15 1.82% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 798 96.73% LIBR - Scotty Boman 2 0.24% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 5 0.61% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 2 0.24% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.24% Write-In 1 0.12% Total... 825 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 11 1.35% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 790 96.81% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 4 0.49% NPA - David Davenport 9 1.10% Write-In 2 0.25% Total... 816 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 19 2.32% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 795 96.95% Write-In 6 0.73% Total... 820 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 16 1.02% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 18 1.14% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 753 47.84% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 733 46.57% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 6 0.38% USTAX - Karen Adams 17 1.08% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 5 0.32% GRN - Candace R Caveny 11 0.70% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 11 0.70% Write-In 4 0.25% Total... 1,574 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 14 0.89% REP - Robert Steele 18 1.15% DEM - Mark Bernstein 744 47.36% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 746 47.49% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 9 0.57%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 213 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 6 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 4 0.25% USTAX - Joe Sanger 12 0.76% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 7 0.45% GRN - Eric Borregard 7 0.45% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 8 0.51% Write-In 2 0.13% Total... 1,571 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 22 1.40% REP - Jeff Sakwa 22 1.40% DEM - Joel Ferguson 750 47.71% DEM - Brian Mosallam 735 46.76% LIBR - Michael H Miller 7 0.45% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 6 0.38% USTAX - Stephen J Young 18 1.15% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 7 0.45% Write-In 5 0.32% Total... 1,572 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 15 0.95% REP - Satish B Jasti 16 1.02% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 764 48.60% DEM - Kim Trent 740 47.07% USTAX - Robert Gale 8 0.51% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 11 0.70% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 8 0.51% GRN - Latham Redding 7 0.45% Write-In 3 0.19% Total... 1,572 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 21 2.57% DEM - John McColgan Jr 786 96.21% Write-In 10 1.22% Total... 817 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 782 97.87% Write-In 17 2.13% Total... 799 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 28 3.45% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 779 95.94% Write-In 5 0.62% Total... 812 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 20 2.47% DEM - Tim Novak 782 96.54% Write-In 8 0.99% Total... 810 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 797 99.38% Write-In 5 0.62% Total... 802 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 794 99.25% Write-In 6 0.75% Total... 800 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 9 (Final) DEM - Robert Moe Woods 792 99.12% Write-In 7 0.88% Total... 799 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 20 1.73% Connie Marie Kelley 409 35.41% Stephen Markman 95 8.23% Bridget Mary McCormack 415 35.93% Kerry L Morgan 45 3.90% Colleen O'Brien 139 12.03% Bob Roddis 21 1.82% Write-In 11 0.95% Total... 1,155 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 31 4.61% Shelia Johnson 563 83.78% Brian Zahra 68 10.12% Write-In 10 1.49% Total... 672 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 466 56.42% Peter D O'Connell 337 40.80% Write-In 23 2.78% Total... 826 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 214 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 6 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 510 93.24% Write-In 37 6.76% Total... 547 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 283 32.95% Darnell Jackson 561 65.31% Write-In 15 1.75% Total... 859 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 534 95.36% Write-In 26 4.64% Total... 560 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 635 97.09% Write-In 19 2.91% Total... 654 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 570 96.28% Write-In 22 3.72% Total... 592 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 258 44.95% Michael D Rowley 292 50.87% Write-In 24 4.18% Total... 574 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 522 94.05% Write-In 33 5.95% Total... 555 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 167 21.60% NO 606 78.40% Total... 773 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 630 80.98% NO 148 19.02% Total... 778 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 488 63.87% NO 276 36.13% Total... 764 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 643 83.29% NO 129 16.71% Total... 772 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 215 27.78% NO 559 72.22% Total... 774 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 556 72.30% NO 213 27.70% Total... 769 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 501 67.98% NO 236 32.02% Total... 737 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 563 75.67% NO 181 24.33% Total... 744 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 7 Registration & Turnout 2,108 Election Day Turnout 853 40.46% AV Polling Turnout 162 7.69% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,015 48.15% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 40 3.96% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 966 95.64% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 4 0.40% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 0 0.00% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,010 0.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 35 3.50% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 954 95.40% LIBR - Scotty Boman 5 0.50%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 215 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 7 US SENATOR (Final) USTAX - Richard A Matkin 1 0.10% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 1 0.10% NATLAW - John D Litle 3 0.30% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 1,000 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 39 3.91% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 936 93.88% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 7 0.70% NPA - David Davenport 14 1.40% Write-In 1 0.10% Total... 997 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 45 4.50% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 950 95.00% Write-In 5 0.50% Total... 1,000 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 39 2.03% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 40 2.08% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 908 47.27% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 877 45.65% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 10 0.52% USTAX - Karen Adams 19 0.99% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 9 0.47% GRN - Candace R Caveny 12 0.62% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 4 0.21% Write-In 3 0.16% Total... 1,921 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 41 2.15% REP - Robert Steele 39 2.05% DEM - Mark Bernstein 888 46.66% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 887 46.61% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 6 0.32% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 5 0.26% USTAX - Joe Sanger 11 0.58% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 7 0.37% GRN - Eric Borregard 6 0.32% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 9 0.47% Write-In 4 0.21% Total... 1,903 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 42 2.21% REP - Jeff Sakwa 41 2.16% DEM - Joel Ferguson 908 47.84% DEM - Brian Mosallam 864 45.52% LIBR - Michael H Miller 14 0.74% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 8 0.42% USTAX - Stephen J Young 15 0.79% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 3 0.16% Write-In 3 0.16% Total... 1,898 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 38 2.01% REP - Satish B Jasti 31 1.64% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 911 48.25% DEM - Kim Trent 878 46.50% USTAX - Robert Gale 8 0.42% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 7 0.37% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 8 0.42% GRN - Latham Redding 4 0.21% Write-In 3 0.16% Total... 1,888 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 50 5.04% DEM - John McColgan Jr 939 94.66% Write-In 3 0.30% Total... 992 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 934 98.32% Write-In 16 1.68% Total... 950 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 44 4.47% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 933 94.72% Write-In 8 0.81% Total... 985 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 43 4.37% DEM - Tim Novak 932 94.72%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 216 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 7 TREASURER (Final) Write-In 9 0.91% Total... 984 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 957 99.27% Write-In 7 0.73% Total... 964 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 955 99.07% Write-In 9 0.93% Total... 964 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 9 (Final) DEM - Robert Moe Woods 955 98.86% Write-In 11 1.14% Total... 966 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 33 2.40% Connie Marie Kelley 452 32.85% Stephen Markman 149 10.83% Bridget Mary McCormack 504 36.63% Kerry L Morgan 41 2.98% Colleen O'Brien 151 10.97% Bob Roddis 15 1.09% Write-In 31 2.25% Total... 1,376 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 29 3.50% Shelia Johnson 666 80.43% Brian Zahra 117 14.13% Write-In 16 1.93% Total... 828 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 556 57.92% Peter D O'Connell 364 37.92% Write-In 40 4.17% Total... 960 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 623 93.26% Write-In 45 6.74% Total... 668 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 316 30.44% Darnell Jackson 695 66.96% Write-In 27 2.60% Total... 1,038 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 649 94.88% Write-In 35 5.12% Total... 684 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 770 96.49% Write-In 28 3.51% Total... 798 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 705 95.53% Write-In 33 4.47% Total... 738 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 286 41.33% Michael D Rowley 379 54.77% Write-In 27 3.90% Total... 692 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 657 96.05% Write-In 27 3.95% Total... 684 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 223 24.34% NO 693 75.66% Total... 916 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 735 79.20% NO 193 20.80% Total... 928 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 534 58.49% NO 379 41.51% Total... 913 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 725 79.58%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 217 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 7 State Proposal 12-4 (Final) NO 186 20.42% Total... 911 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 236 25.71% NO 682 74.29% Total... 918 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 602 64.87% NO 326 35.13% Total... 928 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 569 64.37% NO 315 35.63% Total... 884 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 646 72.75% NO 242 27.25% Total... 888 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 8 Registration & Turnout 2,788 Election Day Turnout 1,012 36.30% AV Polling Turnout 513 18.40% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,525 54.70% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 26 1.72% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 1,481 98.01% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 2 0.13% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 2 0.13% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,511 0.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 17 1.14% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 1,465 97.86% LIBR - Scotty Boman 4 0.27% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 5 0.33% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 1 0.07% NATLAW - John D Litle 3 0.20% Write-In 2 0.13% Total... 1,497 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 23 1.54% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 1,443 96.85% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 7 0.47% NPA - David Davenport 13 0.87% Write-In 4 0.27% Total... 1,490 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 35 2.33% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 1,457 97.20% Write-In 7 0.47% Total... 1,499 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 20 0.70% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 28 0.98% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 1,385 48.27% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 1,349 47.02% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 9 0.31% USTAX - Karen Adams 31 1.08% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 12 0.42% GRN - Candace R Caveny 13 0.45% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 19 0.66% Write-In 3 0.10% Total... 2,869 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 18 0.63% REP - Robert Steele 24 0.84% DEM - Mark Bernstein 1,378 48.20% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 1,367 47.81% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 9 0.31% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 6 0.21% USTAX - Joe Sanger 18 0.63% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 13 0.45% GRN - Eric Borregard 6 0.21% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 17 0.59% Write-In 3 0.10% Total... 2,859 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 32 1.12%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 218 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 8 MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Jeff Sakwa 23 0.80% DEM - Joel Ferguson 1,389 48.50% DEM - Brian Mosallam 1,348 47.07% LIBR - Michael H Miller 15 0.52% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 15 0.52% USTAX - Stephen J Young 27 0.94% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 13 0.45% Write-In 2 0.07% Total... 2,864 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 27 0.94% REP - Satish B Jasti 18 0.63% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 1,401 48.90% DEM - Kim Trent 1,364 47.61% USTAX - Robert Gale 22 0.77% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 11 0.38% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 14 0.49% GRN - Latham Redding 2 0.07% Write-In 6 0.21% Total... 2,865 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 39 2.63% DEM - John McColgan Jr 1,436 96.70% Write-In 10 0.67% Total... 1,485 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,432 98.55% Write-In 21 1.45% Total... 1,453 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 31 2.09% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 1,443 97.43% Write-In 7 0.47% Total... 1,481 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 37 2.50% DEM - Tim Novak 1,435 96.83% Write-In 10 0.67% Total... 1,482 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,453 99.66% Write-In 5 0.34% Total... 1,458 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,453 99.66% Write-In 5 0.34% Total... 1,458 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 9 (Final) DEM - Robert Moe Woods 1,452 99.25% Write-In 11 0.75% Total... 1,463 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 38 1.83% Connie Marie Kelley 769 37.10% Stephen Markman 172 8.30% Bridget Mary McCormack 830 40.04% Kerry L Morgan 73 3.52% Colleen O'Brien 144 6.95% Bob Roddis 28 1.35% Write-In 19 0.92% Total... 2,073 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 34 2.80% Shelia Johnson 1,041 85.61% Brian Zahra 129 10.61% Write-In 12 0.99% Total... 1,216 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 831 56.84% Peter D O'Connell 594 40.63% Write-In 37 2.53% Total... 1,462 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 898 95.84% Write-In 39 4.16% Total... 937 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 528 33.12% Darnell Jackson 1,046 65.62% Write-In 20 1.25% Total... 1,594 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 219 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 8 JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 968 96.51% Write-In 35 3.49% Total... 1,003 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 1,184 98.50% Write-In 18 1.50% Total... 1,202 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 1,016 96.39% Write-In 38 3.61% Total... 1,054 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 497 51.03% Michael D Rowley 444 45.59% Write-In 33 3.39% Total... 974 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 922 96.14% Write-In 37 3.86% Total... 959 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 269 19.94% NO 1,080 80.06% Total... 1,349 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 1,165 83.99% NO 222 16.01% Total... 1,387 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 925 68.62% NO 423 31.38% Total... 1,348 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 1,209 88.06% NO 164 11.94% Total... 1,373 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 333 24.65% NO 1,018 75.35% Total... 1,351 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 951 69.67% NO 414 30.33% Total... 1,365 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 882 68.06% NO 414 31.94% Total... 1,296 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 982 74.96% NO 328 25.04% Total... 1,310 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 9 Registration & Turnout 2,154 Election Day Turnout 777 36.07% AV Polling Turnout 185 8.59% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 962 44.66% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 39 4.08% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 911 95.19% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 2 0.21% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 1 0.10% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.21% Write-In 2 0.21% Total... 957 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 28 2.97% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 898 95.23% LIBR - Scotty Boman 5 0.53% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 3 0.32% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.42% NATLAW - John D Litle 4 0.42% Write-In 1 0.11% Total... 943 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 38 4.06% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 875 93.38% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 9 0.96%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 220 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 9 US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) NPA - David Davenport 11 1.17% Write-In 4 0.43% Total... 937 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 35 3.72% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 898 95.53% Write-In 7 0.74% Total... 940 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 38 2.11% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 42 2.33% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 832 46.15% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 830 46.03% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 11 0.61% USTAX - Karen Adams 21 1.16% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 8 0.44% GRN - Candace R Caveny 13 0.72% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 7 0.39% Write-In 1 0.06% Total... 1,803 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 32 1.77% REP - Robert Steele 39 2.16% DEM - Mark Bernstein 843 46.73% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 836 46.34% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 8 0.44% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 8 0.44% USTAX - Joe Sanger 9 0.50% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 10 0.55% GRN - Eric Borregard 4 0.22% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 12 0.67% Write-In 3 0.17% Total... 1,804 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 41 2.28% REP - Jeff Sakwa 32 1.78% DEM - Joel Ferguson 849 47.27% DEM - Brian Mosallam 815 45.38% LIBR - Michael H Miller 16 0.89% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 11 0.61% USTAX - Stephen J Young 15 0.84% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 14 0.78% Write-In 3 0.17% Total... 1,796 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 41 2.29% REP - Satish B Jasti 26 1.45% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 853 47.57% DEM - Kim Trent 831 46.35% USTAX - Robert Gale 12 0.67% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 10 0.56% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 9 0.50% GRN - Latham Redding 9 0.50% Write-In 2 0.11% Total... 1,793 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 39 4.18% DEM - John McColgan Jr 887 95.07% Write-In 7 0.75% Total... 933 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 885 97.79% Write-In 20 2.21% Total... 905 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 47 5.04% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 880 94.42% Write-In 5 0.54% Total... 932 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 46 4.96% DEM - Tim Novak 874 94.28% Write-In 7 0.76% Total... 927 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 901 98.79% Write-In 11 1.21% Total... 912 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 894 98.13%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 221 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 9 PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) Write-In 17 1.87% Total... 911 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 11 (Final) REP - David Bechard 31 3.31% DEM - Michael J Hanley 866 92.52% NPA - John H Cammin 36 3.85% Write-In 3 0.32% Total... 936 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 22 1.76% Connie Marie Kelley 440 35.17% Stephen Markman 133 10.63% Bridget Mary McCormack 466 37.25% Kerry L Morgan 53 4.24% Colleen O'Brien 106 8.47% Bob Roddis 17 1.36% Write-In 14 1.12% Total... 1,251 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 54 7.35% Shelia Johnson 562 76.46% Brian Zahra 111 15.10% Write-In 8 1.09% Total... 735 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 498 56.53% Peter D O'Connell 358 40.64% Write-In 25 2.84% Total... 881 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 538 93.40% Write-In 38 6.60% Total... 576 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 297 31.94% Darnell Jackson 614 66.02% Write-In 19 2.04% Total... 930 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 576 95.68% Write-In 26 4.32% Total... 602 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 670 97.10% Write-In 20 2.90% Total... 690 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 608 96.97% Write-In 19 3.03% Total... 627 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 236 39.53% Michael D Rowley 342 57.29% Write-In 19 3.18% Total... 597 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 553 95.51% Write-In 26 4.49% Total... 579 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 174 21.14% NO 649 78.86% Total... 823 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 662 78.62% NO 180 21.38% Total... 842 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 539 64.86% NO 292 35.14% Total... 831 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 698 81.83% NO 155 18.17% Total... 853 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 225 27.17% NO 603 72.83% Total... 828 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 222 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 9 State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 577 68.85% NO 261 31.15% Total... 838 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 523 65.95% NO 270 34.05% Total... 793 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 580 72.68% NO 218 27.32% Total... 798 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 10 Registration & Turnout 1,595 Election Day Turnout 640 40.13% AV Polling Turnout 118 7.40% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 758 47.52% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 10 1.32% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 746 98.68% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 0 0.00% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 0 0.00% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 756 0.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 16 2.14% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 727 97.32% LIBR - Scotty Boman 1 0.13% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 2 0.27% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 1 0.13% NATLAW - John D Litle 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 747 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 14 1.89% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 715 96.75% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 2 0.27% NPA - David Davenport 7 0.95% Write-In 1 0.14% Total... 739 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 12 1.61% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 729 97.72% Write-In 5 0.67% Total... 746 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 13 0.91% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 15 1.05% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 700 48.88% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 670 46.79% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 4 0.28% USTAX - Karen Adams 17 1.19% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 2 0.14% GRN - Candace R Caveny 5 0.35% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 4 0.28% Write-In 2 0.14% Total... 1,432 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 13 0.91% REP - Robert Steele 14 0.98% DEM - Mark Bernstein 685 47.97% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 693 48.53% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 4 0.28% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 4 0.28% USTAX - Joe Sanger 3 0.21% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 4 0.28% GRN - Eric Borregard 1 0.07% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 4 0.28% Write-In 3 0.21% Total... 1,428 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 19 1.34% REP - Jeff Sakwa 16 1.13% DEM - Joel Ferguson 685 48.17% DEM - Brian Mosallam 668 46.98% LIBR - Michael H Miller 10 0.70% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 5 0.35% USTAX - Stephen J Young 10 0.70% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 3 0.21%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 223 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 10 MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) Write-In 6 0.42% Total... 1,422 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 13 0.91% REP - Satish B Jasti 11 0.77% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 701 49.26% DEM - Kim Trent 677 47.58% USTAX - Robert Gale 6 0.42% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 2 0.14% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 4 0.28% GRN - Latham Redding 3 0.21% Write-In 6 0.42% Total... 1,423 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 16 2.18% DEM - John McColgan Jr 713 97.14% Write-In 5 0.68% Total... 734 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 714 98.21% Write-In 13 1.79% Total... 727 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 16 2.17% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 718 97.29% Write-In 4 0.54% Total... 738 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 11 1.49% DEM - Tim Novak 723 97.97% Write-In 4 0.54% Total... 738 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 727 99.18% Write-In 6 0.82% Total... 733 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 722 99.04% Write-In 7 0.96% Total... 729 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 4 (Final) REP - Sandra Klopf Lichon 19 2.57% DEM - Susan McInerney 712 96.48% Write-In 7 0.95% Total... 738 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 7 0.76% Connie Marie Kelley 344 37.31% Stephen Markman 78 8.46% Bridget Mary McCormack 388 42.08% Kerry L Morgan 25 2.71% Colleen O'Brien 65 7.05% Bob Roddis 5 0.54% Write-In 10 1.08% Total... 922 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 17 3.18% Shelia Johnson 463 86.54% Brian Zahra 47 8.79% Write-In 8 1.50% Total... 535 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 348 55.95% Peter D O'Connell 260 41.80% Write-In 14 2.25% Total... 622 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 390 95.82% Write-In 17 4.18% Total... 407 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 198 30.09% Darnell Jackson 447 67.93% Write-In 13 1.98% Total... 658 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 423 96.58% Write-In 15 3.42% Total... 438 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 496 96.12%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 224 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 10 JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Write-In 20 3.88% Total... 516 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 438 97.77% Write-In 10 2.23% Total... 448 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 221 52.37% Michael D Rowley 182 43.13% Write-In 19 4.50% Total... 422 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 410 96.02% Write-In 17 3.98% Total... 427 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 135 20.58% NO 521 79.42% Total... 656 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 566 84.73% NO 102 15.27% Total... 668 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 418 64.71% NO 228 35.29% Total... 646 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 558 85.32% NO 96 14.68% Total... 654 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 148 22.73% NO 503 77.27% Total... 651 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 471 72.46% NO 179 27.54% Total... 650 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 418 69.21% NO 186 30.79% Total... 604 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 483 78.03% NO 136 21.97% Total... 619 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 11 Registration & Turnout 1,804 Election Day Turnout 922 51.11% AV Polling Turnout 299 16.57% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,221 67.68% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 463 38.17% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 733 60.43% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 3 0.25% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 6 0.49% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.16% Write-In 6 0.49% Total... 1,213 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 366 30.50% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 807 67.25% LIBR - Scotty Boman 14 1.17% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 4 0.33% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 7 0.58% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.17% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,200 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 361 30.72% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 771 65.62% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 14 1.19% NPA - David Davenport 24 2.04% Write-In 5 0.43% Total... 1,175 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 407 34.88%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 225 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 11 STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 754 64.61% Write-In 6 0.51% Total... 1,167 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 347 16.52% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 359 17.09% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 665 31.65% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 598 28.46% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 30 1.43% USTAX - Karen Adams 39 1.86% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 25 1.19% GRN - Candace R Caveny 18 0.86% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 16 0.76% Write-In 4 0.19% Total... 2,101 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 336 16.21% REP - Robert Steele 335 16.16% DEM - Mark Bernstein 668 32.22% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 619 29.86% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 19 0.92% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 24 1.16% USTAX - Joe Sanger 18 0.87% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 16 0.77% GRN - Eric Borregard 14 0.68% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 22 1.06% Write-In 2 0.10% Total... 2,073 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 379 18.58% REP - Jeff Sakwa 328 16.08% DEM - Joel Ferguson 663 32.50% DEM - Brian Mosallam 579 28.38% LIBR - Michael H Miller 31 1.52% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 20 0.98% USTAX - Stephen J Young 18 0.88% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 20 0.98% Write-In 2 0.10% Total... 2,040 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 352 17.41% REP - Satish B Jasti 287 14.19% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 674 33.33% DEM - Kim Trent 612 30.27% USTAX - Robert Gale 30 1.48% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 24 1.19% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 24 1.19% GRN - Latham Redding 17 0.84% Write-In 2 0.10% Total... 2,022 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 315 27.18% DEM - John McColgan Jr 839 72.39% Write-In 5 0.43% Total... 1,159 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 954 97.65% Write-In 23 2.35% Total... 977 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 314 27.23% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 839 72.77% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,153 0.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 381 33.54% DEM - Tim Novak 749 65.93% Write-In 6 0.53% Total... 1,136 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 941 98.74% Write-In 12 1.26% Total... 953 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 923 98.51% Write-In 14 1.49% Total... 937 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 10 (Final) REP - John J Milne 397 35.26% DEM - Carl E Ruth 725 64.39%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 226 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 11 COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 10 (Final) Write-In 4 0.36% Total... 1,126 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 38 2.18% Connie Marie Kelley 368 21.08% Stephen Markman 375 21.48% Bridget Mary McCormack 554 31.73% Kerry L Morgan 49 2.81% Colleen O'Brien 307 17.58% Bob Roddis 47 2.69% Write-In 8 0.46% Total... 1,746 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 59 6.19% Shelia Johnson 489 51.31% Brian Zahra 398 41.76% Write-In 7 0.73% Total... 953 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 751 56.04% Peter D O'Connell 576 42.99% Write-In 13 0.97% Total... 1,340 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 787 98.50% Write-In 12 1.50% Total... 799 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 642 46.56% Darnell Jackson 725 52.57% Write-In 12 0.87% Total... 1,379 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 841 98.36% Write-In 14 1.64% Total... 855 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 889 98.78% Write-In 11 1.22% Total... 900 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 811 98.90% Write-In 9 1.10% Total... 820 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 264 34.83% Michael D Rowley 490 64.64% Write-In 4 0.53% Total... 758 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 769 98.72% Write-In 10 1.28% Total... 779 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 458 39.15% NO 712 60.85% Total... 1,170 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 621 52.32% NO 566 47.68% Total... 1,187 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 479 40.59% NO 701 59.41% Total... 1,180 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 627 53.36% NO 548 46.64% Total... 1,175 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 346 29.55% NO 825 70.45% Total... 1,171 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 608 51.39% NO 575 48.61% Total... 1,183 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 649 57.08%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 227 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 11 Saginaw City Schools (Final) NO 488 42.92% Total... 1,137 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 755 65.71% NO 394 34.29% Total... 1,149 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 12 Registration & Turnout 1,001 Election Day Turnout 482 48.15% AV Polling Turnout 113 11.29% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 595 59.44% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 199 33.61% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 383 64.70% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 4 0.68% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 1 0.17% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.34% Write-In 3 0.51% Total... 592 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 145 25.17% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 413 71.70% LIBR - Scotty Boman 12 2.08% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 2 0.35% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 1 0.17% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.35% Write-In 1 0.17% Total... 576 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 147 25.93% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 390 68.78% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 17 3.00% NPA - David Davenport 10 1.76% Write-In 3 0.53% Total... 567 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 169 30.07% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 390 69.40% Write-In 3 0.53% Total... 562 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 151 15.04% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 146 14.54% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 340 33.86% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 298 29.68% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 22 2.19% USTAX - Karen Adams 22 2.19% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 9 0.90% GRN - Candace R Caveny 9 0.90% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 3 0.30% Write-In 4 0.40% Total... 1,004 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 145 14.63% REP - Robert Steele 143 14.43% DEM - Mark Bernstein 334 33.70% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 301 30.37% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 14 1.41% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 16 1.61% USTAX - Joe Sanger 8 0.81% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 8 0.81% GRN - Eric Borregard 9 0.91% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 7 0.71% Write-In 6 0.61% Total... 991 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 166 16.89% REP - Jeff Sakwa 135 13.73% DEM - Joel Ferguson 327 33.27% DEM - Brian Mosallam 293 29.81% LIBR - Michael H Miller 24 2.44% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 12 1.22% USTAX - Stephen J Young 16 1.63% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 8 0.81% Write-In 2 0.20% Total... 983 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 146 15.15% REP - Satish B Jasti 119 12.34%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 228 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 12 MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 334 34.65% DEM - Kim Trent 313 32.47% USTAX - Robert Gale 16 1.66% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 9 0.93% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 12 1.24% GRN - Latham Redding 8 0.83% Write-In 7 0.73% Total... 964 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 145 25.85% DEM - John McColgan Jr 412 73.44% Write-In 4 0.71% Total... 561 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 464 98.10% Write-In 9 1.90% Total... 473 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 134 24.10% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 420 75.54% Write-In 2 0.36% Total... 556 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 157 28.55% DEM - Tim Novak 391 71.09% Write-In 2 0.36% Total... 550 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 465 97.69% Write-In 11 2.31% Total... 476 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 457 97.65% Write-In 11 2.35% Total... 468 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 10 (Final) REP - John J Milne 167 30.87% DEM - Carl E Ruth 372 68.76% Write-In 2 0.37% Total... 541 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 22 2.59% Connie Marie Kelley 173 20.35% Stephen Markman 147 17.29% Bridget Mary McCormack 278 32.71% Kerry L Morgan 45 5.29% Colleen O'Brien 154 18.12% Bob Roddis 25 2.94% Write-In 6 0.71% Total... 850 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 43 9.03% Shelia Johnson 211 44.33% Brian Zahra 217 45.59% Write-In 5 1.05% Total... 476 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 348 53.95% Peter D O'Connell 284 44.03% Write-In 13 2.02% Total... 645 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 372 96.88% Write-In 12 3.13% Total... 384 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 314 47.94% Darnell Jackson 331 50.53% Write-In 10 1.53% Total... 655 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 397 96.83% Write-In 13 3.17% Total... 410 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 422 98.60% Write-In 6 1.40% Total... 428 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 372 96.12%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 229 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 12 DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) Write-In 15 3.88% Total... 387 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 174 45.31% Michael D Rowley 200 52.08% Write-In 10 2.60% Total... 384 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 359 97.03% Write-In 11 2.97% Total... 370 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 198 36.20% NO 349 63.80% Total... 547 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 286 51.25% NO 272 48.75% Total... 558 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 218 39.78% NO 330 60.22% Total... 548 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 301 55.33% NO 243 44.67% Total... 544 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 178 32.30% NO 373 67.70% Total... 551 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 296 54.11% NO 251 45.89% Total... 547 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 303 56.95% NO 229 43.05% Total... 532 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 341 63.50% NO 196 36.50% Total... 537 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 13 Registration & Turnout 2,267 Election Day Turnout 1,013 44.68% AV Polling Turnout 237 10.45% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,250 55.14% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 395 31.70% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 830 66.61% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 5 0.40% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 7 0.56% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 9 0.72% Total... 1,246 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 294 23.88% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 894 72.62% LIBR - Scotty Boman 14 1.14% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 12 0.97% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 9 0.73% NATLAW - John D Litle 8 0.65% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,231 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 286 23.71% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 872 72.31% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 17 1.41% NPA - David Davenport 27 2.24% Write-In 4 0.33% Total... 1,206 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 338 28.33% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 846 70.91% Write-In 9 0.75% Total... 1,193 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 230 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 13 MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 293 13.42% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 304 13.92% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 746 34.16% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 683 31.27% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 46 2.11% USTAX - Karen Adams 43 1.97% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 22 1.01% GRN - Candace R Caveny 22 1.01% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 19 0.87% Write-In 6 0.27% Total... 2,184 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 284 13.16% REP - Robert Steele 265 12.28% DEM - Mark Bernstein 757 35.08% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 696 32.25% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 19 0.88% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 22 1.02% USTAX - Joe Sanger 27 1.25% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 26 1.20% GRN - Eric Borregard 29 1.34% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 27 1.25% Write-In 6 0.28% Total... 2,158 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 322 15.05% REP - Jeff Sakwa 265 12.38% DEM - Joel Ferguson 741 34.63% DEM - Brian Mosallam 668 31.21% LIBR - Michael H Miller 33 1.54% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 37 1.73% USTAX - Stephen J Young 30 1.40% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 36 1.68% Write-In 8 0.37% Total... 2,140 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 290 13.85% REP - Satish B Jasti 237 11.32% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 754 36.01% DEM - Kim Trent 681 32.52% USTAX - Robert Gale 45 2.15% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 30 1.43% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 30 1.43% GRN - Latham Redding 20 0.96% Write-In 7 0.33% Total... 2,094 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 306 25.50% DEM - John McColgan Jr 888 74.00% Write-In 6 0.50% Total... 1,200 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,024 98.27% Write-In 18 1.73% Total... 1,042 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 282 23.82% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 899 75.93% Write-In 3 0.25% Total... 1,184 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 332 28.06% DEM - Tim Novak 845 71.43% Write-In 6 0.51% Total... 1,183 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,021 98.93% Write-In 11 1.07% Total... 1,032 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,009 98.73% Write-In 13 1.27% Total... 1,022 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 2 (Final) REP - Alex Boese 347 30.12% DEM - Chuck Stack 799 69.36% Write-In 6 0.52% Total... 1,152 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 64 3.59% Connie Marie Kelley 418 23.43%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 231 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 13 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Stephen Markman 291 16.31% Bridget Mary McCormack 459 25.73% Kerry L Morgan 106 5.94% Colleen O'Brien 382 21.41% Bob Roddis 53 2.97% Write-In 11 0.62% Total... 1,784 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 102 10.13% Shelia Johnson 538 53.43% Brian Zahra 356 35.35% Write-In 11 1.09% Total... 1,007 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 734 55.31% Peter D O'Connell 573 43.18% Write-In 20 1.51% Total... 1,327 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 831 97.88% Write-In 18 2.12% Total... 849 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 608 43.99% Darnell Jackson 758 54.85% Write-In 16 1.16% Total... 1,382 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 879 98.32% Write-In 15 1.68% Total... 894 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 922 98.72% Write-In 12 1.28% Total... 934 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 829 97.41% Write-In 22 2.59% Total... 851 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 332 39.48% Michael D Rowley 491 58.38% Write-In 18 2.14% Total... 841 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 822 97.97% Write-In 17 2.03% Total... 839 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 447 37.95% NO 731 62.05% Total... 1,178 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 649 54.63% NO 539 45.37% Total... 1,188 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 528 44.26% NO 665 55.74% Total... 1,193 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 680 57.63% NO 500 42.37% Total... 1,180 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 353 29.89% NO 828 70.11% Total... 1,181 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 677 56.89% NO 513 43.11% Total... 1,190 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 636 55.45% NO 511 44.55% Total... 1,147 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 766 66.26% NO 390 33.74% Total... 1,156 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 232 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 14 Registration & Turnout 2,247 Election Day Turnout 792 35.25% AV Polling Turnout 139 6.19% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 931 41.43% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 168 18.18% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 734 79.44% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 5 0.54% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 9 0.97% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 2 0.22% Write-In 6 0.65% Total... 924 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 125 13.90% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 748 83.20% LIBR - Scotty Boman 14 1.56% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 3 0.33% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.44% NATLAW - John D Litle 5 0.56% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 899 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 131 14.77% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 716 80.72% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 16 1.80% NPA - David Davenport 21 2.37% Write-In 3 0.34% Total... 887 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 141 15.97% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 740 83.81% Write-In 2 0.23% Total... 883 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 134 8.16% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 137 8.34% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 652 39.71% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 618 37.64% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 25 1.52% USTAX - Karen Adams 30 1.83% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 14 0.85% GRN - Candace R Caveny 13 0.79% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 14 0.85% Write-In 5 0.30% Total... 1,642 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 120 7.33% REP - Robert Steele 134 8.19% DEM - Mark Bernstein 657 40.13% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 632 38.61% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 11 0.67% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 15 0.92% USTAX - Joe Sanger 20 1.22% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 11 0.67% GRN - Eric Borregard 14 0.86% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 18 1.10% Write-In 5 0.31% Total... 1,637 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 148 9.15% REP - Jeff Sakwa 113 6.98% DEM - Joel Ferguson 665 41.10% DEM - Brian Mosallam 613 37.89% LIBR - Michael H Miller 21 1.30% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 13 0.80% USTAX - Stephen J Young 18 1.11% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 18 1.11% Write-In 9 0.56% Total... 1,618 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 123 7.68% REP - Satish B Jasti 111 6.93% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 673 42.01% DEM - Kim Trent 624 38.95% USTAX - Robert Gale 18 1.12% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 15 0.94% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 14 0.87% GRN - Latham Redding 16 1.00% Write-In 8 0.50% Total... 1,602 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 233 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 14 PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 142 16.15% DEM - John McColgan Jr 731 83.16% Write-In 6 0.68% Total... 879 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 779 97.62% Write-In 19 2.38% Total... 798 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 141 16.19% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 725 83.24% Write-In 5 0.57% Total... 871 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 137 15.82% DEM - Tim Novak 725 83.72% Write-In 4 0.46% Total... 866 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 783 98.86% Write-In 9 1.14% Total... 792 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 782 98.74% Write-In 10 1.26% Total... 792 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 10 (Final) REP - John J Milne 161 18.66% DEM - Carl E Ruth 697 80.76% Write-In 5 0.58% Total... 863 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 28 2.18% Connie Marie Kelley 336 26.15% Stephen Markman 184 14.32% Bridget Mary McCormack 414 32.22% Kerry L Morgan 38 2.96% Colleen O'Brien 239 18.60% Bob Roddis 36 2.80% Write-In 10 0.78% Total... 1,285 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 27 3.70% Shelia Johnson 478 65.48% Brian Zahra 216 29.59% Write-In 9 1.23% Total... 730 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 532 56.42% Peter D O'Connell 393 41.68% Write-In 18 1.91% Total... 943 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 592 95.64% Write-In 27 4.36% Total... 619 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 398 40.32% Darnell Jackson 566 57.35% Write-In 23 2.33% Total... 987 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 627 96.46% Write-In 23 3.54% Total... 650 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 663 96.79% Write-In 22 3.21% Total... 685 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 609 97.13% Write-In 18 2.87% Total... 627 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 282 44.76% Michael D Rowley 337 53.49% Write-In 11 1.75% Total... 630 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 600 97.09%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 234 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 14 DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Write-In 18 2.91% Total... 618 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 284 33.69% NO 559 66.31% Total... 843 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 523 60.25% NO 345 39.75% Total... 868 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 414 48.31% NO 443 51.69% Total... 857 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 588 68.53% NO 270 31.47% Total... 858 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 292 34.43% NO 556 65.57% Total... 848 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 541 62.69% NO 322 37.31% Total... 863 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 514 61.93% NO 316 38.07% Total... 830 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 578 69.30% NO 256 30.70% Total... 834 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 15 Registration & Turnout 2,583 Election Day Turnout 1,085 42.01% AV Polling Turnout 261 10.10% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,346 52.11% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 395 29.52% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 929 69.43% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 4 0.30% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 6 0.45% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 4 0.30% Total... 1,338 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 305 23.09% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 986 74.64% LIBR - Scotty Boman 16 1.21% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 2 0.15% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 9 0.68% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.15% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,321 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 312 24.06% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 942 72.63% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 19 1.46% NPA - David Davenport 23 1.77% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,297 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 341 26.19% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 957 73.50% Write-In 4 0.31% Total... 1,302 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 305 12.81% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 295 12.39% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 845 35.49% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 776 32.59% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 43 1.81% USTAX - Karen Adams 50 2.10% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 11 0.46% GRN - Candace R Caveny 29 1.22% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 25 1.05%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 235 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 15 MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) Write-In 2 0.08% Total... 2,381 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 299 12.73% REP - Robert Steele 287 12.22% DEM - Mark Bernstein 850 36.20% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 781 33.26% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 30 1.28% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 26 1.11% USTAX - Joe Sanger 18 0.77% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 15 0.64% GRN - Eric Borregard 18 0.77% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 21 0.89% Write-In 3 0.13% Total... 2,348 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 321 13.82% REP - Jeff Sakwa 290 12.49% DEM - Joel Ferguson 843 36.30% DEM - Brian Mosallam 761 32.77% LIBR - Michael H Miller 41 1.77% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 18 0.78% USTAX - Stephen J Young 17 0.73% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 28 1.21% Write-In 3 0.13% Total... 2,322 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 295 12.78% REP - Satish B Jasti 264 11.44% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 866 37.52% DEM - Kim Trent 782 33.88% USTAX - Robert Gale 28 1.21% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 18 0.78% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 29 1.26% GRN - Latham Redding 21 0.91% Write-In 5 0.22% Total... 2,308 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 312 24.28% DEM - John McColgan Jr 966 75.18% Write-In 7 0.54% Total... 1,285 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,097 97.68% Write-In 26 2.32% Total... 1,123 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 295 23.08% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 977 76.45% Write-In 6 0.47% Total... 1,278 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 320 25.14% DEM - Tim Novak 945 74.23% Write-In 8 0.63% Total... 1,273 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,092 98.73% Write-In 14 1.27% Total... 1,106 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,081 98.90% Write-In 12 1.10% Total... 1,093 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 10 (Final) REP - John J Milne 348 27.68% DEM - Carl E Ruth 903 71.84% Write-In 6 0.48% Total... 1,257 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 79 4.28% Connie Marie Kelley 445 24.13% Stephen Markman 351 19.03% Bridget Mary McCormack 530 28.74% Kerry L Morgan 69 3.74% Colleen O'Brien 309 16.76% Bob Roddis 48 2.60% Write-In 13 0.70% Total... 1,844 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 105 10.04%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 236 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 15 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Shelia Johnson 513 49.04% Brian Zahra 420 40.15% Write-In 8 0.76% Total... 1,046 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 781 55.79% Peter D O'Connell 594 42.43% Write-In 25 1.79% Total... 1,400 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 852 97.59% Write-In 21 2.41% Total... 873 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 635 44.25% Darnell Jackson 791 55.12% Write-In 9 0.63% Total... 1,435 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 890 97.27% Write-In 25 2.73% Total... 915 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 945 98.34% Write-In 16 1.66% Total... 961 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 884 98.00% Write-In 18 2.00% Total... 902 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 327 37.33% Michael D Rowley 530 60.50% Write-In 19 2.17% Total... 876 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 853 97.93% Write-In 18 2.07% Total... 871 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 446 36.20% NO 786 63.80% Total... 1,232 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 681 54.74% NO 563 45.26% Total... 1,244 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 517 41.96% NO 715 58.04% Total... 1,232 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 713 57.59% NO 525 42.41% Total... 1,238 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 350 28.59% NO 874 71.41% Total... 1,224 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 666 53.97% NO 568 46.03% Total... 1,234 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 666 55.69% NO 530 44.31% Total... 1,196 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 766 63.31% NO 444 36.69% Total... 1,210 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 16 Registration & Turnout 2,805 Election Day Turnout 1,299 46.31% AV Polling Turnout 312 11.12% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,611 57.43% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 540 33.73%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 237 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 16 PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 1,039 64.90% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 7 0.44% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 5 0.31% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 5 0.31% Write-In 5 0.31% Total... 1,601 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 415 26.32% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 1,108 70.26% LIBR - Scotty Boman 25 1.59% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 11 0.70% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 10 0.63% NATLAW - John D Litle 6 0.38% Write-In 2 0.13% Total... 1,577 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 389 25.38% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 1,079 70.38% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 26 1.70% NPA - David Davenport 38 2.48% Write-In 1 0.07% Total... 1,533 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 459 30.04% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 1,061 69.44% Write-In 8 0.52% Total... 1,528 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 406 14.93% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 390 14.34% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 913 33.57% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 836 30.74% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 39 1.43% USTAX - Karen Adams 56 2.06% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 22 0.81% GRN - Candace R Caveny 31 1.14% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 20 0.74% Write-In 7 0.26% Total... 2,720 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 388 14.26% REP - Robert Steele 395 14.52% DEM - Mark Bernstein 943 34.67% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 846 31.10% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 27 0.99% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 16 0.59% USTAX - Joe Sanger 27 0.99% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 18 0.66% GRN - Eric Borregard 26 0.96% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 29 1.07% Write-In 5 0.18% Total... 2,720 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 446 16.67% REP - Jeff Sakwa 377 14.09% DEM - Joel Ferguson 913 34.12% DEM - Brian Mosallam 800 29.90% LIBR - Michael H Miller 44 1.64% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 26 0.97% USTAX - Stephen J Young 30 1.12% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 32 1.20% Write-In 8 0.30% Total... 2,676 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 378 14.48% REP - Satish B Jasti 329 12.61% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 940 36.02% DEM - Kim Trent 842 32.26% USTAX - Robert Gale 34 1.30% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 22 0.84% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 28 1.07% GRN - Latham Redding 27 1.03% Write-In 10 0.38% Total... 2,610 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 393 25.91% DEM - John McColgan Jr 1,114 73.43% Write-In 10 0.66% Total... 1,517 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,283 97.94%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 238 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 16 SHERIFF (Final) Write-In 27 2.06% Total... 1,310 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 369 24.45% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 1,135 75.22% Write-In 5 0.33% Total... 1,509 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 446 29.85% DEM - Tim Novak 1,041 69.68% Write-In 7 0.47% Total... 1,494 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,253 98.74% Write-In 16 1.26% Total... 1,269 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 1,233 98.88% Write-In 14 1.12% Total... 1,247 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 11 (Final) REP - David Bechard 347 23.00% DEM - Michael J Hanley 1,012 67.06% NPA - John H Cammin 147 9.74% Write-In 3 0.20% Total... 1,509 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 84 3.83% Connie Marie Kelley 526 23.96% Stephen Markman 482 21.96% Bridget Mary McCormack 605 27.56% Kerry L Morgan 82 3.74% Colleen O'Brien 356 16.22% Bob Roddis 49 2.23% Write-In 11 0.50% Total... 2,195 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 125 10.08% Shelia Johnson 607 48.95% Brian Zahra 500 40.32% Write-In 8 0.65% Total... 1,240 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 962 57.57% Peter D O'Connell 687 41.11% Write-In 22 1.32% Total... 1,671 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 1,022 97.24% Write-In 29 2.76% Total... 1,051 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 788 46.03% Darnell Jackson 903 52.75% Write-In 21 1.23% Total... 1,712 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 1,085 97.75% Write-In 25 2.25% Total... 1,110 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 1,137 98.19% Write-In 21 1.81% Total... 1,158 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 1,040 97.93% Write-In 22 2.07% Total... 1,062 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 418 40.43% Michael D Rowley 598 57.83% Write-In 18 1.74% Total... 1,034 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 998 98.13% Write-In 19 1.87% Total... 1,017 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 556 36.89%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 239 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 16 State Proposal 12-1 (Final) NO 951 63.11% Total... 1,507 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 762 49.74% NO 770 50.26% Total... 1,532 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 638 42.17% NO 875 57.83% Total... 1,513 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 798 52.95% NO 709 47.05% Total... 1,507 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 488 32.62% NO 1,008 67.38% Total... 1,496 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 792 52.17% NO 726 47.83% Total... 1,518 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 830 56.50% NO 639 43.50% Total... 1,469 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 964 65.00% NO 519 35.00% Total... 1,483 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 17 Registration & Turnout 1,682 Election Day Turnout 868 51.61% AV Polling Turnout 187 11.12% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,055 62.72% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 403 38.38% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 610 58.10% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 4 0.38% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 10 0.95% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 5 0.48% Write-In 18 1.71% Total... 1,050 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 318 31.09% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 664 64.91% LIBR - Scotty Boman 23 2.25% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 2 0.20% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 12 1.17% NATLAW - John D Litle 2 0.20% Write-In 2 0.20% Total... 1,023 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 322 32.33% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 620 62.25% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 24 2.41% NPA - David Davenport 28 2.81% Write-In 2 0.20% Total... 996 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 344 34.92% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 636 64.57% Write-In 5 0.51% Total... 985 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 306 17.26% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 312 17.60% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 541 30.51% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 473 26.68% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 54 3.05% USTAX - Karen Adams 32 1.80% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 10 0.56% GRN - Candace R Caveny 23 1.30% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 20 1.13% Write-In 2 0.11% Total... 1,773 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 296 16.97%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 240 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 17 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Robert Steele 285 16.34% DEM - Mark Bernstein 549 31.48% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 481 27.58% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 31 1.78% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 28 1.61% USTAX - Joe Sanger 9 0.52% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 9 0.52% GRN - Eric Borregard 33 1.89% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 18 1.03% Write-In 5 0.29% Total... 1,744 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 331 19.13% REP - Jeff Sakwa 279 16.13% DEM - Joel Ferguson 549 31.73% DEM - Brian Mosallam 466 26.94% LIBR - Michael H Miller 44 2.54% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 13 0.75% USTAX - Stephen J Young 13 0.75% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 27 1.56% Write-In 8 0.46% Total... 1,730 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 297 17.59% REP - Satish B Jasti 251 14.87% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 542 32.11% DEM - Kim Trent 500 29.62% USTAX - Robert Gale 19 1.13% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 19 1.13% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 31 1.84% GRN - Latham Redding 24 1.42% Write-In 5 0.30% Total... 1,688 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 309 31.31% DEM - John McColgan Jr 675 68.39% Write-In 3 0.30% Total... 987 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 777 97.49% Write-In 20 2.51% Total... 797 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 280 28.75% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 690 70.84% Write-In 4 0.41% Total... 974 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 340 35.02% DEM - Tim Novak 627 64.57% Write-In 4 0.41% Total... 971 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 765 98.71% Write-In 10 1.29% Total... 775 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 748 98.55% Write-In 11 1.45% Total... 759 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 11 (Final) REP - David Bechard 281 28.79% DEM - Michael J Hanley 626 64.14% NPA - John H Cammin 66 6.76% Write-In 3 0.31% Total... 976 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 30 2.09% Connie Marie Kelley 358 24.91% Stephen Markman 318 22.13% Bridget Mary McCormack 387 26.93% Kerry L Morgan 50 3.48% Colleen O'Brien 243 16.91% Bob Roddis 42 2.92% Write-In 9 0.63% Total... 1,437 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 53 6.62% Shelia Johnson 390 48.69% Brian Zahra 352 43.95%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 241 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 17 JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Write-In 6 0.75% Total... 801 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 609 55.36% Peter D O'Connell 482 43.82% Write-In 9 0.82% Total... 1,100 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 626 98.74% Write-In 8 1.26% Total... 634 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 536 47.35% Darnell Jackson 585 51.68% Write-In 11 0.97% Total... 1,132 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 688 98.85% Write-In 8 1.15% Total... 696 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 715 99.03% Write-In 7 0.97% Total... 722 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 646 98.78% Write-In 8 1.22% Total... 654 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 232 37.18% Michael D Rowley 383 61.38% Write-In 9 1.44% Total... 624 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 612 98.71% Write-In 8 1.29% Total... 620 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 390 39.51% NO 597 60.49% Total... 987 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 454 45.17% NO 551 54.83% Total... 1,005 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 387 38.97% NO 606 61.03% Total... 993 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 461 46.80% NO 524 53.20% Total... 985 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 260 26.42% NO 724 73.58% Total... 984 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 425 42.67% NO 571 57.33% Total... 996 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 546 57.23% NO 408 42.77% Total... 954 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 621 65.09% NO 333 34.91% Total... 954 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 18 Registration & Turnout 1,226 Election Day Turnout 473 38.58% AV Polling Turnout 54 4.40% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 2 0.16% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 529 43.15% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 118 22.31% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 393 74.29% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 5 0.95%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 242 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 18 PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 4 0.76% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 0 0.00% Write-In 9 1.70% Total... 529 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 91 17.43% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 403 77.20% LIBR - Scotty Boman 13 2.49% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 3 0.57% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 8 1.53% NATLAW - John D Litle 3 0.57% Write-In 1 0.19% Total... 522 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 92 17.73% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 402 77.46% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 12 2.31% NPA - David Davenport 12 2.31% Write-In 1 0.19% Total... 519 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 105 20.35% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 403 78.10% Write-In 8 1.55% Total... 516 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 95 9.76% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 107 11.00% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 351 36.07% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 342 35.15% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 22 2.26% USTAX - Karen Adams 23 2.36% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 8 0.82% GRN - Candace R Caveny 10 1.03% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 10 1.03% Write-In 5 0.51% Total... 973 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 98 10.18% REP - Robert Steele 90 9.35% DEM - Mark Bernstein 361 37.49% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 338 35.10% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 12 1.25% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 13 1.35% USTAX - Joe Sanger 13 1.35% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 5 0.52% GRN - Eric Borregard 14 1.45% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 13 1.35% Write-In 6 0.62% Total... 963 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 103 10.83% REP - Jeff Sakwa 88 9.25% DEM - Joel Ferguson 370 38.91% DEM - Brian Mosallam 328 34.49% LIBR - Michael H Miller 19 2.00% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 11 1.16% USTAX - Stephen J Young 12 1.26% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 14 1.47% Write-In 6 0.63% Total... 951 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 101 10.60% REP - Satish B Jasti 82 8.60% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 368 38.61% DEM - Kim Trent 343 35.99% USTAX - Robert Gale 15 1.57% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 12 1.26% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 15 1.57% GRN - Latham Redding 12 1.26% Write-In 5 0.52% Total... 953 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 107 20.86% DEM - John McColgan Jr 402 78.36% Write-In 4 0.78% Total... 513 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 448 97.39% Write-In 12 2.61% Total... 460 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 243 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 18 CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 98 19.29% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 405 79.72% Write-In 5 0.98% Total... 508 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 106 20.91% DEM - Tim Novak 398 78.50% Write-In 3 0.59% Total... 507 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 450 97.40% Write-In 12 2.60% Total... 462 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 449 97.82% Write-In 10 2.18% Total... 459 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 10 (Final) REP - John J Milne 121 23.96% DEM - Carl E Ruth 375 74.26% Write-In 9 1.78% Total... 505 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 25 3.26% Connie Marie Kelley 179 23.31% Stephen Markman 135 17.58% Bridget Mary McCormack 242 31.51% Kerry L Morgan 37 4.82% Colleen O'Brien 113 14.71% Bob Roddis 24 3.13% Write-In 13 1.69% Total... 768 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 46 10.45% Shelia Johnson 228 51.82% Brian Zahra 154 35.00% Write-In 12 2.73% Total... 440 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 297 53.51% Peter D O'Connell 248 44.68% Write-In 10 1.80% Total... 555 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 366 95.81% Write-In 16 4.19% Total... 382 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 250 42.37% Darnell Jackson 330 55.93% Write-In 10 1.69% Total... 590 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 382 96.22% Write-In 15 3.78% Total... 397 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 399 96.38% Write-In 15 3.62% Total... 414 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 373 96.63% Write-In 13 3.37% Total... 386 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 186 48.95% Michael D Rowley 184 48.42% Write-In 10 2.63% Total... 380 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 368 96.08% Write-In 15 3.92% Total... 383 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 170 35.42% NO 310 64.58% Total... 480 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 277 57.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 244 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 18 State Proposal 12-2 (Final) NO 209 43.00% Total... 486 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 221 46.23% NO 257 53.77% Total... 478 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 287 60.17% NO 190 39.83% Total... 477 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 140 28.87% NO 345 71.13% Total... 485 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 253 52.71% NO 227 47.29% Total... 480 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 279 58.74% NO 196 41.26% Total... 475 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 320 67.80% NO 152 32.20% Total... 472 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 19 Registration & Turnout 2,354 Election Day Turnout 1,072 45.54% AV Polling Turnout 256 10.88% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,328 56.41% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 447 33.84% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 856 64.80% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 3 0.23% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 4 0.30% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 3 0.23% Write-In 8 0.61% Total... 1,321 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 353 27.09% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 909 69.76% LIBR - Scotty Boman 22 1.69% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 5 0.38% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 8 0.61% NATLAW - John D Litle 5 0.38% Write-In 1 0.08% Total... 1,303 100.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 357 27.89% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 882 68.91% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 17 1.33% NPA - David Davenport 21 1.64% Write-In 3 0.23% Total... 1,280 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 386 30.61% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 864 68.52% Write-In 11 0.87% Total... 1,261 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 343 14.79% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 337 14.53% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 771 33.25% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 707 30.49% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 31 1.34% USTAX - Karen Adams 58 2.50% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 27 1.16% GRN - Candace R Caveny 25 1.08% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 17 0.73% Write-In 3 0.13% Total... 2,319 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 335 14.87% REP - Robert Steele 319 14.16% DEM - Mark Bernstein 751 33.33% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 706 31.34% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 17 0.75%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 245 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 19 MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 21 0.93% USTAX - Joe Sanger 27 1.20% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 21 0.93% GRN - Eric Borregard 19 0.84% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 27 1.20% Write-In 10 0.44% Total... 2,253 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 367 16.31% REP - Jeff Sakwa 320 14.22% DEM - Joel Ferguson 764 33.96% DEM - Brian Mosallam 673 29.91% LIBR - Michael H Miller 36 1.60% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 18 0.80% USTAX - Stephen J Young 32 1.42% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 27 1.20% Write-In 13 0.58% Total... 2,250 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 334 15.14% REP - Satish B Jasti 285 12.92% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 772 35.00% DEM - Kim Trent 687 31.14% USTAX - Robert Gale 29 1.31% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 31 1.41% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 35 1.59% GRN - Latham Redding 21 0.95% Write-In 12 0.54% Total... 2,206 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 318 25.22% DEM - John McColgan Jr 935 74.15% Write-In 8 0.63% Total... 1,261 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 1,025 98.18% Write-In 19 1.82% Total... 1,044 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 302 24.18% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 939 75.18% Write-In 8 0.64% Total... 1,249 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 361 29.21% DEM - Tim Novak 871 70.47% Write-In 4 0.32% Total... 1,236 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 1,018 98.45% Write-In 16 1.55% Total... 1,034 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 995 98.32% Write-In 17 1.68% Total... 1,012 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 11 (Final) REP - David Bechard 300 24.17% DEM - Michael J Hanley 843 67.93% NPA - John H Cammin 93 7.49% Write-In 5 0.40% Total... 1,241 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 43 2.38% Connie Marie Kelley 369 20.47% Stephen Markman 304 16.86% Bridget Mary McCormack 558 30.95% Kerry L Morgan 84 4.66% Colleen O'Brien 377 20.91% Bob Roddis 51 2.83% Write-In 17 0.94% Total... 1,803 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 105 10.55% Shelia Johnson 506 50.85% Brian Zahra 373 37.49% Write-In 11 1.11% Total... 995 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 746 56.26% Peter D O'Connell 564 42.53%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 246 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 19 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Write-In 16 1.21% Total... 1,326 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 784 97.03% Write-In 24 2.97% Total... 808 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 591 44.64% Darnell Jackson 718 54.23% Write-In 15 1.13% Total... 1,324 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 830 97.76% Write-In 19 2.24% Total... 849 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 865 98.30% Write-In 15 1.70% Total... 880 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 811 98.18% Write-In 15 1.82% Total... 826 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 288 36.73% Michael D Rowley 481 61.35% Write-In 15 1.91% Total... 784 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 757 97.80% Write-In 17 2.20% Total... 774 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 470 37.96% NO 768 62.04% Total... 1,238 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 637 50.84% NO 616 49.16% Total... 1,253 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 473 37.84% NO 777 62.16% Total... 1,250 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 688 55.00% NO 563 45.00% Total... 1,251 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 379 30.54% NO 862 69.46% Total... 1,241 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 624 49.80% NO 629 50.20% Total... 1,253 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 612 50.96% NO 589 49.04% Total... 1,201 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 729 60.25% NO 481 39.75% Total... 1,210 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 20 Registration & Turnout 2,208 Election Day Turnout 979 44.34% AV Polling Turnout 125 5.66% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 1,104 50.00% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 224 20.44% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 848 77.37% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 8 0.73% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 5 0.46% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 4 0.36% Write-In 7 0.64% Total... 1,096 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 247 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 20 US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 155 14.57% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 858 80.64% LIBR - Scotty Boman 27 2.54% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 14 1.32% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 6 0.56% NATLAW - John D Litle 4 0.38% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 1,064 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 175 16.59% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 822 77.91% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 30 2.84% NPA - David Davenport 25 2.37% Write-In 3 0.28% Total... 1,055 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 196 18.81% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 842 80.81% Write-In 4 0.38% Total... 1,042 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 173 8.92% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 159 8.20% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 746 38.45% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 703 36.24% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 40 2.06% USTAX - Karen Adams 41 2.11% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 20 1.03% GRN - Candace R Caveny 36 1.86% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 14 0.72% Write-In 8 0.41% Total... 1,940 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 169 8.77% REP - Robert Steele 155 8.05% DEM - Mark Bernstein 765 39.72% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 703 36.50% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 15 0.78% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 16 0.83% USTAX - Joe Sanger 20 1.04% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 27 1.40% GRN - Eric Borregard 20 1.04% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 27 1.40% Write-In 9 0.47% Total... 1,926 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 183 9.54% REP - Jeff Sakwa 152 7.92% DEM - Joel Ferguson 761 39.66% DEM - Brian Mosallam 699 36.43% LIBR - Michael H Miller 43 2.24% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 26 1.35% USTAX - Stephen J Young 30 1.56% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 18 0.94% Write-In 7 0.36% Total... 1,919 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 164 8.69% REP - Satish B Jasti 144 7.63% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 762 40.36% DEM - Kim Trent 716 37.92% USTAX - Robert Gale 29 1.54% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 20 1.06% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 22 1.17% GRN - Latham Redding 24 1.27% Write-In 7 0.37% Total... 1,888 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 189 18.14% DEM - John McColgan Jr 847 81.29% Write-In 6 0.58% Total... 1,042 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 928 97.48% Write-In 24 2.52% Total... 952 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 185 17.86% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 847 81.76% Write-In 4 0.39% Total... 1,036 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 248 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 20 TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 188 18.25% DEM - Tim Novak 836 81.17% Write-In 6 0.58% Total... 1,030 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 929 98.83% Write-In 11 1.17% Total... 940 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 919 98.61% Write-In 13 1.39% Total... 932 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 4 (Final) REP - Sandra Klopf Lichon 188 18.32% DEM - Susan McInerney 831 80.99% Write-In 7 0.68% Total... 1,026 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 69 4.64% Connie Marie Kelley 352 23.67% Stephen Markman 220 14.79% Bridget Mary McCormack 419 28.18% Kerry L Morgan 100 6.72% Colleen O'Brien 275 18.49% Bob Roddis 39 2.62% Write-In 13 0.87% Total... 1,487 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 67 7.80% Shelia Johnson 507 59.02% Brian Zahra 272 31.66% Write-In 13 1.51% Total... 859 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 630 56.15% Peter D O'Connell 466 41.53% Write-In 26 2.32% Total... 1,122 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 699 95.23% Write-In 35 4.77% Total... 734 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 467 41.62% Darnell Jackson 637 56.77% Write-In 18 1.60% Total... 1,122 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 712 95.83% Write-In 31 4.17% Total... 743 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 775 96.51% Write-In 28 3.49% Total... 803 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 718 95.86% Write-In 31 4.14% Total... 749 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 355 47.78% Michael D Rowley 367 49.39% Write-In 21 2.83% Total... 743 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 701 95.90% Write-In 30 4.10% Total... 731 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 347 34.53% NO 658 65.47% Total... 1,005 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 611 59.90% NO 409 40.10% Total... 1,020 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 473 47.11% NO 531 52.89% Total... 1,004 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 249 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 20 State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 644 64.08% NO 361 35.92% Total... 1,005 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 356 35.18% NO 656 64.82% Total... 1,012 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 622 61.22% NO 394 38.78% Total... 1,016 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 554 57.00% NO 418 43.00% Total... 972 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 626 63.94% NO 353 36.06% Total... 979 100.00% City of Saginaw Precinct 21 Registration & Turnout 1,347 Election Day Turnout 560 41.57% AV Polling Turnout 99 7.35% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 659 48.92% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (Final) REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 169 25.80% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 478 72.98% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 2 0.31% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 3 0.46% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.15% Write-In 2 0.31% Total... 655 100.00% US SENATOR (Final) REP - Pete Hoekstra 138 21.53% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 480 74.88% LIBR - Scotty Boman 10 1.56% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 5 0.78% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.62% NATLAW - John D Litle 4 0.62% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 641 0.00% US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST (Final) REP - Jim Slezak 133 20.88% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 480 75.35% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 6 0.94% NPA - David Davenport 17 2.67% Write-In 1 0.16% Total... 637 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST (Final) REP - Jeff Baker 157 24.65% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 475 74.57% Write-In 5 0.78% Total... 637 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION (Final) REP - Todd A Courser 129 11.38% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 126 11.11% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 408 35.98% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 374 32.98% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 24 2.12% USTAX - Karen Adams 31 2.73% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 8 0.71% GRN - Candace R Caveny 14 1.23% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 16 1.41% Write-In 4 0.35% Total... 1,134 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS (Final) REP - Dan Horning 126 11.23% REP - Robert Steele 117 10.43% DEM - Mark Bernstein 419 37.34% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 392 34.94% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 11 0.98% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 8 0.71% USTAX - Joe Sanger 11 0.98% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 8 0.71% GRN - Eric Borregard 11 0.98% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 14 1.25% Write-In 5 0.45% Total... 1,122 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 250 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 21 MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES (Final) REP - Melaine Foster 142 12.89% REP - Jeff Sakwa 116 10.53% DEM - Joel Ferguson 418 37.93% DEM - Brian Mosallam 372 33.76% LIBR - Michael H Miller 17 1.54% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 8 0.73% USTAX - Stephen J Young 10 0.91% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 13 1.18% Write-In 6 0.54% Total... 1,102 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS (Final) REP - Michael J Busuito 129 11.64% REP - Satish B Jasti 102 9.21% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 431 38.90% DEM - Kim Trent 393 35.47% USTAX - Robert Gale 13 1.17% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 4 0.36% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 17 1.53% GRN - Latham Redding 13 1.17% Write-In 6 0.54% Total... 1,108 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY (Final) REP - Matthew L Frey 162 25.59% DEM - John McColgan Jr 470 74.25% Write-In 1 0.16% Total... 633 100.00% SHERIFF (Final) DEM - William L Federspiel 542 98.37% Write-In 9 1.63% Total... 551 100.00% CLERK (Final) REP - James F Ormsby 130 21.00% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 486 78.51% Write-In 3 0.48% Total... 619 100.00% TREASURER (Final) REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 144 23.41% DEM - Tim Novak 468 76.10% Write-In 3 0.49% Total... 615 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS (Final) DEM - Mildred M Dodak 533 99.44% Write-In 3 0.56% Total... 536 100.00% PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER (Final) DEM - Brian J Wendling 528 99.44% Write-In 3 0.56% Total... 531 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 11 (Final) REP - David Bechard 114 18.51% DEM - Michael J Hanley 458 74.35% NPA - John H Cammin 43 6.98% Write-In 1 0.16% Total... 616 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT (Final) Doug Dern 33 3.88% Connie Marie Kelley 217 25.50% Stephen Markman 137 16.10% Bridget Mary McCormack 258 30.32% Kerry L Morgan 31 3.64% Colleen O'Brien 148 17.39% Bob Roddis 25 2.94% Write-In 2 0.24% Total... 851 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT (Final) Mindy Barry 64 13.01% Shelia Johnson 246 50.00% Brian Zahra 177 35.98% Write-In 5 1.02% Total... 492 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM (Final) Stephen Leopold Borrello 376 56.54% Peter D O'Connell 281 42.26% Write-In 8 1.20% Total... 665 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART (Final) Amy Ronayne Krause 409 96.92% Write-In 13 3.08% Total... 422 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Janet M Boes 296 43.15%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 251 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Saginaw Precinct 21 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT (Final) Darnell Jackson 381 55.54% Write-In 9 1.31% Total... 686 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT (Final) Patrick J McGraw 433 97.74% Write-In 10 2.26% Total... 443 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION (Final) Terry L Clark 454 98.48% Write-In 7 1.52% Total... 461 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY (Final) R Earl Selby 437 98.20% Write-In 8 1.80% Total... 445 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY (Final) David Lovely 145 34.20% Michael D Rowley 274 64.62% Write-In 5 1.18% Total... 424 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY (Final) Kathy Ellison 418 98.35% Write-In 7 1.65% Total... 425 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 (Final) YES 201 34.18% NO 387 65.82% Total... 588 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 (Final) YES 330 54.91% NO 271 45.09% Total... 601 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 (Final) YES 287 48.32% NO 307 51.68% Total... 594 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 (Final) YES 387 64.61% NO 212 35.39% Total... 599 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 (Final) YES 200 33.96% NO 389 66.04% Total... 589 100.00% State Proposal 12-6 (Final) YES 316 53.38% NO 276 46.62% Total... 592 100.00% Saginaw City Schools (Final) YES 335 58.57% NO 237 41.43% Total... 572 100.00% Delta College (Final) YES 389 67.77% NO 185 32.23% Total... 574 100.00% City of Zilwaukee Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 1,306 Election Day Turnout 880 67.38% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 0 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 880 67.38% PRESIDENT AND VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES REP - Mitt Romney/Paul Ryan 402 46.15% DEM - Barack Obama/Joe Biden 458 52.58% USTAX - Virgil H Goode Jr/James N Clymer 1 0.11% GRN - Jill Stein/Cheri Honkala 2 0.23% NATLAW - Ross C Anderson/Luis Rodriguez 1 0.11% Write-In 7 0.80% Total... 871 100.00% US SENATOR REP - Pete Hoekstra 304 35.85% DEM - Debbie Stabenow 517 60.97% LIBR - Scotty Boman 14 1.65% USTAX - Richard A Matkin 5 0.59% GRN - Harley Mikkelson 4 0.47% NATLAW - John D Litle 3 0.35% Write-In 1 0.12% Total... 848 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 252 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Zilwaukee Precinct 1 US REPRESENTATIVE - 5TH DIST REP - Jim Slezak 283 34.39% DEM - Daniel T Kildee 508 61.73% LIBR - Gregory Creswell 13 1.58% NPA - David Davenport 16 1.94% Write-In 3 0.36% Total... 823 100.00% STATE REPRESENTATIVE - 95TH DIST REP - Jeff Baker 324 40.10% DEM - Stacy Erwin Oakes 479 59.28% Write-In 5 0.62% Total... 808 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION REP - Todd A Courser 272 19.61% REP - Melanie A Kurdys 265 19.11% DEM - Michelle Fecteau 402 28.98% DEM - Lupe Ramos-Montigny 334 24.08% LIBR - Andy LeCureaux 26 1.87% USTAX - Karen Adams 39 2.81% USTAX - Gail M Graeser 18 1.30% GRN - Candace R Caveny 18 1.30% GRN - Dwain Reynolds III 12 0.87% Write-In 1 0.07% Total... 1,387 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE U OF M BOARD OF REGENTS REP - Dan Horning 253 18.56% REP - Robert Steele 255 18.71% DEM - Mark Bernstein 394 28.91% DEM - Shauna Ryder Diggs 348 25.53% LIBR - James Lewis Hudler 19 1.39% LIBR - Gregory Scott Stempfle 19 1.39% USTAX - Joe Sanger 22 1.61% USTAX - Gerald T Van Sickle 21 1.54% GRN - Eric Borregard 13 0.95% NATLAW - Nikki Mattson 16 1.17% Write-In 3 0.22% Total... 1,363 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE MSU BOARD OF TRUSTEES REP - Melaine Foster 274 20.40% REP - Jeff Sakwa 253 18.84% DEM - Joel Ferguson 388 28.89% DEM - Brian Mosallam 321 23.90% LIBR - Michael H Miller 42 3.13% USTAX - Bill Mohr II 21 1.56% USTAX - Stephen J Young 26 1.94% GRN - Lloyd Clarke 17 1.27% Write-In 1 0.07% Total... 1,343 100.00% MEMBERS OF THE WSU BOARD OF GOVERNORS REP - Michael J Busuito 263 20.00% REP - Satish B Jasti 224 17.03% DEM - Sandra Hughes O'Brien 387 29.43% DEM - Kim Trent 349 26.54% USTAX - Robert Gale 28 2.13% USTAX - Marc J Sosnowski 34 2.59% GRN - Margaret Guttshall 19 1.44% GRN - Latham Redding 9 0.68% Write-In 2 0.15% Total... 1,315 100.00% PROSECUTING ATTORNEY REP - Matthew L Frey 298 37.16% DEM - John McColgan Jr 503 62.72% Write-In 1 0.12% Total... 802 100.00% SHERIFF DEM - William L Federspiel 658 98.50% Write-In 10 1.50% Total... 668 100.00% CLERK REP - James F Ormsby 279 34.62% DEM - Susan Kaltenbach 526 65.26% Write-In 1 0.12% Total... 806 100.00% TREASURER REP - Neil A Hammerbacher 276 34.07% DEM - Tim Novak 533 65.80% Write-In 1 0.12% Total... 810 100.00% REGISTER OF DEEDS DEM - Mildred M Dodak 633 98.75% Write-In 8 1.25% Total... 641 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 253 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Zilwaukee Precinct 1 PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSIONER DEM - Brian J Wendling 626 98.27% Write-In 11 1.73% Total... 637 100.00% COUNTY COMMISSIONER DISTRICT 2 REP - Alex Boese 392 48.10% DEM - Chuck Stack 419 51.41% Write-In 4 0.49% Total... 815 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT Doug Dern 56 4.88% Connie Marie Kelley 233 20.30% Stephen Markman 237 20.64% Bridget Mary McCormack 277 24.13% Kerry L Morgan 54 4.70% Colleen O'Brien 245 21.34% Bob Roddis 42 3.66% Write-In 4 0.35% Total... 1,148 100.00% JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT INCUMBENT Mindy Barry 84 13.59% Shelia Johnson 245 39.64% Brian Zahra 287 46.44% Write-In 2 0.32% Total... 618 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS INCUM Stephen Leopold Borrello 498 54.91% Peter D O'Connell 402 44.32% Write-In 7 0.77% Total... 907 100.00% 4TH DISTRICT JUDGE COURT OF APPEALS INCUMBENT PART Amy Ronayne Krause 515 98.66% Write-In 7 1.34% Total... 522 100.00% 10TH CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE INCUMBENT Janet M Boes 449 49.94% Darnell Jackson 443 49.28% Write-In 7 0.78% Total... 899 100.00% JUDGE OF THE PROBATE COURT Patrick J McGraw 544 99.09% Write-In 5 0.91% Total... 549 100.00% JUDGE 70TH DISTRICT COURT 1ST DIVISION Terry L Clark 560 98.59% Write-In 8 1.41% Total... 568 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - SAGINAW COUNTY R Earl Selby 512 98.65% Write-In 7 1.35% Total... 519 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - BAY COUNTY David Lovely 211 41.45% Michael D Rowley 293 57.56% Write-In 5 0.98% Total... 509 100.00% DELTA COLLEGE BD - MIDLAND COUNTY Kathy Ellison 496 98.80% Write-In 6 1.20% Total... 502 100.00% State Proposal 12-1 YES 305 36.97% NO 520 63.03% Total... 825 100.00% State Proposal 12-2 YES 384 45.28% NO 464 54.72% Total... 848 100.00% State Proposal 12-3 YES 282 33.57% NO 558 66.43% Total... 840 100.00% State Proposal 12-4 YES 382 46.02% NO 448 53.98% Total... 830 100.00% State Proposal 12-5 YES 257 30.96% NO 573 69.04% Total... 830 100.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 254 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

City of Zilwaukee Precinct 1 State Proposal 12-6 YES 431 51.13% NO 412 48.87% Total... 843 100.00% Zilwaukee City Fire YES 658 78.61% NO 179 21.39% Total... 837 100.00% Saginaw City Schools YES 463 56.95% NO 350 43.05% Total... 813 100.00% Delta College YES 513 62.41% NO 309 37.59% Total... 822 100.00% Flushing Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 0 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 4 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 4 0.00% NEW LOTHROP PUBLIC SCHOOLS Adam Green 4 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 4 100.00% New Lothrop Schools YES 2 50.00% NO 2 50.00% Total... 4 100.00% Hazelton Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 0 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 961 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 961 0.00% CHESANING UNION SCHOOLS 4 YR Brian W Lewis 4 36.36% Julia Schultz Sadilek 7 63.64% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 11 100.00% NEW LOTHROP PUBLIC SCHOOLS Adam Green 743 99.33% Write-In 5 0.67% Total... 748 100.00% New Lothrop Schools YES 656 68.26% NO 305 31.74% Total... 961 100.00% New Haven Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 0 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 131 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 131 0.00% CHESANING UNION SCHOOLS 4 YR Brian W Lewis 95 40.77% Julia Schultz Sadilek 131 56.22% Write-In 7 3.00% Total... 233 100.00% Rush Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 0 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 3 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 3 0.00% CHESANING UNION SCHOOLS 4 YR Brian W Lewis 3 75.00% Julia Schultz Sadilek 1 25.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 4 100.00% Frankenlust Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 0 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 171 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 255 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Frankenlust Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 0 SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 171 0.00% FREELAND COMM 6 YR SCHOOL Janet M Alexander 9 5.26% Kristin Anderson 20 11.70% Michele Daniels 10 5.85% David Dennis 15 8.77% Melissa Lickly 14 8.19% Shawnette Markey 18 10.53% Toni Riffel 10 5.85% Charles Snider 13 7.60% Holli Wallace 12 7.02% Pete Wiltse 21 12.28% David Youngstrom 29 16.96% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 171 100.00% FREELAND COMMUNITY 4 YR SCHOOLS PARTIAL Dennis J Argyle 24 40.68% Michelle Vanamburg Rankin 11 18.64% Holly Roenicke 19 32.20% Candace Stowell 5 8.47% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 59 100.00% Mt. Haley Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 0 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 351 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 351 0.00% MERRILL COMMUNITY SCHOOLS Matthew H Miller 351 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 351 100.00% MERRILL SCHOOL PARTIAL Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 0 0.00% Ingersoll Township Precinct 1 Registration & Turnout 0 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 471 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 471 0.00% FREELAND COMM 6 YR SCHOOL Janet M Alexander 1 6.25% Kristin Anderson 1 6.25% Michele Daniels 1 6.25% David Dennis 1 6.25% Melissa Lickly 0 0.00% Shawnette Markey 3 18.75% Toni Riffel 0 0.00% Charles Snider 0 0.00% Holli Wallace 5 31.25% Pete Wiltse 3 18.75% David Youngstrom 1 6.25% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 16 100.00% FREELAND COMMUNITY 4 YR SCHOOLS PARTIAL Dennis J Argyle 0 0.00% Michelle Vanamburg Rankin 1 16.67% Holly Roenicke 4 66.67% Candace Stowell 1 16.67% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 6 100.00% HEMLOCK PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD MEMBER Mary Ann Ling 149 31.57% Larry Long 73 15.47% Dennis D McMahan 126 26.69% Matthew Wesener 124 26.27% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 472 100.00% MERRILL COMMUNITY SCHOOLS Matthew H Miller 0 0.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 0 0.00% MERRILL SCHOOL PARTIAL Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 0 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 256 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Vienna Township Registration & Turnout 0 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 63 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 63 0.00% BIRCH RUN AREA SCHOOLS Todd Ferguson 27 31.76% Steve Griggs 10 11.76% Nan Haley 36 42.35% Travis Maginity 12 14.12% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 85 100.00% Arbela Township Registration & Turnout 0 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 3 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 3 0.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS Lori Ettema 1 20.00% David E Harris 1 20.00% Karen Uebler 3 60.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 5 100.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS PARTIAL Al Zehnder 3 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 3 100.00% Denmark Township Registration & Turnout 0 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 25 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 25 0.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS Lori Ettema 4 16.00% David E Harris 9 36.00% Karen Uebler 12 48.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 25 100.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS PARTIAL Al Zehnder 15 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 15 100.00% Tuscola Township Registration & Turnout 0 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 350 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 350 0.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS Lori Ettema 113 32.29% David E Harris 92 26.29% Karen Uebler 145 41.43% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 350 100.00% FRANKENMUTH SCHOOLS PARTIAL Al Zehnder 182 98.91% Write-In 2 1.09% Total... 184 100.00% Lafayette Township Registration & Turnout 0 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 77 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 77 0.00% MERRILL COMMUNITY SCHOOLS Matthew H Miller 14 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 14 100.00% MERRILL SCHOOL PARTIAL Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 0 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 257 of 258 Saginawcounty_Nov12_E November 6, 2012 Precinct Report Saginaw Co

Wheeler Township Registration & Turnout 0 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 67 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 67 0.00% MERRILL COMMUNITY SCHOOLS Matthew H Miller 63 94.03% Write-In 4 5.97% Total... 67 100.00% MERRILL SCHOOL PARTIAL Write-In 3 100.00% Total... 3 100.00% Porter Township Registration & Turnout 0 Election Day Turnout 0 0.00% AV Polling Turnout 0 0.00% Election Day Manual Entry Turnout 12 0.00% SPR Host Turnout 0 0.00% Total... 12 0.00% MERRILL COMMUNITY SCHOOLS Matthew H Miller 12 100.00% Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 12 100.00% MERRILL SCHOOL PARTIAL Write-In 0 0.00% Total... 0 0.00%

May 08, 2013 11:10 AM Page 258 of 258